Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Research Article
This study was carried out to investigate the effects of raffia palm fibre on some mechanical
behaviour (flexural strength, flexural modulus, water absorption rate and density) of concrete. A
concrete mix ratio of 1:2:4 was used for the concrete beams production, while a water to cement
ratio (w/c) of 0.5 was adopted. In the study, three different fibre lengths (10, 20 and 30 mm) and
three different fibre content (volume) by mass of fine aggregate (1, 2 and 3%) were considered.
According to the results of the preliminary test carried out on the fine aggregate, it had a silt
content of 1.6%, a moisture content of 8.3%, and a specific gravity of 2.95. Flexural properties of
the beams were tested in accordance with ASTM recommended procedures after 28 curing days.
Results obtained showed that fibre volume had significant (p ≤0.05) effect on the flexural strength
and flexural modulus of the beams. The flexural strength and flexural modulus decreased linearly
as the fibre volume increased from 0% to 3%. According to the results, the fibre reinforced beams
were more ductile, when compared to the unreinforced concrete beams. In addition, the densities
of the beams decreased with increase in the fibre volume; while their water absorption rate
increased with increase in the fibre volume. The low densities and brittleness of the reinforced
beams (at low volume) made them good building materials, especially when heavy weight beams
are a problem, provided the beams are not exposed to high moisture levels.
Keywords: Raffia palm fibres; concrete, flexural strength, flexural modulus, density
INTRODUCTION
Concrete is one of the most widely used construction accounts for about 39% of the world’s energy consumption
material in the construction and building industries, which and 42% of its CO2 emissions (Lafarge, 2009). To curb this
are among the most active sectors in the world. Concrete menace, sustainable construction methods are been
is a mineral composite, which consists of fine and coarse developed for the building and construction industries.
aggregates, water, and a binding agent (generally
cement), and in some cases admixtures and additives Sustainable construction involves limiting the negative
(Lafarge, 2009). Globally, the utilization of concrete in environmental impacts of buildings, while guaranteeing
building and construction is twice the total amount of all them superior quality in terms of aesthetics, durability and
other building materials used, i.e. wood, steel, plastic and resistance. The International Council of Building (CIB)
aluminum. According to statistics from the Cement stated that sustainable construction is responsible for
Association of Canada, the annual global production of creating and maintaining a healthy built-up environment,
concrete stands at about 4 billion cubic meters, this is based on the efficient use of resources and following
spread unequally in more than 120 countries (Ecosmart, ecological principles (Yan and Chouw, 2014). The usage
2019). By 2025, the world population is expected to rise by
about 35%, rising up to about 10 billion people. Therefore,
about two billion additional human beings will need *Corresponding Author: Akpokodje O.I., Department of
adequate shelter to ensure their mobility. This will further Civil Engineering Technology, Delta State Polytechnic,
contribute to the menace of climate change and energy Ozoro, Nigeria.
efficiency, because presently the building industry E-mail: erobo2011@gmail.com; Tel: +234-8035420074
Study of Flexural Strength and Flexural Modulus of Reinforced Concrete Beams with Raffia Palm Fibers
Akpokodje et al. 058
of plant-based products is of great advantage in observed that nylon fibres could not only increase the
sustainable construction, since it creates new prospects unconfined compressive strength and peak strain of
for these products, it preserves the natural resources, and cement-stabilized clay but also facilitate a transition from
it will not alter the conventional construction methods. On brittle failure to ductile failure. Reinforced cement has been
the basis of this, the United States Department of shown to significantly improve the mechanical properties
Agriculture (USDA) and the United States Department of of soils and is hence widely used in soft soil foundation
Energy (USDE) had set goals of having at least 10% of all treatment, backfilling of retaining walls, roadbed
basic building blocks and concrete produced from reinforcement of roads and railways, etc. (Kim et al., 2008;
renewable and plant-based sources by 2020, which will be Lv and Zhou, 2019).
