Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
CONTENTS
32 Worldwide news
ICM Mission statement
Ichildbearing
n the late 1980s the world became acutely aware of the alarming fact that in many parts of the world,
was not a joyful occasion. The risk of serious complications, disability and death was so high
that women often said good bye to their other children and family members before embarking on the
process of birth. The facts then were clear. More than a half a million women would die each year as a result
of pregnancy and childbirth. In 1987, the World Bank, in collaboration with WHO and UNFPA, sponsored a
conference on safe motherhood in Nairobi, Kenya, to help raise global awareness about the impact of
maternal mortality and morbidity. The conference launched the Safe Motherhood Initiative, which issued an
international call to action to reduce maternal mortality and morbidity, and the challenge was taken up. The
M-word, motherhood, was chosen to reflect both pregnancy and childbirth and respect this rite of passage in a
women’s life. Safe Motherhood became the focus of country developed programmes and strategies. These
Kathy Herschderfer,
included providing family planning services, providing post abortion care, promoting antenatal care, ensuring ICM Secretary
skilled assistance during childbirth, improving essential obstetric care and addressing the reproductive health General
needs of adolescents. All these areas are part and parcel of the global work terrain of midwives.
Two years earlier, in 1985, the Lancet had published an article by Allen Rosenfield and Deborah Maine,1 which challenged the
public health establishment, entitled ‘Where is the M in MCH (Maternal Child Health’. They stated that scrutiny of existing MCH
programmes had shown that they did little to reduce maternal mortality. The authors called for more attention to the maternal
component of MCH. Emergency (also called essential) obstetric care was identified as the key strategy to reducing mortality. This is
also an area of work that belongs to the field of midwifery in a growing number of countries.
At the beginning of the new Millennium (another M-word), international commitment to reducing maternal mortality was
reaffirmed when 149 government leaders from 191 United Nations member states committed themselves to achieving a set of
Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) by 2015. The fifth goal is the reduction of maternal mortality. The proportion of births with
a skilled attendant will be used to monitor progress towards this goal.
ICM has been actively involved in the Safe Motherhood Initiative since its conception in 1987 and, throughout the years,
although the partners have expanded, forums have shifted and the newborn has been added as an individual component in MNCH (an
N-word), we have been a consistent and strong voice for another M-word: MIDWIFERY. There has been significant debate about the
term skilled birth attendant and how this relates to the midwifery profession, and the ICM has been clear in stating two positions: 1)
there is an ICM developed definition of a midwife indicating that a midwife is educated and duly recognised to practise midwifery
and 2) the ICM Essential Competencies for Basic Midwifery Practice is the evidence base to defining midwifery practice (skills,
knowledge and attitude). There is global consensus that the term skilled birth attendant is someone who has core midwifery skills as
defined by the ICM Essential Competencies.2 The World Health Report 2005 stated that ‘the prototype of the skilled birth attendant is
the licensed midwife’. ICM Council approved a position statement in 2005 called ‘The midwife is the first-choice health professional
for childbearing women’. And yet, despite all this, the term skilled birth attendant is used more widely than the term Midwife.
Unfortunately, Midwifery is still not yet universally recognised for what it is; an evidence based strategy that contributes positively to
the health of childbearing women and reduces the risks of maternal death and disability. We have spoken out the M-word so often that
even when our names are not known, we are often recognised as ‘the midwife’ during events and meetings in the international arena.
Our efforts were not in vain. The realisation of the global human resources for health crisis has brought new alliances and
initiatives and more important, new recognition of the midwifery profession as part of the larger global health workforce and the part
midwives play in enhancing Maternal health. One of ICM’s core partners, the UNFPA, has committed resources to scaling up
midwifery, recognising the importance of midwives in the community setting. In the 2006 series in the Lancet on Maternal Survival,
the use of midwifery-led community facilities was recommended as a strategy. Donors, UN agencies, NGOs and policy makers are
slowly starting to use the M-word. There is a growing momentum of interest in our profession.
ICM advocates for midwives and midwifery, not as a means of self-fulfilment but from the core belief that midwifery does make
a difference for mothers and babies. In a perfect world, there would be universal midwifery coverage to all childbearing women and
their families, but this is a long-term vision. The reality we face today is unsettling. Despite many good and some very successful
efforts, 20 years after the launch of the Safe Motherhood Initiative, more than half a million women still die each year due to
pregnancy- and birth-related causes. There are not enough midwives in the world and the profession desperately needs teachers and
leaders.
