See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/27674102

Publicidad y Consumo. Crítica de la Estética de Mercancías.

Article · January 1989

Source: OAI

CITATIONS READS
5 169

1 author:

Wolfgang Fritz Haug

Berliner Institut für kritische Theorie (InkriT)
44 PUBLICATIONS   214 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

Hightech-Kapitalismus in der politischen Krise View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Wolfgang Fritz Haug on 11 July 2017.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


  

     



 
 



  




 
 

  


 
 
 
 




 




   

    

 


 
  
 




   
 
  
 


   

  
   

 

 
   
    
 !  




  

" # 
  



  $ 
 




 
"



  %
  
 


 





   

   
 


 
    & 




  "






  
     '    




   
" ( 




 

  
  
)


 ) 
  

"  
  
)
   
 
 
  

  





*







  
  



 
 

   
 


+*
 
 
 
     



 




 
 *
    "





   
 
"


! 
   #

"$  
   

  
*



   
 )
 



,


  
     

- .,
  



/ 0


  
 
  
  
 

  
 
  
   1  
 

  


- 2 
   

 

   
  
 
 


 !




  "



   
   





 
  
 
 
    




 



  
    




  



 

 
   
  


  

  


  


 
 

 ( 



  

*





  

     



*



    3
 





  


  

   


 

 * 
*

 



      


 


4     
 




  1  

   

",    


  



    



 
3
 







  

 
  
 

   


 #  
$ 
   1
 # 







 $ 1
 #

 

 
*
$ 

 #

 

$
"


 
  




   

   

!

"  

 

 
   1 
 * 

 
 )  

    
   



*


' 
 

  



#


$ &
)


       
  )*

  ' 
 
5
  (
   
 ' ! )*
   )


  '  

   
 
  *
& 

 
 

    






 

  "  
   

 (

   
   
 
  !


  

      
 "   "   
"        


 6
   





  
  

  
    
#



   

 

     
 
 


 
#

$


     

7

#
*
" 
$     
    

  

                   
                  !  

.,
  

 8


  

  

7

" 
  "

  
 *     




&  1    
 
  
)

 
  
 

,  

   '
 


  
 
"

   7*

   9 



   

  
 
 


1

 
*


'
 ( 
  " 
  
 
 

 
 
&

 

       
 
  




 
 



 & 

)' 
1 
1 
 


   
  







   
   






 

 
 
 #
  


  



   
  


  


(

 
  
 
   )

 

      




  






 


 


    

   1

 



 


   
   

     


  
 
&
"  
 
 
 

     
 

 "
  
 "  
*)

  


 
 (



 


 
 




 


  
  
  
   
  





")


 



 & 



 

")
 
 

")

 
 
  


 

     *

 
 
2
  
  


   1 
 
  *



# )   

$ 
* 






  "
 1   
  4 


  



 

  
   
 

 *


 


 
 

    


 





 



     *

  
 
  

 
'
 

7



 


  
 ! 



  




 

   

 
    


 
 
  

  '

!  


"
   
(
   

 '
 


 


 

  
 
 

 &  
 
*




1   

  


 '
    




   
   

  
   
  
  


 '

  



 ' 






( 
 
    
  
       


  
   
    
   



  
 & 

:



  

   

"   
 
 
  :  


; .,
  





  '   1  


 

 
 < 5   $

 %  &

 
  
     


 




#



!
 
 

"  




"

 
 
 
    

  =  
  

    






        

&
  
  
   

"   
    

 
*
  



    
  & 
   




 
   
 

   *



)
   

 

(
 


 *

# 
   *

 



    
 

 
  *
 
 &  
 








  
  

 

 


 
 
   

    *

*


   

      *

3 

 
    

" 

  

    
  
   
   
    
 

 
  




   
  
 
  
  





 

 

  






  

>


  
  
  "  


  


" (
     

 

 
 

 '  




 





    




"
 (  
  

  



  



    


"


  

   

 
  

 
  
   

 


  2 



  


  


   

  
 
 
 






  
4
 
  
   

    
   


 
 





  
  
 
 

  

" 


 



   

" 
 
    1   1
   


 

 


     =
  
 3
 

 


3
  
  
  
 1

 *   


" (
 )

 *  )
  
  

 
 
.,
  

 ?

