Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
30
3. THE INHUMATION GRAW AS A BURIAL ENVIRONMENT
!\cy
J, Iron artefact + CoPPer artefact As has been demonstrated by Janaway (forthcom-
Corrosion-preserved: W wood, T textile, G grass
i.g) in the rBeeston Experimental pitt, an environ-
L leather ? IdentificaEion uncertain ment of mixed decaying organic matter can lead to
NB. A1l shietd fittings- are counted-as one artetact'
Science and Az'chaeolagA no. 27 (1985)
30
1.3 1.4
1.6
31
the rapid decomposition of textile material, and in which the Clostridia predorninate (Evans, L963a,
the rapid deposition of corrosion products onto the Pp. 4_5) .
textile surface. This pit was dug on 25th April
1982 and backfilled with the experimental material In later stages micro-organisms may be
on 29th April 1982. The pit was 1.5m in diameter derived from the soil, and here the soil history is
at the top, l.Om deep and O.9n in diameter at the an important factor. Soil in which a lot of corpses
base. It was cut through a loaroy soil with clay have been interred will have a greater reservoir of
Ienses, and eventually clay and weathered sandstone. dormant micro-organisms, particularly in the case of
In addition to the experimental samples, consisting sequential multiple graves, or new graves cutting
of iron billets, copper alloy coins (2 pence into recent, previous graves. Most fungi that are
pieces) and various organic materials (textile, found on decomposing remains are aerobic, conse-
leather, grass, hair and wood) there was a mixture quently their growth is restricted to che surface
of parsnips, cabbage leaves, potatoes, rotten pears of the cadaver and little deep penetration of the
and pork fat trimings. The pit r{as re-excavated tissues takes place, In a well-sealed coffin or a
137 days later on 9th September 1982. The experi- burial environment where gas exchange through the
mental details and results are discussed at greater soil is s1ow, fungal growth will eventually become
length in Janaway (forthcoming). In the experimen- inhibited by the formation of a reductive atmos-
ta1 refuse pit linen sanples were severely degraded phere. Fungi were not found by Evans in sealed
in 137 days, except where i-ediately adjacent to a coffins; and they r^/ere absent froo the sealed triple
metal object. Although soil chemistry is an impor- coffins exhumed at Huddersfield (Polson et al.,
Ean! factor, it is severely roodified by the inter- 1985, p. 2O).
action of decay products. In the refuse pit the
linen (ce11u1ose) material was decomposed the most Insect larvae which cause focal liquefaction
rapidly; this roay have been the result of localised by proteolysis include the Lucilia (Greenbottles),
acids in the r^rater systeo, or of the other decaying Calliphoridae (Blow flies or Bluebottles), Muscidae
vegetable matter providing a reservoir of (Houseflies), and Piophila caeseri (Cheese skipper) .
cellulose-degrading organisms in a suitable envir- The winged adult lays eggs in carrion (including
onment. In the presence of a corpse, release of dead humans) on which the larvae feed before pupat-
acids will again favour the degradation of ing. Thus infection nust take place prior to burial.
ce1lulose-based material. However, there will be a Iron corrosion casts of fIy pupae have been found on
larger quantity of keratin-decomposing bacteria, two belt buckles from the Christchurch cemetery. In
which will colonise the skin and hair, as well as Ehe case of coffins in vaults or toobs, even those
any wool or hair textiles. of sound construction, the infestation Day not occur
until after the coffin has been inEerred for some
The following discussion is for the most part time. Evans (1963, pp. 50-51) records the presence
based on Polson et a1 (1985, pp. 20-37) and Evans of living Tinea pallescentella (Greater pale clothes
( 1e63) . noth) inside a 'sealedr coffin. In this instance
the body was in a triple coffin, consisting of a
Assuming a tine 1ag between death and burial, r,rooden inner coffin, which was sealed in a lead cof-
the firsE, innediate decay processes will take fin with ao outer wooden casket. Both the coffin
place above ground. The degradation processes ard the vault were not sealed by eerth. The body
above ground are differenE to those when buried. was examined approxirr,ately IO3-127 years after
The presence and type of coffin will also effect burial. According to Evans, the insect had entered
putrefaction (see below). During the firsE twelve via minute holes in the coffin and flourished on the
hours after death the body will coo1, the circula- scalp hair of the body. He does not suggest the
Eion of the blood will have ceased and will accu- possibility that the eggs may have been present in
mulate in the dependent parts of the body, result- woollen clothing or other cloth and maintained a
ing in the phenooenon of post-mortem hypostasis viable population within the coffin. In either case
(Polson et al., 1985, p. 13). If the body is the larvae would not have been viable r{ithout the
exposed to the airrthe blood will become oxidised access of o:cygen to the interior. Some larvae have
in those regions that are not in contact with the remarkably specific proteolytic chemical systess,
ground. Rigornoitis will start to set in at about thus the larvae of Lucilia can secrete a collagenase
4 hours and will be complete in about 6. This con- which dissolves the usually resistant co11agen.
