Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
______________________________________________________________________________________
Abstract—In this paper, a stand-alone application with working on the pipeline is crucial because an appreciable
graphical user interface (GUI) developed for monitoring AC voltage magnitude could be impressed on the pipeline due
induced corrosion expectancies of buried pipelines near a high to transmission line fault [1, 7–9]. The pipeline materials and
voltage AC transmission line is presented. A Rand water site,
South Africa, was used as a case study. The interface was its coating may also be compromised leading to high cost of
based on estimating the AC induced corrosion risk assessment maintenance and repairs most especially for buried pipelines.
indices for buried pipelines near existing overhead high voltage Therefore, the National Association of Corrosion Engineer
transmission lines using Carson’s concept of mutual impedances (NACE) recommended that for safety of personnel working
between both the pipeline and transmission circuits. The GUI on the pipeline, the steady state induced potential should be
was developed using MATLAB software and have been tested
to process user input data from field measurements in such considered dangerous and be mitigated if the measured or
site. The developed application permits the evaluation of the estimated potential on the pipeline exceeds 15 V r.m.s [10].
AC induced corrosion risk assessment indices and may be AC induced corrosion problem has been examined by
particularly useful in the analysis of AC induced potential on many researchers and scientific organizations leading to var-
buried pipelines. ious research reports and technical standards. Of particular
Index Terms—AC assisted corrosion, AC corrosion assess- interest is the technical specification and threshold values
ment criteria, graphical user interface, high voltage transmis- provided on the criteria for assessing AC induced corrosion
sion lines, pipelines. of pipelines [11–15]. These values are based on the practical
experience in the field of AC corrosion. One of the generally
I. I NTRODUCTION accepted ways of assessing corrosion risk due to AC is to
monitor the variation in the AC density through the pipeline
potential along the length of a buried pipeline. tower dimension, configurations and the coordinates on the
pipe across the ROW are depicted in Fig. 2. The transmission
lines were evenly spaced at a tower centre to centre distance
of 32 m from each other.
Fig. 2. The case study site (a) schematics of the HVTL-pipeline ROW for the study site (b) coordinates of the HVTL-pipeline ROW for the study site.
R − W − B or gk conductors and the pipeline or between The Dp−m in (3) may be estimated by applying Pythagoras’
the R − W − B phase conductors and the k th earth wire. theorem to the transmission line/pipeline coordinates shown
Also, the self-impedance of the earth wire conductors with in Fig. 2(b) as
earth return may be expressed as
q
Dp−m = (xp − xm )2 + (ym − yp )2 , ∀m(R, W, B, gk−i )
ωµo ωµo 1 δe (7)
Zggk = Rgk + +j + loge (4)
8 2π 4 RGMk where xp represents the horizontal position of the pipe across
the transmission line ROW, yp represents the pipe depth
In (4), Rgk represents the AC resistance of the k th earth
from the ground to the centre of the pipe. It should be
wire and RGMk denotes the geometric mean radius of the
noted that yp = (hp + rp + tc ) as in Fig. 2(a). Also,
k th earth wire conductors. The nominal values of Rgk and
ym ∀m(R, W, B, gk−i ) represents the various heights of
RGMk depend on the type of earth wire used, the values of
the phase conductors or the earth wire from the ground
which are provided by the manufacturer. Alternatively, the
surface while their horizontal position may be represented
Rgk may be estimated using
by xm ∀m(R, W, B, gk−i ) on the x-coordinate.