   

 

  *

 &  )

 


  

 '


 


  
  

9    
  
 
1

 
   

 

 
   


 6 


  
  
:1  1   
 
  
: 
 
 

 

'  
  
 

  

 
        


         





#
$ "
 
  

 


2


   
  
 
 

1
 



    

" 
 
  
  



"
      7*
 
 9
 

    '




   (  

  

"   





# 6   



 *
 
 


 (  
 
 
 


  

"   

 #
 6   


    *
 

 
 
     
  

!  

 
 


 1

    
  
 



   : 
    



'

  


:   
 
 6 
   
 
 



   



  

 
*

@3
  
 

  
  

 


 
A & )   


  

 
 


   
  

&
#

 
'  



 

 




 
 
  


  

"  



 


  , B
1   
  
  
  

"
  

  
    '
A !  
 
 , 

  

 

 9
  


   
 




'
    ( 
'
 
#

 
 
'
 
 (
 
  
 



#



  '
$ 
 





   
  


  
     

 " #  $                

                   
   %      
 %  &      !
          '    (    
 )           (        
            $ *      
     

       +%      
                   
       )      
,-
  .
C .,
  




        
    
   
  

        
  

  

& 
 

 5  
  



    1 


  

  
   "   
  "
 

,  
  



   

     

 '


 
 

 & 
  
  
 

   
    

 B 
  


 



A
)

 
 
   


   



 

 !

   

"  
  




 
'  
   )
   




 
 '1 


 *


 
    

 
  
 
 
6



*

 


  
  
 4



 1 

  


 1
   



 



      
    
 9   



 * 


 



 
   

" 






*  
  
   

 
    
*

  
 
  
  

  


, 




 
  *  
  
  =   
  *
 

    
 
  
*
  
  

*



(

 
 

 


 #

 

 # 

  
 
 


  #






 
  &


   

"   

 )





   

  
  


3
 

 
 
 
  




 *



     
 
 


 


+

  
#  




 
 ,

 
  




 

 



 
 

  

 
#  



 
  +*







  

"

" 
 
 
   *
 
 !    

  

"  1  



   

  



 * D


 

  
  
   
 
 

 
 *

"


  

*
  *  
  
 (
 *
 


 

    

   
  *  
  
    
  
  
 


    
 
  


 *

     


 
 (
 
   
 

 
  
  
   
  
   

 


  

   
 





  



' 


  
 
   
.,
  

 E



#


 
 



%
  
 
 
 
  "   
 

& 

 
  


    
 
 
,  

 

  
  
 2
  

   

" 

  

 

 
      
  '
  
 
 

( 

 






 
#  
 

   #
 
 
  

  

# ! 
 
 
 
  
  
  

   




#   

  

 


 $
& 

   
 
 
  
 
  


"       
 

   

" 

  
  
 #
    *  5 &






  

:
  
 

 





 
  :  
 
    
 

 

 


   

" 


 
   



#
  


" 





    
   

  
 

   
  
  *
$ !







   *
 
   
)
  
 




  


   
 
 
   






!  

  
      *

  
  


   ,  #
 !


  
 


 
   
 
   
  
 .







  

"


 
*
 

 


     

  

" 9  





#

 
 

       
 

  
 
  


    

   

   

 





  1  &


  





  
#


 

  #

 
    

 
 

 

   
' 
 





 

 

 
 


 
!  

 
  

"  

   
  

   
   
  
   
 

   
 &  
   

 
   

" 

 
  
  
  
 



   

   

 
#  

 

#



 
 


 

 4 


  
 
 
   "  
   
  


 
 
 %
 


 

 
 



  




  ! 
 