increased to 50% by 2050 (Yan et al., 2014). The use of
biomaterials to replace these synthetic fibres as Proper waste disposal and recycling of waste materials
reinforcement or partial replacement has been a growing have become a critical issue in Nigeria, from the
interest for different engineering applications. This is environmental protection point of view. Therefore, the use
because natural fibres are biodegradability, less dense but of plant-based fibres to reinforce concrete beams will not
with high specific strength, moth-proof, resistant to fungi only be beneficial to the engineering field, but also solve
attacks, provide excellent insulation against sound, flame- significant environmental problem. The objectives of this
retardant, tough and durable (Ali et al., 2012; Yan, 2012; study were to:
Umurhurhu and Uguru, 2019). The use of (i) Investigate the flexural behaviour of raffia palm fibre
chemical/synthesized fibres will inevitably result in reinforced concrete beams and comparison of these
environmental pollution. Therefore, the reinforcement of results with that of unreinforced concrete beams.
cement-stabilized soil using fibers or blocks obtained from (ii) Evaluate the effect of raffia palm fibre volume and
waste materials has emerged as a hot research topic and length on the water absorption rate and density of
many studies been conducted by several researchers (Lv concrete beams.
and Zhou, 2019).
Researches on new building materials have been on for MATERIALS AND METHOD
the past decades, with the sole aim of developing low cost
construction materials that can be affordable to the people. Materials
Cheap and standard building materials are necessary for
the construction of low-cost housing estates, and other The following materials were used for the production of the
structures. Composites are a versatile and valuable family concrete beams.
of materials that can solve problems of different
applications and facilitate the introduction of new Cement: Ordinary Portland cement (Manufactured by
properties in materials (Gon et al., 2012). Park (2009) Dangote), was used as the binder in the production of the
carried out a series of unconfined compression tests on reinforced concrete beams. The cement was of grade
samples reinforced with fibres. He reported that a fibre 42.5, which was in compliance with Nigeria Industrial
reinforced specimen was twice as strong as a non-fibre- Standard (NIS, 2003; Esegbuyota et al., 2018).
reinforced specimen. The author also reported that a
specimen with five fiber inclusion layers was 1.5 times Water: Fresh tap water (pH 7.5 and electrical conductivity
stronger than a specimen with one fibre inclusion layer. 30 μS/cm) was used for the study. The water met the
According to Aho and Ndububa, (2015) concrete beams Nigeria Industrial Standard (NIS) recommendation.
reinforced with raffia palm fruit peel fibres improved their
flexural strength but resulted in reduction of their Raffia palm fibres: The raffia palm fibres were purchased
compressive strength. Ahmad et al. (2014) reported that from a local market located at Otor - Owhe, Delta State,
the flexural strength of beam increases when we use Nigeria. They were air-dried in the laboratory at an ambient
bamboo stick as reinforcement in concrete. The flexural temperature of 29±4oC for two weeks. Thickness of the
strength of doubly bamboo reinforced beams reached up fibres was measured with the aid of a digital micrometer,
to 80MPa as compare to 48MPa for concrete beams and the fibres thickness ranged between 0.027 and 0.032
without any reinforcements. The maximum deflection at mm (Figure 1). These fibres were cut in three length sizes
the mid span reaches up to 1mm approximates. Mostafa (10mm, 20 mm and 30 mm).
and Uddin, (2015) studied the behaviour of mortar
reinforced with different percent of coconut and banana Fine aggregate: The fine aggregate used in this study was
fibres. They observed that the maximum tensile strength obtained from Ase River in Delta State, Nigeria (Figure 1).
and modulus of rupture of mortar composite increased up The fine aggregate was air dried at the Civil Engineering
to certain fibre content (percent), before the values soil laboratory, Delta State Polytechnic, Ozoro, Nigeria for
dropped as the fibre volume increases. Similarly, two weeks. Sieve analysis was carried out on the fine
Estabragh et al. (2012) studied the effects of fibre volume, aggregate to determine their suitability for concrete
cement volume, and curing age on the unconfined production.
compressive strength of cement-stabilized clay. They
Study of Flexural Strength and Flexural Modulus of Reinforced Concrete Beams with Raffia Palm Fibers
World J. Civ. Engin. Constr. Techn. 059
Coarse aggregate: The coarse aggregate was free from W3 = Weight of the bottle and its content filled with distilled
deleterious materials like silt, plant roots, etc. (Figure 1). water up to the meniscus.
