Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
ne of the most important types nism should be kept as simple as likely it is to happen, then the
of protective devices is a possible and all materials used in more difficult it should be to
safety interlock switch which its manufacturer should be of the override the switch or system. The
interlocks a guard door with the highest quality. The design should level of estimated risk should also
power source of the hazard. ensure that component wear is be a factor at this stage. Switches
When the guard door is kept to a minimum. The mecha- are available with various levels
opened, the power is isolated, nism should be enclosed in a of security ranging from resis-
ensuring that the machine is safe strong, sealed case. tance to impulsive tampering, to
when the operator requires being virtually impossible to
access. Security defeat.
There are many variations of The security of an interlock It should be noted at this stage,
interlock switches, each with their switch is dependent on its ability that if a high degree of security is
own characteristics. to withstand attempts to “cheat” required, it is sometimes more
It is important to ensure that or defeat the mechanism. An practical to achieve this by the
the type of device chosen is interlock switch should be way in which the switch is
correct for its application. Later designed so that it cannot be mounted.
in this chapter we will look at a easily defeated. For example, if the switch is
series of logical decisions In some circumstances, person- mounted as in fig. 44 with a
leading to the exact choice of nel may be tempted to override covering track, there is no access
device to be used. First, let's the switch in some way. Informa- to the switch with the guard door
familiarize ourselves with some tion concerning the use of the open. The nature of any “cheat-
of the general features and machine, gathered at the risk ing” prevention measures taken at
requirements which make assessment stage, will help to the installation stage will depend
devices suitable for interlocking decide whether this is more likely on the operating principle of the
duties. or less likely to happen. The more switch.
Standards
The European Standard EN
1088 - “Interlocking devices
associated with guards” gives
guidance. It is intended to be
used in conjunction with EN
60947-5-1 for electromechanical
switches and an equivalent
standard for magnetic and
proximity type switches.
Reliability
An interlock switch must
operate reliably even under
extreme conditions and rough
treatment. The operating mecha- Fig. 44
D OOR RD
DOO
R E
ARD GUA
GU
engineering
FORCED
STICKING OR POSITIVE MODE DISCONNECTION
WELDED FORCED
CONTACTS DISCONNECTION
OVERCOMES
CONTACT WELD
Positive Mode Operation relies entirely on spring pressure cam and the contact block cannot
(also referred to as direct to open the contacts. In the event become separated and it is
operation) of spring failure, contact weld or impossible to defeat the switch by
EN 292 explains that if a sticking, the system will fail to cutting another slot in the cam.
moving mechanical component danger and is therefore unaccept- The principle is adapted further
inevitably moves another compo- able. This type of system is easily for actuator operated interlock
nent along with it, either by direct defeated by pushing the plunger switches as shown in fig. 47.
contact or via rigid elements, while the guard is open. Even These devices are widely used as
these components are said to be worse, the switch can be tripped they are simple to mount at the
connected in the positive mode. accidentally by an operator opening edge of the guard and
With single mechanical type leaning onto or into the machine can be used on sliding, hinged
interlocking switches, when the while the guard is open. and removable guard doors. The
guard is opened the movement of Fig. 46 shows a simple example actuator is mounted on the guard
the guard should be connected in of positive mode operation giving door and opening the guard
the positive mode to the safety forced disconnection of the causes it to force disconnect the
related contacts of the switch. contacts. A cam is mounted on contacts. The switch mechanism
This ensures that the contacts are the door hinge so that it directly is enclosed and is designed to
physically pulled apart or “force operates the contacts whenever resist tampering.
disconnected” by the movement the guard door is open. Spring
of the guard. pressure can only close the Fitness for Purpose
The switch should NOT rely contacts when the guard is fully As a minimum, all designs and
solely on spring pressure to open closed. Any spring breakage will materials must be able to with-
the contacts, as the force exerted only result in a failure to a safe stand the expected operating
may not be able to overcome condition. stresses and external influences.
sticking or welded contacts. There
is also the possibility that the Enclosure Other Safety Principles
switch could fail to danger if the The positive mode operation For non-mechanical devices,
spring breaks and there is no other principle shown in fig. 46 is used there is usually no physical
means of opening the contacts. wherever it is relevant in safety contact between the switch and
Fig. 45 shows a typical negative interlock switches. They also actuation method. Therefore,
(or non-positive) mode operating avoid any possible abuse by positive mode operation cannot
system. There is no direct link enclosing the contact block and be used as the way of ensuring
between the guard door and the cam in a strong and secure the switching action and we need
safety contacts, so the system enclosure. This means that the to use other methods as follows.