  
 




 
   
  
  





     

" 
  
  
   


 

 
    * D  

  
 


 
 
   



 '
  
 



 
 ! 
" 



    
  
   
7       * 
 
  
  
 
F .,
  



*
  
 9    

 
 
 

 
#   
 
  


 #
 #


  

   #

 

   
#   #




#
$ 
%
 

 


& 



 

   
 
   

   
  
  
  
 &  *



   


  


#


 

   

 !  )
 






  #

 

 
 


 #
  

      



  
   

" !
 
 
  
       * (


 
 

 

  


 
 
  


 


 
& 



)


 



 
   
  


" 2 
     
 
 
 






  " 

  

 


& 

           
#
  #
 


  *


 

  

  


 


 
)

 


  

" !


  
'   



   

       * 
 




 
   " 


  


&
"



   
  

" 
   


  
,


  

"       *  

"

 
 G 

   

  
 

1

        *
,  

 


     
     

 !  
 


 


 
 )
 
   
 


 !

 

& 
'


  



   
 



 
6   
 

    
 



 
 
  

  
 
  
 



  H

   
  
  


     

   

 " '       
   

     
  


   


" 
    *

, 
 
 1 ;  
  



 
 ! 
 

  


  

  
 
 
   
  ' !






 

7

 51   
    
 



          

 '


' 

 !    *  
  
 
  
   

  
 





  

.,
  

 I

   
  
 

 

" 
  
     

# 

&

'
 
  


! 
  


*
    
 





   & 



 
 
 

  "  
  

 
 



    

   
  





 D
    1

  

(


 
  



  


   


" 

  
 
 


 
    


   


 
  
 
  

 , 
 


& 
     
 
    

#
 



 
 
'

  
$ 


, 

" 

 

 
  
 J
  "


)  




  *
 




  

 
 ! 

   1 
  

  
 & 

 
 



  
 
  
     

 2
 
  
 
   ! 
 
 M − D − M 





  
   

 
 D





  


  



  1
 %
  

 
  1
 
   

 
")
    


 

"  

& 
 1
    :     

" 
 
:
      
 


  
  
 9 " # 

   
 $   




  


'
  
 
  
'
  
  
   
     

   
'
  


 
  
*




   

   

    
 
 
  
 2   





*
 9      
 
 




  

      
 
 & 
 
    
 


  



  

"
 



)   


 &    
 






  )     

 
 '




 
  '  

  
'




   
 


  
 & 






   
 " 

  







 
5




   


  

   *

*

 &  
      
  
  
 

  

"   5'

  
 
 

  *


  
 
 
 

  



 
 

 


  
 
  
 (

 
/K .,
  



 

1 

    ) 


6  
 



   
 4 
     
  


 
 


 
 3
 
  


 
   
  1
 
 )
& 

 
   


)
 





 
 
  *


 
*




  9
    



 



 

  


   







   '  

& 

  
    
  




 

   

 ) 
   

 


&

#
"



&  
 M − D − M   
  D − M − D,

 
 & 
  
       

& 

'    


, 
  (
 
    
   
 (


 

  )   

 
  



  51    







#

$ & 
 " 1

 



 ) 

 *
  

"  "  
 






  
 
  


  )  
 D



   
   =        







 

 
  

     
  

! 

   
 
6  




  



 '
 
& 

 
   
'
 
 


   

!

"    
 
 
1



  


  
'

&



  
    
   
'  "

 & 
  
 

"
  






'  
  
 




  
 
 

& 
 
 
   
 
 , 



"     
    


)

 
 

 

"  





)



  3
 

 
  
   

  
   ) 

   )
    






  

 4
 



  
  

 
'  =
 


 1

  
 

  ,  

    

 
   
  

 9  

  







 
    * 

  1
 

 &  



 
 
& 


  

   

 
6  





 


 


!
 =
  


  
  




 


   
  

 &    

 
      


 
'
 ! 
 

