Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
INTRODUCTION
Brakes are most important safety parts in the vehicles. Generally all of the
vehicles have their own safety devices to stop their car. Brakes function to slow and
stop the rotation of the wheel. To stop the wheel, braking pads are forced
mechanically against the rotor disc on both surfaces. They are compulsory for all of
the modern vehicles and the safe operation of vehicles. In short, brakes transform the
kinetic energy of the car into heat energy, thus slowing its speed.
Brakes have been retuned and improved ever since their invention. The
increases in traveling speeds as well as the growing weights of cars have made these
improvements essential. The faster a car goes and the heavier it is, the harder it is to
stop. An effective braking system is needed to accomplish this task with challenging
term where material need to be lighter than before and performance of the brakes
must be improved. Today's cars often use a combination of disc brakes and drum
brakes. For normal sedan car, normally disc brakes are located on the front two
wheels and drum brakes on the back two wheels. Clearly shows that, together with
the steering components and tyres represent the most important accident avoidance
systems present on a motor vehicle which must reliably operate under various
conditions. However, the effectiveness of braking system depends on the design
itself and also the right selection of material. It is important to do some analysis on a
disc brake rotor which has been designed to predict the behavior of the systems than
follow with some improvements. In order to understand the behaviors of braking
system, there are three functions that must be complied for all the time
b) The braking should permit the vehicle to maintain a constant speed when
traveling downhill.
c) The braking system must hold the vehicle stationary when on the flat or on a
gradient.
1
1.1 Brake System Review
In the early days of the automobile, drum brakes were standard. Drum brakes
offered several advantages over other types of brakes. One of these was that the
drum could keep out water and dust, materials that could damage disc brakes which
were out in the open.
The main problem with drum brakes is that the heat is not efficiently
disbursed. The heat that is produced inside the drum does not escape easily since the
drum prevents wind from drawing it away. However, disc brakes killed the issues
when it allowed the heat to be carried away which increased the efficiency of the
brake. However, their use was limited up until the 1950's since their efficiency was
not required and they required more pedal pressure to operate. The reason for the
higher pedal pressure is that disc brakes have no self-servo effect or no self-
energizing capacity that the drum brakes have. The self-servo effect is caused by the
forward motion of the car. This forward motion helps pull the brake shoe into
contact with the drum. This helped lower the required pedal pressure. Now that their
efficiency was needed and the hydraulic brake system multiplied the force applied to
the brake pedal, disc brakes seemed to be the better alternative. Chrysler was the
2
first to widely introduce the disc brake in its cars in the early 1950's. The system did
not have much success till automaker Studebaker to reintroduce the system in 1964.
This time it saw much more success and in a few years, disc brakes were common
on most new cars.
One of the reasons that disc brakes were a success with the Studebaker and
not the Chrysler was due to the development of the power braking system. Power
brakes became common in the 195Ots, after Chrysler had developed and dropped its
disc brake program. The system assisted the movement of the piston in the master
cylinder which meant that the driver needed to apply less peddle pressure to get the
same braking effectiveness. Therefore, since ease of braking was no longer an issue,
the adoption of the more efficient disc brake became widespread.
It is know that, the basic functions of the brake system are to slow down a
vehicle speed to the point we need. It is also help to maintain acceleration during
moving downhill and keep the vehicle on static conditions. Brakes operate by
converting the kinetic energy (motion) of an automobile into heat energy. A typical
vehicle braking system is shown in Figure 1.1
In the passenger or commercial vehicle, there are always two main types of
brake assemblies have been used. Those types of brakes are drum and disc brakes
which have been described as below.
Drum brakes (Figure 1.2 and Figure 1.3) have their pads located inside of a
drum. Like the disc in disc brakes, drum brakes also are attached to the wheels.
Usually, main components of drum brake for passenger or commercial vehicle
consist of brake shoes, backing plate, parking brake cable and wheel cylinder. When
the brake pedal is pressed the curved brake shoes (pads) are pushed outward so that
they make contact with the rotating drum. Retracting spring is used in this type of
brake. Just as with disc brakes, this causes friction which turns kinetic energy into
heat energy, thus slowing and stopping the car to the right point. There is an
advantage of using drum brakes, where there is low cost of common parts. However,
there are also some disadvantages, such as the drum heats up and expands away
from the lining material which increasing fading. It is also have lower efficiency in
wet braking action.
4
Figure 1.2: Components of Drum Brake
5
1.2.2 Disc brakes
6
1.2.2.1 Disc Calipers
There are two types of disc calipers where further classified as floating and
fixed caliper.
Other type of disc calipers is a fixed caliper. Figure 1.6 shows a type of fixed
caliper. In these types of brakes, the caliper body is fixed and uses two or more
pistons on each side of the rotor. The pistons are located in each half section of the
fixed caliper. Hydraulic pressure is applied during braking to each of the piston.
