Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Learning Team 9:
University of Arizona
December 4, 2018
Quit the Stick Program Plan
2
Table of Contents
Introduction……………………………………………………………………………………... 3
Literature Review………………………………………………………………………………. 5
Figure 1…………………………………………. 14
Table 1 …………………………………………. 15
Program Description…………………………………………………………………….……. 15
Table 2 …………………………………………. 18
Figure 2………………………………………… 37
Figure 3……………………………………........ 38
References……………………………………………………………………………………… 40
Appendices……………………………………………………………………………………... 43
Quit the Stick Program Plan
3
Introduction
Quit the Stick’s overall findings from the Pima County Community Health Needs
Assessment of 2015 found that the quality of life of Pima County ranks the best among
Arizona’s 15 counties. Pima County ranks high in areas of health behaviors, clinical care, social,
economic, and environment factors. These factors can impact the overall and future health within
the county. The health status of Pima County can be considered healthy, however, Pima County
does struggled in areas of substance abuse and dependency. In fact, Pima County has the highest
drug induced deaths when compared to statewide statistics. Substance abuse and dependency
have become a prioritized health need. Pima County still has great medically underserved areas
such as in the Northeast and Northwest parts of Tucson where the ratio of physicians to patient is
1:315-1:1,000. However, health status of adults in Pima County is higher than other US counties
with 62% of the adults meeting CDC’s physical activities guidelines and only 20-25% reporting
as inactive outside of work. Unfortunately, for children, only 45% meet these CDC guidelines
Health needs that have been found in Pima County and that are considered priorities are
anxiety and depression spectrum disorders, substance abuse and dependency, injuries and
accidents and diabetes (Pima County, 2018). Quit the Stick is looking to address the health needs
of dependency among the target population. Resources for the general population within Pima
County varies throughout the county, the community health resources ranges from private
Community Food Bank of Tucson and Child & Family Resources which offer 31 programs
The Quit the Stick program assessed adolescent smoking in Central and Northeast
Tucson, focusing on high school students ages 14-18 years old. Quit the Stick will be
implementing the smoking cessation program within Tucson Unified School District which has a
total of 14,337 students. Quit the Stick chose Sabino High School representing Northeast Tucson
and Tucson Magnet High School representing Central Tucson. Sabino High School consist of
947 enrolled students, 42% being minority and Tucson Magnet High School consist of 3,181
For the Quit the Stick’s target population, the staff of the program decided to address the
health issue of nicotine usage in high school students ages 14-18 years old. The Quit the Stick
staff felt that this health issue should be further defined to include cigarettes and e-cigarettes as
well as juuls. The staff feels that by encompassing these forms of nicotine, they are able to gain
more of a response from the desired target population. Overall, Quit the Stick wants to lessen the
use of nicotine within this age group in order to ensure our society a healthier future.
Within the total population of Pima county, Tucson has 1.02 million people. After doing
some research, the staff of Quit the Stick found that the median household income for Pima
county is $47,560 with a poverty rate of 18.4%. 36.8% of the population is Hispanic and 52.4%
is white. Spanish is the most spoken foreign language at 22% of the population (Data USA,
2018). The large presence of Hispanic culture in Pima county explains the percentage of the
population who speak Spanish. Hispanic households on average tend to be a lower income
household. Lower income households are less willing to seek medical attention due to their
financial status. Therefore, the staff of Quit the Stick has seen a higher prevalence of negative
health outcomes among that population. There is also a language barrier that can prevent itself
when healthcare providers don’t speak Spanish and 22% of the population are Spanish speakers.
Quit the Stick Program Plan
5
Similarly the language barrier Spanish speakers is another contributing factor to the Hispanic
population not seeking medical help. There is a high national percent of adolescents who
participate in the use of nicotine products. The CDC states that, “nearly 9 out of 10 cigarette
smokers first tried smoking by age 18” (Smoking & Tobacco Use, 2018). Thus, there is a great
need for smoking interventions among adolescents. It has been also found that smoking
behaviors in adolescents are enticed by the different flavors that electronic cigarettes offer. The
CDC reported that, “73% of high school students and 56% of middle school students who
reported using tobacco products in the last 30 days reported using a flavored tobacco product”
(Smoking & Tobacco Use, 2018). The availability of tobacco products, the marketed flavors, and
smoking behaviors that their peers have influence the experimentation of tobacco at a younger
age. The percentage of teens who smoke tobacco in Arizona in 2011 was 17.4% and Arizona
ranked 23rd among 44 states (Tobacco Control State Highlights 2012, 2014). Since, there is a
high prevalence of adolescent smoking in Arizona it is important for the state to implement
prevention programs. 31 percent of adolescents in pima county have tried cigarettes compared to
the average in Arizona which is 28.8% (Arizona Department of Health Services, 2012). The use
of nicotine products increase with grade at 8% in 8th grade to 22% in 12th grade. This data
shows a higher use of nicotine use among adolescents in specifically pima county. This is why
Literature Review
The health educational specialist team in Pima County, AZ conducted a literature review
in order to evaluate the available resources related to nicotine use through smoking behaviors in
adolescence. Smoking behaviors can be impacted by different influential factors. This is essential
to understand in order to create an effective adolescent smoking cessation program. The Quit the
Quit the Stick Program Plan
6
Stick staff assembled the chain of circumstances existing and related to nicotine use among
In regards to the prompt given, the Quit the Stick team noticed the common target
population amongst studies was middle school to high school aged students ranging from 14-18
years old (Balch, 1998). The population found within most studies was a larger sample size of
approximately 400 individuals (Prokhorov, 2000). This way, both genders were equally
represented within the studies, helping us understand the culture behind adolescent smoking. The
racial background behind most of the studies included all races, however, a dominance within the
white races was found within some studies (Balch, 1998). In regards to a common health issue
amongst these studies, it appeared that smoking cessation along with nicotine use in adolescents
is a common theme. The health issues suggested within all of the studies reveal that adolescents
faced with underlying challenges often surround themselves within environments that contain
There have been numerous policies and programs implemented in Arizona and Pima
County. Arizona’s Tobacco Education and Prevention Program (AZTEPP) hoped to reduce the
access youth have to tobacco (Siegel, 2006). This intervention was able to use a variety of factors
such as increased law enforcement, warning signs, a media campaign, and merchant education.
