Sei sulla pagina 1di 59

PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

Project submitted to Osmania University towards the partial


fulfilment of the award of Masters Degree in Hospital Management

Submitted by

TEJASWI KOCHERLAKOTA
Enrol no: 140413676035
BATCH-19 (2013-15)
Academic year 2013- 2014

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION


APOLLO HEALTH CITY CAMPUS, JUBILEE HILLS
HYDERABAD – 500 096

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

DECLARATION

I hereby declare that the Project Report entitled “PATIENT FLOW


MANAGEMENT IN OPD” submitted by me to the Department of
Business Management, Osmania University, Hyderabad, is a bonafide work
carried out by me and is original and not submitted to any other University or
Institution for the award of any Degree/Diploma/Certificate or published any
time before.

PLACE: Hyderabad Signature:


DATE: Name: TEJASWI.K
Roll No.:140413676035

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

CERTIFICATION

This is to certify that the Project Report entitled “PATIENT FLOW


MANAGEMENT IN OPD” submitted in partial fulfilment for the award of
M.D.H.M programme of Osmania University, Hyderabad, was carried out by
Ms. TEJASWI KOCHERLAKOTA under my guidance. This has not been
submitted to any other University or Institution for the award of any degree/
diploma/certificate.

Signature of the Internal Guide Signature of the Principal


Name: M. Krishna Kartheek (with stamp)

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

ABSTRACT

Ensuring efficient and safe patient flow through the hospital system is a consistent problem in
healthcare settings. As demand and patient complexity increases small in efficiencies and
errors in health care delivery can cause hospital overcrowdings and service delay. An
inefficient layout may also create problem concerning patient supervision may increase the
travel time and waiting time. This may give patients a poor overall impression of the setting.
Reducing delays and making sure that patients receive the right care at right time will have a
significant beneficial effect on the quality of care patients receive.

To accomplish the above criteria the objectives are set which include, to
understand the problems which the outdoor patients encounter like long standing queues,
improper maintenance of patient traffic at the out patient department section, to find the
bottlenecks, reasons and solutions for the problems encountered. A random sampling
technique is followed to collect the data. A sample of 300 patients is selected randomly
from out patient department i.e., OP consultation patients, patients in casuality or
emergency department and from the diagnostics. The data is collected by observation
method and by preparing a format in which time slots are given to each activity i.e., waiting
time for op registration, waiting time for doctor consultation, waiting time for diagnostic
billing, testing and dispatch of reports. Data is analysed by plotting graphs and histograms.
The average time taken for OP registration is 5.5 minutes, waiting time for doctor
consultation is 37.1 minutes, for diagnostic billing it is 5.0 minutes, for diagnostic
procedures it is 14.1 minutes and for dispatch of reports it is63.1minutes. The inferences
made from the above analysis is the waiting time is more for doctor consultation and
dispatch of reports. As dispatch of reports is delayed, by the time the patient gets the report
the doctors may not be available in OP. This is due to improper scheduling of consultants
and radiologist. So, some suggestions are recommended to improve the patient care
delivery.
This project will help to optimise patient’s flow that is necessary to understand
how the system is currently working by reviewing existing process and determining weak or
broken links of the system.

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

The success and final outcome of this project required a lot of guidance and assistance from
many people and I am fortunate to have got this all along the completion of my project work.
Whatever I have done is only due to such guidance and assistance and I would not forget to
thank them.

I respect and thank Dr.Satish Reddy (Managing Director) for giving me an


opportunity to do the project work in Prime Hospitals, Ameerpet and I am also thankful to the
hospital staff for providing me the support and guidance which made me complete the project
on time.

I would also like to thank my Principal Prof.D.Obul Reddy and Internal Guide
Prof.M.KrishnaKartheek without whom the project would have been a distant reality.

I owe my profound gratitude to my project guide Dr.Sarath (Senior Medical


Director),who took keen interest in my project work and guide all along, till the completion
of my project work by providing a the necessary information.

I take this opportunity to acknowledge the services provided by the library sir, lab sir
and everyone who collaborated in producing this work.

I also wish to thank specially my husband, family members and well wishers who has
always been supportive in successful completion of my project.

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

Table of Contents

S.No Description Page No


1. Introduction 1- 9
 Patient Flow 1
 Principles of patient flow management 3
 Bottlenecks 4
 Research problem 7
 Sources of information 9
2. Literature Review 10 - 15
 Types of literature review 10
 Literature review on patient flow management 11
 Case Study-1 11
 Case Study-2 12
 Case Study-3 13
 Case Study-4 14
3. Organization 16 - 38
 History of Prime Hospitals 16
 Directors vision 16
 Services 17
 Hospital Branches 17
 Certifications, Quality policy and objectives 20
 Strengths of the hospital 23
 Outpatient department 23
 OP and IP Registration 24
 Diagnostics billing 24
 Diagnostics 25
 Emergency department / Casuality 32
 Organograms 33
 Patient flow processes 35
4. Data Analysis 39 - 45
 Waiting time for OP registration 39

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

 Waiting time for Doctor Consultation 40


 Waiting time for Diagnostics billing 41
 Waiting time for Diagnostics 42
 Total waiting time at various stages in patient flow process 43
 Average waiting time at various stages in patient flow process 44
5. Inferences 46
6. Summary and conclusions 47
Bibliography48
Appendix 49

1. List of Figures Page No


 Figure 1.1 Process Bottlenecks 6
 Figure 3.1 Prime hospital 17
 Figure 3.2 Services 17
 Figure 3.3 Prime Hospital Ameerpet 18
 Figure 3.4 Prime hospital Kukatpally 19
 Figure 3.5 National certification Board 20
 Figure 3.6 ODC standard certification 21
 Figure 3.7 Objectives and policies 22
 Figure 3.8 Organo gram of Prime hospitals 33
 Figure 3.9 Organo gram for Aarogyasree department 34
 Figure 3.10 Patient flow process for emergency patients 35
 Figure 3.11 Patient flow process for direct and appointment patients
36
 Figure 3.12 Patient flow process for Aarogyasree patients 37
 Figure 3.13 Process flow in X-Ray department 38

2. List of Charts Page No


 Chart 4.1 No of patients vs. OP registration time 39
 Chart 4.2 No of patients vs. Doctor consultation time 40
 Chart 4.3 No of patients vs. Diagnostics billing time 41
 Chart 4.4 No of patients vs. Diagnostics time 42
 Chart 4.5 Total waiting time in various stages 43
 Chart 4.6 Average waiting time in various stages 44

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

CHAPTER-1
INTRODUCTION

As there are numerous technological advances in diagnostics, medications, procedures and


modifications in healthcare reimbursement plans, the mode of healthcare has been gradually
shifting away from the inpatient setting to the outpatient basis.

