Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
External
Analysis
Internal
Analysis
The Strategic Management Process
External
Analysis
3. Decision Stage
Quantitative Strategic Profile (QSP)
The Strategic Management Process
External
Analysis
3. Decision Stage
Quantitative Strategic Profile Matrix
The Strategic Management Process
3. Decision StageEach
- to reveal the
of this relative
matrix attractiveness
has feasible or of alternative
recommends
strategies.
appropriate strategy
Evaluation Tool Matrix: QSPM
The Strategic Management Process
These
2.The are Stage
Matching the TOP ALTERNATIVE
- focuses STRATEGIES
on generating feasible alternative strategies
by aligning key external and internal factors.
Evaluation Tool Matrix: SWOT, SPACE, IE, BCG, GS
Because they all have high frequency of appearance in
3. evaluation
Decision Stagematrices
- to reveal the relative attractiveness of alternative
strategies.
Evaluation Tool Matrix: QSPM
EFE IFE
External Analysis Internal Analysis
(Opportunities and Threats) (Strength and Weaknesses)
BCG Analysis
SPACE Analysis
SWOT Analysis
I.E. Analysis
Grand Analysis
EFE IFE
External Analysis Internal Analysis
(Opportunities and Threats) (Strength and Weaknesses)
Accuracy of
generated feasible
strategies
Top Alternative Strategies for Starbucks depends on
Market Penetration
accuracy of
Market Development
Product Development
External and
Internal Analysis
EFE IFE
External Analysis Internal Analysis
(Opportunities and Threats) (Strength and Weaknesses)
CPM
The author of the
strama paper
must be
objective in
assigning weight
and rating in
EFE, IFE and
CPM
The Matching Stage
The Strengths-Weaknesses-Opportunities-Threats
(SWOT) Matrix helps managers develop four types of
strategies:
SO (strengths-opportunities) Strategies
WO (weaknesses-opportunities) Strategies
ST (strengths-threats) Strategies
WT (weaknesses-threats) Strategies
6-20
SWOT Matrix
1. List the firm’s key external OPPORTUNITIES
2. List the firm’s key external THREATS
3. List the firm’s key internal STRENGTHS
4. List the firm’s key internal WEAKNESSES
Strengths Weaknesses
Opportunities
Threats
6-21
SWOT Matrix (cont.)
5. Match internal strengths with external
opportunities, and record the resultant SO
6. Match internal weaknesses with external
opportunities, and record the resultant WO
Strategies
7. Match internal strengths with external threats,
and record the resultant ST Strategies
8. Match internal weaknesses with external
threats, and record the resultant WT Strategies
6-22
SWOT Matrix (cont.)
5. Match internal strengths with external opportunities, and record
the resultant SO
6. Match internal weaknesses with external opportunities, and record the resultant WO Strategies
7. Match internal strengths with external threats, and record the resultant ST Strategies
8. Match internal weaknesses with external threats, and record the resultant WT Strategies
Strengths
S5.Research & Development
S11. Good Financial Ratios
S5.R&D
S11. Good Financial Ratios
WO Strategies
aim at improving
internal
weaknesses by
taking advantage
of external
opportunities W.O.
6-25
SWOT Matrix (cont.)
5. Match internal strengths with external opportunities, and record the resultant SO
6. Match internal weaknesses with external opportunities, and record the resultant WO Strategies
7. Match internal strengths with external threats, and record the resultant
ST Strategies
8. Match internal weaknesses with external threats, and record the resultant WT Strategies
ST Strategies
use a firm’s
strengths
to avoid or
reduce the
impact of
external
threats S.T.
6-26
SWOT Matrix (cont.)
5. Match internal strengths with external opportunities, and record the resultant SO
6. Match internal weaknesses with external opportunities, and record the resultant WO Strategies
7. Match internal strengths with external threats, and record the resultant ST Strategies
WT Strategies
defensive
tactics
directed at
reducing
internal
weakness and
avoiding
external
threats
W.T.
