Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
face up.
Card 1: O
Card 2: F
Card 3: <BLANK>
Card 4: O, D
Card 5: F, I, O
Card 6: <BLANK>,A, F
Card 7: S, H, M(1), <BLANK>
Card 8: P, E, M(2), C
Card 9: A, O, L
Card 10: D, R, N, U
Card 11: E, T, D, B
Card 12: S
M(1) and M(2) are each part of a M, M is special- it do not fit to just one half card, therefore it takes two
cards, as you can see on
These 12 cards needs to be printed so all 4 parts have text on them- but we do not at any time see all
cards- he can easily hide 12 cards in that deck.
Now we have calculated he can spell OF CLUBS,OF DIAMONDS,OF HEARTS and OF SPADES with
just 12 cards depending on how he lay them out- what about the other part?
ACE
TWO
THREE
FOUR
FIVE
SIX
SEVEN
EIGHT
NINE
TEN
JACK
KING
QUEEN
we know for sure that he needs to show at least three cards( shortest word length), so three cards can
have all 4 parts printed on. The rest needs to have one blank part to show.
To spell a word he take a specific set of cards, and choose the correct side to have upwards, and the
correct way to flip them.
To not waste cards, it makes sence to group them into words with the same length.
Card 1:S,T,A
Card 2:I,W,C
Card 3:X,O,E
FOUR,FIVE,NINE
Card 1:N,F,F
Card 2:I,O,I
Card 3:N,U,V
Card 4:E,R,E
Five letter words:
THREE,SEVEN,EIGHT
Card 1:E,S,T
Card 2:I,E,H
Card 3:G,V,R
Card 4:H,E,E
Card 5:T,N,E
TEN,KING,JACK
Card 1:K,J,T
Card 2:I,A,E
Card 3:N,C,N
Card 4:G,K,
Card 1:Q
Card 2:U
Card 3:E
Card 4:E
Card 5:N
so with 21 cards it is possible to spell all needed combinations just be selecting a specific set and
selecting the correct direction And if i spended a bit more time on it I could do it much better.
Perhaps he even only used one side of the cards? I bet it is possible
The weird cards in the deck are markers, so he know what set of cards to select, then he remembers what
way he should flip them to spell what he wants.
A basic example: He wants to spell SIX, so he graps the set that spell ACE, TWO or SIX:
Card 1:
-------- --------
| | | |
|A T| other side |S |
|______| |______|
Card 2:
-------- --------
| | | |
|C W| other side |I |
|______| |______|
Card 3:
-------- --------
| | | |
|E O| other side |X |
|______| |______|
He turns the side to the right in the image up, only revealing S,I and X
In that way he can spell any word, by just selecting the right set and what direction to turn them because
the set is prearranged so the sets spells words
5
jonasLyk
•
656d, 12h
This may contain many errors, and I am on my way to bed, but i scribbled an idea down.
I think it is possible to make a deck of cards where the marker cards are not needed.
They require you to be quite good at counting how many cards you lift, but arent magicians that?
With some minor adjustments I can make make it work even if the stack lifting is off with 2 cards in
either way.
You would just need to memorise this easy algorithm to choose what you want the cards to spell.
Convert the card to an integer, subtract 1, divide that with 3, multiply with 5.
Now you dig 10 cards into the stack, grab five cards.
Use this rotate table:
0=Do nothing
1=rotate 180 degree
2=Flip
Now you have the word EIGHT in your hand, place it where you want it to end.
Now split the stack at ~ card 27, use this rotate table:
Nothing=OF HEARTS
80 degree=OF CLUBS
Flip=OF DIAMONDS
Flip and rotate 80 degree= OF SPADES
4
jonasLyk
•
656d, 11h
Side A Side B
Perhaps I could even make the trick work with only one side of each card? Would require some tricks
though....
tomorrow perhaps?
3
Scamwau
•
656d, 14h
How do you know this? Are you a magician or did you just figure this out by watching the video? If so,
you are fucking awesome.
2
jonasLyk
•
656d, 14h
So I coded a small program to help me think about the problem, and then things started lining up....
I am already thinking about how I could make an algorhitmn that would make the trick possible without
marker cards....I think it is possible :)
3
Motanum
•
656d, 11h
So, magic?
1
gordonisnext
•
656d, 11h
Now you just need to buy the trick to see if youre right
1
[deleted]
•
656d, 13h
Yes Pen and Teller couldn't figure this out but you did!
