Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Ocean Engineering
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/oceaneng
art ic l e i nf o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Reliable measurement of a deflection magnitude refers to one of the most important tasks in floating dry
Received 25 June 2015 dock operation. Current and accurate information about the deflection can prevent structural damage
Accepted 6 March 2016 and failure by activating alarms and on-board deflection compensation systems. This paper describes the
Available online 22 March 2016
development of a deflection measuring system for floating dry docks. The measuring system is capable of
Keywords: measuring the actual deflection of a dock structure in real-time and fully automatic mode. The system
Deflection measurement consists of a set of reference marks based on light emitting diodes and a measurement unit with two
Floating dry dock oppositely directed camera-based channels. The measurement unit is placed in the middle of a wing deck
Camera-based measuring system of the dock. The measurement unit and the reference marks are aligned along the wing deck. The
Reference mark
accuracy of deflection measurement of 7 1:5 mm in the range of 7150 mm for the docks in length more
Harsh environment
than 100 m was achieved during laboratory tests. The system resistance to harsh environment (salt fog,
temperature gradient, high humidity, etc.) and the ability to perform measurements in 24/7 regime was
proved through field tests at a floating dry dock in operation.
& 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.oceaneng.2016.03.012
0029-8018/& 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
40 V.V. Korotaev et al. / Ocean Engineering 117 (2016) 39–44
each end of the wind deck) and the rest two points are at 1/4 and 3.2. Principle of operation
3/4 of the wing deck length. In this case, the fourth-degree poly-
nomial deformation profile can be calculated by solving a system A deflection of the dock causes linear shift of the reference
of five equations to find the polynomial coefficients k4 ; k3 ; k2 ; k1 ; k0 . marks. As the marks are projected onto the cameras sensors, the
images with marks are captured and analysed to give the shift of
the marks. The developed software automatically detects the
marks images and measures their location at the cameras sensors.
3. Camera-based deflection control system
The used algorithm for the detection of the mark image is pre-
sented in Fig. 4. First, an image with the switched on mark is
3.1. Description of the system
captured (Fig. 4(a)). A region of interest (ROI) is used to minimise a
The structure of the system to measure deflection of one wing search area (Fig. 4(b)). The ROI is defined during the installation of
the system and it corresponds to the defined measurement range
wall is shown in Fig. 3. The same set of units has to be mounted at
(see Table 1). Then an image with the switched of mark is captured
the second wing wall. The system to measure one wing wall
(Fig. 4(c)). As a result a frame-to-frame difference (Fig. 4(d)) which
contains a set of reference marks, a measuring and a processing
reveals the mark location is calculated. In addition a check using
units and a monitor. The reference marks are mounted at holders
expected intensity level and the image size of the mark is done for
at the measurement points along the wing deck to visualize the
reliability.
linear displacement of these points. Electrical power is supplied to
Once the image of the mark is detected, the location of the
each mark by wires. The measurement unit is placed in the middle
mark is measured in the raw image (Fig. 4(a)) with a subpixel
of the wing deck. The unit measures relative position of the marks
accuracy. For this task different kinds of algorithms with accura-
with respect to its own position. Each mark contains a set of
cies up to 0.01 pixel can be used (Zhukov et al., 2009; Mas et al.,
infrared light emitting diodes (LEDs) TSAL5100 (wavelength
2012; Savransky et al., 2013; Haist et al., 2014). An iterative algo-
940 nm, angle of half intensity 10°, optical power 35 mW) by
rithm based on Zhukov et al. (2009) was used due to its high
VISHAY. LEDs are projected to a camera sensor by a long focal-
reliability. The detection and measuring algorithms are imple-
length lens Jupiter 11 (f ¼ 135 mm, F set to 12). The camera is
mented in an automatic mode, so no human interaction with the
based on Aptina MT9P031 sensor with 2592 1944 pixels. One software is required. The displacement hðzi Þ of the i mark located
camera with lens forms “bow” measurement channel (Fig. 3), at a distance zi can be found by estimating the coordinate of the
another one forms “stern” channel. Each channel has an infrared mark image ypix0i in pixels (Korotaev et al., 2010; Pantyushin and
pass and visible cut off filter to match the spectral range of the Korotaev, 2012):
LEDs with the cameras. During the measurements the images from
z
bow and stern channels are analyzed by a designed software at the hðzi Þ ¼ ypix0i p i0 ; ð3Þ
f
processing unit, which is based on an industrial computer (945GSE
0 0
by LiPPERT). The information about current deflection is displayed when zi ⪡f , where f is a back focal length of the lens, p is the
0
in a control room of the dock and transferred to a control system linear size of the sensor element (pixel). The ratio zi =f defines the
of the dock. The overall system performance results in a mea- scale of the pixel to mm conversion. To simplify the estimation of
0
surement data rate of 1 Hz. the distance zi and the back focal length f at a real dock the
In addition, the developed camera-based system (Fig. 3) does calibration of the scale can be done with designed mark holders
not require significant infrastructure at a dock, so it can be (Fig. 3). The holders have mounting places for the marks at 0 and
installed to a new or existing dock. 7150 mm. The positions are predefined with accuracy up to
Fig. 3. Structure of designed and developed system for deflection measuring. Units to measure the deflection of one of two wing walls are depicted.