Fig. 48
E VOLTAGE
CROSSOVER
engineering
engineering
POWER INTERLOCKING signed power interlocking systems position. When the key is turned
The movement of the guard is with the power interrupting the isolation switch contacts are
interlocked with the direct switch- switch capable of handling and locked open (isolating the power
ing of the power to the hazard. breaking the load reliably. supply) and the key can be
For equipment using low voltage The most practicable method of withdrawn. The guard door is
and power most types of interlock power interlocking is a trapped locked closed and the only way to
switches can be used for power key system such as the PROSAFE unlock it is by using the key from
interlocking. But because most system (see fig. 50). The power the isolator. When this key is
industrial machinery uses a isolation switch is operated by a turned to release the guard locking
relatively high power three phase key which is trapped in position unit it is trapped in position and
supply, we need specially de- while the switch is in the ON cannot be removed until the guard
is closed and locked again.
KEY TRAPPED
MAIN SUPPLY
Therefore, it is impossible to
ELECTRICAL SUPPLY
ON LOCKED OFF open the guard without first
A isolating the power source and it
A
A is also impossible to switch on
the power without closing and
locking the guard.
MACHINE IS RUNNING. MACHINE IS NOW STOPPED AND THE
ELECTRICAL SUPPLY HAS BEEN ISOLATED. This type of system is extremely
ELECTRICAL SUPPLY IS ON.
ACCESS DOOR CAN NOW BE OPENED. reliable and has the advantage of
ACCESS DOOR IS LOCKED.
WHEN DOOR IS OPEN, KEY IS TRAPPED. not requiring electrical wiring to
the guard. The main disadvantage
Fig. 50
is that because it requires the
transfer of the key every time, it is
not suitable if guard access is
KEY TRAPPED required frequently.
MAIN SUPPLY ELECTRICAL SUPPLY
ON LOCKED OFF Whenever whole body access is
required, the use of a personnel
A A
A key is recommended (see fig. 51,
52 and 53). The PROSAFE range
is available in double key ver-
sions to serve this requirement.
The use of a personnel key
ensures that the operator cannot
be locked in the guarded area.
MACHINE IS RUNNING. MACHINE IS NOW STOPPED AND THE The key can also be used for
ELECTRICAL SUPPLY IS ON. ELECTRICAL SUPPLY HAS BEEN ISOLATED. robot teach mode switches, inch
ACCESS DOOR IS LOCKED. ACCESS DOOR CAN NOW BE OPENED.
mode controls etc.
WHEN DOOR IS OPEN KEY A IS TRAPPED
KEY B IS TAKEN INTO THE GUARDED AREA
By using double key locking
TO ENSURE THE DOOR CANNOT BE units and keys with different
LOCKED BY A THIRD PARTY. codes together with a key ex-
Fig. 51
change unit, complex systems can
E
engineering
engineering
opened at any time; but as soon
as it is opened the switch isolates 1
the power to the hazard via the
contactor control circuit. If the Fig. 56 Use an interlocking device with guard
hazard always ceases immedi- locking to prevent guard opening before the
ately, then the requirements are hazard has ceased.
satisfied because the operator
cannot reach the parts while they
are dangerous.
If the hazard does not cease
immediately, there is a possibility
that an operator can reach it
while it is “running down” and
still dangerous. To avoid this
unacceptable situation, there are
three alternatives as illustrated in 2
the figures on the bottom of this
page.
Fig. 57 Install some form of braking device to
Note: The integrity of the achieve a fast stop.
braking device needs to be
considered both in terms of fault
D.C
resistance and wear characteris- .