Each of the pistons has a function to press against the brake pads of the brake disc.
Shaped piston seals will retract the piston when the brakes are released. Referring to
Figure 1.6, the brake fluid pushes the both piston when the brake is applied to the
left and the right of the piston and immediately pushes the both inner pads and
presses it against the rotor disc. Normally, these types of brake caliper are used in
high performance and heavy duty vehicle due to high physical strength.
7
HYPERLINK "E:\\Program
Files\\CDXARK30\\AT206AU\\dswmedia\\video\\discbrakecalipers.mpg" INCLUDEPICTURE
"http://www.cdxetextbook.com/images/350px-Bcallipers_01m.jpg" \* MERGEFORMAT
As shown in Figure 1.7, brake pads consist of steel carrier which the pad are
bonded to the steel carrier. According to organically bonded pads consist of metallic,
ceramic or organic friction materials in a bonded mass such as rubber or synthetic
resin. The bonded friction materials can withstand temperatures up to 750°c, with
short term peaks-up to 950'~ where the friction coefficient is between 0.25 and 0.5.
8
There is an advantage of brake pads, where most of them are poor to thermal
conductivity which protects the hydraulic actuating elements from overheating. It is
also ease to manufacture and low cost. However, the pads needs to inspect
frequently due to rapid wear as result from higher temperatures and contact
pressures associated with the operation of a brake disc.
9
1.2.2.4 Disc Brake Rotor Description
Overall idea on vehicle brake system and disc brake theories has been
described as above. As similar to the type disc brake described above, the author
used the disc brake rotor from normal passenger vehicle. The disc brake rotor was
taken from normal passenger vehicle which having type of ventilated disc (Figure
1.9). Basically, disc brake rotor consists of rotating circular plate and cylinder disc
(hat) attached and rotated to wheel hub.
1. Ceramic brake discs are 50% lighter than metal brake discs. As a result, they can
reduce the weight of car by up to 20kg. In case of a high speed ICE like train
with 36 brake discs, these savings amount to 6 tons. And apart from saving fuel,
this also means a reduction in unsprung masses with a further improvement of
shock absorber response and behavior.
2. The ceramic brake disc ensures very high and, in particular, consistent frictional
values throughout the entire deceleration process. With Porsche ceramic brake
discs, a car was able to decelerate from 100Km to 0Km in less than 6 seconds. In
the case of Daewoo’s Nexia, it takes about 8 seconds to stop the vehicle.
3. Brake temperature – a factor crucial to stopping distances with metal brake discs
– is now only a minor factor, both the brake lining and ceramic brake disc
retaining their high level of friction regardless of whether they are hot or cold.
This not only shortens stopping distances by a couple of – often decisive –
meters, but also spares the driver unpleasant surprises whenever having to apply
the brakes, say, from a high speed.
10
4. Ceramics retain their resistance up to 2000 degree Celsius. Only if the
temperature is excess of this, they loose their dimensional stability.
5. Initial field studies have shown that ceramic brake discs can still reliably bring
an automobile to standstill even after 300,000 kilometers. Brake disc changes
will in future be unnecessary.
6. They are not subject to wear, are maintenance free and are heat and rust resistant.
7. Heavily commercial vehicles can be braked safely over long distances without
having to undergo brake maintenance. This dispenses with the need for
expensive maintenance.
9. Dry and wet performances are excellent. Ceramics are water proof materials and
the brake pads always remain dry.
1.3.2 Disadvantages
The main disadvantage of ceramic brake discs is their high initial cost.
Initially the ceramic matrix composite brake discs will be more expensive than the
current technology metal ones due to the low manufacturing volumes and high cost
of production. But, because of the advantages listed above, the ceramic brakes will
work out to be cheaper in the long run.
1.3.3 Applications
1. It was first introduced in Formula One, but applying to road cars seems
impractical (F1 cars have warm up lap to bring the discs into appropriate
working temperature), although the short-lived French sports car specialists
Venturi made history by applying it to its road cars in the mid-90s
2. The new 911 GT2 comes with the most effective braking system ever featured
on a production Porsche: the Porsche Ceramic Composite Brake (PCCB) - a
powerful new technology designed to cope with even the most extreme
conditions on racetrack and road?
3. Mercedes-Benz’s the futuristic Vision GST concept car features 22 inch wheels,
'butterfly' doors, three-dimensional instruments, a 360 horsepower 5.5 litre V8
engine, and carbon-fiber reinforced ceramic disc brakes. Mercedes Benz SLR IS
ALSO available with ceramic disc brakes.
