Sei sulla pagina 1di 17

ARTICLE IN PRESS

Evidenced-Based Interventions
for Children With Autism
Spectrum Disorder
D1X XMeredith N. WillD2X X, D3X XKristn CurransD4X X, D5X XJennifer SmithD6X X, D7X XStephanie WeberD8X X, D9X XAmie DuncanD10X X,
D1X XJenny BurtonD12X X, D13X XKimberly Kroeger-GeoppingerD14X X, D15X XValerie MillerD16X X, D17X XMegan StoneD18X X,
D19X XLindsay MaysD20X X, D21X XAshley LuebrechtD2X X, D23X XAnna HeemanD24X X, D25X XCraig EricksonD26X X and D27X XJulia AnixtD28X X*

This paper reviews evidenced-based interventions for children interdisciplinary autism center. An emphasis was placed on
with autism spectrum disorders (ASD) across the disciplines of results of the National Autism Center's National Standards Proj-
psychology, speech-language pathology, occupational ther- ect. Results and Conclusions: within each discipline, interven-
apy, and developmental pediatrics. Background: rates of ASD tions exist that vary in level of evidenced-based support.
diagnoses have been steadily rising over the past 2 decades. Although disciplines may differ in their definitions of evidence-
There are a wide range of therapies and interventions, of vary- based treatments, it is important for each discipline to strive to
ing levels of evidence, across disciplines that are now available offer and promote practices with the best evidenced-based sup-
to treat children with ASD. The field has moved toward a port according to each field's standards.
greater emphasis on the identification and utilization of evi-
denced-based treatments. Methods: a review and summary of Curr Probl Pediatr Adolesc Health Care 2018; 000:1 17
recent literature was conducted by professionals in an

Introduction among females (6.6 per 1000).2 The documented rise


in the prevalence of ASD is a much-debated topic,
utism spectrum disorder (ASD) is a neurode- and may be linked to improvement in diagnostic tools,
A velopmental condition characterized by per-
vasive deficits in social interaction and
increasing awareness of the disorder, and/or an
increase in incidence over time.
communication, as well as the presence of rigid and/ The manifestation and severity of symptoms of ASD
or repetitive behaviors or sensory concerns that impact vary widely, with treatment typically focusing on the
the individual’s functioning and development. Indi- core features of ASD such as: deficits in social com-
viduals with this disorder may experience symptoms munication or social interactions, restricted behaviors,
with or without intellectual or language impairment. sensory concerns, or on co-occurring challenging
The term “spectrum” is used to capture the wide array behaviors that impact the development of functional
of symptomology seen across age and developmental skills and independence. Symptom presentation and
levels.1 According to the Center for Disease Control treatment may be further complicated by medical con-
and Prevention’s 2018 published data, approximately cerns such as: epilepsy, sleep problems, and gastroin-
1 in 59 children in the United States are diagnosed testinal problems, as well as intellectual/cognitive
with ASD, with reported prevalence in all racial, eth- impairment, and, in some children, the presence of
nic, and socioeconomic groups. ASD is about 4 times challenging maladaptive behaviors such as hyperac-
more common among males (26.6 per 1000) than tivity, anxiety, irritability, self-injury, and aggression.3
Effective treatment for children with ASD involves an
From the The Kelly O’Leary Center for Autism Spectrum Disorders, Cin- interdisciplinary approach. It includes a combination
cinnati Children’s Hospital Medical Center, University of Cincinnati Col- of educational interventions, psychological/behavioral
lege of Medicine, 3333 Burnet Avenue MLC 4002, Cincinnati, OH 45229, therapies, speech-language therapy, occupational/
United States.
*Corresponding author. Julia Anixt physical therapy, and medical treatments (e.g., psy-
E-mail: julia.anixt@cchmc.org chopharmacology). The focus of this paper is on the
Curr Probl Pediatr Adolesc Health Care 000;000:1 17 non-pharmacologic treatments and therapies that sup-
1538-5442/$ -see front matter
port optimal outcomes for children and adolescents
Ó 2018 Published by Elsevier Inc.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cppeds.2018.08.014 with ASD.

