Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Abstract
Measurements of small air ion concentrations, electrostatic potential and AC electric field strengths were taken in an
office setting to investigate the link between electric fields and charged molecule and particle concentrations in individual
microenvironments. The results obtained indicate that the electromagnetic environments individuals can be exposed to
whilst indoors can often bear little resemblance to those experienced outdoors in nature, and that many individuals may
spend large periods of their time in ‘‘Faraday cage’’-like conditions exposed to inappropriate levels and types of electric
fields that can reduce localised concentrations of biologically essential and microbiocidal small air ions. Such conditions
may escalate their risk of infection from airborne contaminants, including microbes, whilst increasing localised surface
contamination. The degree of ‘‘electro-pollution’’ that individuals are exposed to was shown to be influenced by the type of
microenvironment they occupy, with it being possible for very different types of microenvironment to exist within the same
room.
It is suggested that adopting suitable electromagnetic hygiene/productivity guidelines that seek to replicate the beneficial
effects created by natural environments may greatly mitigate such problems.
r 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1352-2310/$ - see front matter r 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.atmosenv.2007.02.050
ARTICLE IN PRESS
K.S. Jamieson et al. / Atmospheric Environment 41 (2007) 5224–5235 5225
2.3. Alternating current (AC) electric fields are also required to have a factor of unipolarity Y,
with a minimum and maximum ratio of positive to
AC fields are measured in volts per metre (V m1) negative ions being given by 0.4pYp1.0.
and can be created by high-voltage power lines, Though the recommended optimal and manda-
electrical wiring and items of electrical equipment. tory maximum small air ion concentrations sug-
They increase in strength as voltage is raised. Whilst gested by the Russian SanPiN guidelines are far
electrical equipment has to be switched on before higher than often found in nature, such levels can
magnetic fields are registered, electric fields can be help to reduce incidences of excess charge.
detected even if the equipment is switched off but Though no formal legislation appears to exist in
not unplugged from the mains power socket. the western world, in the USA, the Federal Aviation
Frequencies within the range being measured in Authority (F.A.A.) acknowledged that both very
the present case study (10–2000 Hz73 dB) can be low SAI concentrations, and high ion concentra-
biologically active (Lang, 1972a, b). tions with a factor of unipolarity with a strong
imbalance of positive air ions can produce detri-
2.4. Electrostatic fields mental effects (Rosenberg, 1972).
Under natural fair weather conditions an electro- 2.5.2. Standards regarding AC fields
static vertical potential gradient of 100–200 V m1 Whilst International Commission on Non-Ionis-
can exist near the ground, with the positively ing Radiation Protection (ICNIRP, 1998) guidelines
charged ionosphere acting as an anode and the stipulate that 60 Hz AC electric fields encountered
earth as a cathode causing a transfer of negative by members of the general public should be
ions from the earth to the sky and positive ions from p4200 V m1, Russian and Swedish guidelines for
the ionosphere to the earth along electrostatic lines computer users advocate AC field levels of p25 and
of force. When poor weather conditions, such p10 V m1, respectively, at 0.5 m from computers
as thunderstorms, arise this situation is reversed in the ELF 5–2000 Hz (Band I) range (SanPiN,
and triboelectric inversion occurs, with the air 2003; TCO, 2003).
below positively charged clouds becoming more AC fields may partially influence ion deposition,
negatively charged than the ground underneath, coagulation rates along with localised contamina-
causing the vertical electric current to flow in the tion levels if they are sufficiently strong.
opposite direction—in such situations fields of
3000–10,000 V m1 can be encountered (Sulman, 2.5.3. Standards regarding electrostatic fields
1980; Sheppard and Eisenbud, 1977; Bach, 1967). The Russian guidelines for computer users
Distorted current flow and higher fields than this stipulate that the electrostatic potential at 0.5 m
can however be created indoors, particularly when from computers should be p500 V (SanPiN, 2003),
conditions of low RH or dew-point temperature whilst the Swedish guidelines specify a maximum
exist. surface potential of 7500 V (TCO, 2003).
