Innova Rubbers Pvt Ltd.

Cost Comparison Sheet

Vendor I
M/s Tirupati engg Works
Sr. Description QTY UOM
No. Final
Initial Offer Total Price in INR Negotiated Total Price in INR
Price Price
INNER AL 314610017HD
1 24X21.1X10.25X49.9L 1800 Nos 42.58 76,644.00 35.70 64,260

INNER AL 32146100000_HD
2 36X24.1X14.15X53 1250 Nos 51.18 63,975.00 37.70 47,125

3 SP.INNER 7147100016_HD 1250 Nos 108.76 135,950.00 95.50 119,375

37X24X114L
Total Price in INR Nos INR 202.52 INR 276,569.00 INR 168.90 INR 230,760.00
Taxes Extra as applicable
S.T. As applicable
Extra KM
Delivery 3 -4 Weeks
Excise Applicable

Payment Terms 60 days From the date of receipt.

Technical Rating I

Total Price in INR INR 230,760.00

Finalised Supplier
M/s Tirupati engg Works

REMARK Existing vendor

Prepared By
 Innova Rubbers Pvt Ltd.
Cost Comparison Sheet
Vendor I Vendor II
M/s Abhijeet Plast M/s Satish Injectoplast Pv.t Ltd.
Sr. Description QTY UO
No. M
Initial Offer Price Final Negotiated Price Total Price in INR Initial Offer Price Final Negotiated Total Price in INR
Price

1 AntiSkid Part-611 1 Nos 1,885,000 1,885,000 1,885,000 916,000 916,000 916,000

1400840010

2 AntiSkid Part-624 1 Nos 1,925,000 1,885,000 1,885,000 1,283,000 1,283,000 1,283,000

1400840002

3 AntiSkid Part-656 1 Nos 1,988,000 1,885,000 1,885,000 978,000 978,000 978,000

1400840003
Total Price in INR Nos INR 5,798,000 INR 5,655,000 INR 5,655,000 INR 3,177,000 INR 3,177,000 INR 3,177,000
Taxes Extra as applicable Extra as applicable
S.T. As applicable As applicable
Extra KM
Delivery 3 -4 Weeks 3 -4 Weeks
Excise Applicable Applicable

Payment Terms

Technical Rating I (Customer Approved Source) I

Total Price in INR INR 3,177,000.00

Finalised Supplier Finalised Cost in INR

M/s Satish Injectoplast Pv.t Ltd. INR 3,177,000.00

REMARK Existing vendor New Vendor

Prepared By Approved By
 Innova Rubbers Pvt Ltd. Innova Rubbers Pvt Ltd.
Cost Comparison Sheet Cost Comparison Sheet for TOOLING OF 0401BAA09391N & 0401BAA09391N
Vendor I Vendor II Vendor II Vendor I Vendor II Vendor II
M/s Goldy Engg M/s Global Ind M/s Samarth Dies M/s Goldy Engg M/s Global Ind M/s Samarth Dies

Sr. UO Final Cost

No. Description QTY M Sr. No. Description QTY UOM
Initial Offer Final Total Price in wrt toll Total Price in Initial Final Initial Final Final Final
Negotiated amortization Negotiate Total Price in Offer Negotiated Total Price in Initial Offer Negotiated Total Price in INR Initial Offer Price Negotiated Total Price in Initial Offer Price Final Negotiated Total Price in INR
Price Price INR qty lakh INR Offer Price d Price INR Price Price INR Price Price Price INR Price
each

BB47300900-01 WASHER BB47300900-01 WASHER

1 (30 X 17.95 X 1.2T) 100000 Nos 1.59 1.47 147000.00 1.77 177000.00 1.50 1.50 150000.00 2.50 2.00 200000.00 0.30 1 (30 X 17.95 X 1.2T) 1 Nos 32500.00 30000.00 30000.00 50000.00 40000.00 40000.00 35600.00 31500.00 31500.00

GM45433300D2-02 GM45433300D2-02
2 WASHER LWR (22.5 X 100000 Nos 1.20 1.14 114000.00 1.44 144000.00 1.50 1.35 135000.00 2.00 1.90 190000.00 0.30 2 WASHER LWR (22.5 X 15.0 X 1 Nos 37500.00 30000.00 30000.00 50000.00 40000.00 40000.00 63600.00 59500.00 59500.00
15.0 X 1.0T) 1.0T)

