Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Edward C. O'Dowd
To cite this article: Edward C. O'Dowd (2013) Ho Chi Minh and the origins of the
Vietnamese doctrine of guerrilla tactics, Small Wars & Insurgencies, 24:3, 561-587, DOI:
10.1080/09592318.2013.802606
Introduction
All comrades must close ranks! Unite one thousand as one! Rise to realize the anti-
imperialist national united front!2
When the Indochinese Communist Party (ICP) called for the people of Indochina
to launch an armed struggle for national liberation from the occupying French
and the invading Japanese, the party did not have an approach to guerrilla
warfare. Since the ability to conduct decisive conventional warfare was only a
distant dream to the leading members of the Indochina Communist Party in 1941,
the need for a doctrine for guerrilla warfare was urgent. The result was Ho Chi
Minh’s essay, ‘Guerrilla Tactics’ (cach danh du kich), which appeared in 1944
and is provided here in translation for the first time (arranged as an appendix to
this article).3
Doctrine
In 1939, there were books available in Vietnam that described Mao Zedong’s
ideas on the methods that could drive an insurgency, but there was no single
*Email: edward.odowd@att.net
Acknowledgements
Edward C. O’Dowd is Director of East Asian Studies at the Marine Corps University. The
Vietnamese scholar who has made a significant contribution to this study has chosen to
remain anonymous while allowing this work to be published as a contribution to the spirit
of friendship of the Vietnamese and American peoples. Any flaws or shortcomings readers
may find in this work are the responsibility of Edward C. O’Dowd. The views expressed in
this work are those of the author. They do not necessarily reflect the views of the Marine
566 E.C. O’Dowd
Corps University, the United States Marine Corps or any other organization or institution
with which the author is or has been affiliated.
Notes
1. Ministry of Defense Center for the Military Encyclopedia, Tu Dien Bach Hoa Quan
Su Vietnam, 69.
2. Duiker, Sacred War, 37.
3. Prepared by author with assistance of a Vietnamese scholar. This translation is based
on ‘Cach Danh Du Kich’ in Ho Chi Minh, Collected Works, vol. 3, 165– 207. This is
the authorized version released by the Marxist-Leninist Institute of the Central
Committee of the Communist Party of Vietnam (VCP).
4. Duiker, The Communist Road to Power in Vietnam, 42.
5. Qiang Zhai, China and the Vietnam Wars, 11 – 12.
6. Ibid., 19 – 20.
7. Lockhart, Nation in Arms, 100. Lockhart claims (p. 7) that Vietnamese translations
of Mao Zedong’s On Guerrilla Warfare reached Vietnam in 1938, but he has not
provided a reference for this point.
8. Johnson, Vietnam and the American Doctrine for Small Wars, 32.
9. Duiker, Ho Chi Minh, 236– 7.
10. Almost all the active military forces in North China after 1939 were aligned with the
Chinese Communist Party or part of the Red Army (later known as the PLA).
11. Ho Chi Minh, Collected Works, vol. 3, 165–207.
12. Duiker, Ho Chi Minh, 259.
13. Ho Chi Minh, Collected Works, vol. 3 (2-1930 to 2-9-1945), 165– 207.
14. Duiker, Ho Chi Minh, 262– 3. Duiker has identified the National Salvation Army
(Cuu Quoc Quan), which was based in Bac Son, as one of these units. He does not
place the text at the ‘scene’. However, he does state that Phung Chi Kien, a close
colleague of Ho’s and a member of the Vietnamese Communist Party Central
Committee, had been sent to Bac Son to expand guerrilla warfare operations in the
early 1940’s and was killed there by a French patrol. It is not a leap of logic to assume
that Kien had the Ho text or a similar volume when he was ordered by Ho to
undertake the mission.
15. The manner in which Ho suggested the ambushers should deal with prisoners was not
entirely clear, but his other writings emphasize his goal was ‘winning them over’.
Therefore, a policy of leniency similar to that announced by the Chinese People’s
Liberation Army could be expected (Trinh Vuong Hong and Nguyen Huy Toan, Ho
Chi Minh Thought on the Military, 215).
