Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
FILED
rN THE CIITCUIII COURT OF COOK COUN'rg ILLINOXS 8/12/2019 12:37 PM
COUN'IY DEI'ARTMENT LANø DIVISION DOROTHY BROWN
CIRCUIT CLERK
Shearal Cole, as Special Administrator of the Estate of Felon Nicole Smith deceased COOK COUNTY, IL
FILED DATE: 8/12/2019 12:37 PM 2019L008880
2019L008880
No.
Pro Se On[y: E I have ¡oacl ancl ¿ìgree to the telns of rhe Clcrl¿i Ofice li/cctronic Noticc Po/icy ancl choose ro opt in to elecrlonic r.rorice
folrn rhc Clerl<'s Office fol this case at th.is email aclcless:
8/12/2019 12:37 PM
DOROTHY BROWN
CIRCUIT CLERK
COMT'LAINIT AT LAW
NOW COMES the Plaintiff, SHEARAL COLE, as Special Administrator of the Estate ol
FELON NICOLE SMITH, Deceased, by and through his attorneys, JEFFREY J. NESLUND,
LAW OFFICES OF' JEFF'REY J. NESLUND and TI-IOMAS J. IIYLAND, HYLAND LAW,
COMMON ALT,EG,ATTONS
1. On and prior to June27,2019, and at all tinres thereaf'ter relevant l"o this action,
PlaintilT, SHEARAL COLE, as Special Administrator ol the Estate ol'FELON NICOLE SMITI-I,
corporation created by Section 3 of the Metropolitan Transit Authority Act, codified at 70 ILCS
3. On and prior to June 27,2019, and at all tirnes thereafter relevant to this action,
public transit rail selvice to the public at large in the City of Chicago, within Cook County, Illinois,
4. On ancl prior to June21,2019, and at all times therealtel relevant to this action,
Defendaut, AGB INVESTIGATIVE SERVICES, INC. ("AGB"), was an Illinois corporation that
5. On or about April 17,2019, Defendant CTA entered into a contract witli Defèndant
AGB to provide security selvices to monitor CTA platforms, enforce CTA security and safety
rules and protect the well-being and safety of members of tlie public who uiilized CTA trains and
platforms.
6. On and prior to June2J,2079, and at all times thereafter relevant to this action,
Defendant, CTA owned, operated, maintained and controllecl electric commuter trains and the
station on the Red Line track, commonly known as the "69'l' Street Red Line" station, located at
7. On and prior to June 2J,2019, CTA had an affirmative duty as a common carrier
to aid and protect passengers against unreasonable risks of physical harrn, including the decedent,
a contractual obligation to aid and protect CTA passengers agains[ unl'easonable risks of physical
9 . On anil prior to June 27 , 2079, and at all times thereafter relevant to this action, the
"69t1' Street Recl Line" station owned, operatecl, maintained and controllecl by Defendant, CTA,
was open to commuters and the public at large to use for public transportzrtion.
10. On ancl prior to Jtne 2J ,2019 , and at all times thereafter relevant to this action, the
"69tI'street Red Line" station owned, operated, maintained and controlled by Defendant, CTA was
1 1. On and prior to June 27 ,2019, it was the cluty and responsibility of CTA and AGB
employees and agents to oversee all issues of safety for commuters while they were located at the
12. On and plior to June2J,2019, ancl at all tirnes thereafter relevant to this ¿rction,
Def'endant CTA owned, operated and controlled certain electric commuter trains that were staffed
13. On and prior to June 2 / , 2019, and at all times thereafter relevant to this action, it
was the responsibility of Defendant CTA's rail operators to maintain a proper lookout for any track
obstructions, including pedestrians in tlie track alea and reduce speed and/or stop the train if
necessary.
14. On and prior to June 21 ,2019, and at all times thereafter relevant to this action, the
Defendant CTA, individually and tl-rrough its agents, servants, and employees, owecl a duty of care
in both ownership, man¿ìgement, and control of the commuter trains and ¡¡" "69tlt SÍeet Recl Line"
station, including the platform ancl traclc areas, to protect individuals from trains being operatecl on
FILED DATE: 8/12/2019 12:37 PM 2019L008880
the traclcs which would enter and pass through the station.