dition lasts for about 36 hours. The onset and Tineola (Clothes moths) are able to attack keratin
duraEion will be largely dependent on the physio- by reducing its S-S bond to -SH.(Evans, 1963, p. 5).
logical state of the body at death and the post
morteo environment. Considerable variation has Although necrophagous animals (especially
been recorded (op. cit., p. 15). those in the soil.) are attracted to a dead body,
they are largely repelled during the more active
The process of putrefaction begins ime- phase of decourposition. They reappear when this
diately after death and is visible under normal has passed, and a great range of animals can be
conditions fron 48 to 72 hours afterwards (op. found to attack the liquefying remains. Kuhnelt
cit., p. 20). Putrefaction is a result of both (1961, p. 243 et seq) lists these organisms which
action by bacteria and degradation by the bodyts range from ptotazoa to insects. The Colembola
orrn enzymes, "Miero-organisms from the intestines (Springtails) have been discovered at a depth of 2m
migrate into the local Eissues, and gain access to in grave yards (op. cit. p. 161) despite the fact
the lyurphatics, b1ood, capilliaries and veins, and that their normal burrowing depth is locm.
Ehence by way of the tissue planes and blood and
lymph to rhe body tissue generally". Aerobic It'is now intended to discuss the main chemi-
organisms deplete the tissues of oxygen and, cal changes thaE take place during putrefaction;
although their numbers decrease as the available the account is largely based on Evans (1963).
o).ygen is diminished, they create conditions which
are more suitable for the more destructive anaero-
bic organisms thaE ultiDately come froo the inles- 3.1 Charqes dn fat: hydtolysis
tinal cana1. Thus the bacterial flora change from
aerobic groups as exemplified by the coliform- NeuEral fat is hydrolysed to some extent by
staphyl ococcalproteus varieties, to the anaerobic intrinsic tissue lipases. This proceeds slowly and
Science and ArchaeoLogg no. 27 (1985)
32
the activity of this enzyme system soon diminishes, much that it burst the coffin. Professor Gee (pers.
Analyses of post mortem faf exhibiL the presence of com.) has conrnented t'I have never seen a corpse where
o1eic, palmitic and stearic acids as soon as eight the body cavities have ruptured and the conEents
hours after death, These are the first stages of spilled forth simply due to putrefaction. I very much
neutral fat breakdoi,m. The palmitic acid increases doubt if it actually occurs. Certainly not in the way
and the oleic becomes increasingly reduced in some authors would suggest, with the body going off
amount through hydrolysation. More effective than rather like a bomb. As pressure builds up within the
the intrinsic lipases are the lipolytic enzymes cavities it releases itself through the natural ori-
produced by bacteria, particularly those of fices lvith progressive eversion of the anus and evac-
Clostridia (esp. C, Welchii). However, other uation of fluid by that route as well as through the
micro-organisms also take part in neutral faE mouth and nose. I have no doubt that theoretically
breakdown. Water is necessary for both the intrin- it is possible for a body cavity to burst, but in
sic and bacterial enzymes to work, but Lhere is practice I have never seen it happen".
usually sufficient in the far tissue itself. If
the process continues, Ehe neutral fat is totally There is a tradition in archaeology that a dig-
converted to fatty acids, which are deposited in ger put his pick through a sealed Roman lead coffin
its place. If no further chemical changes take and was showered by Ehe liquified contents being
place these farty acids remain as adipocere, expelled under the pressure of the gas. tr^lhen Dr.
Adipocere, depending on age and burial conditions, Brierley examined the forty lead coffins from
has been described as looking like suet or cheese, Huddersfield (Polson et aI.,1985,p.21) one or t!r'o of
Lrhen analysed, in addition to the mixture of them contained gas under pressure, although others
stearic, oleic and palmic acids, there is a frac- were no longer gas-tight. due Eo the seals breaking up,
Eion of calcium soaps (Polson et al., 1985, p.24). As the soft tissues start to break dor,m and
Adipocere may effect the preservation of textile gases are formed the skin sr+ells and blisLers. The
material; when Dr. Brierely examined some forty gases formed are carbon dioxide, hydrogen sulphide,
burials in lead coffins (interred before t85O) the armnonia and methane, It is the formation of these
grave clothes had rotted but Lhe remains were pre- gases together with the ingestion of oxygen by
served by adipocere formation (op. cit. , p. 27). aerobic micro-organisms that will convert the body
3.2 Changes t-n fat: oridation tissues and the immediate burial environment Lo
reducing cooditions (unless oxygen is free to
As well as changing by hydrolysis, fat can diffuse in).