Bibliography
Duiker, William J. Ho Chi Minh. London: Allen and Unwin, 2000.
Duiker, William J. Sacred War: Nationalism and Revolution in a Divided Vietnam. New
York: McGraw Hill, 1994.
Duiker, William J. The Communist Road to Power in Vietnam, 2nd edition. New York:
Westview, 1996.
Ho Chi Minh. The Collected Works of Ho Chi Minh (Ho Chi Minh Toan Tap), vol. 3.
Hanoi: The Truth Publishers [Nha Xuat Su That ], 1983.
Hong, Trinh Vuong, and Nguyen Huy Toan, eds. Ho Chi Minh Thought on the Military.
Hanoi: The Gioi Publishers, 2002.
Johnson, Wray R. Vietnam and the American Doctrine for Small Wars. Bangkok: White
Lotus, 2001.
Small Wars & Insurgencies 567
Lockhart, Greg. Nation in Arms: The Origins of the People’s Army of Vietnam. London:
Allen and Unwin, 1989.
Ministry of Defense Center for the Military Encyclopedia. Tu Dien Bach Hoa Quan Su
Vietnam. Hanoi: People’s Army Publishing Company, 1996.
Qiang Zhai. China and the Vietnam Wars, 1950– 1975. Chapel Hill, NC and London: The
University of North Carolina Press, 2000.
Appendix
Guerrilla Tactics (Cach Danh Du Kich)
Ho Chi Minh
Apparently written 1941; released 1944
4. Command structure
Every guerrilla unit – from the small group, the squad, the platoon, the company, to the
larger guerrilla units – has its own leader and deputy leader. Politically, every level of
guerilla unit has one political representative who has been chosen by the revolutionary
organization in that unit or from the others.
Small Wars & Insurgencies 569
If there are many members in a guerrilla unit, they need to organize special
departments that are responsible for things such as unit management, reconnaissance, and
sabotage. On the political side, the larger guerrilla unit has sections for those involved in
education, explaining news from the newspaper, mobilizing the masses, or demoralizing
the soldiers of the empire.
Avoid attacking the enemy’s strong point. Always attack the enemy’s weak
point; pretend to attack one point but attack another one.
We have to know as much as possible about the adversary. We cannot make silly attacks
on the enemy’s strong points. We must attack the enemy’s weak point. When we trick the
enemy into defending one place, we attack another place. Fighting means pretending to
attack one point, then attacking another point.
570 E.C. O’Dowd
Dodge any fight that the enemy can win. Do not try to hold the battlefield at any
cost.
Guerrilla forces should choose the enemy target that is easiest for them to attack with
minimum casualties. Guerrilla units must avoid battles in which it is too difficult to assess
casualties and foresee the final outcome. When guerrilla forces have been attacked by the
enemy and are at a disadvantage compared with the enemy, the guerrilla unit should find
escape from the battlefield to maintain their strength intact. Do not try to hold the
battlefield at any cost.
Scatter the forces (hoa chinh vi linh); gather the forces (hoa linh vi chinh).
Guerrilla forces should be scattered in case the enemy attacks them or in case of the entire
force being pushed into inconvenient conditions. In those circumstances, guerrilla forces
must ‘hoa chinh vi linh’, meaning scatter the forces. After that, when it is necessary,
guerrilla men gather again (hoa linh vi chinh) to do their mission. ‘Chinh’ means the entire
guerrilla unit. ‘Linh’ means part of the guerrilla unit or individual guerrillas.
When we are still, we attack the enemy who is moving. We fight the enemy when
we are strong and our enemy is tired.
We have to gain the initiative in guerrilla warfare. We must choose good opportunities to
hit the enemy. We pay attention to the following actions: when the enemy is doing
something, especially when he is moving on the road; when the enemy is not vigilant, we
set an ambush at a secret place and then suddenly attack the enemy. That means when we
are still, we attack the moving enemy. We choose the attack time because we want to
attack when we are strong but the enemy is tired. We will be the winner if we make a
surprise attack when we are strong and appear to be still. The best time to attack is when
the enemy is moving and tired.