Curr Probl Pediatr Adolesc Health Care, & &&&& 1


ARTICLE IN PRESS

What is meant by evidence-based to address the need for evidence-based practice guide-
practice? lines in ASD.6 This effort focuses on educational and
behavioral interventions that improve core symptoms of
There is a wide range of possible interventions avail-
children and adolescents with ASD less than 22 years of
able to treat core symptoms of ASD and co-occurring age.6 In this systematic review, an interdisciplinary
conditions. The cause of ASD is unknown and team of experts critically evaluated 775 research studies
believed to be multi-factorial, including a combination published between 1957 and late 2007. A Scientific
of predisposing genetic factors and environmental Merit Rating Scale (SMRS) was developed to evaluate
exposures.4 There is no single cause for ASD, and the methods used in each study. This scale included five
there is no single best treatment option. Given the het-domains: (1) research design, (2) measurement of the
erogeneity of ASD symptoms and severity across the dependent variable, (3) measurement of the independent
spectrum, ASD is generally not a condition that can variable or procedural fidelity, (4) participant ascertain-
be “cured.” The primary goal of treatment is to opti- ment, and (5) generalization.6 Based on scores from the
mize functional outcomes, including: communication SMRS, interventions were categorized into four classifi-
skills, social skills, quality of life, and independent liv-
cations called the Strength of Evidence Classification
ing, while reducing or eliminating maladaptive behav- System: (1) Established, (2) Emerging, (3) Unestab-
iors. Without a cure, families may be easily persuaded lished, and (4) Ineffective/Harmful. No interventions
to try a range of complementary and alternative medi- reviewed were classified into the Ineffective/Harmful
cal (CAM) treatments, with little-to-no rigorous category. Interventions in each of the other classifica-
empirical research to support effectiveness. In addi- tions are listed in Table 1.
tion, many well-established medical/behavioral treat- In 2015, a second iteration of this work, the National
ments used in traditional practice may also lack a Standards Project, Phase 2 (NSP2) was released and
rigorous research base. Given the multitude of treat- included research published between the end of 2007
ment options available, with varying levels of research and early 2012. These results are also shown in
support, it is imperative that the field reliably evaluate
Table 1. The NSP2 focused on updating findings from
interventions and that clinicians follow evidence- the original report for individuals in the target age
based practices. Evidence-based practice consists of range as NSP1 (< 22 years of age), while also analyz-
three elements: (1) consideration of the best available ing studies published from 1987 to 2012 for interven-
research evidence, (2) applied in the context of an tions used with individuals with ASD ages 22 years
individual patient’s profile / characteristics, (3) based
and older.7 NSP2 included analysis of an additional
on the judgement/professional expertise of the 361 studies for the former age range (<22 years) and
clinician.5 28 studies for the latter (22 years). Other groups
Faced with a multitude of potential interventions andhave also conducted systematic reviews of ASD
no single obvious best choice that works for all individ-
treatments.8 10 However, the combination of NSP1
uals with ASD, families often explore treatments that and NSP2 encompasses the largest review of its type
may have long-standing scien- in the field of ASD.
tific support, as well as those
with limited or no research sup- To aid families in selecting evi- Developmental
port. To aid families in selecting dence-based interventions, clini- screening and
evidence-based interventions, cians must be mindful of the monitoring
clinicians must be mindful of the breadth of interventions that
breadth of interventions that Following guidelines of the
parents/caregivers consider, the
parents/caregivers consider, American Academy of Pediat-
associated evidence to support the associated evidence to sup- rics (AAP), primary care clini-
use of each intervention, the port use of each intervention, cians who provide well child
likelihood of benefit, and poten- the likelihood of benefit, and care for children are expected
tial associated harms or risk. to conduct routine developmen-
The National Autism Center
potential associated harms or tal surveillance at all well child
launched the National Standards risk. visits and structured develop-
Project (NSP) in 2005 in order mental screening at 9, 18, and

2 Curr Probl Pediatr Adolesc Health Care, & &&&&


ARTICLE IN PRESS

TABLE 1. Evidenced-based interventions as identified by the National Standards Project (Phases 1 and 2).6,7

Established
 Antecedent Package*  Schedules
 Behavioral Package*  Self-management
 Comprehensive Behavioral Treatment for Young Children  Story-based Intervention Package
 Joint Attention Intervention Behavioral Interventions*
 Modeling Cognitive Behavioral Intervention Package
 Naturalistic Teaching Strategies Language Training (Production)
 Peer Training Package Parent Training
 Pivotal Response Treatment Scripting
Social Skills Package

Emerging
 Augmentative and Alternative Communication Device  Music Therapy
 Cognitive Behavioral Intervention Package  Peer-mediated Instructional Arrangement
 Developmental Relationship-based Treatment  Picture Exchange Communication System
 Exercise  Reductive Package
 Exposure Package  Scripting
 Imitation-based Interaction  Sign Instruction
 Initiation Training  Social Communication Intervention
 Language Training (Production)  Social Skills Package
 Language Training (Production and Understanding)  Structured Teaching
 Massage/Touch Therapy  Technology-based Treatment
 Multi-component Package  Theory of Mind Training
Functional Communication Training

Unestablished
 Academic Interventions Movement-based Intervention
 Auditory Integration Training SENSE Theatre Intervention
 Facilitated Communication Sensory Intervention Package
 Gluten-free/Casein-free diet Shock Therapy
 Sensory Integrative Package Social Behavioral Learning Strategy
Animal-assisted Therapy Social Cognition Intervention
Concept Mapping Social Thinking Intervention
DIR/Floor Time
+Bulleted items include interventions listed in NSP and NSP2.
++Italics indicate NSP2 categorization only.
++Bold and italics indicates movement from Emerging to Established.
*In NSP2, Antecedent Package and Behavioral Package were combined into Behavioral Interventions.

30-months, including the use of ASD-specific screen- free, caregiver-tested online and print materials
ing tools at ages 18 and 24-months.11 Despite the designed to support caregivers, clinicians and profes-
AAP’s 2006 recommendations for developmental sionals in early childhood settings to recognize devel-
screening, a 2014 report from the Centers for Disease opmental red flags.15
Control and Prevention (CDC) demonstrated that When a child “fails” a developmental screening,
reported use of screening tools for young children is he or she should be referred to a developmental-
mixed.12 Less than half of pediatricians in a 2011 behavioral or neurodevelopmental pediatrician,
study reported consistently using a standardized child neurologist, child psychiatrist, psychologist,
developmental screening tool.13 Parents/caregivers or other developmental specialist for additional
report low rates of engagement with healthcare clini- evaluation, diagnosis, and treatment. In an interdis-
cians in their child’s developmental screening pro- ciplinary center, the developmental pediatrician, or
cess.14 To assist clinicians who engage with families other consulting developmental expert, oversees the
in the developmental surveillance and screening of care of the patient by (1) establishing a diagnosis of
children, the CDC launched the “Learn the Signs. Act ASD (often with the support of a team of psycholo-
Early.” public health initiative. This initiative includes gists and other allied health professionals such as