6-27
STRENGHTS WEAKNESSES
1. High brand equity 1. Product pricing
2. Largest and fast growing coffee shop chain in the 2. Highly dependent on the outsource
world suppliers
3. Excellent employee relationship 3. Less marketing efforts Limited product
4. Starbucks experience mix
5. R&D
SWOT 6. Rustan Coffee Corp, the operator of Starbucks
specialist coffee shops in the Philippines,
MATRIX continues to be the biggest chained player.
7. Fixed prices and price-to-be-fixed in their supply
8. Highly penetrated and has a large market share
in the Philippines coffee shop industry
9. Increase sales growth of 9.91% during 2012
10.Increase Net Income Growth rate up to 26.76%
during 2012
11.Financial Ratios
OPPORTUNITIES SO STRATEGIES WO STRATEGIES
1. Philippine coffee shops up domestic consumption by
2.25%
1. Increase coffee variety) and create 1.Increase marketing and
2. The specialty coffee shop industry is projected to sustain more healthy product options or promotion efforts (w1, w3, o1,
growth of 20 percent over the next five years. redevelop their product to a healthy o2, o3, o6)
3. Cafés/bars will be registering a constant value CAGR of drink (s5, s11, o1, o2, o5, ) 2.Collaborate w/ Suppliers: (w2, o1,
1% over the 2012-2017 forecast period.(euromonitor,
2013)
2. Increase coffee chain stores in the o4)
4. expanding coffee production industry in the Philippines Philippines (s6, s8, s11, o1, o2, 03
5. increase health and wellness awareness trend
6. Filipino love socializing
7. Coffee has a large market in the Philippines
THREATS ST STRATEGIES WT STRATEGIES
1. Increased competition from local cafes and 1.Joint venture or partnering (s1, s2, s11, 1.Increase market activity efforts
specialization of other coffee chains
2. Large value and increase of instant coffee competitor t2, t4) (w1, w3, t2, t4, t6)
3. Emerging coffee vending machines and coffee maker 2.Maintain price fixation on their product 2.Build and maintain a better
machines supply (s10, t5) supplier and manufacturer
4. Filipino high tendency to substitute 3.Work with suppliers to create a better relationship (w2, t1, t5)
5. Natural calamities, climate change, and crop diseases
that affects supply and demand of coffee
product using those raw materials: (s5,
6. Free wi-fi usage from other competitors s6, t1, t2)
STRENGHTS WEAKNESSES
1. High brand equity 1. Product pricing
2. Largest and fast growing coffee shop chain in the 2. Highly dependent on the outsource
world suppliers
3. Excellent employee relationship 3. Less marketing efforts Limited product
4. Starbucks experience mix
5. R&D
SWOT 6. Rustan Coffee Corp, the operator of Starbucks
specialist coffee shops in the Philippines,
MATRIX continues to be the biggest chained player.
7. Fixed prices and price-to-be-fixed in their supply
8. Highly penetrated and has a large market share
in the Philippines coffee shop industry
9. Increase sales growth of 9.91% during 2012
10.Increase Net Income Growth rate up to 26.76%
during 2012
11.Financial Ratios
OPPORTUNITIES SO STRATEGIES WO STRATEGIES
1. Philippine coffee shops up domestic consumption by
2.25%
2. The specialty coffee shop industry is projected to sustain
growth of 20 percent over the next five years.
3. Cafés/bars will be registering a constant value CAGR of
1% over the 2012-2017 forecast period.(euromonitor,
2013)
4. expanding coffee production industry in the Philippines
5. increase health and wellness awareness trend
6. Filipino love socializing
7. Coffee has a large market in the Philippines
THREATS ST STRATEGIES WT STRATEGIES
1. Increased competition from local cafes and
specialization of other coffee chains
2. Large value and increase of instant coffee competitor
3. Emerging coffee vending machines and coffee maker
machines
4. Filipino high tendency to substitute
5. Natural calamities, climate change, and crop diseases
that affects supply and demand of coffee
6. Free wi-fi usage from other competitors
STRENGHTS WEAKNESSES
1. High brand equity 1. Product pricing
2. Largest and fast growing coffee shop chain in the 2. Highly dependent on the outsource
SWOT
world suppliers
Strategist must classify this generated strategies based on the 3. Excellent employee relationship
4. Starbucks experience
3. Less marketing efforts Limited product
mix
5. R&D
11 Alternative Strategies 6. Rustan Coffee Corp, the operator of Starbucks
specialist coffee shops in the Philippines,
continues to be the biggest chained player.
