Brillantes VS Yorac GR 93867

Search
Philippine Supreme Court Jurisprudence > Year 1990 > December 1990 Decisions > [G.R. No. 93867 : December
18, 1990.] 192 SCRA 358 SIXTO S. BRILLANTES, JR., Petitioner, vs. HAYDEE B. YORAC, in her capacity as
ACTING CHAIRPERSON of the COMMISSION ON ELECTIONS, Respondent.:
Search
EN BANC
[G.R. No. 93867 : December 18, 1990.]
192 SCRA 358
Robles On-Line Bar SIXTO S. BRILLANTES, JR., Petitioner, vs. HAYDEE B. YORAC, in her capacity
Review CHAIRPERSON of the COMMISSION ON ELECTIONS, Respondent.
DECISION
The petitioner is challenging the designation by the President of the Philippines

Commissioner Haydee B. Yorac as Acting Chairman of the Commission on Elections
Chairman Hilario B. Davide, who had been named chairman of the fact-finding co
investigate the December 1989 coup d' etat attempt.
The qualifications of the respondent are conceded by the petitioner and are not in
case. What is the power of the President of the Philippines to make the challenged d
view of the status of the Commission on Elections as an independent constitutional b
specific provision of Article IX-C, Section 1(2) of the Constitution that "(I)n no ca
Member (of the Commission on Elections) be appointed or designated in a tempora
capacity."
The petitioner invokes the case of Nacionalista Party v. Bautista, 85 Phil. 101, whe
Elpidio Quirino designated the Solicitor General as acting member of the Commission
and the Court revoked the designation as contrary to the Constitution. It is also alle
respondent is not even the senior member of the Commission on Elections, being o
ollect Company, Inc. Associate Commissioner Alfredo E. Abueg, Jr. :-c ralaw
The petitioner contends that the choice of the Acting Chairman of the Commission on
an internal matter that should be resolved by the members themselves and that the
the President of the Philippines violates their independence. He cites the practice in
where the senior Associate Justice serves as Acting Chief Justice in the absence
Justice. No designation from the President of the Philippines is necessary.
In his Comment, the Solicitor General argues that no such designation is necessary in
the Supreme Court because the temporary succession cited is provided for in Sectio
Judiciary Act of 1948. A similar rule is found in Section 5 of BP 129 for the Court of Ap
is no such arrangement, however, in the case of the Commission on Elections. The
made by the President of the Philippines should therefore be sustained for
"administrative expediency," to prevent disruption of the functions of the COMELEC.
Expediency is a dubious justification. It may also be an overstatement to sugg
operations of the Commission on Elections would have been disturbed or stalem
President of the Philippines had not stepped in and designated an Acting Chairman. T
nRobles Intellectual seem to be any such problem. In any event, even assuming that difficulty, we do no
"only the President (could) act to fill the hiatus," as the Solicitor General maintains.
roperty Division
Article IX-A, Section 1, of the Constitution expressly describes all the Constitutional C
as "independent." Although essentially executive in nature, they are not under the c
President of the Philippines in the discharge of their respective functions. Ea
Commissions conducts its own proceedings under the applicable laws and its own rule
exercise of its own discretion. Its decisions, orders and rulings are subject onl
on Certiorari by this Court as provided by the Constitution in Article IX-A, Section 7.
The choice of a temporary chairman in the absence of the regular chairman come
discretion. That discretion cannot be exercised for it, even with its consent, by the Pre
Philippines.
A designation as Acting Chairman is by its very terms essentially temporary an
revocable at will. No cause need be established to justify its revocation. Assuming its
designation of the respondent as Acting Chairman of the Commission on Electio
withdrawn by the President of the Philippines at any time and for whatever reason sh
is doubtful if the respondent, having accepted such designation, will not be es
challenging its withdrawal.chanroble s virtual law l ibra ry
It is true, as the Solicitor General points out, that the respondent cannot be removed
her permanent position as Associate Commissioner. It is no less true, however, that
replaced as Acting Chairman, with or without cause, and thus deprived of the
perquisites of that temporary position.
The lack of a statutory rule covering the situation at bar is no justification for the Pre
Philippines to fill the void by extending the temporary designation in favor of the resp
is still a government of laws and not of men. The problem allegedly sought to be co
existed at all, did not call for presidential action. The situation could have been han
members of the Commission on Elections themselves without the participation of th
however well-meaning.
In the choice of the Acting Chairman, the members of the Commission on Elections
likely have been guided by the seniority rule as they themselves would have appreciat
event, that choice and the basis thereof were for them and not the President to make.
ber-1990
udence The Court has not the slightest doubt that the President of the Philippines was moved
best of motives when she issued the challenged designation. But while conceding her
. 32945 : December 3, 1990.] cannot sustain her act because it conflicts with the Constitution. Hence, even a
T. NASSER, Petitioner, vs. THE revoked the designation in the Bautista case, so too must it annul the designation in
APPEALS, HON. MALCOLM
O, in his capacity as Presiding bar.
urt of First Instance of Pampanga,
AURORA RIVERA CANLAS, PATERNO
The Constitution provides for many safeguards to the independence of the Com
, and TOMAS CENTILLAS, Elections, foremost among which is the security of tenure of its members. That gua
nts. [G.R. No. 32946. December 3, available to the respondent as Acting Chairman of the Commission on Elections by de
RIANO T. NASSER, Petitioner, vs.
T OF APPEALS, PATERNO R. CANLAS,
the President of the Philippines.
IVERA-CANLAS, TOMAS CENTILLAS
HIEF OF POLICE OF SAN ISIDRO,
WHEREFORE, the designation by the President of the Philippines of respondent Haydee
IENTAL, Respondents. Acting Chairman of the Commission on Elections is declared UNCONSTITUTIONA
. 39430 : December 3, 1990.] respondent is hereby ordered to desist from serving as such. This is without prej
O MANLAPAZ, DELFIN SANGCAP,
SANGCAP, PEDRO CUNANAN,
incumbent Associate Commissioners of the Commission on Elections restoring her
E LA PENA and HONORATA DE LA position if they so desire, or choosing another member in her place, pending the appo
tioners, vs. HON. COURT OF permanent Chairman by the President of the Philippines with the consent of the Co
HON. JUDGE LORENZO R.
A, HON. JUDGE VIRGILIO CANIVEL,
Appointments. : rd
RIVERA, PABLO RIVERA, RENATO