To fight the French and Japanese, guerrilla units need to do the following things:
Raids
The secrecy and thoroughness in preparation as well as quickness and resolution in assault
are necessary conditions to conduct a successful raid. Therefore, we should take the
following steps in preparing and conducting raids: scout, arrange the plan, start occupying
raid area, settle in the raid place, assault, actions to take after the assault.
1. Scouting
The guerrilla should know: A) the enemy’s situation; B) the terrain; C) the political
situation in the battle area. We should know precise information about these situations
before making plans. Due to the importance of this information, the scout has an important
role in determining the winning or losing of these battles.
A. Scouting the enemy’s situation.
a) The scout needs to determine the strength, services, weapons, ruses of fighting,
combat efficiency, defensive measures, guard pattern, and officers of the enemy unit.
b) The scout needs to assess the enemy’s other units, particularly those that adjoin the
unit we intend to attack. The assessment should include the number of men in those
units, their increasing strength, how they contact each other, and their means of
contact. We have to know about these things to avoid bad and surprise situations.
Example: Chinese guerrillas in Hoa Bac [North China, Ed.] have successfully
scouted to get information relating to the enemy because they got help from the
people. They knew exactly what Japanese troops were doing. The guerrillas always
win because they are not afraid of being defeated. If they are afraid of losing, they
cannot fight the enemy.
There were 200 Japanese troops in the village of Binh Dinh [possibly Pingding
district, Henan Province, Ed.]. They had posted numerous sentries around their area
to prevent a surprise attack. But guerrillas scouted the area with the help of the
people. They paid special attention to the time the Japanese changed their sentries.
At night, when the Japanese sentries were tired, the clever and aggressive guerrillas
killed them while other guerrillas attacked the Japanese troops sleeping in the
village.
572 E.C. O’Dowd
B. Scouting terrain.
a) What is the condition of traffic along the narrow or wide streets from the
guerrilla’s area to the enemy’s area?
b) Where are the places to hide guerrilla forces along the roads? What good terrain
is available for guerrillas? What places are near the enemy to hide guerrilla
forces? What are the routes for guerrillas to advance and retreat from battlefield?
C. Scouting the political situation of the battle area.
a) How does the enemy behave toward the people and vice versa? Has the enemy
killed people for robbery? How do the people behave toward the revolution?
b) How are the enemy’s accommodations? What is the fighting spirit of the enemy?
How do the enemy’s men behave toward their officers, the people, and the
revolution? What people can help guerrillas? How is guerrilla contact with the
people?
2. Making plans and preparations for fighting.
After carefully scouting, the leaders and political commissar should make an attack plan.
In case there is no opportunity for a raid, we should divert the enemy from an intended
direction. We should pretend to attack in one place to divert him from another place. By
doing this we can create the conditions for a successful raid. We should follow these
principles when making attack plans:
A. Choosing the time for the attack.
There are four good times for raids:
a) At night. Night ambushes are easy to keep secret, and it is easy to move our forces
at night. It is also easy to get tired and lose the way at night, but the night raid is
not difficult for the skilled and strictly disciplined guerrillas.
b) At dawn. After marching a long way at night, the guerrillas can attack the enemy
in the early morning while the enemy is sleeping. The battle can be finished right
after dawn. This is the good time for a raid.
c) At sunset. The enemies often guard their bases carelessly at sunset. The guerrilla
can hide along the way during daytime and easily surprise the enemy at sunset. If
our attack is not successful, we can retreat at night.
d) During the day. It is very difficult to attack the enemy during the day. To win a
daytime battle, the guerrilla should have all these following conditions:
1. The enemy’s fighting ability is not good. He does not have his own stronghold.
The enemy’s ability to move is bad.
2. The enemy is lonely.
3. The enemy disregards the guerrillas.
4. The guerrilla is able to hide and move closer to the enemy because of bad
weather conditions such as heavy rain, strong winds, or fog.