Curr Probl Pediatr Adolesc Health Care, & &&&& 3


ARTICLE IN PRESS

speech-language pathologists), (2) evaluating, mon- is strong evidence that EI programs that employ an
itoring, and treating medical and mental health con- Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA) approach yield opti-
ditions potentially related to the disorder (e.g., mal outcomes for the child, his or her family, and com-
irritability), (3) supporting parents/caregivers in munity (e.g.18 21).
making educational and other treatment decisions, Early intensive behavioral intervention (EIBI)
and (4) coordinating care over time, including refer- programs, which are EI programs that follow an
rals to specialists in psychology, speech-language ABA model of treatment, are characterized by the
pathology, or occupational therapy for treatment as following attributes: (1) an individualized and com-
indicated. prehensive curriculum that targets multiple devel-
opmental domains; (2) employs a wide variety of
behavior analytic strategies to increase and decrease
Treatment interventions target behaviors; (3) is supervised, at minimum, by
The goal of this paper is to provide an overview of a professional with advanced training in ABA and
evidence-based therapeutic interventions that clini- ASD; (4) use of neuro-typical development sequen-
cians in the fields of primary care and developmental ces to identify behaviors to modify; (5) parents and/
pediatrics should consider for treatment of children or other caregivers are trained as co-therapists and
and adolescents with ASD. This includes a review of monitored by the supervising ABA professional; (6)
the evidence-based therapies (non-pharmacologic intervention that is both one-on-one and group
treatments) across disciplines including the fields of: delivered; (7) intervention that is home-based, cen-
psychology, speech-language pathology, and occupa- ter-based, and generalizes to other treatment and/or
tional therapy. It is important to note that the scope of educational placements; (8) continuous treatment
many treatments overlaps among disciplines. There- with a minimum of 20 30 structured hours per
fore, in some content areas, to reduce redundancy, the week; and (9) intervention that begins prior to or
reader may be referred to other sections of the paper during the preschool years and continues for no less
for additional information. than two years (e.g.18,22). EIBI programs utilizing
ABA yield positive outcomes with 20 50% of par-
ticipant children (as young as 2-years old) achieving
Early intervention and early intensive average IQ and placement in general education set-
behavioral intervention programs tings upon the conclusion of treatment.22-24 An
Early intervention (EI) includes treatments that additional 20 40% of participant children make
begin before the age of 5 years, or prior to entry into moderate gains (but still require additional aca-
formalized schooling, and aims to increase skills in demic and/or social assistance upon the conclusion
the core deficits of ASD, such as communication and of treatment), and 10% of children make modest
socialization, while decreasing excessive maladaptive gains and require ongoing support.23 25 Children
symptoms, such as stereotypies and self-injurious who participate in EIBI according to the criteria
behaviors. Initiation of EI as young as possible is cru- listed above will be more likely to make and main-
cial to improve long-term outcomes for children diag- tain significant gains in intelligence/cognitive func-
16
nosed with ASD. Establishing an ASD diagnosis as tioning, language and communication, daily living
early and efficiently as possible and independent self-help
is important for intervention skills, and social functioning
services to begin during this crit- Establishing an ASD diagnosis compared to children who par-
ical early window of develop- as early and efficiently as possi- ticipate in alternative inter-
ment.17 While there is general ble is important for intervention vention 26
or no intervention at
consensus that EI is helpful for all. Participation in early
services to begin during this criti- intervention is therefore the
reducing ASD core symptoms,
there is less agreement about the cal early window of standard for evidence-based
17
type and quantity of services or development. intervention during this devel-
which curriculum is best. There opmental period.16

4 Curr Probl Pediatr Adolesc Health Care, & &&&&


ARTICLE IN PRESS

Treating behavior challenges in ASD to an item, gain the attention of others, engage in a
pleasurable activity (e.g., rocking back and forth), or
Applied behavior analysis (ABA) and escape a demand. With this information, the treating
functional behavior assessment (FBA) clinician is able to select an appropriate behavioral
Individuals with ASD often present with co-occur- intervention to either increase the frequency of an
ring challenging behaviors that include: disruptive adaptive behavior or decrease the frequency of a mal-
behaviors, aggression, and self-injury and these adaptive behavior. While analyzing the function/pur-
behaviors may affect the safety of the child with ASD pose of a behavior, it is important to keep in mind
and others. Developmental disabilities associated with potential medical conditions that could be a trigger for
ASD such as impaired cogni- disruptive behaviors and would
tive functioning, decreased require a different treatment
adaptive behaviors, and com- Behavioral interventions, includ- approach. For example, an indi-
munication delays may also ing antecedent (e.g., prompting, vidual may present to clinic
increase the potential for mal- environmental modifications) with a challenging behavior of
adaptive behaviors in children and consequent (e.g., reinforce- hitting himself in the head with
with ASD.27 Behavior chal- his fist. If the “function” of the
lenges, if left untreated, have
ment, extinction) strategies, is hitting behavior is to avoid the
the potential to negatively the largest category of Estab- pain of a severe sinus infection,
impact social-emotional func- lished Interventions for individu- medical treatment is the first
tioning, educational and voca- als under age 22 years and the priority.
tional opportunities, and the Once clinicians have identi-
development of independent
only category of Established fied the function of challenging
living skills.28 ABA incorpo- Interventions for those age behaviors, they can work to
rates behavioral learning theory 22 years and older as reported prevent the behavior from
into real-world settings and is in the NSP2.7 occurring or limit occurrence
not a single strategy or inter- in the future. Behavioral inter-
vention. Rather, Baer et al ventions, including antecedent
define ABA as “the process of systematically applying (e.g., prompting, environmental modifications) and
interventions based upon the principles of learning consequent (e.g., reinforcement, extinction) strate-
theory to improve socially significant behaviors to a gies, is the largest category of Established Interven-
meaningful degree,”29. Based on scientific inquiry, tions for individuals under age 22 years and the only
ABA requires ongoing measurement of target out- category of Established Interventions for those age
comes and analysis of collected data to determine 22 years and older as reported in the NSP2.7
effectiveness of interventions.29 For over 70 years, Whereas antecedent strategies described above are
research has supported the effectiveness of ABA to more proactive or preventative in nature, consequent
improve pro-social behaviors.30,31 strategies are more reactive and involve responding
It is essential to note that each challenging behavior following a challenging behavior. These antecedent
serves a purpose for an individual in their environ- or preventative approaches involve altering an indi-
mental context. An imperative first step in any effec- vidual’s environment to decrease the probability of
tive behavioral intervention plan is to complete a challenging behavior.
Functional Behavioral Assessment (FBA). An FBA
involves examining what happens before (i.e., ante- Antecedent strategies to prevent disruptive
cedent) and after (i.e., consequence) a maladaptive behaviors
behavior. Data from a FBA are used to determine Effective strategies for preventing or reducing prob-
which function(s) motivate and/or maintain maladap- lem behaviors in individuals with ASD include visual
tive behaviors32,33 to determine how best to respond supports, such as schedules or story-based interven-
to the behaviors to disrupt their maintenance. Individ- tions, and modeling. Picture or written schedules ori-
uals behave in ways that enable them to either: (1) get ent the individual to the order of daily activities and
something or (2) escape something. The function story-based interventions, such as Social StoriesTM,
behind a challenging behavior may be to obtain access establish explicit expectations for behaviors across