nd BONIFACIO RIVERA,
SO ORDERED.
nts. Fernan C . J., Narvasa, Melencio-Herrera, Gutierrez, Jr., Paras, Gancayco, Pa
. 55466 : December 3, 1990.]
URETY & FIDELITY CO., INC., Griño-Aquino, Medialdea and Regalado, JJ., concur.
vs. COURT OF APPEALS and
H. QUASHA, Respondents. Feliciano, J., is on leave.
. 78778 : December 3, 1990.] 191
LEONIDA CORONADO, FELIX BUENO, Sarmiento, J., took no part.
RETIZOS, BERNARDINO BUENASEDA
A MONTEFALCON, Petitioners, vs.
T OF APPEALS and JUANA BUENO
, Respondents.
. 79560 : December 3, 1990.] 191
ANDRES E. DITAN, Petitioner, vs.
NE OVERSEAS EMPLOYMENT
RATION ADMINISTRATOR,
LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION,
LD RECRUITMENT, INC., AND/OR Back to Home | Back to Main
SALES CORPORATION, Respondents.
. 80904 : December 3, 1990.] 191
BALTAZAR, PEDRO, URSULA, and
, all surnamed PANTIG, Petitioners,
CIO BALTAZAR, Respondent. QUICK SEARCH
. 82115 : December 3, 1990.] 191
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES,
ppellee, vs. ROMEO ORTIZ y
, Accused-Appellant.
. 84884 : December 3, 1990.]
M. RUIZ and ILUMINADA RUIZ, 1901 1902 1903 1904 1905 1906 1907 1908
s, vs. HON. DOROTEO N. CANEBA,
SHERIFF OF MANILA AND/OR HIS 1909 1910 1911 1912 1913 1914 1915 1916
, ZENAIDA SANGALANG and ADOLFO
pondents. 1917 1918 1919 1920 1921 1922 1923 1924
. 87264 : December 3, 1990.]
DINGLASAN and FELICIDAD 1925 1926 1927 1928 1929 1930 1931 1932
N, Petitioners, vs. THE HON. MARIA
AUSTRIA, Presiding Judge of Branch 1933 1934 1935 1936 1937 1938 1939 1940
nal Trial Court, Pasig, Metro Manila,
apital Judicial Region, The 1941 1942 1943 1944 1945 1946 1947 1948
ENT SERVICE INSURANCE SYSTEM,
EPCION T. TINIO, Respondents. 1949 1950 1951 1952 1953 1954 1955 1956
. 89545 : December 3, 1990.]
ROLANDO DOLORFINO and MONINA 1957 1958 1959 1960 1961 1962 1963 1964
tioners, vs. THE HON. COURT OF
SEVERO ALCOS and EFIGENIA DE 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969 1970 1971 1972
OS, Respondents.
. 9864 : December 3, 1990.] 1973 1974 1975 1976 1977 1978 1979 1980
DA. DE TANGUB, Petitioner, vs.
APPEALS, PRESIDING JUDGE of the 1981 1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988
, Branch 4, Iligan City, and SPOUSES
and EUGENIA MARTIL, 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996
nts.
. 58668 : December 4, 1990.] 192 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004
NTIAGO ESCARTE, JR., ERNESTO
VA, FELIXBERTO VILLANUEVA, and 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
VILLANUEVA, Petitioners, vs. OFFICE
ESIDENT OF THE PHILIPPINES and 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
MEDINA, Respondents.
. 71929 : December 4, 1990.] 192
ITALIA, Petitioner, vs.
IATE APPELLATE COURT and FELIPA
Respondents.
A 21 CONSOLACION VILLANUEVA,
vs. THE INTERMEDIATE APPELLATE
SUS BERNAS and REMEDIOS Q.
Respondents.
. 80505 : December 4, 1990.] 192
HE PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES,
ppellee, vs. MARIO TANDOY y LIM,
-Appellant.
. 80791 : December 4, 1990.] 192
EOPLE'S FINANCING CORP. and
V. ARCENAS, Petitioners, vs. COURT
LS (Sixteenth Division), GAUDIOSO
EZ and PURIFICACION MANLIGUEZ,
nts.
. 86586 : December 4, 1990.] 192
ATIONAL IRRIGATION
RATION, Petitioner, vs. HONORABLE
P. REGINO, PRESIDING JUDGE,
TRIAL COURT, BRANCH 84,
ITY and CONSTRUCTION SERVICES
ALIA-PHILIPPINES INC.,
nts.
. 86889 : December 4, 1990.] 192
UZ FARMS, Petitioner, vs. THE
LE SECRETARY OF THE DEPARTMENT
IAN REFORM, Respondent.
. 88177 : December 4, 1990.] 192
OLORES A. PAREDES, Petitioner, vs.
VICE COMMISSION AND REMEDIOS
Respondents. [G.R. No. 89530 :
4, 1990.] 192 SCRA 84 DOLORES A.
Petitioner, vs. CIVIL SERVICE
ON, MERIT SYSTEMS PROTECTION
D REMEDIOS A. AMOR,
nts.
. 93054 : December 4, 1990.] 192
Cordillera Regional Assembly
LEXANDER P. ORDILLO, (Banaue),
vincial Board Member CORAZON
G, (Mayoyao), Former Vice-Mayor
DAN (Banaue), Municipal Councilors
ANO, (Lagawe), and TEODORO
ngyon), Barangay Councilman
DULAG (Lamut); Aguinaldo
SANDY B. CHANGIWAN, and
IMAGO; Lamut resident REY
Kiangan residents ORLANDO
and REYNAND DULDULAO; Lagawe
TOMAS KIMAYONG, GREGORIO
EORGE B. BAYWONG, and VICENTE
ngyon residents PABLO M. DULNUAN
TANCIO GANO; Mayoyao residents
BAOANG, LEONARDO IGADNA, and
GADNA; and Banaue residents
ULHI, LATAYON BUTTIG, MIGUEL
N, ANDRES ORDILLO, FEDERICO
SANDY BINOMNGA, GABRIEL
ROMEO TONGALI, RUBEN
MHOMDY GABRIEL, and NADRES
, Petitioners, vs. THE COMMISSION
ONS; The Honorable FRANKLIN M.
ecretary of Justice; Hon. CATALINO
G, Executive Secretary; The Cabinet
Regional Development; Hon.
O CARAGUE, Secretary of Budget
gement; and Hon. ROSALINA S.
OIC, National Treasurer,
nts.
. 30616 : December 10, 1990.] 192
EUFRACIO D. ROJAS, Plaintiff-
vs. CONSTANCIO B. MAGLANA,
-Appellee.
. 36827 : December 10, 1990.] THE
OF FOREST ADMINISTRATION, THE
OF LANDS and THE REPUBLIC OF
PPINES, Petitioners, vs. HON.
FERNANDEZ, HERMOGENES
ON, JR., and EMILIO A. GANCAYCO,
spondents. [G.R. No. 56622 :
10, 1990.] THE DIRECTOR OF
d THE DIRECTOR OF FOREST
MENT, Petitioners, vs. COURT OF
Ninth Division), GREGORIO A.
nd VALENTINA CERVANIA,
nts. [G.R. No. 70076 : December 10,
YNALDA ESPEJO, BENITA GARLITOS
QUETA OXCIANO, Petitioners, vs.
IATE APPELLATE COURT, HON.
M. BELEN, as Judge of the Regional
of Lingayen, Pangasinan Branch
nd ASTERIO SAURA, Respondents.
. 44749 : December 10, 1990.] 192
ppellee, vs. MELVIN GIRON y
Accused-Appellant.
. 50661 : December 10, 1990.] 192
RUBEN DELFIN, BENITO DOLOSA,
AGUILAR, ANASTACIO GORDOLA,
NALIGAN, LUIS VIESCA, VICENTE
R, JUAN CAGATIN, SIMEON CHICA,
O CINCO, WILFREDO IPAS, SIMEON
A, FLORENCIO SINAMBAN,
DIEGO, POLICARPIO DILE, EDDIE
O, AQUILINO CABILITASAN,
NO CANTERO, GUALBERTO
, RODOLFO GATCHALIAN, ANGELITO
, FERNANDO JOVER, RAFAEL
SIMON DIANA, BENJAMIN
, JR., BENIGNO ROJA, DEMETRIO
OSE TELAN, HILARIO VILLANUEVA,
NCISCO, PACIFICO DALIPE,
DALITE, ARTEMIO DE CASTRO,
RASTICA, ANECITO RASTICA,
O NIETO, ESMERALDO TATEL,
BATOCTOY, ESMENIO PATRICIO,
DE GUZMAN, JESUS MALLARI, JOSE
SULPICIO MALLARI, GENEROSO
PITO ESPINOSA, VIRGILIO SEVAÑES,
MANZAN, OSCAR BENSOL, PABLO
EMILIO DIAGSAY, PAULINO
MATERO COREA, BENJAMIN
A, GAUDY TIU, JOVENCIO AGUILAR,
OSADA, RICARDO POSIC, ALFONSO
RICARDO TAGANAP, ARMANDO
FELIPE RAMIRES, EDELBERTO
O, PONCIANO MONTILLA, JUAN
, IGNACIO PANCHITO, JEORGE
VICTOR IGNIS, LUCAS IGAT,