The media’s campaign goals were able to help change the community norms as well as increase
the probability of community members stepping in when viewing underage tobacco sales.
CounterActs was a program administered by the AZTEPP which sought to increase identification
Quit the Stick Program Plan
7
checking policies that would consequently lessen adolescents tobacco access. This program also
included “We Card” signs that would help decrease underage access to tobacco and identify
Definition/Description
Most adults who are current smokers, began when they were adolescents and in recent
years smoking has continued to increase for adolescent smokers. Many who don’t seek
assistance with quitting at a young age will continue into their adulthood (CDC, 2018). From the
Quit the Stick team’s collected data, they reviewed different effective and ineffective studies
based on smoking cessation intervention programs, which expanded throughout the United
States, for example, in Baltimore City, Tucson, Southern California, Los Angeles, Southeastern
Connecticut, Chicago, Massachusetts and District of Columbia. There were also some studies
While conducting the literature review, the target population for adolescents attempting
to quit the use of nicotine smoking ranges from 14 to 18 years old. Most adolescents reported
attempting to quit or thought of quitting; in one particular study adolescents were asked a series
of questions related to the frequency of their smoking use and determining if they are former or
current smokers (American Academy of Pediatrics, 2018). Another study focused on adolescents
but found that smoking was indeed high in recent years, in 1991 the rate of smoking among
adolescents was 27.5% and four years later it increased to 34.8%. In this study, adolescent girls
reported to have higher symptoms of nicotine dependence (Nichet et al., 1997). Based on our
research there has been an increase in adolescent nicotine use, but also there is a low probability
of adolescents successfully quitting which leads into developing a higher nicotine dependence in
their adulthood.
Quit the Stick Program Plan
8
Precursors
Adolescents begin to participate in high nicotine use through smoking behaviors for
various reasons. While conducting the literature review, the research team found that the most
common precursor for adolescents is stress (Adelman et al., 2001). Stress was shown to be a
strong indicator in multiple studies. Since the target population was identified as being high
school students aged 14-19 in Pima County, academic stress was a major contributor. Along with
stressors from school, a study among adolescent girls found that stressors with peers, family, and
friends also had an impact in taking up nicotine use through smoking behaviors (Nichter et al.,
1997). Another strong precursor that leads teens to participate in smoking behaviors is the
nicotine dependence, researchers found that nicotine had the ability to outperform drugs and had
nicotine use through e-cigarettes, the precursors varied from traditional smoking. For e-
cigarettes, the main reason behind why adolescents started using them was because e-cigarettes
were more appealing to those who have not tried any type of tobacco product (American
Consequences
adolescents, the results found that there are many health associated consequences. One of the
biggest problems among adolescents was that they were not identifying themselves as smokers.
Lack of identity as a smoker can lead teens to dismiss cessation as a whole; therefore greatly
affecting their health in the long run (Mermelstein, 2003). Some of the many consequences
Quit the Stick Program Plan
9
related to health, found in the studies, were heart disease, cancer, overdose effects, and cardiac
arrhythmias (Niaura, 1996). In addition, adolescents are not properly equipped with the right
knowledge in regards to nicotine. With this, many students did not take into consideration the
long term health effects of smoking. A majority of the students believed that smoking for
approximately 1-2 years would not cause any detrimental health effects over time (Nichter et al.,
1997). In addition, many students associate smoking as a trend. The teens thought that a
temporary fad would not cause addictive nor chronic behaviors (American Academy of
Pediatrics, 2018). Furthermore, some of the smokers who identified themselves as smokers,
disregarded harmful health effects when the smoking product included flavors marketed towards
their age: fruit, dessert, and menthol (American Academy of Pediatrics, 2018). As for programs
aimed at cessation, adolescents did not take them seriously. One of the studies implemented a
cessation program but the students only attended the program to avoid class time (Balch, 1998).
In addition, one study had a focus on multimedia and adolescents in order to teach the teens the
negatives of smoking. Yet again, the adolescents did not take the program seriously and or did
Successful Interventions
The effective interventions that surfaced the most within the research, were school based
programs. Implementing an in-class curriculum was proven to be one of the most effective
interventions due to them being implemented during school hours and being short-term.
Adelman et al. (2001) states that they implemented a successful 6-week and 8- week cessation
program into a school that consisted of eight sessions. One session was introduction and team
building skills while session 2 was recognizing personal habits with smoking and possible
obstacles that could be in their way when they decide to quit. Session 3 consisted of developing
Quit the Stick Program Plan
10
personal and group strategies on how to quit while session 4 and 5 were focused on them
practicing these strategies. Session 6 focused on physical and mental preparedness and sessions 7
and 8 were devoted to relapse interventions and how to deal with these symptoms (Adelman et
al., 2001). The CDC offered a similar in-class curriculum that was based off the social cognitive
theory. This program was deemed successful due to its use of 10 similar sessions for the students
that focused on life skills, stress management, and healthy behaviors (CDC, 2018). Another
program researched how to create a possible effective intervention for a smoking cessation
program by interviewing focus groups of students who are smokers (Balch, 1998). These focus
groups were located in different states along with one focus groups consisting of a primary care
provider. The research results showed that students were most likely to stop smoking through use
of enticements, shorter lessons, money, or being able to speak to a personal physician (Balch,
1998). The use of an enticement was discussed by Nitcher et al. (1997) as girls participating in a
physical education class were told they did not have to attend the class if they attended an initial
presentation for the proposed cessation program instead. 80% of these girls then chose to
Aside from school-based programs, programs that are easily accessible to students have
been proven effective as well. These programs are mobile phone and media based. Whittaker et
al. (2008) states that not all students have the proper access to these support groups and students
liked when the intervention was brought to them via mobile devices. They saved time and effort
through this method. 9 of the 15 students reported liking the program stating that they enjoyed
watching the videos on their own devices and the text messages containing motivational and
informational content. These 9 had also quit smoking while the rest of the students reported
Quit the Stick Program Plan
11
limiting their use. They also reported saving the videos on their mobile devices, so they could
Unsuccessful Interventions
After assessing multiple interventions focused on adolescent nicotine use cessation, the
results found that using an informational pamphlet alone is not enough to influence the change
of smoking behaviors. Adelman et al. (2001) performed a study on high school programs
their success on reducing adolescent nicotine use. The study concluded that the informational
pamphlets were not as successful and did not reduce the rate of cigarette use among the
participants (Adelman et al., 2001). Some programs which relied on information sessions that
the adolescents would attend did not successfully relay the information. Some students, after
the program, still did not think that nicotine smoking would lead to addiction (Difranza,
2000). While students in another program did not believe that smoking was as bad as doing
other drugs, so they did not understand the importance of changing their smoking behaviors .