Blockage in the flow can increase waiting time. When patient flow is handled well, it is
represented by short wait at the registration, examination, diagnostic testing, surgery, placement in
beds and discharge.

PATIENT FLOW

What is it and how can it help me?

More and more people are using the term ‘patient flow'. The term flow describes the progressive
movement of products, information and people through a sequence of processes. In simple terms,
flow is about uninterrupted movement, like driving steadily along the motorway without
interruptions, or being stuck in a traffic jam.

In healthcare, flow is the movement of patients, information or equipment between departments,


staff groups or organisations as part of a patient's care pathway. Patient flow means movement of
patients through multiple stages of care.

PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT

It represents ability of healthcare system to serve patients quickly and efficiently as they move
through stages of care.

This is an operational or process view of patient flow. A clinician may have a different
focus. Their focus could be on the progression of a patient's health status, disease progression
and/or the clinical knowledge and understanding of both. The clinical focus naturally allows for
appropriate waits, for example ‘watchful waiting'.

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 1


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

There has to be a close relationship between both the operational and clinical perspectives. What
happens to a patient clinically will dictate his or her movement through different steps and
settings, as well as the movement of associated information, equipment, samples etc.

One way to engage and ensure that patient flow incorporates the clinical view is to include
clinicians in mapping sessions, i.e. where teams map out patient pathways and associated
processes. If you find it difficult to engage clinical staff, you may find it helpful to start from their
viewpoint - and then see how processes fit around this.

Reducing delays and making sure that patients receive the right care at the right time will have a
significant beneficial effect on the quality of care patients receive. In turn, this will improve
patient outcomes and reduce the cost of care.

When does it work best?

Patients referred to and treated in hospitals and systems that ‘keep the flow' and ‘keep things
moving' will have quicker referral to treatment times. Any waits that occur will be necessary;
either for clinical reasons or due to patients choosing to wait (for example, the time needed to
make a decision about whether or not to have a treatment).

How to use it?

This is useful to structure the overall approach to improving patient flow, and thereby reducing
delays. It links up to tools and other guides that provide more detail. The approach is based on two
main improvement strategies: the theory of constraints and Lean thinking; and a body of practical
knowledge - clinical systems improvement and clinical micro-systems.

It's useful to start from these theories as they provide health services with proven approaches to
improvement, as well as the tools and techniques which we know work. Despite the origins of
patient flow being in the manufacturing industry, there are many ideas and concepts that can be
borrowed and adapted to help manage health services.

Patient flow in context?


Improving patient flow is one way of improving health services. Evidence suggests that enhancing
patient flow also increases patient safety and is essential to ensuring that patients receive the right

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 2


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

care, in the right place, at the right time, all of the time (reliability). However, it is important that
patient flow does not improve at the expense of safety or system reliability.

Factors affecting patient flow:

 Volume of patients on daily basis.


 Types of patients seen in terms of stage care.
 Clinic policies on frequency of the patient visits.
 Type of provider they should see.
 Size and composition of providers and staffing models.

Reasons for delay in patient flow:

 Waiting for a doctor or a test result.


 Waiting for investigations performed outside or for a specialist from outside.
 Waiting to find a hospital bed or to go to a hospital bed.
 Waiting for an ambulance or patients attendants for patient admission.

Principles of patient flow management:

Lengabeer in his book health care operation management a quantitative approach to


business and logistics points, there are five principles for improving operational efficiency
during hospital design.

 Observe the movement pattern, volume, distance travelled and analyse length of time to
move staff, supplies and other resources.

 Focus on interdependent movement and decreasing geographical distance from patient


examination room to minimize number of trips.

 Use optimization to minimize costs.

 Separate patient flow from staff reduces over crowing.

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 3


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

 Physical and visual accessibility of spatial layout have the ability to improve
operational efficiency and maximize patient satisfaction by moving patients and
resources efficiently through the units by minimizing wait and transport time.

 Spatial attributes included are visibility, accessibility, connectivity and path distance.

BOTTLENECKS:

A bottleneck is any part of the system where patient flow is obstructed causing waits and delays.
It interrupts the natural flow and hinders movement along the care pathway, determining the pace
at which the whole process works. You cannot make changes to improve the care process if you
don’t tackle the bottleneck. Any service improvement is unlikely to succeed because the patient
will be accelerated into the queue, only to be halted further along the pathway by the bottleneck.

Keep a look out for bottlenecks (usually identified by finding a queue). In the whole patient
journey, from visiting the GP to discharge after treatment, it is very likely that there will be at
least one.

Start by analysing the patient's journey to identify the location of any bottlenecks. The aim is to
identify where the flow is slowed within the overall process of care. This typically requires
developing a patient process flow map.

Reducing current waiting times requires a reduction in backlog of patients at every stage
of the journey. Matching capacity and demand is a key approach to removing some of the visible
and hidden backlogs along the patient pathway.

A bottleneck is usually caused by something - this is known as the constraint. The


constraint is the part of the process which ultimately restricts the amount of work that can be
done. By concentrating on the bottlenecks, you can accurately manage demand and capacity and
therefore keep the flow of patients moving, which will in turn reduce overall waiting times.

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 4


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

Concentrate on the bottlenecks to reduce delays:

 Look very carefully at the process map (a guide to mapping patient journeys - process
mapping, a conventional model) and identify stages in the patient journey where patients
have to queue or are put on a waiting list - this is a bottleneck.

 Map that part of the process in more detail to make sure you really understand what is
going on. Map to the level of what one person does, in one place, with one piece of
equipment, at one time.

 Look carefully for the true constraint. This is often a lack of availability of a specific skill
or piece of equipment. Queues tend to occur before the bottleneck in the patient journey,
and clear after the patient has gone past the stage with the constraint.

 Measure at the bottleneck to really understand the capacity and demand. These guides will
help you: quick introduction to demand and capacity and comprehensive guide to demand
and capacity.

 Begin to test and implement the relevant change ideas as a result of what the measurement
shows you.

 Keep asking ‘why?’ (Five whys) to try to discover the real reason for the delay. For
example, if your starting point is ‘the clinic always overruns and patients have to wait for a
long time’, ask why? At least five times. Possible responses might be that the consultant
doesn’t have time to see all their patients in clinic as they have to see everyone who
attends, including first visit assessments and follow up patients.

 Create templates of the processes (process templates), begin to schedule these templates
and watch the whole process improve.

 Keep a look out for other bottlenecks. In the whole patient journey there is likely to be at
least one bottleneck.

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 5


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

Different types of bottlenecks:

Bottlenecks are the parts of the healthcare system with the smallest capacity relative to the
demand. There are two different types of bottlenecks: process bottlenecks and functional
bottlenecks.

1. Process bottlenecks are the stage in a process that takes the longest time to complete. Process
bottlenecks are often referred to as the ‘rate limiting step or task’ in a process.