ME MAGDAEL, AUGUSTO ROSALINAS,
OCITO, JORGE CO, LUCINO WAGAN,
RADA, WINSTON DIENZO, PAULINO
ELESEO SANCHES, CONRADO
GENEROSO ANTONIO, AGUSTIN
DY SOCITO, SEGUNDO SOCITO,
PARAS, DOMINADOR BUTAHON,
NES GINGCO, HONORIO DETOITO,
ENDOZA, RUBEN QUITORIANO, LEON
Z, PACITO SALES, ANTONIO
IRENEO LUBUGIN, FORTUNATO
MEO MERIC, ALBERTO GALLO,
SALGADO, SIMEON QUIJANO,
CARAAN, CARLITO GUZMAN,
SALMON, FELIMON TAN, FERNANDO
, CONRADO DAVID, REYNALDO
ANTONIO NIETO, JAIME CAMACHO,
PANGLAO, ROSAURO GANAC,
ARCABIO, PEDRO MANASALA,
BELARMINO, ROMULO SIOCO,
ATIENZA, JR., RUFO ABALOS, JESUS
ALBINO BACARRO, ERNESTO DAJAY,
O VILLALON, CELESTINO BACARRO,
OLENTINO, ERNESTO ANTONIO,
UNDIO, ZOSIMO IJARES, RUBEN
NAS, GAUDENCIO CASTILLO,
DELA TORRE, DANILO RONCADA,
PA, ALFONSO SAPINORO, LUISITO
, MARCELINO BESA, ANSELMO
ALBERTO PALCULAN, BIENVENIDO
DA AND JOSE ORZAL, Petitioners, vs.
AMADO G. INCIONG in his capacity
Minister of Labor; NLRC
oners DIEGO ATIENZA, CLETO
A and GERONIMO QUADRA;
CONTAINER CORPORATION;
NDUSTRIES, INC., LAZARO ARRIOLA,
DO KATALBAS, AURORA JEREZA,
YULO AND PAZ YULO AND ROBERTO
Respondents.
. 55361 : December 10, 1990.] 192
SPOUSES TEOFILO ERCILLO and
ERCILLO, Petitioners, vs. COURT OF
and SPOUSES LUTGARDA CIFRA and
CIFRA, SR., represented by their
torney-in-fact, BENJAMIN CIFRA,
ON. JOSE P. CASTRO, Respondents.
. 55613 : December 10, 1990.] 192
ERNESTO DICHOSO, Petitioner, vs.
RABLE COURT OF APPEALS and
O RAMOS, Respondents.
. 56620 : December 10, 1990.] 192
FILIPINAS MILLS, INC.,
NTURA TAN and VIRGINIA DUMLAO-
oners, vs. HON. ABELARDO M.
his capacity as Presiding Judge of
of First Instance of Manila, Branch
IATED CITIZENS BANK and OSCAR V.
n his capacity as the Deputy Sheriff
-Manila, Branch II, Respondents.
. 69863-65 : December 10, 1990.]
183 LINO BROCKA, BENJAMIN
S, COSME GARCIA, RODOLFO
VALENTINO SALIPSIP, RICARDO
C MARIANO, JOSE EMMANUEL
ONNIE MATTA, ALFREDO VIAJE,
GENIO, REYNALDO ORTIZ, ORLANDO
EL REYES, EDUARDO IMPERIAL,
ARMIENTO, FRANCO PALISOC,
DE GUZMAN, ALBERTO REYES,
NILI, ROMULO AUGUIS, DOMINADOR
ION III, RONNIE LAYGO, ROSAURO
LARENCE SORIANO, OCTAVO
CARLITO LA TORRE, SEVERNO
., DOMINGO CAJIPE, ALAN ALEGRE,
ARTINEZ, MA. GILDA HERNANDEZ,
ILLANUEVA, DOLLY S. CANU,
DES C. ATIENZA, ELIGIO P. VERA
GER C. BAGAN, ABUNDIO M.
Petitioners, vs. JUAN PONCE ENRILE,
RAL FIDEL V. RAMOS, BRIG.
PEDRO BALBANERO, COL. ABAD,
IS, SERGIO APOSTOL, P/LT,
M. GARCIA and JUDGE RICARDO
Respondents.
. 74762 : December 10, 1990.] 192
COMMERCIAL MOTORS
TION, Petitioner, vs.
ONERS, SECOND DIVISION,
LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION,
O UMLAS, Respondents.
. 78163 : December 10, 1990.] 192
ANGELINA P. SANTIAGO, Petitioner,
norable DEPUTY EXECUTIVE
Y and HI-CEMENT CORPORATION,
nts.
. 79962 : December 10, 1990.] 192
LUCIO R. CRUZ, Petitioner, vs.
APPEALS AND CONRADO Q.
Respondents.
. 80397 : December 10, 1990.] 192
S & A GAISANO INCORPORATED,
UPIN, represented by his son
. Cupin as Attorney-in-Fact;
UPIN; EVARISTO CUPIN,
ed by his wife Marites R. Cupin as
n-Fact; RAMON CUPIN; FE CUPIN
AVENTURA CUPIN, both represented
other Ramon Cupin as Attorney-in-
ioners, vs. HON. VICENTE A.
Executive and Presiding Judge of
rial Court of Butuan City and Agusan
Branch V, Region X; VICTOR CHAN;
URO RICAFORTE, in his capacity as
f Deeds of Butuan City; CITY
VICTORIOSO GO, in his capacity as
uilding Official of Butuan City,
nts.
. 82215 : December 10, 1990.] 192
ANTIPAZ PRESCO y PARAS,
AMORES y PARAS, and ANSELMA
titioners, vs. HON. COURT OF
HON. MARIANO UMALI, Judge of the
rial Court of Cavite, Branch 25,
ires City, HON. EDWINA P.
Judge of the Municipal Trial Court
Trias, Cavite, MODESTO PARAS, and
O SANCHEZ, Respondents.
. 82374 : December 10, 1990.] 192
ppellee, vs. ERNESTO AVILA y
AND JOHN DOE, Accused-Appellant.
. 82495 : December 10, 1990.] 192
ALLIED BANKING CORPORATION,
vs. HON. SECRETARY SEDFREY
(Public Respondent) and ALFREDO
ivate Respondent), Respondents.
s. 84132-33 : December 10, 1990.]
257 NATIONAL DEVELOPMENT
AND NEW AGRIX, INC., Petitioners,
PINE VETERANS BANK, THE EX-
HERIFF and GODOFREDO QUILING,
city as Deputy Sheriff of Calamba,
espondents.
. 85531 : December 10, 1990.] 192
ppellee, vs. AMANDO TASARRA and
O TASARRA, Accused-Appellants.
. 89988 : December 10, 1990.] 192
ppellee, vs. LYDIA RAMA,
-Appellant.
. 91041 : December 10, 1990.] 192
JOSE A. SADDUL, JR., Petitioner, vs.
COURT OF APPEALS and THE PEOPLE
ILIPPINES, Respondents.
o. P-86-32 : December 10, 1990.]
288 ALFREDO LLANES, complainant,
OSO BORJA, DEPUTY SHERIFF, RTC,
9, NAGA CITY, Respondent.
. 31688 : December 17, 1990.] 192
DIRECTOR OF LANDS, DIRECTOR OF
and REPUBLIC OF THE
NES, Petitioners, vs. HON. JUAN P.
as Judge of the Court of First
f Abra, Second Judicial District and
USTRIAL CORPORATION,
nts.
. 68514 : December 17, 1990.] 192
TRADERS ROYAL BANK, Petitioner,
NTERMEDIATE APPELLATE COURT
GREGORIO S. CENDAÑA, in his
s DIRECTOR OF THE NATIONAL
ODUCTION CENTER (NMPC),
nts
. 71589 : December 17, 1990.] 192
CAGAYAN DE ORO COLISEUM, INC.,
vs. OFFICE OF THE MINISTER OF
D EMPLOYMENT, represented by
nister VICENTE LEOGARDO, JR. and
AVES, Respondents.
. 76303 : December 17, 1990.] 192
DIRECTOR OF LANDS, Petitioner, vs.
FRANCISCO K. REDOR and ANGELITA
nd HON. SALVADOR P. DE GUZMAN,
ing Judge of the Regional Trial
nch XXVII, Sta. Cruz, Laguna,
nts.
. 78623 : December 17, 1990.] 192
DR. OFELIA P. TRISTE, Petitioner,
STATE COLLEGE BOARD OF
, namely: Hon. Lourdes R.
g, Secretary of the Department of
Culture and Sports and Chairman of
and/or Dr. Minda C. Sutaria as the
d representative; Dr. Purificacion M.
esident of the Leyte State College
hairman of the Board; Director
Baclagon, National Economic and
ent Authority, Regional Office No.
Member of the Board; HON. SEDFREY
EZ, Secretary of Justice and
of the Review Committee under
Order No. 17; and DR. CRES V.
NZAGA, Respondents.
. 83530 : December 18, 1990.] 192
CRISTITO AUSTRIA y RODIS,
-Appellant, vs. PEOPLE OF THE
NES and THE HONORABLE COURT OF
Respondents-Appellees.
. 93867 : December 18, 1990.] 192
SIXTO S. BRILLANTES, JR.,
vs. HAYDEE B. YORAC, in her
s ACTING CHAIRPERSON of the
ON ON ELECTIONS, Respondent.
s. 95203-05 : December 18, 1990.]
363 SENATOR ERNESTO MACEDA,
vs. ENERGY REGULATORY BOARD
RCELO N. FERNANDO, ALEJANDRO
NG; REX V. TANTIONGCO; and OSCAR
