Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
03 Introduction
Reference Material
17 Key Canadian LNG Projects
19 Glossary & Conversions
19 Web Resources
2
INTRODUCTION
Natural gas is enjoying a feet per day (bcf/d) from 18 bcf/d, with the lowest GHG emissions
renaissance around the world. with prices collapsing. These in the world, especially in B.C.,
Consumption and production of shifting supply/demand market where most of the province’s
natural gas was up over five per dynamics in North America have power is generated by hydro. But
cent in 2018, one of the strongest also sparked interest by Canadian Canada must also address current
rates of growth for both demand producers in developing their own disadvantages — in particular,
and output for over 30 years.1 LNG exports. regulatory issues and the lack of
certainty in the overall investment
And the outlook for natural gas Alberta and British Columbia climate for energy projects in
uses remains promising. While fields have generations’ worth the country.
natural gas demand in the past of abundant natural gas. LNG
was driven by power generation — projects are absolutely essential This report examines how
displacing more carbon-intensive for Canadian natural gas Canadian gas supplies — delivered
energy sources such as coal and producers to reach new markets, to worldwide markets through
oil — in the future the demand will diversify the natural gas sector LNG export terminals on the
come from industrial applications and create new employment West Coast and the East Coast
and petrochemicals. opportunities. — can help meet burgeoning
market demand and offer a
Canada has a tremendous In October 2018, LNG Canada transformative opportunity for
opportunity to supply large announced a positive final struggling producers.
populations with cleaner burning investment decision (FID) for
natural gas. The country’s its proposed export project
operators produce more gas than in Kitimat, B.C. This major
is needed for domestic markets. infrastructure project is backed
LNG projects are
That excess gas production has heavily by Royal Dutch Shell to
traditionally been exported by supply LNG to Asian markets. absolutely essential for
pipeline to the U.S., but the shale More positive FIDs are expected Canadian natural gas
gas revolution south of the border on both coasts. producers to reach new
has led to reduced demand as that
country moved from needing to
Canadian LNG developers have markets, diversify the
import gas to exporting it, via a
many advantages, including access natural gas sector and
to large and low cost gas supplies,
handful of LNG export projects.
as well as faster access to Asian
create new employment
As a result, production in Western and other markets than U.S. Gulf opportunities.
Canada had declined in the past Coast LNG plants. There is also
decade to about 16 billion cubic the potential to produce LNG
1
BP Statistical Review of World Energy – 2019 edition
3
An artist’s rendering of the LNG Canada project at full build out. Image courtesy LNG Canada
4
THE NATURAL GAS SUPPLY PICTURE
Bcf/d 106m3/d
25 700
600
20
500
15 400
10 300
200
5
100
0 0
2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040
2
National Energy Board (NEB), 2017
3
International Energy Agency (IEA), Gas 2019: Analysis and Forecast to 2024
4
NEB, Canada’s Energy Future 2018: Energy Supply and Demand Projections to 2040
5
Production begins to increase after 2021 as development associated with assumed LNG exports
gradually higher prices (see below for AB-NIT support increased capital spending. This leads to
price assumptions) encourage enough drilling to more natural gas wells and production in
offset production declines from older wells, and Western Canada.
2016 US$/MMBtu
5
-1
-2
2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040
Fort
Alberta — has grown significantly over the past five
Nelson
Grande
In the Alberta Deep Basin — a tight gas play that
Prairie SAS KATCH EWAN
BRITISH
runs along the Alberta foothills — production grows
COLUMBIA
Edmonton
modestly as natural gas and NGL prices increase,
DUVERNAY
rising to four bcf/d by 2040 from 3.4 bcf/d in the
ALBERTA
Reference Case.
DEEP BASIN
Map produced by the NEB, September 2015 currently produce small amounts of natural gas,
Source: Geological Atlas of the Western Canada
Sedimentary Basin
and production from both grows modestly over the
Source:
Canada’s Energy Future 2016: Energy Supply and Demand Projections to 2040 projection period with combined production from the
(Source: Canada’s Energy Future 2016: Energy Supply and Demand two plays increasing to 900 mmcf/d in 2040 from 500
Projections to 2040)
mmcf/d in 2017 for the Reference Case.
6
THE GLOBAL SUPPLY PICTURE
Global natural gas production is forecast to rise from BP’s most recent projection6 says global gas
3.94 trillion cubic metres (tcm) in 2018 to 4.33 tcm development is expected to grow strongly to 2040,
by 2024, an average annual increase of 1.6%, the supported by broad-based demand, plentiful low-cost
International Energy Agency (IEA) says in a supplies, and the increasing availability of gas globally,
recent report.5 aided by the growing supplies of LNG.