Curr Probl Pediatr Adolesc Health Care, & &&&& 5


ARTICLE IN PRESS

various situations with a combination of text and pic- from their child’s treating clinicians on how to iden-
tures to explain expected behaviors in a targeted situa- tify the functions of behavior, recognize the environ-
tion.7,34 Modeling is also a highly effective approach mental impact upon maladaptive behavior, and
to teach an individual an expected behavior. Although implement an appropriate intervention plan.
individuals with ASD may have a deficit in imitation
skills, research has demonstrated that both live and
video modeling (e.g., showing an individual a pre-
Social skill interventions
recording of behavioral expectations in a situation) Deficits in social skills are a core feature of ASD.
are effective strategies in teaching individuals with Difficulties in social functioning include challenges
ASD.7 in: initiating and maintaining eye contact, joint atten-
tion, engaging in reciprocal conversations, emotion
Consequent strategies in response to disruptive recognition, empathy, and recognizing/reading social
behaviors cues. Social skill deficits in children with ASD do not
Despite using preventive strategies, challenging tend to improve over time with developmental matura-
behaviors commonly occur in individuals with ASD. tion alone.35 Often, as individuals with ASD enter
Consequent strategies can impact behavior in two later childhood and adolescence, social skill deficits
ways. They can result in the behavior happening become more pronounced and have been associated
either: (1) more frequently in the future or (2) less fre- with academic problems, depressive symptoms, and
quently in the future. ABA focuses on improving anxiety.36 Social skills deficits may be challenging to
socially significant behaviors in a meaningful way and treat as interactions with others are complex, some-
is based on learning theory, which includes the princi- times unpredictable, and vary greatly depending on
ples of reinforcement and punishment. Following con- the context of the situation. As such, few social skill
sequences, reinforced behaviors are more likely to interventions have an established evidence base.
occur in the future, and punished behavior are less Although many social skills interventions exist, this
likely to occur. Positive reinforcement designates the review focuses on the few interventions supported by
increase in a target behavior following the addition of some level of evidence, including: (1) social skill
a stimulus (e.g., a child sits nicely and receives an edi- groups, (2) peer-mediated interventions, (3) video
ble reward and praise for sitting). Negative reinforce- modeling, and (4) social narratives.6,7,37 39
ment has occurred when removal of a stimulus leads
to an increase in behavior (e.g., a child completes a Social skill interventions within larger
task after he leaves a noisy classroom). Alternatively, comprehensive programs for young children
when a behavior decreases following the addition of a Many treatment programs for toddlers and young
stimulus, the behavior has been positively punished (e. children with ASD, include a focus on improving
g., a child stops screaming when she is reprimanded social functioning (e.g., EIBI, Early Start Denver
for doing so). Behaviors that decrease after the Model, etc.). Joint attention is a particularly salient
removal of a stimulus are negatively punished (e.g., a skill to target at a young age, because it is one of the
child stops screaming after his favorite toy is earliest precursors for development of later social-
removed). Extinction is a procedure that involves communication skills.40 Joint attention describes the
removing the reinforcement that was previously main- process of a child trying to share his or her experience
taining maladaptive behavior.30 with another by visually referencing another person to
Although treatment relying on antecedent/conse- show them something of interest. Joint attention inter-
quent strategies is effective, generalizability may be ventions will be further discussed below in the
limited by caregiver involvement in treatment and “Speech and Language Interventions” section.
practice of strategies in the natural environment. Care-
giver involvement in behavioral intervention is a cru- Social skill groups
cial component to generalizing treatment effects Group-based interventions are one of the most
going from therapeutic to real-world settings. Care- widely used treatment methods to teach social skills in
giver involvement helps to increase adaptive behavior youth, and, therefore, are often readily available treat-
and decrease maladaptive behavior. Caregivers are ments. Social skills groups include direct instruction
encouraged to learn through modeling and coaching of basic concepts and role-playing or practice. Many

