Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
edited by
Green Chemistry Mary M. Kirchhoff
ACS Green Chemistry Institute
Washington, DC 20036
Developing instructional laboratory experiments that naphthalene, biphenyl, benzil, p-nitrotoluene, and benzophe-
demonstrate key chemical concepts while simultaneously in- none. Despite the educational and practical advantages de-
corporating green constraints is not trivial. The results of a rived from using aromatic substances, aromatic compounds
joint effort between faculty, graduate, and undergraduate stu- pose significant environmental and safety hazards, particu-
dents to develop a new greener laboratory designed to mea- larly in chlorinated or nitrated form (3). Safety hazards asso-
sure colligative properties are presented. Since colligative ciated with aromatics include carcinogenicity (4), noxious
properties depend on the number and not the identity of the fumes, bioaccumulation of halogenated aromatics, and
molecules being measured, there is no a priori reason why a ecotoxicity of nitroaromatics (5). A list of aromatic and
colligative properties experiment cannot be made rigorously nonaromatic compounds, cryoscopic constants, and freezing
green. points, some of which are commonly used in fp depression
The experiment presented here uses freezing point (fp) experiments, are provided in Table 1.
depression data to determine the molar mass, M, of an uni-
dentified compound (1, 2). Normally an aromatic solvent Green Aspects
such as p-dichlorobenzene is used because of a high cryoscopic
constant, convenient freezing point, ease of cleanup, and low As is apparent from Table 1, relatively few compounds
cost. Aromatic solvents readily dissolve aromatic compounds, simultaneously possess convenient freezing points and high
so the initial choice of solvent locks in the use of other aro- cryoscopic constants at a reasonable cost. The list is even
matic compounds as unidentified substances, for example, shorter when green constraints such as toxicity and bioaccum-
Experimental Procedures
In one laboratory period students determine the fp of
three fatty acid samples: pure stearic acid (ca. 9 g) and stearic SOAP
acid with first 1 g, then a total of 2 g of an unidentified fatty
acid (lauric, palmitic, or myristic) added. The students ob- cleaning
biodiesel wax
products
serve the depression in fp relative to the fp of the pure stearic
acid and use the information to determine the molar mass,
M, of their unidentified sample. Scheme 1. Comparison of conventional and green laboratory pro-
cedures for measuring colligative properties.
Colligative Properties Measurements
A hot water bath (85–90 ⬚C) is used to melt an accu-
rately weighed sample of about 9 g of stearic acid in a test
tube. The test tube containing the molten stearic acid at ap-
proximately 85 ⬚C is removed from the heating bath and
placed in an insulating jacket to cool (see the Supplemental
MaterialW). An alcohol-based thermometer is used to stir and Utilizing the Waste Stream
measure the temperature of the mixture over a period of 8– The fatty acid mixture is recovered by reheating to
10 minutes. Students record temperature data every 30 sec- 85 ⬚C and pouring the molten mixture into a clean, food-
onds. After completion of the first cooling trial, the measuring grade waste container for further use as a feedstock for mak-
procedure is repeated 2–3 more times. ing soap, biodiesel, or wax (see Supplemental MaterialW).
Next, an accurately weighed sample of about 1 g of an Residual fatty acids remaining in the test tube and on the
unidentified fatty acid is added to the stearic acid and the thermometer are dissolved with hot 2-propanol and trans-
measuring procedure repeated. An additional aliquot of about ferred to a separate container. Cooling of the 2-propanol mix-
1 g of the same unidentified fatty acid is added to the mix- ture or removal of the 2-propanol via rotary evaporation
ture and the measuring procedure again repeated. Collected allows an additional crop of fatty acids to be recovered. The
data are then analyzed (see the Calculations section below 2-propanol can be recycled and reused if desired. Even if the
for instructions and equation) to yield the M of the uniden- waste stream from the experiment is not utilized, recycled,
tified sample. or reused, it is at least benign.
90 25
∆Tf = 4.5 m
85 20
Temp / °C
80 15
Tf
freezing point
75 10
70 5
65 0
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 0 1 2 3 4 5 6
Figure 1. Example of data collected by students using a mixture of Figure 2. Plot of temperature change versus molality of the myristic
stearic and myristic acids. The squares represent temperature acid for addition of myristic acid to stearic acid. The initial slope
changes greater than 0.5 ⬚C per 30 seconds and the circles repre- of the line yields a kf value that matches the literature value over a
sent temperature changes by less than 0.5 ⬚C per 30 seconds. The wide range of molalities.
intersection of the two best-fit lines estimates the fp of the mixture.
Acknowledgments tions and quizzes, are all available in this issue of JCE
Online.
We would like to thank members of the Spring 2002
and 2003 introductory chemistry classes Denise Pisani, Literature Cited
Rosemarie Candido, Meredith Kocur, Emily King, Colt
Lorson, Patty-Ann Czismesia, Rosalie Wilson, Lisa 1. Parker, R. C.; Kristol, D. S. J. Chem. Educ. 1974, 71, 492.
Rinaldi, members of the GreenCats student organization, 2. Beran, J. A. Laboratory Manual for Principles of General Chem-
the ChemCats student organization president Anya istry, 5th ed.; John Wiley & Sons, Inc.: New York, 1994.
Gushchin, and the chemistry laboratory supervisor John 3. Educating for OSHA Savvy Chemists; Utterback, P. J., Nelson,
Sharp for their help in developing and implementing this D. A., Eds.; American Chemical Society: Washington DC,
laboratory. We would also like to thank the University of 1998; ACS Symposium Series Vol. 700.
Vermont and VT EPSCoR for their support of this work. 4. The Merck Index, 13th ed.; O’Neil, M., Ed.; Merck & Com-
Finally, acknowledgment is made to the donors of the Pe- pany, Inc.: Whitehouse Station, NJ, 2001.
troleum Research Fund, administered by the American 5. van Loon, W. M. G. M.; Wijnker, F. G.; Verwoerd, M. E.;
Chemical Society, Grant #36567-G3 for partial support Hermens, J. L. M. Anal. Chem. 1996, 68, 2916–2926.
of this research. 6. Lange’s Handbook of Chemistry; Dean, J. A., Ed.; McGraw-Hill
Inc.: New York, 1979.
W
Supplemental Material 7. CRC Handbook of Chemistry and Physics, 76th ed.; Lide, D.
R., Ed.; CRC Press Inc.: New York, 1995.
Comprehensive instructor notes, a detailed discussion 8. Anastas, P.; Warner, J. Green Chemistry: Theory and Practice;
of the freezing behavior of various fatty acid mixtures, ex- Oxford University Press: Oxford, 1998.
amples of typical data obtained, and a detailed description 9. Awang, R.; Ahmad, S.; Ghazali, R. J. Oil Palm Res. 2001, 13,
of the experimental protocols, including student calcula- 33–38.