42 V.V. Korotaev et al. / Ocean Engineering 117 (2016) 39–44
deflection is
Fig. 6. Developed deflection measurement system installed on a 125 m floating dry dock during the field tests.
Fig. 7. Results of the laboratory tests: (a) and (b) error of measurement of the bow and stern marks position, respectively, and (c) the resultant error of the deflection
measurement.
Materials and Products for Ships, Part V Technical Supervision Haist, T., Dong, S., Arnold, T., Gronle, M., Osten, W., 2014. Multi-image position
During Construction of Ships, 2014) on international requirements detection. Opt. Express 22 (12), 14450–14463.
Hedger, R., 2007. Dockmaster Training Manual.
for deflection measuring systems (Germanischer Lloyd Aktienge- Kleshchenok, M.A., Anisimov, A.G., Lashmanov, O.U., Timofeev, A.N., Korotaev, V.V.,
sellschaft. Rules for Classification and Construction. Floating 2014. Alignment control optical-electronic system with duplex retroreflectors.
Docks, 1993; Rules for Classification of Floating Docks, 2009; Rules In: SPIE Photonics Europe. International Society for Optics and Photonics,
pp. 91311X–91311X.
for Building and Classing. Steel Floating Dry Docks, 2009). Korotaev, V.V., Konyakhin, I.A., Timofeev, A.N., Yaryshev, S.N., 2010. High precision
It should be noted, that the system is capable of measuring multimatrix optic-electronic modules for distributed measuring systems. In:
linear shift of reference mark along X 0 direction too (see Fig. 1). Sixth International Symposium on Precision Engineering Measurements and
Instrumentation. International Society for Optics and Photonics, pp. 75441E–
This is secondary data in general dock operation, but it can be 75441E.
presented without changes of system structure (owning to used Korotaev, V.V., Timofeev, A.N., Gorbachev, A.A., Pantjushin, A.V., Aleev, A.M., Kule-
camera sensors). shova, E.N., 2012. Apparatus for controlling deformations of elongated object.
RU Patent 2445572, March 20.
For future development additional improvements of the system
Korotaev, V.V., Timofeev, A.N., Ivanov, A.G., 2000. Problems in the development of
can be done. A deflection profile of a floating dry dock depends on optoelectronic systems for monitoring displacements of large-sized objects. J.
a water–air temperature difference (Tupper, 2013). So additional Opt. Technol. c/c Opticheskii zhurnal 67 (4), 336–339.
temperature compensation of the measurement output can be Lynch, J.P., Wang, Y., Loh, K.J., Yi, J.-H., Yun, C.-B., 2006. Performance monitoring of
the geumdang bridge using a dense network of high-resolution wireless sen-
implemented. Another challenge for the deflection measurement sors. Smart Mater. Struct. 15 (6), 1561.
by optics is the sun heating of the wing deck, that causes air Maraev, A.A., Timofeev, A.N., 2013. Energetic sensitivity of optical-electronic sys-
refraction and turbulence. Still it is important to notice that tems based on polychromatic optical equisignal zone. In: SPIE Optical Metrol-
ogy 2013. International Society for Optics and Photonics, pp. 878836–878836.
combined influence of the said factors does not exceed 1 mm at Maraev, A.A., Vasilev, A.S., Timofeev, A.N., 2014. Study of irradiance distribution in
working distances and the total error of the system taking these optical equisignal zone. In: SPIE Photonics Europe. International Society for
factors into account is still smaller than required 75 mm. Optics and Photonics, pp. 91380Q–91380Q.
Mas, D., Ferrer, B., Sheridan, J.T., Espinosa, J., 2012. Resolution limits to object
tracking with subpixel accuracy. Opt. Lett. 37 (23), 4877–4879.
Mott, R.L., 2014. Applied Strength of Materials. CRC Press.
6. Conclusions Newman, T.S., Jain, A.K., 1995. A survey of automated visual inspection. Comput.
Vis. Image Underst. 61 (2), 231–262.