GM45433300D2-01 GM45433300D2-01
3 WASHER UPPER (29.8 X 100000 Nos 3.62 3.25 325000.00 3.65 365000.00 4.00 3.59 359000.00 4.50 3.50 350000.00 0.40 3 WASHER UPPER (29.8 X 1 Nos 45000.00 40000.00 40000.00 50000.00 40000.00 40000.00 36100.00 32000.00 32000.00
13.0 X 1.0T) 13.0 X 1.0T)
Total Price in INR Nos INR 6.41 INR 5.86 INR 586,000 INR 6.86 INR 686,000 INR 7.00 INR 6.44 INR 644,000 INR 9.00 INR 7.40 INR 740,000 Total Price in INR Nos 115,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00 150,000.00 120,000.00 120,000.00 135,300.00 123,000.00 123,000.00
Taxes Extra as applicable Extra as applicable Extra as applicable Taxes Extra as applicable Extra as applicable Extra as applicable
S.T. As applicable As applicable As applicable S.T. As applicable As applicable As applicable
Extra KM N/A Extra KM N/A
Delivery 3 -4 Weeks 3 -4 Weeks 3 -4 Weeks Delivery 3 -4 Weeks 3 -4 Weeks 3 -4 Weeks
Excise Applicable Applicable Applicable Excise Applicable Applicable Applicable

50% Advance and balance 50% after succeful trial 50% Advance and balance 50% after succeful trial 50% Advance and balance 50% after succeful trial and
Payment Terms 60 Days after receipt 60 Days after receipt 60 Days after receipt Payment Terms and OK Sample and OK Sample OK Sample

Technical Rating I (Customer Approved Source) I I Technical Rating I III II

Total Price in INR INR 686,000.00 INR 644,000.00 INR 740,000.00 Total Price in INR INR 100,000.00 INR 120,000.00 INR 123,000.00

Finalised Supplier Finalised Cost in INR Finalised Supplier Finalised Cost in INR
M/s Global Ind INR 644,000.00 M/s Global Ind INR 120,000.00

REMARK New Vendor Existing vendor Existing vendor New Vendor Existing vendor Existing vendor
Prepared By Approved By Prepared By Approved By

BB47300900-01 WASHER
1 (30 X 17.95 X 1.2T)
0.30
GM45433300D2-02
2 WASHER LWR (22.5 X 15.0
X 1.0T) 0.30
GM45433300D2-01
3 WASHER UPPER (29.8 X
13.0 X 1.0T) 0.40
Total Cost (Part
A cost + Tooling) INR 786,000.00
 Innova Rubbers Pvt Ltd.
Cost Comparison Sheet
Vendor I Vendor II Vendor II
M/s Sai Auto M/s Tirupati Engg M/s Gayatri Industries
UO
Sr. No. Description QTY M Final Final Final
Total Price in Initial Offer Total Price in Initial Offer
Initial Offer Price Negotiated Negotiated Negotiated Total Price in INR
INR Price INR Price
Price Price Price

1 RDD-0401EAA2071N-1 2000 Nos 2.30 2.00 4000.00 2.02 2.02 4040 1.71 1.40 2000.00

Total Price in INR Nos INR 2.30 INR 2.00 INR 4,000 INR 2.02 INR 2.02 INR 4,040 INR 1.71 INR 1.40 INR 2,000
Taxes Extra as applicable Extra as applicable Extra as applicable
S.T. As applicable As applicable As applicable
Extra KM N/A
Delivery 3 weeks 3 week 3 week
Excise Available Available Available

Payment Terms 60 Days cafter receipt 60 Days cafter receipt 60 Days cafter receipt

Technical Rating I I I

Total Price in INR INR 4,000.00 INR 4,040.00 INR 2,000.00

Finalised Supplier Finalised Cost in INR

M/s Tirupati Engg INR 4,040.00

REMARK New Vendor Existing vendor Existing vendor

Prepared By Approved By

Total Cost
A INR 52,000.00
(Part cost + Tooling)
 Innova Rubbers Pvt Ltd.
Cost Comparison Sheet for TOOLING OF 0401BAA09391N & 0401BAA09391N
Vendor I Vendor II Vendor II
M/s Sai Auto M/s Tirupati Engg M/s Gaytri Industries