also oxidise, a process that can be brought about 3.5 Factots tnfluencing the changes accu?yLrLg
by the action of bacteria, fungi and atmospheric
oxygen. In most instances hydrolysis rather than after burt,al
oxidation dominate the fat degradation system, The major contributor to this area is Mant,
Fatty acids, the products of hydrolysis, will be who had Lhe opportunity to investigate in 1950 a
quickly oxidised into aldehydes and ketones; this, large number of exhumations while working for the
however, can only lake place in rhe presence of War Crimes Investigations after World War II. This
oxy'gen, which is often absent in a sealed coffin. work is sunEnarised by Mant in Simpson (1953,
pp, 84-91). I will use his headings:
3.3 Changes in p:rotein
Protein is broken down by enzyme action, bu! (a) State of body before death.
this does not proceed at a uniform rate throughout This was found to be more critical than hitherto
the body. The rate is determined by the amount of believed before. An emaciated body may decompose
moisEure, the temperature, and bacterial action. with extreme rapidity, whereas a well-covered body
may decompose less under similar conditions and
luloisture favours decay, and proteolysis is slowed
by cooling and increased by warming, In the event over the same time span. An emaciated body rnay
of death caused by viral or bacterial infection, tend to munmify.
not only will the body lemperalure be higher but (h) Time lapse between death and burial.
also bacEeria may be widespread throughout the Bodies Ehat have !een allowed to start decomposing
cadaver and hasten post mortem decomposition.
above ground r,ii11 skeletalise much quicker when
In general, proteins breakdown into pro- buried.
teoses, pepEone, polypeptides and amino-acids, As
the proteins are broken down into more simple units (c) Effect of coffin.
a greater range and number of micro-organisms can The coffins in these investiga!ions were roughly
grow on the substrate. The tissues become increas- made of unseasoned r^rood; usually they had warped
ingly liquid and, in the case of a body buried and collapsed wirhin two years. Most of these
directly in the soi1, a mucus sheath r^rill form coffins were not airtight. trrrhere the base of coffin
around the corpse consisting of liquid body decom- is watertight, water tha! percolates down from the
position products and the fine silt fraction from top and is retained there was usually one !o two
the soil (Barford, L979, p. 45). inches of mixed waEer and putrefied tissue. This
3.4 Production of gases Eype of burial will decompose quicker than an uncof-
Initially gaseous pioduction is evident in fined burial, especially if the uncoffined burial is
the intestines and is a result of the rapid decom- in clothes, Bodies buried in non-airtight coffins
position of their contents, as a result the gut will exhibit little adipocere formation, whereas
cavity becomes disEended; discoloured natural uncoffined burials of the same date and cemetery
liquids and liquefying tissues are made frothy by will show considerable adipocere formation.
the gas, and some may exude from the natural ori- Liquefaction of Ehe body was so1e1y associated with
fices, forced out by the increasing pressure of coffined burials,
the gases. As the skin starts to break dor,l.n the
body cavities will rupture. Not having \{ilnessed (d) Clothing.
this event I am not sure with what force this occurs Clothing tends to retard decomposition, and adipo-
and what irnplications this has for associaEed grave cere formation is more contrnon under clothing. The
goods. Evans (1963, p. 10) records the popular clothing probabl,v acted as a physical barrier to
Iegend that the body of Queen Elizabeth I swelled so insects and retained a high moisture 1eve1 around
the body.
lulrcir e:-.pl:asis crl soiI char.rcteristics in thrtirr dis- aiialysis of th: textile and rvoorl
cussio:.is of pr:itc.ess,.:s associatecl tJifh eilher decay- ir Jarvis, l(. (ed. ) , 1983 l!:ccttttettotis .in
irg borii.es or ref\lsi: ri:.pcsits. CTnlstclnrciL,
Barlor:d, P.M., 1979
4. PRji>)SilD il:i.f.lltl!.2ilr.4L ii)pJ{ ){.inr:ral pse.urlomorphs of orglnic nateri-als: a
s Ludy (jf b'-u:ial. env:'.:ccr,n..:nEs RSc, Disserttlttc:n,
Irr orcler ED test ehe l:ffecL of a caci;:ver on .[t.tst ttute of At.citrtec'Lagy, Loticlon.
tha j-lteracEion'b*i:ireer argsilic naieriaLs and neLal
nrlrrEir"a.ts in ilhrnalioir gravrs it is propcseii L,: Iiv,:uts, l,l.E.D., 1.963
i;ury a i\.:rLct' of pigs, both w:i-th errd. irithout coi j:ii.ts,
;rn.i a;rltunr: itlletll aa sr: c ilttorvals, Pigs are fhr: besE :llhe chenisi;:ry oi rieoLlt r\neri.ran lecture series.