   
'  " 
  


 

 
.,
  

 //

 " 
 

) ( '
 


 
   "

 
! 
 
    

 " 
  3
 


 
 

  ) # 
 )  
$ 

*

 



  *
   
   
 
 * 
!  
    
 
 
 



 
 
 &  
 

   
 
1  

 
   
   
  
  
 

 & 
 
  )
  )
   


 





 
 

  *
  " 9  



 
    
   

"  

 
 
 
  

  

  
 
    " !


 


  


 '   *

 
   

" 1 
  
 




 
)  
' !   



 
'    


  

 
  
   
   



" 
  
   
 

&

 






! 
 
  

   


   
  
'  

     
 
 & 

 

     
   *
 



  
 



 
  2





 

 
 :


 

   
  


 




"
  
 

       
 '   *
* 
   
   
 *"
 

    '  
 
 : 
    
 
 

   *
 

  &  

  


 D − M − D
  '   *
:

 
  D  D
:
  


  


 


  



 
          


    

  &    
 


    
   


 *
  
    *
 

& )    

 
   
   
6 

  
 #)  
$  
 


1  

6   
 
 
 
 
 
 

 
    *
 
 "        ) *    * %     %
   *     /  0    & %  
                * %   
          %  '   '  
  

        #    )           #1

   
 

     *  2      
 3             *    '    1
             *   %    !
       *   %        * 
/- .,
  



&

(  
 %%
       




 
 
   

  

  
 
 

 
  
   



 



     

  *    


 

 4 


    

 



 


  
  

 .
  



 


   '
 # D  
'
   
)


 




  

  
'
   *
6 
 

 
  

   
1
 
 

& 

   ' 

  
 
 
  
 

  
'   




  9 


 
 

  


 
  '  

    

 

 '


$ !    
   

!
 




  
   





"




  2

     

  









     
 
   
 6 
 
 
   
 

 



  4



 
 



"  
 




  :
 '  
 
  L

: " 


 
 !


  


     





  



"




  !  




    





 
 
   



   

   
>
  
 
 
 
 

   
 

   


 1  
L

  

  
 
    
  
'





  
# & 


    


 



  
 


 


" *  

  
  
  

 





    

    



 
 





 

   '    
  
 

  ! 

" 

    *
 
  

  


  
    

" 
 
 


    


"
& 
  
      
  

"   *
 
 


  
 
  









  

 

   


    
' 

  

"



  &    


 



 


  
    

  

 



 
 2



  




   



    #                
          %   

.,
  

 /8





  

    
"

 




 



 
!
     
  
  
 
 
    

" &  "

    

" 




  








  
  
 ! 
     

:

)
 


   
:   

  

"



 

% !    
  


9"  






  
  

 


  
# 1   "
    !
 
   
 
  
  
  *





 


  

"

& !    
 
  

)

  

  
%

! 


  
  

   
 

 
  




      



1

 ! 


  
   


 (   

"
          
  
 '  






  


 3
 
   


   

   
 







 





 
 

 
 





 
6 
  
 







,
/   

*   
  

" 
-   
 
 


   
 '     



(
  


     
  

)
 

  



9"      

" 



  

"
  1
 
 
  
  
   

 

     

    


 
     


"   
 

   
   


 !

   

"   





 



)

#



%
 %
  
! 


 
    )
 


   


 



     
      

 




 
/; .,
  



  

 
   

"
     
  


 
  9"  
  

"   










   )
 

  

" 



 





! 



