Sei sulla pagina 1di 6

ADVANTAGES OF GRID-TIED DC MICROGRID

Marcello da S. Neves, Maynara A. Aredes, Hamidreza. Khezri, Elisa T. H. Ida, Maurício Aredes1
1
Electrical Engineering Department of Federal University of Rio de Janeiro, Cidade Universitária – Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
e-mail: marcello, maynara, hamid, elisa, aredes @lemt.ufrj.br

Abstract – The present work aims to investigate the Some of the advantages in the implementation of DC
advantages of the implementation of a grid-tied DC microgrid are [1] [2] [3]:
microgrid (MG), thus integrating several types of • higher efficiency and reduced losses due to the
distributed generation, DC loads and the AC power grid. reduction of multiple converters used for dc loads;
The distributed resources of the DC MG consist of a • easier integration of various dc DERs, such as
photovoltaic generation system in addition to a fuel cell energy storage, solar photovoltaic (PV), and fuel
generation unit. The control of the MG is performed in a cells, to the common bus with simplified interfaces;
decentralized manner, where each power converter • more efficient supply of dc loads, such as electric
connected to the DC bus performs certain features vehicles and LED lights;
without a communication channel. The DC MG studied • eliminating the need for synchronizing generators,
in this paper is able to operate in island mode and reject which enables rotary generating units to operate at
AC disturbances, by the implementation of an Energy their own optimum speed;
Storage System connected to the DC bus by a • enabling bus ties to be operated without the need for
bidirectional converter. Simulation results show the synchronizing the buses.
operation and viability of the aforementioned DC MG. These benefits, combined with the significant increase in
electrical vehicles research and dc loads such as personal
Keywords – DC microgrid, Fuel Cells, Grid-tied computers, laptop computers, LED lights, data and
microgrid, PV generation, bidirectional converter. telecommunication centers have been encouraging research
in DC microgrids.
On the other hand, the system integration of PV array, fuel
I. INTRODUCTION cell, and batteries has some difficulties and requires some
precautions: firstly, at least one of the converters must
A microgrid is a localized grouping of distributed energy guarantee DC bus voltage regulation in any mode of
resources, (including generation, storage devices and demand operation. Secondly, power generation steps or other types of
management) and loads that can operate with the main power disturbances can affect system stability. Finally, the designed
grid or while in island operation. DC microgrids are a new energy storage must contribute to system reliability and
way of interconnecting local power generation and loads, flexibility without discharging yourself completely. This
resulting in a more secure, sustainable and reliable power paper proposes a decentralized control strategy that covers
grid. these issues to optimize electrical operation in a 450 V DC
Local power generation, e.g. Distributed Generation (DG) level, in order to work with commercial AC transform-less
include solar photovoltaic (PV), small wind turbines, inverters.
combined heat and power (CHP), fuel cells, and micro- In section II the structure of a general DC microgrid, as
turbines. The amount of solar DG has increased significantly well as a brief description of the DC microgrid components
in the last years. Driving this exponential growth is the is given. In section III, to investigate the advantages of a
decrease in the price over the years of solar panels, and grid-tied DC microgrid, a simulation in PSCAD of a grid-
installation costs of residential and commercial PV units. tied DC microgrid is presented. Section IV concludes the
Moreover, as the other sources of power generation, solar paper and summarizes results.