their collective official capacities as
and Members of the Board (ERB),
ly; CATALINO MACARAIG, in his
official capacities as Executive
Chairman of Philippine National Oil
Office of the Energy Affairs, and
UEL ESTRELLA, in their respective
pacities as Chairman and President
on Corporation; PILIPINAS SHELL
M CORPORATION; with CESAR
NTURA and REY GAMBOA as
and President, respectively; CALTEX
NES with FRANCIS ABLAN, President
Executive Officer; and the Presidents
ne Petroleum Dealer's Association,
aler's Co., Petron Dealer's Asso.,
er's Asso. of the Phil., Liquefied
Gas Institute of the Phils., any and
ned gasoline and petrol dealers or
nd such other persons, officials, and
ting for and on their behalf; or in
ation of and/or under their
Respondents. [G.R. Nos. 95119-21 :
18, 1990.] 192 SCRA 363 OLIVER O.
Petitioner, vs. ENERGY REGULATORY
RB), PILIPINAS SHELL PETROLEUM
TION, CALTEX (PHIL.), INC., and
ORPORATION, Respondents.
. 95263 : December 18, 1990.] 192
ppellee, vs. JUVENAL KYAMKO,
ppellant.
. 2756 : December 18, 1990.] 192
PRUDENTIAL BANK, Petitioner, vs.
M. GRECIA, Respondent.
. 44167 : December 19, 1990.] 192
JULITA FRANCISCO and her
HERMENEGILDO TANKENKO, and
O FRANCISCO and his wife, FELISA
titioners, vs. CRISPIN V. BAUTISTA,
he Court of First Instance of
RANCISCA FRANCISCO, MAXIMA
O and FRANCISCO FRANCISCO,
nts.
s. 88710-13 : December 19, 1990.]
396 UNION OF FILIPRO EMPLOYEES
NUEL L. SARMIENTO, BENJAMIN M.
S, RODOLFO D. PAGLINAWAN,
A G. NUQUI, CORAZON Y SAZON,
P. LUCAS, RUDOLPH C. ARMAS,
A. ABELLA, ANGEL A. CANETE,
T. CAPILI, ADOLFO S. CASTILLO, JR.,
O A. CARINGAL, ERIBERTO S.
O, ADELAIDA B. MIRA, EUGENIA C.
AZ B. SAN JOSE, VENUSITO S. SOLIS,
L S. VILLENA, ALFONSO R.
TE, MELANIO C. LANTIN, AMADOR
JO, RODOLFO M. MUNSOD, RENATO
ODRIGO M. URGELLES, CARLOS B.
EUSTAQUIO E. BUNYI, NELSON P.
SOTERO A. GACUTAN, GUILLERMO
JA, DIONISIO H. NIPALES, EUGENIO
DRO, MANUEL DELA FUENTE, CARLO
CESAR B. PONCE, JORGE B. CASTRO,
DO AREVALO, REY M. BEO, FELIX
A, REYNALDO ALMENANZA, MELITON
(as represented by his surviving
A. CORAZON ROXAS), ROMEO A.
A, ISIDRO A. NATIVIDAD, EMILIANO
CELSO J. CENIDO, PAUL C.
SILVERIO C. PAMPANG, DIONISIO
O, GILBERT C. NOBLE, RODOLFO D.
ALONG, SR., PEPITO Q. QUITLONG,
C. COMPLETO, ANTONIO T.
ANGELITO PAYABYAB, ISAIAS A.
ODITO M. BELARMINO, QUEZON G.
ARLITO PRE, CIPRIANO P. LUPEBA,
DINSAY, WILDON C. BARROS, SUSAN
MANUEL A. LAVIN, ROY U.
IS, JEROME T. FIEL, ANASTACIO G.
O, JR., ROGELIO E. RAIZ, JOSE T.
NGELITO M. ANICIETE, RAUL
C. NANQUIL, LIZA T. VILLANUEVA,
CRUZ, REYNALDO L. CALIGUIA,
M. SOLOMON, OSCAR G.
DO, DIEGO P. OLIVA, JAIME D.
LPIDIO A. HERMOCILLA, DANTE L.
A, FEDERICO P. CONTEMPRATO,
MAKILING, RENATO O. MINDANAO,
TURA AND QUINTIN J. PEDRIDO,
oners, vs. NESTLÉ PHILIPPINES,
IONAL LABOR RELATIONS
ON, HON. EDUARDO G. MAGNO,
IMO T. VASALLO and HON.
NE S. LUBATON, Respondents.
. 91025 : December 19, 1990.] 192
UNION OF FILIPRO EMPLOYEES,
vs. THE HONORABLE NATIONAL
LATIONS COMMISSION and NESTLE
NES, INC., Respondents.
. 95478 : December 19, 1990.] 192
EDUARDO ACOP, ROGER
REZ, BIENVENIDO AMBRAY, BENITO
, WILLIAM ARMENDARES,
O ARREZA, TEODORO ARREZA,
O BANGUIS, MOISES BARENG,
BONGGOT, RAMON BUCALON,
UENAVIDES, FELIX CAGONG,
CALIWATAN, ANGEL CALUMBA,
RIAGA, GEORGE CASANO,
O CAPUTOLAN, FELOMENO CHATO,
ONGSIGNA, REYMUNDO CUADRA,
CUBERO, BIENVENIDO CURAYAG,
RO CURAYAG, JOVENCIO DARAY,
LEON, NELSON ECHIN, ROLANDO
N, BERTINO ESPINOLA, CRESENCIO
MATEO FRIAS, RODOLFO FUENTES,
O GALLOGO, HERMANO GALOPE,
LVE, ERNESTO GONABO, VIRGILIO
EMELITO GUBAL, RICARDO GUILLEN,
O HERNANDEZ, JR., NELSON JABAY,
CINTO, EMELIANO JALA, JR.,
URALBAR, ALFREDO LOMOLJO,
O LOMOLJO, EDUARDO LOPEZ,
PIO, SAMUEL LOREDO, NORBERTO
RCOS LOSIS, MARIO LUENGAS,
MAGHINAY, ROGELIO MATILDO,
MIRANDA, ANACLETO MONTON,
MONTON, ERNESTO OROZCO,
ORQUITA, MERLCHOR PANTO,
PEREGRINO, EDUARDO PLAZA,
LAZA, PAQUITO PLAZA, PEDRO
EDIOMIO QUIÑONES, PEPE
JOEL REMEDIO, EDUARDO
A, GERALDO ROSIL, JR.,
LES RUBENAL, REMEGIO SABUSIDO,
TES, BELTRANO SULLANO, JAIME
ERNIE TACUGDOY, WENIFREDO
R., PAQUITO TRUGILLO, ANIOLITO
DO, ROMARICO URIARTE DARIO
BERTINO VALLEJO, FRANCISCO
SENCIO YPARRAGUIRRE, RUDY
UIRRI and EDUARDO SACRAGON,
oners, vs. NATIONAL LABOR
S COMMISSION, (Fifth Division),
DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION
) and RET. GEN. REYNALDO G.
ce President for Field Operations &
ation, Respondents.
o. RTJ-89-380 : December 19, 1990.]
434 EFREN JAVIER and PEDRO
omplainants, vs. JUDGE SALVADOR
MAN, JR., Respondent.
. 46198 : December 20, 1990.] 192
DOMINGO REYES, Petitioner, vs.
RABLE JUDGE SERAFIN
. 53556 : December 20, 1990.] 192
LILIA AGUIRRE, GENATO AGUIRRE
O AGRAVA, Petitioners, vs. THE
LE COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE OF
ANCH III, EDUARDO TAMPIL and
. TAMPIL, Respondents.
. 72019 : December 20, 1990.] 192
WORLD MACHINE ENTERPRISES,
vs. INTERMEDIATE APPELLATE
D J.R. LITHOPLATES, Respondents.
. 81835 : December 20, 1990.] 192
ROMEO J. ORDOÑEZ, Petitioner, vs.
ALFREDO J. GUSTILO, in his capacity
ng judge of Regional Trial Court of
anch XVI, Cavite City, Municipality of
avite, former Mayor Calixto D.
f Rosario, Cavite, and Valeriano
Mabolo, Bacoor, Cavite,
nts.
. 82002 : December 20, 1990.] 192
ppellee, vs. FRANCISCO DE GUZMAN
, Accused-Appellant.
s. 86492-94 : December 20, 1990.]
483 THE PEOPLE OF THE
NES, Plaintiff-Appellee, vs.
O MONTANTE, Defendant-Appellant.
. 88114 : December 20, 1990.] 192
PENTAGON SECURITY and
ATION AGENCY, Petitioner, vs.
. JIMENEZ, ET AL., and NATIONAL
LATIONS COMMISSION, SECOND
Respondents.
. 89618 : December 20, 1990.] 192
HON. RAUL S. MANGLAPUS, in his
s Secretary of Foreign Affairs,
vs. HON. ANDRES E. MATIAS, Judge
ional Trial Court of Manila (Branch
AVINO P. ABAYA, Respondents.
s. 92029-30 : December 20, 1990.]
507 NICANOR G. DE GUZMAN, JR.,
vs. HON. COURT OF APPEALS,
th Division, HON. REGIONAL TRIAL
ational Capital Judicial Region, Br.
, and ENRIQUE KP. TAN,
nts.
. 93394 : December 20, 1990.] 192
FNCB FINANCE, Petitioner, vs.
N ESTAVILLO, Respondent.
. 43659 : December 21, 1990.] 192
vs. HON. FELICIDAD CARANDANG
and FEDERICO DE GUZMAN,
nts.
s. 48535-36 : December 21, 1990.]
533 KOH TIECK HENG, Petitioner,
E OF THE PHILIPPINES and COURT
LS, Respondents.
. 49454 : December 21, 1990.] 192
vs. SALVADOR MONTEIRO,
. 49588 : December 21, 1990.] 192