However, whilst such standards can be of great
2.5. Standards and guidelines use in reducing incidences of electrostatic discharge,
induced charge and surface contamination, they do
2.5.1. Standards regarding air ion concentrations not take into account the fact that the body appears
The Ministry of Health of the Russian Federa- to function best when exposed to constant vertical
tion’s ‘Sanitary and Epidemiologial Norms’ guide- electrical fields and that exposure to distorted field
lines (SanPiN, 2003) stipulate mandatory maximum regimes and ‘‘Faraday-cage’’ conditions may actu-
and minimum levels of bipolar air ion concentra- ally prove detrimental to health (Jamieson et al.,
tions in the computer workplace. SAI concentra- 2006).
tions must not be o600 negative (NSAI) and 400
positive small air ions (PSAI) cm3, and levels must 2.6. Hypothesis and scientific evidence
not exceed 50,000 NSAI or PSAI cm3. These
regulations state that optimum recommended ion The presence of inappropriate levels and types
concentrations to reduce fatigue and enhance of electric fields in individual microenvironments
capacity for work are 3000–5000 NSAI and may greatly reduce localised concentrations of
1500–3000 PSAI cm3. These air ion concentrations SAI, whilst increasing localised concentrations of
ARTICLE IN PRESS
K.S. Jamieson et al. / Atmospheric Environment 41 (2007) 5224–5235 5227
Table 2
Synopsis of results
Vertical plane Average negative air 276 361 263 302.5 10 930
(Section A16-L5) ions cm3a
Lower bound 276 288 257 230 0 870
Upper bound 276 434 279 420 20 1070
AC fields (V m1)a 276 19.5 49.0 4.5 1.0 452.0
Electrostatic potential (V)b 276 104.9 495.2 27.9 2.2 7705.8
Horizontal plane Average negative air 202 433 205 435 35 910
at 1.10 m (Grids ions cm3b
0A-18L) Lower bound 202 372 204 375 10 960
Upper bound 202 494 224 500 50 1060
a
19.370.3 1C, with 66.774.2% RH (dew-point temperature 12.96 1C).
b
26.870.6 1C, 29.173.6% RH (dew-point temperature 7.35 1C).
Fig. 2. Vertical section showing concentrations of small negative air ions cm3.
average maximum and minimum values of 930 and was grounded are shown in Fig. 3. On the day these
10 SNAI cm3 being found. The lowest actual value measurements were taken the weather was far
detected in several areas was 0 SNAI cm3 and the warmer than when the data for the vertical ion
highest value 1070 SNAI cm3. The isopleths cre- isopleths were collected, see Table 2, necessitating
ated from these measurements are shown in Fig. 2, the continual use of an oscillating fan unit within
which indicates that very low SAI concentrations the room, and natural ventilation provided by an
were found in the microenvironments where the opened high-level external window, in addition to
operative was sitting and where high electric fields the sporadically operating air conditioning unit.
occurred. In the personal breathing zone of the Analysis of the data taken at the 202 sampling
computer operator concentrations of points used determined an arithmetic mean of
10–280 SNAI cm3 were detected, whilst the influ- 433 SNAI cm3 for this section, with average max-
ence of inappropriate types and levels of fields on imum and minimum values of 910 and
SAI concentrations was also clearly seen for the 35 SNAI cm3, respectively, being found. The low-
anglepoise desk-light located on grid-line 10 where est actual value detected was 10 SNAI cm3 and the
concentrations of 0–40 SNAI cm3 were registered. highest value 1060 SNAI cm3. The isopleths cre-
ated from these measurements are shown in Fig. 3.
4.1.2. Horizontal section The measurements taken clearly indicate that
Measurements were taken to create horizontal concentrations of negative small air ions measured
isopleths at a height of 1.1 m when the laptop com- in the room used for the case study were well below
puter on the main workstation was both grounded the minimum acceptable level of 600 SNAI cm3
and ungrounded, though only those taken whilst it given in the Russian SanPiN (2003) guidelines. As
ARTICLE IN PRESS
5230 K.S. Jamieson et al. / Atmospheric Environment 41 (2007) 5224–5235
17 17
16 16
15 15
14 14
13 13
12 12
11 11
10 10
9 9
−3
SNAI cm
8 8 SNAI cm−3
3000
3000
7 2600 7
2600
6 2200 6 2200
1800 1800
5 5
1400 1400
4 1000 4 1000
600 3 600
3
2 2
0
0
1 PLAN 1
PLAN
0 0
A B C D E F G H I J K L A B C D E F G H I J K L
Fig. 3. Plan section at height of 1.1 m showing concentrations of small negative air ions cm3.