MATRIX
7. Fixed prices and price-to-be-fixed in their supply
8. Highly penetrated and has a large market share
in the Philippines coffee shop industry
9. Increase sales growth of 9.91% during 2012
10.Increase Net Income Growth rate up to 26.76%
during 2012
11.Financial Ratios
OPPORTUNITIES SO STRATEGIES WO STRATEGIES
1. Philippine coffee shops up domestic consumption by
2.25%
2. The specialty coffee shop industry is projected to sustain
growth of 20 percent over the next five years.
3. Cafés/bars will be registering a constant value CAGR of
1% over the 2012-2017 forecast period.(euromonitor,
2013)
4. expanding coffee production industry in the Philippines
5. increase health and wellness awareness trend
6. Filipino love socializing
7. Coffee has a large market in the Philippines
THREATS ST STRATEGIES WT STRATEGIES
1. Increased competition from local cafes and
specialization of other coffee chains
2. Large value and increase of instant coffee competitor
3. Emerging coffee vending machines and coffee maker
machines
4. Filipino high tendency to substitute
5. Natural calamities, climate change, and crop diseases
that affects supply and demand of coffee
6. Free wi-fi usage from other competitors
SWOT
3. Excellent employee relationship 3. Less marketing efforts Limited product
4. Starbucks experience mix
5. R&D
6. Rustan Coffee Corp, the operator of Starbucks
specialist coffee shops in the Philippines,
continues to be the biggest chained player.
SWOT
3. Excellent employee relationship 3. Less marketing efforts Limited product
4. Starbucks experience mix
5. R&D
6. Rustan Coffee Corp, the operator of Starbucks
specialist coffee shops in the Philippines,
continues to be the biggest chained player.
6-35
The SPACE Matrix
These factors
are perhaps
the most Is your company Is your company
important Conservative? Aggressive?
determinants
of an
organization’s
overall
Is your company Is your company
strategic Defensive? Competitive?
position.
6-36
The SPACE Matrix
These factors
are perhaps
the most Is your company Is your company
important Conservative? Aggressive?
determinants
of an
organization’s
overall
Is your company Is your company
strategic Defensive? Competitive?
position.
SPACE shows the direction of
the company.
6-37
The SPACE Matrix
Each strategic
position has
quadrant
location that has
corresponding
alternative
strategies
6-38
SPACE Matrix
The strategic position depends on the two internal
dimension and two external dimensions
6-39
Two internal dimensions (financial position [FP] and competitive position [CP]) are placed here
Two external dimensions (stability position [SP] and industry position [IP]) are placed here
Financial
Position
Conservative Aggressive
Competitive Industrial
Position Position
Defensive Competitive
Stability
The SPACE Matrix Position
6-40
Important
Financial
determinants of the
Position organization’s overall
strategic position
Competitive Industrial
Position Position
Stability
Position
6-41
FP
CP IP
SP
Factors That Make Up the SPACE Matrix Axes
6-43
Factors That Make Up the SPACE Matrix Axes
These
factors will
enables the
strategist to
analyze the
position of
the
organization
6-44
Steps to Develop a SPACE
Matrix
1. Select a set of variables to define financial position
(FP), competitive position (CP), stability position
(SP), and industry position (IP)
6-45
Steps to Develop a SPACE
Matrix Variables to be selected are the factors from the
identified Strength, Weaknesses, Opportunities and
Threats
1. Select a set of
variables to
define financial
position (FP),
competitive
position (CP),
stability position
(SP), and
industry position
(IP)
6-46
Need to reclassify these
variables based on
Financial Position,
Industrial Position,
Stability Position and
Competitive Position
Financial
Position
Competitive Industrial
Position Position
Stability
Position
Need to reclassify these
variables based on
Financial Position,
Industrial Position,
Stability Position and
Competitive Position
Financial
Position
Competitive Industrial
Position Position
Stability
Position
Steps to Develop a SPACE Matrix
FINANCIAL POSITION
Increase sales growth of 9.91% during 2012
Increase Net Income Growth rate up to 26.76% during 2012
Increase operating income rate of 27.26% during 2012
INDUSTRY POSITION
Domestic demand for coffee has been on a steady rise per year with instant coffee growing by 20 to 25
percent, while "roast and ground" requirements rising by five to six percent.