INJE
C
BRA TION
tics. KE
If a precise calculation is
required, the European standard
EN 999 deals with the positioning
of protective equipment in respect
to approach speeds of parts of the
human body. At present it does
not specifically cover interlocked
guard doors, but its principle for 3
the positioning of other safety
devices based on approach speed
Fig. 58 The separation distance between the
and machine stopping time can hazard and the guard door should be such that it
reasonably be extrapolated to takes longer for the operator to reach the hazard
cover interlocked guard doors than it does for the hazard to stop.
E
engineering
Mechanically Actuated
Devices
With these devices the guard
door is linked mechanically to the
control circuit contacts of the
switch using positive mode
operation. There are three main
types of mechanical actuation.
These are:
Fig. 59 Tongue Operated Actuation
Actuator Operated
With the T2010 switch, as
shown in Fig. 59, the guard
mounted actuator “tongue” opens
or closes the contacts via the
internal mechanism.
Features:
The actuator and mechanism
are designed to prevent easy
cheating of the switch. These
devices are straightforward to
install and are very reliable.
They can be used on sliding,
hinged and lift-off guards and
because of their versatility they
are one of the most commonly
used types of interlock switches.
For consideration:
The guard mounted actuator Fig. 60 Hinge Operated Actuation
needs to remain reasonably well
aligned with the entry hole in the mechanism to the control circuit For consideration:
switch body. Actuator operated contacts (fig. 60). Care must be taken on very
switches can be difficult to clean Features: wide guard doors, as an opening
thoroughly. This may be a problem When properly installed, these movement of only 3° can still
in industries such as food manu- types of switches are ideal for result in a significant gap at the
facturing and pharmaceuticals. most hinged guard doors where opening edge. It is also important
there is access to the hinge center to ensure that a heavy guard does
Hinge Operated Actuation line. They can isolate the control not put undue strain on the
The device is mounted over the circuit within 3° of guard move- switch actuator shaft.
hinge-pin of a hinged guard. The ment and they are extremely
opening of the guard is transmit- difficult to defeat without disman-
ted via a positive mode operating tling the guard.
engineering
Fig. 62 Cam Operated Actuation - 2 Switches
POSITIVE MODE
LIMIT SWITCH
Fig. 65
E HAZARD AREA
STOP SWITCH ACTUATOR
engineering
in
bolt is not fully retracted until the
Madend
Engla
CONTROL knob is turned many more times
POWER UNIT CONTACTOR
Red
Blue
Blk
Wht
(taking up to 20 secs.).
X1
X2
SUPPLY MONITORING
R The PROSAFE trapped key
SAFETY 1
SAFETY 2
MF
rol Un
it stem
ty Sy Yel
Cont of Safe 2 Grn system (see power interlocking
Auxiliary
Pro y
per Safet
Tam Safety 1
Aux
engineering
For less frequently accessed
applications, the PROSAFE
trapped key system (see power
interlocking section) can be
configured to operate in this way.
In the example shown in fig. 68,
the hazard ceases as soon as
power is isolated by switching the
machine OFF at the normal
controls. The guard cannot be
Fig. 66
opened until the contactor has
able and it must not be possible lock release, it makes them switched OFF. Once the guard is
for the bolt to be withdrawn particularly suitable for use with opened the control circuit con-
before the hazard has ceased. It PLC or other programmable tacts ensure that the contactor
must only be possible to extend electronically controlled machines. cannot be re-energized until the
the bolt into its locked position The usual type of interlocking guard is closed and locked.
when the guard is fully closed. device for these purposes is a With the configuration shown
This means that it will usually be solenoid operated locking switch in fig. 69, the switch will not
necessary to install stops to restrict such as the TL8012 (fig. 67), release the guard until the
the travel of the guard door. TL8018, or TL5012. contactor is OFF and a pre-set
START
engineering
Fig. 69
A1
X1 START
K1
K1
X2 STOP
SMD02 N
MOTION P
SENSING N
UNIT
P
N
P
SENSOR M SENSOR
SAFETY
SOLENOID
SOLENOID LOCKING
CONTACTS SWITCH
13
14
A2
Fig. 70