very low concentrations of SAI are detected in the The arithmetic mean for the AC fields measured
main work area, the concentrations of charged at the 276 sampling points was 20.9 V m1, with
oxygen molecules must also have been greatly actual maximum and minimum values of 452.0 and
reduced. 1.0 V m1, respectively, being obtained. The isopleth
It is suggested that the presence of inappropriate created from the data collected is shown in Fig. 4,
levels and types of electric fields in individual and when studied in conjunction with Fig. 2 visually
microenvironments within the room may greatly demonstrates the link between high AC electrical
increase both the localized concentrations of fields and low SAI concentrations.
charged sub-micron particles, such as large air ions, Though the AC fields emitted from the monitors
in those areas and the risk of contamination and complied with both Russian and Swedish guidelines,
respiratory problems. the fields emitted by the junction box on the
workstation and the anglepoise desk-light exceeded
4.2. AC electric fields those suggested guidance levels for computers,
thereby preventing the creation of low-field condi-
4.2.1. Vertical section tions in those microenvironments and creating high
Natural vertical atmospheric fields are often local concentrations of charged sub-micron parti-
almost completely prohibited from entering many culates.
modern buildings due to the type of construction
methods used. Even if such fields had been able to 4.3. Electrostatic potential
penetrate the room being measured; they would
often have been masked by the high levels of AC 4.3.1. Vertical section
electric and electrostatic fields present that would This was measured on the same day as the ion
have distorted the direction of current flow. measurements taken for the horizontal section, and
This section was measured on the same day as the is shown in Fig. 5. The average electrostatic
vertical isopleths showing NSAI concentrations. potential measured was 104.9 V, with maximum
ARTICLE IN PRESS
K.S. Jamieson et al. / Atmospheric Environment 41 (2007) 5224–5235 5231
AC E-fields V m−1
210 V m−1
475
190 375
170
150
130
110 25
90
70
10
50
30
10 0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
SECTION
210
190
170
150
130
110
90
70
50
30 kV
0.5
10
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 0.0
SECTION -0.8
and minimum values of 7705.8 and 2.2 V also being operative’s chair by the user (concentrations of
noted. Field readings in excess of 500 V were also 0–40 SiNAI cm3 being noted there). Again low
recorded off-grid above the CRT monitor. concentrations of SAI were found where high fields
It can be clearly seen in Fig. 5 that the from electrical equipment and wiring existed.
electrostatic field in this room does not resemble In addition to the electric fields created by the
fair weather field conditions and that the room’s items of electrical equipment and cabling in the
occupant is constantly exposed to distorted current room, high body voltages can be created through
flow regimes. It is suggested that such conditions frictional charging, particularly when individuals
may greatly reduce the operator’s biological and wear insulative footwear, or come into contact with
work efficiency. insulative materials such as are often used for
Moreover, the influence of tribolectric charging in clothing and furnishings. The most notable cause of
creating high electrostatic potentials is clearly this in the room was the insulative footrest which
demonstrated in Fig. 5, with the greatest poten- curtailed charge dissipation from the computer
tial measured in the room being created by fric- operative. Such charging leads to a high body
tional charging of the footrest of the computer potential being created by frictional charging and
ARTICLE IN PRESS
5232 K.S. Jamieson et al. / Atmospheric Environment 41 (2007) 5224–5235
retention of charge, with the excess charge being Faraday cages. Constant vertical electrostatic fields
dissipated when a conductive surface is touched. can significantly influence a number of physiological
The problems encountered from electrostatic char- parameters in comparison to controls under Fara-
ging in such situations are much exacerbated in day conditions. These include breathing rate,
wintertime when lower RH/dew-point temperature oxygen uptake, activity levels and immune system
leads to higher potentials being generated. As an functioning (Möse and Fischer, 1975; Altmann,
example of this, Moss (1987) showed that walking 1974, 1969; Lang, 1972a, b; Kritzinger, 1957; Hahn,
on a floor finish similar to the one in the surveyed 1956). It is suggested by the present authors that
room at 20% RH at 21 1C (2.5 1C dew-point exclusion and/or masking of individuals from such
temperature) could generate 12,000 V whilst the phenomena, or artificial simulations of them, may
same action at 80% RH at 21 1C (17.4 1C dew-point significantly influence their health, performance and
temperature) generated only 250 V. well-being.