This year the 20th anniversary of the Safe Motherhood Initiative will be commemorated in many ways and in various venues
leading up to a large Conference in London in October.3 This is an opportunity to profile and promote the M-word outside our natural
circle of partners and acquaintances. ICM pledges to be present and vocal - and will use every opportunity to use the M-word,
MIDWIFERY.
1. Rosenfield A, Maine D. Maternal mortality - a neglected tragedy. Where is the M in MCH? Lancet 1985; 2: 83-85.
2. Making Pregnancy Safer : the critical role of the skilled attendant; 2004, WHO Geneva.
3. http://www.womendeliver.org
In addition, the Malawian Road Map, developed during the Lessons learnt
Maputo Plan of Action for the Operationalisation of the The way in which the Malawian midwives demonstrated that
Continental Policy Framework for Sexual and Reproductive they had been motivated and empowered suggests that this is
Health and Rights 2007-2010, is a strategy on which an effective model to use in other countries. The approach
midwives can capitalise for how to make midwifery visible would need to be adapted to each country’s context but the
and how to build capacity for reducing maternal and neonatal manner of operationalisation of the workshop ensures that the
mortality and morbidity. Opportunely, the theme of the Road midwives’ voices are heard – literally by those who are
Map is ‘Maternal death is preventable. No more silence. Act charged with decision and policy making.
now!’ All organisations represented pledged support for The model also achieves the objective of profiling and
midwives and midwifery. positioning midwifery as an essential resource in health
systems and as a means of improving health outcomes of
Group work childbearing women and their newborns. This is a rare
After group discussion sessions which focused on the Malawi opportunity in many low resource countries and in Malawi
midwives’ concept of ‘The Malawi midwife today‘ and specifically - as was voiced by the participants of this
‘Where do midwives in Malawi want to be in the future?’, the workshop. When the midwives presented their analyses and
key issues emerging from the group presentations were: solutions to their own supervisors, policy makers and
stakeholders, it became visible that they were proud and
Opportunities - midwifery work was acknowledged and
confident to do so. It was clear that, with support, midwives
valued by all as vital to reduction of maternal and neonatal
were confident to demand - not request - appropriate
mortality and morbidity. The existence of AMAMI was
equipment, a good working environment and adequate
perceived as a pillar of the structure for advancing the
remuneration; they were also able to express their rights to
midwifery agenda and strengthening advocacy for women’s
those demands. Some policy makers verbalised that this was
health in partnership with the ICM, WHO and UNFPA.
the first time midwives had worked together so hard in such a
Threats - however, midwifery is faced with challenges. There short time, producing and presenting information useful for
are unacceptably high maternal mortality ratios and a policy development.
consequent need to take midwifery services to where women
live. At the same time there are severe shortages of staff and a
continuing staff exodus to greener pastures, owing to the poor
working environment, poor remuneration, insecurity and poor
housing, lack of status and hence visibility.
Possible solutions - for maximum impact there is need for:
• a multidisciplinary, multisectoral approach to care
provision
• community involvement in decision making and planning
care provision models
• strengthening midwifery education to increase output of
qualified midwives
• strengthening problem-based learning
• putting in place mechanisms to retain more midwives and
thus enhance quality care for women and their babies.
It was repeatedly said that midwives have to demand
resources that will facilitate effective delivery of services.
Finally, the midwives agreed that they must each ask
themselves: ‘Despite the limited resources and poor
remuneration, what can we midwives do to make a difference,
as we are the front line care providers?’
Midwives were clear about the changes that must take
place:
participants through introspection, self assessment and clear
understanding of the situation in which midwives work.
Although they were sceptical at first, they quickly discovered
that they had to actively participate during the workshop
because of the opportunity created for them to dialogue with
their employers (policy makers) and stakeholders who are key
people in advancing the midwifery agenda and women’s
health in Malawi.
Additional comments reflected the importance of
midwives working as a team, valuing the role of their
Association, potential midwifery leadership and community
in their contribution to reducing maternal mortality and
morbidity. They also valued the atmosphere in which the
workshop was facilitated; the experience and expertise of the
The true success of this model of work will be demonstrated facilitators and presenters; and the encouraging comments
in the near future, at which time, and after close conscientious from the policy makers and stakeholders.
follow-up by ICM and AMAMI, the results of the consensus In conclusion, an extract from the presentation made by
action plan are evaluated. The pledges and promises from all midwives to the other stakeholders will summarise the sense
the stakeholders in Malawi indicate that there is great of resolution that has come from the workshop:
potential for collaborative work that will make a difference
‘The midwife in Malawi
for the women and newborns in the country.
