Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Misguided Methodology
Introduction:
I’d hoped to prepare something under the title of “My weekend with
the Lutheran Confessions and a bottle of Jagermesiter – How I Learned
to Stop Worrying and Love the Missouri Synod.”
It didn’t work. But for those of you who know my father – and it
seems every member of the LCMS does – there’s a passion for speaking
about Judaism and Christianity. I’m not going to tell his story today. If
nothing else, I don’t tell his jokes quite as well.
But even though I’m not a convert, there are things in that realm we
can and should talk about. This is because whether Lutheran, Mormon,
Evangelical, or any other group placing itself under the banner of
Christianity, there are more misconceptions and assumptions than with
any other group that is rightly connected directly to the Christian
Church on earth. It wouldn’t be difficult to spend days on this subject
because the more you learn; the more you realize there are numerous
additional layers that can be explored.
During the course of the time I have with you, I’m going to break this
into three sections. Invariably, I’m going to leave some things out that
would be pertinent, so I hope I can provide additional insight once we get
to questions. If there’s something I don’t know, I’ll be glad to connect
you to the Balfour True Jew Hotline. The office is open from 9-5,
depending on traffic. The menu you’ll hear is a bit different than most
call centers, however. You’ll hear something like, “Welcome to the True
Jew Hotline, all of our dear Yentas are taking other calls right now, so
just wait a bit and we’ll be right there. But if you can’t take the time to
hold, don’t worry about it. It’s o.k. So I stayed up all night preparing to
talk to you, but don’t make a fuss, it’s not like I needed sleep. But…your
late uncle Greenburg, God rest his soul, he would understand, I
suppose.”
If you don’t think caricatures like that exist, trust me, they do. Even
today, I still feel guilty for all of the times I didn’t eat my great
grandmothers cookies (which she said she spent all night preparing), left
her house too early, etc.
Well, before I get too far off track explaining the truth of most Jewish
stereotypes, here’s how we’re going to cover things today: First, we’ll take
a look at the misconceptions Jews and Christians typically have about
one another. Second, I’ll give you an overview of Jewish belief systems,
and finally, some advice on the subject of evangelism.
This is not true and as time goes on, will be even less true. I think
you know the reality of this one. What percentage of your members
actually show up on a weekly basis in your congregation? I know it
varies, but it certainly isn’t 100 percent. A study released back in May
says that around 31 percent of those who identify as Christians attend a
service on a weekly basis.1 Another study shows that in my home state of
Maine, we have the lowest percentage of all – 21%. In fact, when my
father’s former congregation needed to move, they didn’t build. They
simply went “church shopping,” which means picking a location from
among the many closed and/or abandoned church buildings.
3. Christians all believe pretty much the same thing when it comes to
Christ.
Of course we in this room know that’s not even close to being true.
That said, there are two occasions that stick in my mind where a Jewish
Rabbi asked a Christian about Jesus as the only means of salvation. In
both cases, it was obvious that the Rabbis were testing Christians, or in
one case – me, to see how true this was. (Tell of what happened at
Concordia and during research in Maine.) If that’s the question posed by
these Rabbis to Christians, it stands to reason that it’s more likely than
not that this misconception is taught to a good portion of the Jewish
laity.
1 http://www.religionnews.com/2014/05/17/christians-church-atheists-prri/
Roman Catholic. His understanding of her faith, based on what he’s said
to me, is that she believes in Jesus and is required to go to Mass each
week. Beyond that, he told me, “[In our marriage] we just don’t deal with
that ‘religion thing.’”
Belief systems
Orthodox: Not to be confused with the Hasidic movement. That
might be best called “Extreme Orthodoxy,” I suppose. If you’d like to
discuss that, we can cover that more informally when there’s time to take
questions.
http://www.jewishjournal.com/judaismandscience/item/the_curious_consensus_of
_jews_on_abortion
make the point of Conservative Jewish orientation in a
lighthearted way, a proper understanding is to look at
this as an evolutionary form of Judaism. I label this as
“evolutionary” because the central ideology is that
although ancient Jews applied Scripture and the Talmud
(their “Confessions”) in a narrow form, the evolution of
culture and the contexts of modern life require "a
minimum of revelation and a maximum of
interpretation."3 An implicit devotion to Zionism is
understood to be part of the movement also. I can
expand on that later if you have questions about it.