Chris101b
•
657d, 2h
/comments/2dltip/brilliant_magic_trick_performed_by_matthieu_bich/cjqvkpk
I'm not sure what to think of this one. First off, I have to say that it is an amazing trick. It is performed
well, and the idea behind it is sound. I think that Penn and Teller knew how the trick was done, but opted
to give an explanation that was false in order to allow him into the next round (Since the trick really was
amazing). Personally I believe that he has a sort of "algorithm" in mind once he takes the cards out of
the deck. The cards are mixed in a way that while he is taking the "Your card is" cards out of the deck,
he is cutting, flipping, and rearranging the cards in his hand in order to put the cards in the correct order
so that when he spreads them out, they spell out the card. If you were to inspect the other cards, I think
you would find black marks on the underside of them that would have allowed him to spell out any card
in the deck. But it is this "algorithm" that allows him to shuffle it into the correct sequence. But I'm still
glad he made it through. I'm just wondering if Penn and Teller let him through on purpose.
96
WilliamHealy
•
657d, 2h
Also has to do with the spacing of certain cards. You can see the D on the right and left are different.
One is using 2 cards the other 1. The one on the right, would be used in the word Spades as well. The S
at the end is always there.
31
jonasLyk
•
656d, 22h
I think you are right, I did a quick program to find the needed letters to spell every card.
The next step is then to draw them, and find out what letter "building stones" are required on the cards to
create those letters.
Remember, the card can have one half that can be used to create one letter, and another half to create
another. The cards can also be flipped vertically.
string allWords =
"ONETWOTHREEFOURFIVESIXSEVENEIGHTNINETENOFDIAMONDSSPACEHEARTSSPADESCLUBS";
string uniqueCharacters = "";
for (char currChar : allWords)
{
if (uniqueCharacters.find(currChar) == string::npos)
{
uniqueCharacters += currChar;
}
}
cout << "Unique characters is:" << endl << uniqueCharacters << endl << endl;
system("pause");
28
jonasLyk
•
656d, 22h
I took the letters, and splitted them in half, some letters I bet could be splitted a better place, to make
them form other letters.
20
jonasLyk
•
656d, 21h
I drawed a red line between the most obvius duplicates(Half letters that already exists, or can be made
by flipping another)
I am sure there are other shortcuts, or ways to cut the letters up- but these where what i found in 1
minute. And i am pretty sure I made some mistakes, but this is just to test the concept.
If we then remove the duplicates we end up with an "alphabet" looking like this:
22 building blocks, and there can be two building blocks on each card, so 11 cards.
All those cards that are only shown half when he lays them out can also contain a letter building block
on the haft that is not shown.
And perhaps there is letter building blocks on the other side of the cards?
I think he have arranged the deck very cleverly, so if he wants to create the word "NINE", he knows
exactly where to lift the cardstack, and place on top.
If you look are the word "DIAMONDS", there is no I, but he have one in NINE, so I think he needed to
compromise in some of the prearranged card end position, to make hes stacking algorhitmn work.
10
PoisonousPlatypus
1
•
656d, 16h
I drawed
15
yzlautum
•
656d, 13h
2
jonasLyk
•
656d, 20h
So, he can actually make all four diffent required letters in that position to spell "CLUBS",
"DIAMONDS", "HEARTS" and "SPADES"
If we take the last D letter in diamonds (before the s), it could have been 4 different letters depending on
what class he was trying to spell.
Card 1:D
Card 2:I
Card 3:SHA
Card 4:PEMC
Card 5:AOL
Card 6:DRNU
Card 7:ETDB
Card 8:S
arranged in a way, so it spells DIAMONDS, then if he covers the other half of the cards it says
HEARTS, if he then flips it around it says CLUBS, and if he then cover the other half it says SPADES.
10
jonasLyk
•
656d, 19h
So, by having the following printed on the cards he can spell out
OF CLUBS
OF DIAMONDS
OF HEARTS
OF SPADES
Card 1:O
Card 2:F
Card 3:<BLANK>
Card 4:O,D
Card 5:F,I,O
Card 6:<BLANK>,A,F
Card 7:S,H,M(1),<BLANK>
Card 8:P,E,M(2),C
Card 9:A,O,L
Card 10:D,R,N,U
Card 11:E,T,D,B
Card 12:S
Only by choosing what side to have up, and what direction to flip over the cards.
7
o0Ax0o
•
656d, 16h
amazing!
2
Brewster-Rooster
•
656d, 17h
But they can't be two sided like that. he layed out all of the cards at the start, and at least half of one side
of every card was blank
2
jonasLyk
•
656d, 17h
The rest of them requires a blank half though- but as my calculations in my new post show- it is
possible.
2
Superguy2876
•
656d, 22h
Almost, "one" is supposed to be "ace" and you're missing "jack", "queen", and "king".
2
jonasLyk
•
656d, 21h
3
C2BE62DE
•
656d, 15h
#include <algorithm>
#include <iostream>
#include <string>
int main() {
std::string allWords =
"ONETWOTHREEFOURFIVESIXSEVENEIGHTNINETENOFDIAMONDSSPACEHEARTSSPADESCLUBS";
std::cout << unique_letters(allWords) << std::endl;
}
1
Niacain
•
656d, 23h
You know you could just buy the trick on his website and get certainty...