15. On and priol to June21,2019, Defendant CTA had prior notice that the public at
large standing on platforms with the intention to board trains at CTA stations, including the "69tb
S[reet Red Line" station, had entered the track area on prior occasions to retrieve belongings, were
pushed, or otherwise had wound up on the train tracks and were injured by trains.
16. On and prior to June27,20l9, Defendant, C'fA, had actual and constructive notice
that its rail system, including its tracks zrnd trains, could pose a dangerous hazard and could harm
commuters present at CTA stations, including the "69t1' Street Red Line" station.
17. On and prior to lune 2J,2019, the responsibilities of the CTA and AGII
employees/agents for ensuring commuter safety at train stations such ¿rs the "69th Street Red Line"
station included monitoring commuter activity, ensuring that commuters clid not approach or enter
the train tracks and provide assistance and aicl to commuters who may have entered the tlain tracks
train stations like the "69th Street Red Line" station had a communication system in place where
employees/agents could immediately contact CTA central command and/or rail operators directly,
and inform CTA central command and/or CTA rail operators about the presence of commuters on
tlie train tracks so that CTA rail operators could slow or stop trains and/or shut off power to the
19 . On and prior to June 27 , 2019 , Defendant CTA and Defendant AGB, thlough their
employees and/or agents had a duty to take steps to assist passengers who they knew or should
have knowll were on the tracl<s, including contzrcting CTA central command and/or rail operators
FILED DATE: 8/12/2019 12:37 PM 2019L008880
20. On June 27,2019, FELON NICOLE SMITH presented herself at the 69tì' Street
Recl Line train platform, with the intention of becorling a passenger on a CTA train. As such,
Defendant CTA by ancl through its agents, Defenclant AGB ancl FELON NICOLE SMITIf stood
21, On June 21,2019, CTA and AGB employees/agents were ou duty and in the course
and scope of their employment ¿rt the 69tl' Stl'eet Red Line platform.
22. On June 27,2019, FELON NICOLE SMITH was on the north platform waiting for
a train, when she dropped her cell phone into tlie track area.
23. On June 27,2019, the CTA and/or AGB employees/agents failed to instruct or
prevent FELON NICOLE SMITH from entering the track area to retrieve her phone.
24. Ou June 2'7,2019, FELON NICOLE SMITH retrieved hel cell phone and no trains
25. On June 27 , 2019, CTA and/or AGB employees/agents were in close proximity to
the area on the tracks where FELON NICOLE SMITH went to retrieve her phone and knew or
26, On June 21, 2019, CTA and/or AGB employees/agents abandoned FELON
NICOLE SMITH who was in obvious need of assistance to exit the track area.
28. On June 2'/,2019, despite knowledge that FELON NICOLE SMITH was in the
track area in need of assistance and despite the CTA policy that no one should be in the track area,
the CTA and AGB ernployees/agerlts failed to ensure that FELON NICOLE, SMITFI safely existed
FILED DATE: 8/12/2019 12:37 PM 2019L008880
29. On June 27,2019, the CTA rail operzrtor of the northbound train zrpprozrching the
"6911' Street Recl Line" station was looking out the window and rnaking hand gestures r¿rther than
30. On June 27,2019, the CTA rail operator on the notthbound train was looking out
the window and failed to see the dececlent and stop the train when he knew or shoulcl have known
maintained and controllecl by Defenciant CTA struck decedent, FELON NICOLE SMITH,
çAUXTI
Ç-h! çaeq T raaq i!.4 !r-th qd tv
(Negligence)
32. Plaintiff adopts ancl re-alleges paragraphs 1 through 3l of the Common Allegations
33. That at all times relevant, Defendant CTA through the CTA's respective agents,
servants and employees, named and unnamecl, had a cluty to exercise reasonable care for the safety
34. That at the aforesaid time and place, Defenclant CTA through the CTA's respective
agents, servants and employees, named and unnamed, breached their duty by con-rmitting one or
more of the following acts ancl/or omissions in a careless anil negligent manner:
a) The CTA rail operator failed to keep ¿ì proper lookout as tl-ìe northbouncl
train approachecl the 69rl' Street Red Line platforrn;
b) The CTA rail operator failed to exercise due care and diverted his attention
aw¿ìy frorn the tracks as he approached the 69rl' Street lled Line platforrn;
FILED DATE: 8/12/2019 12:37 PM 2019L008880
c) The CTA rail operator failed to reduce speed and/or stop the train to avoicl
striking the decedent, FELON NICOLE SMITH;
h) The CTA ernployees/agents on the platfbrm fìiiled to gct the tracks' power
shut off after the clecedent enterecl the track area;
35. The death of dececlent, FELON NICOLE SMITH, occurred as a proximate result
of one or more of the negligent acts and omissions of Defenclant CTA as listed above.