Sr. No. Description QTY UOM

Final Total Price in Initial Offer Price Final Negotiated Total Price in INR Initial Offer Price Final Negotiated Total Price in
Initial Offer Price Negotiated
INR Price Price INR
Price

RDD-0401EAA2071N-
1 1 Nos 80000.00 50000.00 50000.00 100000.00 100000.00 100000.00 80000.00 50000.00 50000.00
1(Blanking+Piearcing and Forming)

Total Price in INR Nos 80,000.00 50,000.00 50,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00 80,000.00 50,000.00 50,000.00
Taxes Extra as applicable Extra as applicable Extra as applicable
S.T. As applicable As applicable As applicable
Extra KM N/A
Delivery 3 week 3 week 3 week
Excise Available Available Available

50% Advance and balance after succesful trial

Payment Terms 60 Days cafter receipt and OK samples received. 60 Days cafter receipt

Technical Rating I III II

Total Price in INR INR 50,000.00 INR 100,000.00 INR 50,000.00

Finalised Supplier Finalised Cost in INR

M/s Sai Auto INR 50,000.00

Existing vendor Existing vendor Existing vendor

Prepared By Approved By
 Innova Rubbers Pvt Ltd.
Cost Comparison Sheet
Vendor I Vendor II Vendor II
M/s Sai Auto M/s Harsh engineering
UO
Sr. No. Description QTY
M Initial Final
Final Negotiated Final Negotiated Total Price in INR Total Price in
Initial Offer Price Total Price in INR Initial Offer Price Offer Negotiated
Price Price INR
Price Price
RDD-5523-4110-0105-02
1 25 Nos 1400.00 1260.00 31500.00 1758.0 1758.00 43950 0 0 0
Inner Ø 120 * Ø115
RDD-5523-4110-0105-01
2 25 Nos 550.00 495.00 12375.00 1182.0 1182.00 29550 0 0 0
Outer Ø 186.8 * Ø 150.00
Total Price in INR Nos INR 1,950.00 INR 1,755.00 INR 43,875 INR 1,758.00 INR 1,758.00 INR 73,500 INR 0 INR 0.0 INR 0
Taxes Extra as applicable Extra as applicable Extra as applicable
S.T. As applicable As applicable As applicable
Extra KM N/A
Delivery 15 Days after Given PO 3 week 3 week
Excise Available Available Available
Payment Terms 30 Days cafter receipt 60 Days cafter receipt 60 Days cafter receipt
Technical Rating I II III
Total Price in INR INR 43,875.00 INR 73,500.00 INR 0.00
Finalised Supplier Finalised Cost in INR
M/s Sai Auto INR 73,500.00

REMARK Its our existing vendor dispatches TVD Inner and New Vendor Its existing but not yet
Outer supplied TVD
Prepared By Approved By

A Total Cost (Part INR 43,875.00

cost + Toling)

Cost Comparision wrt Machining Route and Press Route

Sr NO QTY Total Price per set Price per set Total Price per set Price per set % Cost Burdon Remark
in Nos through machining through Press Route through machining through Press Route
route route

1 25 INR 1,755.00 INR 2,863.00 INR 43,875.00 INR 71,575.00 -63% for initial 25 set

2 50 INR 1,755.00 INR 783.00 INR 87,750.00 INR 39,150.00 55% for firther 50 set

3 100 INR 1,755.00 INR 760.00 INR 175,500.00 INR 76,000.00 57% For Further 100
Set

1500 360 2368 495 12375

1200 432000 2863
288
7200
52000
2080 inner outer total
2368 59200 12375 71575 2863
 Innova Rubbers Pvt Ltd.
Cost Comparison Sheet for TOOLING OF RDD-P-405-2
Vendor I Vendor II Vendor II
M/s Sai Auto M/s Tirupati Engineering M/s Global Industries