energy provides numerous benefits and challenges. Potential
benefits of solar DG include avoided generation capacity II. GRID-TIED DC MICROGRID
costs (e.g., less need to build new generation), ancillary In the literature the advantages of AC, DC and hybrid
services (e.g., need for less back up power), and avoided microgrid have been widely discuss, [2] [3] [4]. Microgrid
transmission costs, as well as reduced air pollution and deployments are trusted to:
greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and mitigation against • improve power quality;
outages on the grid. However, DG poses many operational
• reduce emissions;
challenges to electric utilities. They include maintenance of
• reduce network congestion;
electric grid active power balance (DG’s power output may
vary significantly through the day), safety issues for line- • reduce power losses;
workers, load forecasting impairment (variable solar power • increase energy efficiency;
makes it harder to predict the need for generation), and • improve system economics;
increased strain on the distribution system. Solar panels, fuel • islanding capability in the event of faults or
cells, energy storage systems such as super capacitors or disturbances in upstream networks, enhancing
batteries, are DC devices. Therefore, DC microgrids have the grid and customers’ reliability and resilience.
potential to increase the system efficiency and will likely be Furthermore, extensive research has been conducted in the
part of future electrical power systems. operation and control of AC microgrids [5] [6].
Nevertheless, AC microgrids are associated to several describe the converters operation are summarize at follows
problems as the need for synchronization of the [8].
distributed generators, inrush currents due to
transformers, reactive-power flow, harmonic currents, and 1) Boost Converter: This power converter is a step-up
three-phase unbalances voltages, [7]. DC microgrids could, converter; the output voltage is always greater than the input
however, offer several advantages compared to AC voltage as shown in Equation 1, where the duty cycle varies
microgrids: providing a more efficiently supply of dc loads from 0 to 1.
by reducing losses due to the reduction of multiple
converters used for dc loads, easier integration of DC DERs,
and eliminating the need for synchronizing generators. ‹ ‘—–
In AC microgrids, DC generating units as well as energy
storage systems are connected to the AC bus via DC/AC
inverters, and further, AC/DC rectifiers are used for
supplying DC loads. In DC microgrids, however, the Fig. 3 Boost Converter.
common bus is DC, where AC/DC rectifiers are used for ଵ
connecting AC generating units, and DC/AC inverters are ܸை௎் ൌ ܸ (1)
ଵି஽ ூே
used for supplying AC loads. Presently, with the growing
installed capacity of solar energy and the extensive use of Where ܸை௎் is the output voltage, ܸூே is the input
DC loads, DC microgrids deployment would reduce the voltage and D is the converter duty cycle.
amount of AC/DC converters connected to the bus.
Therefore, decreasing the injection of harmonic currents 2) Buck Converter: This power converter is a step-down
cause by the switching action of the converters. converter; the output voltage is always smaller than the input
The grid-tied DC microgrid studied in this paper is shown voltage as shown in Equation 2.
in Fig. 1. It consists of a PV generation, fuel cell generation,
a storage unit, the utility grid, and DC loads. Both power
generations are connected to the DC bus through DC/DC ‹ ‘—–
converters. And the energy storage unit is composed of a
bank of batteries, connected to the DC bus also through a
DC/DC bidirectional converter. The utility grid is connected
to the DC bus through a three-phase bi-directional full-bridge Fig. 4 Buck Converter.
AC/DC converter. In this way, a brief introduction to general
ܸை௎் ൌ ‫ܦ‬Ǥ ܸூே (2)
DC microgrid components is given, as follows.

