Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
(SEIRI) V COMING
G.R. NO. 186621, 12 MARCH 2014
VILLARAMA, JR., J.
FACTS:
• Estanilao Agbay (petitioner) is the President and General Manager of SEIRI, a
domestic corporation engaged in the business of manufacturing and exporting
furniture.
• In 1990, his employment was interrupted and was told to resume work in two months
time without apparent reason. Respondent, being uneducated, was persuaded by
the management and Vicente (brother) not to complain, otherwise, petitioner might
decide not to call him back. After two months, he reported back to work upon order
of management.
• January 1, 2002 - Respondent was dismissed without lawful cause. He was told that
he will be terminated because the company is not doing well financially and would
call him back when in need of his services again. He filed a complaint before the
regional arbitration branch.
• Petitioners denied having hired respondent. They stressed that respondent was not
included in the list of employees submitted to the SSS.
• Petitioner appealed to NLRC submitting additional evidence: payroll and pay records
did not include the name of respondent.
NLRC RULING: Set aside and vacated LA’s decision. Dismissed the complaint. Denied
respondent’s motion for reconsideration.
CA RULING: CA reversed the NLRC and ruled that there existed an employer-
employee relationship between petitioners and respondent who was dismissed without
just and valid cause. CA denied petitioner’s motion for reconsideration.
SC RULING: YES.