The U.S. provides the largest individual contribution In its Evolving Transition (ET) scenario, natural
to this increase due to its ample shale gas resources. gas grows at an average rate of 1.7% per annum —
China and Australia drive production growth in increasing nearly 50% by 2040 — the only source
the Asia Pacific region, while production growth in of energy, along with renewables, whose share in
other Asian economies remains limited due to the primary energy increases over the outlook period.
depletion of historical resources and the lead time of [Note, BP’s Evolving Transition scenario assumes
exploration and production investment. that government policies, technology and social
preferences continue to evolve in a manner and speed
Gas production in the Middle East keeps on growing seen over the recent past.]
at a stable rate, but is mainly driven by domestic
needs in Iran and Saudi Arabia. While prospects for Natural gas output is led by the U.S. and Middle East
production development in Qatar remain uncertain, (Qatar and Iran) — who together account for almost
especially surrounding the timing of LNG export 50% of the growth in gas production to 2040 —
capacity expansion, the IEA forecast assumes a stable supported by strong increases in output in China and
level of production to 2024 in the absence of a final Russia, BP says.
investment decision (FID) on LNG expansion at the
time of writing.
Top 10 - Global onstream LNG export capacity by nation as of May 31, 2019
(million tonnes per year)
Australia
Qatar
United States
Indonesia
Malaysia
Russia
Algeria
Nigeria
Egypt
0 20 40 60 80 100
5
IEA, Gas 2019: Analysis and Forecast to 2024
6
BP Energy Outlook 2019
7
NATURAL GAS DEMAND
200 Middle East Although the use of gas within the transport
sector grows rapidly, it remains small relative
100 EU
to industry and power. The use of gas for
US heating buildings also expands during the
0
period, although slower than other sectors.
-100
Power Industry Buildings Non- Transport
combusted
7
IEA, Gas 2019: Analysis and Forecast to 2024
8
BP Energy Outlook 2019
8
LNG CONTINUES TO EXPAND ITS REACH
Global LNG volumes are set to expand substantially. In BP’s Evolving Transition (ET) scenario, LNG trade more
than doubles, reaching almost 900 billion cubic metres (bcm) in 2040, up from around 400 bcm in 2017.9
The increase in LNG exports is led by North America, followed by the Middle East, Africa and Russia. As the LNG
market matures, the U.S. and Qatar emerge as the main centres of LNG exports, accounting for around 40 per
cent of all LNG exports by 2040.
2017
2020
2030
2040
According to the BP outlook, Asia remains the dominant market for LNG imports, although the pattern of
imports within Asia shifts, with China, India and Other Asia overtaking the more established markets of Japan
and Korea, and accounting for around half of all LNG imports by 2040.
Europe remains a key market, both as a “balancing market” for LNG supplies and a key hub of gas-on-gas
competition between LNG and pipeline gas. The European market is growing because countries like Germany
don’t want to be over-reliant on Russia for their gas supplies.
Overall, LNG is becoming a much larger part of the global energy system with over 40 countries now importing
LNG compared to fewer than 10 in 2000.10
9
BP Energy Outlook 2019
10
International Energy Agency (IEA)
9
CHINESE DEMAND FOR GAS AND LNG ‘ALMOST INFINITE’
In China, imported LNG can be a key driver in the China is on target to be the largest LNG importer
country’s efforts to tackle poor air quality. Over by 2025.
the last few years, natural gas has been used mainly
Two years ago, 60% of China’s primary energy came
to replace coal-fired boilers in residential buildings
from coal. It fell to 56% in the first quarter of 2019.
or in smaller industrial facilities on the outskirts of
Natural gas consumption rose from 6.5% of total
towns that are the source of many of the particulate
energy consumption to 8.3% over that period. Li
emissions related to health impacts in China
estimates China’s demand for LNG imports will rise
and elsewhere.
from less than 40 million tonnes per annum (mtpa) to
Yao Li, CEO of Chinese energy consulting firm SIA 90 mtpa by 2030.
Energy, says that China’s demand for LNG is “almost
infinite.” The country’s shift from coal to natural gas
to provide power will require a substantial increase
in LNG imports, Li says, since only about 57% of its The country's shift from coal to
natural gas needs are supplied domestically. China natural gas to provide power
will not be able to repeat the American shale gas
will require a substantial
revolution, she adds, so it will need a lot of
imports of LNG. increase in LNG imports.