Sr. No. Description QTY UOM

Final
Initial Offer Price Final Negotiated Total Price in INR Initial Offer Final Negotiated Total Price in Initial Offer Total Price in
Negotiated
Price Price Price INR Price INR
Price

1 RDD-P-405-2 Forimg II 1 Nos 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

2 RDD-P-405-2 Forimg II 1 Nos 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Total Price in INR Nos INR 0.00 INR 0.00 INR 0 INR 0.00 INR 0.00 INR 0 INR 0 INR 0.0 INR 0
Taxes Extra as applicable Extra as applicable Extra as applicable
S.T. As applicable As applicable As applicable
Extra KM N/A
Delivery 15 Days after Given PO 3 week 3 week
Excise Available Available Available
50 % Advance and balance after Proto Sample 20 % Advance and balance after Proto Sample 50 % Advance and balance after Proto Sample
Payment Terms submission submission submission
Technical Rating I III II
Total Price in INR INR 0.00 INR 0.00 INR 0.00
Finalised Supplier Finalised Cost in INR
M/s Sai Auto INR 0.00

Its oue existing vendor dispatches TVD New Its existing but not yet supplied TVD
Inner and Outer
Prepared By Approved By
 Innova Rubbers Pvt Ltd.
Cost Comparison Sheet
Vendor I Vendor II Vendor II
M/s Sai Auto M/s Harsh engineering

Sr. No. Description QTY UO

M Initial Final
Final Negotiated Final Negotiated Total Price in
Initial Offer Price Price Total Price in INR Initial Offer Price Price Total Price in INR Offer Negotiated INR
Price Price

1 RDD-P-405-2 Inner 25 Nos 1500.00 1500.00 37500.00 2073.0 2073.00 51825 0 0 0

machining route
2 RDD-P-405-1 Outer 25 Nos 592.00 400.00 10000.00 2073.0 2073.00 51825 0 0 0
Total Price in INR Nos INR 2,092.00 INR 1,900.00 INR 47,500 INR 2,073.00 INR 2,073.00 INR 103,650 INR 0 INR 0.0 INR 0
Taxes Extra as applicable Extra as applicable Extra as applicable
S.T. As applicable As applicable As applicable
Extra KM N/A
Delivery 15 Days after Given PO 3 week 3 week
Excise Available Available Available

Payment Terms 30 Days cafter receipt 60 Days cafter receipt 60 Days cafter receipt

Technical Rating I II III

Total Price in INR INR 47,500.00 INR 103,650.00 INR 0.00

Finalised Supplier Finalised Cost in INR

M/s Sai Auto INR 103,650.00

REMARK Its our existing vendor dispatches TVD Inner and Outer New Vendor Its existing but not yet
supplied TVD
Prepared By Approved By

Total Cost (Part

A cost + Toling)
INR 47,500.00

Cost Comparision wrt Machining Route and Press Route

Total Price per set Total Price per set
Sr NO QTY through machining Price per set through machining Price per set % Cost Burdon Remark
in Nos route through Press Route route through Press Route

1 25 INR 1,900.00 INR 2,840.00 INR 47,500.00 INR 71,000.00 -49% for initial 25 set

2 50 INR 1,860.00 INR 760.00 INR 93,000.00 INR 38,000.00 59% for firther 50 set
For Further 100
3 100 INR 1,860.00 INR 760.00 INR 186,000.00 INR 76,000.00 59% Set
 Innova Rubbers Pvt Ltd.
Cost Comparison Sheet for TOOLING OF RDD-P-405-2
Vendor I Vendor II Vendor II
M/s Sai Auto M/s Tirupati Engineering M/s Global Industries

Sr. No. Description QTY UOM

Final Negotiated Initial Offer Final Negotiated Total Price in Initial Offer Final Total Price in
Initial Offer Price Price Total Price in INR Price Price INR Price Negotiated INR
Price

1 RDD-P-405-2 Forimg II 1 Nos 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

2 RDD-P-405-2 Forimg II 1 Nos 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Total Price in INR Nos INR 0.00 INR 0.00 INR 0 INR 0.00 INR 0.00 INR 0 INR 0 INR 0.0 INR 0
Taxes Extra as applicable Extra as applicable Extra as applicable
S.T. As applicable As applicable As applicable
Extra KM N/A
Delivery 15 Days after Given PO 3 week 3 week
Excise Available Available Available