   

 
  
:
  

)

:  
  
   

 (




 
  
  
   


 


     
 



 

 



 
  


  


)

#



%
 %
  
3




 
 " 
    * 
 
1


       

" (
  
  )





  
  
 

   

 
  
6 




 

  
  
'
 2  )
 

  

"
 

   

   
  


   

 


 



     
  
    * 2     "  







  

"          


 

 


  
 

 *
 )

 

 

 

  
 M"

   1

   

 


" :'

: 

     


 
'  

   &  
      
  

  

  


 
9 
  

"  
 
    

 

   


 
 

 



9 
 




  
     
 


  

" & 
    
 6 


   
   1
  






   '
         
  
      


  "    
 )
 


   


)


 


 
   


       $  *

%

  
  

&  
   


  

   

  


 





  
   



      & 


  

    
 

    
  
 


 1 
  

 
 
  


 
   

  


  
  

" (       



 
     
  
  

" 
 4    #             
    

.,
  

 /?

  " 
   
  

 
   
  


"      

&  

  

 
 




   
 


 


  



 

 
   



 

)
   
   

"    



   

# $  



!

)
 
   

"    )
  



  

   6   
    


  




 ' 6 
   
' 



 

)
 )*

"   
   

"      
 



  

6 

    
  
)
 
     



    

"
! 
  

" " 1  
 





 

 
  
  
 &    
 
 '
 


        




' (  
)
       


 *  


+

  
  
&


  

"   
    

 
  
 (



*
  
  
     








  & 




 1 
     
 
'
  

  

)
  
 5 



  

" 
  

1
 

  
 ! ) 

  
*



 #
 *
  



 '   


 

   
$ !


 


   
  
  
  
 ! 


 
 


  

  
  1


 N






 
 :


 1

 
  
 


 



:     

" 


 

 
  
  


+

   % 
   ,  

 $ 
    
D 




 
 
 



  
 

 

"      

 


 

 

 
 

  



 

"  
)

   

 
  


   
 
!
 

*
 
   1

    
 



   

" 
 
 
 
  
 ! 
 

  
      ' 
   

 

" 

"
 
   
 


 9


  
   
/C .,
  



 1  *





  6  
  
 9  1





   

 
 #



$   



 ,  
         

" 



  
  

     "    



&
 
  

  


    

 

"

  
 )
)
  


 



 4    *



      '  "


 
  
  


)'      
   
  & 


  

  
")

  
  
  
 
  
 
 
")



    ' 
 


+

   % 
 %  




&  

  
    

"    

    

)*
 &  

 


 



 
 


  
  
 &



  1


 
   
  
  
 5     


   

    
 
  




  
   1  

& 
      

   
 &  1






     
 

  
&


   
  



     
  
   
   
   
  

    



   !

")


  

 
 



   
  
 



  '  



4  
  


    
 
 
 :

  


 

 

:  

"  

 
  
 
 !

")

  


    


 

    



 
  

 


  
 #5$ 3


   
      
   



  
 
  



#.$
N

    
  
     

 



   

 



 
")
 3    
 
   *
  




+

-%
    .  "
  $   
    "
" 
 

!
 


 
  
 "
 



  
 



 &  
  
 1
   
 
 

 
  
 


 *"

.,
  

 /E

+ ( )
        

,         


/

#
0
.
 

    
 
   
  


"   


  

" 9" 
  
"  

  

"

'

  1     
  

 

 
   )
 & 
    
"   

   



 
 

  

"     

.
 
 




 
   
  

"
   
   
,
 




 

  
 

  
  


  
 


 

 &



   


 
 
   1


 =
 

"  





 
  

   
'

  



")
 9 



 
   
  '



 #


/

 


&  


  

   *




 






   


  

)



  
    

 
   )
 

 


" 
   
 
 
#
 4 
    *
  




  
  
#


 
$ 3

  
  *     

  

   





  

9  
  
 #  



  
$  
 
  

" 2     
   )
 


  

" : 
  
 
:6   


 

    

    

 

 
    * 9"
   

   



   * 
 


 
 





   

  
 
 



 

   
 
 
4  

  

  


  =
6
 

  
  #
  " 
 






' 



 
 #


  4  
*

)
 
  *     
 


  1

 

/

 



!
 