Therefore, it will be important to successfully engage and inform the students about the risks
they face with nicotine use, so that the program goal of reducing adolescent nicotine use in
An important finding stated that without intervention, adolescents have a very low rate of
spontaneous quitting (Mermelstein, 2003). This makes it clear that there is not only a need for
adolescent cessation interventions, but a demand for them. It was also found that a multi session
intervention and prevention. These in person classes are more effective than sending out an
Quit the Stick Program Plan
12
informational pamphlet because the students will be able to receive in person information and
guidance (Adelman et al., 2001). On a national level, a study found that flavored e-cigarette use
correlated with a higher chance of intention to begin tobacco use among the youth population
that had never used tobacco products (American Academy of Pediatrics, 2018). As quitting is not
seen as an important issue among adolescents, researchers have identified high rates of
After assessing all the information presented by various sources, the research group
found it most beneficial to implement a Quit the Stick cessation program. This program will be
held during normal school hours as it has been shown to be more effective in comparison to after
school (Mermelstein, 2003). After considering different options, the research team concluded
that this program will be targeted at 14-18 year old students that attend a public high school in
the Tucson Unified School District or Tanque Verde Unified School District. The information
presented in the literature review will help the research group implement the best smoking
Problem Statement
The problem the research team identified in Pima County was that adolescents
demonstrated high nicotine use through smoking behaviors. In Arizona, 10% of female and male
high school students reportedly smoked cigarettes at least once within a 30 day period (U.S
Department of Health and Human Services, 2015). Within this 10%, 46% of males and 51% of
females have attempted to quit smoking . As for electronic cigarettes (e-cigarettes), 16.1% of
high school students utilized this device (Truth Initiative, 2018). Also, 5.5% of high school
students smoked cigars within a 30 day period. These high percentage rates have a strong
Quit the Stick Program Plan
13
correlation with a direct consequence and a variety of precursors. Some indirect precursors
include: social influence, community environment, and lack of parental care. Demographic risks
that relate to these indirect precursors include: race, gender, and age. The research team found
that Blacks alone are most likely to intake nicotine through smoking behaviors. Also, males who
were within the age group of 18-24 are most likely to adhere to these behaviors. These
precursors lead to the direct problem of nicotine use through smoking behavior. Following this
problem were several consequences: morbidity and mortality. Morbidity and mortality
consequences included: cancer, emotional stress, cardiovascular disease, and stroke (Center for
Disease Control and Prevention, 2017). If these precursors are not addressed, the rate of nicotine
use through smoking behavior among adolescents will continue to increase with time.
The research group hypothesizes that the Pima County teens who are involved in Quit the
Stick Cessation Program will be able to demonstrate safe and responsible decisions regarding
nicotine use through smoking behaviors leading to an overall decrease throughout the target
population.
Quit the Stick Program Plan
14
Theoretical Framework
The theoretical framework that Quit the Stick selected as the basis of the intervention
program, is the Lewin’s Field Theory, which will guide the planning of each of the components
of the program plan by utilizing the force-field analysis of change forces and resisting forces.
Change forces are those that can push the target population or individual towards a specific goal
while the resisting forces are those that prevent the individual or group from making a change.
This theory was chosen in order to guide the development of the goals and objectives because
Quit the Stick Program Plan
15
resisting forces are highly prevalent in cessation programs for nicotine users. These forces never
align and in order for there to be successful change, the change forces need to be greater than the
resisting forces. Health educators will utilize the force-field analysis in developing the
intervention methods. This analysis is done by increasing the impact of the change forces that
will promote understanding the health risks related to smoking and strategies of quitting smoking
through guest speakers, cooperative learning and group work, peer education, and improvement
projects to include reflection journaling. Healthy coping mechanisms can be used through
intervention methods of problem solving and self appraisal. An external health education
specialists who has had previous experience working with adolescents in smoking cessation
programs in the community will be able to evaluate the influence of change forces and resisting
forces based on the adolescents understanding of these health risks and using these strategies at
Program Description
This program was developed by the research team after completing and analyzing the
literature review. The purpose of this program is to address the growing rate of adolescents
nicotine use through smoking behavior in Central and Northeast Tucson. Quit the Stick will be a
20 week program implemented in both Sabino High School and Tucson Magnet High School
Quit the Stick Program Plan
16
that will consist of an introductory presentation the first week, 8 sessions, and 11 discussion
sessions. This program will be implemented from August 2020 to December 2020. Quit the Stick
will focus on providing the participants with basic background information on nicotine use
through smoking behaviors, while offering them different coping mechanisms. After each
session, the research team will follow up with a discussion where students can practice and
implement different strategies to quit nicotine use through smoking behaviors. Discussions will
offer opportunities to implement a social media platform that allows for media interaction
through online videos and photos. The social media platform such as Instagram includes weekly
inspirational quotes and activities related to smoking cessation which will aim to create a healthy
Mission Statement
Tucson Unified School Districts and Tanque Verde School District in Central and
adolescents. Healthy environments for adolescents promotes security, access to resources, and
positive community interactions. Quit the Stick will help encourage adolescents to seek healthy
coping mechanisms through guided discussions, counseling, along with advice from mentors in
Goal
By December 21, 2020, the rate of nicotine use among adolescents 14-18 years old in
Objectives
Administrative Objectives
Quit the Stick Program Plan
17
● By June 2020, the research group will receive feedback from the pilot program that will
be assessed by a program evaluator and will be incorporated into Quit the Stick.
● By July 31, 2020, certified health educators will be hired for Quit the Stick.
