Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
net/publication/325775644
CITATIONS READS
0 11
3 authors:
Deepak Khare
Indian Institute of Technology Roorkee
169 PUBLICATIONS 963 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Climate change Impact Assessment over Upper Narmada River Basin View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Karthik Desingu on 26 June 2018.
Abstract— Synchronous generators (SGs) are widely used in mGeno - Weight of rotating part of the generator
power generating plants including hydropower as it is easy to Pcomb - Calculated loss of the combined bearing
control, supports large amount of reactive power, and offers PUGB - Upper guide bearing losses
higher energy efficiency in comparison with asynchronous
generators. SGs are often overloaded through hydro-turbines by
α - Heat transfer coefficient
utilizing excess water flow in the river (e.g. 1000 MW Kancham
Wangtoo hydropower station (India) at 20% continuous
overloading condition for more than six weeks). This paper I. INTRODUCTION
investigates the efficiency of a 277.8 MVA SG, through its loss
models, under two operating conditions: (i) at rated load, (ii) at
20% overload. Temperature of cooling air inlet to the stator of SG
Among all electrical generators synchronous generator (SG)
is owing more attention for power production. In
(primary cooling) and the temperature of water inlet to the cooler hydropower plant up to 700 MW unit capacity SGs are
(secondary cooling) are considered for the analysis. Simulated preferred [1]. Cooling system in generators are of great
results are compared with a commissioned generator through the importance, which provides longer lifetimes of certain
on-site measurements. From the test results, it is observed that the components such as insulation, windings, etc. Furthermore, the
cooler performance (temperature of air leaving from the cooler) electric resistances of the windings are temperature dependent.
was poor at overloads which causes reduction in efficiency and This means that in order to keep the generator at its maximum
temperature-rise in stator windings of tested SG. efficiency, it should work in its normal design temperature
Index Terms-- Calorimeter, efficiency, temperature, losses,
range (60oC – 80oC) [2]-[4]. Hydro-power generators are
synchronous generator, cooler performance. equipped with a closed air circulating cooling system with
surface air coolers spaced symmetrically around the periphery
I. NOMENCLATURE of the stator frame. The air cooler including the cooling air
circuit of the generators is able to satisfy the required loading
ϑw ,W - Warm water temperature of the generator
conditions. SGs are often operated at over-load condition
Cm ,W - Mean specific heat capacity of the water during the period when excess water flows in the river to meet
ρK - Cold air density the power demand. While feeding generator of 250 MW
.
V - Volumetric water flow capacity with 120% of shaft power will lead to generate 300
ρ w ,W - Warm water density MW power and thereby increase in thermal energy losses. As
.
Q - Thermal losses the large hydro-generators are operated beyond the rated value,
Pfw - Ventilation losses (friction and windage) the energy losses also amplifies correspondingly that leads to
ρN - Rated air density alarming temperature rise and insulation breakdown [3]. During
PFe - Open circuit losses the past several eras, the researches and findings were
prominent in these areas such as insulation breakdown for
PSC - Rated stator I2R winding losses
N
machine winding, ventilation and cooling system. To ensure the
PLLN - Rated additional load losses
cooling performance of the SGs while operating above rated
I fg - Air gap excitation current
load, efficiency measurement is important. During the past
I fk - Short circuit excitation current
twenty years, the calorimetric method has been used quite
mI - Incline short circuit characteristic widely to determine the losses and efficiency of large hydro
Pf N - Rated excitation power generators [5]-[11]. Different implementations from closed-
Pbe - Electrical brush loss cycle water-cooled systems [12] to high-precision calorimeters
Pbm - Mechanical brush loss with seemingly complex arrangements [13] have been reported.