In indoor environments where large concentra-
4.4. Temperature, RH and dew-point temperature tions of aerosols exist, the main cause of decay of
SAI can be collision with neutral or oppositely
Indoor temperatures on the first measurement day charged particles. When this occurs, the result of the
were 26.870.6 1C, necessitating the continual use of collision can be the creation of an intermediate or
an oscillating fan unit within the room, in addition to large air ion. SAI can also be lost due to plate-out
the air conditioning unit (which was sporadically in on surfaces, this situation being greatly exacerbated
operation) and natural ventilation provided by the when the surfaces themselves obtain a high
opened external window. 29.173.6% RH was also degree of charge and when there is o20–30% RH.
recorded during that period, giving an average dew- As previously mentioned, high electric fields can
point temperature of 7.35 1C. On the final measure- also be created from electrical items and wiring,
ment day the temperature was 19.370.3 1C, with and through frictional charging, as was demon-
66.774.2% RH (12.96 1C dew-point temperature). strated by the measurements taken next to the
The air conditioning was still in sporadic operation, footrest of the computer operative’s chair in this
though the fan was no longer in use and the external present study.
window shut. Recombination of oppositely charged cluster ions
Furthermore, large seasonal variations can occur in the air can additionally occur and result in their
with regard to charge generation in buildings, with neutralisation, though this is more likely to occur in
higher charges generally being generated in winter areas where there is little aerosol pollution. High
months (even when external RH levels are 450%). levels of unipolar charge in particular, such as are
This is primarily due to the reduction in indoor RH noted in the case study, can affect the concentra-
levels due to the operation of heating systems with tions of different sizes of aerosols, with droplet
RH being halved for every 10 1C increase in disintegration occurring when the repellent forces
temperature over the outdoors. Vonnegut (1973) that unipolar charges apply to each other exceed the
noted that in a hypothetical situation where 100% droplet’s surface tension, causing the creation of
RH was encountered at 20 1C, indoor tempera- smaller particles (Wehner, 1969). Such situations
tures of 20 1C would reduce RH to o10%. Low may further exacerbate contamination and health
humidities can greatly increase the deposition and risks by creating higher concentrations of charged
retention of contaminants as they encourage the ultrafine particles. Excess electrical charges may
generation of higher electric fields. often play a key part in contamination incidences by
significantly increasing the coagulation, charging
5. Effects of electrostatic and AC electric fields on and deposition of microbes, contaminated airborne
charged molecules and particles droplets and particulate matter on the skin,
surroundings and airways of those exposed. The
Both fair weather and poor weather field condi- greater the degree of charge that such contaminants
tions can significantly influence biological processes, receive, the greater the likelihood of infection and
with poor-weather fields tending to be seen as contamination, as high electric fields can also
detrimental and fair weather fields beneficial. significantly raise the deposition velocity and
Building occupants can often be screened from localised deposition rate of charged and charge-
these however due to many buildings acting like neutralised dielectric particles p1 mm in diameter.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
K.S. Jamieson et al. / Atmospheric Environment 41 (2007) 5224–5235 5233
This is because increased potential linearly increases more readily than charge-neutralised particles.
their deposition onto oppositely charged objects. Creating conditions where such particles gain
As demonstrated in the case study, high electrical charge may greatly increase risk of infection and
fields can often be created in everyday life. The respiratory problems.