The specialty coffee shop industry is projected to sustain growth of 20 percent over the next five years.
Cafés/bars will be registering a constant value CAGR of 1% over the 2012-2017 forecast period.(Euromonitor,
2013)
Philippine coffee shops up domestic consumption by 2.25% After reclassification of
STABILITY POSITION the factor, here are the
Natural calamities, climate change, and crop diseases that affects supply and demand of coffee variables for the 4
Local production in the Philippines still did not meet coffee demand in the country.
increase health and wellness awareness trend dimensions
Increased competition from local cafes and specialization of other coffee chains (This reclassification is
COMPETITIVE POSITION done already at the end
High brand equity
Largest and fast growing coffee shop chain in the world
of external and internal
Excellent employee relationship analysis, chapter 4 and 5
High quality product and Starbucks experience
R&D
respectively)
Rustan Coffee Corp, the operator of Starbucks specialist coffee shops in the Philippines, continues to be the
biggest chained player.
Starbucks Philippines with a network of more than 200 coffee chain stores
6-49
Steps to Develop a SPACE Matrix
2. Assign a numerical
value ranging from +1
(worst) to +7 (best) to
each of the variables
that make up the FP
and IP dimensions.
Assign a numerical
value ranging from –1
(best) to –7 (worst) to
each of the variables
that make up the SP
and CP dimensions
6-50
Steps to Develop a SPACE Matrix
Ratings
FINANCIAL STRENGTH
INDUSTRY STRENGTH
Domestic demand for coffee has been on a steady rise per year with instant coffee growing by 20 to 25 6.0
percent, while "roast and ground" requirements rising by five to six percent. 6.0
The specialty coffee shop industry is projected to sustain growth of 20 percent over the next five years. 5.0
Cafés/bars will be registering a constant value CAGR of 1% over the 2012-2017 forecast period.(Euromonitor, 6.0
2013)
Philippine coffee shops up domestic consumption by 2.25%
STABILITY POSITION
Natural calamities, climate change, and crop diseases that affects supply and demand of coffee -4.0
Local production in the Philippines still did not meet coffee demand in the country. -3.0
increase health and wellness awareness trend -3.0
Increased competition from local cafes and specialization of other coffee chains -2.0
COMPETITIVE POSITION
High brand equity -1.0
Largest and fast growing coffee shop chain in the world -1.0
Excellent employee relationship -1.0
High quality product and Starbucks experience -2.0
R&D -2.0
Rustan Coffee Corp, the operator of Starbucks specialist coffee shops in the Philippines, continues to be the -2.0
biggest chained player. -2.0
Starbucks Philippines with a network of more than 200 coffee chain stores
6-51
Steps to Develop a SPACE Matrix
•Compute an average score for FP, CP, IP, and SP by summing the values given to the
variables and dividing by the number of variables included in each dimension.