6 Curr Probl Pediatr Adolesc Health Care, & &&&&


ARTICLE IN PRESS

social skills groups require participants to have at least especially beneficial as it “taps into” the visual learn-
low-average cognitive ability. A recent meta-analysis ing acuity of those with ASD.37 A meta-analysis of
of group-based social skills interventions for youth social skill interventions for children with ASD found
with ASD indicated that such interventions yielded that video modeling was the only intervention that
large effects for self-report measures (of social-knowl- was evidenced-based and highly effective as an inter-
edge), smaller effects for parent- and observer- vention strategy.38 Video self-modeling, in particular,
reported measures, and non-significant effects for is an effective element in teaching skills for those
teacher reported measures.41 This study, which with high-functioning ASD and video self-modeling
included only randomized controlled trials, concluded generalizes skills across settings.36
that group-based social skill interventions are
“modestly” effective for youth with ASD. This is due Story-based interventions/social narratives
to skills developed in the context of social skills Story-based interventions generally incorporate
groups not necessarily generalizing to other settings, written or visual descriptions of specific situations
such as school. The authors noted that the largest under which certain behaviors are expected to occur.
effect, in self-report measures of social skills, was Social narratives are typically written by clinicians,
attributable to an increase in social knowledge, but teachers, parents, or other adults. The content of the
not necessarily an increase in observable skills. Never- story depends on the learner’s cognitive ability, but in
theless, this research highlights the challenge of gener- general, such story-based interventions focus on the
alizing skills from the clinic to everyday life. “who, what, where, when, and why” questions
A specific social skills group curriculum called the designed to improve perspective-taking and self-regu-
Program for the Education and Enrichment of Rela- lation skills. Story-based interventions are categorized
tional Skills (PEERSÒ ) is an empirically supported as an “Established Intervention” by the National
and evidenced-based program that teaches skills for Standards Project, and are considered evidenced-
adolescents with high-functioning ASD.42 Please refer based by the National Professional Development Cen-
to the section entitled, “Evidence-Based Practices and ter.39,43 Despite this, other review studies do not pro-
Interventions for Adolescents with ASD” for addi- vide support for the use of story-based
tional information on PEERSÒ . interventions.36,38 There have been mixed reviews
regarding the level of effectiveness of this interven-
Peer-mediated interventions tion; thus additional, research is needed to clarify the
Social skill group-based interventions are taught efficacy of social narratives.
using a variety of different formats. They are often
implemented by clinicians and include other partici- Interventions to address co-occurring mental
pants with similar diagnoses. However, groups may
health conditions
also include same-age peers who are considered
“typically developing.” Rather than adult-led groups, The mental health concerns of individuals with ASD
peer-mediated interventions have shown promising have been historically overlooked for a variety of rea-
results and are considered an “Established Inter- sons. A professional’s clinical perspective and ability
vention” in the National Standards Project.7 Peer- to recognize symptoms of mental health conditions in
mediated interventions focus on teaching neuro-typi- context of a developmental disability such as ASD or
cally developing peers how to initiate social interac- Intellectual Disability is complex. This bias of clini-
tions with individuals with ASD to increase social cians to attribute behaviors to the patient’s underlying
interactions in their daily life. disability rather than a co-morbid condition (e.g.,
Attention Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder, depression,
Modeling and video modeling or anxiety) is known as diagnostic overshadowing.44
In-vivo modeling is an intervention technique in In addition to diagnostic overshadowing, there are
which a teacher demonstrates a desired behavior that inherent challenges associated with diagnosing mental
the learner then imitates and eventually acquires. health symptoms in individuals with ASD. Most
Video modeling is a technique that involves watching measures that assess mental health concerns, such as
a video of someone (or oneself) demonstrating a target anxiety and depression, rely on an individual to self-
behavior. Video modeling is hypothesized to be report their symptoms. Individuals with ASD often

Curr Probl Pediatr Adolesc Health Care, & &&&& 7


ARTICLE IN PRESS

present with communication impairments that make prevalence rates vary widely, ranging from 10 to
self-report of symptoms a significant challenge, as 53%.50 Symptoms of depression in youth with ASD
well as social deficits that make identification and are often under-recognized and under-treated due to
understanding of emotional states difficult. In addi- the challenges associated with making accurate diag-
tion, it is often difficult for families and professionals noses and a reliance on self-report of symptoms. As a
to differentiate between symptoms of a mental health result, observable behaviors reported by caregivers
condition, such as anxiety or obsessive compulsive become even more important.45 In addition to the tra-
disorder, and core features of ASD that may overlap, ditional signs of depression (e.g., changes in sleep or
such as rigid and repetitive behaviors.45,46 disinterest in preferred activities), the symptoms of
Fortunately, mental health challenges in individuals depression in children with ASD may include higher
with ASD have started to receive increased attention rates of aggression, self-injurious behavior, hyperac-
within the past few decades. Anxiety and depression tivity, compulsiveness, and stereotypic behavior as
will be the focus of the remaining section due to their well as regression in skills and decreased adaptive
high prevalence in this population, as well as the num- functioning.45 Higher-functioning individuals with
ber of studies that examine assessment and treatment ASD also have more symptoms of depression as
of these conditions. Individuals with ASD may be sus- reported by their parents and have lower self-esteem
ceptible to symptoms of anxiety and depression due to compared to their lower-functioning peers.51 Lower-
characteristics inherent to their diagnosis including functioning individuals may demonstrate higher levels
communication and social deficits, rigid thinking pat- of externalizing behaviors (e.g., increased aggression)
terns, sensory processing differences, and emotional during periods of depression while higher-functioning
regulation difficulties.45,47 individuals may be able to report more of the internal-
izing symptoms of depression (e.g., depressed mood,
Anxiety feelings of guilt, negativistic thinking, etc.).
Symptoms of anxiety are extremely common in
individuals with ASD. The majority of studies report Treatment approach for anxiety/depression
a prevalence rate of anxiety disorders in children and Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) is an empiri-
adolescents to be around 50%, with rates varying cally-supported treatment for typically developing
from 42 to 79%.48 Specific phobias (e.g., anxiety children with anxiety disorders.52 Moderate to large
towards specific objects or situations) were the most effect sizes have been found across studies that have
prevalent diagnosis in 8 of 12 studies reviewing anxi- evaluated the effectiveness of CBT for children and
ety disorders in children and adolescents with ASD.48 adolescents with ASD.53 CBT for anxiety typically
Social anxiety disorder and generalized anxiety dis- addresses three areas: identification of emotions and
order are also common diagnoses among individuals physiological arousal, reduction of avoidance behav-
with ASD.49 Despite the high prevalence, the symp- iors, and restructuring distorted thoughts.54 Read et al.55
toms of anxiety may present differently in individu- identified the following steps involved in CBT for anxi-
als with ASD compared to other populations. In ety: psychoeducation about emotions and physiological
addition to physiological symptoms, individuals with symptoms, relaxation training to reduce physiological
ASD may appear more irritable and engage in more arousal, cognitive restructuring to target distorted
challenging behaviors such as aggression, self-injury, thoughts, problem solving, gradual exposure to feared
and tantrums when they are anxious.47 Anxiety in tasks, and booster sessions to prevent relapse. Adapta-
individuals with ASD may be triggered by different tions to CBT for individuals with ASD have included
events or experiences related to diagnostic features the use of visual supports, more concrete language,
of ASD compared to other children and adolescents. incorporation of special interests, additional repetition
Triggers may include changes to their routine, being and practice, and extra rewards for participation in thera-
overstimulated by sensory experiences, and idiosyn- peutic activities with effectiveness.55
cratic/highly specific fears. Within the past decade, researchers and clinicians
have made considerable strides in the treatment of
Depression anxiety in youth with ASD. Vasa et al.49 found the
It is now widely accepted that individuals with ASD moderate evidence for treatment of anxiety in youth
experience symptoms of depression and reported with ASD to be moderate in a systematic review of