presence of inappropriate charging regimes in
individual microenvironments may greatly increase 6. Conclusions
incidences of skin and surface contamination and
the likelihood of contaminants, including patho- The measurements discussed within this docu-
gens, being retained by the body when inhaled, ment, and taken during additional surveys by the
though there are many ways in which excess charge main author, indicate that many individuals may
can be reduced (Jamieson et al., 2006). spend the majority of their time indoors in ‘‘Fara-
Past research by Wedberg (1991, 1986, 1987) day cage’’-like conditions exposed to (unnecessarily)
found that in office environments the deposition of high electrostatic and AC electric fields. Such
particulate matter 40.07 mm in size on individuals’ conditions can reduce available concentrations of
faces was significantly influenced by electrical field biologically-essential SAI, whilst increasing their
regimes, with precipitation rates increasing markedly likelihood of inhaling and retaining airborne con-
as the magnitude of applied voltages increased— taminants, such as charged ultrafine particles and
facial deposition rates of E100 particles mm2 h1 at being exposed to higher levels of difficult-to-remove
0 kV increasing to E1000 particles mm2 h1 when surface contamination. The degree of ‘‘electro-
the body was charged to a potential of 75–6 kV. pollution’’ that individuals are exposed to is very
This is because though such particles have drift much determined by the type of microenvironment
velocities far lower than normal indoor (and out- they occupy, with inappropriate levels and types of
door) wind velocities, they are likely to be captured electric field normally resulting in low concentra-
when passing sufficiently close to suitably charged tions of SAI and high concentrations of LAI. Very
surfaces. High charging will also increase contami- often, different types of microenvironment can exist
nant deposition onto other areas of exposed skin, within the same room, with the location occupied by
such as the hands, thereby increasing the risk of individuals for prolonged periods greatly influen-
contamination spread. Research by Rao et al. (2005) cing the levels of pollution they are exposed to.
indicates that 490% of airborne particles may be Therefore, where possible, future research studying
o1 mm in size. Electrostatic attraction between the link between particulate pollution and health
airborne ultrafine particles and charged surfaces is should include measurements of concentrations
often a greater determinant of localised contaminant (and charge) of small, intermediate and large air
deposition than aerodynamic forces or gravity. ions and sub-micron particles in such areas.
Unlike gas molecules and millimetre-sized mole- The cost to national economies of poor indoor
cules, aerosols strongly adhere to surfaces they air/indoor environmental quality (IAQ/IEQ) prac-
contact (Hinds, 1999; Yost and Steinman, 1986). tices is immense and may be significantly reduced by
Electrical forces can greatly increase the deposi- introducing suitable electromagnetic hygiene/pro-
tion of charged particles in the respiratory tract ductivity guidelines. It was estimated by Mendell
since whilst its surface, is uncharged, it is electrically et al. (2002) that respiratory illnesses due to poor
conductive, and when a suitably charged particle building management and practices in the USA
approaches the alveolar surface the particle induces alone may cost $32 billion dollars annually in terms
an image charge of opposite polarity on its surface, of absenteeism, health-care costs and reduced work
thereby attracting the particle. Work by the Inter- efficiency, whilst Clements-Croome and Baizhan
national Commission on Radiological Protection (1997) suggest that improving indoor air quality
(ICRP, 1994) modelling particle deposition in the may increase the productivity of office staff by
respiratory tract indicates that maximum alveolar E10%. It is suggested by the current authors that
deposition in humans may occur with singlet creating indoor environments which more closely
ultrafine particles of approximately 20 nm enhance/simulate beneficial natural electromagnetic
(0.02 mm) diameter. Research by Cohen et al. phenomena and reduce incidences of excess charge,
(1998) has indicated that this size of particle when whilst exposing individuals to constant vertical
singly charged may deposit 5.370.3 times more electrical fields and suitable concentrations of
readily than uncharged particles, and 3.470.3 times balanced bipolar small air ionisation, may greatly
ARTICLE IN PRESS
5234 K.S. Jamieson et al. / Atmospheric Environment 41 (2007) 5224–5235
improve their productivity and biological function- Hahn, F., 1956. Luftelektrizität Gegen Bakterien für Gesundes
ing at the same time as significantly reducing Raumklima und Wohlbefinden. Albrecht Philler Verlag,
incidences of contamination and infection. Further Minden.
Hinds, W.C., 1999. Aerosol Technology: Properties, Behaviour
research in this relatively unexplored area is and Measurement of Airborne Particles, second ed. Wiley,
urgently required. New York, pp. 141–144.