B. The preparation for ambush.
Before conducting a raid, the guerrilla units need to do a good job of preparation. The
guerrillas must do the following:
a) Establish the time and signal to attack and assault.
b) Establish the way to retreat and to assemble in case the attack fails.
c) The guerrilla should carry rafts, lifebuoys, and rope in case he has to retreat
across rivers or across mountains. He should take equipment to destroy or set fire
to enemy blockhouses and billets.
d) The guerrilla should carefully announce and distribute information about the raid
to ensure success.
Small Wars & Insurgencies 573
C. Keeping the plan at the top-secret level.
Although we may have a very good plan, it is very dangerous if we let the enemy know
about it. We have to keep the raid plan secret. It is not necessary to explain all aspects
of the plan to everybody in the unit. We should just explain the relevant part of the
plan to each person who has a specific duty in that part of the plan. The entire plan
information should only be explained to the entire unit when it is necessary. To keep
our activities secret and deceive the enemy in a raid, we should start moving in a
diversionary direction, and then, when we approach the attack site, we turn to the right
direction.
3. Start deploying forces to the attack area.
a) Guerrillas should travel on a new road. Do not use a wide or narrow one. Be
careful of getting lost on the way because this leads to guerrillas being tired and
late for the raid.
b) Keep absolutely quiet during the operation. No one is allowed to use any kind of
light or to cock their rifle. The only exceptions are when conducting
reconnaissance or to avoid surprise fire.
c) Guerrillas should conduct reconnaissance in mufti [non-uniform, locally suitable
clothes, Ed.].
d) Guerrillas should avoid enemy sentries when marching. If we encounter enemy
sentries, we should catch them alive or kill them quietly. We should not shoot
them or make noise. If the guerrilla clashes with the enemy during an approach
march, we should attack quickly to seize the most advantageous terrain.
4. Occupying attack positions.
a) We should secretly occupy the places from which to launch the raid. Those places
should not be too far or too near the enemy’s location.
b) We should summon our commanders quickly to assign their duties and explain
the enemy’s condition just before the fighting breaks out. It is best to capture the
enemy sentries alive.
c) We should observe the following principles when attacking: our force should be
divided into two parts. The smaller part restrains the enemy and the larger part
attacks him. We should have some small groups of guerrillas hiding along the
enemy’s route of retreat to attack him or prevent his combining with other
forces. The guerrillas’ duties are to ruin bridges and roads and to cut telephone
wires. Guerrillas should be prepared to signal the attack when everything is
ready.
5. Assault.
a) The guerrillas should surprise the enemy with a broadsword attack right after
getting the signal to attack. We should not shoot because it makes noise and it is
less effective. It is better to use broadswords to kill the enemy.
b) For example, in Trieu’s ambush in Duong Phong [Unknown location, Ed.], near
Beijing in North China, the Japanese sentry was surprised and killed by the
guerrillas. The other Japanese troops did not know anything until the guerrillas
had closed on them. The guerrillas mainly used the broadsword to kill them.
Some Japanese troops tried to resist the guerrillas but they were killed in the end.
In that battle a small number of guerrillas killed a large number of Japanese
troops. Also, more than a hundred Japanese troops were taken prisoner. We
achieved victory by using the broadsword. If we had used guns, we could not
have obtained such a complete victory. When asked, the Japanese troops always
said that they were afraid of the guerrillas’ broadswords.
574 E.C. O’Dowd
c) When the enemy retreats into blockhouses, we should burn the blockhouses and
continue fighting.
d) Although most of the guerrillas should withdraw after a raid, a few should remain
to collect war booty and take care of prisoners of war. We should pursue and kill
the fleeing enemy troops. But we should not follow them too far to avoid being
attacked by their relief forces.
e) If the raid has failed because the enemy is too strong – he has the benefit of
good positions or he is supported by other enemy units – the guerrillas
should quietly retreat. We should let a small number of guerrillas remain to
cover the retreat. The destination of the retreating forces should be decided
in advance.