● By August 1, 2020, all guest lecturers for Quit the Stick will be recruited and scheduled.
● By the first week of August 2020, Quit The Stick will have recruited a minimum of 60
Impact Objective
Learning Objectives
● By August 21, 2020, participants involved with Quit the Stick will be able to identify the
common health outcomes associated with nicotine use through smoking behaviors.
nicotine dependence.
● By October 30, 2020 at least 50% of adolescent nicotine users participating in the weekly
cessation program will be able to recognize at least three more effective stress coping
● By the completion of the program in December 2020, 80% of participants will be able to
Behavioral Objectives
● By December 2020, 75% of participants in Quit the Stick program will demonstrate
● By October 2020, 90% of participants in Quit the Stick will demonstrate 3-5 journal
● By October 2020, 80% of participants will demonstrate reducing their monthly costs
Environmental Objectives
● By September 30, 2020, 90% of the students attending Sabino High School and Tucson
Magnet High School will have access to recreational activities as stress outlets.
● By October 2020, 70% of the participants can identify a support system within their
social environment.
Outcome Objectives
● By January 1, 2020, the rate of nicotine use among adolescents participating in Quit the
Intervention Method
Theater Storytelling
By utilizing the Lewin’s Field Theory, the research team will develop intervention
methods that promote the force field analysis of increasing change factors, decreasing resisting
forces, and a combination of both of these factors together (Parker, 2013). Quit the Stick
work, peer education, problem solving, storytelling, guest speakers, self-appraisal, and personal
improvement projects. As for social media, Quit the Stick has a focus on Instagram, Facebook,
Quit the Stick Program Plan
19
and text messages. Theater includes situational scenarios and role playing. This allows the
adolescents to correct and improve their behaviors. Brainstorming includes strategizing possible
obstacles that they will encounter and how they should overcome them. In addition, cooperative
learning and group work includes discussions and sessions held weekly. Peer education includes
bringing peer advocates that have successfully quit nicotine. Problem solving includes
implementing the brainstormed strategies into their daily routines. Storytelling includes sharing
thoughts, past experiences, fears, and or anything in relation to nicotine during discussion and
sessions. As for guest speakers, Quit the Stick will bring in physicians and counselors to
communicate with the program’s adolescents. Self appraisal is acknowledged during graduation
in Session 8. Adolescents are appraised for finishing and or improving their smoking behaviors.
Lastly, personal improvement projects include self reflection through weekly journal entries that
Session 1
Session 1 of Quit the Stick will take place a week after the presentation was given in
class. The educational session will involve a pre-program survey about smoking habits and any
prior knowledge they have about cessation, as well as an introduction to what the course will
look like over the following 19 sessions. The pre-survey will consist of their current smoking
behaviors, how often they smoke, how much they spend monthly on nicotine products, why they
smoke, and what they are looking to learn or identifying their goal through completing the
program. There will also be a variety of icebreakers and team building activities to begin the
building of friendships and supports systems to help each other through the process of quitting.
Quit the Stick staff will also hand out personal journals that will be used later in the program to
write about personal strategies for quitting, obstacles faced during the process and thoughts
Quit the Stick Program Plan
20
throughout as well. These journals will be an important tool used in discussion sections to reflect
on improvements made. Lastly, the research team will share our social media accounts and have
the participants sign up for the text messaging system. These are going to be very important tools
used throughout the program to bring the necessary information, as well as uplifting quotes to the
students outside of the weekly meeting times. This will give students a way to engage with
health educational specialists and continually receive information on how to successfully change
Discussion 1
In Discussion 1, following Session 1, the research team will review the survey results
and compare the averages among all responses. These averages will be reevaluated at the end of
the program in order to show areas of improvement within the program. The research team will
discuss these results and the initial feelings that participants had about the program. After
completing this, Quit the Stick participants will engage a team bonding activity, where each
participants will write down a struggle or struggles that they have felt while trying to quit
smoking, or what caused them to smoke initially. An example of this is could be, “I feel stressed
with school so I smoke”. These statements will be identified anonymously within our program.
After drafting their struggles, each participant will receive a string. With the string, students will
tie a knot every time they relate to a particular statement read aloud by one of the health
education specialists. At the end of the activity, students will have a visual representation
showcasing how they face similar struggles and how they are not alone. The remainder of the
time within this discussion will be spent reflecting on the activity. The research team finds that
the first session and discussion are important for building a strong team among the participants
Quit the Stick Program Plan
21
of the program and establishing an environment where participants feel safe as well open to talk
Session 2
Participants will listen to a presentation regarding the health effects of using nicotine
through smoking behaviors and will be able to analyze their own smoking behaviors. During this
presentation, a speaker will introduce the smoking health outcomes that one may face if they
continue to participate in this behavior. These will be presented with acute and chronic effects
regarding smoking, along with some of the risk factors. Images related to each disease or
physical change due to smoking will be incorporated into the overall presentation. Considering
that not all our participants are smokers, there will be information given in regards to the effects
that second-hand smoking can have on the body. Participants will also be given the opportunity
to participate in the presentation by naming some of the effects they believe smoking has on the
body.
Since the research team discovered through the literature review that nicotine dependence
is a main contributor to why adolescents struggle to quit smoking, part of the presentation will
focus on nicotine dependence (Mermelstein, 2003). During this section of the presentation,
participants will gain a better understanding of what nicotine dependence is and how they might
be exposed to it. At the end of the presentation, students will be given a clear definition of what
it means to be considered a smoker. This will help the students identify themselves as a smoker
Discussion 2
Quit the Stick Program Plan
22
This discussion will build upon the previous session. There will be volunteer physicians
participating in the group discussion with students in regards to health outcomes associated with
smoking. This gives the students the opportunity to ask any questions that they may have had
during the presentation in a more intimate setting. After asking all lingering questions,
participants will have the opportunity to list possible obstacles that they feel could lie ahead and
fears that they have for upcoming sessions. These obstacles and fears will be recorded in their
Session 3
In this session, participants will be able to utilize positive action planning in overcoming
obstacles they may face with quitting. Through this action planning, they will be able to
determine at least one alternative coping mechanism in a group setting and individual setting
which can involve peer pressure from friends or family, overall stress management from their
social environment and possible barriers based on an adolescents gender tendency. Various
positive coping mechanisms can include Meditating, Yoga (any form of desired exercise),
changing routines that can relate or lead to cravings, listening to music or seeking guidance from
a friend or family.