Nixon, M., Nixon, M.S., Aguado, A.S., 2012. Feature Extraction and Image Processing
In this paper a system for deflection measuring of floating dry for Computer Vision. Academic Press.
docks is presented. The developed system is the camera-based Pantyushin, A.V., Korotaev, V.V., 2012. Control measurement system for railway
track position. In: SPIE Optical Engineering þ Applications. International
device that employs digital image processing of the spatial posi-
Society for Optics and Photonics, pp. 84861B–84861B.
tion of reference marks placed along each wing deck of the dock. Rules for Building and Classing. Steel Floating Dry Docks, 2009. American Bureau of
Approach to perform the deflection control of the floating dry Shipping.
dock based on measuring of position of a finite number of points Rules for Classification of Floating Docks, 2009. China Classification Society.
Rules for Technical Supervision during Construction of Ships and Manufacture of
along the wing deck was described. The system can be installed to Materials and Products for Ships, Part V Technical Supervision During Con-
a new or an existing dock and does not require significant infra- struction of Ships, 2014. Russian Maritime Register of Shipping.
structure. Test results of use of the developed system both in the Sannerhaugen, V., Hellvik, S., 1999. Method and device for continuous monitoring
of dynamic loads. US Patent 5,942,750, August 24. URL: 〈http://www.google.
laboratory facility and the real dock infrastructure are provided com/patents/US5942750〉.
and discussed. The laboratory tests indicated that the developed Savransky, D., Thomas, S.J., Poyneer, L.A., Macintosh, B.A., 2013. Computer vision
system demonstrates good measurement accuracy and the tests at applications for coronagraphic optical alignment and image processing. Appl.
Opt. 52 (14), 3394–3403.
the real dock showed that the system is capable to work in a harsh Smith, D., LeVezu, A., 2012. Floating dock deflection management systems. US
environment with no breakdowns. Patent 8,155,812, April 10. URL: 〈https://www.google.com/patents/US8155812〉.
Smith, W.F., Hashemi, J., 2006. Foundations of Materials Science and Engineering.
Mcgraw-Hill Publishing.
Sonka, M., Hlavac, V., Boyle, R., 2014. Image Processing, Analysis, and Machine
Acknowledgements Vision. Cengage Learning.
Stiros, S.C., Psimoulis, P.A., 2012. Response of a historical short-span railway bridge
to passing trains: 3-d deections and dominant frequencies derivedfrom robotic
This work was partially financially supported by the Govern- total station (rts) measurements. Eng. Struct. 45, 362–371.
ment of the Russian Federation, Grant 074-U01. Swartz, R.A., Zimmerman, A.T., Lynch, J.P., Rosario, J., Brady, T., Salvino, L., Law, K.H.,
2012. Hybrid wireless hull monitoring system for naval combat vessels. Struct.
Infrastruct. Eng. 8 (7), 621–638.
Tupper, E.C., 2013. Introduction to Naval Architecture: Formerly Muckle's Naval
References Architecture for Marine Engineers. Butterworth-Heinemann.
Vincent, P.S., Gardiner, C.P., Wilson A.R., Ellery, D., Armstrong, T., 2008. Installation
of a sensor network on an ran armidale class patrol boat. In: Materials Forum,
Carbonari, S., Gara, F., Roia, D., Leoni, G., Dezi, L., 2013. Tests on two 18-years-old
vol. 33, pp. 307–316.
prestressed thin walled roof elements. Eng. Struct. 49, 936–946.
Yang, G., Liang, H., Wu, C., 2013. Deflection and inclination measuring system for
Froggatt, M., Moore, J., 1998. High-spatial-resolution distributed strain measure-
floating dock based on wireless networks. Ocean Eng. 69, 1–8.
ment in optical fiber with rayleigh scatter. Appl. Opt. 37 (10), 1735–1740.
Zhukov, D.V., Konyakhin, I.A., Usik, A.A., 2009. Iterative algorithm for determining
Gaythwaite, J.W., 2004. Design of Marine Facilities for the Berthing, Mooring, and
the coordinates of the images of point radiators. J. Opt. Technol. 76 (1), 36–38,
Repair of Vessels, 2nd edition.
URL: 〈http://jot.osa.org/abstract.cfm?URI ¼jot-76-1-36〉.
Germanischer Lloyd Aktiengesellschaft. Rules for Classification and Construction.
Zou, L., Bao, X., Yang, S., Chen, L., Ravet, F., 2006. Effect of brillouin slow light on
Floating Docks, 1993.
distributed brillouin fiber sensors. Opt. Lett. 31 (18), 2698–2700.
Gorbachev, A.A., Konyakhin, I.A., Musyakov, V.L., Timofeev, A.N., 2007. Study of the
structural features of invariant optoelectronic systems with a unified matrix
analysis field. J. Opt. Technol. 74 (12), 810–814.