• Is a proud specialist in normal childbirth
• Is an independent practitioner
Conclusion and recommendation • Has undergone comprehensive training in a recognised
The overall objective of the workshop was to initiate a institution
dialogue between midwives, policy makers and stakeholders • Attempts to provide comprehensive care in the face of
that will result in a measurable increase in the quantity and limited resources
quality of care given to women and newborns with the aim of
• Spends more time with the mother in the health care
reducing maternal and neonatal mortality and morbidity in
setting than any other frontline care provider
Malawi. This objective was achieved.
The group work processes answered all the questions ‘Midwives will
posed to guide the process. It is now incumbent upon • Change their attitude
midwives to continue the dialogue in a proactive manner to • Contribute to fund raising
sustain the momentum on strengthening and scaling up • Maintain confidence and competence through practice
midwifery. There is strong evidence from the workshop • Remain committed, compassionate and hard working
discussions that taking midwifery services to where most • Through AMAMI, strengthen partnerships with the
women live is the appropriate initiative necessary for Ministry of Health and other stakeholders
midwives to effectively contribute toward MDGs 4 and 5. • Unite and work as a team.
Strengthening and scaling up midwifery education, practice,
leadership and management and research should be ongoing ‘Our motto is ‘Zero tolerance to maternal death’ - help us and
for sustainable development and for midwifery to be visible at we will do it! Thank you.’
the highest level of policy and decision making, in colleges,
public and private health institutions and in the community.
As the workshop was progressing it was clear that the
environment was fertile for AMAMI to advocate for
midwives in Malawi and lobby the policy makers,
stakeholders and partners to implement the process of
strengthening and scaling up of midwifery in order to reduce
maternal mortality. The midwives were determined to go on.
Therefore, follow-up mechanisms must be put in place to
monitor progress and to further address needs. This could
start with a plan of action with persons responsible,
organisation and time frame. The plan of action should be
followed by the implementation. ICM can continue offering
desk and direct support (through the consultant and the board
member who were co facilitators of this workshop) for
AMAMI to push the agenda forward while the midwives are
still motivated by the activities of the workshop. A forceful The ICM Young Midwifery Leaders Group of mentors and
membership drive at this point will also be very fruitful. mentees, shown above, were instrumental in organisation of
the event and they took the wonderful photographs which are
Workshop evaluation seen in this article. We are also grateful to the midwives,
Interactions during tea and lunch breaks indicated that mothers and babies who appear in the pictures.
participants perceived the workshop as significant because it A copy of the full report is available from ICM:
was their first time to attend a workshop which guided the please e-mail info@internationalmidwives.org
‘Why are there no celebrations yet?’
Making best use of perinatal audit data
Nester T Moyo of ICM presented on perinatal audit and safer motherhood to the 5th
European Congress on Tropical Medicine & International Health, Amsterdam, May 2007
Recording the number and causes of deaths of pregnant
women and babies is essential health information. In all
countries, audit shows that the causes of maternal and
neonatal deaths have not changed much over the years. The
problems are known. (A recent example of an audit of women
who died on arrival at Jinnah Postgraduate Medical Centre,
Karachi, Pakistan, revealed what everyone already knew: the
need for going to hospital was not realised early enough; there
was no male relative to sanction the travel to hospital; there
was no transport). We are at a point where it is important to
determine the action required of health care providers to
impact on the numbers. It appears knowledge alone is not
helping the mothers who die. The lack of progress is not
puzzling when we live in a world where growing wealth and
increasing poverty, advanced education and no education, Kenya-UK collaboration: the ‘know-how’ project was co-ordinated
nd
by Gillian Barber (2 from rt) of the RCN Midwifery Society
superhighways and impassable mud roads, advances in health
care and lack of access to health care all exist side by side. For communities. It has been done in Kenya, India, Indonesia,
most of these things there is need for strong political will to South Africa and of course in the developed world. In Africa
change situations – fighting poverty, building roads, making there is progress: 35 countries have started their own road
available essential drugs, increasing access to care. maps to reduce maternal and newborn and child deaths. Also
in Columbia, Mexico, Honduras and Vietnam there is good
Strong professional associations can sway political will progress in reducing maternal, newborn and child deaths.