Discussion 3
During this discussion, participants will be divided into groups based on their background
obstacle they wish to overcome while trying to quit smoking, which include peer pressure, stress
management, and obstacles based on gender tendencies. During this discussion, Quit the Stick is
open to the idea of inviting guest speakers who are former smokers. Through their own
Quit the Stick Program Plan
23
experiences with smoking cessation, these former smokers are able to encourage adolescents and
Session 4
In this session, participants will be practicing strategies for overcoming obstacles that
were established in the previous session. This is a session that goes more into depth in regards to
developing the strategies and knowing how to recognize these obstacles beforehand.
This allows the adolescents to have a more positive outlook on quitting and become more aware
of the positives and negatives of their daily choices in lives that can lead to cravings or stress
related obstacles.
Discussion 4
In this discussion, adolescents will be able to discuss how these obstacles were presented
to them in Session 4 and what they did in the situation to overcome them. Through this, they are
able to analyze their action planning on areas they could improve on and how to recognize future
fears related to smoking cessation. This guided discussion will also have a panel from a guest
speaker who was a previous smoker who can talk about their own experiences in regards to
Session 5
Within this session, Health Educators will work together in order to compose a skit to
depict the obstacles they’ve had to overcome in their lifetime. These obstacles can be related in
regards to peer pressure, current nicotine usage, influences, and their environment. Similarly,
health educators will dictate to their audience how they handled each obstacle within their life.
influence/support system within their everyday life. Participants within Quit the Stick will then
evaluate the skits, acknowledging what each health educator did wrong and right within their
presentation. This way, students are able to identify obstacles as well as how to handle obstacles
Discussion 5
The discussion will be based on the previous session and contain more information for
participants on positive as well as negative solutions in regards to obstacles within their lives.
This enables students to not only ask questions in regards to obstacles, but to understand that
they are not alone. Everyone faces obstacles, due to the peer pressures from society, yet it is
ultimately an individual’s choice if they wish to give in. Student’s understanding of these
obstacles as well as their skit evaluations will be recorded within their personal journals in
Session 6
This session will focus on dealing with mental and physical health. Within this session
the research team would like to define what a healthy state of mind involves along with how to
become physically healthy. The desire to smoke can often stem from outside stressors or from
body image issues. Quit the Stick will focus on teaching participants how to recognize health
issues that can occur through this program or might already be present. The Quit the Stick team
will also discuss how participants can cope with these issues through physical health. Similarly,
the research team will also give tips in order to help participants strategize about how to maintain
Discussion 6
Quit the Stick Program Plan
25
In this discussion the program will discuss coping mechanisms that are considered
healthy when participants are presented with an obstacle or begin to feel symptoms such as
doubt. Participants will reflect on what they have been currently doing to cope. Quit the Stick
staff will hold group discussions so participants are able to gain insight in regards to new ideas as
well as coping in a healthy manner. Participants will also discuss how they will implement
physical activity as a way to cope with stressors. After this discussion, participants will set goals
on how they will respond when stressors or obstacles occur. Participants will strategize together
on what goals to set pertaining to specific scenarios that they could find themselves in.
Session 7
Session 7 has an overall focus on relapse and withdrawal as well as helping a friend quit
nicotine usage. This session stems off of previous sessions with applying coping mechanisms as
well as alternatives to smoking. This session allows adolescents within the program to discuss
possible symptoms: sweating, tingling in hands and feet, insomnia, cravings etc. and apply their
knowledge from Quit the Stick to their friends. The program participants can reflect on how
much they have learned throughout the program while attempting to inform their friends about
Discussion 7
During discussion seven, a guest counselor will attend in order to discuss possible relapse
symptoms and health issues. The counselor’s job is to inform and teach the adolescents the
negative health issues that nicotine has on the body. One main focus throughout this discussion is
to point out how dangerous a “slip” is in regards to a relapse. Also to point out the triggers of
Quit the Stick Program Plan
26
relapse: consuming alcohol, associating themselves with other smokers, sleep deprivation etc.
The counselor is prepared and ready to answer any health related issues stemmed from smoking.
Session 8
Session 8 has an overall focus on a post program survey and graduation ceremony.
Within this post survey, the adolescents are given the opportunity to compare their results and
recognize their personal improvements within their nicotine usage. Session eight will also hold a
graduation ceremony. The ceremony is held to congratulate and acknowledge adolescents for
completing the program and/or making improvements with their relationship to smoking.
Discussion 8
Quit the Stick staff and participants are able to celebrate and spend time with their fellow
graduates.
The Quit the Stick intervention program will utilize the specific target audience of ages
14-18 within both Sabino High School in Northeast Tucson as well as Tucson Magnet High
School in Central Tucson. Within both of these high schools, the research team will present the
program to both Physical Education classes and Health Education classes within the program.
During the initial presentation, Quit the Stick staff will provide consent forms for students to take
home in order for parents to sign so that students are able to participate and receive the necessary
course credit. After the presentation, the research team will encourage students to sign up for the
In regards to finding channels to advertise the program, the research team feels that they
can effectively recruit the target population by the use of social media. Accounts such as
Facebook and Instagram have a large impact on high school aged students, due to the tech-savvy
generation society has become. Quit the Stick feels that by establishing a social media presence
within the program, staff will have the ability to create content that is both inspirational and
informational for the program participants. Quit the Stick will set up a text message system in
order to send uplifting and inspirational messages to the participants, updates about
In order to distribute the health education services and benefits, Quit the Stick has decided to use
methods such as skits, PowerPoints, interactive activities, educational videos, a social media
From May to July of 2020, the Quit the Stick staff will need to be trained as well as
prepared for the launch of the program in August of 2020. Staff will need to have established
both a social media presence within the program as well as prepare the materials needed for the
initial presentation in the beginning of August 2020. In order to fulfill the programs objectives,
Quit the Stick staff will use a classroom as a facility as well as a projector for PowerPoint
presentations. Quit the Stick staff will also need a whiteboard within a classroom setting, due to
the nature of the program and the activities are set up for participants.