36. The CTA's conduct as listed herein was a material element and ¿r subst¿rnti¿rl f¿rctor
in bringing about the dececlent's injures and death. trspecially given CTA's ¿ìw¿ìreness of prior
incidents ancl advertising campaigns about members of the public being on the tracks in adclition
to the fact that CTA employees/agents knew of decedent's presence on the tracks, Despite this
actual or collstructive notice, tlie CTA employees/agents nonetheless failed to ensure the
FILED DATE: 8/12/2019 12:37 PM 2019L008880
decedent's safety.
37 . In light of the facts and knowleclge described herein, the CTA knew or should have
known that FELON NICOLE SMITH's injury and/or death were foreseeable.
38. On June 27 ,2019, if the CTA ernployees/agents h¿rd exercised re¿rsonable cal'e in
operating the train and monitoring the platform and track area, steps could h¿rve been taken to
assist FELON NICOLE SMITH after she was ou the tracks and to prevent her death, inclucling
removitlg her from the tracks, alerting central command and/or the rail operatol of her presence to
39. On June 27 ,2019, the failure to take the steps listed ¿ibove was a cause of the death
40. The Plaintiff, SHEARAL COLE, as Special Aclministrator of the Estate of FELON
NICOLE SMITH, deceased, brings this action pursuant to the provisions of 740ILCS 180/l et
seq., commonly known as the Wrongful Death Act of the State of Illinois.
41. The decedent, FELON NICOLE SMITH, is survived by her next of kin:
42. I'-ELON NICOLE SMITH's next of kin sulfered injuries as a result of her death,
including the loss of companionship ancl society and grief and sorrow, and FELON NICOLE
SMITH's next of kin have sustained significant pecuniary loss and loss of consortium, having
suffered and will continue to suffer into the future as a result of the death of FEI-ON NICOLE
FILED DATE: 8/12/2019 12:37 PM 2019L008880
SMITH.
FELON NICOLE SMITH, deceased, asks that a juclgrnent be entered against the Defenclant
CI-IICAGO TRANSIT AUTIIORITY, in such an amount which exceeds the jurisdiclional limit or
in such ar-ì amourlt sum that a Court or jury may deem fit and proper, plus costs of suit.
qOUNT II
A-GB -.I¡ry eslrsq-t! yç $ eryicq.s" I! ç.
(l{egligence)
43. Plaintiff adopts and re-alleges paraglaphs 1 througli 31 of the Common Allegations
44. That at all times relevant, Defendant AGB thlough the AGB's respcctive agents,
servants and employees, named ancl unnamed, had a duty to exercise reasonable care for the safety
45. 'fhat at the aforesaid time and place, Defenclant AGB through the AGB's respective
agents, servants and employees, narned and unnamed, brezrched their duty by committing one or
more of the following acts and/or omissions in a careless and negligent manner:
b) allowed or permitted the decedent to enter the track area in disregard fbr
the safety and well-being of the decedent;
c) failed to instruct the decedent to move under the platforrn off the tracks
alier irnproperly allowing or pelrnitting her to enter the tracl< area, in
disregard for the saf'ety ancl well-being of the dececlent;
reduce speed and/or stop tl-ìe train prior to entering the station and striking
decedeut.
h) failed to take the reasonable and necessary steps to ensure clececlent's safety
on the premises.
46. The death of decedent, FELON NICOLE SMITII, occurred as a proximate result
ol'one or more of the negligent acts an<J omissions of Defendant, AGB as listed above.