50 % Advance and balance after Proto Sample 20 % Advance and balance after Proto Sample 50 % Advance and balance after Proto Sample
Payment Terms submission submission submission

Technical Rating I III II

Total Price in INR INR 0.00 INR 0.00 INR 0.00

Finalised Supplier Finalised Cost in INR

M/s Sai Auto INR 0.00
Its oue existing vendor dispatches TVD New Its existing but not yet supplied TVD
Inner and Outer
Prepared By Approved By
 Innova Rubbers Pvt Ltd.
Cost Comparison Sheet
Vendor I Vendor II Vendor II
M/s Oshin Engg M/s Gayatri Inustries M/s Global Industries

Sr. No. Description QTY UO

M Final Final Final
Initial Offer Price Total Price in Initial Offer Price Total Price in Initial Offer Total Price in INR
Negotiated INR Negotiated INR Price Negotiated
Price Price Price

1 RDD-0401BAA09391N-04 LCA ITR dai 2000 Nos 8.01 8.01 16020.00 4.71 4.21 8420 9.25 9.25 18500
44.00 mm

2 RDD-0401BAA09391N-03 LCA ITR dia 1000 Nos 9.36 9.36 9360.00 6.91 5.28 5280 11.41 11.41 11410
54.00 mm
RDD-0401BAA09401N-03 LCA RR OTR
3 1000 Nos 10.92 10.92 10920.00 9.23 7.09 7090 12.15 12.15 12150
dia 63.00 mm
Total Price in INR Nos INR 17.37 INR 17.37 INR 25,380 INR 11.62 INR 9.49 INR 13,700 INR 20.66 INR 20.66 INR 29,910
Taxes Extra as applicable Extra as applicable Extra as applicable
S.T. As applicable As applicable As applicable
Extra KM N/A
Delivery 3 weeks 3 week 3 week
Excise Available Available Available

Payment Terms 60 Days cafter receipt 60 Days cafter receipt 60 Days cafter receipt

Technical Rating I I I

Total Price in INR INR 25,380.00 INR 13,700.00 INR 29,910.00

Finalised Supplier Finalised Cost in INR

M/s Gayatri Inustries INR 13,700.00

REMARK New Vendor Existing vendor Existing vendor

Prepared By Approved By

A Total Cost INR 208,700.00

(Part cost + Tooling)
 Innova Rubbers Pvt Ltd.
Cost Comparison Sheet for TOOLING OF 0401BAA09391N & 0401BAA09391N
Vendor I Vendor II Vendor II
M/s Oshin Engg M/s Gayatri Inustries M/s Global Industries

Sr. No. Description QTY UOM

Final Final
Initial Offer Total Price in INR Initial Offer Price Total Price in Initial Offer Price Final Negotiated Total Price in INR
Price Negotiated Negotiated INR Price
Price Price

1 RDD-0401BAA09391N LCA 1 Nos 150000.00 150000.00 150000.00 81498.00 65000.00 65000.00 100000.00 100000.00 100000.00
ITR

2 RDD-0401BAA09391N-03 1 Nos 150000.00 150000.00 150000.00 81498.00 65000.00 65000.00 100000.00 100000.00 100000.00
LCA ITR
RDD-0401BAA09401N-03
3 1 Nos 150000.00 150000.00 150000.00 81498.00 65000.00 65000.00 100000.00 100000.00 100000.00
LCA RR OTR
Total Price in INR Nos 450,000.00 450,000.00 450,000.00 244,494.00 195,000.00 195,000.00 300,000.00 300,000.00 300,000.00
Taxes Extra as applicable Extra as applicable Extra as applicable
S.T. As applicable As applicable As applicable
Extra KM N/A
Delivery 3 week 3 week 3 week
Excise Available Available Available

Payment Terms 100% Advance 50% Advance and balance 50% after succeful trial 100% Advance
and OK Sample