The Quit the Stick program will go through a pilot testing period in order to try out the
educational materials on the targeted audience. The research team will run a sample educational
session and discussion session at five schools within the two school districts of Central and
Northeast Tucson. This will be a two week pilot and participants will have the opportunity to
continually give feedback during both sessions. After completing the pilot session, students will
Quit the Stick Program Plan
28
be given the opportunity to fill out a post-pilot survey in regards to their thoughts and
experiences based on what they learned. The program will be piloted in one Physical Education
and one Health class at each school. With an average of 30 students per class, the pilot will
involve around 300 participants. This will give the research team a decent amount of feedback in
order for the program administrators to reevaluate and edit the program. This will ensure that the
program is tailored to the specific target audience by August 2020 when the program is set to be
implemented within Sabino High School and Tucson Magnet High School.
The timeline below gives a brief explanation of the dates for the program piloting and
preparation. Quit the Stick staff has written and edited this in order to help the staff accomplish
● January 2020 approval from TUSD and TVSD school board for program implementation
● June- July 2020 gather program materials and create all activities
Programming
For Quit the Stick, a Pima County health education specialist will be responsible for
designing a cessation program for adolescents participating in nicotine use through smoking
behaviors. To document the success and effectiveness of our program, an external health
educational specialist evaluator who has worked with smoking cessation will be hired to report
all findings regarding the program and staff effectiveness. The research team wanted the most
accurate program evaluation and therefore, chose an external evaluator to eliminate any potential
bias. With the external evaluator being implemented in Quit the Stick, there are three main
evaluations that will be conducted: Process, Impact, and Outcome. These evaluations will be
engineered during the spring after Quit the Stick has been implemented for two years.
Evaluation Objectives
Process Evaluation
Administrative Objective A
● By June 2020, the research group will receive feedback from the pilot program that will
be assessed by a program evaluator and will be incorporated into Quit the Stick.
Depending on the program evaluation, Quit the Stick specialists will administer and alter the
program as needed. The external program evaluator will use the surveys implemented in the
● The external program evaluator will gather all relevant data from the program to confirm
that Quit the Stick has attracted adolescents between ages 14-18 and has had an impact
on their behavior.
Administrative Objective B
● By July 31, 2020, certified health educators will be hired for Quit the Stick.
This conference will discuss the health educator’s experience with nicotine and have them
explain why they are suitable educators for adolescents ages 14-18. From there, the program
● The external program evaluator will assess certified health educators by confirming
Administrative Objective C
● By August 1, 2020, all guest lecturers for Quit the Stick will be recruited and scheduled.
The content provided by the guest lecturers will be approved to assure that it is appropriate for
adolescents age 14-18. When all guest lecturers are recruited, the program creators will cross
● The external program evaluator will assess the content provided by the guest lecturers
and discuss any scheduling conflicts. If conflicts arise, alternative scheduling dates will
Administrative Objective D
● By the first week of August 2020, Quit The Stick will have recruited a minimum of 60
Quit the Stick will post flyers around the school along with host a pilot program in order to
recruit students to participate in the program. Students will sign up on a sheet during the pilot
● The external program evaluator will approve that 60 students is a sufficient sample size to
implement Quit the Stick in both Sabino High School and Tucson Magnet High School.
Once the sample size is approved, the external program evaluator will examine if Quit the
Impact Objective
Learning Objective A
● By August 21, 2020, participants involved with Quit the Stick will be able to identify the
common health outcomes associated with nicotine use through smoking behaviors.
The Quit the Stick program will incorporate a pre and post program survey that shows the
improvement of education and smoking behaviors among its participants. During the biweekly
discussion sections there will also be guided conversations. In the survey and the discussion, the
health education specialists will be able to monitor the participants’ understanding of health
outcomes through these methods. The evaluator will review Quit the Stick’s discussions and
approve that the staff has gained adequate knowledge for the students to do so.
● The external program evaluator will approve that August 21, 2020 is a sufficient amount
of time for the program’s adolescents to identify the common health outcomes associated
Learning Objective B
Quit the Stick Program Plan
32
nicotine dependence.
In order to track the characteristic of nicotine dependence, Quit the Stick staff will hold guided
dependence including discussion on physical and mood altering effects nicotine has on the brain
and body.
● The external program evaluator will approve that Quit the Stick has provided adolescents
Learning Objective C
● By October 30, 2020 at least 50% of adolescent nicotine users participating in the weekly
cessation program will be able to recognize at least three more effective stress coping
In order to track the participation of adolescent nicotine users within the program, participants
will have to comprehend as well as understand effective stress coping mechanisms. Health
education instructors will present these mechanisms as well as help students further understand
that there are multiple ways to cope with stressful scenarios in their everyday lives.
● The external program evaluator will determine if Quit the Stick health specialist are
Learning Objective D
● By the completion of the program in December 2020, 80% of participants will be able to
The health education specialists will be able to identify how many of the participants will be able
to develop strategies for smoking cessation by the end of the program through the use of the post
program survey. This survey will help identify the level of participant’s understanding and
● By the end of the program, the external program evaluator will be able to measure if the
completion date is an adequate amount of time for participants to develop two group
Behavioral Objective A
● By December 2020, 75% of participants in Quit the Stick program will report specific
The external program evaluator will address if the stress mechanisms taught during class
acknowledges various lifestyles among the program’s adolescents. This information will be
gathered through the post and pre surveys given throughout the program.
● The external program evaluator will address if the stress mechanisms taught are realistic
Behavioral Objective B
● By October 2020, 90% of participants in Quit the Stick will report 3-5 journal entries per
week.
Journal entries will be discussed during the discussions sessions. The content during the time can
be evaluated by the external evaluator during the first discussion in order to determine if sharing
Quit the Stick Program Plan
34
of the journal entries should be continued. Quit the Stick will take into consideration the
evaluators input after consideration of the participants vulnerability to share their entries.
● The external program evaluator will determine if journal entries are appropriate to
implement in Quit the Stick. This will take into consideration the emotions and
Behavioral Objective C
● By October 2020, 80% of participants will report reducing their monthly costs spent on
The external evaluator will use the pre and post survey to acknowledge the comfort among
program participants. The evaluator will see any additional comments within the comments box.