11
12
CHAPTER 2
LITERATURE REVIEW
G P Voller, et. al, [1] (2003) Analysis of automotive disc brake cooling
characteristics have investigated about characteristics experimentally using a
specially developed spin rig and numerically using finite element (FE) and
computational fluid dynamics (CFD) methods. All three modes of heat transfer
(conduction, convection and radiation) have been analysed along with the design
features of the brake assembly and their interfaces. The spin rig proved to be very
valuable equipment; experiments enabled the determination of the thermal contact
resistance between the disc and wheel carrier. The analyses demonstrated the
sensitivity of this mode of heat transfer to clamping pressure. For convective
cooling, heat transfer coefficients were measured and very similar results were
obtained from spin rig experiments and CFD analyses.
M.Z. Akop, et. al, [5](2009) Thermal Stress Analysis of Heavy Truck Brake
Disc Rotor have investigated for steady state and transient condition. The heat
dissipated along the brake disc surface during the periodic braking via conduction,
convection and radiation. In order to get the stable and accurate result of element
size, time step selection is very important and all of these aspects are discussed in
this paper. The findings of this research provide a useful design tool to improve the
brake performance of disc brake system.
Saw Chun Lin, et. al, [6](2009) Supressing Disc Brake Squeal Through
Structural Modification have investigated proposes a solution to suppress disc brake
using the finite element method. First a three dimensional finite element (FE) model
of a real disc brake assembly is developed and validated. Then, complex eigenvalue
analysis made available in commercial FE software package is performed to
determine stability of the brake system where positive real parts of the complex
eigenvalue indicate unstable system and in turn exhibit squeal generation in the
brake assembly. Then, various disc modifications are proposed to reduce the brake
squeal.
14
Pevec.M , et. al, [7](2010) Numerical Temperature Analysis Of Brake Disc
Considering Cooling have investigated the temperature numerical calculation of a
ventilated front brake disc. The goal was to simulate the sequent vehicle brake test
that comprises 10 stops from 100 km/h. The film coefficient factors for the
ventilated brake disc were calculated using the CFD software and afterwards
considered in thermal numerical simulation.
16
Haripal Singh and Harshdeep Shergill [14](2012) Thermal Analysis of
Disc Brake Using Comsol have investigated the heat generation and dissipation in a
disc brake of an car during panic braking and the following release period by using
computer aided engineering software for three different materials of rotor disc. The
objective of this work is to investigate and analyze the temperature distribution of
rotor disc during operation using comsol multiphysics. The work uses the finite
element analysis techniques to predict the temperature distribution on the brake disc
and to identify the critical temperature of the brake rotor disc. All three modes of
heat transfer (conduction, convection and radiation) have been analyzed. The results
obtained from the analysis shows that different material on the same retardation of
the car during panic braking shows different temperature distribution.
17
V.M.M.Thilak [15](2012) transient analysis of rotor disc of disc brake using
ansys have investigation into usage of new materials is required which improve
braking efficiency and provide greater stability to vehicle. This investigation can be
done using ANSYS software. ANSYS is a dedicated finite element package used for
determining the temperature distribution, variation of the stresses and deformation
across the disc brake profile. In the present work, an attempt has been made to
investigate the suitable hybrid composite material which is lighter than cast iron and
has good Young’s modulus, Yield strength and density properties. Aluminium base
metal matrix composite and High Strength Glass Fiber composites have a promising
friction and wear behaviour as a Disk brake rotor.
18
Ştefan VOLOACĂ and Gheorghe FRĂŢILĂ [19](2012) concerns
regarding temperature distribution obtained by experiments and finite element
analyses for two types of brake discs have investigation the analyses causes of
thermal stress which appears in two different brake discs, with different geometries.
A case study was made for an intensive braking from 100 km/h. It was possible to
study, to compare and to explain the temperature distribution obtained by
experiments and finite element analyses (FEA). Further the study encompasses
temperature distribution inside the studied brake discs obtained by finite element
analyses, highlighting some thermal stress influence factors. It was observed the
non-uniform repartition of radiation and conduction over the surfaces and inside the
brake discs, due to characteristics of material, their processing and the braking
severity.
Guru Murthy Nathi , et. al, [20](2012) coupled structural thermal analysis
of disc brake have investigation the performance under severe braking conditions
and there by assist in disc rotor design and analysis. This study is of disc brake used
for cars. ANSYS package is a dedicated finite element package used for determining
the temperature distribution, variation of stresses and deformation across the disc
brake profile. In this present work, an attempt has been made to investigate the
effect of stiffness, strength and variations in disc brake rotor design on the predicted
stress and temperature distributions. By identifying the true design features, the
extended service life and long term stability is assured. A transient thermal analysis
has been carried out to investigate the temperature variation across the disc using
axisymmetric elements. Further structural analysis is also carried out by coupling
thermal analysis.