wb - Tangential width length of carbon brush In SGs, losses are classified into four categories: winding
lb - Axial length of carbon brush (copper losses), core (iron losses), mechanical, brush-ring
nb - Total number of brushes on both slip rings electrical losses. Through the loss models, total efficiency of the
Ab - Brush contact area SGs is obtained. In general, efficiency of large SG is about 98%
uSR - Circumferential speed of slip ring in total, including field-winding losses. This paper presents the
PTB - Thrust bearing losses
Rotor Water
radiator
` Collector of
hot air
Rotor
Windings
Stator end
windings
Fan 1
Temperature( oC)
200 Stator Winding Temp. (oC) 80
60
150 Stator Core Temp. (oC) 60
Temperature ( ̊ C)
50
40 100 40
30 50 20
20 0 0
Cold Air Inlet Temp. (̊C) 0 10 20 30 40 50 60
10 Hot Air Outlet Temp. (̊C) No. of Days
0 Fig. 10 Stator core and winding temperature at 250MW
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 350 120
No. of Days
300 100
Fig. 7. Inlet air and outlet air temperature (250 MW) 300 MW Stator Winding Temp. (oC)
250
Temperature (oC)
80
200
70
Stator Core Temp. (oC) 60
150
60
Temperature ( ̊ C)
40
100
50
50 20
40
0 0
30 0 10 20 30 40 50 60
20 No. of Days
Cold Air Inlet Temp. (̊C) Fig. 11. Stator core and winding temperature at 300MW
10 Hot Air Outlet Temp. (̊C) Table IV :Generator heat Test (250 MW)
0 Generator parts Unit Value Average Maximum
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 Stator winding o
C (95-100) 97.5 100
No. of Days Stator core o
C (73 -95) 74 95
Fig. 8. Inlet and outlet air temperature of cooler (300 MW) Thrust bearing o
C (56-64) 60 64
o
1 Upper guide bearing C (40-46) 43 46
o
0.995 Lower guide bearing C (39-46) 42.5 46
Air cooler
0.99 o
Temperature C (31-66) - -
0.985 cold/Hot
Efficicney
0.98 o
Air cooler water C (15-25) - -
0.975 TABLE V :GENERATOR HEAT TEST (300 MW)
0.97 Generator parts Unit Value Average Maximum
o
Stator winding C (103 -109) 103 109
0.965 o
Stator core C (78-96) 79 96
0.96 Efficiency at 250 MW Thrust bearing o
C (60-64) 62 64
0.955 Efficiency at 300 MW o
Upper guide bearing C (44-52) 44 52
o
0.95 Lower guide bearing C (41-48) 41 48
17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 Air cooler Temperature o
C (27-71) - -
Air cooler water inlet Temp.( ̊C) cold/Hot
o
Fig. 9. Efficiency performance of 250 MW and 300 MW Air cooler water C (15-25) - -
120 % overload 649.2 888.6 600.5 399.2 2.9 330.1 66.1 20.6 41.27 5.2 3003.67 0.9903
120%
Overload at 3oC 0.9889
650.9 889.1 602.8 401.2 3.1 332.6 69.7 21.4 42.48 5.2 3012.4
increase in cold
air
SG at rated and 20% overloads are shown in Fig. 9. The overall REFERENCES
efficiency of the synchronous generator is calculated as 0.9909 [1] B. Liddle, A. Tucker, I. Huntsman, M. Manders, and C. McDonald,
for 250 MW, 0.9903 for 20% overload and 0.9889 for 20% ‘‘Redesigning the rotor fan blades to improve the cooling of Roxburgh’s
overload with 3oC rise in temperature. Power delivery of rated hydro-generators,’’ 14th Australasian Fluid Mechanics Conference,
Adelaide University, Adelaide, Australia, December 2001, pp. 465- 468
and 20% overloads with stator core and stator winding
[2] IEC34-2A: Rotating electrical machines, Part 2, supplement A: Methods
temperature are shown in Fig. 10 and Fig 11. Generator heat for determing losses and efficiency of rotating electrical machines. 1.
test results for rated and 20% overloads are shown in Table IV Edition. Genf: IEC, 1974
and V. The various power losses in synchronous generator at [3] IEC60034-1: Rotating electrical machines, Part 1: Rating and
rated and 20 % of overloads are tabulated in Table VI. performance. 11. Au- flage. Genf: IEC, 04 2004
Compared to 250 MW, generator operate at 20 % of overload [4] IEC60034-2-2: Rotating electrical machines, Part 2-2: Specific methods
(300 MW) losses are amplified. From the analysis, it is for deter- mining separate losses of large machines from tests -
Supplement to IEC 60034-2-1. 1. Edition. Genf: IEC, 03 2010
observed that the maximum field current and stator current
[5] International Electrotechnical Commission, ‘‘Methods for determining
were reached to 2090.14A and 10968A, respectively, at rated losses and efficiency of rotating electrical machinery from tests
and 120% rated loads. Since the current is the primary function (excluding machines for traction vehicles) Measurement of losses by the
of overall temperature rise, it is clear that the efficiency of the calorimetric method,’’ IEC 60034-2A, Genève, Switzerland, 1974.