STABILITY POSITION
Natural calamities, climate change, and crop diseases that affects supply and demand of coffee -4.0
Local production in the Philippines still did not meet coffee demand in the country. -3.0 SP
increase health and wellness awareness trend -3.0 average is
Increased competition from local cafes and specialization of other coffee chains -2.0 -3
COMPETITIVE POSITION
High brand equity -1.0 CP
Largest and fast growing coffee shop chain in the world -1.0
average is
Excellent employee relationship -1.0
High quality product and Starbucks experience -2.0 -1.57
R&D -2.0
Rustan Coffee Corp, the operator of Starbucks specialist coffee shops in the Philippines, continues to be the -2.0
biggest chained player. -2.0
Starbucks Philippines with a network of more than 200 coffee chain stores
Steps to Develop a SPACE
Matrix
4. Plot the average scores for FP, IP, SP, and CP on
the appropriate axis in the SPACE Matrix
5. Add the two scores on the x-axis and plot the
resultant point on X. Add the two scores on the
y-axis and plot the resultant point on Y. Plot the
intersection of the new xy point
6-53
4. Plot the average scores for FP, IP, SP, and CP on the
appropriate axis in the SPACE Matrix
5. Add the two scores on the x-axis and plot the resultant
point on X. Add the two scores on the y-axis and plot the
resultant point on Y. Plot the intersection of the new xy
point
Conclusion:
IP average is 5.75
CP average is -1.57 3.67
SP average is -3
FP average is 6.67
4.18
Directional vector coordinates:
6-55
Starbucks Example
SPACE Analysis
Example Strategy Profiles
6-58
Example Strategy Profiles
6-59
Boston Consulting Group Matrix
Graphically portrays differences among divisions in terms
of relative market share position and industry growth rate
Dogs – Quadrant IV
compete in a slow- or no-market-
growth industry
businesses are often liquidated,
divested, or trimmed down through
retrenchment
Boston Consulting Group Matrix
Strategies
•Forward, backward,
horizontal integration;
•Market penetration,
•Market development,
•Product development.
BCG Analysis
The Internal-External (IE) Matrix
The IE Matrix is based on two key dimensions: the
IFE total weighted scores on the x-axis and the EFE
total weighted scores on the y-axis IFE
EFE 3.11
3.17
The Internal-External (IE) Matrix
Three major regions
Grow and build
Hold and maintain
IFE
Harvest or divest
EFE
The IE Matrix
6-72
The IE Matrix
Harvest or Divest
-Retrenchment
-Divestiture
The IE Matrix
6-75
IFE TOTAL
WEIGHTED Starbucks Example
SCORE: 3.11
EFE TOTAL
WEIGHTED
SCORE: 3.17
Starbucks Example
Grow and Build
Grow and Build Starbucks Example
-Backward, Forward, or Horizontal Integrations
-Market Penetration
-Market Development
-Product Development
I.E. Analysis
The Grand Strategy Matrix
Grand Strategy Matrix
based on two evaluative dimensions: competitive
position and market (industry) growth
RAPID MARKET
GROWTH
WEAK STRONG
COMPETITIVE COMPETITIVE
POSITION POSITION
SLOW MARKET
GROWTH
6-81
*Note: Any industry whose annual growth in sales exceeds
5% could be considered to have rapid growth.
RAPID MARKET
GROWTH
SLOW MARKET
GROWTH
Quadrant II Quadrant I
Unable to compete effectively Continued concentration on current
need to determine why the firm’s current markets (market penetration and
approach is ineffective and how the market development) & products
company can best change to improve (product development) is an
its competitiveness appropriate strategy
6-84
Starbucks Example
SUMMARY OF STRATEGIES
The recommended strategies from the different strategy formulation tools stated above
are summarized below:
The recommended strategies from the different strategy formulation tools stated above
are summarized below:
3. Decision Stage
Strategy Evaluation
The Quantitative Strategic
Planning Matrix (QSPM)
Quantitative Strategic Planning Matrix (QSPM)
objectively indicates which alternative strategies are
best
uses input from Stage 1 analyses and matching
results from Stage 2 analyses to decide objectively
among alternative strategies
6-90
The Quantitative Strategic
Planning Matrix (QSPM)
6-91
QSPM of Starbucks
KEY FACTORS PRODUCT MARKET MARKET
DEVELOPMENT DEVELOPMENT PENETRATION
W’T RATE SCORE RATE SCORE RATE SCORE
STRENGTH:
WEAKNESSES
OPPORTUNITIES
THREATS
100%
TOTAL WEIGHT
WEAKNESSES
OPPORTUNITIES
THREATS
100%
TOTAL WEIGHT
WEAKNESSES
OPPORTUNITIES
THREATS
100%
TOTAL WEIGHT
OPPORTUNITIES
THREATS
100%
TOTAL WEIGHT
1.Market Development
2. Product Development
3. Market Penetration
Thank you.