ρe l The longitudinal induced EMF (V /m) on the pipe, Ep , is
Rgk = (5) computed as the resultant of the individual inductive coupling
Aef f
effects of the N transmission lines. Thus
where ρe represents the resistivity of the earth wire, l is
N =4
the length of the conductor and Aef f its the effective cross- X
sectional area. The depth of equivalent earth return δe is Ep = Epi (8)
i=1
related to the soil resistivity ρsoil and the transmission line
operating frequency f as Therefore, the longitudinal induced voltage (V ) on the entire
r pipeline exposure length L may be computed as
ρsoil
δe = 658.87 (6) Vp = Ep L (9)
f
C. Evaluation of the pipe-to-soil-potential For a buried coated pipeline, the longitudinal impedance Z
To estimate the pipe-to-soil potential at any point x, along and its shunt admittance Y per unit length may be estimated
the parallel length of the pipeline, a circuit analysis method using (14) and (15) [28]
is applied to the pipe-transmission line equivalent circuit. To
this end, the pipeline was modelled as a lossy transmission 1 p πf µo 1 p
Z= πf ρp µo µp + +j πf ρp µo µp
line having a series impedance and a shunt admittance to- πDp 4 πDp
gether with a distributed voltage source which is equivalent to
r
3.7 ρsoil
the longitudinal induced EMF on the pipeline. The equivalent +jµo f ln
Dp 2πf µo
circuit diagram of a distributed pipeline section of length L (14)
in parallel with an overhead HVTL is shown in Fig. 3. In
this figure, the pipeline has a termination impedances of Z1 πDp εo εc πDp
Y = + j 2πf (15)
and Z2 seen from ends A and B. ρc tc tc
where Dp denotes the pipeline diameter, ρp is the resistivity
of the pipeline, µo is the permeability of free space usually
expressed as 4 × 10−7 H/m, µp is the relative permeability
of the pipe material, f is the operating frequency of the
transmission line, ρc is the resistivity of the pipe coating
material, εc is the relative permittivity of the pipe coating
material and εo is the permittivity of free space expressed as
8.85 × 10−12 F/m.
generality without any noticeable technical error, the soil is III. R ESULTS AND D ISCUSSIONS
assumed to be homogeneous with uniform soil resistivity. The GUI displays result, such as the induced voltage on the
Also, the reciprocal effects of the earth wires on each other pipeline, the pipe-to-soil potential, the relative risk value of
are neglected. Thereafter, a GUI was developed for these AC corrosion as well as the current density through a coating
corrosion assessment criteria meant for AC induced corrosion defect on the pipe based on the user input data from field
risk monitoring and analysis. measurement. These AC corrosion risk assessment criteria
may be monitored using the developed GUI to ensure that
F. GUI development and model evaluation a threshold value above which there is a higher likelihood
of corrosion damage to the pipeline is not exceeded. If in
A MATLAB-based graphical user interface (GUI) was any case the threshold is exceeded, it will prompt the user to
developed and made to run as a stand-alone application give adequate corrective measures through the installation of
using the deployment tool in MATLAB, for monitoring the AC mitigation system or any other equivalent AC reduction
AC induced corrosion risk assessment indices. It eases the strategies.
evaluation of the pipe-to-soil potential and the AC densities
through a pipeline defect at any point on the pipe. The
A. The developed GUI
GUI displays result such as the induced voltage on the
pipeline, the pipe-to-soil potential, the relative risk value of The opening interface of the developed GUI is shown in
AC corrosion as well as the current density through a coating Fig. 6. This displays among others, the title of the work, and
defect on the pipe based on the user input data from field the GUI developers. As may be observed in Fig. 6, clicking
measurement as may be observed in Fig. 4. the start button from the file menu bar brings up Fig. 7, which
shows the interface for the AC induced corrosion risk moni-
toring platform for the Rand Water Strydpan site based on the
pipeline-transmission lines model ROW. As shown in Fig. 7,
the interface consists of three input section for pipeline, soil
and transmission line parameters. It also provides options
for choosing the phase conductor transposition/combinations
between the four transmission lines in that site to analyse
its effect on the corrosion assessment criteria. Thereafter,
a result section is provided featuring, among others, the
longitudinal induced voltage and the AC density.