Bastion Raids
We have to plan carefully and cleverly.
a) We should have spies living with the enemy to get information. The spies can be
enemy soldiers. The spies must be able to coordinate closely with the guerrillas.
For example, a guerrilla unit that belonged to the Eighth Route Army killed more
than 200 Japanese soldiers with the help of a large number of Chinese spies in Tru
Chau rampart.
b) The guerrillas should choose the place where the enemy is off his guard, break in to
the bastion, and then silently attack.
For example, the Japanese troops occupied an airport in Duong Ninh
[Unknown Chinese location, Ed.] rampart that had four sides. But, they had only
built fortifications on three sides carefully. They did not reinforce the last side
because it bordered a dangerous river. The commander of the guerrilla unit
conducted a reconnaissance and knew that his troops could not be stalled by the
mud if they ran across the river quickly. So the guerrillas attacked the rampart from
the weak side and burned 20 Japanese airplanes and withdrew secretly.
c) Dress like the enemy to attack them.
For example, a guerrilla unit that belonged to the Eighth Route Army dressed
like Japanese soldiers to attack a small rampart in Tich Duong [Unknown Chinese
location, Ed.]. When they went to the Japanese bastion, the sentry could not
recognize them, welcomed them, and let them enter. After they entered, the
guerrillas suddenly attacked and then withdrew immediately.
d) When the enemy goes out of his bastion, the guerrilla ambushes him and attacks
his bastion.
Small Wars & Insurgencies 575
The way to cope with enemy raids.
The guerrillas always conduct raids to kill the enemy. The guerrillas should not allow
themselves to be attacked by the enemy. Therefore, they must take precautions to win in
case our forces are attacked by the enemy.
When living in a place for a long period of time, especially in a village, the guerrilla
units must carefully organize their guards. People should not be allowed to enter or leave
the village. The guerrilla units should have plans to respond to enemy raids. If the guerrilla
is attacked, the main guerrilla force should immediately retreat and then conduct a surprise
attack to help the troops who have been left behind. It is easier to attack the enemy if he
thinks that our guerrilla force has run away without any attempt to conduct a defense.
Chapter 5: Ambush
An ambush means hiding in a place, waiting for an enemy force to pass, and then making a
surprise attack on the enemy force. It is easier to succeed at an ambush than a raid.
Therefore, guerrilla units, especially the new, less experienced, and less well-trained units,
should pay more attention to the ways of conducting ambushes.
We must pay attention to the following when laying an ambush: reconnaissance and
choosing the best ambush location, and after the ambush has been executed, wiping out the
remaining enemy soldiers, transportation convoys, cavalry units, vehicles, and trains.
4. Conducting an ambush.
a) Our ambush force must divide into two parts. The first part, normally one-third, is used
to stop the enemy, while the second part of the ambush force is used to fight the enemy.
The commander must stay in a convenient place from where he can clearly observe the
enemy situation. From this position he can signal our troops to attack the enemy.
b) Each unit and each guerrilla must thoroughly understand the mission, and the
commander must correctly execute the plan to lead the troops in battle.
c) If the enemy is few in number, we can block his advance and withdrawal routes and
wipe him out. But if the enemy has a larger number of troops, we must divide them
into two parts or three groups. Then we must attack the second or third groups to
ensure success.
d) When attacking the rear part of the enemy convoy, we must have some guerrillas
harass the front and both sides of the convoy. If it is possible, we can destroy the
roads and bridges to create disorder for the enemy and interrupt the mutual support
between the front and rear groups.
e) To begin the attack, we must do so in a consistent, rapid, and lightning manner. This
is done so the enemy cannot respond. First, ignite a series of explosives or open
strong small arms fire on the enemy convoy, then attack with knifes and falchions
(swords). This attack will cause the enemy to panic and he will not be able to resist.
The commander must have a detailed, specific, and careful plan for the operation in
order to reduce our human losses to the minimum. It is of no value if we win but lose
many human lives.