47 . The AGII's conduct as listed herein was a naterial elernent and a substantial factor'
48. On June 27 ,2019, il the AGB ernployees/agents had excrcised rcasonablc ca.re in
monitoring the track area alier lcarning of FELON NICOLE SMITI-I's preseÍìce on the lrach area,
steps could have been taken to assist FELON NICOLE SMITH aI'ter she was on the tracks and to
prevent her dea[h, including rcmoving her from the tr¿rcl<s, alerting central command ¿rnd/or the
rail operator of her prcsence on the tracks, and/or turning off the power to the on-corning train
and/or tracks.
49. On June 27 ,2019, the failure to take the steps listed above was a cause of the death
50. The Plaintilï, SIIEARAL COLE, as Special Administrator of the Estate of FELON
NICOLb, SMITH, cleceased, brings this action pursuant to the provisions of 140ILCS 180/1 et
seq., comrrìonly l<nown as the Wrongful Death Act of the State of Illinois.
-5I . The Decedent, FELON NICOLE SMITFI, is survived by her next of lcin:
l0
c) Her minor sor.r, S. C., age 12; and
FILED DATE: 8/12/2019 12:37 PM 2019L008880
52. FELON NICOLE SMITH's next of kin sufferecl injulies as a result of her death,
inclucling the loss of companionship and society and glief and sorrow, and FELON NICOLE
SMITI{'s next of kin have sustainecl significant pecunìary loss and loss of consortiutn, having
suffered and will continue to suffer into the future as a result of the death of FELON NICOLE
SMITFI.
FELON NICOLE SMITII, deceirsecl, asks th¿it a judgrnent be entered againsl- the Defenclant AGII
INVESTIGATIVE SERVICES, INC., in such an amount which exceeds the jurisdictional limit or'
in such an amounf sum that a Court or jury may deem fit and proper, plus costs of suit.
COUNT TII
(735 ILCS 5/27-62 Survival Action)
53. PlaintifÏ adopts and le-alleges paragraphs I through 31 of the Cornmon Aliegations
54. FELON NICOLE SMITH sustained severe emotional and physical pain and
suffering prior to her death as the direct and proximate result of one or lrore of the Defenclants'
negligent conduct outlinecl above. FELON NICOLE SMITH would have been entitled to receive
NICOLE SMITH, deceased, brings this action pursuant to the Illinois Survival Statute, 735 II-CS
5/27-6.
FELON NICOLE SMITH, deceased, asks that a judgrnent be entered against the Defendants
lt
CHICAGO TRANSIT AUTHORITY and AGB INVESTIGATIVE SERVICES, INC., in such an
FILED DATE: 8/12/2019 12:37 PM 2019L008880
amount which exceeds the jurisdictional limit or in such an amount sum that a Coult ol july rnay
COUINT IV
(Negligent F{iring ancl ftefcntion a gainst Chica go'tr'ransit,r\uthority)
57. Defèndant CTA had a duty to use reasonable care to select a security firm that was
competent, qualif ied and fit to perfbnl the duties reqr.rired to enf'orce CTA security and sal'ety rules
and protect the well-being and safèty ol rnembers of the public who utilized CTA trains and
58. At all tirnes material, Delèndant CTA either dircctly ol through its urgents,
negligently hired, retained and/or supervised the agents/employees of Def'endant AGB whcn the
Delèndant CTA l<new or should have hnown that a failur-e to ¿ìppropriately evaluate, asscss and
intervene in the event of a pedestt'ian on the traclcs could result in severe injury and death.
59. Despite this knowledge, Defèndant CTA failed to exercise reasonable care in
hiring, retaining and/or sr-rper:vising platfbrm security agents of Delèndant AGB on the "69t1'
60. Defèndant CTA knew, or should have known that Defendant AGB did not liave
the ability to hire and/or train qualified personnel for the transit security and saf'ety neecls of
Defèndant CTA.
61 . Defenclant CTA knew, or should have hnown that Defenclant AGB security guards
lacked the qualif ications and specific training to reasonably or aclequately enfolce CTA secLrrity
l2
and safety rules ancl protect the well-being and safety of mernbers of the public who utilized CTA
FILED DATE: 8/12/2019 12:37 PM 2019L008880
62. As a direct and proxirnate cause of the negligent hiring, retention zrnd supervisiorr
by Defèndant CTA of Defendant AGB, FELON NICOLE SMITII, suffered the fatal injulies
described herein.