Figure1.1

In the example above, activity 3 is the process bottleneck as it takes the longest time. This may be
the consultant seeing the patient in outpatients.

2. Functional bottlenecks are caused by services that have to cope with demand from several
sources. Radiology, pathology, radiotherapy, and physiotherapy are often functional bottlenecks
in healthcare processes. Functional bottlenecks cause waits and delays for patients because:

 One process, such as ENT surgery, might share a function, such as imaging with other
processes, e.g. orthopaedic surgery, and medicine
 A surgeon may be called to theatre when he is also needed in outpatients.

This type of bottleneck causes a disruption to the flow of all patient processes. Functional
bottlenecks act like a set of traffic lights, stopping the flow of patients in one process while

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 6


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

allowing the patients in another process to flow unheeded. Where you have a bottleneck, there is
usually a queue i.e. a delay that the patient will experience.

Methods for reducing the effect of bottlenecks:

 Ensure that the bottleneck has no idle time, for example, have a list of stand by patients
who can be called at short notice in the event of idle capacity

 Put inspection or checking tasks in front of the bottleneck (e.g. if the bottleneck is the
doctor in clinic, check that all test results are available at the clinic)

 Don't allow the room or clinical area to be the bottleneck

 Distribute the work amongst the clinical team so that everyone works to their highest level
of skill and expertise, for example take administration away from rehabilitation nurses and
give it to appropriate clerical staff

 If experts are the bottleneck they should only be doing work for which an expert is needed
e.g. the development of nurse initiated transfer from critical care

 Separate responsibilities for clinical care and paper flow

 To increase the capacity of the bottleneck, give some of the work to non-bottleneck areas,
even if it is less efficient for these areas.

RESEARCH PROBLEM:

The research problem is to study the patient flow management in outpatient department.

NEED FOR STUDY:

As the patient flow increases there may be increase in bottlenecks, which gives a poor overall
impression for the patient. So to avoid this, reasons for increase in waiting time is analysed to
enhance patient satisfaction.

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 7


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

SIGNIFICANCE OF THE PROJECT:

Significance of the project is to analyse the inefficiencies and bottlenecks to improve patient care
delivery.

OBJECTIVES:

To understand the problems which the outdoor patients encounter like:

 Long standing queues


 Limited number of counters for patient registration and enquiries
 Improper maintenance of patient traffic at the out patient department section.
 To find the reasons and solutions for the problems encountered.

METHODOLOGY:

o Sampling method is followed for determining the patient flow process.


o Random sampling technique is followed
o The details of patients and time of his/her entry, the time for which the patient moves
through various departments till either exit of the patient or IP admission is noted.
o After the data collection is done the data is analysed for any delays in patient flow process
and they are resolved.

SAMPLE DESIGN:

The total monthly new OP is 1600-1650.A sample of 300 patients is selected which is 18% of the
whole population. The sample is selected by simple random sampling technique. The sample
represents the whole population.

SCOPE OF THE REPORT:

The project includes patient flow regarding only out patient department and the patient
management in various departments in out patient department i.e., registration process, in patient
admission, casualty/emergency department, diagnostic billings, diagnostics services.

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 8


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

SOURCES OF INFORMATION:

Primary sources:

o Survey method
o Relevant file study

Secondary sources:

o Internet used as a source of theoretical information.


o Registers and records of hospital.

TOOLS AND TECHNIQUES OF ANALYSIS:

For data collection:

o Personal observation: direct and indirect observation


o Interviews with staff
o Quantitative method of analysis

For data analysis: Mean

STRUCTURE OF THE STUDY:

Current study includes the literature review of other studies done on patient flow management,
historical aspect of the organisation in which project is done and outpatient department is selected,
data is collected, analysed and inferences are given.

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 9


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

CHAPTER-2

LITERATURE REVIEW

A literature review is a text of a scholarly paper, which includes the current knowledge including
substantive findings, as well as theoretical and methodological contributions to a particular topic.
Literature reviews use secondary sources, and do not report new or original experimental work.

Types of literature review:


Most often associated with academic-oriented literature, such as a thesis, dissertation or peer-
reviewed journal article, a literature review usually precedes the methodology and results section.
Literature reviews are also common in a research proposal or prospectus (the document that is
approved before a student formally begins a dissertation or thesis). Its main goals are to situate the
current study within the body of literature and to provide context for the particular reader.
Literature reviews are a staple for research in nearly every academic field.

A systematic review is a literature review focused on a research question, trying to identify,


appraise, select and synthesize all high quality research evidence and arguments relevant to that
question. A Meta analysis is typically a systematic review using statistical methods to effectively
combine the data used on all selected studies to produce a more reliable result.

Why do we write literature reviews?


Literature reviews provide you with a handy guide to a particular topic. If you have limited time
to conduct research, literature reviews can give you an overview or act as a stepping stone. For
professionals, they are useful reports that keep them up to date with what is current in the field.
For scholars, the depth and breadth of the literature review emphasizes the credibility of the writer
in his or her field. Literature reviews also provide a solid background for a research paper’s
investigation. Comprehensive knowledge of the literature of the field is essential to most research
papers.

Who writes these things?


Literature reviews are written occasionally in the humanities, but mostly in the sciences and social
sciences; in experiment and lab reports, they constitute a section of the paper. Sometimes a
literature review is written as a paper in itself.

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 10


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

LITERATURE REVIEW ON PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT:

There was a lot of research work done on patient flow management by many scholars since many
years on various issues like patient flow in hospitals, patient flow in the emergency department,
patient flow analysis to improve patient visit efficiency, improving patient flow—In and Out
of Hospitals and Beyond etc.,
Some of those studies are given below:

CASE STUDY 1:

Patient Flow in Hospitals:


Understanding and Controlling It Better
Carolharaden, PhD and Androgerresar, M.D.

Summary: Because waits, delays, and cancellations are so common in Healthcare, patients and
providers assume that waiting is an inevitable, but regrettable, part of the care process or years,
hospitals responded to delays by adding resources more beds and buildings or more staff as the
only way to deal with an increasingly needy population. Furthermore, as long as payment for
services covered the costs, more construction and more staff allowed for continued inefficiencies
in the system. Today, few organizations can afford this solution. Moreover, recent work on
assessing the reasons for delays suggests that adding resources is not the answer. In many cases,
delays are not a resource problem they are a flow problem. The Institute for Healthcare
Improvement has worked with more than 60 hospitals in the United States and the United
Kingdom to evaluate what influences the smooth and timely flow of patients through hospital
departments and to develop and implement methods for improving flow. Specific areas of focus
include smoothing the flow of elective surgery, reducing waits for inpatient admission through
emergency departments, achieving timely and efficient transfer of patients from the intensive care
unit to medical/surgical units, and improving flow from the inpatient setting to long-term-care
facilities.