B. Running the GUI with user input data 1640 A for four bundle conductors (TL3 & TL4).
To test the applicability of the developed GUI application, TABLE I
the data relating to the HVTL-pipeline in a real case study T HE CASE STUDY PARAMETERS
site where AC interference is frequent is shown in Table I
and Table II. It is important to mention that experimental S/N Parameter Value
measurements in such site have shown that the soil can be 1 Diameter 1000 mm
assumed homogeneous with a measured soil resistivity of 2 Burial depth 1m
12.96 Ωm. Table II shows the conductor rating of the HVTL 3 Defect size 1 mm
in the case study site used for the program verification. 4 Exposure length 1000 mm
The maximum rated current (maximum current capacity of 5 Coating thickness 4 mm
the line conductors) of the transmission line conductors 6 Soil resistivity 12.96Ωm
was applied as inducing current in accordance with Eskom 7 Soil relative permeability 1
guide [31]. In general, Zebra type conductor commonly 8 Operating frequency 50 Hz
used in South Africa for transmission line conductors, has 9 Operating voltage 275 kV
a maximum current carrying capacity of 710 A at normal 10 Peak load current per conductor 410 A
operating condition (Rate A) as illustrated in [31]. However,
considering the transmission lines at case study site, the
maximum MVA rating of the line at 275 kV is 676 M V A TABLE II
C ONDUCTOR RATINGS OF THE HVTL S IN THE CASE STUDY SITE
and 1353 M V A for two bundles (TL1 & TL2) and four
bundles conductor (TL3 & TL4) respectively as shown in HVTL ID Number of Template Thermal Thermal
Table 2. Therefore, the line current is 410 A (rms) per conductors Temperature rate A rate B
conductor which is now the maximum current carrying (o C) (M V A) (M V A)
capacity for the transmission line phase conductor at that site TL1 & TL2 2 50 676 974
with operating voltage of 275 kV . This maximum current is TL3 & TL4 2 50 676 974
used as inducing current in accordance with Eskom guide.
This rated current was multiplied by the number of sub- The input data provided in Table I were supplied to the
conductors in the bundle. Hence for a line with two bundle interface shown in Fig. 7. The presented GUI generates
conductors (TL1 & TL2), the rated current is 820 A and for the user defined boundary conditions of the HVTL-
may be observed that for new pipeline installations along the for deployment in any situation of pipelines and transmission
transmission lines, pipelines installed near TL1, and away lines right of way remains a future research work.
from this point (71.5 m) will experience lower induced
potential compared to those installed near TL4. Thus, to
reduce the induced potential on the pipe, when considering R EFERENCES
the option (1) of the phase conductor transposition, the pipe [1] M.M. Saied, “The capacitive coupling between EHV
should be installed beside TL1 and with a minimum distance lines and nearby pipelines,” IEEE Transactions on
of 14.3 m from its last phase conductor. Power Delivery, vol. 19, no. 3, 2004, pp. 1225-1231.
In Fig. 11, a plot of the longitudinal induced poten- [2] J.P. Nelson, “Power systems in close proximity to
tial on the pipeline with position across the transmission pipelines,” IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications,
line is shown, by selecting the transmission line phase vol. 1A-22, no. 1, 1986, pp. 435-441.
conductor transposition option TL1-TL2 phase conductors [3] K.B. Adedeji, A.A. Ponnle, B.T. Abe, A.A. Jimoh,
untransposed; TL3-TL4 phase conductors transposed from “Analysis of the induced voltage on buried pipeline in
the interface in Fig. 10 and clicking the plot button. In a the vicinity of high AC voltage overhead transmission
similar way to Fig. 10, one may observe areas across the lines,” Proceedings of the 23rd Southern African Uni-
transmission line’s route where the pipeline will experience versities Power Engineering Conference, 7-12, Johan-
higher induction from the line. nesburg, 28-30th January, 2015.
