Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Importance of integrating
a cultural module in the
community nursing curriculum
Noha Al-Shdayfat, Fadia Hasna, Mohammad Al-Smairan, Gillian Lewando-
Hundt, Tamador Shudayfat
Noha Al-Shdayfat, Assistant Professor, Faculty of Nursing, Al al-Bayt University; Fadia Hasna, Associate Professor, Faculty of
Health Sciences, American University of Madaba, Jordan; Mohammad Al-Smairan, Assistant Professor, Renewable Engineering
Department, Engineering Faculty, Al al-Bayt University; Gillian Lewando-Hundt, Professor of Social Sciences in Health and
Co-Director of the Institute of Health, University of Warwick, Coventry, England; Tamador Shudayfat, Lecturer, Department of
Community Health Nursing, Faculty of Nursing, Al al-Bayt University, Jordan
dr.nuhash@aabu.edu.jo
vider of public health services, delivering health care at three ability and clarity of the module.
levels: village centres, primary health centres, and comprehen- The staff of Al al-Bayt University carried out the imple-
sive health centres (CHCs) (Hasna et al, 2010). Although the mentation of the module, and have shared training materi-
health-care system in Jordan appears to function well overall, als with another two government-funded universities: the
it faces many problems and serious challenges. For example, Hashemite University and Jordan University of Science
some subpopulations lack access to health care and/or cannot and Technology.
What changes would you like to see in the future? ‘The content of the module is taking into consid-
eration the Bedouins’ nature.’ [Faculty member,
Any other recommendations to ensure sustainability of the module? 32 years old, female]
However, another faculty member felt that the mod-
Rationale: sustainability of interventions ule emphasis was on health problems that were also shared
for cultural competency by the rural Jordanian population and were not specific to
Cultural competency is crucial to provide quality care Bedouin health:
and overcome the disparities in health care. This study was
‘The Bedouin Health module addressed the rural
designed to explore nursing students’ and faculty members’ health problems and not Bedouin health problems.’
attitudes regarding reform of the community health nursing [Faculty member, 27 years old, female]
courses to make them more culturally competent, especially
because the Bedouins are the main target population for the All students indicated that the objectives of the module were
clinical training courses at Al al-Bayt University. clear to them. One student stated that:
‘Students who did not have any idea learnt
Method about Badia.’ [Nursing student, 20 years old, male]
A qualitative approach was adopted in the current study. Two
focus group discussions were carried out, with a group of A nursing student from the Badia region said:
five faculty members involved in the implementation of the
‘Although I am a resident of Badia and I am
© 2016 MA Healthcare Ltd
Bedouin Health module. In addition, a group of five, fourth- Bedouin, I learnt more about it through the mod-
year nursing students, who had participated in the revised com- ule.’ [Nursing student, 21 years old, female]
munity health courses after integration of the Bedouin Health
module, were invited for a meeting at Al al-Bayt University The students stated that they also learnt most about the
to discuss the module. Leading questions based on the group- Badia through the projects they worked on, which made them
discussion themes were prepared for both groups (Table 1). aware of Badia issues, such as, environmental problems (sulphur
dumping in Jaber village in Badia) and community assessment a qualified Bedouin nurse would be the best person
in Badia. One faculty member stated: to do this because she understands their culture’
[Nursing student, 21 years old, female]
‘Module was descriptive, we initiate some interac-
tive practical project[s], such as Sulfur dust pollu-
tion in Jaber village.’ [Faculty member, 25 years However, this will not be an easy change to implement,
old, male] given that it is a social stigma to be a nurse in Bedouin society,
particularly for Bedouin females.
However, the faculty members reported facing some
obstacles during clinical practice sessions in the Badia. Motivation
Owing to the nursing curriculum’s focus on curative care The faculty members described their students as active rather
and the de-emphasis on community health nursing, it was than passive recipients of the training, which was made pos-
difficult for them to convince the nursing faculty admin- sible by the interactive project component in the module. One
istration about the importance of practising in the Badia. faculty member stated:
In addition, the faculty members cited a lack of context-
‘Our students become more positive and motivated
specific community health nursing textbooks (most of the to implement the module once they [are] involved
reference materials used come from the USA or UK, and in practical projects.’ [Faculty member, 29 years
do not incorporate the local context). Hence, the group old, male]
discussion’s faculty participants recommended creating com-
munity health nursing textbooks that highlighted the health The students discussed facing rejection from the commu-
needs of the Bedouins and other Jordanian subpopulations. nity at the beginning of their community health practice. For
One of the faculty members stated: example, in Jaber village in the Badia, the school principal said
to the students:
‘I would rather if we [have] the Bedouin Module
contents within a community nursing textbook.’ ‘What will you [be able to] offer ... us from your
[Faculty member, 35 years old, female] closed doors (meaning ivory towers)?’ [Nursing stu-
dent, 20 years old, female]
The faculty members also highlighted logistical issues such
as transportation between the university and villages and However, within 3 weeks, the Jaber community had accept-
between the health centre and patients’ houses. For some fac- ed them.The school principal even apologised and told the Al
ulty members, experiencing difficulties with public transport al-Bayt university team: ‘you broke [down] closed doors and
helped them to understand some of the struggles the Bedouins reached the local community’.
face everyday: The students noticed a lack of health awareness among the
local community as well as a shortage of outreach activities
‘I experienced myself the difficulty of moving
from one place to another in Badia because of the organised by the health centres. To remedy this, the students
[scarcity] of the transportation.’ [Faculty member, sought to raise the awareness of the local community about
32 years old, male]. public health problems and available health and social services.