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 11


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

CASE STUDY 2:

Analysis of patient flow in the emergency department and the effect of an


extensive reorganisation:

Emergency Department, Hospital Clinic, Barcelona, Catalonia, Spain Correspondence to: Dr Ò


Miró, Emergency Department, Hospital Clinic, Villarreal 170, 08036 Barcelona, Catalonia,
Spain.

Abstract:

Objectives: To evaluate the different internal factors influencing patient flow, effectiveness, and
overcrowding in the emergency department (ED), as well as the effects of ED reorganisation on
these indicators.

Methods: The study compared measurements at regular intervals of three hours of patient arrivals
and patient flow between two comparable periods (from 10 February to 2 March) of 1999 and
2000. In between, a structural and staff reorganisation of ED was undertaken. The main reason for
each patient remaining in ED was recorded and allocated to one of four groups: (1) factors related
to ED itself; (2) factors related to ED-hospital interrelation; (3) factors related to hospital itself;
and (4) factors related to neither ED nor hospital. The study measured the number of patients
waiting to be seen and the waiting time to be seen as effectiveness markers, as well as the
percentage of time that ED was overcrowded, as judged by numerical and functional criteria.

Results: Effectiveness of ED was closely related with some ED related and hospital related
factors. After the reorganisation, patients who remained in ED because of hospital related or non-
ED-non-hospital related factors decreased. ED reorganisation reduced the number of patients
waiting to be seen from 5.8 to 2.5 (p<0.001) and waiting time from 87 to 24 minutes (p<0.001).
Before the reorganisation, 31% and 48% of the time was considered to be overcrowded in
numerical and functional terms respectively. After the reorganisation, these figures were reduced
to 8% and 15% respectively (p<0.001 for both).

Conclusions: ED effectiveness and overcrowding are not only determined by external pressure,
but also by internal factors. Measurement of patient flow across ED has proved useful in detecting
these factors and in being used to plan an ED reorganisation.

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 12


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

CASE STUDY 3:

Use of patient flow analysis to improve patient visit efficiency by decreasing


wait time in a primary care-based disease management programs for
anticoagulation and chronic pain: a quality improvement study

Nicholas M Potisek, Robb M Malone, Betsy Bryant Shilliday, Timothy J Ives, Paul R Chelminski,
Darren A DeWalt and Michael P Pignone.

Abstract:

Background:

Patients with chronic conditions require frequent care visits. Problems can arise during several
parts of the patient visit that decrease efficiency, making it difficult to effectively care for high
volumes of patients. The purpose of the study is to test a method to improve patient visit
efficiency.

Methods:

We used Patient Flow Analysis to identify inefficiencies in the patient visit, suggest areas for
improvement, and test the effectiveness of clinic interventions.

Results:

At baseline, the mean visit time for 93 anticoagulation clinic patient visits was 84 minutes (+/- 50
minutes) and the mean visit time for 25 chronic pain clinic patient visits was 65 minutes (+/- 21
minutes). Based on these data, we identified specific areas of inefficiency and developed
interventions to decrease the mean time of the patient visit. After interventions, follow-up data
found the mean visit time was reduced to 59 minutes (+/-25 minutes) for the anticoagulation
clinic, a time decrease of 25 minutes (t-test 39%; p < 0.001). Mean visit time for the chronic pain
clinic was reduced to 43 minutes (+/- 14 minutes) a time decrease of 22 minutes (t-test 34 %; p <
0.001).

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 13


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

Conclusion:

Patient Flow Analysis is an effective technique to identify inefficiencies in the patient visit and
efficiently collect patient flow data. Once inefficiencies are identified they can be improved
through brief interventions.

CASE STUDY 4:

Work pressure and patient flow management in the emergency department: findings from
an ethnographic study.

Nugus P, Holdgate A, Fry M, Forero R, McCarthy S, Braithwaite J.

Author information: Centre for Clinical Governance Research in Health, Australian Institute of Health
Innovation, Faculty of Medicine, University of New South Wales, Sydney, Australia.
p.nugus@unsw.edu.au

Abstract:

Objectives:

In this hypothesis-generating study, we observe, identify, and analyse how emergency clinicians
seek to manage work pressure to maximize patient flow in an environment characterized by
delayed patient admissions (access block) and emergency department (ED) crowding.

Methods:

An ethnographic approach was used, which involved direct observation of on-the-ground


behaviours, when and where they happened. More than 1,600 hours over a 12-month period were
spent observing approximately 4,500 interactions across approximately 260 emergency physicians
and nurses, emergency clinicians, and clinicians from other hospital departments. The author’s
content analysed and thematically analysed more than 800 pages of field notes to identify
indicators of and responses to pressure in the day-to-day ED work environment.

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 14


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

Results :

In response to the inability to control inflow, and the reactions of inpatient departments to whom
patients might be transferred, emergency clinicians: reconciled urgency and acuity of conditions;
negotiated and determined patients' admission-discharge status early in their trajectories; pursued
predetermined but coevolving pathways in response to micro- and macro flow problems; and
exercised flexibility to reduce work pressure by managing scarce time and space in the ED.

Conclusions :

To redress the linearity of most literature on patient flow, this study adopts a systems perspective
and ethnographic methods to bring to light the dynamic role that individuals play, interacting with
their work contexts, to maintain patient flow. The study provides an empirical foundation,
uniquely discernible through qualitative research, about aspects of ED work that previously have
been the subject only of discussion or commentary articles. This study provides empirical
documentation of the moment-to-moment responses of emergency clinicians to work pressure
brought about by factors outside much of their control, establishing the relationship between
patient flow and work pressure. We conceptualize the ED as a dynamic system, combining socio
professional influences to reduce and control work pressure in the ED. Interventions in education,
practice, policy, and organizational performance evaluations will be supported by this systematic
documentation of the complexity of emergency clinical work. Future research involves testing the
five findings using systems dynamic modelling techniques.

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 15


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

CHAPTER-3
ORGANIZATION

HISTORY OF PRIME HOSPITALS:

Prime Hospitals situated in Ameerpet and Kukatpally, are one of the pioneer corporate
health care hospitals in the state of Andhra Pradesh. Since its inception, Prime hospitals have been
in the forefront in offering International standard corporate health care facilities. As leaders in
super specialty healthcare in the state of Andhra Pradesh.

Prime Hospitals is a private, full-fledged multi-speciality hospital with 250 beds of


which 75 are ICU beds in Ameerpet and also 110 beds of which 30 are ICU beds in Kukatpally
centres.