3) Bidirectional Converter: It is important to notice that


boost and buck converter are operate in a single quadrant of
the output voltage-current plane, thereby allowing power to
flow only in one direction. Thus, a bidirectional converter is
necessary for power flow regulation of the EMS [9]. This
converter as shown in Fig. 4, with a negative value of ݅௜௡ ,
and with ܵଵ and ‫ܦ‬ଶ operating, resembles a buck converter
where the power flow is from the output to the input circuits.
On the other hand, with a positive ݅௜௡ , and with ܵଶ and ‫ܦ‬ଵ
operating, it resembles a Boost converter where the power
flow is from the input to the output circuits.

B. DC/AC utility grid converter


A three-phase power converter is used for interfacing the
Fig. 1 Grid-Tied DC microgrid structure. power grid with the DC microgrid. Its control system is
responsible for the active power flow regulation between the
A. DC/DC converters utility grid and the DC microgrid through voltage regulation
It should be noted that different DC loads require different
DC voltage levels, and then some DC/DC converters have to
be considered as well in order to change the voltage level of
the DC sources to desired levels. Likewise, DC/DC ͳ

converters are employed for control issues such as
power/voltage regulation and Energy Management Storage ‹‹
‘—–
control. In this paper three types of DC/DC converters were
considered: boost, buck and bidirectional converter. All
‹ ʹ ʹ
converters main application is to regulate the output power
from the energies sources and/or regulate the DC bus
voltage. The equivalent circuits and the equations that
Fig. 2 Bidirectional Converter.
of the DC bus as depicted in Fig. 5. [10]. Nevertheless, it also
performances other control features such as ride-through
capability for grid disturbances and bi-directional power flow
capability to support charging of a DC energy store using
grid power.
As seen in the control system of Fig.5 the DC bus voltage
error (ܸ௥௘௙ െ ܸ௕௨௦ ) is the input of a PI controller, which Fig. 5. AC/DC power converter control system.
outputs the necessary active power (ܲ௥௘௙ ) for the voltage
regulation. By means of the Instantaneous Power Theory
[11], the reference current (‫ܫ‬௥௘௙ ) is calculated with the
fundamental component of the grid voltage (ܸଵା ) obtained by
a positive-sequence detector. The current control can be
implemented either by a hysteresis control, or by another PI
controller that outputs the voltage reference for the PWM
controller [12].

C. PV Source
Presently, PV generation is being encouraged to take part
in supplying household power systems. Nevertheless, PV
generation is an intermittent energy source due to its
dependency on solar irradiance and temperature. Hence, Fig. 6. PV power curves.
according to the climate conditions, different power curves
characterize the solar source and a unique point of operation
is able to extract the maximum power from the PV array,
called Maximum Power Point (MPP). As shown in Fig. 6,
the maximum power transfer can be guarantee by controlling
the applied voltage on the PV array.
In this way, Maximum Power Point Tracking (MPPT)
algorithms are applied to ensure the maximum output power Fig. 7. PV generation DC/DC converter control system.
from the solar source. These MPPTs techniques are easily
employed by the use of DC/DC converters aforementioned.
Thus, the solar source is connected to the DC bus through a
DC/DC converter in order to perform a MPPT algorithm and
match the PV voltage to the DC bus voltage. Thereby, the
PV source can be seen as a controlled current source, with an
intermittent characteristic since it depends on climate
conditions. Fig. 5. Fuel Cell DC/DC converter control system.
Fig. 7 shows a simple control system of a DC/DC
converter for PV generation deployment, where the MPPT fuel cells (AFCs), phosphoric acid fuel cells (PAFCs), proton
algorithm gives the reference voltage (ܸ௥௘௙ ) for the PI exchange membrane fuel cells (PEMFCs), molten carbonate
controller that outputs the desired duty cycle of the DC/DC fuel cells (MCFCs) and solid oxide fuel cells (SOFCs).
converter (‫ܦ‬௣௩ ). In further studies, the DC/DC converter Fuel cell power generation systems are generally
could also perform ancillary controls such as voltage connected to the DC with a DC/DC power converter, which
regulation of the DC bus. matches the output voltage of the generation unit to the bus
voltage [14]. The control system of the DC/DC converter is
D. Fuel Cell depicted in Fig. 8, where a PI controller is designed to
Fuel cells generation units are attractive mainly due to control the output power. Hence, considering a constant DC
their sustainable characteristics and their efficient bus voltage, the PI controller produces the duty cycle of the
performance, since it can operate at efficiencies greater than converter (‫ܦ‬ுଶ ) for the PWM controller by the error of the
traditional energy sources. Additionally, they are easily place reference current (‫ܫ‬௥௘௙ െ ‫ܫ‬ுଶ ), that is the error of the
at any site in a power system and do not depend on reference power.
meteorological variables as PV sources [13] [14].
Fuel cells are electro-chemical devices, which convert the E. Energy Storage System (ESS)
chemical energy of a gaseous fuel directly into electricity. In Energy storage systems guarantee system reliability and
fuel cells, a chemical reaction takes place to convert stability in case of utility grid’s blackouts. Even more, ESS’s
hydrogen and oxygen into water, releasing electrons in the can attenuate power system mismatches between generation
process. In other words, the hydrogen fuel is burnt in a and the consumption in to the DC microgrid. These systems
reaction to produce electric current and water. The several can be categorized based on power density, energy density,
types of fuel cells are generally classified according to their ramp rate, life cycle. In this scenario, Batteries still have
electrolyte. There are many types of fuel cell such as alkaline been the most rentable and available way to install an ESS in
electrical systems. In the microgrid showed in this paper, the stability analysis. At the moment that the AC grid is
ESS is composed of a bank of batteries, connected to the DC disconnected by a blackout or by a fault, the ESS must act
bus through a bidirectional converter. and replace the function of the DC/AC converter, in the
Is important to notice that the maximum capability of the steady state. In island mode, the moment of the utility grid
battery bank is generally greater than nominal, as the battery restoring is critical, since the DC/AC converter must be
must attenuate power mismatch in the microgrid. When the synchronized with the network to re-operate as a bus voltage
utility grid is not connected, the converter that controls the regulator. The synchronization process is done by detecting
DC bus will not work properly due to the current flow the positive sequence of the AC grid, allowing the DC/AC
impossibility. Then, the ESS must be able to do this task converter to interconnect the DC microgrid. The situations
during the autonomous mode operation. The control system described above will be analyzed in the following section.
of the ESS is shown in Fig. 9, where the output variable is
the converter duty cycle (‫ܦ‬௘௦௦ ). III. SIMULATION RESULTS