19
minimise disc rotor weight, minimise brake pad wear and to extend the working
range of an EV or HEV. Regenerative braking would extend the working range of an
EV or HEV provided that any extra energy consumption e.g. from increased vehicle
mass and system losses did not outweigh the saving from energy recuperation, also
reduce duty levels on the brakes themselves, giving advantages including extended
brake rotor and friction material life, but more importantly reduced brake mass,
minimise brake pad wear. The objective of this research is to define thermal
performance on lightweight disc brake models. Thermal performance was a key
factor which was studied using the 3D model in Finite Element Analysis
simulations. Ultimately a design method for lightweight brakes suitable for use on
any car-sized hybrid vehicle was used from previous analysis. The design
requirement, including reducing the thickness, would affect the temperature
distribution and increase stress at the critical area. Based on the relationship
obtained between rotor weight, thickness, undercut effect and offset between hat and
friction ring, criteria have been established for designing lightweight brake discs in a
vehicle with regenerative braking.
2. To analyze the model for displacement and stress using Hyper Mesh 11
4. To find the best material for disc brake among the selected materials
using comparative study.
20
CHAPTER 3
METHODOLOGY
3.1 Introduction to CATIA
CATIA V5 has an innovative and intuitive user interface that unleashes the
designer's creativity. Context-sensitive integrated workbenches provide engineers
21
with the tools they need for the task at hand, and they are beneficial for multi-
discipline integration. The workbenches have powerful keyboard-free direct object
manipulators that maximize user productivity.
22
Design is used to model the rotor blade. It is a complete surfacing tool used to create
complex shape parts such as steam turbine blades.
The geometrical module of the rotor and blade is created using CATIA V5
R20 software, CATIA is a pre-processor were the solid geometry is created using 2-
D drawings, module created in CATIA is exported as IGES file for the next pre-
processor for meshing. The figure 3.2 contains the disc brake rotor and the stages of
the Modeling of disc brake rotor is done by importing nodal data entered in
Microsoft excel sheet into CATIA v5 generate shape design work bench by running
micros.
Part and Shape design are the basic modules of design in CATIA software.
They are based on several tools for easy and qualitative modeling of any kind of
machine elements. First step of design any part is to define position (plane) of
Sketch and to draw profile in chosen Sketch. After that there are several groups of
options that give designers opportunity to make a 3D model: Sketch-Based Features
are entities you combine to make up your part. The features are obtained by applying
commands on initial profiles created in the Sketcher workbench, or in the
Generative Shape Design workbench as well as surfaces.
23
Create a Pad, Create a Pocket, Create a Shaft, Create a Hole, Create a Loft etc.
These features are very useful for different transformations such as: Create a
Translation, Create a Rotation, Create Symmetry, Create a Circular Pattern,
Exploding Patterns, Create a Scaling etc.,
You must use bodies as entities you will eventually associate to the Part
Body using the capabilities described below to finish the design of your part. Here
are Displaying and Editing Parts Properties, Bodies and Features Properties.
This commands are use for some analysis such as Perform a Surface
Curvature Analysis, Analyze Disc brake , Apply a Material, Display Parents and
Children, Define an Axis System, Publish Elements etc. For designing simplest Disc
brake it is first right sketch to define, where should be imported involutes profile
3.4.2 Fundamentals
CATIA V5 employs two operating modes for part modeling, model made for
modeling 3Dparametric parts and drawing mode for creating 2D drawings of them.
These modes operate independently but share the same design data. Part modeling
requires beginning the design work in model mode where a model of the part is
immediately built. Then the drawing mode can be used at any point to document the
design. In traditional CUMPUTER AIDED DESIGN, a 2D drawing is created at the
beginning and then 3D model is built to analyze, and verify the initial concept.
24
Figure 3.2
25
CHAPTER 4
FINITE ELEMENT METHOD
4.1 Introduction to Finite Element Method
The finite element method is a powerful tool to obtain the numerical solution
of wide range of engineering problems. The method is general enough to handle any
complex shape or geometry, for any material under different boundary and loading
conditions. The generality of the finite element method fits the analysis requirement
of today’s complex engineering systems and designs where closed form solutions of
governing equilibrium equations are usually not available. In addition, it is an
efficient design tool by which designers can perform parametric design studies by
considering various design cases, (different shapes, materials, loads, etc.) and
analyze them to choose the optimum design.
The concept of finite element method has been used several centuries back,
although it has named recently. Basic ideas of the finite element method originated
from the aircraft structural analysis, the concept of finite element method was first
used by courant in 1943. He used the principle of stationary potential energy and
piece-wise polynomial interpolation over triangular sub regions, to study the torsion
problems. In 1956 Turner and Clough derived stiffness matrices for truss, beam and
other elements in their presentation. The term finite element was first coined and
used by Clough in 1960. Paper presented by the Clough and Turner presents the
application of simple finite elements for the analysis of aircraft structure and is
considered as one of the key contribution in the development of the finite element
method. The digital computer provided performs many calculations rapidly involved
26
in the finite element analysis and make the method practical viable. Along with
development of high-speed digital computers, the application of the finite element
method also progressed at a very impressive rate. Large general-purpose finite
element computer program emerged during the late 1960s and early1970s.