Technical Rating I III II

Total Price in INR INR 450,000.00 INR 195,000.00 INR 300,000.00

Finalised Supplier Finalised Cost in INR

M/s Gayatri Inustries INR 195,000.00

New Vendor Existing vendor Existing vendor

Prepared By Approved By
 Innova Rubbers Pvt Ltd.
Cost Comparison Sheet
Vendor I Vendor II Vendor II
M/s Sai Auto M/s Tirupati Engineering M/s Global Industries

Sr. No. Description QTY UO

M Final Final
Initial Offer Price Final Negotiated Total Price in INR Initial Offer Total Price in INR Initial Offer Total Price in INR
Price Price Negotiated Price Negotiated
Price Price
1 RDD-P-405-2 25 Nos 416.67 360.00 9000.00 360.0 360.00 9000 360 360 9000
2 RDD-P-405-1 25 Nos 592.00 400.00 10000.00 486.0 486.00 12150 924 924 23100
Total Price in INR Nos INR 1,008.67 INR 760.00 INR 19,000 INR 360.00 INR 360.00 INR 21,150 INR 360 INR 360.0 INR 32,100
Taxes Extra as applicable Extra as applicable Extra as applicable
S.T. As applicable As applicable As applicable
Extra KM N/A
Delivery 15 Days after Given PO 3 week 3 week
Excise Available Available Available

Payment Terms 30 Days cafter receipt 60 Days cafter receipt 60 Days cafter receipt

Technical Rating I II III

Total Price in INR INR 19,000.00 INR 21,150.00 INR 32,100.00

Finalised Supplier Finalised Cost in INR

M/s Sai Auto INR 21,150.00

REMARK Its oue existing vendor dispatches TVD Inner and New Its existing but not yet supplied TVD
Outer
Prepared By Approved By

Total Cost(Part
A cost + Tooling)
INR 71,000.00
jkgAz
 Innova Rubbers Pvt Ltd.

Vendor I Vendor II Vendor II

M/s Sai Auto M/s Tirupati Engineering M/s Global Industries

Sr. No. Description QTY UOM

Initial Offer Final Negotiated Final
Initial Offer Price Final Negotiated Price Total Price in INR Total Price in INR Initial Offer Negotiated
Total Price in
Price Price Price Price INR

1 RDD-P-405-2 Forimg II 1 Nos 26000.00 26000.00 26000.00 75000.00 75000.00 75000.00 30000.00 30000.00 30000.00
2 RDD-P-405-2 Forimg II 1 Nos 26000.00 26000.00 26000.00 75000.00 75000.00 75000.00 30000.00 30000.00 30000.00
Total Price in INR Nos INR 52,000.00 INR 52,000.00 INR 52,000 INR 75,000.00 INR 75,000.00 INR 150,000 INR 30,000 INR 30,000.0 INR 60,000
Taxes Extra as applicable Extra as applicable Extra as applicable
S.T. As applicable As applicable As applicable
Extra KM N/A
Delivery 15 Days after Given PO 3 week 3 week
Excise Available Available Available

Payment Terms 50 % Advance and balance after Proto Sample submission 20 % Advance and balance after Proto Sample submission 50 % Advance and balance after Proto Sample
submission

Technical Rating I III II

Total Price in INR INR 52,000.00 INR 150,000.00 INR 60,000.00

Finalised Supplier Finalised Cost in INR

M/s Sai Auto INR 52,000.00
Its oue existing vendor dispatches TVD Inner and New Its existing but not yet supplied TVD
Outer
Prepared By Approved By
 SAP code Material Description GRN NO GRN Date Receipt QTY
31101104000051 INNER HARDEN - 84777 5000245542 1 16.02.2015 4,000
4,000
Baisc Price In INR Total Value In INR
1.80 7200
7200
 Innova Rubbers

Cost Comparison Sheet

Supplier I Supplier II Supplier III Supplier IV Supplier V
Exsiting Tal Engg Coporation M/s Global Engg M/s Gurukripa Revised offer Tal Engg Coporation

Sr. No. Description QTY UO

M Final Final Initial Final Initial Final Initial Final
Initial Total Price in Initial Offer Total Price in Total Price Total Price in Total Price in
Offer Price Negotiated INR Price Negotiate INR Offer Negotiate in INR Offer Negotiate INR Offer Negotiate INR
Price d Price Price d Price Price d Price Price d Price