2. Reformed Judaism: As just mentioned, Reformed
Judaism cronologically before the Conservative
movement. Although it doesn’t proceed it by a great deal
(10-20 years approximately), it was first. Even so,
Reformed Judaism didn’t formally get underway in the
U.S. until the 1920s. This also can be seen as an
evolutionary form of Judaism, but a form that has
evolved more radically and much more rapidly. I
wouldn’t have called it a radically different form of the
faith in its early form. Now, however, it seems to me that
there’s little truly Jewish about it. The central focus is
not on the faith, which is little more than a vague deism,
but social activism. Worship practices are as widely
varied as a person can imagine and in some ways, seems
to me a parallel to the so-called “worship style” of most
modern Evangelical Christians. Admittedly, I haven’t
attended a Reformed service, but in some congregations,
there’s a stress on an “informal, exuberant style.”4 My
favorite use of modern music of which I’m aware was the
incorporation of music by James Taylor. For those of you
who like James Taylor, I think, “How Sweet It Is To Be
Loved By You,” was a likely inclusion, but as for me, I’d
like to see how “Steamroller” or “I’m Your Handy Man,”
might have been adapted.
3 Abraham Joshua Heschel, God in Search of Man, New York, 1956, p. 274.
4 https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/Judaism/reform.html
Cultural identity – This is Critical!
5 http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/isdf/text/Maor.html
6 http://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/high-court-with-vocally-devout-
justices-set-to-hear-religious-objections-to-health-care-law/2014/03/23/ff54147a-
af97-11e3-9627-c65021d6d572_story.html
non-Jews. Actually, there’s not much to tell. There’s pride in the
fact that Jews don’t have evangelism programs, especially not the
Orthodox. In fact, you could call the standard Jewish approach
“reverse evangelism.” If you want to join, you go to them and if
you’re persistent enough, you might be able to take classes for a
year or two, or more. Do all of that and, perhaps then you might
be able to join. I asked my Rabbinical friend about this, because I
was aware that outreach wasn’t done, but never understood why.
He said that numerical growth was simply up to God and was
proud of the fact that joining was difficult. If a person had to work
at becoming a Jew, he said, then a person was obviously serious
and could be counted upon to be devoted to the faith. He felt the
standard Christian approach made things too easy for converts.
An interesting perspective and, to me, pretty ironic. Think about it:
I know a Rabbi, somewhat doctrinally liberal, who is adamant that
a person who refuses to show any desire to be catechized cannot
join. For most who call themselves Christians in any way, the
unspoken orientation is this: Catechesis doesn’t sell the product.
Second, with an understanding the Jewish approach to
evangelism, it’s easier to understand the Jewish view of Christian
evangelism, but especially the sort that targets them directly.
Now, take what you know about Jewish evangelism (or the lack
of it) and combine it with the Jewish stress on the importance of
cultural identity above faith identity. When you combine all of
that, you can understand why the standard, popular Jewish
outreach methods are so ineffective.
They’re well intentioned, but essentially worthless. The
overarching idea is nearly always centered on the idea that
“success” depends on sharing the Christian faith by appealing to a
Jewish person’s religious faith. This completely overlooks (perhaps
out of simple ignorance) cultural identity, and yet it persists. I
have no doubt that anyone here can think of numerous outreach
efforts that take exactly this misguided approach. Whether you’re
in the LCMS or not, I’m sure you’ve heard of the “Apple of His Eye”
organization. Appealing to the Jewish faith has been their
approach for nearly 25 years. One of their statements says, “We
carry the Gospel of the Living Torah, Y'shua, outward to the
unbelieving Jewish and Gentile population, as well as the message
of the Jewish roots of Christianity inward to Believers in the
Churches. (I’m not sure why a focus of Jewish outreach would be
the “Gentile population,” but I guess like any product, you have to
expand your target audience if you hope to grow.)