In the early 1960s, engineers used the method for approximate solution of
problems in stress analysis, fluid flow, heat transfer and other areas. The book by
Prezemieniecki presented the finite element method as applied to the solution of
stress analysis problems. Zienkiewicz and Cheung presented the broad interpretation
of the method and its applicability to any general field problem. In the late 1960s
and early 1970s finite element analysis was applied to non-linear problems and large
deformations. In 1963, the finite element method gained popularity, when it was
recognized as having a sound mathematical foundation. In 1970s study is focused on
new element development and convergence studies. With this broad interpretation of
the finite element method, it has been found that using a weighted residual method
such as Gale kin method or least squares approach can also derive finite element
equations. With all the progress, today the finite element method or least squares
approach is considering as one of the well-established and convenient analysis tool
by engineers and applied scientists.
27
The step-by-step procedure for static structural problem can be stated as follows:
Step 1:- Description of Structure (Domain). The first step in the finite element
method is to divide the structure of solution region in to sub divisions or
elements.
Step 2:- Selection of proper interpolation model. Since the displacement (field
variable) solution of a complex structure under any specified load
conditions cannot be predicted exactly, some suitable solution, is assumed
within an element to approximate the unknown solution. The assumed
solution must be simple and it should satisfy certain convergence
requirements.
Step 3:- Derivation of element stiffness matrices (characteristic matrices) and load
vectors. From the assumed displacement model the stiffness matrix [K(e)]
and the load vector P(e) of element „e‟ are to be derived by using either
equilibrium conditions or a suitable Variation principle.
Step 4:- Assemblage of element equations to obtain the equilibrium equations. Since
the structure is composed of several finite elements, the individual element
stiffness matrices and load vectors are to be assembled in a suitable manner
and the overall equilibrium equation has to be formulated as
[K]φ = P
Step 5:- Solution of system equation to find nodal values of displacement (field
variable) the overall equilibrium equations have to be modified to account
for the boundary conditions of the problem. After the incorporation of the
boundary conditions, the equilibrium equations can be expressed as
[K]φ = P
28
For linear problems, the vector „φ‟ can be solved very easily. But for non-
linear problems, the solution has to be obtained in a sequence of steps, each step
involving the modification of the stiffness matrix [K] and „φ‟ or the load vector P.
Step 6:- Computation of element strains and stresses. From the known nodal
displacements, if required, the element strains and stresses can be
computed by using the necessary equations of solid or structural
mechanics. In the above steps, the words indicated in brackets implement
the general FEM step-by-step procedure.
29
The properties of each element are evaluated separately, so an obvious
advantage is that we can incorporate different material properties for each element.
Thus almost any degree of non-homogeneity can be included. There is no restriction
on to the shape of medium; hence arbitrary and irregular shapes cause no difficulty
like all numerical approximations FEM is based on the concept of description.
Nevertheless as either the variations or residual approach, the technology recognizes
the multidimensional continuous but also requires no separate interpolation process
to extend the approximate solution to every point with the continuum.
The most tedious aspects of use of FEM are basic process of sub-dividing the
continuum of generating error free input data for computer.
The finite element method was developed originally for the analysis of
aircraft structures. However, the general nature of its theory makes it applicable to
wide variety of boundary value problem in engineering. A boundary value problem
is one in which a solution is sought in domain or region of a body subject to the
satisfaction of prescribed boundary conditions. Finite element method is the best
tool in investigation of aircraft structures involving static analysis of wings,
structures of rockets and missiles, dynamic analysis, response to random loads and
periodic loads. In mechanical design, stress concentration problems, stress analysis
of pressure vessels, dynamic analysis of mechanical linkages can be effectively dealt
using finite element method.
30
The specific application of the finite element method in the three major
categories of boundary value problems, namely equilibrium of steady state or time
independent problems, Eigen value problems, and propagation or transient
problems. In the equilibrium problems steady state displacement or stress
distribution is found for a solid mechanics problem, temperature or heat flux
distribution in the case of heat transfer problem. Referring to Eigen value problems
in solid mechanics or structural problem, natural frequencies, buckling loads and
mode shapes are found, stability of laminar flows is found if it is a fluid mechanics
problem and resonance characteristics are obtained if it is an electrical circuit
problem, while for the propagation or transient problem, the response of the body
under time varying force is found in the area of solid mechanics.
Finite element method finds its application in the field of civil engineering in
carrying out the static analysis of trusses, frames and bridges. The dynamic analysis
of the structure is to obtain natural frequencies, modes and response of the structures
to periodic loads. Nuclear engineering also uses finite element method concept in
the static and dynamic characterization of its systems such as nuclear pressure
vessels, containment structure and dynamic response of reactor component
containment structures. Even the Bio-medical engineering applies finite element
method, for impact analysis of skulls. Finite element method can be applied to
analysis of excavation, underground openings and dynamic analysis of dam
reservoir systems, which come under Geo-mechanics.