● The external program evaluator will acknowledge the comfort among program
Environmental Objective A
● By September 30, 2020, 90% of the students attending Sabino High School and Tucson
Magnet High School will have access to recreational activities as stress outlets.
The external program evaluator will attend Pima County public meetings where they will assess
the willingness of them to contribute. Pima County officials will be given materials to vote on
● The external program evaluator will assess Pima County committees willingness to offer
Environmental Objective B
Quit the Stick Program Plan
35
● By October 2020, 70% of the participants can identify a support system within their
social environment.
The team building exercises implemented in the program are designed to build a support system
within the program. The health education specialists will hold discussions as well as offer
counseling services to the participants in the program. Through these discussion the education
specialists will be able to identify how many students feel they have a support system to help
● The external program evaluator will confirm that Quit the Stick gives adolescents a
Outcome Objective A
● By January 1, 2020, the rate of nicotine use among adolescents participating in Quit the
The external program evaluator will measure how many of the adolescents have reduced nicotine
use by giving a community survey. They will also pull data from Pima County’s database to
a. The external program evaluator will report the percentage of adolescents ages 14-18 in
the Tucson Unified School District and Tanque Verde District that have reduced nicotine
use.
Methods
The methods used for the process evaluation include focusing on sample sizes,
credentials, and scheduling conflicts. Sample size will be regulated through the enrollment of the
Quit the Stick Program Plan
36
class within their school schedule. Credentials will be cross referenced with state laws. Lastly,
scheduling conflicts will be comparing Quit the Stick’s schedule to the guest lectures personal
schedule.
The methods used for the impact evaluation was divided into: learning, behavioral, and
environmental. As for learning, there was an overall focus on: timeframe and the information
presented. In regards to time frame, the method was based off of the external evaluators
judgment. The method for evaluating the information presented was comparing the information
to accurate health manuals and books published. Furthermore, behavioral aspects were focused
on the information’s appropriateness and attainability. The method for judging the
appropriateness and attainability was based off of the external evaluators judgments as well as
feedback from the adolescents in the pilot test. Lastly, the environmental aspect had a focus on
the cooperation from Pima County and establishment of support systems. The method for the
Pima County co-operation was to attend the facilities and discuss their willingness to participate
in Quit the Stick. The method for evaluating the support system was to base off the pilot testing
experiences.
The methods used for evaluating the outcome of Quit the Stick was to look at all
Timeline
Evaluation Tools
The evaluation tools will be given to the external program evaluator during each session
and discussion to evaluate the content presented. The external program evaluator will then use
the program evaluation form to assess the material presented during each session and discussion.
Depending on the comments and feedback given on this form, the program creators will make
Reports
The audience receiving the external program evaluators report will be Quit the Stick
program creators. This report ranges from very satisfied to unsatisfied. Depending on the
severity of the evaluators comments/remarks, Quit the Stick creators will adjust accordingly. The
external program evaluator will deliver the report to the appropriate audience. This report will be
Quit the Stick Program Plan
39
delivered by March 1, 2022. This gives the program creators enough time to make adjustments
References
Adelman, W. P., Duggan, A. K., Hauptman, P., & Joffe, A. (2001, April 01). Effectiveness of
a High School Smoking Cessation Program. Retrieved from
http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/107/4/e50.full
Arizona Department of Health Services, 2012 Youth Smoking in Pima County [PDF file]
retrieved from https://azdhs.gov/documents/prevention/tobacco-chronic-disease/
tobacco-free-az/resources/btcd/youth-smoking-pima-county.pdf
Balch, GI. (1998) Exploring Perceptions of Smoking Cessation among High School
Smokers: Input and Feedback from Focus Groups. Preventive Medicine. 27 (5): A55
A63. https://doi.org/10.1006/pmed.1998.0382
CDC. (2018). Not On Tobacco (NOT)—Smoking Cessation Program for 14–19 Year Olds
Selected as a Model Program. Retrieved from https://www.cdc.gov/prc/pdf/not
on tobacco-smoking-cessation.pdf
Center for Disease Control and Prevention. (2017). Health Effects of Cigarette Smoking.
Retrieved from https://www.cdc.gov/tobacco/data_statistics/fact_sheets/
health_effects/effects_cig_smoking/index.htm
Data USA. (2018). Pima County, AZ. Retrieved 2018, from https://datausa.io/profile/geo/pima
county-az/
Difranza, J. R., Rigotti, N. A., McNeil, A. D., Ockene, J. K., Savageau, J. A., Cyr, D.,
& Rodgers, A. (2008).). Initial symptoms of nicotine dependence in adolescents.
Tobacco Control, 9(3), 313-319. doi:10.1136/tc.9.3.313
Mermelstein, R. (2003). Teen Smoking Cessation. Teen Smoking Cessation, 12(1), 25-24
Nichter, M., Nichter, M., Vuckovic, N., Quintero, G., & Ritenbaugh, C. (1997). Smoking
experimentation and initiation among adolescent girls: Qualitative and quantitative
findings. Tobacco Control, 6(4), 285-295. doi:10.1136/tc.6.4.285
Quit the Stick Program Plan
41
Parker, S. (2013). The Practice and Process of Health Education in Health Promotion.
Dubuque: Kendall Hunt Publishing Company.
Prokhorov, A. V., Pallonen, U. E., Fava, J. L., Ding, L., & Niaura, R. (1996). Measuring
nicotine dependence among high-risk adolescent smokers. Addictive Behaviors, 21(1),
117-127. doi:10.1016/0306-4603(96)00048
Siegel, J. T., & Alvaro, E. M. (2006). An Evaluation of Arizona’s Youth Tobacco Access
Prevention Media Campaign. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 30(4), 284
291.doi:10.1016/j.amepre.2005.11.008
Smoking & Tobacco Use. (2018, June 25). Retrieved December 3, 2018, from
https://www.cdc.gov/tobacco/data_statistics/fact_sheets/youth_data/tobacco_use/index
htm
Tobacco Control State Highlights 2012. (2014, December 8). Retrieved December 3, 2018,
from https://www.cdc.gov/tobacco/data_statistics/state_data/state_highlights/2012/
index.htm
Truth Initiative. (2018, June 29). 2018 Arizona tobacco use fact sheet. Retrieved from
https://truthinitiative.org/tobacco-use-arizona
U.S. Census Bureau. (2017). U.S. Census Bureau QuickFacts: Pima County, Arizona.