According to NIS recommendation, coarse aggregate W4 = Weight of the bottle filled with distilled water to the
which are to be used for concrete production must be meniscus.
clean, hard, and free from chemicals or any materials that
could cause the deterioration of concrete. All the tests were carried out at the Concrete laboratory of
the Department of Civil Engineering Technology, Delta
State Polytechnic, Ozoro, Nigeria, at ambient temperature
(29±4oC). Four blocks from each sample were tested and
the average value was recorded.
Concrete production
Study of Flexural Strength and Flexural Modulus of Reinforced Concrete Beams with Raffia Palm Fibers
Akpokodje et al. 060
Study of Flexural Strength and Flexural Modulus of Reinforced Concrete Beams with Raffia Palm Fibers
World J. Civ. Engin. Constr. Techn. 061
60
fibre reinforced cement concrete (RCC). It can be seen in
Figure 6 that the inclusion of raffia palm fibres inclusion
makes concrete more ductile compared to the CC. The
40
unreinforced concrete exhibited brittle failure behaviour.
On the average, concrete reinforced with 3% fibres had
20 higher deflection (better ductility) than other RCC samples
with 1% or 2% fibre reinforcement. Similar results were
0
obtain by Rai1and Joshi (2014) and Yan and Chouw
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 (2014). Rai1and Joshi (2014) reported that addition of coir
seive size (mm
fibres to concrete increased its flexural properties by about
Figure 4: Particle size distribution of the fine aggregate. 10%. Yan and Chouw (2014) observed that concrete
reinforced with coir fibres had higher deflection on loading
Moisture content: The result of the moisture content of when compared with unreinforced concrete samples.
the fine aggregate was 8.6% (Table 2). The moisture
content was below the maximum value of 12% Flexural modulus: The flexural modulus of the concrete
recommended by the Nigeria Industrial Standard. samples is presented in Figure 7. Compared with the
control samples, the raffia palm fibres inclusion reduced
Specific gravity: The mean specific gravity of the fine the flexural modulus depending on the fibre volume and
aggregate used for the concrete production was 2.95 fibre length used. As shown in Figure 7, the unreinforced
(Table 2). High specific gravity of the fine aggregate (control) concrete which was considered as a reference for
contributes to the high concrete density. the evaluation had flexural modulus of 920.91 MPa. The
concrete with fibre length of 10 mm (1% volume) had best
Table 2: Characteristics of the fine aggregate flexural modulus (392.15 MPa) when compare to the other
Parameter Value concrete samples with other fibre lengths and contents.
Moisture content (%wb) 8.6± 0.44 For all the reinforced concrete cases, statistically, fibre
Specific gravity 2.95±0.03 lengths did not significantly (p ≤0.05) affect the flexural
Values are means ± standard deviation modulus of the concrete samples. The results obtained
Study of Flexural Strength and Flexural Modulus of Reinforced Concrete Beams with Raffia Palm Fibers
Akpokodje et al. 062
6 6
a
Control
1% Fibres
5 2% Fibres 5
CC
3% Fibres
1% RCC
b 2% RCC
b 3% RCC
Flexural Strength (MPa)
4 c 4
b
c
Load (KN)
d
3 c 3
d
d
2 2
1 1
0 0
Control 10 mm 20 mm 30 mm 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5
Fibres lenght and Volume Deflection (mm)
Figure 5: Effect of fibre content and its length on the Figure 6: Load –deflection curves of the concrete beams
flexural strength of concrete during flexural testing
Different common letters on columns represent statistical CC = Unreinforced cement concrete; RCC = Reinforced
differences (p ≤0.05) using Duncan’s multiple range test. cement concrete
from this study are in conformity with the previous study of density. Boob, 2014, reported a similar trend for sawdust
Ali et al. (2012). Ali et al. (2012) investigated the reinforced blocks, where the density decreased from 2400
mechanical properties of coir fibre reinforced concrete Kg/m3 to 1800 Kg/m3, as the sawdust content increased
(CFRC) of different fibre lengths and fibre volume, and from 0% to 20%. In contrast, Musa and Abubakar (2018)
observed a decrease in the static modulus of elasticity of observed an increment in sandcrete blocks density, as the
the concrete as the fibre volume and lengths increased. steel fibre reinforcement increased; which they attributed
to the higher steel fibre density compare to that of the fine
1000
aggregate they replaced.