1 INNER PUNCH - 500 Nos 20.5 20.5 10250 85.0 81.00 40500 110 75 37500 93 75 37500
827/3 LOHIA

2 PLATE LOHIA - 500 Nos 37.3 37.3 18650

827/3 WELDED
Total Price in INR Nos INR 57.80 INR 57.80 INR 28,900 INR 85 INR 81 INR 40,500 ### INR 75.0 INR 37,500 INR 93 INR 75 INR 37,500 INR 0 N/L INR 0
Taxes Extra as applicable Extra as applicable Extra as applicable Extra as applicable Extra as applicable
S.T. As applicable As applicable As applicable As applicable As applicable
Extra KM N/A N/A N/A
Delivery Immediate Immediate 2-3 week 2-3 week 2-3 week

Payment Terms 90 Days after receipt 60 dyas Hundi 60 days cafter receipt 60 days cafter receipt 15 Days after receipt

Total Price in INR INR 28,900.00 INR 40,500.00 INR 37,500.00 INR 37,500.00 INR 0.00
Finalised Supplier Finalised Cost in INR
M/s Gurukripa /Tal INR 37,500.00

Initial Offer Final

Cost burdon IN INR QTY Price
Negotiat -INR 8,600.00
ed Price

500.00 INR 57.80 75.00

Annual projection of Saving IN INR on volume -INR 17.20

Prepared By Approved By
 Innova Rubbers

Cost Comparison Sheet

Supplier I Supplier II Supplier III
Exsiting Tal Engg Coporation M/s Global Engg M/s Gurukripa

Sr. No. Description QTY UO

M Final Final Initial Final
Initial Offer Total Price in Initial Offer Total Price in Total Price in
Price Negotiated INR Price Negotiated INR Offer Negotiated INR
Price Price Price Price

INNER PUNCH -
1 827/3 LOHIA & 500 Nos 234.05 234.05 117025 303.0 228.11 114055 234.05 234.05 117025
PLATE LOHIA -
827/3 WELDED
0 0
Total Price in INR Nos INR 234.05 INR 234.05 INR 117,025 INR 303.00 INR 228.11 INR 114,055 INR 234 INR 234.1 INR 117,025
Taxes Extra as applicable Extra as applicable Extra as applicable
S.T. As applicable As applicable As applicable
Extra KM N/A
Delivery Immediate Immediate 2-3 week
Excise NA Available NA

Payment Terms 90 Days after receipt 60 dyas Hundi 60 days cafter receipt

Total Price in INR INR 117,025.00 INR 114,055.00 INR 117,025.00

Finalised Supplier Finalised Cost in INR
M/s Global Engg INR 114,055.00

Prepared By Approved By
 MAHAN PRICE INCREASE Dated 07.04.2009

Powder Avg Mahan

Existing Sq Ft Coating Finished Proposed Mahan
Sr NO Part NO Part Description rate Area cahrges Weight Rate Proposed Rate
Plate base powder Based on weight
1 3110130200002 coated 1.85 0.31 NA 0.413 3.70 @ Rs.9/Kg
2H.122(AVM200)
MAHAN PRICE INCREASE Dated 01.09.2014

Powder Avg Mahan

Existing Sq Ft Coating Finished Proposed Mahan
Sr NO Part NO Part Description rate Area cahrges Weight Rate Proposed Rate
Plate base powder Based on weight
1 3110130200002 coated 1.85 0.31 NA 0.413 3.70
2H.122(AVM200) @ Rs.9/Kg

Revised offer price dated_23..06.2015

Existing Price increase Break up for additional process cost of preheating at 200 degree temp
Sr No Desc Speification Remark
1 Oven capacity 400 x 0.400 Kgs 160 Kgs
2 loading Trolley wt 100 Kgs 100 Kgs
3 Total Weiight 260 kgs

4 Lpg Gas
Consumption (260*0.7*200)/11250 3.25 Kgs

Total Value of LPG

5 gas 290.7 Rs
consumption(3.25*9
0/Per Kgs)
6 Per piece 0.725

7 Negotiated price per 0.56 This price is due to overcome from problems of open Pin
piece holes & bubbles of Powder coated surface.