The main characteristics of the simulated DC microgrid in


PSCAD are given in Table I. Both solar source and fuel cell
generation units are connected to the DC bus through a boost
converter in order to adjust the output voltages to the DC bus
voltage. The Boost converter of the PV generation also
(a) performs a MPPT algorithm to guarantee the maximum
power transfer from the solar source.
The capacity of the battery bank is designed to supply the
rated load for up to 6 hours when the DC microgrid is
working in autonomous mode. However, the battery must
attenuate power mismatch in the microgrid, thus the
maximum capability of the battery bank is about 15% greater
than nominal. Therefore, the nominal capability (ܳ௡௢௠ ) is
(b) given by the nominal battery current (‫ܫ‬௕௔௧ ௡௢௠
) and the
Fig. 9 (a) – ESS control in autonomous mode (a), and in stand-by discharge time (‫ݐ‬௕௔௧ ) as follows:
mode (b).
௡௢௠
ܳ௡௢௠ ൌ ‫ܫ‬௕௔௧ Ǥ ‫ݐ‬௕௔௧ ൌ ͷͲͲ‫ܣ‬Ǥ ݄ (3)
In islanded mode, the ESS controls the DC bus voltage
(ܸ௕௨௦ ) and the battery output current (‫ܫ‬௕௔௧௧ ) through a
It is important to notice that small filters are necessary to
cascade structure. When connection with the utility grid is
connect the power converters of the DC sources to the DC
restored, the control operates in stand-by mode and starts a
bus due to the switching action, and thus smoothing high
charging process, which depends on state of charge (SoC) of
frequency currents.
the battery bank. The reference current (‫ܫ‬௥௘௙ ) is determined
In the simulation, three different models represented a
by the difference between the nominal SoC and the actual variety of DC loads: pure resistance, constant current source,
estimated SoC (ܵ‫ ܥ݋‬െ ܵ‫ܥ݋‬௡௢௠ ). The model of battery and and controlled current source with constant power. In this
the SoC estimation adopted in this paper follows the way, linear and nonlinear loads are present in the simulation
methodology shown in [15]. The electrical dynamics of the in such a way that part of the load power depends on the bus
battery bank model has large time constants. However, the voltage and transient power loads can affect the bus voltage.
operating SoC point is relevant for the charging current. The
charge current dynamics and effects will be shown in section TABLE I
III. DC Microgrid Characteristics
DC Bus 450 V
F. Stability of DC microgrid AC Bus 380 V
PV Generation Array type: 8 series modules; 6 parallel
The main task of controllers in terms of stability is to strings
keep the DC bus voltage constant and at its nominal value in PMAX = 11,76kW
any mode of operation. In addition, the micro-grid must also VMPP = 241,6 V
remain stable in the presence of abrupt power disturbances IMPP = 48,66 A
VOC = 302,4 V
from the generating units or loads, which may occur ISC = 51,78 A
frequently in the system. To represent the most relevant types Fuel Cell 180 fuel cells
of loads connected to the DC bus, like DC buck converters or PMAX = 10,0kW
passive elements and other insensible loads, the total load of Vfuel cell = 1.28 V
VOUT = 230.4 v
the DC microgrid was shared in three types: a constant Array type: 15 series batteries; 5 parallel
Energy Storage
impedance load, a constant current load, and a constant strings
power load. In this case, the DC/AC and the ESS converters QNOM = 500 Ah
control the bus voltage and ensure the stability of the QMAX = 580 Ah
INOM= 83,3 A
microgrid. VNOM = 240 V
Therefore, the transients between modes of operation or
failures occurred in these converters are determinant for the
A. Power Flow analysis and island mode operation B. Utility grid restoring
The first subject verified in the simulations results was One important and salient feature of microgrids that
the power flow between converters connected in the DC increases the reliability is their islanding capability which
microgrid bus and the interaction between converters and allows microgrids to be disconnected from the main grid in
loads during island mode operation. the presence of faults, disturbances, or voltage fluctuations in
Fig. 10 and Fig. 11 show the power flow and the voltage the AC power system. However, if after disconnecting from
at the DC bus, respectively. The simulation starts with the the main grid, the microgrid could not supply all the loads,
DC microgrid connected to the utility grid. Then, in 3 some loads should be curtailed, but critical loads will still be
seconds, the DC microgrid is disconnected from the power supplied.
grid and starts operating in island mode. In this way, the ESS The figures below show the case when the microgrid is
is responsible for regulating the DC bus voltage and working in autonomous mode for several hours, and then the
attenuate power mismatches between DC sources and load. utility grid is restored. The DC bus voltage is shown in Fig.
As can be seen in Fig. 10, the transient voltage overshoot is 12 and the DC bus input powers are shown in Fig. 13.
less than 5% and reaches steady state in 0.7s, approximately. V cc
However, the transient at the time of disconnection depends
on the magnitude of the power mismatch. Nevertheless, the
ESS could be used for reducing the power mismatch, and 0.460