DIONG BI CHU, alias PATRICK
HANG KA HEE and LU LIONG
TION, Petitioners, vs. THE HON.
APPEALS, HON. GREGORIO G.
s Presiding Judge, Court of First
f Rizal, Branch XXI; JAIME NAVOA
GROS DE LEOS, Respondents.
. 63753-54 : December 21, 1990.]
561 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES,
ppellee, vs. GREGORIO BERINGUEL,
EVARAS, ARTEMIO TULANG (at
d RUFINO CAMINONG (at large),
GREGORIO BERINGUEL and ARTURO
Accused-Appellants.
. 76519 : December 21, 1990.] 192
TIMOTEO POJAS, Petitioner, vs. THE
LE MERCEDES GOZO-DALOLE,
TRIAL COURT JUDGE, CITY OF
AN, IRENEA POJAS, CESARIA
and CORNELIA BETINOL,
nts.
s. 78551-52 : December 21, 1990.]
ppellee, vs. ROLANDO MARCEDONIO
UEVA and ANTONIO MARCEDONIO y
VA, Accused-Appellants.
. 78854 : December 21, 1990.] 192
ppellee, vs. SALVADOR V. LUTAÑEZ
Plementero", Defendant-Appellant.
. 79526 : December 21, 1990.] 192
NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF FREE
IONS (NAFTU), Petitioner, vs.
UMBER DEVELOPMENT COMPANY
UNION-UNITED LUMBER AND
WORKERS OF THE PHILIPPINES.
WU-ULGWP), Respondents.
. 80276 : December 21, 1990.] 192
HYDRO RESOURCES CONTRACTORS
TION, Petitioner, vs. THE COURT OF
ALS and THE HON. DEPUTY
OF FINANCE, ALFREDO PIO DE
pondents.
. 83257-58 : December 21, 1990.]
612 OSIAS ACADEMY and MONICA
TRO, Petitioners, vs. THE
ENT OF LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT,
MERCADO, NECITAS GACIS,
GARAIS, ESTRELLA GATON, EVA L.
O, TERESA G. BILAZON, SUSAN G.
ELVIRA D. GACIS, LOURDES
ULIETA A. MANALO, NILA G.
nd TEODORO GUANIZO,
nts.
. 83696 : December 21, 1990.] 192
THE PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES,
ppellee, vs. DANTE BARTULAY
ppellant.
. 84918 : December 21, 1990.] 192
ppellee, vs. ED FERNANDEZ AVILA,
-Appellant.
. 87807 : December 21, 1990.] 192
ppellee, vs. ISAGANI DESLATE and
NCISCO alias "Romeo Francisco",
SAGANI DESLATE, Appellant.
. 89407 : December 21, 1990.] 192
ppellee, vs. ISABELO SANCHEZ y
Accused-Appellant.
s. 89682-83 : December 21, 1990.]
ppellee, vs. BENJAMIN HERICO,
-Appellant.
. 91513 : December 21, 1990.] 192
ppellee, vs. GERONIMO GOLES,
-Appellant.
. 43491 : December 26, 1990.] 192
ATTY. TEODORO V. CABILAN &
O A. PARALISAN, Petitioners, vs.
GE JOSE R. RAMOLETE &
AL/CITY JAIL WARDEN of Cebu City,
nts.
. 46210 : December 26, 1990.] 192
RICARDO VILLAFLOR, Petitioner, vs.
APPEALS and PEOPLE OF THE
NES,** Respondents.
. 61527 : December 26, 1990.] 192
VICENTE GERARDO, VALENTINA
CORNELIO GERARDO, BENJAMIN
ANGEL GERARDO, & CONSTANTE
Petitioners, vs. HON. FLORENTINO
A, Presiding Judge, Branch VI, Court
stance of Ilocos Norte, TERESA
BELZA, VISITACION ANTONIO
UMINADA PASCUA ANTONIO,
D BATACAN MATA, POLICARPO
BASILIO BATACAN, ISABEL
IRINEO BANGLOY, EDUARDO
DIONICIO BANGLOY, DOMINGA
and ERMINIO BANGLOY,
nts.
. 70556 : December 26, 1990.] 192
ppellee, vs. MARIO ABLAO, ISAGANI
OPOLDO DE GUZMAN, PEDRO
ZENON SAMONTE, ALFREDO DEL
RUNO ABLAO, ISIDORO GALEMA,
ERCADO, RUSTICO LIWANAG,
O BALDEMECA, HECTOR SAMONTE
D ABLAO, accused, MARIO ABLAO,
SACOP, LEOPOLDO DE GUZMAN,
DIANA, ZENON SAMONTE, and
DEL MUNDO, Accused-Appellants.
. 77668 : December 26, 1990.] 192
SPOUSES EUFRACIO ROJAS AND
ON ROJAS, Petitioners, vs. HON.
APPEALS, AND SPOUSES FELIX E.
AND DIONISIA PACATAN MEDALLA,
nts.
. 81039 : December 26, 1990.] 192
INVESTMENT AND UNDERWRITING
TION OF THE PHILIPPINES,
s, vs. COMPTRONICS PHILIPPINES,
GENE V. TAMESIS, Respondents.
. 85157 : December 26, 1990.] 192
FRANCISCO JOSE, ANTONIO,
JOVITA, ARACELI, DOLORES,
MARTA, LEDINIA, and ANITA, all
RAMON JAO, Petitioners, vs. COURT
LS and LAUREANA C. VDA. DE
s administratrix of the Estate of
an, Respondents.
. 88336 : December 26, 1990.] 192
REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES,
vs. THE HONORABLE
NBAYAN (FIRST DIVISION),
nts.
. 92625 : December 26, 1990.] 192
JOSE ORDA and IMELDA LOZADA,
s, vs. THE HONORABLE COURT OF
and GIL GALANG Respondents.
32945 December 3, 1990 -
T. NASSER v. COURT OF APPEALS,
39430 December 3, 1990 -