a
900
2450
800
2400 Control
700 1% Fibres
Control
2% Fibres
Flexural modulus (MPa)
1% Fibres 2350
3% Fibres
600 2% Fibres
3% Fibres 2300
500
Density (kg/m3)
2250
400 b
b
b 2200
300 c
c
c 2150
d
200 d
d
2100
100
2050
0
Control 10 mm 20 mm 30 mm 2000
Fibres lenght and Volume
1950
Figure 7: Effect of fibre volume and its length on the Control 10 mm 20 mm 30 mm
Fibres lenght and Volume
flexural modulus of concrete
Different common letters on columns represent statistical Figure 8: Effect of fibre volume and its length on concrete
differences (p ≤0.05) using Duncan’s multiple range test. density
Concrete density: As presented in Figure 8, the concrete Water Absorption: The effect of fibre volume and lengths
density decreased with increase in the fibres volume and on the water absorption rate of raffia palm reinforced
length. The unreinforced concrete had the highest density concrete is presented in Figure 9. As shown in Figure 9,
(2425 kg/m3), while the 3% (30 mm) fibre reinforced the concrete water absorption rate was highly dependent
concrete had the lowest density (2117 Kg/m3). As showed on the fibre volume. The water absorption rate increased
in Figure 8, fibre length had no significant (p ≤0.05) effect linearly as the fibre volume increased from 1% to 3%. The
on the concrete density, but fibre volume significantly (p minimum water absorption rate was recorded in the
≤0.05) influenced the concrete density. This means that unreinforced concrete (8.14%), while the maximum water
fibre length did not play a significant role in the concrete absorption rate (13.44%) was recorded in the concrete
Study of Flexural Strength and Flexural Modulus of Reinforced Concrete Beams with Raffia Palm Fibers
World J. Civ. Engin. Constr. Techn. 063
reinforced with 30 mm (3% volume) raffia palm fibres, after recommended standards. Results obtained from the study
28 days of curing. The water absorption rates recorded for showed that the mechanical properties of the concrete
concrete reinforced with 1% fibres; across the three fibres were highly dependent on the fibre volume. Flexural
lengths, fall within water absorption limits recommended strength of the concrete decreased from 5.56 MPa in the
for concrete in the Nigeria Industrial Standard. The higher control (unreinforced) concrete to 2.28 MPa in the
water absorption rate for the fibre reinforced concrete concrete reinforced with 3% (30 mm) raffia palm fibre.
could be attributed to the cellular structure of the raffia Similarly, the flexural modulus decreased linearly from
fibres, and the high void ratio induced within the concrete, 920.91 MPa in the control concrete to 153.15 MPa in the
leading to higher water permeability (Esegbuyota et al., concrete reinforced with 3% fibre. In contrast, the water
2019). According to Ugwuishiwu et al. (2013), fibres are absorption of the concrete increased with increase in the
responsible for the high absorption of water in fibre fibre volume and length. At 0% fibre volume, the water
reinforced blocks, while the blocks densities decreased absorption rate was 8.14%, which increased to 12.78% as
with the increase in fibre volume. Water absorption is the fibre volume and length increased to 3% and 30 mm.