As one student said:
‘We have enhanced the Bedouins’ knowledge about
Sustainability
different health problems through health education
In response to a question about the module’s sustainabil-
sessions, we improved their knowledge about chronic
ity, the faculty members revealed how they perceived the
diseases, family planning, breast feeding, breast self-
module as being ‘descriptive’ and accordingly, had adapted
examination, environmental problems such as air
it to incorporate interactive practical projects. Project topics
pollution and other problems. We also told them
included environmental health threats in the Badia and a
about the locations and types of social and health
community needs assessment.
services provided by certain public and private agen-
The students recommended that project materials be kept
cies to the Bedouins.’ [Nursing student, 21 years
in local health centres, mosques, and municipal libraries, as
old, female]
resources for the public to use and to be disseminated to dif-
ferent communities in the Badia, ensuring knowledge transfer.
They also suggested that the Bedouin Health module be made Acceptance
mandatory for nursing students at universities where students The students in one village described how they had inte-
conduct clinical rotations in the Badia. grated into the village community with the support of a
The students suggested that, in the future, all health and major stakeholder. These students approached the village
© 2016 MA Healthcare Ltd
social providers in Badia should be Bedouins, in order to imam (religious leader) and convinced him to talk about the
guarantee the sustainability of the module and reduce turno- module and encourage cooperation with the students during
ver. One nursing student commented: Friday prayers.
‘I would rather if the health providers be Bedouins, ‘We met the imam of the village masjid (mosque)
especially if the services are meant to be for women, and we could convince him to talk about the
Bedouin module after Friday Khutba (sermon).’ The results of the focus group discussions showed that
[Nursing student, 20 years old, female] both faculty members and students realised the importance
of this intervention and supported permanently reforming
The students said that the course had enriched their practice the nursing curriculum to integrate the module and ensur-
and life experiences (e.g. leadership skills, knowledge about ing sustainability of the programme. Some of the focus group
Bedouin tradition and culture, and understanding of the nurs- participants also suggested further research about Bedouin
ing profession). health, culture, and traditions, as well as the ethics of home
visits for this population. Faculty members highlighted the lack
‘I learnt from the Bedouins the importance of fam-
ily life and intimacy.’[Nursing student, 21 years of resources about the Bedouin community and recommended
old, female] that culturally sensitive community health nursing textbooks
be published to teach nursing students about providing health
‘I learnt how to reach [out to] people meaning care to Bedouin patients.
breaking the fear from the ghost of the Badia for Both students and faculty members described their expe-
people not from the Badia.’ [Nursing student, rience with the module as largely positive. We hope that,
22 years old, male] in the future, they might consider working as health-care
providers in the Northern Badia or other remote areas.
Furthermore, most of the health-care providers in north
Discussion and implications Badia are not from the Badia, and might not be familiar with
for clinical practice the Bedouin culture. They should be provided with thor-
The Bedouin Health Project has had a meaningful effect on ough training on culturally sensitive practice, with a special
the health services offered to the Bedouin community. Some focus on communication skills.
of the implications would be to put all the key players on board Though many studies highlighted the importance of pro-
to work together on key issues of transportation and access, viding a culturally sensitive health services for disadvantaged
as well as cultural sensitivity and communication skills of the communities living in remote areas (i.e. Bedouins in the
providers when they are placed in the Badia region. Thus, Mediterranean region, indigenous or Aborigines in Australia
an evaluation of its opportunities to be sustainable through and Canada, and Gypsies/Roma/Traveller in the EU), to the
an intervention approach becomes crucial.The project’s team best of our knowledge, none of the studies aimed to evaluate
developed the Bedouin Health module on the basis of the the future health-care providers’ attitudes toward integrating a
findings of the Bedouin Health Project culturally sensitive module into their curriculum.This experi-
The findings of this study showed that it is crucial for nursing ence was unique as, currently, none of the universities adjacent
students and faculty members to be culturally competent when to the Badia in the Mediterranean region have similar culturally
practising community health care in the Bedouin community. sensitive programmes to qualify nursing students to be effective
This can be achieved by developing a theoretical understand- prospective health care workers in the Badia.
