Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
MecaWind doesn’t address my situation, and I need someone to tell me how to model my
structure in MecaWind?
The single biggest challenge to calculating wind loads is taking your real world structure and
trying to determine how to best approximate it within ASCE 7. The ASCE 7 standards don’t
cover every situation, and so there is a lot of room for interpretation. It’s a difficult situation
and we are sympathetic to your frustration (we have the same issues in our design work);
however, these types of interpretation requests are not questions about the software, they are
actually questions about how to apply the code. We just simply don’t have the expertise or
resources to address these types of questions, we have to limit our technical support to the
software only.
I entered one zone for my C&C and the software is using another zone, why?
The C&C figures in ASCE 7 have a lot of notes at the bottom of each figure. If you read those
notes, often you will see that you have a special situation which requires that one of those
notes be followed. If you have looked at ASCE 7 and still feel there is a bug, email us the details
and the input file and we will investigate.
I ran the same building as Simpllfied and Detailed and got different results?
They are different methods, and they will not give the same results.
I ran the same building in ASCE 7-05 and ASCE 7-10 and got different results, why?
There are many calculations within ASCE 7-05 and ASCE 7-10 that are the same; however, there
are many new sections that were added to ASCE 7-10. Depending upon which options you
selected, the methods could have been completely different.
Why do I have two columns of output +/- GCPi, which one do I use?
The output has pressures for +GCpi and –Gcpi. The GCPi term is referring to the internal
pressure inside the building. The ASCE 7 requires that we consider two cases one when the
GCPi is Postive and the other when it is negative. Therefore MecaWind considers both
situations, and indicates whether the pressure is based upon the +GCpi or –Gcpi value. For
designing, typically the largest values are used.
What do the positive (+) and negative (-) signs mean in the output pressures?
The convention in ASCE 7 is that Positive pressures are acting toward the wall and negative are
acting away. If a windward wall is being considered, a positive pressure indicates that it is
trying to push the wall toward the interior of the building, and a negative pressure indicates
that it is trying to pull the wall away from the interior of the building. In the case of a leeward
Why doesn’t the program print the overturning moment and shear?
In past versions of the software, we did have the total overturning moment and shear loads
calculated. Due to the large number of different types of buildings and the way in which these
loads are determined in the different directions, it was prone to mislead designers and have
errors. Therefore we found it best to eliminate these to avoid giving misleading information.