The hospital has expert and renowned doctors, state of the art medical infrastructure
which includes the advanced Cath Lab, CT Scan, Colour Doppler, Ultrasound and other
diagnostic services with fully equipped labs. All these combine to provide round the clock prompt
and accurate treatment.
As a leading healthcare provider, the hospital provides patients with the latest
technological innovations for diagnosis and treatment of the most acute clinical conditions. This is
made possible by the compassionate care and expertise of doctors providing the "Healing Touch"
to the patient.
The Hospital has trained staff including nurses; full time doctors and support staff to
provide round the clock personalized attention and care leading to faster recovery of patient.

DIRECTORS' VISION

We are pleased to introduce you to the world of the Prime Hospitals. We reinvented ourselves as
a group in 2007. We entered into the service sector enterprise to what I call "The Place Of
Care". Earlier, it was known as the Mythri Hospital, but renamed it as Prime Hospitals because
"Prime" symbolizes the location of the hospital, the quality of our services and the expertise of
our faculty.

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 16


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

Figure 3.1

As we know "Prevention is better than cure". So, Prime gives clear cut guidelines for prevention
of disease by its experts and experienced personnel.

We are actively involved in social service through Rajeev Aarogyasree services.

Our vision is to deliver world class health care with a sensitive focus by creating an institution
committed to the highest standards of medical and service excellence, patient care, scientific
knowledge and motivational approach.

We have set ourselves the mission of creating unparalleled standards and outcome. Our aim is to
be first in care providing as well as in patient's choice of home for care.

SERVICES:

Figure 3.2

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 17


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

» We provide a large range of consultative, diagnostic and surgical services to people


whose health complaints do not warrant hospitalization through our Out-Patient Dept.

» Quick registration procedures, extensive tie-ups with medical insurance organizations and
corporate world - credit cards are accepted for payment.

» An Emergency Medical service takes care of all emergency patients which has got
telephone access and round the clock red alert team along with all concerned specialities.

PRIME HOSPITALS
We have Two Branches in Hyderabad. Super Speciality Services at Ameerpet & Kukatpally.

Ameerpet:

Figure3.3
The Hospital is centrally located in Hyderabad at Ameerpet and accommodated in a building with
state-of-the-art medical equipment coupled with modern amenities. The Hospital houses all the
routine and the latest diagnostic facilities that are very important to enable quick and accurate
diagnosis to facilitate quality treatment.

Prime Hospitals is equipped with the latest facilities which function round-the-clock including
Cath Lab, T.M.T, ECG, PFT, CAT scan, Ultrasound-Ray and laboratory and five State-of-the-art
Operation Theatres. And with advantage of being centrally located and easily accessible, Prime
Hospitals provides 24 hours emergency care by experienced doctors in their respective specialities
including trauma care.

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 18


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

Kukatpally:

Figure3.4

The Hospital is air conditioned in all the patient care areas, providing the right ambience for
psychological and physical comfort. The well equipped four State-of-the-art Operation Theatres
can take-up all surgeries ranging from Laparoscope to Cardiothoracic surgeries. The intensive
care / acute medical care units are centrally monitored and are truly world-class. We have 4 OT's
with 24/7 coverage for any Emergencies.

SPECIALITIES IN PRIME HOSPITALS:

1. Anaesthesiology. 11.Plastic Surgery


2. Cardiology 12.Nephrology
3. Critical care 13.Gynaecology
4. Obstetrics 14.Metabolic Surgery
5. Internal Medicine 15.Advanced Laparoscopy
6. Neuro Surgery 16.Bariatric Surgery
7. Orthopaedics 17.ENT
8. Paediatrics 18.General Surgery
9. Radiology 19.Gastroenterology
10.Urology

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 19


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

CERTIFICATIONS:

The certifications given for prime hospitals are NABH, Indian Health Organisation and ODC
standards certification.

NATIONAL ACCREDITATION BOARD

Figure3.5

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 20


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

ODC STANDARDS CERTIFICATIONS:

Figure3.6

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 21


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

PRIME HOSPITALS QUALITY POLICY AND OBJECTIVES:

Figure3.7

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 22


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

STRENGTH OF THE HOSPITAL:

 The strength is its dedicated, committed and sincere multidisciplinary team approach of
medical, paramedical, non medical personnel and administrators who are committed to
continue to provide the highest quality care in an emergency.

 The training of staff and research continue to meet the needs of patients.

 Their focus is on patient care and patient safety.

 Working together the staff provides comprehensive diagnosis and coordinated


treatment.

 Proximity of outpatient department with lab facilities and other diagnostics ensure well
coordinated care.

Statistical information:

 Yearly OP range from 14000-15000


 Yearly IP range from 4800-5000
 Yearly diagnostics range from 30,000-35,000
 Monthly OP range from 1000-1500
 Monthly IP range from 3000-4000
 Monthly diagnostics range from 250-500
 Daily OP range from 30-40
 Daily IP range from 10-12
 Daily diagnostics range from 90-120

OUTPATIENT DEPARTMENT: Outpatient department is very important wing of


hospital serving as mirror. This department is visited by large section of community which is the
first point of contact between patient and hospital staff. The human relation skills/public relation
functions are utmost important. OPD is related with other departments like emergency,
diagnostics etc, This includes front office and emergency department.

Front office:

It contains reception, admissions, billing, diagnostics billing.

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 23


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

The work that goes on in a hospital front office vary depending on the size of the hospital and
the number of employees that work there. In general the hospital front office includes a reception
desk to greet patients and visitors as they enter the hospital and provide information where to go
or the services that are provided.

Functions of front office:

Function of front office are OP registration, IP registration, making site for the patients, making
bed occupancy, to minimise waiting time for all patients, to satisfy patients/visitors by proper
guidance, to organise consultant chambers as per their op timings, to minimise billing errors and
counselling of patients. The purpose of front office is to provide assistance for people when they
first enter the hospital.

OP and IP registration:

OP registration services are also available in the front office of the hospital. Patients can
provide their name and contact information, as well as any other information such as emergency
contact details. Certain administrative work is also done in front office such as maintenance of
records and paper throughout the hospital.

 Staff: 08 Nos
 No. of Shifts: 3 Shifts
 Shift timings:
 8am-5pm
 11am-8pm
 8pm-8am

Diagnostics billing : All the tests performed for op patients billing is done at this counter.

 Staff: 2 Nos
 No. of Shifts: 2 Shifts
 Shift timings:
 8am-5pm
 11am-8pm

From 8pm-8am the diagnostic billing is done at op registration desk .IP admissions from
8am-11am are also done at this desk.

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 24


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

Diagnostics:

Radiology department:

Location: Radiology department is located in ground floor close to out patient department.
Radiology department includes x-ray, ultra sound scan and CT scan.

Sources of data:

Primary source:

 Personal observation

Secondary source:

 Radiology department files


 Department Employees.