Considering the profile of the induced potential in Fig. 11, [4] A. Ogunsola, A. Mariscotti, L. Sandrolini, “Estimation
it may be observed that there is a large reduction in voltage, of stray current from a DC-electrified railway and im-
especially on the other side of the transmission lines (TL4). pressed potential on a buried pipe,” IEEE Transactions
It is obvious from the figure that pipelines installed near TL1 on Power Delivery, vol. 27, no. 4, 2012, pp. 2238-2246.
for these allowable distances (71.5 m away the centre line of [5] M.O. Ouadah, O. Touhami, R. Ibtiouen, “Diagnosis
the transmission lines) will experience much higher induced of the AC current densities effect on the cathodic
voltage than those installed near TL4. In general, it may be protection performance of the steel x70 for a buried
seen that the application through its interface may be used pipeline due to electromagnetic interference caused by
to assess the interference effect on a pipe installed in the HVPTL,” Progress In Electromagnetics Research M,
right-of-way of a HVTL. vol. 45, 2016a, pp. 163171.
[6] M.O. Ouadah, O. Touhami, R. Ibtiouen, “Diagnosis of
AC corrosion on the buried pipeline due to the high
voltage power line,” Journal of Electrical Engineering,
vol. 16, 2016, pp. 76-83.
[7] G.C. Christoforidis, D.P. Labridis, P.S. Dokopoulos,
“Inductive interference on pipelines buried in multilayer
soil due to magnetic fields from nearby faulted power
lines,” IEEE Transactions on Electromagnetic Compat-
ibility, Vol. 47, no. 2, 2005a, pp. 254-262.
[8] K. Kopsidas, I. Cotton, “Induced voltages on long
aerial and buried pipelines due to transmission line
transients,” IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery, vol.
23, no. 3, 2008, pp. 1535-1543.
Fig. 11. The GUI displaying plot of longitudinal induced voltage on the [9] L. Qi, H. Yuan, Y. Wu, X. Cui, “Calculation of overvolt-
pipeline with pipeline at different locations across the transmission line route age on nearby underground metal pipeline due to the
for the transmission line phase conductor transposition option of TL1-TL2
phase conductors untransposed; TL3-TL4 phase conductors transposed.
lightning strike on UHV AC transmission line tower,”
Electric Power Systems Research, vol. 94, 2013, pp.
54-63.
[10] NACE RP0177, “Mitigation of alternating current and
IV. C ONCLUSION lightning effects on metallic structures and corrosion
The development and implementation of a standalone control systems,” NACE International Standard Prac-
graphical user interface of the AC induced corrosion risk tice, Houston, Texas, 2007.
assessment for monitoring the corrosion expectancies of a [11] S. Goidanich, L. Lazzari, M. Ormellese, “AC corrosion-
metallic pipeline buried near an existing transmission lines part 1: effects on over-potentials of anodic and cathodic
have been presented. The interface was developed using processes,” Corrosion Science, vol. 52, no. 2, 2010a, pp.
MATLAB software and has been tested to process user input 491-497.
data from field measurements in a Rand Water site in South [12] CEN/TS12954, “Cathodic protection of buried or im-
Africa. This paper has shown how the developed GUI was mersed metallic structures: general principles and appli-
used for evaluating the AC corrosion risk assessment indices cation for pipelines,” European Technical Specification,
based on the supplied input data. It can be inferred from the Germany, 2001.
results presented that the interface is easy to use and provides [13] CEN/TS15280, “Evaluation of AC corrosion likeli-
a friendly user environment. Although, the application was hood of buried pipelines-application to cathodically
developed to assess and monitor the corrosion expectancies protected pipelines,” Technical Specification, CEN-
in a Rand Water site, South Africa, improving the application European Committee for Standardization, 2006.