appreciable to an extent, but excessive of it causes defects Results obtained from this study showed the prospects of
in the block work, such as, shrinkage of block after drying, utilizing raffia palm fibres at low volume reinforcement, in
cracking of blocks, opening of the joints, etc. (Boob, 2014). building components that are not exposed to high moisture
The mechanical properties of raffia fibre are affected by levels. Flexural strength will however be impaired but
the local climate; e.g. rainfall and temperature during ductility is improved.
growth; maturity stage of the fibres; fibres extraction
method, i.e. type of retting method, separating conditions;
storage conditions; age of fibres and type surface REFERENCES
treatment. The mechanical mixing of the concrete’s Ahmad S, Raza A, Gupta H. (2014). Mechanical
constituent materials increased the distribution of fibres, Properties of Bamboo Fibre Reinforced Concrete. 2nd
thereby creating homogeneity of the mixture. This helps to International Conference on Research in Science,
enhance the concrete’s flexural strength, reduce the water Engineering and Technology (ICRSET’2014), (UAE).
absorption rate, and improves the concrete tensile Aho I O, Ndububa E E. (2015). Compressive and flexural
strength. Dahunsi (2000) reported that cement matrices strength of cement mortar stabilized with raffia palm
reinforced with natural materials have been adapted to fruit peel (RPEP). Global Journal of Engineering
various uses such as construction of reservoirs, pipes, Research, 4: 1-7
floors and concrete covers. Akpokodje O I, Uguru H. (2019. Effect of fermented
cassava waste water as admixture on some physic-
16
mechanical properties of solid sandcrete blocks.
14
International Journal of Engineering Trends &
Technology (IJETT), Article in Press
12 Akpokodje O I, Uguru H, Esegbuyota D. (2018).
Remediation of cassava effluent contaminated soil
Water absorption rate (%)
10
using organic soap solution: Case study of soil physical
8 Control
properties and plant growth performance. Journal of
1% Fibres Scientific Research and Reports. 21(3): 1-11.
2% Fibres
6 3% Fibres Ali M, Liu A, Sou H, Chouw N (2012) Mechanical and
dynamic properties of coconut fibre reinforced
4 concrete. Constr and Build Mater 30: 814-825
Aliv M, Briet R, Chouw N. (2013). Dynamic response of
2
mortar-free interlocking structures.
0
AOAC. Official Methods of Analysis of AOAC
Control 10 mm 20 mm 30 mm INTERNATIONAL, 21st Edition. Association Official
Fibres lenght and Volume
Analytical Chemists, Washington, DC., USA. 2019
Figure 9: Effect of fibre volume and length on concrete Boob T N. (2014). Performance of saw-dust in low cost
water absorption rate sandcrete blocks, American Journal of Engineering
Research. 3(4):197-206.
Cho S. (2013). Effect of silt fines on the durability
CONCLUSION properties of concrete. Journal of Applied Science and
Engineering, 16 (4): 425-430
This study was carried out to investigate the effect of raffia Construction and Building Materials, 42: 168-189.
palm fibre volume and length on some mechanical Dahunsi B I O. (2000). The Properties and Potential
(flexural strength, flexural modulus, density and water Applications of Ratton Canes as Reinforcement
absorption) of concrete samples. The concrete samples Material in Concrete. Unpublished Ph.D. Thesis,
were prepared and tested according to ASTM Department of Agric. Engineering, University of Ibadan.