thus improving voltage transient in islanding occurrences. In


the event where the battery bank exceeds its nominal current 0.440
limits, if the generated power is greater than the load power,
overvoltage can occur at the DC bus and undervoltage
0.420
otherwise.
In the moment of the disconnection, the generated power
is greater than the load power in 2,5kW, as seen in Fig. 11. 0.400
sec
Thus, the ESS takes the surplus power and the battery bank is 3.50 3.75 4.00 4.25 4.50 4.75 5.00 5.25 5.50

charged. Afterwards, from 6 seconds until the end of the Fig. 12: DC bus in utility grid restoring.
simulation, the PV generation varies in such a way that the
generated power from the DC sources is not enough for 10.0
P grid P fuel cell P pv P load P ES

supplying the DC loads. Thereby, the ESS provides the


necessary energy. 5.0

Vcc
0.0

0.480
-5.0

0.460
-10.0

0.440
-15.0
sec 3.50 3.75 4.00 4.25 4.50 4.75 5.00 5.25 5.50
0.420

Fig. 13: DC bus powers in grid restoring.


0.400
sec 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 6.0 7.0 8.0 9.0 10.0 The utility grid is restored at 4 seconds. Then, the ESS
Fig. 10: DC bus voltage in island mode operation under PV power control system starts the recharging process, at 4.5 seconds.
variations. In this manner, the ESS control is able to smooth the
transient power/voltage as can be seen in Fig 12 and Fig. 13,
P grid P fuel cell P pv P load P ES
15.0 where the voltage overshoot is less than 10% at moment of
10.0
connection, less than 6% after the ESS control is switched to
stand-by mode.
5.0