4.5 Hypermesh 11
31
Altair HyperMesh is a high-performance finite element pre-processor to
prepare even the largest models, starting from import of CAD geometry to exporting
an analysis run for various disciplines.
4.5.1 Benefits
32
With the broadest set of direct CAD and CAE interfaces and the ability to define
custom integrations, HyperMesh works seamlessly within any engineering
environment.
With automatic and semi-automatic shell, tetra, and hexa meshing capabilities,
HyperMesh simplifies the modeling process of complex geometries.
Increase End-user Efficiency with Batch Meshing and Automated Model Assembly
Highly automated methods for rapid model assembly including the assignment
and management of connections such as bolts spot welds, adhesives and seam
welds.
A flexible set of morphing tools allows users to modify legacy meshes without
re-meshing to automate the investigation new design proposals.
Extract shell meshes straight from a thin solid geometry including thickness
assignments with the powerful Mid-map Mesh Generation tools.
Extract composite data from geometry files and transfer it to finite element data
with minimal user interaction.
33
4.5.2 Capabilities
Surface meshing
Tetra meshing
CFD meshing
SPH meshing
34
meshing tasks, this auto-meshing technology provides more time for value-added
engineering simulation activities. BatchMesher provides user-specified control over
meshing criteria and geometry clean-up parameters as well as the ability to output to
customized model file formats.
CATIA V5
IGES
PRO-ENGINEER
PARASOLID
UNIGRAPHICS
STEP
ACIS
JT Precise
4.5.2.4 Connectors
35
4.5.2.5 Composites
For a highly efficient workflow the CATIA reader has been enhanced to read
composite definitions, such as ply shapes, material and ply orientations, directly
from the geometry file. Fibersim drape data can be imported in a very similar way.
HyperMesh offers sophisticated mapping algorithms to transfer the geometric input
data to an FE mesh and associated properties.
HyperMesh supports a host of different solver formats for both import and
export. Along with fully supported solvers, HyperMesh provides a completely
tailored environment (user profile) for each supported solver. It also provides the
flexibility to support additional solvers through a unique and straightforward
interfacing language
Custom Utilities: Create custom applications that are fully integrated within
the HyperMesh interface.
4.6 Radioss
37
4.6.1 Aerospace
To succeed in this task, the aerospace product developers and their extended
enterprise need to exploit full potential of CAE; on one side early in the process to
predict performances supporting decision making, and on the other to accurately
verify designs to meet requirements. Altair HyperWorks provides best-in-class
simulation tools to the aerospace industry for:
Composite Design
38
4.6.2 Automotive
Design Optimization
Durability analysis
Manufacturing simulation
Powertrain systems
39
Chassis systems
40
Altair HyperView is a complete post-processing and visualization
environment for finite element analysis, multi-body system simulation, digital video,
and engineering data. HyperView combines advanced animation and XY plotting
features with window synching to enhance results visualization. HyperView also
saves 3D animation results in Altair's compact H3D format, so users can visualize
and share CAE results within a 3D web environment using Altair HyperView Player.
HyperView’s animation capabilities and speed make it ideal for working with
extremely large models and results files.
To check for correlations between two models or simulation and reality, results
can be overlaid with a model or video within the same window.
41
All post-processing sessions can be stored in a session file or a report template.
Session files help to reopen a complete session spanning across multiple pages
and applications. Report templates similarly reopen previous sessions but can
be used to generate sessions for model variations or similar simulations.
Users can explore CAE models with HyperView’s in-depth model and results
interrogation tools that are based on user-defined criteria.
Users can create custom model views such as section cuts and exploded views
by combining functionality from HyperView’s comprehensive post-processing
tool and utility set.
Completely customize the GUI to cater to the user’s preferences and needs.
Automate any post-processing procedure and embed logical control through the
42
command layer and Tcl/Tk programming.
4.7.2 Capabilities
Animations
Contours (Scalar & Tensor)
Vector plots
Tensor plots
Deformation plots
43
Deformed animations
Linear animations
Modal animations
Transient animations
HyperWorks also offers two translators, HvTrans and HgTrans, for working
with any type of engineering data. HvTrans allows you to extract, translate, and
compress CAE results while HgTrans enables you to convert, compress and process
data files using custom math expressions that can be built from the embedded math
function library.
ABAQUS
LS-DYNA
NASTRAN
ANSYS
PAMCRASH
Adams
44
MADYMO
DADS
SIMPACK
MOLDFLOW
MARC
NIKE3D
LLNL DYNA
Others
2. Processing (or solution) - just click on “Solve"& it's the software's turn to do
the job
45
3. Post processing- Result viewing & interpretation
a) CAD data
C) Boundary conditions
CAD & Meshing -There are specialized software’s for CAD, Meshing &
Analysis. CAD & meshing consumes most of the time For example - Typical time for
a single person to mode1 (CAD) 4cylinder engine block is 6 weeks & for brick
meshing 7 weeks (For tetra mesh about 2 weeks).