Retrieved from https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/pimacountyarizona
U.S Department of Health and Human Services. (2015). Arizona Adolescent Substance Abuse
Facts. Retrieved from https://www.hhs.gov/ash/oah/facts-and-stats/national-
and-state-data-sheets/adolescents-and-substance-abuse/arizona/index.html
U.S. News and World Report - Education. (2015). Sabino High School in Tucson, AZ.
Retrieved from https://www.usnews.com/education/best-high
schools/arizona/districts/tucson-unified-district/sabino-high-school-1120
U.S. News and World Report - Education. (2015). Tucson Magnet High School in Tucson, AZ.
Retrieved from
https://www.usnews.com/education/best-high-schools/arizona/districts/tucson-unified-
district/tucson-magnet-high-school-1123
Quit the Stick Program Plan
42
Whittaker, R., Maddison, R., McRobbie, H., Bullen, C., Denny, S., Dorey, E., Pegler, ME.,
Rooyen, JV., Rodgers, A. (2008). A Multimedia Mobile Phone-Based Youth Smoking
Cessation Intervention: Findings from Content Development and Piloting Studies. JMR
Publications. 10(5):e49. Doi: 10.2196/jmir.1007
Quit the Stick Program Plan
43
Appendix A
Quit the Stick Cessation Program 2020
Consent Form
The mission of Quit the Stick Cessation Program in Pima County is to help encourage
adolescents age 14-18 to seek healthy coping mechanisms through guided discussions,
counseling, along with advice from mentors in order to adopt a healthy lifestyle including
nicotine cessation. This program will be a 20 week program implemented in both Sabino High
School and Tucson Magnet High School. These 20 weeks will be divided into an introductory
presentation on the first week, followed by 8 sessions, and 11 discussions. The discussions
will cover the material presented in the previous session. Our goal is to reduce the rate of
nicotine use among adolescents 14-18 years old in Central and Northeast Tucson. To help the
research team reach this goal, there will be various methods and objectives implemented
throughout the program.
There will be a pre-test and post-test conducted throughout the duration of the program. The
pre-test will consist of 10 questions. The pre-test will be given to the participants at the
beginning of the program and the post-test will be given at the completion of the program.
The survey is expected to take approximately 15 minutes each.
Participants information will remain confidential throughout the duration of the program.
Participants have the right to withdraw from the program at any time. Further questions about
Quit the Stick can be directed to the program director at (520) 345-6789.
Appendix B
Quit the Stick
Pre-Survey
2020
Thank you for participating in Quit the Stick and taking the pre-survey. This pre-survey will
allow Quit the Stick staff to obtain knowledge and information about the attitudes towards
nicotine use through smoking behaviors. This survey is expected to take 15 minutes and
encourage you to leave any comments or questions.
1. I am a
○ Female
○ Male
○ Do not wish to answer
2. How old are you?
○ 14
○ 15
○ 16
○ 17
○ 18
3. What grade are you in?
○ 9th grade
○ 10th grade
○ 11th grade
○ 12th grade
4. What is your race/ethnicity? (select all that apply)
○ White
○ Hispanic/Latino
○ American Indian/Alaska Native
○ Asian
○ Black or African American
○ Native Hawaiian/Other Pacific Islander
○ Do not wish to answer
5. Have you ever used nicotine through smoking behaviors (cigarettes, e-cigarettes,
Juuls, cigars, etc)?
○ Yes
○ No
6. If yes, how often do you engage in these behaviors?
○ Only tried once
○ Once a week
○ 2-5 times a week
Quit the Stick Program Plan
45
Appendix C
Quit the Stick
Post-Survey
2020
Thank you for participating in Quit the Stick and taking the post-survey. This post-survey will
allow Quit the Stick staff to make necessary adjusts to the program for future participants.
This survey is expected to take 15 minutes and encourage you to leave any comments or
questions.
1. I am a
○ Female
○ Male
○ Do not wish to answer
2. How old are you?
○ 14
○ 15
○ 16
○ 17
○ 18
3. What grade are you in?
○ 9th grade
○ 10th grade
○ 11th grade
○ 12th grade
4. What is your race/ethnicity? (select all that apply)
○ White
○ Hispanic/Latino
○ American Indian/Alaska Native
○ Asian
○ Black or African American
○ Native Hawaiian/Other Pacific Islander
○ Do not wish to answer
5. Have you ever used nicotine through smoking behaviors (cigarettes, e-cigarettes, Juuls,
cigars, etc)?
○ Yes
○ No
6. How do you feel that your outlook on nicotine use through smoking behavior has changed?
____________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
Quit the Stick Program Plan
47
8. List three stress coping mechanisms that Quit the Stick has taught you.
____________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________
9. Would you recommend Quit the Stick to friends and family? Please circle one
Yes No
Why?
____________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________
11. Do you think this program has the ability to help adolescents across the country?
____________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________
Quit the Stick Program Plan
48
Appendix D
Quit the Stick
Post-Pilot Survey
2020
Thank you for participating in Quit the Stick and taking the post-pilot survey. This post-pilot
survey will allow Quit the Stick staff to make necessary adjusts to the program for future
participants. This survey is expected to take 15 minutes and encourage you to leave any
comments or questions.
1. I am a
○ Female
○ Male
○ Do not wish to answer
2. How old are you?
○ 14
○ 15
○ 16
○ 17
○ 18
3. What grade are you in?
○ 9th grade
○ 10th grade
○ 11th grade
○ 12th grade
4. What is your race/ethnicity? (select all that apply)
○ White
○ Hispanic/Latino
○ American Indian/Alaska Native
○ Asian
○ Black or African American
○ Native Hawaiian/Other Pacific Islander
○ Do not wish to answer
5. Would you recommend Quit the Stick to be implemented in two different high school?
Why?
____________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________