ing of the Badia culture and context before sending students The findings of this study are beneficial to decision makers
for training. Faculty members and students demonstrated in the academic sector in Jordan, Mediterranean countries,
motivation and self-reliance in terms of applying the module, and other parts of the world (where Bedouins, indigenous
probably because practising community health nursing in the and Aboriginal communities live). It is essential for prospec-
Badia is a new experience for them. The students and faculty tive health-care providers for disadvantaged communities
members learnt about the Badia in the theoretical lectures prior (medical, nursing, and allied health sciences students) to be
to the training. Consequently, they might become committed equipped with the knowledge and skills required for cultur-
and motivated to provide health care for other members of the ally competent practice. Qualitative research is needed to
community in the Badia. determine the attitude of Bedouin community members
toward the effectiveness of the nursing students’ cultural
competent practice. BJCN
KEY POINTS
It is crucial for nursing students and faculty members to be culturally
ww Accepted for publication: 10 December 2015
competent when working with the Bedouin community
Both the students and faculty members involved were clear about the
ww
module’s objectives and described their experience with the module as Declaration of interest: The authors acknowledge the funding and
largely positive support of the European Commission for this study through INCO
In spite of the limitations and obstacles reported by the participants in the
ww
DEV Framework 6 STREP 015362.
© 2016 MA Healthcare Ltd
Abu-Jaber KS, Gharaibeh FA (1981) Bedouin settlement: organizational, legal, Family Health Survey 2012. Department of Statistics and ICF International,
and administrative structure in Jordan. In: Galaty JG, Aronson D, Salzman Calverton, MD
PC, Chouinard A, eds. The Future of Pastoral Peoples. Proceedings of a Conference Dutton R, Shahbaz M, eds (2008) Jordan’s Arid Badia: Deepening our Understanding.
Held in Nairobi, Kenya, 4–8 August 1980. The International Development Smith-Gordon & Co Ltd
Centre, Ottawa, Canada: 294–301 El-Azhary Sonbol A (2003) Women of Jordan: Islam, Labor, and the Law. Syracuse
Al-Smairan MH (2006) Investigation of a hybrid wind-photovoltaic electrical energy University Press
system for a remote community. PhD Thesis, Coventry University El-Shati H (2001) The impact of genetic diseases on Jordanians: strate-
Al-Smairan M, Hasna F (2008) Bedouin Health Module. Internal Report pre- gies towards prevention. J Biomed Biotechnol 1(1): 45–7. doi:10.1155/
pared for the Bedouin Health Project. Philadelphia University, Amman, S1110724301000092
Jordan Hasna F, Hundt GL, Al-Smairan M, Alzaroo S (2010) Quality of prima-
Al-Tabini J, Hawmdeh IA (2004) Local community participation in liveli- ry nursing care for Bedouin in Jordan. Int J Nurs Pract 16(6): 564–72.
hoods improvement and sustainability ‘Anaqeed Al-khair Project case study’. doi:10.1111/j.1440-172X.2010.01882.x
Proceedings of the International Conference on Promoting Community- Lewando Hundt G, Alzaroo S, Hasna F, Alsmeiran M (2012) The provision
driven Conservation and Sustainable Use of Dry Land Agro Biodiversity, of accessible, acceptable health care in rural remote areas and the right to
18–21 April 2004, Aleppo, Syria health: Bedouin in the North East region of Jordan. Soc Sci Med 74(1): 36–43.
Belmaker I, Dukhan L, Elgrici M,Yosef Y, Shahar-Rotberg L (2006) Reduction of doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2011.08.042
vaccine-preventable communicable diseases in a Bedouin population: summary Nimri L (2008) Common infectious diseases and risk factors in the North-
of a community-based intervention programme. Lancet 367(9515): 987–91 Eastern Jordan Badia. In: Dutton R, Shahbaz M, eds. Jordan’s Arid Badia:
Community Research and Development Information Service (2011) Bedouin Deepening our Understanding. Smith-Gordon: 313–23
Health Report Summary. http://cordis.europa.eu/result/rcn/52962_ Thompson Rivers University (2010) Cultural Competence and Cultural Safety
en.html (accessed 2 December 2015) in Nursing Education Report on Thompson Rivers University Strategy
Chatty D, Colchester M, eds (2002) Conservation and Mobile Indigenous Peoples: Session. http://bit.ly/1Q0BXwM (accessed 2 December 2015)
Displacement, Forced Settlement and Sustainable Development. Berghahn Van Cleemput P, Bissell P, Harris J (2010) Pacesetters Programme Gypsy, Roma
Books, Oxford and Traveller core strand. Evaluation Report for the Department of Health. Public
Department of Statistics [Jordan], ICF International (2013) Jordan Population and Health Section ScHARR, University of Sheffield
Not only does the book encourage nurses and midwives to develop
their research and evidence skills, by the time the reader has
completed it, they will have the knowledge and skills to conduct
their own small scale research projects.