Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
North-HoIIand, Amsterdam
Hydrogen-permeation behaviors of 316L stainless steel, Inconel 600, Inconel 750, Nimonic 80A and Hastelloy X at 873
K-1173 K have been investigated under a pressure range of 0.1 MPa-0.7 MPa by using a gas-flow system. Measurements have
been carried out by use of a helium-carrier-gas method. It has been proved that this method is good for examining
transient-~rmeation behaviors as well as steady-state permeation if the instruments time-lag is taken into account. ~ffusivity
and soiubility of hydrogen for the alloys are derived from the transient and steady-state permeation. The y’-precipitation
strengthened alloys - inconel 750 and Nimonic 80A - show a larger activation energy of diffusion and a smaller solution heat
than the other nickel-base alloys. This result is ascribed to the trapping effect due to titanium in the former alloys, i.e. solute
titanium atoms and/or y’-precipitations.
2.1. Apparatus
Hydrogen permeation has been measured with a negligibly low in comparison to the supplied hydrogen
hollow-cylindrical specimen by using a gas-flow system. pressure under the helium flow-rate condition used.
A block diagram of the experimental system is shown in An advantage of this apparatus is a high stability
fig. 1 and the shape of the specimen is in fig. 2. due to the use of the gas-flow system and the gas-mass
Hydrogen is supplied at a flowrate of lo3 Ncc/min spectrometer. But, the response of the hydrogen detec-
(NCC = cm3 at N.T.P.) outside of the specimen in a tion is poor in comparison with conventional vacuum-
furnace. Helium gas (ultra-purity grade) is furthermore extraction methods, because it takes a fairly long time
purified just before entering the furnace and introduced for the hydrogen to flow from the specimen to the
inside of the specimen at 1100 Ncc/min (including detector. However, this drawback has been overcome by
sampling gas of 100 Ncc/min). Linear flow-velocity using a samphng duct of small volume (l/8 inch 304
along the specimen surface is 0.95 cm/s for hydrogen stainless-steel tube) and by checking the response be-
and 4.1 cm/s for helium gas. The dewpoint at the outlet havior of the system. In order to examine the response
of the furnace is < -7OOC for hydrogen and - -75°C of the system, we utilized a step-functional hydrogen-
for helium gas (0, (: 0.1 ppm). drive at the specimen position and observed the re-
Hydrogen which has permeated through the metal sponse of the detector. The step-functional signal was
wall is carried by the helium gas and detected by a generated by on-off operation of a gas-sampling valve
quadrupole mass-filter combined with a gaschromato- which was located at the outlet tube of the specimen.
graph. Calibration of the detector was made with either We generated the signal also by switching the
a dilution flask or a standard gas (323 ppm H, + He). hydrogen-supply pressure at the front surface of the 0.5
Partial pressure of hydrogen inside the specimen was mm-thick Ni specimen (at 1273 K), where the signal
Fig. 1. Block diagram of the experimental system. An argon sealing is employed outside Of the furnace for safety. Pumps are used for
pre-evacuation.
N. Kishimoto et al. / Hydrogen diffusion at high temperatures 3
2.2. Specimen
Table 1
Chemical composition of alloys used
C Si Mn Ni Cr Iyo Cu Al Ti Fe others
SUS 316L 0.029 0.49 1.72 12.7 16.6 2.14 0.27 Eal.
Inconel 600 0,047 0.25 0.45 Bal. 15.9 0.20 0.32 0.41 7001
Inconel 750 0.04 0,08 0,20 Bal, 15.3 0.04 0.57 2.52 7.04 Nb+Ta:O.94
Nimonic 80A 0,051 0.08 0.05 Bal, 19.3 0.01 1035 2.28 .1,02 Co:O.71
HastelloY X 0,lO 0.14 0.15 Bal, 20,7 8.86 0,Ol 19,7 W:O.48,Co:1.6
4 N. Kishimoto et al. / Hydrogen diffusion at high temperatures
I
Inceoet 600
a5$
SUS 316L
Inconet 600
Incortel750
Nimonic 6OA
liostetloy x
_ 1.0
Fig. 5. Permeation rate at 0.2 MPa and diffusivity plotted
$1 against reciprocal temperature.
d
X0.5 diffusion time corresponding to the half-height value of
B
:: the variation of the permeation, lb, by using a relation
for the master curve:
i4
-0 Dt,,/L* = 0.139, (12)
Q= DSp’j2, (14)
Table 2
Power index of pressure dependence of Q in the relation of Q cx p”. Deviation of the data from the relation corresponds to
An=f0.002.