While LNG suppliers can expect other Asian — Yao Li, SIA Energy
countries, such as India, to also increase their imports
of LNG, it is China that represents the biggest market.
Bcm
700
600
Other
500
LNG
400 Russia
200
100
0
2010 2020 2030 2040
10
LNG: CANADA’S
GLOBAL MARKET OPPORTUNITY
Canada’s natural gas producers, LNG developers, as this coalition is to prepare a compelling narrative to all
well as industry associations and LNG industry groups Canadians on the importance of this transformative
all speak optimistically about the future of LNG industry on behalf of all stakeholders — business, First
development, given the demand outlook. Nations and government.
To realize how important a new industry such as LNG Dan Allan, president of CSUR, says LNG represents
is to Canada, you need look no further than the newly a key opportunity to kick the country’s natural gas
formed LNG Narrative Group. This organization was sector back into high gear over the long-term. “A large
formed by the Canadian Society for Unconventional majority of our members are gas producers and they
Resources (CSUR), Resource Works, the Canadian urgently require a robust LNG industry to allow for
Global Affairs Institute (CGAI) and JWN Energy market diversification,” he says.
(publisher of the Daily Oil Bulletin). The purpose of
“A large majority of our members are gas producers and they urgently
require a robust LNG industry to allow for market diversification.”
— Dan Allan, CSUR
11
SLOW GROWTH IN CANADA
A decade ago there were more than 20 LNG export quarter of the size of LNG Canada. Chevron Canada
projects proposed for Canada’s West Coast, but Limited earlier this year applied to the National
developers have dropped plans for most of those, with Energy Board (NEB) for a licence to export LNG from
the exception of the Shell-led LNG Canada project Canada for a term of 40 years. And on the East Coast,
and the smaller Woodfibre LNG project, planned for Pieridae Energy Limited is planning to develop an LNG
the Squamish area of B.C. It would be about one- project near Goldboro, N.S.
Capital Cost
Project Owner(s) Capactiy Status
(billions)
Shell, PETRONAS,
PetroChina, 13-26 mtpa Under construction;
LNG Canada Mitsubishi $40 completion expected by
Corporation, 1.7-3.4 bcf/d 2025
KOGAS
* Only projects with export licenses and regulatory approvals in place are included. Source: Canadian Energy Research Institute, company
announcements
Capital Cost
Project Owner(s) Capactiy Status
(billions)
* Only projects with export licences and regulatory approvals in place are included. Source: Canadian Energy Research Institute, company
announcements
The NEB’s most recent energy market report11 A second phase assumed to come online in 2030
assumes LNG exports from B.C.’s coast begin in 2025 would increase total LNG exports to 2.25 bcf/d in
at 750 mmcf/d and double by 2026 to reach 1.5 bcf/d. 2030 and 3.0 bcf/d in 2031.
12
However, LNG veteran Alfred Sorenson, president of from being heavily invested in the oilsands sector
Pieridae, points out that Cheniere Energy Inc., a first- should be a lesson for Canada as the LNG sector
mover in LNG development on the U.S. Gulf Coast, is needs to attract domestic and foreign investment.
about to develop its sixth train of LNG exports, which
While some analysts suggest there is a narrow
will lead to exports of about six bcf/d overall.
window of opportunity within which future LNG
Pieridae’s plant, unlike those on Canada’s West Coast, projects will need to fit, Birchcliff’s Tonken doesn’t
which are aimed at exports to Asia, is being designed buy that. “I believe that when you watch the large
to transport LNG to Europe and possibly India and international players, or look at their presentations,
elsewhere. In 2013, the company finalized a 20-year the world is going to LNG so that window is a
agreement to sell five million tonnes per year of LNG huge window.”
to German-based utility and energy company Uniper
However, “what we are missing is the fact that all
Global Commodities SE.
the investors have left the industry so if we don’t get
He says governments and Canadians need to support them back to support what we want to do, then we’ve
LNG development. Moreover, the departure of U.S.- got a problem,” he says.
based majors and international companies like Shell
LNG Opportunity
LNG Canada
Kitimat, B.C.
Kitimat LNG
Woodfibre LNG
Squamish, B.C.
Bear Head LNG
Saquenay, Que.
Énergie Saguenay
Port Tupper, N.S.