250 MW generator at normal loading condition is better than [6] ISO5801: Industrial fans - Performance testing using standardized
airways. 2nd Edition. Genf: ISO, 12 2007.
overloads. At 20% overload, the generator performance is
[7] Lide, D. : Handbook of Chemistry and Physics. 90th Edition. London,
slightly affected due to the increase in cooling air temperature. New York : CRC Press, 2010
This can be compensated by improving the performance of [8] Szabados, B, Mihalcea, A., ‘‘Design and Implementation of a
cooler provided for the generator. Calorimetric Measurement Facility for Determining Losses in Electrical
Machines,’’ IEEE Trans. Instrum. Meas., Vol. 51. No. 5, pp. 902-907,
VI. CONCLUSION October 2002.
The present study has investigated the performance of a [9] McLeod, P., Bradley, K. J., Ferrah, A., Magill, R., Clare, J. C., Wheeler,
P., Sewell, P., ‘‘High Precision Calorimetry for the Measurement of
277.8 MVA SG at rated and 20 % overloads. The efficiency Efficiency of Induction Motors,’’ The 1998 IEEE Industry Applications
of hydrogenrator was obtained through the Conference. Thirty-Third IAS Annual Meeting, St. Louis, MO, USA,
calorimetric/experimental test. With the measured results, the Conf. Publ. Vol. 1, pp. 304- 311, October 1998.
effects of cooler performance at different loading condition [10] Binns, K. J., Turner, D. R., Warne, D. F., Shamsadeen, B. N., ‘‘A balanced
calorimeter for measurement of induction motor losses,’’ Fifth
were analyzed. The investigation has led to the following main International Conference on Electrical Machines and Drives, London,
conclusions: (i) the measured hot air temperatures lies United Kingdom, Conf. Publ. No. 341, pp. 67-71, September 1991.
sufficiently below the normal design temperature range (60oC [11] IEEE115: Test Procedures for Synchronous Machines Part I and II. 3.
– 70oC) for the generator operating at rated loading condition, Edition. Washington DC: IEEE - Electric Machinery Committee, 12 1995
(ii) the hot air temperature maintains uniform flow behavior of [12] Turner, D. R., Binns, K. J., Shamsadeen, B. N., Warne, D. F., ‘‘Accurate
the circulating air, (iii) during the 20% overloading condition, measurement of induction motor losses using balance calorimeter,’’ IEE
Proc. B, Vol. 138, No. 5, pp. 233-242, September 1991.
hot air temperature range lies between 70oC to 80oC. The
[13] Georg Traxler-Samek, Richard Zickermann, Alexander Schwery,
difference between cold air leaving from the cooler and the "Cooling Airflow Losses and Temperatures in Large Air-Cooled
cooling water temperature is observed as 18°C which is higher Synchronous Machines", Industrial Electronics IEEE Transactions , vol.
by 8°C as per IEC 60085:2007. Due to this under performance 57, pp. 172-180, 2010
of cooler, machine efficiency drops out slightly (i.e. from [14] O. Aglen, ‘‘Calorimetric measurement of losses in air cooled and water
cooled asynchronous motors,’’ in Proc. ICEM, Vigo, Spain, vol. pp. 256---
0.9903 to 0.9889). These test results shall be helpful to the 262
plant authorities to operate the machine in effective manner by [15] W. Cao, K. J. Bradley, A. Member, and A. Ferrah, ‘‘Development of a
providing significant attention to cooling systems. High-Precision Calorimeter for Measuring Power Loss in Electrical
Machines,’’ vol. 58, no. 3, pp. 570---577, 2009.
APPENDIX
[16] B. Szabados and A. Mihalcea, ‘‘Design and implementation of a
Rated Output power 277.8 MVA calorimetric measurement facility for determining losses in electrical
Max. continuous output power 305.8 MVA machines,’’ IEEE Trans. Instrum. Meas., vol. 51, no. 5, pp. 902---907, Oct.
Power factor 0.9 lag 2002.
Frequency 50±3% Hz [17] E. Ritchie, J. K. Pedersen, F. Blaabjerg, and P. Hansen, ‘‘Calorimetric
Rate line voltage 15.75±5% kV measuring systems,’’ IEEE Ind. Appl. Mag., vol. 10, no. 3, pp. 70---78,
May/Jun. 2004.
Rated speed 214.3 rpm
[18] W. Cao, K. J. Bradley, I. French, and H. Zhang, ‘‘A review of calorimetric
Field voltage (at rated load) 300 V
application for accurate power loss measurement,’’ in Proc. 41st Int.
Field current (at rated load) 1600 A UPEC, Newcastle, U.K., Sep. 6---8, 2006, pp. 550---554
No. of poles 28 [19] H. Ales,F. Matej,’’ Investigating the malfunction of a Hydro-Generator’s
Cooling-System,’’ in Proc. 15th Int. Research, Czech Republic, 12-18
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT sept 2011.
[20] Project Report, ‘‘Evaluation and Checking of Adequacy of Project
The authors would like to thank THDC India Limited and Components for 20% Overload Condition of Karcham-Wangtoo
Jaiprakash Power Ventures Ltd., India for their support in Hydroelectric Project)’’, Dept. of WRD&M, Indian Institute of
funding and supplying the data required for this research work. Technology Roorkee, 2015.