8 Curr Probl Pediatr Adolesc Health Care, & &&&&


ARTICLE IN PRESS

eleven studies using CBT, with 38 to 71.4% of chil- encouraging and reflects the existing mental health
dren participating being diagnosis free after participat- challenges of this population. Clinicians who work
ing in treatment. Ung et al.56 conducted an updated with individuals with ASD may need to modify man-
systematic review and meta-analysis that included ualized CBT curriculum and provide extra supports to
more recent studies and also found CBT (ranging meet the unique needs of these individuals. Primary
from 6 to 32 weeks in duration) to have a moderate care clinicians can be confident that therapy should be
treatment effect size in youth with high-functioning successful when they refer individuals with ASD to
ASD. CBT programs to address symptoms of anxiety.
All of the studies examined by systematic reviews
utilize structured treatments to deliver CBT. One
Interventions to build skills and independence
study57 used a modified version of a commercially
available, manualized cognitive-behavioral interven- for adolescents with ASD
tion, the Coping Cat program,58,59 to accommodate The National Professional Development Center39,43
the learning styles of children with ASD. Other stud- has identified a range of evidence-based practices that
ies60 63; used a modular CBT program, Behavioral are effective to improve skills in adolescents with
Interventions for Anxiety in Children with Autism ASD (ages 15 22 years) across a range of domains
(BIACA), but this program is not commercially avail- (e.g., social, communication, joint attention, behavior,
able at this time. Manualized treatments designed to school-readiness, play, cognitive, motor, adaptive,
address the specific needs of youth with ASD, includ- vocational, and academic). For example, evidence-
ing the Facing Your Fears curriculum,64 are available based practices that have been identified in the area of
for purchase and dissemination. vocational skills include modeling, prompting, rein-
Concerns have been raised that children with ASD forcing, self-management, technology aided instruc-
who have lower intellectual abilities are unable to par- tion, and video modeling. It is important to note that
ticipate in the cognitive aspects of CBT. However, there are significantly fewer evidence-based practices
this does not mean that such individuals can not bene- and interventions for adolescents with ASD compared
fit from the behavioral aspects of CBT including grad- to preschool and school-aged children with ASD.
ual exposure to a feared object or avoided situation. While many of the evidence-based practices discussed
Behavioral treatment has been identified as an evi- above have been used to improve skills,71 adaptive
dence-based treatment for “phobic avoidance” in indi- behavior,72 and technology-aided interventions and
viduals with intellectual disabilities.65 Graduated instruction,73 this section focuses on specific interven-
exposure and positive reinforcement, two components tion packages that have been shown to be effective or
of CBT, are effective to reduce anxiety related to spe- have shown promise to improve skills in adolescents
cific phobias in individuals with ASD (for a review, with ASD, in the following 3 domains: (1) social
see Hagopian et al.66). skills, (2) daily living skills, and (3) employment. It is
Compared to the multitude of studies that examine important to note that anxiety is one of the most com-
the efficacy of CBT with individuals with ASD who mon co-morbid disorders in adolescents with ASD.42
have anxiety, studies that examine CBT for depressive The reader is referred to the section entitled, “Mental
symptom is extremely limited. CBT is an effective Health Interventions in ASD” for additional informa-
treatment for depression in typically developing chil- tion on this topic.
dren53 and adolescents.67 More recent studies have
also shown promising results for CBT adapted for par- Social skills in adolescence
ticipants with ASD in the reduction of depressive The PEERSÒ program has been shown to be an
symptoms.68 70 effective social skills intervention for high-function-
The assessment and treatment of depression in indi- ing adolescents and young adults with ASD.42,74
viduals with ASD remains an area that will require an PEERSÒ consists of 14 weekly, 90-min sessions that
increase in the future collaboration among patients, are attended by parents and teens separately. Session
families, clinicians, and researchers. The number of content includes engaging in back and forth conversa-
scientifically-sound research studies that have been tion, developing and maintaining friendships, using
published recently on the assessment and evidence- humor, handling bullying and teasing, and planning
based treatment of anxiety in individuals with ASD is get-togethers with friends. In adolescent sessions,