O MANLAPAZ, ET AL. v. COURT OF
ET AL.
55466 December 3, 1990 - MANILA
FIDELITY CO., INC. v. COURT OF
ET AL.
78778 December 3, 1990 -
CORONADO, ET AL. v. COURT OF
ET AL.
79560 December 3, 1990 - ANDRES
v. PHILIPPINE OVERSEAS
ENT ADMINISTRATION
RATOR, ET AL.
80904 December 3, 1990 -
PANTIG, ET AL. v. VENANCIO
82115 December 3, 1990 - PEOPLE

IL. v. ROMEO B. ORTIZ
84884 December 3, 1990 - EULALIO
T AL. v. DOROTEO N. CANEBA, ET
87264 December 3, 1990 -

DINGLASAN, ET AL. v. MARIA
AUSTRIA, ET AL.
89545 December 3, 1990 -
DOLORFINO, ET AL. v. COURT OF
ET AL.
9864 December 3, 1990 - RUFINA
ANGUB v. COURT OF APPEALS, ET
58668 December 4, 1990 -

ESCARTE, JR., ET AL. v. OFFICE OF
DENT OF THE PHIL., ET AL.
71929 December 4, 1990 -
v. INTERMEDIATE APPELLATE
AL.
74577 December 4, 1990 -
CION VILLANUEVA v. INTERMEDIATE
E COURT, ET AL.
IL. v. MARIO L. TANDOY
80791 December 4, 1990 -
FINANCING CORP., ET AL. v. COURT
LS, ET AL.
86586 December 4, 1990 -
IRRIGATION ADMINISTRATION v.
P. REGINO, ET AL.
86889 December 4, 1990 - LUZ
SEC. OF THE DEPT. OF AGRARIAN
88177 December 4, 1990 -

A. PAREDES v. CIVIL SERVICE
ON, ET AL.
93054 December 4, 1990 -
R P. ORDILLO, ET AL. v.
ON ON ELECTIONS, ET AL.
30616 December 10, 1990 -
D. ROJAS v. CONSTANCIO B.
36827 December 10, 1990 -