Also the rules of the show don't really allow them to change their theory as then it would be impossible
to fool them. They'd just have to guess their way through.
7
noxville
•
656d, 18h
There's no "next round", if you fool them you go to Vegas with them.
He used what's called the "Spreadwave Deck", which as you allude to allows you to algorithmically
shuffle the deck to say anything you want.
6
cwcriner
•
656d, 14h
considering that this is the guy who created the Spreadwave Trick, yes that's what he does.
6
noxville
•
656d, 13h
Yeah, I'm aware it was him who made it (there was a cool Youtube video on him).
1
Chris101b
•
656d, 15h
That's what I meant. I am surprised that Penn and Teller would say that there were multiple decks in the
box or that the box was important somehow, when it's fairly easy to see what he did. My theory is that
they loved the idea and the presentation of the trick so much, they gave an incorrect guess on purpose so
that he could go to Hollywood with them.
2
noxville
•
656d, 15h
From what I recall watching the show, they're only allowed one guess (and a lot of the contestants who
got through did so by making more obvious (wrong) hints at how they did it).
The most likely way he could have done it was several decks, each with only a few moves, or one deck
with lots of more complicated shuffles - it makes more sense to have a few decks.
Also, I think Bich made the deck up himself, so can catch them by surprise ^
3
Chris101b
•
656d, 15h
The reason he got through was because Penn and Teller said that the box was important and that he had
multiple decks in it. Which is what surprised them when he showed them that they were wrong. I think
multiple decks would have been easier, but it also would have been more likely to be discovered by
Penn and Teller. I'm pretty sure only one deck was used.
1
noxville
•
656d, 14h
It was a single deck, the trick has been reveled. The box being important was a bait by him.
5
DaddyF4tS4ck
•
656d, 16h
Yes, but what you have is a guess. Penn and Teller get 1 guess. Even still, it's not like you have good
proof of it, like Penn and Teller do of all the other tricks they were not 'fooled' on.
Just saying, I don't think Penn and Teller let him pass on purpose. There were other really good acts, that
Penn and Teller saw which they didn't let pass.
4
ThisBetterBeWorthIt
•
656d, 17h
Yep it's all to do with the rotation and orientation of the blocks of cards before, after and in between the
3 cards with words on them. You can watch him (and others who have done this trick) rotate and flip the
blocks of cards. I am almost certain that all you have to do is know exactly how to align the cards for
each number and suit.
2
Buzzard
•
656d, 15h
The trick is called Spreadwave and you're right about how the cards work, except I don't believe they are
marked. IIRC you need to memorise the algorithms to reorder the deck to spell out each card. The cards
are arranged quite cleverly ("Your", "Card", "Is The" are markers) and there is only a few operations to
get to each one.
It's a very cool trick and you can see that a lot of work went into constructing the deck.
2
riptide747
•
656d, 15h
The ball seems insignificant, but largely helps with this explanation. By using a red ball, he's subtly
forcing a red card to be chosen, cutting his choices of cards to spell in half.
1
Chris101b
•
656d, 15h
Eh I'd be nervous with that. If he only had enough cards in the deck to spell out "Red" cards, then he
would be completely screwed if someone said "Black". It would then make it impossible for him to
shuffle the cards into anything even remotely correct since he wouldn't be able to get the color or the
suite right. I think the cards could be typed out in a way that would allow him to shuffle the deck into
any order he wants. Someone said above that it is called a Spreadwave.
3
Gfresh404
•
656d, 13h
Fairly certain you're right. I'm not sure Penn and Teller really new that right away though. Remember
they only have about 60 seconds to solve each problem. I can't provide the link now since I'm on mobile
but you can literally buy this trick and everything required to preform for about $40 online
1
ThexAntipop
•
656d, 10h
1
Chris101b
•
656d, 9h
Doubt it, that is the whole point of the ball. He could never assure that the people that he wanted to get
the ball WOULD get the ball. It was there just to show that the card chosen was truly random. And like
many people have stated, you can go online and buy this trip relatively cheap. The trick is in how he
shuffled the cards while removing the 3 text cards.
2
Sentence55
•
656d, 7h
I think your right. I also think there is no way Penn and Teller got fooled by this. However, I hope they
were because that would really ruin the point of the show.
3
The_Dacca
•
656d, 20h
It was a good trick, but the best part of the presentation was Teller's reaction to his 'no' reveal.
12
ArchDucky
•
656d, 17h
Thats because Teller is the magician. If you watch this show, he figures out 98% of the tricks with Penn
basically being stumped them whole time. I've seen them live, Teller is fantastic.