Radiology department:

The Radiology is a medical specialty that employs the use of imaging to both diagnose and treat
disease visualized within the body. Radiologists use an array of imaging technologies such as X-
ray radiography, ultrasound, computed tomography (CT),nuclear medicine, positron emission
tomography (PET) and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to diagnose or treat diseases.
Interventional radiology is the performance of (usually minimally invasive) medical procedures
with the guidance of imaging technologies.

Staff:
 X-ray department staff -2 and incharge-1.
 Ultra sound staff-2.
 CT scan staff-3
 Shifting boys-2, one in the morning and other in the night
 Typists – 2.
 Radiologists -2.

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 25


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

Shift timings: For x-ray and CT scan staff- 3shifts.

 8am-2pm
 2pm-8pm
 8pm-8am
 For typists: 8am-5pm and 11am-8pm
 For ultrasound staff: 8am-5pm and 2pm-8pm

Radiologist timings:

 10 am – 4pm
 6pm – 8pm

Inventory management:

 Indent for the required stock is given weekly once.


 The stock is obtained from the stores and pharmacy.
 Sufficient stock is maintained for the whole week as indent should be given only once in a
week.
 Per week around 200 films are used in x-ray department.
 Per month around 200-300 films are used in CT scan department.

Departmental orientation:

Newly joined staff has orientation classes by quality department staff and for old staff training
classes are conducted regularly. All the staff are qualified and efficient.

Patient management:

 The x-ray and CT scan departments are open for both IP and OP patients round the
clock.(24hrs)
 For IP patients who cannot be shifted to x-ray room, a portable x-ray machine is there
which is used at bed side.

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 26


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

X-ray:

Procedure:

 The radiographer shall strictly monitor all the results of the patients undergoing
radiography procedures.
 From 9am till 8pm if he/she finds that any findings is of a critical value, he/she shall report
the same to the radiologist. The Radiologist will confirm the critical result and will inform
the referring consultant. From 8pm till 9am the radiographer will inform the critical result
to duty medical officer.
 The x-ray film is given to patient within 5minutes for cash patients and for Aarogyasree
patient’s film is not given. Either doctor comes to x-ray department and see the x-ray or x-
ray image is given on a scanned paper.
 The image which is present in the system is saved and sent for report preparation.
 The radiologist sees the image and prepares the report.
 The report is given after 2 to 3 hrs.
 The film is given immediately in case of emergency patients and for patients who are
referred to other hospitals.
 The radiologist verifies the number of x-rays taken per day and number of films used.

Preparation of patients:

 Clean hospital gown is provided for patients to undress. A separate cabin is provided to
patients for changing the dress.

Preparation of the machine/room:

 The biomedical department holds the responsibility of all the machinery in x-ray
department.
 They check the machines and their working conditions every morning.
 In case of defects in the machines the biomedical department informs to the engineering
department to rectify the defect.

Critical results in x-ray imaging department:

 All the critical results will be reported to the treating consultant within 10 minutes after
completing the investigation.

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 27


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

 In case of emergency or code blues, the x-ray technician informs to the radiologists and
the process flow during this situation is as follows:

patient in emergency condition during x-ray imaging

patient is stabilised and shifted to casuality immediately under anesthetist supervision

code blue is announced

code blue team arrives and do the needful treatment

 During nights x-ray imaging of critical cases like intra venous pyelogram (IVP) are not
done only in case of emergency it is done under supervision of anaesthetist as
radiologist will not be available.
 Written consent is taken for IVP patients.

Radiology quality and safety parameters in prime hospitals:

 To minimize repeat exposures.


 To ensure that adherence to safety precautions of patient and employees are met.
 To minimize number of reporting errors.
 To reduce turn around time.

Radiation monitoring for staff:

 Proper precautionary measure has to prevent from radiation like radiation absorbent
aprons, TLD batches etc.
 TLD badges are to be worn during working hours to monitor their occupation radiation
dose.
 These batches are sent to BARC at Bombay for every 3months to know the radiation
exposure, by the employees.

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 28


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

Radiation protection for patients:

 Usually x-rays are not taken for pregnant women .only in case of emergency and
under prescription of doctor it is done.
 Lead aprons are given in case if x-rays are to be taken for pregnant women.

Ultrasound scanning department:

 The radiologist shall strictly monitor all the results of the patients undergoing scanning
procedures.
 The radiologist will confirm the result and will dictate to the typist. The report is typed
and given to patient.
 Scanning during nights is done only for emergency cases.
 In case of emergency or code blues, the process flow is as follows:

patient in emergency condition during scanning,informed to respective consultant

patient is stabilised and shifted to casuality immediately under anesthetist supervision

code blue is announced

code blue team arrives and do the needful treatment

 Various other procedures are carried in ultrasound department called as interve ntional
radiological procedures. This includes ultrasound guided fine needle aspiration technique,
biopsy, pleural effusion. Doppler studies of veins and arteries.
 Written consent is taken for any interventional procedures and also for other high risk
cases.
 For pregnant women scanning procedures like early pregnancy scan, TIFFA scan etc,

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 29


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

CT scan:

Procedure:

 The CT technician shall strictly monitor all the results of the patients undergoing
radiography procedures.
 From 8am till 8pm if he/she finds that any findings is of a critical value, he/she shall report
the same to the radiologist. The Radiologist will confirm the critical result and will inform
the referring consultant. From 8pm till 10am the technician will inform the critical result to
duty medical officer and to the radiologist.

In case of emergency or code blues, the CT scan technician informs to the respective
consultant and the process flow during this situation is as follows:

patient in emergency condition during CT scanning

informed to anesthetist,pateint is given emergency drugs and airway maintained

code blue is announced

code blue team arrives and do the


needful treatment

patient is shifted to casuality immediately under anesthetist supervision

Blood sample collection:

This is a medical specialty that employs the blood sample collection to both diagnose and treat
disease within the body.

Process flow in sample collection:

 Identify the patient.


 Assess the patient’s physical disposition.

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 30


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

 Check the requisition from for requested tests, patient information and any special
requirements.
 Select a suitable site for venipuncture.
 Prepare the equipment, the patient and the puncture site.
 Perform the venipuncture.
 Collect the sample in the appropriate container.
 Recognise complications associated with the phlebotomy procedure.
 Assess the need for sample collection or rejection.
 Label the collection tubes at the bedside or drawing area.

Statistical information of sample collection: 20 – 30/day

Staff:

 Number of staff:2

Shifts:2 shifts

 Timings : 7:30am – 4:30pm and 11am – 8pm

During night after 8pm sample collection is done in the laboratory.

Inventory management:

 Indent for the required stock is given weekly once.


 The stock is obtained from the stores and pharmacy.
 Sufficient stock is maintained for the whole week as indent should be given only once in a
week.

Departmental orientation:

Newly joined staff has orientation classes by quality department staff and for old staff training
classes are conducted regularly.