To influence the politicians, professionals cannot afford to be
apolitical. To be included in the relevant meetings, professionals North-South Partnerships: the Kenya-UK example
must be visible and they will not be if they are each working as In Kenya, work between the Kenyan and UK obstetrical,
an individual. There is need for strong professional associations midwifery and nursing associations and the two governments
to put the professions and their skills in the spotlight; to facilitate resulted in a set of standards for emergency obstetric care
the drafting of programmes and projects that lead directly to applicable to all levels of maternity care facilities, and a
saving lives; to lead in the development of effective partnerships clinical audit hand book. Midwife Gillian Barber and
and collaboration; and to advocate for women and newborn care Professor Karanja co-ordinated the project (Early reports were
in a manner that will influence the equitable distribution of published in IM May-June and July-August 2002). During
resources for the benefit of women, newborns and children. this project it was demonstrated that the ‘near-miss’ audit is
another valuable tool. It is believed that the Kenyan and UK
Involvement of communities teams are progressing this further with FIGO to the next
Ultimately it is the care-seeking behaviour of women and phase. There was also evidence that ownership of the
families that can lead to the reduction of maternal and standards, with the doctors, midwives, nurses and clinical
neonatal mortality. Women die because they come late to the officers seeing themselves as a multiprofessional group , was
health care facility, because they have not recognised the a key element of success. Working together as a team
seriousness of a complication or do not have the money or improved the relationships among all the cadres involved:
transport to access care anyway. They also die in the facility. some of them were heard to comment that they had never
Lack of essential drugs, equipment and skilled personnel have before felt so valued by their colleagues from other
been identified and where these have been tackled, the results professions. Feedback suggest that mortality rates have been
have been rewarding. The results will be just as rewarding if declining in the hospitals participating in the projects.
communities are empowered and informed; if men recognise
and see the need for receiving health care. For this to happen, Conclusion
community members should be members of the audit team. A few decades ago there was lack of knowledge and
Then informed and effective health decisions will be made agreement internationally on which interventions were the
with health priorities and cultural appropriateness in balance. most important. Today there is both more information and
greater consensus. Enough is known to inform global action -
Why are there no celebrations yet somewhere? though the poorest countries have the poorest data. The
Progress has been slow because of inadequate focus and success stories give optimism about the reduction of maternal,
funding on perinatal mortality. It is time we realised that we neonatal and child mortality. Progress will ultimately be
must avoid competing calls for mother vs. newborn care – dependent on strong health systems ensuring high coverage of
they should be viewed as a unit; and for community vs. services supported by timely competent hospital care.
facility based care - care is a continuum. Let us get rid of Solutions must take account of the wide diversity of problems
unhelpful dichotomies that slow action, waste funding and in different countries and regions hence they must be country
ultimately cost lives. Let us link skilled care with empowered specific and based on good evidence.
International Midwifery Volume 20 – Number 2 June 2007 27
ICM Southern Europe Region: new goals and
priorities in education and practice
Vitor Varela, ICM Board member in the Southern Europe Region, brought together
midwives from the Mediterranean countries to agree a new plan for action
In midwives’ clinical practice, the important aspects are:
strengthening physiological processes during pregnancy, birth
and the postnatal period, and avoiding unnecessary
interventions, i.e. those not based on clinical needs, during
pregnancy and childbirth. Last but not least, we included
‘Empowering midwives to feel competent and safe in their
midwifery skills in normal childbirth’; and ‘Empowering
women to have access to evidence-based midwifery care’.
Priorities
We saw as the greatest priority the development of Midwifery
Education in all levels, according to the Bologna Declaration.
We aim to ensure the provision of life-long, evidence-based
education in midwifery. A further priority is to carry out work
(l to r) Alexandra Amaral, Olga Orvanitidou, Glória Seguranyes, to identify the particular needs of both women and midwives -
Dolores Sardo, Dolores Costa, Vitor Varela, Malfa Kalliope, Niki through a research process - to contribute to the practice of
Panayiotou, Maria Papadopoulou, Permanthia Panani, Rita Pace normal childbirth.
Parascandalo, Mary Buttigitq, Rallou Lymperi
Celebration of the International Day of the Midwife
Vitor writes: During the first regional meeting of this The representative of each member association presented a
triennium – held in Athens, Greece, on 12–13 January, we report about the celebration of the International Day of
had a priority: to make our Action Plan. Midwives (IDM) in their country. Olga Arvanitidou put
forward the suggestion to rename the day to become
Vision ‘International Day of Normal Birth’. However, Gloria
First, we discussed how we would envisage an ideal situation Seguranyes from Spain made the point that, in Spain, a day to
for midwives in this region. We agreed on two significant celebrate midwives existed even before ICM nominated the
points of great importance: IDM. For that reason - also because the IDM has been agreed
• Midwives are educated within the European Higher by the whole international Council of ICM - the Spanish
Education Area and are qualified for autonomous practice midwives did not wish to vote for the change of name.