Boundary Conditions -Consumes least time but it is the most Important step
(typically applying load cases is about 1 day job). 3 months hard work of meshing &
CAD data preparation of engine block would be undone in just 1 day if boundary
conditions are not applied properly.
During preprocessing user has to work hard while solution step is the turn of
computer to do the job. User has to just click on solve icon & enjoy a cup of tea!
Internally software carries out matrix formations, inversion, multiplication &
solution for unknown e.g. displacement & then find strain stress for static analysis.
Today FEA being used just because of availability of computers. FEM has
been known to Mathematicians & engineers right from late 50's but since solving so
many equations manually was not possible, in true sense FEA got recognition only
46
after emergence of high capacity Computers.
Consider a simple example which involves al1 the above Steps Probably at
the moment you are sitting on a chair or stool & reading this book. In this example
we will analyses the stool itself for stress & displacement for a load of 200 kg
(assuming it could be used for sitting as well as supporting any object up to max. 200
kg wt.)
47
CHAPTER 5
1. The analysis is done taking the distribution of the braking torque between the
front and rear axle is 70:30
3. The analysis is based on pure thermal loading .The analysis does not
determine the life of the disc brake.
4. The kinetic energy of the vehicle is lost through the brake discs i.e. no heat
loss between the tyres and the road surface and the deceleration is uniform.
5. The disc brake model used is of solid type and not the ventilated one.
6. The thermal conductivity of the material used for the analysis is uniform
throughout.
7. The specific heat of the material used is constant throughout and does not
change with the temperature.
8. Heat flux on each front wheel is applied on one side of the disc only.
= 19*25.4 ( 1inch=25.4mm)
= 482.6 mm
48
5.2.1 For Velocity 60 kmph:
D= 16.66*6
D=99.96 meters
Torque T=F.r
Stopping force
a=2.77 m/sec2
F = 1400*2.77(kg.m/sec2)
F=3878 N
Torque =F.r
= 3878* (482.6/2)
= 935761.4 N-mm
= 935.761 N- m
Brake set=4
= 233.94 N-m
Tf =µ N rm
N=
N=
49
µ=0.4 from the review paper (20)
= mm
rm =0.131 m
N=
N=4464 N
Pressure (P) =
= 0.579 MPa
D= 27.77*6
D=166.62 meters
Torque T=F.r
Stopping force
50
a=4.6283 m/sec2
F = 1400*4.6283
F=6479.62 N
Torque =F.r
= 6479.62* (482.6/2)
= 1563532.306 N-mm
= 1563.53 N- m
Brake set=4
= 390.88 N-m
Tf =µ N rm
N=
N=
= mm
rm =0.131 m
N=
51
N=7459.54 N
Pressure (P) =
= 0.9636 MPa
5.3 Thermal Calculations
5.3.1 Disc Brake Calculations for 100 kmph:
Given Data:
Velocity of the vehicle =100 km/h
υ = 27.77 m/s
Step-1:
Kinetic Energy (K.E) = ½ * m * υ2
= ½ * 1400 *(27.77)2
= 539821.03 Joules
The above said is the Total Kinetic Energy induced while the vehicle is under
motion.
Step-2:
Qg = 539821.03 Joules
52
Step-3:
The area of the rubbing faces
Step-4:
Heat Flux (q) = Heat Generated / Second / rubbing area
= 539821.03/6/ 61928.808
= 1.3014 Watts / mm2
The analysis is done by taking the distribution of braking torque between the front
and rear axle is 70:30
Thus
Heat Flux on each front wheel = (1.3014* 0.7)/2
= 0.4559 Watts / mm2
υ = 16.66 m/s
Step-1:
Kinetic Energy (K.E) = ½ * m * υ2
= ½ * 1400 *(16.66)2
= 194288.42 Joules
The above said is the Total Kinetic Energy induced while the vehicle is under
motion.
53
Step-2:
The total kinetic energy = the heat generated
Qg = 194288.42 Joules
Step-3:
The area of the rubbing faces
The analysis is done by taking the distribution of braking torque between the
front and rear axle is 70:30
Thus
Heat Flux on each front wheel = (0.7843* 0.7)/2
= 0.2745 Watts / mm2
The Properties of the materials selected for present study is shown in table 5.1.
Table5.1 Properties of materials used
54
Poisson’s Ratio 0.3 0.3 0.33
Coefficient of Thermal 1e-5 2.3e-5 17.6e-6
Expansion in /0C
Static analysis for displacement and stress have been carried out for materials
such as steel, Aluminum and Aluminum matrix material composite at velocities
60kmph and 100kmph are given in the sub sections
At velocity 60kmph
55
Fig 5.2: Stress of Steel disc at 60 kmph
56
Fig 5.5: Displacement of AlMMC disc at 60 kmph
At velocity 100kmph
57
Fig5.8: Stress of Steel disc at 100 kmph
58
Fig5.11: Displacement of AlMMC disc at 100 kmph
Static loads are those which are applied to a structure very gradually,
increasing from zero to their final value and then either do not change their
magnitude, direction or point of application with time at all or change them very
slightly, so that accelerations occurred in this case can be neglected.