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 31


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

Emergency Department/Casuality:

Patients who need emergency care is directly bought into the emergency department. After
the initial care is given then they are shifted into the required ward i.e., ICU or AMCU or
general ward or step down.

Staff: There are two nursing staff and one DMO available round the clock. During day time all
the consultants are available according to their given schedule.
During nights consultants are available on call as per their schedule

Shifts timings:

There are 3 shifts for nursing staff and DMO.

 8am-2pm
 2pm-8pm
 8pm-8am

Inventory management:

 Indent for the required stock is given weekly once.


 The stock is obtained from the stores and pharmacy.
 Sufficient stock is maintained for the whole week as indent should be given only once in a
week.

Departmental orientation:

Newly joined staff has orientation classes by quality department staff and for old staff training
classes are conducted regularly.

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 32


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

ORGANOGRAM OF PRIME HOSPITALS

Managing
Director

Senior Medical Medical


Superintendent Superintendent

Consultant Administrative
NS CSO Manager
Specialist staff

ANS Security DMO Manager Floor Incharge

Nursing
PRO
Supervisor

Nursing
Incharge

Nursing Staff

Figure 3.8

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 33


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

ORGANOGRAM FOR AAROGYASREE DEPARTMENT

Managing Director

Medical superindent

HOD of aarogyasree
department

Executive

Figure 3.9

They are in coordination with government deputed Aarogyasree employees.

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 34


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

PATIENT FLOW PROCESS IN PRIME HOSPITALS :

Patients arriving at the hospital may be 3 kinds.

They are appointment patients, direct patients, emergency patients.

PATIENT FLOW PROCESS FOR EMERGENCY PATIENTS:

Emergency patients

Enters Casuality

Patients Stabilized

OP Registration

IP Admission

Investigations

Send to ICU/AMCU

Figure 3.10

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 35


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

PATIENT FLOW PROCESS FOR DIRECT AND APPOINTMENT PATIENTS

Appointment
Direct Patients
Patients

OP Registration

Doctor Consultation

Doctor takes history from patients

Investigation Required

YES NO

Diagnostics Billing
Done

Diagnostic
Procedures Done.

Reports Collected

Meet the Doctor

Admission Required NO Prescribes medication

YES Purchase Medicine


from Pharmacy

Patient reports at Leaves the Hospital


Admission Counter
Follow up
Admission Done.

Figure 3.11

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 36


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

PROCESS FLOW FOR AAROGYASREE PATIENTS

Aarogyasree Patients

Goes to Aarogyasree counter gets the op card and OP Registration


done at the registration counter

Doctor Consultation

Investigation Required

YES NO

Diagnostics Billing
Done

Diagnostic
Procedures Done.

Reports Collected

Meet the Doctor

Admission Required NO Prescribes medication

YES Purchase Medicine


from Pharmacy

Patient goes to the Aarogyasree department and Leaves the Hospital


confirms the eligibility for admission
Follow up
Goes to admission counter and Admission Done.

Figure 3.12

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 37


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

PROCESS FLOW IN X-RAY DEPARTMENT

Receiving patient bill with the required test

Arrival of the patient

Explaining the procedure to the patient

Preparation of the patient

Area of interest is made free from metal objects

Preparation of the machine

Required accessaries are made ready

Machine is kept ready with approppriate technical exposure

Exposure done

Film is processed using automatic film exposure

Film is obtained

Figure 3.13

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 38


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

CHAPTER-4

DATA ANALYSIS
A sample of 300 patients is selected for data collection.

Sample represents the whole population.

The data is collected in a format in which the time slots are given at each step i.e., at OP registration counter, in waiting area for doctor consultation,
diagnostic billing counter and for dispatch of reports.

The OP registration waiting time is represented graphically:

No. of Patients vs OP registration Time (Mins)


40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
Patient 15

Patient 23

Patient 31

Patient 39
Patient 41

Patient 47
Patient 49

Patient 55
Patient 57

Patient 65

Patient 73

Patient 81

Patient 89

Patient 97
Patient 11
Patient 13

Patient 17
Patient 19
Patient 21

Patient 25
Patient 27
Patient 29

Patient 33
Patient 35
Patient 37

Patient 43
Patient 45

Patient 51
Patient 53

Patient 59
Patient 61
Patient 63

Patient 67
Patient 69
Patient 71

Patient 75
Patient 77
Patient 79

Patient 83
Patient 85
Patient 87

Patient 91
Patient 93
Patient 95

Patient 99
Patient 7
Patient 1
Patient 3
Patient 5

Patient 9

OP registration Time (Mins)

The approximate time taken for op registration is 5-7 minutes. (Chart 4.1)

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 39


0
50
300
350

100
150
200
250
Patient 1
Patient 3
Patient 5
Patient 7
Patient 9
Patient 11
Patient 13
Patient 15
Patient 17
Patient 19
Patient 21
Patient 23
Patient 25
Patient 27
Patient 29
Patient 31
Patient 33
Patient 35
Patient 37
Patient 39
Patient 41
Patient 43
Patient 45
Patient 47
Patient 49
Patient 51
Patient 53
Waiting time for doctor consultation as in graphical representation:

Patient 55

The approximate time taken for doctor consultation is 30-40 minutes. (Chart 4.2)
Patient 57

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION


Dr. consultation Time (Mins)

Patient 59
Patient 61
Patient 63
Patient 65
Patient 67
Patient 69
Patient 71
Patient 73
Patient 75
No. of Patients vs Doctor Consultation Time (Mins)

Patient 77
Patient 79
Patient 81
40

Patient 83
Patient 85
Patient 87
PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

Patient 89
Patient 91
Patient 93
Patient 95
Patient 97
Patient 99
2
4

0
6
8
10
12
Patient 1
Patient 3
Patient 5
Patient 7
Patient 9
Patient 11
Patient 13
Patient 15
Patient 17
Patient 19
Patient 21
Patient 23
Patient 25
Patient 27
Patient 29
Patient 31
Patient 33
Patient 35
Patient 37
Patient 39
Patient 41
Patient 43
Patient 45
Patient 47
Patient 49
Patient 51
Patient 53
Waiting time for diagnostics billing as in graphical representation:

Patient 55

The approximate waiting time for diagnostic billing is 4 to 6 minutes. (Chart 4.3)
Patient 57
Diagnostics billing (Mins)

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION


Patient 59
Patient 61
Patient 63
Patient 65
Patient 67
Patient 69
Patient 71
Patient 73
No. of Patients vs Diagnostics Billing Time (Mins)