Goldboro LNG Goldboro, N.S.
11
NEB, Canada’s Energy Future 2018: Energy Supply and Demand Projections to 2040
13
ANALYSIS:
CANADA ENTERING COMPETITIVE
LNG MARKETPLACE
Finding buyers for LNG in an increasingly competitive “For Canada’s West Coast projects, all eyes are
market is a key obstacle to overcome for any of on the Asia Pacific region. It is home to the world’s
Canada’s many LNG export projects heading into three largest LNG consumers in China, Japan and
the 2020s. South Korea. Canada, due to proximity, is potentially
a key exporter for these nations thanks to low
Even after all approvals and licences have been transportation costs compared to competing regions
awarded and any required funding has been secured, from further afield,” says Mark Young, a senior oil and
if a project cannot find a buyer, it cannot succeed. gas analyst with Evaluate Energy.
LNG Canada and Woodfibre LNG on the West Coast “But this cost advantage will not be enjoyed — at least
and Pieridae’s Goldboro project on the East Coast are not to so great an extent — over major LNG producing
the only Canadian projects that have secured long- nations in the Asia Pacific region itself. This is the
term buyers so far and competition is growing fast in largest LNG producing area in the world thanks to
ideal markets. volumes from Malaysia, Indonesia and Australia.”
Asia - Pacific
Middle East
Africa
North America
Latin America
Europe
14
Canada’s ownership. There are only a handful of
projects worldwide with this elite roster
“LNG Canada appears to be
of backers.
Canada’s best chance to enter
Other projects on the West Coast do not tend to
the LNG export market in the
have such powerful backing, have not reached FID
near future and Pieridae is and, with the exception of Pacific Oil & Gas’ smaller
undoubtedly taking its own Woodfibre LNG project, do not have buyers in place.
encouraging steps to export (In June 2019, Woodfibre announced it has signed a
unit of BP Plc as its first customer.)
from the East Coast.”
“It remains to be seen how much of a Far Eastern
— Mark Young, Evaluate Energy market will be left if, and when, these other projects
finally enter the market, but it is certain that the
market will be far more crowded with suppliers when
Within the next year, Australia is set to briefly they do,” says Young.
overtake Qatar as the world’s largest exporting
nation until a major expansion in Qatar completes in It is a similar story on the East Coast. For projects
2024. Other Asia Pacific expansions are also set to be here, the ideal market due to proximity would be
completed before a single Canadian LNG cargo leaves Europe. Europe’s coastline is peppered with LNG
the West Coast. import facilities and the region has been importing
LNG for decades, but expansion plans are relatively
To add to this competition, major importing scarce. Canada’s East Coast exporters will be
companies from China, Japan and South Korea can attempting to enter a market late in the day.
be seen securing supply and effectively cutting their
overall import costs by taking minor stakes in export “Pieridae Energy stands out as it has managed to do
projects all over the world. this by signing one of the world’s single largest supply
deals over the past few years with Germany’s Uniper,
Despite all of this, LNG Canada stands out as highly a 20-year deal to provide Uniper with five million
promising among Canadian West Coast projects with tonnes a year from 2023 from its Goldboro project in
regards to entering this target market. Nova Scotia,” says Young.
• Its owners are all heavily involved in Asia Pacific Other planned projects on the East Coast, where
LNG trading, taking LNG from projects they own buyers are not yet secured, will have to contend with
into their “global portfolio” that is used to sign expanding competition from Qatar, new projects that
supply deals all over the world. Shell and partner are springing up in the U.S. and the vast supply of
Petronas are both among the world’s very Russian pipeline gas, among others. An added issue is
largest companies. that no East Coast export project has any major LNG
trader or potential customer in an ownership position,
• Its owners also include Japan-headquartered
like LNG Canada, to secure a portion of the market
Mitsubishi Corp., which has been very quick to
that way.
sign up fellow Japanese companies as future
buyers on long-term contracts for LNG Canada’s “LNG Canada appears to be Canada’s best chance to
gas since the FID was announced last year. enter the LNG export market in the near future and
Pieridae is undoubtedly taking its own encouraging
• China, through PetroChina, and South Korea,
steps to export from the East Coast,” says Young.
through Korea Gas, are also represented in LNG
15
NEXT “WAVE” ESSENTIALS
Canada has many of the elements that position it to become a major LNG
supplier in the future. Reserves are plentiful. The technology that is used to
drill for and produce gas in an efficient and environmentally friendly manner
is second-to-none. There is a sophisticated midstream and pipeline sector to
deliver that gas to market. Export points on both the West Coast and the East
Coast provide market benefits vis-à-vis other global LNG suppliers.