 
  
 

 

 
  

'  

  

" 2
   
      


    
 O  


   *

 
  

)
  7*   


  '1
 "
/F .,
  



/

#

 


D 




 "

 
  
 

 *


)
 
   


 
  

"  







    




      

!  
    
   

& 


     
  

 



   

" (

  
)

 

  


"   
   )  
  
 










  " !

  )

   
  

" 



  
  

   
 1 

  


 '
 

9   



  '
 
  

  
 
   



6   

 *


  

 
 

  

"  
1 
  





 !    
 


     %
  
& 


  






   





 ! 


      
   



    
 




 ! 
   
 


  
  



  
 
'

  
   

" ! 

   


 


"

 
   
    








  




 






  












   '     #
 
 

"


 

   
 
  
  
 


"
& 
  


   

)

 
 
 
2 "   
  
 
  
& 
   
  


)  


 

 

  
 

  
  
 '
 
 

  
 

 
  & 
  

  


   
    
 

  
 '

 

  
   
  

 
 
!   
 
   "
#
  

!  
  $    
  "
% 
 
         

        
 
 
"  # 


 
!     
 
 




 
 & 
   '! 
 

 
   
  (
) 

  
.,
  

 /I

(  #  
 
  
  


  






& 
 

 
    

  

  

 

)
 # 




 


  

 
 
 )



 $


   


 


 

(
 
  "

 
    
 

 *  
 


  & 

  


 
  ' 




 " 




 (


   






 



 
   



 










   




 O7 
 
 
 

  





   


 
 
 





 (







 






 
  ' 
      
 

 

.
  " 



 



    

3

  
      
   

 
 



  

" .  

 
   
" 
' #  


   
 

  
  
 


"$ 
 * 
      
  


% 
   

 
#   
   #


   
 *
  
(
  *   


   

  
  ' 
  #
   
+
   #
 
   
 #


  
 #
    "
#
     
 $   

 ' '
    #
     #     +
 
  #
 
 '  
 
     
  
 !
    
  
) 


.  


   


"  






"   
  
 6 
 
  
  


 
 
   




 ! 

   
  







   '  

)
 

  

"    
 & "

 
    
   





 
  

!


 
 
 

 



 ' 1 

 


     

  



 
  

")
    3

 
    
 

 

 
   '  

  
     

  

   

 &


  .  
 
 

 
   
  
 
#  
  &






 
   
 


  
"  



 



 

  
  
 !  
 
 
    


"   !
 "

  
  
 
    
 


     
  

 
 


   

"
-K .,
  




1
  2  "



 
 



 )*
    

  
  *',
4 2
P
& *'   
 
!
  :"

 
:
& 

:
  

 :
Q'  





 4 
P   
  #

 $ 
 

"  
 
  !
     

 
 
  

 
 
  
   
 

   
 
    ' 
     











 & 

   
  

 
 =   

 
     * 91 

   
  
  
  

   
  
 



*   
   
 *

  
  



 


 #
"   
   *$

&


 




  '

 
 




 
  

  (



  




 '  " 
 


    
 

 



!   

 


 
  




 
 






  
   
 
  2  

"  
 
    
  

  
      
  





   


")

 



 " 
 3
  






     
    
  





91

   1   
  
, 


=" 5  *
  
 



  ,  
)     

  
& 





 
  
  

"
  



 




 




6 
 
 



 



" 
 

 D
 *

 




3 '
  )

   


    1 '





   
' 
    

  

 
   
  


 

 




     


 
 
  



 


&    


 


 
 
  


  




 
 ,     

  '


  "  


   1 
  

 # 
$6  
  
   


   


"

 




 
  

!