Chapter 8: Withdrawal
It should be acknowledged that the method of withdrawal is important in guerrilla warfare
because a guerrilla unit must withdraw immediately after fighting whether it has succeeded
or failed to accomplish its mission. Sometimes, it should withdraw at once and stop
fighting because it is clear that the enemy is too strong.
Usually, there is no difficulty if our attacks against the enemy have been successful.
Moreover, the guerrilla unit should be prepared to withdraw in order to avoid being
defeated by the enemy. After it has withdrawn, the guerrilla unit can launch an offensive
if it calculates carefully and realizes with 100% certainty that its attacks can succeed.
In contrast, it shouldn’t fight if there is even a little doubt or hesitation that it may not
succeed. This will avoid the problem of failing in an operation and then needing to conduct
a withdrawal operation. However, in some cases, such as an unlucky defeat followed by
a forced withdrawal, or confronting a strong enemy and being unable to succeed, then
having to withdraw and being chased by the enemy, the guerrilla leader should pay
attention to the five following measures:
1. First and foremost, it is necessary to choose some brave and smart pioneers of the
guerilla unit to fight against the enemy in order to support the withdrawal of the
majority of the guerrillas. While withdrawing, the unit shouldn’t divide into small
groups, because by doing so, the guerrilla soldiers can easily lose their will and,
perhaps, they may lose their way as well. In some unavoidable situations, it may be
necessary to divide into small groups; however, the unit must have a plan to move
to an assembly area.
2. The chief and vice chief for political affairs of the unit must strongly show their will,
attitude, and leadership ability. The more difficulty and danger there is, the more
these two people must volunteer and go ahead in order to lead their troops.
3. Even if being chased or run after by the enemy, guerrilla units still have to maintain
contact with the local people (or populace) and encourage them to support the
guerrillas’ cause. They can help by supplying food, securing road guides,
maintaining security, assisting in surveillance, safeguarding people and places, and
even fighting against the enemy.
4. An appropriate plan should be made when withdrawing. Withdrawing troops
(guerrilla men) must identify the way (or road) to be used, and they must calculate
carefully and thoughtfully how they will withdraw. It is especially important to
avoid attacks from the machine (mechanized) and cavalry forces of the enemy.
When troops cross a road, the traces should be swept away. The route of
withdrawal should follow the shortcut (road) and the operation should be
conducted at night. Or the unit can go publicly one way then secretly make a U-
turn and go another way. The unit can find a new way to go, or make up and dress
in clothes as the normal civilians or soldiers of the enemy while withdrawing. The
withdrawing guerrillas may need to travel very fast and cover more than 50 km
per day.
5. When staying far away from the enemy, the guerrilla unit should find a good place
and begin training for local people in order to make that place become a steady
troop station (stop site). At the same time, the guerrillas must reorganize their unit
for the next operations.
Small Wars & Insurgencies 583
All the measures mentioned above are applied in case the enemy is so strong that it is
impossible to fight against him, thus forcing a withdrawal. If the enemy is weak, the
guerilla units can find a good place, hide, and ambush the enemy when he goes across the
area, then withdraw. However, the guerrillas should be careful and never take risks.
The guerrillas should pay attention to the problem of withdrawing in a force that has
some support people such as medical staff, engineers, etc., who support the guerrilla units;
defending these people and helping them withdraw safely should always be a high priority.
However, in peacetime, these people should be trained how to respond to such a difficult
situation as withdrawal. In particular, they must learn to maintain order, to keep calm, and
to follow the predetermined plan.
Chapter 9: Sabotage
Sabotage is a vital part of guerrilla warfare. Sabotage may prevent the enemy’s machine
(mechanized) and cavalry forces from conducting offensive operations, and it may delay
his infantry forces.
Sabotage operations need the support and assistance of the local people. At the same
time, only when the local people create a situation of ‘no man’s land’ can the destruction
be most effective. Wherever the enemy moves, all roads and bridges should be
destroyed. The enemy will fall into a miserable situation of hunger and thirst (no food,
no water).