OF FOREST ADMINISTRATION, ET
ON C. FERNANDEZ, ET AL.
IL. v. MELVIN S. GIRON
50661 December 10, 1990 - RUBEN
T AL. v. AMADO G. INCIONG, ET AL.
55361 December 10, 1990 -
RCILLO, ET AL. v. COURT OF
ET AL.
55613 December 10, 1990 -
DICHOSO v. COURT OF APPEALS, ET
56620 December 10, 1990 -

MILLS, INC., ET AL. v. ABELARDO
, ET AL.
69863-65 December 10, 1990 -
CKA, ET AL. v. JUAN PONCE ENRILE,
74762 December 10, 1990 -

IAL MOTORS CORPORATION v.
ONERS, NLRC, SECOND DIVISION
78163 December 10, 1990 -
P. SANTIAGO v. DEPUTY
E SECRETARY, ET AL.
79962 December 10, 1990 - LUCIO
COURT OF APPEALS, ET AL.
80397 December 10, 1990 - S & A
INC., ET AL. v. VICENTE A. HIDALGO,
82215 December 10, 1990 -

P. PRESCO, ET AL. v. COURT OF
ET AL.
IL. v. ERNESTO M. AVILA, ET AL.
82495 December 10, 1990 - ALLIED
CORPORATION v. SEDFREY
. 84132-33 December 10, 1990 -

DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, ET AL. v.
NE VETERANS BANK, ET AL.
IL. v. AMANDO TASARRA, ET AL.
IL. v. LYDIA RAMA
91041 December 10, 1990 - JOSE A.
R. v. COURT OF APPEALS, ET AL.
P-86-32 December 10, 1990 -
LLANES v. GAUDIOSO BORJA, ET AL.
31688 December 17, 1990 -
OF LANDS, ET AL. v. JUAN P.
ET AL.
68514 December 17, 1990 -
ROYAL BANK v. INTERMEDIATE
E COURT, ET AL.
71589 December 17, 1990 -
DE ORO COLISEUM, INC. v.
OF LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT, ET
76303 December 17, 1990 -

OF LANDS v. FRANCISCO K. REDOR,
78623 December 17, 1990 - OFELIA

v. LEYTE STATE COLLEGE BOARD OF
, ET AL.
83530 December 18, 1990 -
R. AUSTRIA v. PEOPLE OF THE
AL.
93867 December 18, 1990 - SIXTO
NTES, JR. v. HAYDEE B. YORAC
. 95203-05 December 18, 1990 -
MACEDA v. ENERGY REGULATORY
T AL.
IL. v. JUVENAL KYAMKO
2756 December 18, 1990 -
AL BANK v. BENJAMIN M. GRECIA
44167 December 19, 1990 - JULITA
O, ET AL. v. CRISPIN V. BAUTISTA,
. 88710-13 December 19, 1990 -

FILIPRO EMPLOYEES, ET AL. v.
HILIPPINES, INC., ET AL.
91025 December 19, 1990 - UNION
O EMPLOYEES v. NATIONAL LABOR
S COMMISSION, ET AL.
95478 December 19, 1990 -
ACOP, ET AL. v. NATIONAL LABOR
RTJ-89-380 December 19, 1990 -
VIER, ET AL. v. SALVADOR P. DE
JR.
46198 December 20, 1990 -
REYES v. SERAFIN E. CAMILON, ET
53556 December 20, 1990 - LILIA

ET AL. v. COURT OF FIRST
OF LEYTE, ET AL.
72019 December 20, 1990 - WORLD
ENTERPRISES v. INTERMEDIATE
E COURT, ET AL.
81835 December 20, 1990 - ROMEO
EZ v. ALFREDO J. GUSTILO, ET AL.
IL. v. FRANCISCO DE GUZMAN
. 86492-94 December 20, 1990 -
F THE PHIL. v. LEOPOLDO
E
88114 December 20, 1990 -
N SECURITY, ET AL. v. VICENTE T.
ET AL.
89618 December 20, 1990 - RAUL
APUS v. ANDRES E. MATIAS, ET AL.
. 92029-30 December 20, 1990 -
G. DE GUZMAN, JR. v. COURT OF
ET AL.
93394 December 20, 1990 - FNCB
v. NAPOLEON ESTAVILLO
IL. v. FELICIDAD CARANDANG
, ET AL.
. 48535-36 December 21, 1990 -
K HENG v. PEOPLE OF THE PHIL., ET

IL. v. SALVADOR MONTEIRO
49588 December 21, 1990 - DIONG
T AL. v. COURT OF APPEALS, ET AL.
63753-54 December 21, 1990 -
F THE PHIL. v. GREGORIO
L, ET AL.
76519 December 21, 1990 -
POJAS v. MERCEDES GOZO-DALOLE,
. 78551-52 December 21, 1990 -

F THE PHIL. v. ROLANDO
NIO
IL. v. SALVADOR V. LUTAÑEZ
79526 December 21, 1990 -
ASSO. OF FREE TRADE UNIONS v.
UMBER DEVT. COMPANY WORKERS
80276 December 21, 1990 - HYDRO
ES CONTRACTORS CORPORATION v.
TAX APPEALS, ET AL.
83257-58 December 21, 1990 -
ADEMY, ET AL. v. DEPARTMENT OF
D EMPLOYMENT, ET AL.
IL. v. DANTE BARTULAY
IL. v. ED FERNANDEZ AVILA
IL. v. ISAGANI DESLATE, ET AL.
IL. v. ISABELO P. SANCHEZ
. 89682-83 December 21, 1990 -
F THE PHIL. v. BENJAMIN HERICO
IL. v. GERONIMO GOLES
43491 December 26, 1990 -
V. CABILAN, ET AL. v. JOSE R.
E, ET AL.
46210 December 26, 1990 -
VILLAFLOR v. COURT OF APPEALS,
61527 December 26, 1990 -

GERARDO, ET AL. v. FLORENTINO DE
ET AL.
IL. v. MARIO ABLAO, ET AL.
77668 December 26, 1990 -
ROJAS, ET AL. v. COURT OF
ET AL.
81039 December 26, 1990 -
NT AND UNDERWRITING CORP. OF
v. COMPTRONICS PHILIPPINES,
L.
85157 December 26, 1990 -
O JOSE, ET AL. v. COURT OF
ET AL.
88336 December 26, 1990 -
OF THE PHIL. v. SANDIGANBAYAN
92625 December 26, 1990 - JOSE
AL. v. COURT OF APPEALS, ET AL.
32945 December 3, 1990 -
39430 December 3, 1990 -

ET AL.
ET AL.
78778 December 3, 1990 -
ET AL.
ENT ADMINISTRATION
RATOR, ET AL.
80904 December 3, 1990 -

87264 December 3, 1990 -

AUSTRIA, ET AL.
89545 December 3, 1990 -
ET AL.
58668 December 4, 1990 -

71929 December 4, 1990 -
AL.
74577 December 4, 1990 -
E COURT, ET AL.
80791 December 4, 1990 -
LS, ET AL.
86586 December 4, 1990 -
P. REGINO, ET AL.
86889 December 4, 1990 - LUZ
88177 December 4, 1990 -