16
REFERENCE MATERIAL –
KEY CANADIAN LNG PROJECTS11
1. LNG Canada
• Location: Kitimat, B.C. full build out, LNG Canada will • Recent announcements:
have four trains or processing
• Proponents: A joint venture In June 2019, the federal
units, each with the capacity to
comprised of Royal Dutch government said it will
process approximately 7 mtpa
Shell plc, through its affiliate of LNG for export to countries spend $220 million to help
Shell Canada Energy (40%); in Asia and elsewhere. fund energy-efficient gas
PETRONAS, through its turbines and another $55
wholly-owned entity, North • FID: A final investment decision million to replace a bridge
Montney LNG Limited was made for the first two for the project.
Partnership (25%); PetroChina trains on Oct. 1, 2018.
In April 2019, the LNG
Company Limited, through
• Anticipated onstream date: Canada project owners
its subsidiary PetroChina
2025. officially handed over
Canada Ltd. (15%); Mitsubishi
construction management
Corporation, through its • Associated infrastructure: to their prime contractor,
subsidiary Diamond LNG TC Energy will build, own and JGC Fluor.
Canada Partnership (15%); operate the 670-kilometre
and Korea Gas Corporation, Coastal GasLink (CGL) pipeline In January 2019, LNG
through its wholly-owned that will connect natural gas Canada approved $937
subsidiary Kogas Canada from northeast B.C. to the million in contracts and
LNG Ltd (5%). export plant. subcontracts to First
Nations and Canadian
• Capacity: The project will • Regional economic benefits: businesses.
initially export 14 mtpa, the 4,500 people employed at
equivalent of about 1.8 bcf/d, peak construction on the • More details: https://www.
from two processing units. At Kitimat site. lngcanada.ca/
12
Updated as of July 15, 2019
17
2. Kitimat LNG
• Location: Bish Cove, near Kitimat, B.C. LNG plant site with another 1,500 workers
building PTP. In addition, Kitimat LNG has a
• Proponents: The proposed project is a 50/50 joint benefits agreement with the Haisla Nation for the
venture between Chevron Canada Limited and plant, which is located on Haisla Nation Reserve
Woodside Energy International (Canada) Limited. land, and an agreement with all 16 First Nations
• Capacity: The Kitimat LNG plant includes up to along the proposed PTP route through the First
three LNG trains totalling 18 mtpa (6.0 mtpa/train). Nations Limited Partnership (FNLP).
The initial foundation project consists of two • Recent announcements:
trains (12 mtpa).
In July 2019, in an NEB filing, the proponents
• Anticipated FID: 2022 to 2023. said supply will come from the equity gas
• Construction of Phase 1: 2022/23 to 2028/29; resources of Chevron and Woodside held
commissioning of first LNG train begins after together in the Liard Basin, Chevron’s equity
construction is complete; commissioning of gas resource in the Kaybob Duvernay resource
second LNG train begins three weeks after the and, if needed, from other contingent and
commissioning of the first train; construction and prospective resources, and open market
commissioning of the third LNG train as market purchase or swaps made in WCSB market hubs.
conditions allow. In July 2019, the project proposed to become
• Associated infrastructure: The 471-kilometre an all-electric plant that will be powered by
Pacific Trail Pipeline (PTP). hydroelectricity from BC Hydro. In July, the
proponents also proposed a third train for
• Regional economic benefits: At peak construction the project.
of the LNG facility, it is estimated that more than
3,000 people would be working on the Kitimat • More details: https://canada.chevron.com/our-
businesses/kitimat-lng-project
3. Woodfibre LNG
• Anticipated FIB: Summer 2019. In June 2019, Woodfibre said that BP Gas
Marketing Limited had agreed to buy 0.75 mtpa
• Anticipated onstream date: 2023. of LNG for 15 years starting in 2023.
• Associated infrastructure: The project will receive In May 2019, PO&G said it is acquiring all of the
natural gas from the Eagle Mountain – Woodfibre issued and outstanding shares of privately-held
Gas Pipeline (EGP) Project. Canbriam Energy Inc. and its Montney assets.
• Regional economic benefits: 650+ jobs at peak • More details: https://www.woodfibrelng.ca/
construction; 100+ jobs at Woodfibre site;
18
4. Goldboro LNG
19