Curr Probl Pediatr Adolesc Health Care, & &&&& 9


ARTICLE IN PRESS

techniques such as teaching the rules of specific social communication skills, functional behavioral assess-
behaviors and then role-playing and receiving/provid- ments and intervention plans for problem behaviors,
ing feedback are used. In parent sessions, instruction and customized employment methods. The results of a
on how to help their teen overcome any social difficul- pilot RCT revealed that 74% of adolescents with ASD
ties through coaching and using weekly homework were competitively employed at the end of the inter-
assignments is provided. A pilot study demonstrated vention as compared to 6% of adolescents with ASD
that, after completing PEERSÒ , adolescents with ASD who just received supports through the high school
made significant gains in areas such as frequency of special education program. These results were main-
peer interactions and improved social responsiveness tained at a 1-year follow-up.79
and social skills knowledge.42 Laugeson and col-
leagues74 recently conducted a long term follow-up
study (1 5 years after completion of PEERSÒ ) and Evidence based practices to address
found that most social improvements were main-
communication (speech-language pathology)
tained.
Deficits in social-communication are a core feature
Daily living skills of ASD, though there is tremendous heterogeneity in
Adolescents with ASD often have daily living skills the presentation of speech/language concerns across
that fall far below their chronological age; this then the autism spectrum. According to the American
affects their ability to successfully transition to col- Speech-Language Hearing Association (ASHA), defi-
75,76
lege, work, and independent living. Duncan and cits in social communication are the result of disrupted
colleagues77 recently developed “Surviving and early social-cognitive behaviors including joint atten-
Thriving in the Real World”, which is a 12-week, 90- tion (e.g., directing another’s attention towards items
min intervention attended by adolescents with ASD of interest by pointing), social reciprocity (e.g., main-
and their parents. Adolescent sessions target the acqui- taining interactions by taking turns), language and rel-
sition of skills such as self-care, cooking, laundry, and ative cognitive skills (e.g., understanding and using
money management through direct instruction, peer nonverbal and verbal communication and symbolic
modeling, and video modeling. Parent sessions focus play), and emotional-behavioral regulation (e.g.,
on how to assist their adolescent in acquiring and mas- appropriately regulating one’s emotional state and
tering daily living skills in the home and community. behavior while engaging in social interaction).80 Dis-
Follow-up to this study indicated that adolescents rupted joint attention is one of the earliest signs of
with ASD made significant progress in all targeted ASD.81,82 Impairments in joint attention pose a serious
daily living skills, and gained 2 2.5 years of daily liv- problem by limiting the language promoting interac-
ing skills on a standardized measure of adaptive func- tions with parents and caregivers83 and the acquisition
tioning over the course of the 12 week intervention.77 of other developmental skills including play.84
Some children with ASD have strong verbal abilities
Employment and demonstrate average to above average use of
Project SEARCH78 is a 9-month job training pro- vocabulary and sentence structures. These children
gram for adolescents and young adults with develop- may struggle with pragmatic language, which includes
mental disabilities who are still enrolled in high using language appropriately in social interactions.85
school that focuses on building Many children with ASD dem-
employability skills through For children with ASD, sponta- onstrate impairments in their
didactic sessions while also ability to understand and use
completing several internships
neous use of expressive lan- age-appropriate vocabulary and
at local businesses (e.g., hospi- guage skills by the end of the sentences structures (e.g.,
tal, university, private sector preschool years has been asso- receptive and expressive lan-
companies). Wehman et al.79 ciated with positive outcomes in guage), in addition to pragmatic
recently modified the tradi- language deficits.86 Approxi-
tional Project SEARCH model
adulthood, including social and mately 30% of children with
by utilizing ABA techniques to vocational success. ASD fail to acquire meaningful
address behavioral and social- use of expressive language. The

10 Curr Probl Pediatr Adolesc Health Care, & &&&&


ARTICLE IN PRESS

reason why this group remains essentially “nonverbal” environments.95 To improve the generalization of
or acquires only minimal use of words and phrases is skills, there is a growing trend toward using develop-
not well understood.87 mental behavioral approaches in daily life as part of
For children with ASD, spontaneous use of expres- speech-language treatment. These approaches are
sive language skills by the end of the preschool years child-led and focus on activities and routines that are
has been associated with positive outcomes in adult- familiar and highly motivating for the child to elicit
hood, including social and vocational success. 88 and improve a variety of social-communication skills
Therefore, addressing social-communication deficits deficits.96,97
as early as possible is a critical priority. Speech-lan-
guage pathologists (SLPs) provide assessment and Commonly used intervention strategies
treatment services to children with impaired social- A variety of language modeling strategies are used
communication skills and language impairment. by SLPs to encourage understanding and using lan-
Research has shown that teaching foundational social- guage in social interactions. Parents, family members,
communication skills such as joint attention, social and others involved in interactions with children with
reciprocity, and play, facilitates later language acqui- ASD should also be trained to use these strategies in
sition.89 Thus, an appropriate goal for treatment serv- the child’s daily environment to model appropriate
ices provided by SLPs is to address foundational use of language. Such modeling strategies are also cat-
social-communication skills rather than addressing egorized as “Established” interventions in the
language impairment in isolation. The social-commu- NSP2.6,7
nication deficits experienced by youth with ASD also Environmental arrangement or “communicative
impact their communication partners. Family mem- temptations” involves setting up the environment so
bers, peers, teachers, SLPs, and other professionals that the child must initiate a communication bid such
who interact with children with ASD are faced with as a gesture, word, or phrase toward the adult in order
the challenge of learning to respond to unusual styles to obtain a desired item or outcome. The use of envi-
of communication, interpreting the function of prob- ronmental arrangement strategies may include specific
lem behavior, and modifying the environment to foster strategies such as limiting access to high preferred
social engagement. Treatment by the SLP may be items, or more broadly, designing a treatment space to
delivered in a variety of settings (e.g., one-on-one, provide visual clarity regarding the activity that occurs
classroom- or community-based models) and should in that space. Such environmental arrangements are
include education and training of family members, consistent with behavioral antecedent strategies,
teachers, peers, and other child health professionals.80 which are considered to be “Established” intervention
SLPs may use a variety of specific treatment strategies in the NSP.6
approaches or they may be involved in implementing Schedules and written scripts are also considered
a comprehensive treatment program. Treatment “Established” intervention strategies by the NSP2.7
approaches may include adult-led to child-led strate- Schedules are used to successfully promote engage-
gies to improve social-communication. Below we ment and understand task completion for children
briefly describe specific speech/language treatment with ASD who range from being minimally verbal to
approaches. very verbal.98,99 Schedules may consist of words, pic-
tures, or a combination of both. They may include a
Early comprehensive models daily sequence of activities that need to be completed
As previously described in the “Early Intervention” (e.g., a daily schedule) or they may be used to illus-
section, principles of Applied Behavioral Analysis trate a sequence of steps that need to be completed
(ABA) are used to teach communication skills to chil- within a single activity (e.g., circle time at preschool,
dren with ASD. One particular component of ABA is bed time routine at home). Written scripts, are used to
discrete trial teaching (DTT) methodology, which has help readers with ASD initiate and engage in conver-
been used to teach children expressive communica- sational exchanges.7,100 The child may be provided
tion,90 verbal imitation,91,92 play,93 and joint atten- with cue cards with text or more extensive written
tion.94 While children may acquire communication scripts and prompted as needed to read the appropriate
skills using DTT, a criticism of this approach has been lines of text. As the child learns the scripts, cue cards
that skills often fail to generalize to other or written scripts are removed. Written scripts can be