• Midwives aim to achieve optimal health for mothers and Vitor Varela presented the proposal from the Central
newborns. Europe Region about the celebration of the IDM on 5 May
2007. According to this proposal, it could be a joint
Goals programme of celebration across Europe: to launch a
Secondly, we worked to identify specific goals that will take campaign on 5 May at 12:00 o’clock Central European Time
us forward towards achieving the vision. in all cities in Europe, by releasing white balloons with blue
• To promote midwifery education (direct university entry) letters saying ‘Midwives Keep Birth Normal’, and the launch
within the European Higher Education Area and to ensure to be followed by a media campaign.
that midwives are qualified for autonomous practice Panani Perma, from Greece, expressed the opinion that
• To ensure that midwives are responsible for and act as the focus of the celebration depends on the needs of each
educators in midwifery programmes society. After discussion, members took the decision,
• To promote the midwifery profession and the value of the following a proposal from Portugal, to have one action in
midwife in keeping birth normal. common. After this action, each association can celebrate in
the way seen as appropriate in that country.
Actions Gloria Seguranyes (Spain) explained that the Federacion
Finally, consideration of the vision and goals led to the de Asociaciones de Matronas de Espana (FAME) had already
formation of a more detailed action plan. started a normal birth initiative in 2006 which is going to be
The educational programme should be based on implemented in 2007. They will therefore aim to merge the
competencies, specifically on the ICM’s Essential actions to reflect both campaigns.
Competencies for Basic Midwifery Practice. Finally, the decision taken about the celebration of the
A midwifery educational programme must have access to IDM in Southern Europe Region was to release the balloons
the three levels of undergraduate and postgraduate education - as suggested above, as a joint action with Central Europe,
BSc, MSc and PhD in midwifery - in accordance with the along with a media campaign. Members from Cyprus will
cycles of education set out in the Bologna Declaration prepare a leaflet, common for the member associations of
(www.bologna-berlin2003.de/pdf/bologna_declaration.pdf). Southern Europe, translated in different languages. The
Midwifery knowledge and competencies must be evidence subject of the leaflet will focus on normal birth, which is one
based. of ICM’s key strategies. Rallou Lymperi will act as secretary.
Midwifery practice
Several Filipino speakers shared their experiences in the field
of midwifery practice in the country. Midwives working in
government, private hospitals, academia and even in privately
owned clinics undergoing business entrepreneurship narrated
their own stories.
Delegates from different countries also talked about their
midwifery practice in their particular workplaces such as
studies in Japan and Australia. The afternoon session of
October 17 ended the congress with the discussion of ‘The
Dancers at the opening ceremony of the Congress
Future Direction of ICM’ by Ms. Sandy Grey.
The lectures were given in the formal session with
The congress opened with a very festive mood of sinulog (a provision of visual materials during the discussions and about
festival of dance associated with Cebu City held to honour the 10-15 minutes were allotted for every three presenters for the
Santo Niño) to welcome the participants to the beautiful city open forum and question and answers.
of Cebu, mirroring its history and culture through the dance Filipinos showcased the hospitality and warm acceptance
presentation. It was a pleasure to welcome acting ICM Asia of the foreign delegates with a very festive mood of singing
Pacific Regional Representative, Sandy Grey, who attended and dancing during the formal closing of the programme.
this event. The World Health Organization (WHO) Country Even the foreigners danced and moved as the congress ended!
Representative, Dr Jean Marc Olive, gave the keynote speech There were no sponsorships from commercial companies.
as he discussed the ‘WHO: towards Achieving the The proceeds of the event paid for the expenses of the
Millennium Development Goals.’ association in hosting the congress.
A welcome reception was provided to entertain the
delegates during the first day of the congress.
Midwifery education
The educators’ forum marked the second day of the congress.
The whole morning was filled with enriching discussion and
exploration about the different midwifery curriculum models
of the different participating Asia Pacific region countries.
Speakers from Japan, Australia, New Zealand, Indonesia,
USA and Philippines presented the current midwifery
education model of their own countries.
The aim of this activity was to serve as a basis for the
breakthrough and advancement of the midwifery education in The IMAP organising committee with guests: ICM
representative Sandy Grey is 5th from left
the Philippines. The Director of the Office of Programs and