    

  









 
   


  
 
 '
  

.,
  

 -/

 



 
 

    



  


 
 
! )

  
 
 


 # 






 

 $  
   
  
 

6    


     
 
&


    
  
 




  7*



   




 2  
  



 
 
1 
    



 




D1  
  



     






 
  
 
1 *




)
  



 7 1  

  

" 
  
    





 &
 "

 



  
  
  


 
  
     
  
 
 
 
    
  
 ! 
 1 
    



       
  
 
   


  



   
  
& 



 
 


  
  

 
 

 '

   


    *

 
 
 
 




  
  *
 

! 

  "

 
  

   
  






 4 
  
 
  





 
*



 ( ,  


   -

 ,  
    
 



&   *   
   





 
  
 

    
  
"

 
 3
 


 
  



 
  


  

"  









 3
  

 
  

" 
   

"  ' 


"
   1


 
*
      * 
  










& 1

   
     


 ' 
 2 
 1 '    
 & 
   



 

)

 1     
  
  
 




  
 
 

      
 
    '

             

      !
  "       
  

  
 

 
) 

  


   

 
  

! 

   


    


  
 
-- .,
  



 
 
 
 


   

     =


 
*
   
'  
    
%  
 

 




#


 


! 
 
 
   "
' 





  

 &  
 1 
"    




   





  


  
  



"  

   = 
* & 1


 



   

"
 
 
   

   
1

 
3
 
  

  

 


  
  
  

 &   
  =
 

" 
 
  


  
 
  
 9
   " (




 
 "    =



 *  
9" "   
 



&    

    


   

  
 

  

 

"



 

 


 
  



*    &
 
 
 



     =


9


 
 * 1 " 
  
 &
 

  
  
   

*   
 
 

  
 


  

" 9    
 

  




  
 
 
  
*

  

& 
 


  

*   
 

  


  

" &  

   

  
  


  



 
 


  

&   
 
   
1
  

" 

   
   

" 

  

 '

  
 


    
   

 



   


   

 !    
 
  



3 %
 

.
 
  


 
 
  


  
     

     

 !  
 

#
  
$ 

  #
  
 $   !


 


   

"  

   




 






 
 
   
  









 

 

 & 
 

 

   
 
  
  
  
 '  


"      

'  


.,
  

 -8

  4
 
 '
    
'
   


  

", 
 
  

*
 
 
  

 
  
   
 
  


  

 
  
  

"
9  
 



  


 

3






   


 


    

*   * 9  

*  





 
 

 


  
 '
 
 




 

  




   
  
   , 

   

! 

"  
 

   
  
 

 
 
  '
   

   
  



   *
3 
   "   1 (



,  



   ' 
 
 1  1   
   
!

  


     ! 

  
 




 (


 


 1 
 

"  
 =  

 '  " 
& "

 
 

 '  " 
6  


 






   1 
 &  
      

 


   





 
  
 %   



)
  
  

"





 1 

  
 
  
  



    
 2  
  
 
  



  
" 


 
  






 ! 
   


 

 
 



3 %
 
$ 

5
  

"  *


 &
 
 

 

  

"  





,  
)
 

 



   
" N   

 


  
 9"
 1 

 *
5 
 
1
 


   

 

      
"6    
 

   


 
 


     

 
    
 &
 
 
  

   

  1 
  


  

 

 
(




"  *


 ' 
 )

 


   



6 


   
 







    

' 
    
 



   
 


  #  

 



 ! 


 

  






 

  

-; .,
  



 
    
 9   






 

 

  






    






   1



 

 
      


 (



     
 




 
 

! 
 
    
 


    

 
 


   *
 
  

  1 
 
  





  & 



  
'   '


 
.
 
  

 
 



 
 

  "

 
 (

    





 


 

    


 
 
 

  

 D
 
   

 
  1 


 



  1   
 2



    '

     

  

 
  1 

  
   
 
    

!   

' 
 


 







  


 (
 

  
  
 
 





      

   

 


  
     1  

)

 
 !
 


 
    

 
 

 





   
1
 

 
  *
  
   
2*
    


 
  
  
  

  

 

   

  

 

 
   6 
  



 
1




 
" 
  

" 
 !
 