[14] S. Goidanich, L. Lazzari, M. Ormellese, “AC corrosion. A.M. Abu-Mahfouz, Y. Hamam, “AC induced corrosion
part 2: parameters influencing corrosion rate,” Corro- assessment of buried pipelines near HVTLs: A case
sion Science, vol. 52, no. 3, 2010b, pp. 916-922. study of South Africa,” Progress in Electromagnetic
[15] S.D. Philip, “Overview of HVAC transmission line Research B, vol. 81, 2018, pp. 45-61.
interference issues on buried pipelines,” Proceedings of [23] Y. Xiao, Y. Du, D. Tang, L. Ou, H. Sun, Y. Lu,
the NACE Northern Area Western Conference, Alberta, “Study on the influence of environmental factors on
Canada, Feb. 15-18, 2010. AC corrosion behaviour and its mechanism,” Materials
[16] A. Fu, Y. Cheng, “Effect of alternating current on and Corrosion, vol. 69, no. 5, 2018, pp.601–613.
corrosion and effectiveness of cathodic protection of [24] D.D. Micu, G.C. Christoforidis, L. Czumbil, “AC inter-
pipelines,” Canadian Metallurgy Quarterly, vol. 51, no. ference on pipelines due to double circuit power lines:
1, 2012, pp. 81-90. A detailed study,” Electric Power Systems Research,
[17] M. Zhu, C. Du, X. Li, Z. Liu, S. Wang, J. Li, D. vol. 103, 2013, pp. 1–8.
Zhang, “Effect of AC current density on stress corrosion [25] L. Czumbil, G.C. Christoforidis, D.D. Micu, D. Stet,
cracking behaviour of X80 pipeline steel in high pH A. Ceclan, A. Pop, “A user friendly software appli-
carbonate/bicarbonate solution,” Electrochimica Acta, cation for induced voltage evaluation,” Proceedings of
vol. 117, 2014, pp. 351-359. the 46th International Universities Power Engineering
[18] A. Brenna, L. Lazzari, M. Pedeferri, M. Ormellese, Conference, Soest, Germany, 5–8 September, 2011.
“Cathodic protection condition in the presence of AC [26] Safe Engineering Services (SES) and Technolo-
interference,” La Metallurgia Italiana, no. 6, 2014, pp. gies Ltd., 1544 Viel, Montreal, Quebec, Canada.
29-34. www.sestech.com.
[19] M.H. Ouadah, M. Zergoug, A. Ziouche, O. Touhami, [27] Low-Fi, Sigma Power Engineering Pty Ltd.
R. Ibtiouen, S. Bouyegh, C. Dehchar, “AC corrosion www.sigmapower.com.au
induced by high voltage power line on cathodically [28] CIGRE, “Guide on the influence of high voltage AC
protected pipeline,” Proceedings of the International power systems on metallic pipelines,” CIGRE Working
Conference on Control, Engineering and Information Group 36.02 Technical Brochure no. 095, 1995.
Technology, Sousse, Tunisia, 22–25 March, 2014. [29] J.R. Carson, “Wave propagation in overhead wires with
[20] D.Z. Tang, Y.X. Du, Y. Liang, M.X. Lu, Z.T. Jiang, ground return,” Bell System Technical Journal, vol. 5,
“Electrochemical studies of the galvanic coupling pp. 1926, 539-554.
zinc/pipeline steel in the presence of an applied alter- [30] K.B. Adedeji, “Development of an assessment model
nating current,” Materials and Corrosion, vol. 67, no. and graphical user interface for monitoring alternat-
5, 2016, pp.463–470. ing current interference induced corrosion of buried
[21] M.O. Ouadah, T.R.Ibtiouen, M.F. Benlamnouar, M. pipelines,” M.Tech Dissertation, Department of Elec-
Zergoug, “Corrosive effects of the electromagnetic in- trical Engineering, Tshwane University of Technology,
duction caused by the high voltage power lines on Pretoria, South Africa, 2016.
buried X70 steel pipelines,” International Journal of [31] Eskom, “Guideline on the electrical co-ordination of
Electrical Power & Energy Systems, vol. 91, 2017, pp. pipeline and power lines,” Paper No. 240- 66418968,
34-41. pp. 2573, South Africa, 2015.
[22] K.B. Adedeji, A.A. Ponnle, B.T. Abe, A.A. Jimoh,