ICNIRP, 1998. Guidelines for EMF Exposure. International
Commission on Non-ionising Radiation Protection (IC-
Acknowledgements NIRP).
ICRP, 1994. Human respiratory tract model for radiological
protection. A Report of a Task Group of the International
Special thanks are given to assistant professor
Commission on Radiological Protection (ICRP). Annals of
Alvhild Allette Bjørkum of Bergen University the ICRP 24 (1–3), 1–482, ICRP Publication 66.
College, Norway and professor Karen Rosendahl Jamieson, K.S., Jamieson, S.S., 2006. Electromagnetic phenom-
of Haukeland University Hospital, Norway for ena, microbial infection, charged oxygen and environmental
their generous help, advice and assistance in air quality. In: Proceedings of VALDOR (Values in Decisions
On Risk). Stockholm, Sweden, 14–18 May 2006, ISBN 91-
conducting this research. The authors would also
6318876-7, Congrex Sweden AB/Informationsbolaget Nyberg
like to thank Dr. Roy N. Colvile and Dr. Dominic & Co., pp. 281–288.
Weiss of Imperial College London for their Jamieson, K.S., ApSimon, H.M., Bell, J.N.B., Yost, M.G., 2005.
assistance during the course of this work. Interaction of charged molecules and particles with electro-
magnetic fields in the indoor environment. In: Proceedings of
the 10th International Conference on Indoor Air Quality and
Climate (Indoor Air 2005), II(2), 2515–2521. Beijing, China,
References September 4–9, 2005.
Jamieson, K.S., ApSimon, H.M., Bell, J.N.B., Holdstock, P.,
Altmann, G., 1969. Die physiologische Wirkung elektrischer 2006. Electromagnetic phenomena, productivity, health and
Felder auf Organismen. Archiv für Meteorologie Geophysik infection: Potential cost-benefits of enhanced low-EMF
und Bioklimatologie, Series B 17, 269–290. environments, Electrostatic and Electromagnetic Fields ver-
Altmann, G., 1974. Oxygen and biochemical changes following sus Environment, Session II of EL-TEX 2006, 7th Interna-
ELF exposure. In: Persinger, M.A. (Ed.), ELF and VLF tional Symposium, Łódź, Poland 16 November 2006.
Electromagnetic Field Effects. Plenum Press, New York, Conference Proceedings, 16-11-2006, Paper 7, pp. 1–11.
pp. 227–241. Kellogg III, E.W., Yost, M.G., 1986. The effects of long-term air
Bach, C., 1967. Ions for Breathing: Control of the Air-electrical ion and D.C. electric field exposures on survival character-
Climate for Health. Pergamon Press, Oxford (translated and istics in female NAMRU mice. Journal of Gerontology 41 (2),
edited by The Pilcox Consultant Service). 147–153.
Barron, C.E., Dreher, J.J., 1964. Effects of electric fields and Kritzinger, H.-H., 1957. Praktische Bioklimatik, insbesondere der
negative ion concentrations on test pilots. Aerospace Medi- Luftelektrizität im freien Raum und im Wohnraum. For-
cine 35, 20–23. tschritte der Medizin 75, 469–470.
Clements-Croome, D., Baizhan, L., 1997. Assessment of the Lang, S., 1972a. Physiologische untersuchungen an weissen
influence of indoor environment on occupant productivity of Mäusen im faradayschen käfig. Wetter Boden Mensch 14,
occupants in offices. In: Woods, J.E., Grimsrud, D.T., Boschi, 831–833.
N. (Eds.), Healthy Buildings/IAQ ’97: Global Issues and Lang, S., 1972b. Faradayscher Käfig verändert Ionenmilieu des
Regional Solutions. Proceedings of the fifth International Bluts. Umschau—Kurzberichte aus Wissenschaft und Tech-
Conference on Healthy Buildings, vol. 2. Office and Public nik 72 (12), 390.