59
Steel 1079 433
Aluminum 508 204
Aluminum based Metal 435 174
Matrix Composite
5.8 Thermal Analysis for Grid Temperature of disc using Hyper Mesh
Thermal analysis for Grid temperature has been carried out for materials
such as steel, Aluminum and Aluminum matrix material composite for velocities
60kmph and 100kmph are given in the sub sections
At velocity 60kmph
60
Fig5.15: Grid Temperature of AlMMC disc at 60 kmph
At velocity 100kmph
61
Fig5.17: Grid Temperature of Al disc at 100 kmph
At 60 kmph:
62
Fig 5.19 Stress distribution along radial distance at 60kmph
At 100 kmph:
63
Fig 5.21 Stress distribution along radial distance for 100 kmph
At 60 Kmph
64
Fig 5.23 Grid Temperature along Radial Thickness at 60kmph
At 100 kmph:
65
CHAPTER-6
6.1 Conclusion
The present study can provide a useful design and improve the brake
performance of disc brake using three different materials Steel, Aluminum,
Aluminum based metal matrix composite. The design was analyzed considering the
effects of thermal expansion and pressure load separately. This is done to study the
amount of deformation due to pressure loading individually. These results are used to
study the increase in deformation. The following conclusions are drawn from the
present study.
66
matrix composite are high and hence maximum stress obtained is low for the
materials.
2. Even though stress and displacement for Aluminum and Aluminum based metal
matrix composite are almost equal to steel but the nodal temperatures for the
applied heat flux are very high in the disc made of steel.
3. From the study it is concluded that all values obtained from the analysis are less
than their allowable values.
Thus conclusion is made from the above analysis stating that the brake disc
made of Aluminum and Aluminum based metal matrix composite can be used as
alternative materials.
67
REFERENCE
2. Abd Rahim AbuBakar and Huajiang Ouyang Complex eigenvalue analysis and
dynamic transient analysis in predicting disc brake squeal Int. J. Vehicle Noise
and Vibration, Vol. 2, No. 2, 2006
68
stress in ventilated disc brake based on 3D thermo-mechanical coupling model
DOI 10.1007/s12206-009-1116-7 Journal of Mechanical Science and
Technology 24 (2010) 81~84 www.springerlink.com/content/1738-494x.
6. Saw Chun Lin1, Abd Rahim Abu Bakar*, Wan Mohd Musyris Wan Harujan,
Badri Abd Ghani and Mohd Rahimi Jamaluddin SUPPRESSING DISC
BRAKE SQUEAL THROUGH STRUCTURAL MODIFICATIONS Jurnal
Mekanikal December 2009, No. 29, 67-83.
10. A.A. Adebisi1, M.A. Maleque1 and Q.H. Shah2 SURFACE TEMPERATURE
DISTRIBUTION IN A COMPOSITE BRAKE ROTOR International Journal
of Mechanical and Materials Engineering (IJMME), Vol.6 (2011), No.3, 356-
361 Received 1 December 2010, Accepted 25 December 2011
11. Mohd Firdaus Abu Bakar1, Muhd Ridzuan Mansor2, Mohd Zaid Akop3, Mohd
Afzanizam Mohd Rosli4, Mohd Azli Salim5 Thermal Analysis of Ventilated
Disc Brake Rotor for UTeM Formula Varsity Race Car Journal of Engineering
and Technology ISSN: 2180-3811 Vol. 2 June 2011
69
12. Sharath Kumar T. and S.Vinodh Novel Design and Analysis of a Brake Rotor
World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology 61 2012
13. G. Babukanth & M. Vimal Teja Transient Analysis of Disk Brake By using
Ansys Software International Journal of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering
(IJMIE), ISSN No. 2231 –6477, Vol-2, Issue-1, 2012
14. Haripal Singh and Harshdeep Shergill Thermal Analysis of Disc Brake Using
Comsol International Journal on Emerging Technologies 3(1): 84-88(2012)
18. S Naveen Kumar and Dr. M B Kiran Redesign of Disc Brake Assembly with
Lighter Material International Journal of Engineering Research & Technology
(IJERT) ISSN: 2278-0181 Vol. 1 Issue 7, September - 2012
70
21. M. K. Khalid, M. R. Mansor, S. I. Abdul Kudus, M. M. Tahir, and M. Z. Hassan
Performance Investigation of the UTeM Eco Car Disc Brake System
International Journal of Engineering & Technology IJET-IJENS Vol: 11 No: 06
DEC-2012
71