ON, ET AL.
93054 December 4, 1990 -
30616 December 10, 1990 -
36827 December 10, 1990 -

55361 December 10, 1990 -
ET AL.
55613 December 10, 1990 -
56620 December 10, 1990 -

, ET AL.
69863-65 December 10, 1990 -
74762 December 10, 1990 -

78163 December 10, 1990 -
E SECRETARY, ET AL.
80397 December 10, 1990 - S & A
82215 December 10, 1990 -

ET AL.
. 84132-33 December 10, 1990 -

IL. v. LYDIA RAMA
91041 December 10, 1990 - JOSE A.
P-86-32 December 10, 1990 -
31688 December 17, 1990 -
ET AL.
68514 December 17, 1990 -
E COURT, ET AL.
71589 December 17, 1990 -
76303 December 17, 1990 -


, ET AL.
83530 December 18, 1990 -
AL.
. 95203-05 December 18, 1990 -
T AL.
2756 December 18, 1990 -
. 88710-13 December 19, 1990 -

95478 December 19, 1990 -
RTJ-89-380 December 19, 1990 -
JR.
46198 December 20, 1990 -

OF LEYTE, ET AL.
E COURT, ET AL.
. 86492-94 December 20, 1990 -
E
88114 December 20, 1990 -
ET AL.
. 92029-30 December 20, 1990 -
ET AL.
, ET AL.
. 48535-36 December 21, 1990 -

63753-54 December 21, 1990 -
L, ET AL.
76519 December 21, 1990 -
. 78551-52 December 21, 1990 -

NIO
79526 December 21, 1990 -
TAX APPEALS, ET AL.
83257-58 December 21, 1990 -
. 89682-83 December 21, 1990 -
43491 December 26, 1990 -
E, ET AL.
46210 December 26, 1990 -
61527 December 26, 1990 -

ET AL.
77668 December 26, 1990 -
ET AL.
81039 December 26, 1990 -
L.
85157 December 26, 1990 -
ET AL.
88336 December 26, 1990 -
32945 December 3, 1990 -
39430 December 3, 1990 -
ET AL.
ET AL.
78778 December 3, 1990 -
ET AL.
ENT ADMINISTRATION
RATOR, ET AL.
80904 December 3, 1990 -

87264 December 3, 1990 -

AUSTRIA, ET AL.
89545 December 3, 1990 -
ET AL.
58668 December 4, 1990 -

71929 December 4, 1990 -
AL.
74577 December 4, 1990 -
E COURT, ET AL.
80791 December 4, 1990 -
LS, ET AL.
86586 December 4, 1990 -
P. REGINO, ET AL.
86889 December 4, 1990 - LUZ
88177 December 4, 1990 -

ON, ET AL.
93054 December 4, 1990 -
30616 December 10, 1990 -
36827 December 10, 1990 -

55361 December 10, 1990 -
ET AL.
55613 December 10, 1990 -
56620 December 10, 1990 -

, ET AL.
69863-65 December 10, 1990 -
74762 December 10, 1990 -

78163 December 10, 1990 -
E SECRETARY, ET AL.
80397 December 10, 1990 - S & A
82215 December 10, 1990 -

ET AL.
. 84132-33 December 10, 1990 -

IL. v. LYDIA RAMA
91041 December 10, 1990 - JOSE A.
P-86-32 December 10, 1990 -
31688 December 17, 1990 -
ET AL.
68514 December 17, 1990 -
E COURT, ET AL.
71589 December 17, 1990 -
76303 December 17, 1990 -


, ET AL.
83530 December 18, 1990 -
AL.
. 95203-05 December 18, 1990 -
T AL.
2756 December 18, 1990 -
. 88710-13 December 19, 1990 -
95478 December 19, 1990 -
RTJ-89-380 December 19, 1990 -
JR.
46198 December 20, 1990 -

OF LEYTE, ET AL.
E COURT, ET AL.
. 86492-94 December 20, 1990 -
E
88114 December 20, 1990 -
ET AL.
. 92029-30 December 20, 1990 -
ET AL.
, ET AL.
. 48535-36 December 21, 1990 -

63753-54 December 21, 1990 -
L, ET AL.
76519 December 21, 1990 -
. 78551-52 December 21, 1990 -

NIO
79526 December 21, 1990 -
TAX APPEALS, ET AL.
83257-58 December 21, 1990 -
. 89682-83 December 21, 1990 -
43491 December 26, 1990 -
E, ET AL.
46210 December 26, 1990 -
61527 December 26, 1990 -

ET AL.
77668 December 26, 1990 -
ET AL.
81039 December 26, 1990 -
L.
85157 December 26, 1990 -
ET AL.
88336 December 26, 1990 -
998 - 2019 ChanRobles Publishing Company | Disclaimer | E-mail Restrictions ChanRobles™ Virtual Law Library™ | chanro

Brillantes VS Yorac GR 93867

Caricato da

Informazioni sul documento

Titolo originale

Copyright

Formati disponibili

Condividi questo documento

Condividi o incorpora il documento

Opzioni di condivisione

Hai trovato utile questo documento?

Questo contenuto è inappropriato?

Copyright:

Formati disponibili

Brillantes VS Yorac GR 93867

Caricato da

Copyright:

Formati disponibili

Search

The petitioner is challenging the designation by the President of the Philippines

RIVERA, PABLO RIVERA, RENATO

. 49588 : December 21, 1990.] 192

39430 December 3, 1990 -

82115 December 3, 1990 - PEOPLE

87264 December 3, 1990 -

58668 December 4, 1990 -

88177 December 4, 1990 -

36827 December 10, 1990 -

56620 December 10, 1990 -

74762 December 10, 1990 -

82215 December 10, 1990 -

. 84132-33 December 10, 1990 -

76303 December 17, 1990 -

78623 December 17, 1990 - OFELIA

. 88710-13 December 19, 1990 -

53556 December 20, 1990 - LILIA

49454 December 21, 1990 - PEOPLE

. 78551-52 December 21, 1990 -

61527 December 26, 1990 -

39430 December 3, 1990 -

82115 December 3, 1990 - PEOPLE

87264 December 3, 1990 -

58668 December 4, 1990 -

88177 December 4, 1990 -

36827 December 10, 1990 -

56620 December 10, 1990 -

74762 December 10, 1990 -

82215 December 10, 1990 -

. 84132-33 December 10, 1990 -

76303 December 17, 1990 -

78623 December 17, 1990 - OFELIA

. 88710-13 December 19, 1990 -

53556 December 20, 1990 - LILIA

49454 December 21, 1990 - PEOPLE

. 78551-52 December 21, 1990 -

61527 December 26, 1990 -

82115 December 3, 1990 - PEOPLE

87264 December 3, 1990 -

58668 December 4, 1990 -

88177 December 4, 1990 -

36827 December 10, 1990 -

56620 December 10, 1990 -

74762 December 10, 1990 -

82215 December 10, 1990 -

. 84132-33 December 10, 1990 -

76303 December 17, 1990 -

78623 December 17, 1990 - OFELIA

53556 December 20, 1990 - LILIA

49454 December 21, 1990 - PEOPLE

. 78551-52 December 21, 1990 -

61527 December 26, 1990 -

Potrebbero piacerti anche