FELON NICOLE SMITI-I, deceased, asks that a judgment be entered against the Defendant
CI{ICAGO TRANSIT AUTFIORITY, in such an amount which exceeds the julisdictional lirnit
or in such an amount sum that a Court or.jury may deem fit and proper, plus costs of suit.
COT]NIT V
(Ncgligcnt Training by Defendant Chicago Transit Authority)
63. Plaintiff adopts and re-alleges paragraphs I through 3 I o1'the Common Allegations
64. At all times m¿rterizrl, the operator of the train that struck FELON NICOLE
SMITH was either directly or through its agents, under the direction, supclvision and control of
Defèndant CTA.
65. Def-endant C'fA either directly or thror"rgh its agents, negligently trainecl the
operator of the train that struck FELON NICOLE SMITH when the Defèndant CTA knew or
should have lçnowu that its failure to properly train the operator could pose a threat of severe
injury ancl death to pedestrians on the tracks, including FELON NICOLE SMII'I-I.
66. Despite this knowledge, Defendant CTA either directly or through its agents,
failed to exercise reasonable care in the training of the operator of the train that struck FELON
NICOI.E SMITFI in the proper proceclures, assessÍnents and protocols to safely operate an
13
electric colnlnuter tlain aud to reduce speed or stop the train in the event of a peclestrian on the
FILED DATE: 8/12/2019 12:37 PM 2019L008880
tracks.
67 . As a direct and proxirnate cause of the acts describecl above, FELON NICOLE
FELON NICOLE SMITH, deceased, asks that a judgment be entered zrgainst the Defendant
in such an amount sum that ¿r Court or jury may deem fit and proper, plus costs of suit.
ÇAUNT Y-I
(Negligent Training by f)efendants Chicago 'I'ransit Authority and/or AGB Investigative
Services,Inc")
68. Plaintiff adopts and re-alleges pal'agraphs 1 through 31 of the Common Allegations
69. At all material times, security guarcls on the "69tl'street lìecl L,ine" station wele
either clirectly or through its agents under the direction, supervrsion and control of Defenclant
70. Defendant CTA and/or Defencl¿rnt AGts either directly or through its agents,
negligently tr¿rined security guards when Defendant CTA and/or Defendant AGB knew or should
have known that its failure to properly train platform security guarcls could pose a threat of
severe harm or death in the event zi pedestrian enters the track alea.
71. Despite this knowledge, Defendant CTA ancl/or Defendant AGB either clirectly or
through its agents, failed to exercise reasonable care in the training of platform security guarcls to
appropriaiely evaluate, assess and intervene to assist in the event of a pedestrian on the tracks.
l4
72. As a direct ancl proximate cause of the acts described above, I.'ELON NICOLE
FILED DATE: 8/12/2019 12:37 PM 2019L008880
FELON NICOLE SMITH, deceased, asks that a judgment be entered against the Defèndants
amount which exceeds the.jurisdictional limit or in such all amount sum thât a Court orjury rnay
Respectfully subrnittecl,
THOMAS J. I-IYLAND
Hyland Law Ltcl.
20 N. Wacker Drive, Suite 3710
Chicago, Illinois 60606
(108) 712-9668
Attorney No.: 61790
t5
Attorney #:41155
IN THE CII{.CUIT COURT OF' COOK COUINTY,ILLII{OIS
COUI.ITY DtrPARTMEI{T, LAW DIVISION
FILED DATE: 8/12/2019 12:37 PM 2019L008880
AFFIDAVIT PURSUAN
I, Jeffrey J. Neslund, one of plaintiffs attorneys, on oath states that this affidavit is macle
t. Upon information and belief, the total amoutrt of money damages ght in the
yJ.
One of t
Subscribed and Sworn to before me this
_Í&"rn' day of _,&_t tfu_e{*l' 20 jq .
., (pu*rrttu!¿t - \^e9^.1\r1r'rrr.lv4\ 5
NOTARY PUBLIC OFFIOIAT SF¡t
MURAGORONADO
NOTARY PUËtICI " STATE ÕF ItIINOIS
JEFFREY J. NESLUND MV CCIMMISSION ËXPIRËS:07/17I21
Law Offices of Jeffrey J. Neslund
20 N. Wacker Drive, Suite 3710
Chicago, Illinois 60606
(312) 223-r100
Attorney No.: 41155