1073 K
1173 K I 0.40
0.47 0,44
a,50 0.45
0.51 0.44
0.49 O-43
0.42 I
Table 3
Activation energy and pre-exponential terms of permeability. diffusivity and solubility. Experimental errors (or deviation of fitting)
are + 3% for J, D and S and t-O.01 eV for activation energies.
Jo (l~cc~mm/cm* hr MPcI~/') 7.1 x 103 6.4 x 103 8&l x I03 8.1 x IO3 7.2 x lo3
Do icm*/sec) 1.3 x 10-2 4.9 x 10-3 1.6 x lo-' 1.4 x 10-2 4.9 x 10-3
smaller for the former than the latter, while the values Quantitative discussion of the permeation rate among
of ES (a half of the molar heat of solution) are larger for alloy species is difficult particularly for the multi-ele-
the former than the latter. ment commercial alloys, in comparison with binary
alloys [lO,ll] where simple relations between the per-
meation rate and the composition are observed. Here,
5. Discussion we should rather recognize a considerable similarity in
the magnitudes of the permeation rate not only among
5. I. Carrier-gas method the nickel-base alloys but also between. nickel-base al-
loys and stainless steels. Such a similarity between
Prior to the discussion on the permeation data. we nickel-base alloys and stainless steels has been observed
mention the feasibility of the experimental method used. to date [l-6]. Moreover, there are similarities in solubil-
It may be emphasized that the helium-carrier-gas method ity and diffusivity among the nickel-base alloys and the
would be useful also for transient-permeation measure- 316L stainless steel. The similarity of the values is rather
ments so far as the diffusion time of the specimen (i.e. surprising, because there are considerable differences in
- L2/O) is much larger than the blunted time of the the amounts of the major elements Ni and Fe (see table
hydrogen-detection system. 1). It is thus considered that Fe may not have a drasti-
By virtue of the cylindrical specimen and the gas-flow cally different effect on the permeation from Ni in the
system, a high efficiency of hydrogen ventilation and a y-phase alloys.
low dewpoint of hydrogen were attained. The problem We would be able to compare the two groups of
is this kind of a long pass between the specimen and the { Inconel 600, Hastelloy X} and { Inconel 750, Nimonic
hydrogen detector, which makes it difficult to determine 80A} with each other, since each group possesses a
the accurate hydrogen amount at the specimen position. common feature for the values of E, and Es. Note that
In order to overcome this difficulty and to make the the difference in chemical composition between Inconel
best use of the helium-carrier-gas method, two im- 600 and Inconel 750 is only the amount of Ti and also
portant requirements should be satisfied, (i) high purity that Nimonic 80A includes a considerable amount of Ti
(and flow-rate) and (ii) large linear velocity of the as well as Inconel 750. So, the difference in activation
carrier gas. The equilibrium oxygen-potential of the energies between the two groups may be ascribed to the
helium gas might be larger than that of the “vacuum” difference in the amount of Ti in the alloys.
usually obtained by pumping (e.g. 0.1 ppm Hz0 - 10e4 A schematic potential curve for a hydrogen atom in
Torr), but, empirically, helium gas with a dewpoint of the metal phase is illustrated in fig. 7, where the activa-
-75°C and a flow-rate of 1100 Ncc/min was satisfac-
tory to avoid surface oxidation of the specimens. As for
the linear velocity, we have to set a considerably large E (eV)
velocity so that the transIationa1 motion of the carrier HW-,,
Gas \ Surface Metal
gas is much faster than the intra-diffusion of hydrogen ‘. t
in the carrier gas, since, otherwise, the intra-diffusion
might influence the transient permeation. It seemed that
a helium linear velocity of 4 cm/s and a sampling rate
of 100 Ncc/min would be roughly minimum values for
the present specimens (- L2/D) in the temperature
range of Tc 1173 K.
H,I Z-
5.2. Hydrogen diffusion and solution (9)
tion energies listed in table 3 together with an available peratures are described by a bulk-diffusion process of
value of adsorption energy for Ni or Fe - 0.65 eV [12] hydrogen.
are used. A solid line indicates a case of Inconel 600 (2) Permeation rates follow the Sieverts’ law, and
and Hastelloy X, and dot-dash lines show a modifica- hydrogen diffuses through the alloys in the form of
tion of the potential curve fitted to Inconel 750 and monoatoms.