Study of Flexural Strength and Flexural Modulus of Reinforced Concrete Beams with Raffia Palm Fibers
Akpokodje et al. 064
Ecosmart (2019). “Concrete”. Available at: Ugwuishiwu B O, Mama B O, Okoye N M. (2013). Effect of
http://ecosmartconcrete.com/?page_id=208. Retrieved natural fibre reinforcement on water absorption of
on 2nd July, 2019. compressed Stabilized earth blocks. International
Esegbuyota D, Akpokodje O I, Uguru H. (2019). Physical Journal of Scientific Research, 2 (11):165-167
characteristics and compressive strength of raffia fibre Umurhurhu B, Uguru H (2019). Tensile behaviour of oil
reinforced sandcrete blocks. Direct Research Journal of bean pod shell and mahogany sawdust reinforced
Engineering and Information Technology, 6(1):1-8 epoxy resin composite. International Journal of
Estabragh A R, Namdar P, Javadi A A. (2012). Behavior of Science, Technology and Society. 7(1):1-7. doi:
cement-stabilized clay reinforced with nylon fiber. 10.11648/j.ijsts.20190701.11
Geosynthetics International, 19(1): 85–92. Yan L. (2012). Effect of alkali treatment on vibration
Gon D, Das K, Paul P, Maity S. (2012). Jute composites characteristics and mechanical properties of natural
as wood substitute. International Journal of Textile fabric reinforced composites. Journal of Reinforced
Science, 1(6):84-93. Plastics and Composites, 31(13): 887-896.
Islam S M, Hussain R R, Morshed M A Z. (2012). Fiber- Yan LB, Chouw N, Jayaraman K. (2014) Effect of
reinforced concrete incorporating locally available triggering and polyurethane foam-filler on axial crushing
natural fibers in normal- and high-strength concrete and and natural flax/epoxy composite tubes. Mater and
a performance analysis with steel fiber-reinforced Des., 56: 528-541.
composite concrete. Journal of Composite Materials, Yan LB, Chouw N. (2014). Sustainable Concrete and
46: 111-122. Structures with Natural Fibre Reinforcement.
Kim Y, Kim H J, Lee G H. (2008). Mechanical behavior of Infrastructure Corrosion and Durability – A
lightweight soil reinforced with waste fishing net. Sustainability Study. Editor: Yang Lu, OMICS Group
Geotextiles and Geomembranes, 26(6): 512–518. Incorporation.
Lafarge (2009). “Lafarge: Concrete reborn.” Available at:
https://www.lafargeholcim.com/sites/default/files/impor
t/press_kit/10012008-press_themabook-
Columbia_2008-uk.pdf retrieved on 20th August, 2019.
Lv X, Zhou H. (2019). Shear characteristics of cement-
stabilized sand reinforced with waste polyester fiber
fabric blocks. Advances in Materials Science and
Engineering, 2019:1-12
Mostafa M, Uddin N. (2015). Effect of banana fibers on
the compressive and flexural strength of compressed
earth blocks. Buildings. 5: 282-296;
Musa N M, Abubakar M. (2018). Effects of tyre steel fibre
reinforcement on sandcrete blocks. Nigerian Journal of Accepted 24 May 2019
Technology. 37(4): 875 – 879
NIS-444. (2003). Quality standard for ordinary Portland Citation: Akpokodje OI, Uguru H, Esegbuyota D (2019).
cement. Standard Organization of Nigeria, Lagos, Study of Flexural Strength and Flexural Modulus of
Nigeria Reinforced Concrete Beams with Raffia Palm Fibers.
Odeyemi S O, Akinpelu MA, Atoyebi O D, Orire K J. World Journal of Civil Engineering and Construction
(2018). Quality assessment of sandcrete blocks Technology, 3(1): 057-064.
produced in Adeta, Kwara state. Nigeria. Nigerian
Journal of Technology, 37(1):53 – 59.
Park S S. (2009). Effect of fiber reinforcement and
distribution on unconfined compressive strength of
fiber-reinforced cemented sand. Geotextiles and Copyright: © 2019 Akpokodje et al. This is an open-
access article distributed under the terms of the Creative
Geomembranes, 27(2): 162–166.
Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted
Rai1 A, Joshi Y P (2014). Applications and properties of
use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium,
fibre reinforced concrete. International Journal of
provided the original author and source are cited.
Engineering Research and Applications. 4(5): 123-131
Study of Flexural Strength and Flexural Modulus of Reinforced Concrete Beams with Raffia Palm Fibers