Such an approach is not only ineffective among faithful
Jews, it’s downright offensive. Christian evangelism efforts
focusing on Christ as the fulfillment of Judaism are simply a
means of “picking off the weak Jews who really weren’t all that
good of Jews to begin with,” my friend told me.
Equally offensive are the so-called, “Messianic Christian”
efforts, that attempt to blend together as much of Judaism and
Christianity as possible, resulting in strange combinations of
traditional Jewish worship, bland evangelical Christian doctrine,
and an identity that is neither completely Jewish or completely
Christian. There’s a Lutheran of some sort that I read about
recently who was very proud of how he’d combined Jewish rites
into Lutheran worship, making sure that the setting looked as
Jewish as possible. This doesn’t work. Devout Jews ignore it as
pandering and condescending. Strictly cultural Jews notice, but
the message of, “We’re similar” doesn’t have any meaning to them.
It’s as if you were to say to a non-practicing Roman Catholic,
“Look, a Lutheran liturgy is similar to a Roman Catholic Mass!”
Why would they care?
Even in Maine, the land of no religion, we have one of these
congregations in my area. Because they describe themselves as a
type of Jewish congregation, they reached out to the local
Rabbinical Association. The organization, which is consisted of all
of the Rabbis in the Portland, Maine area, refuses to even speak to
the leader of that congregation for any reason.
The most egregious Messianic Christian effort I’ve come across
is from the more well-known “Jews For Jesus” organization, who
for a time used the slogan, “Jesus, why not?”
Back in April, these so-called “Messianic Jews” released an
online video that showed “Jesus bearing the cross just as he is
about to be sent to the gas chambers at Auschwitz.” 7 No matter
how I look at it, I can’t see how this proclaims the Gospel to Jews,
or anyone else, for that matter.
Whether it’s the “We can show you the true Jewish faith”
outreach efforts or something as over the top as that downrightly
offensive video, neither have a positive effect on practicing Jews
and do even less for the unfaithful. Saying to a non-practicing
Jew, “Look at how our worship is similar to Jewish worship” is like
saying to a non-practicing Roman Catholic, “Look at how a
Lutheran liturgical service is almost like a Catholic service!” Why
would they care?
So what kind of outreach to Jews does work? The best way is getting
yourself out of the way. The more I learn about “techniques” and
“methods” that are the supposed means of “effective outreach” to Jews,
the more annoyed I become. The Holy Spirit working through Holy
Scripture is sufficient. No training video, no special educational visit to a
7http://www.jpost.com/Jewish-World/Jewish-News/Messianic-Jews-court-
controversy-with-Jesus-in-Auschwitz-video-349850
congregation by some sort of Jewish/Christian hybrid that’s supposed to
enlighten a congregation, no book of suggestions is greater than the all-
encompassing power of the voice of God Himself. (Surprise!).
Now, a couple of you may know what happened in my own family and
perhaps it’s not a typical (if in fact there is one) example of conversion,
but it’s relevant nonetheless.
I’m sure most of you know my father, as his reputation seems to
precede me everywhere I go. Not easy to be the son of the well-known
former LCMS board member some call “Fast Eddie.” Me? I call myself
“Balfour the Lesser Known, but Slightly Taller.” Of course, part of his
notoriety comes from the fact that he was a convert from Orthodox
Judaism in his early 20s. One of the prices he paid for that conversion
was alienation from his family. While time has taken care of that to an
extent, there was always the difficulty of knowing his own parents would
likely never become Christians of any sort.
Before hurricane Katrina, most of my family still lived in my
hometown of New Orleans. The hurricane changed all of that. I’ll not get
into the entire story, but because my grandmother’s home was
destroyed, no other relative’s home was left untouched, and because my
father was dealing with cancer and recovery from emergency heart
surgery, my grandmother became my responsibly. At the time, I was
serving a parish in Wyoming. After a cross-country trip with an 87 year
old Jewish woman who exemplified every stereotype of an old Jewish
Woman, I had a chance to show her what I thought was the most
wonderful place to live I’d ever seen. Obviously, as pastor of the
congregation, that was where my family and I spent a great deal of time.