srri;...;cil-r:tcs for hr:inarr bor1j.es, hevi-iry1 ;lppr:o:<iraLely Cii:ir:1es C. Thcn;rs, I1li.nois,
t-ird co-;:rect :.reigilt aitd sr:i:1:aco iiit+ii Lo .lo-j-r-lre ri-..tio,
.lrd a sinilar f JL coi-tieilt. Ther: have treen r"is:..1 in s Janr.r,'ay, R.C,, 1933
tit,t::rl: er.. Llf ezlr.c rir:1iii l :.1 i.;trzes t i- g:t e i.riis i.l f rens i c
<; llcxfil* fib;e characteri:tic pre-cerved by netal
:.ri:rai.ne. 1f l;i1i. br: or;ssiblr: lo rrin a i:ulrler of c-oi:r:osion: t:h,: l.:t-+:tti:.1. c:f li.E,X, Strrdies '!l:c
ilrrisrsIigaLioili.:; c(:',:ic1Jr-rerLtiy, such as lite novenir]iil- of C0!1su?,l)ator 7 ( 1-.r 83) .
i. ii,r:c i ie rl da cllr:i)., iiillr pr:o<.1rii:t:.i ill ro:-i;i'r the s oi 1,
r1c,:,;s iti<-.n of m;,:''riianesr: anLl phospiri.rte , ancl Lhe spa- .Janr':.r+ay, R, C. (:ior:t'hcoaring)
I i,.1 I 3 i..tili Lity .r )r.r- avD gooCs. 1i:'lyiror]y inr:eresLed
ir. il;:clpor;Liirg,:xperinent.s irit-o i:iri: br,irj.als shoLrld C,:rri:sion pri:ilei:r'ed texriles: mechanisn, b.i-as and
cci'11::lci'cix.' :r;litr-.r itjl at*r)n ;t:i !rc!,iibl-e sc lhili !:he illterapretation
fu l-1. iesearch C::sign car bc- Iineli.s;e11. A! p.r(]senL a. in Jaravav, R.C. 6n'd Scoic, ji, (eds),
s:rr1 1 piloL studT is in iri:c,gr:ass, :thicir ii.r.:olves ilu'i tt.:it c e l,r e s r: t, t; e d'it t C o z.t o s ci t Pyc ciuc i; s,
i.
.As hi;; L*r:l ."lr::irioiistre.tr:d, i;hi: iloclltocsi_ti.,:ll of Si.n,;s<;r-_, ii, (cC.. ) , 1953
ilr,.: l::ciiy cii. ha:?-rl a ccn:;i.i:l-:::til:l-c il,;,.i i-fyi.nt3 r:f:lcL:t on
i.ii. ir:i{r(iiaic br.iil-:1 6i1,7.j-16r-,;::rt;rr:":ioL iear:t j"rr i:ire i.io:!z'c,t ttr:itit-s i;i I'ar':;,tsic !it:4.ic-ire l-rutt -:i:ir, i:t_:h,
J.r :1{icil.
'.; .;, irr .;11i,'11 r;,Iri,.';ivt: ,:o;r,.iil:i,:rrr; '..,,i1-1 pr,::r:ri 1 irr a
:1.:i::Ii)d r:n.if -:rir or jl :;oi 1 t,;i:e i:.: gt!lr:cus ilxil]nitAe
'i:lrrlrgir Ll',e s;.ri1 ;:i:n,-::;';he'ra is l-lil;,t-ed. {t hiis rilso
1-.rr:::r siir:'.;:'l l,y i.lart jj'l);:i:.i;plh i-)l;:),g .1 cr)r.si_Calr:11,1e
;:i:::l i:r t.lr: r.':r:n,:i: cf lire decOnl;cri ti-itL envi_-I:o:t;lent,
iir::: ii: is a nisl-i:lkc sL1.l-:ll\r lo (:ci'isi.lqr sr:i,1 ci'lt:m-
i;:ir:7 es Iile ij:-t.i ,i: [ar:i:or, bot-it i;L the Citi:a;r lI i]-,;:
,:..;i:i)ili-r, ri+,:lry,:f .1::i.icaj;:icd olrr.i-ilt-ic...t:i,:r.-ia1s, l:':ch
il5 :ai'i:i1lrs, r.rr {:1le:;i,.ctL-- i-(:t':r; r:oi'i:ltij.c:r o.f :ii:l;rl.
irrJ.-trf r'..rrar"i. lii:,:: .l . i:ii:i: l;i.11 t::lil Lll i:aacl1 n ni:.,