  

1 
" 
  
     
   
     
   

   
  



  

   
1




- 


! 

 
  

" 



#


 4

 
 

,  ) 
  

 
  




 
  
  


 
 
"  ' 
  
  


  
  


3







   

 



  






 #



  D

 
 





 
   

 
  
 &






 



  

  
 )
  




 

 


    '  






   
   
  

    



! 

 
 
' 
*

  


  


   
 ! 
 

     






 
  

    !
 


 


 


   



 
  
  





 &


)  
 


   
  


.,
  

 -?


 ,
 ' 1     






  "
  


 
 
  

&  

L



 
    7    
 
  
*   *   ) 
 '   
 


  

"   
   G
'
 
 









 



"
 
 '
 
 




 
 & 

 
   )   




 
    


 

  
 




3
 

    

  *
 



 
 



 




 R .
      

 
 
 





  

  



    

 

   
6 
 *




 




   9


 

   
   


 


  
 
#
   7*

 


 
 & 
* 
  *









 
 




 
   
    
 +
*











  

   *




   
 
")
   
  
 ! * 

  

*





 

" 


 
 
"



        
   


*
 
 
")
   
   6   

  



       *    
 
  
    
*


 . *     


2

"  
  0  2   )




 
   
 
   
    

 6  "


    


" 

  



   


"  
(
  


")

 )
 

  
 
 

 

 
 

 )



 


 




 



  

 

  
  !

)
 1

   


  
    
   



   

   
 

  

  
      
   
(
 
  


  
, 
*
  
  




  
*
 

  

 
 
  
  

 
 
 ! )
 
=     


 (
  
   
 




  =
 

" &    )  
5 
  '  )

 

 

 



)

   
   

   (
 
  
-C .,
  



)

   
 
  
    



 
  (
    
 
  
  


   
9 

   
  

1   
  
 

 

 &

  
 
 
  
*

 
" 

*   

 ! 

 
  
     

 

*
 
 D

*
  
  
   



 

   


  

 

1
  

&
  

"  
 
  
  
   
 
 
 

   

     


 
  
")
  
 
  )



* 




 
  
 




 
 
 
 "


+      )

   "

 !
 



 



 
")

      )
  
)

 & 
 
 M"





  
 )


     )

     
 1

 *

+   '  *
 

    
   

" 



   )
  
 
(
  
 





 

 
 
 M"


 .
  
*  




  

"


 



#
  1

$ 

 

 9" 

 '

    


   
   
 

 





 )

 
 

1


 
 
   

* !  


 
 '

 

   


 
 4  

 

 
 
   


 
")
  



   


 
  
! 
    
      

,  
  

"     )

"

6 


 

 
*  
 "

 

 

 


  


   
  

     

  & 

"

  



 
 
  ! 
  )  


  )
   


6    
 

 

 # 


  

"

  


$  
  )
  

*
 )


  



   )
 2   
 

"   



  
 





 
 
 1 1


 

  1

 *

!
  
  

 
 " 
 
  )




*  (


 

  

   


 
 
  
 
 

   


 &



  
    


 


 





  


   

 D  
 





 



  
 

  4 
 
  

  
 





  *  


 
  
 .,
  

 -E

 
    

   
 
!   
 
 
 

 


 

 
  


 



  
 

 !
 

  
 
     



    


  

" 
+*
 7*
   
  
 
'1 
 
 

   
 
 

 2 
  *  


   


 

  )
 
 )

 
)
 
   
 
 
& 

 7*
  

 
     


  1 "
      

 & 




   
'  
6   

   1 

'
    (
 

 
 


  
 

   !
  " 
  '





 

 
  
 


 
   
  
 
 
       
  
 
 
 

 

(
 
 
 


   

 



 

 ! 
  

  
    





   
  


 

   





 2  
   "


  

 

 
 
  

" & 


 




 
 

      
  
 
 


 

View publication stats