Nimonic 80A. The 316L stainless steel belongs to the (3) The nickel-base alloys and 316L stainless steel
latter case. For Inconel750 and Nimonic 80A as well as have close magnitudes of pre-exponential terms and
316L stainless steel, the lattice potential well is deeper activation energy of permeability to one another, in
than for the other alloys. On the other hand, the peak spite of a variety of the chemical composition.
height of the potential curve is unchanged between the (4) 316L stainless steel, Inconel 750 and Nimonic
alloys, since they have the same magnitude of E,. Thus, 80A show a larger activation energy of diffusivity and a
this schematic diagram well represents the data of E,, smaller heat of solution than Inconel 600 and Hastelloy
E, and Es for the alloys, that is, Inconel 750 and X.
Nimonic 80A which contain a larger amount of Ti as (5) The difference in activation energies among the
compared to the other alloys have larger values of E, nickel-base alloys is ascribed to the effect of Ti.
and smaller Es. They are both y’-precipitation
strengthened alloys.
The Ti atoms in the alloys which have a large affinity Acknowledgments
of hydrogen, may reduce the dissociation energy, Es,
and accordingly, increase the diffusion energy, E,. In We would like to express our deepest gratitude to
other words, the Ti atoms deepen the potential well Dr. R. Watanabe and his colleagues of Hitachi Metal
acting as trap sites of hydrogen atoms. However, we can Ltd. for presenting us the alloys.
not determine which is more effective; Ti atoms as
solute in the metal phase or those in precipitated y’-
phase, because both states of Ti atoms are expected to Appendix. Transient permeation for a hollow cylinder
have a similar effect on the trap of hydrogen atoms.
Up to date, values of EJ and ED have been found in Transient permeation for a hollow cylinder and a
the range of 0.6 - 0.7 eV and 0.5 - 0.6 eV, respectively slab is expressed by the following equation of the same
for stainless steels and nickel-base alloys [l-6]. The form [9]:
present results lie in these ranges. As for the pre-ex-
ponential terms, J, and D,,, the magnitudes have strongly Q(T)-Q(o)
=I+ zn,exp(--&), (16)
depended on the respective experiments. The scattering Q(m) - Q(O) ?Z=l
of the data seems to be due not only to the differences
in metallurgical factors of the specimen (chemical com- Table 4
position, thermal history, cold-work etc.) but also to Comparison of transient-permeation equations between a slab
experimental ambiguities because of difficulties in the and hollow cylinders.
experiment, such as purity control of hydrogen gas,
accurate determination of hydrogen amount and so on. Slab HOIlow cylinder
Therefore, ~gh-temperature data in well-defined experi- b/a - 15/12 1515 15/3 15/l
mental conditions (specimen shape, dewpoint, calibra-
tion of the hydrogen detector etc.) should be accu- All-2 -1 -1.998 -1.965 -1.932 -1.859 1
mulated hereafter. ci2 9.870 9.857 9.591 9.319 8.646
where r = Dt/L’, and L = b - a for the hollow cylinder. 131 R.W. Webb, NAA-SR-10462, Atomic Internationat (1965).
The values of A,, and a, for n 5 3 are given in table 4. 141 J.R. Phillips and B.F. Dodge, A.1.Ch.E.J. 14 (1968) 392.
As the ratio of the outer- to inner diameter, b/a, I51 D.W. Rudd and J.B. Vetraro, NAA-SR-6109, Atomic In-
approaches unity, the values of A,, and a, for the hollow ternational (1961).
cylinder become closer to those for the slab. For com- 161T. Namba, S. Kokubo, M. Yamawaki and M. Kanno, J.
Japan Inst. Metals 42 (1978) 374.
parison, the values of eq. (16) at r = 0.1 and rM) are also
I71 H.J. Kbnig and K.W. Lange, Arch. Eisenhiittenwes. 46
listed in table 4, where T,,* is defined by
(1975) 237.
(Q(T,,) - Q(O>L’(Q(=J) - Q(o)) = 112. (17) 181N. Kishimoto, T. Tanabe, H. Araki, H. Yoshida and R.
Watanabe, Nucl. Technol. 66 (1984) 578.
As seen from these values, a hollow cylinder with b/a =
191 H.S. Carslaw and J.C. Jaeger, Conduction of Heat in
15/12 is almost equivalent to a slab so far as the Solids (Oxford Univ. Press, London, 2nd ed., 1967) p. 319.
transient variation is concerned. IlO? M. Smialowski, Hydrogen in Steel (Pergamon Press, 1962).
I111 K.W. Lange and H. Schenck, Z. Metalik. 60 (1969) 62.
11210. Beek, Discussions Faraday Sot. 8 (1950) 118.
References