0.0
C. AC Faults and Disturbances
In order to investigate possible disturbances caused by
-5.0
AC faults, a three-phase fault was simulated at the AC side
-10.0 of the AC/DC converter. The fault occurs in at 3 seconds,
lasting for 500 milliseconds. As can be seen in Fig. 14,
-15.0
during the fault occurrence, there is a transient voltage with a
-20.0 nonlinearity characteristic due to the nonlinear loads and
sec 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 6.0 7.0 8.0 9.0 10.0
interaction between DC/DC power converters. However, the
Fig. 11: DC bus powers in island mode operation under PV power EES control contributes to the DC bus power/voltage
variations. regulation as in the islanding occurrence. Therefore, the DC
microgrid is able to continuously supply the DC loads and
take advantage of the DERs generated power even in the Control Concept for Grid-Tied and Autonomous DC
event of AC faults, and the is rapidly restored. Microgrids,” em 2015 IEEE International
During the fault occurrence, the ESS contributes to Telecommunications Energy Conference (INTELEC),
regulate the DC bus importing power to the DC microgrid. 2015.
When the fault is over, the DC microgrid comes back to the [4] A. G. Tsikalakis e N. D. Hatziargyriou, “Centralized
same state that it was before. Control for Optimizing Microgrids Operation,” em
Vcc
2011 IEEE Power and Energy Society General
0.500
Meeting, 2011.
0.480 [5] P. Piagi e R. H. Lasseter, “Autonomous Control of
0.460
Microgrids,” em 2006 IEEE Power Engineering
0.440
Society General Meeting, 2006.
0.420 [6] J. Rocabert, A. Luna, F. Blaabjerg e P. Rodríguez,
0.400
“Control of Power Converters in AC Microgrids,”
0.380
IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics, vol. 27, n.
11, pp. 4734 - 4749, 2012.
0.360
[7] J. M. Guerrero, J. C. Vasquez, J. Matas, L. G. de
sec 4.50 5.00 5.50 6.00 6.50 7.00
Vicuña e M. Castilla, “Hierarchical Control of Droop-
Fig. 14: DC bus voltage during AC three-phase fault. Controlled AC and DC Microgrids—A General
Approach Toward Standardization,” IEEE
P grid P fuel cell P pv P load P ES
15.0 Transactions on Industrial Electronics, vol. 58, n. 1,
10.0 pp. 158 - 172, 2011.
5.0 [8] N. Mohan, T. M. Undeland e W. P. Robbins, Power
0.0 Electronis: converters, applications, and design,
-5.0
Second ed., New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1995.
-10.0
[9] P. Garcia, L. M. Fernandez, C. A. Garcia e F. Jurado,
-15.0
“Energy Management System of Fuel-Cell-Battery
Hybrid Tramway,” IEEE Transactions on Industrial
-20.0
Electronis, vol. 57, n. 12, pp. 4013 - 4023, 2010.
-25.0
sec
[10] M. A. Aredes, B. W. França, L. G. B. Rolim e M.
4.50 5.00 5.50 6.00 6.50 7.00
Aredes, “P&O method controls applied to grid
Fig. 15: DC bus powers during AC three-phase fault. connected PV systems,” em 2015 IEEE 24th
International Symposium on Industrial Electronics
(ISIE), 2015.
IV. CONCLUSION
[11] H. a. W. E. a. A. M. Akagi, Instantaneous Power
In this paper, a DC microgrid with two different Theory and Applications to Power Conditioning,
renewable energy generation and an Energy Storage System Wiley, 2007.
was implemented. The present decentralized control strategy [12] L. Malesani e P. Tomasin, “PWM Current Control
was able to guarantee DC voltage bus regulation and manage Techniques of Voltage Source Converters - A Survey,”
the power flow inside the DC microgrid. Thus, the energy em International Conference on Industrial Electronics,
storage control allows the island mode operation and Control, and Instrumentation (IECON'93), 1993.
enhances the reliability and flexibility of the system. [13] S. Fedakar, S. Bahceci e T. Yalcinoz, “Modeling and
Simulation results have validated the effectiveness of the simulation of grid connected solid oxide fuel cell using
proposed DC microgrid. PSCAD,” em Eurocon 2013, 2013.
REFERENCES [14] A. A. Salam, M. A. Hannan e A. Mohamed, “Dynamic
Modeling and Simulation of Solid Oxide Fuel Cell
System,” em 2008 IEEE 2nd International Power and
[1] H. Lofti e A. Khodaei, “AC Versus DC Microgrid Energy Conference, 2008.
Planning,” IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid, vol. 8, n. [15] O. Tremblay, L.-A. Dessaint e A.-I. Dekkiche, “A
1, pp. 296 - 304, 2017. Generic Battery Model for the Dynamic Simulation of
[2] J. M. Guerrero, M. Chandorkar, T.-L. Lee e P. C. Loh, Hybrid Electric Vehicles,” em 2007 IEEE Vehicle
“Advanced Control Architectures for Intelligent Power and Propulsion Conference, 2007.
Microgrids—Part I: Decentralized and Hierarchical
Control,” IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics,
vol. 60, n. 4, pp. 1254 - 1262, 2013.
[3] L. Ott, Y. Han, B. Wunder, J. Kaiser, F. Fersterra, M.
Schulz e M. März, “An Advanced Voltage Droop

Potrebbero piacerti anche