She’d really never seen my three children much, so I told her, “If you
want to spend as much time with the kids as you can, you’ll need to
show up at church on Sundays.” This was not an effort at conversion.
Over time, I noticed she’d moved up to the front row and then started
mentioning that she enjoyed the sermons. She’s my grandmother, so I
thought it was a nice sentiment at left it at that. But there was more I
began to notice: When we prayed the Our Father, she was reciting it as
well. Then she began reciting the creed, singing the hymns, even
showing up for a Bible study on Hebrews (of course) that I was teaching
during the week. I thought that maybe something miraculous was
happening, but didn’t say anything. This continued on, even when I
moved back to Ft. Wayne and brought her along. About a year after that,
with great nervousness, I approached the subject of her being baptized.
Her response wasn’t exactly “no” as much as it was her great fear that
someone in the family might find out. I was stunned beyond words. I
waited a year and tried again. This time she said she would be baptized,
but it had to be private and I couldn’t tell anyone about it except my
parents and the chaplain of the facility where she lived. And so it
happened. The faculty did have a donated stand, but no bowl. I found a
metal mixing bowl that fit inside, brought my children, put my father on
speakerphone and went through the baptismal liturgy in its entirety.
That day, a 92 year old Jewish woman became a member of the Holy
Christian Church on earth. She was excited to be allowed to receive the
Sacrament of the Altar, Holy Absolution, and to be able to participate in
the liturgy that she’d come to love so well.
I’m not here to say that this is the only means of a Jewish conversion,
but if this is possible, then as Scripture says, “Nothing is impossible with
God.” You either believe that His Word never returns to Him empty or
you don’t. I can’t tell you how or when the door will be opened for any of
us to place God’s Word in the ears of a Jew, but remain aware that the
opportunity may come and if it does, our Lord is faithful to direct you to
know what to do.
I wasn’t sure if I’d have time to address current events affecting the
Jewish population in the U.S. and elsewhere, but since there’s some
time, I want you to have a picture of what’s affecting Jews today. I bring
this up because events which effect any part of the populace serve to
strengthen that sense of cultural identity I talked about earlier. Sadly,
none of what is happening at the moment is positive. There can be no
mistaking the fact that there is an increase in overt anti-Semitism. Anti-
Semitism never goes away, but how active it is comes in waves and at the
moment, the current wave hasn’t crested yet.
First, some examples in the United States are worth noting. In New
York, the home of a significant Jewish population, Anti-Semeitc incidents
tripled last year. I realize that “incident” is a pretty broad term, but
having looked over what these events were, every single one I read about
was of a violent nature.
More recently, there have been a number of events that have taken
place on college campuses during 2014.
At DePaul University in Chicago, the student body voted on a non-
binding resolution to divest itself from all companies that do business
with the state of Israel. Because of verbal harassment directed towards
Jewish students during the campaign surrounding the vote, many felt
unsafe and transferred to other schools.
At Vassar University, Nazi imagery was posted to Jewish students’
Facebook accounts.
At the University of Michigan, an anti-Israel group came to a student
government meeting and shouted racial epithets at Jewish student
government members.
At New York university, mock eviction notices were “served” to Jewish
students by sliding them under the doors of their dormitory rooms.
Second, there are no shortage of concerns for Jews outside of the U.S.
I don’t doubt you’ve at least heard in a general sense of what’s been
going on in France and Germany recently. Take these examples from the
newspaper, The Guardian:
“In the space of just one week last month, according to Crif,
the umbrella group for France's Jewish organisations, eight
synagogues were attacked. One, in a Paris suburb, was
firebombed by a 400-strong mob. A kosher supermarket and
pharmacy were smashed and looted; the crowd's chants and
banners included "Death to Jews" and "Slit Jews' throats".
That same weekend, in [another part of the capital], stone-
throwing protesters burned Israeli flags.