Assembly Buildings, Bethesda, MD, 27 September–2 October McMurry, P.H., Rader, D.J., 1985. Aerosol wall losses in
1997, pp. 495–500. electrically charged chambers. Aerosol Science and Technol-
Cohen, B.S., Xiong, J.Q., Fang, C.-P., Li, W., 1998. Deposition ogy 4, 249–268.
of charged particles on lung airways. Health Physics 74 (5), Mendell, M.J., Fisk, W.J., Kreiss, K., Levin, H., Alexander, D.,
554–560. Cain, W.S., Girman, J.R., Hines, C.J., Jensen, P.A., Milton,
Dolezalek, H., 1985. Remarks on the physics of atmospheric ions D.K., Rexroat, L.P., Willingford, K.M., 2002. Improving the
(natural and artificial). International Journal of Biometeor- health of workers in indoor environments: priority research
ology 29 (3), 211–221. needs for a national occupational research agenda. American
Ghaly, M., Teplitz, D., 2004. The biological effects of grounding Journal of Public Health 92 (9), 1430–1440.
the human body during sleep, as measured by cortisol levels Möse, J.R., Fischer, G., 1975. Das elektrostatische feld als
and subjective reporting of sleep, pain and stress. The Journal klimafaktor? Wiener Medizinische Wochenschrift 125, 30–35.
of Alternative and Complimentary Medicine 10 (5), 767–776. Moss, R., 1987. Exploding the humidity half-truth and other
Goldstein, N., Arshavskaya, T., 1997. Is atmospheric superoxide dangerous myths. EOS/ESD Technology Magazine 10.
vitally necessary? Accelerated death of animals in a quasi- Rao, C.Y., Cox-Ganser, J.M., Chew, G.L., Doekes, G., White,
neutral electric atmosphere. Zeitschrift für Naturforschung S., 2005. Use of surrogate markers of biological agents in air
(Biosciences) 52c, 396–404, Verlag der Zeitschrift für Nat- and settled dust samples to evaluate a water-damaged
urforschung, Germany. hospital. Indoor Air 15 (Suppl. 9), 89–97.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
K.S. Jamieson et al. / Atmospheric Environment 41 (2007) 5224–5235 5235
Rosenberg, B.L., 1972. A study of atmospheric ionization: Wait, G.R., Parkinson, W.D., 1951. Ions in the atmosphere. In:
measurement of the ion conditions in an ATC laboratory Malone, T.F. (Ed.), Compendium of Meteorology. American
and a review of the literature of ions effects on performance. Meteorological Society, Boston, MA, pp. 120–121.
F.A.A. Report No. NA 72-19. Wedberg, W.C., 1986. The influence of static electricity on
SanPiN, 2003. Sanitary and Epidemiological Norms (SanPiN) aerosol deposition in indoor environments. Aerosols: forma-
2.2.4.1294-03. Ministry of Health of the Russian Federation tion and reactivity. In: Proceedings of the Second Interna-
(in Russian). tional Aerosol Conference. West Berlin 22–26 September
Sheppard, A.R., Eisenbud, M., 1977. Biologic Effects of Electric 1986, Pergamon Press, Oxford, pp. 793–796.
and Magnetic Fields of Extremely Low Frequency. NY Wedberg, W.C., 1987. Facial particle exposure in the
University, New York. VDU environment: The role of static electricity. In: Knave,
Sulman, F.G., 1980. The Effect of Air Ionization, Electric Fields, B., Widebäck, P-G. (Eds.), Work with display units 86.
Atmospherics and Other Electric Phenomena on Man and Elsevier Science Publishers B.V., North-Holland,
Animal. Thomas, Springfield, IL. pp. 151–159.
TCO, 2003. TCO’03 Displays, CRT Displays, Ver. 3.0, TCO Wedberg, W.C., 1991. Risks to VDT operators. Scientific
Development, Tjanstemannens Central Organisation (TCO), correspondence. Nature 352, 199.
Swedish Confederation of Professional Employees, Stock- Wehner, A.P., 1969. Electro-aerosols, air ions and physical
holm, 1–100. medicine. Special Review in American Journal of Physical
Vonnegut, B., 1973. Atmospheric electrostatics. In: Moore, A.D. Medicine 48 (3), 119–149.
(Ed.), Electrostatics and its Applications. Wiley, London, Yost, M.G., Steinman, A.J., 1986. Electrostatic attraction and
pp. 390–424 (Chapter 17). particle control. Microcontamination 4 (6), 18–26.