Patient 75
Patient 77
Patient 79
Patient 81
Patient 83
41

Patient 85
Patient 87
PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

Patient 89
Patient 91
Patient 93
Patient 95
Patient 97
Patient 99
0
10
40
70

20
30
50
60
Patient 1
Patient 3
Patient 5
Patient 7
Patient 9
Patient 11
Patient 13
Patient 15
Patient 17
Patient 19
Patient 21
Patient 23
Patient 25
Patient 27
Patient 29
Patient 31
Patient 33
Patient 35
Patient 37
Patient 39
Patient 41
Patient 43
Patient 45
Patient 47
Patient 49
Patient 51
Patient 53

Diagnostics
Patient 55
Patient 57
Waiting time for diagnostics procedures as in graphical representation:

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION


Patient 59

The approximate waiting time for diagnostic procedures is 10 to 30 minutes. (Chart 4.4)
Patient 61
Patient 63
Patient 65
Patient 67
Patient 69
No. of Patients vs Diagnostics Time(Mins)

Patient 71
Patient 73
Patient 75
Patient 77
Patient 79
Patient 81
42

Patient 83
Patient 85
Patient 87
PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

Patient 89
Patient 91
Patient 93
Patient 95
Patient 97
Patient 99
PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

Waiting Time at Various Stages in Patient Flow Process:

Total waiting time at various stages in


Patient Flow Process

3602

2095

660
546
390
222 165 180 135
130 95

Registration Time Consultation Pharmacy Diagnostic Billing X-Ray Ultrasound


Sample ECG Reports Not Consulted IP Admission

Hence it is concluded that maximum time consumption is for “Doctor Consultation”. (Chart 4.5)

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 43


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

Avg. waiting time at various stages in


Patient Flow Process

94.3

63.5 65.0

37.1

22.5

15.0
10.8
7.4 7.9
5.5 5.0

Registration Time Consultation Pharmacy Diagnostic Billing X-Ray Ultrasound


Sample ECG Reports Not Consulted IP Admission

The average waiting time is maximum for the IP admission. (Chart 4.6)

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 44


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD
 The average time for dispatch of reports is

 Sample collection 2-3 Hrs

 X-ray 4-5 Hrs

 Ultrasound 20-30minutes.

 For cash patients IP admission requires 15-30 minutes, in case of non availability of beds
2-6 hrs.

 For credit patients admission requires 30-40 minutes if they get clearing from the
insurance company.

If credit patients does not get clearing from insurance company and the, if the patient is willing
to admit on cash basis, admission is done and treatment is continued. If patient is not willing to
admit on cash basis, patient is discharged and billing is done.

 In OP, doctors are available 9am – 4pm and 5pm-8pm. On call doctors arrive within 20
minutes.

 Duty roasters are given all medical and paramedical staff.

 Patients referred from other hospitals are also accepted.

 Patients from prime hospitals are also referred to other hospitals.

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 45


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

CHAPTER-5
INFERENCES
 In unduly cases, doctor consultation time varies from 1 to 4 hrs due to non-availability of
doctors in OP.
 Reasons for this may be
 Doctors may be in OT during OP time.
 Surgeries in other branches.
 Doctors in rounds.
 This is due to the improper scheduling of doctor timings
 Front office staff at OP registration are unable handle properly the patients.
 There is no separate help desk or enquiry.
 Time of reports dispatch is greater in X-Ray department, as there is only one radiologist
during day time for ultrasound, CT scanning and X-Ray.
 Sampling test for IP and OP patients are done simultaneously so delay may occur in
reports despatching.
 There is no separate reports dispatch counter as there is only one counter for dispatch and
billing.
 Admission of patients is delayed due non-availability of beds and lack of nursing staff in
wards, which cause delay in arrangements.
 There is no MRI facility available.
 As reports despatched is delayed, by the patient gets the report the doctors may not be
available in OP.
 There is lack of nursing staff in casuality and the equipments are not under proper
working condition.
 Duplication of work occurs in front office, due to wrong entry of patient information.

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 46


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

CHAPTER-6
SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS
 Thus the major requirements of out patient department are:
 Patient registration with complete information of the patient.
 Check doctor availability.
 Patient case history record should be visible and should include the package deals
for a patient at a fixed cost.
 Consultation reminders need to send to patient on periodical basis, through
various modes like telecal, SMS, e-mail etc.
 Having improved the situation at one bottleneck, others may emerge as rate limiting
steps in the patient journey. Bottleneck management is, therefore, a process of
continual improvement.
 Thus improving patient flow is one way of improving healthcare services.

RECOMMENDATIONS:

 Training classes for front office staff is to be conducted.


 Consultant timings is to be properly scheduled.
 Recruitment of new radiologist and other required consultants is to be done.
 Duplication of work by the front office staff is to be avoided.
 Nursing staff should be recruited.
 Bed occupancy should be properly managed.
 A separate help desk and report dispatch counters are recommended.

LIMITATIONS OF THE STUDY:

 Project work was done in a small hospital.

 Sample size may be insufficient.


 The study was concerned with only outpatient department, so it does not include the
details of other department.

 Study was done for short duration.


 Due to improper time scheduling, was unable to consult with doctors.

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 47


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

BIBLIOGRAPHY:
 Hospitals: Facilities Planning and Management G. D. Kunders
 Patient Flow - NHS Institute for Innovation and Improvement.html
 Work pressure and patient flow management in ... [Academe Med. 2011] - PubMed –
NCBI.
 Managing-patient-flow-keep- lines-communication-open.html
 Barriers-remedies-to-optimizing-patient- flow
 Maximizing_Throughput_and_Improving_Patient_Flow.html
 ManagingpatientflowSmoothingORschedulecaneasecapacitycrunchesresearcherssay.aspx
 Profdavidben-tovim-131003191932-phpapp01
 Frontiers.pdf
 Analysis of patient flow in the emergency department and the effect of an extensive
reorganisation -- Miró et al. 20 (2) 143 -- Emergency Medicine Journal.html
 In Focus Improving Patient Flow—In and Out of Hospitals and Beyond - The
Commonwealth Fund
 Bottlenecks - NHS Institute for Innovation and Improvement.html
 Root Cause Analysis Using Five Whys - NHS Institute for Innovation and
Improvement.html
 Theory of Constraints - NHS Institute for Innovation and Improvement.htm
 Radiology - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.html
 Literature review - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.html
 Literature Reviews - The Writing Center.html
 Welcome to Prime Hospitals.html
 Referred old reports from library.

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 48


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

APPENDIX:
The following format was prepared for data collection:

 Patient name:
 Entry time:
 Op registration time:
 Dr Consultation time:
 Diagnostic billing time:
 Time at diagnostics:
 Reports dispatch time:
 Dr Consultation time:
 IP admission time:
 Or
 Time at OP pharmacy:
 Exit time:

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 49


PATIENT FLOW MANAGEMENT IN OPD

APOLLO INSTITUTE OF HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION 50

Potrebbero piacerti anche