Curr Probl Pediatr Adolesc Health Care, & &&&& 11


ARTICLE IN PRESS

created and adapted easily based on the child’s inter- Addressing sensory processing and motor
ests and implemented in a variety of social situations skills: occupational-therapy based interventions
Visual cues are considered an “Emerging” interven-
Children with ASD often have impairments in activ-
tion in the NSP6 and are also used to support children
with ASD in making choices. Visual cues may also be ities of daily living due to behavioral, motor, and/or
social deficits related to the diagnosis. Areas of func-
used to support social initiation, including play with
peers, or the initiation of requests for a break or assis- tion affected include basic activities of daily living,
play skills, productive occupations such as school,
tance. The strategy of visual cues is well-aligned with
a common pattern of relative strengths for individuals socialization, and the ability to handle schedule and
routine changes.108 Occupational therapists (OTs) are
with ASD, including visuospatial skills, memory
poised to address two common challenges in children
recall, and comprehension of graphic symbols.101
with ASD: decreased sensory processing abilities and
decreased motor skills.
Augmentative and alternative communication According to Ayres,109 sensory integration is a
systems neurological process that determines how we make
Since a significant minority of individuals with ASD sense of how our bodies interact with the environ-
fail to acquire adequate use of expressive language, ment. Sensory processing dysfunction occurs when
SLPs may provide assessment and treatment for the the neurological system does not interpret or react
use of augmentative and alternative communication to sensory information appropriately.110 These dif-
(AAC) systems, currently considered an “Emerging” ficulties are hypothesized to cause disruptions to
intervention by the NSP2.6,7 A wide range of AAC daily living activities. They also impact how a
approaches may be used to improve the social-com- child with ASD engages with his or her environ-
munication skills of children with ASD. Unaided ment. An OT trained in sensory integration will
AAC approaches include the use of gestures and sign identify and treat sensory processing difficulties
language. Aided AAC approaches may include the using sensory-based interventions, such as those
use of pictures, graphic symbols, written cues, speech that follow Ayres’ Sensory Integration theory. The
generating devices, or mobile technologies with ideal goal of sensory-based therapy is to provide a
AAC-specific apps. The Picture Exchange Communi- “just right challenge” that will elicit what is termed
cation System (PECS)102 combines both behavioral an adaptive response, “an appropriate action in
principles and aided AAC to teach individuals with which the individual responds successfully to some
ASD to initiate requests for highly preferred items. environmental demand”.109 An OT can work with
The use of AAC may have positive effects on behav- a family to gradually expose a child to a sensory
ior for children with ASD,103 such as improved social challenge and teach him or her strategies to cope
interaction104 and receptive and expressive lan- with it.
guage.105 A systematic review by Schlosser and A limited number of research papers have evaluated
Wendt found that AAC does not impede and may the effectiveness of sensory integration therapy. This
actually encourage the development of expressive lan- may be due to the wide variety of sensory differences
guage.106 The current literature does not yet identify among children with ASD and differences in thera-
specific forms of AAC that may be appropriate for peutic approaches. Currently, sensory integration ther-
individuals with ASD.107 Clinical decisions about the apy is considered an “Unestablished” intervention by
use of unaided and aided AAC techniques should be the NSP.6,7 Clinicians are encouraged to follow guide-
made on an individual basis. Considerations should lines to ensure best-practice in sensory integration
include the individual’s learning strengths and weak- therapy, such as the fidelity measure developed by
nesses, his or her developmental level of social-com- Parnham et al.111 based on Ayres’ Sensory Integration
munication skills, and vision as well as motor skills. theory.82 Watling and Hauer’s systematic review112
The context in which the AAC system might be used states that, when Parham’s fidelity measure is
(e.g., home, school), communication partners, and the applied111 in sensory integration therapy, there is
individual’s and family’s preferences should also be moderate evidence for the use of Ayres approach in
considered before AAC is implemented. children with ASD.

12 Curr Probl Pediatr Adolesc Health Care, & &&&&


ARTICLE IN PRESS

Motor coordination deficits, while not part of the diag- 3. Myers SM JC. Management of children with autism spec-
nostic criteria for ASD, are a common concern in children trum disorders. Pediatrics 2007;120:1162–82.
with ASD.113 115 ASD is associated with gross and fine 4. Lyall K, Croen L, Daniels J, et al. The changing epidemiol-
ogy of autism spectrum disorders. Annual review of public
motor coordination problems including: clumsiness, pos- health 2017;38:81–102.
tural instability, and poor performance on standardized 5. Initiative MAG. Autism spectrum disorders: Guide to evi-
tests of motor functioning.113 Deficits in motor skills can dence-based interventions. St Louis and Springfiled, MO:
impact independence with activities of daily living as Missouri Foundation for Health; 2012.
well as socialization due to the gross-motor nature of 6. Howard H, Ladew P, Pollack E. The National Autism Cen-
ter’s National Standards Project “Findings and Conclusions”.
play, especially in younger children. OTs are skilled in
Randolph, MA: National Autism Center; 2009.
addressing fine motor concerns and motor planning 7. Findings and conclusions: National standards project, phase
(praxis), and physical therapists (PT) are skilled in assess- 2(Accessed Retrieved May 10, 2018 from http://www.natio-
ment and intervention for children with gross motor defi- nalautismcenter.org; 2015.
cits. Using the basis of engagement in functional tasks in 8. Odom SL, Collet-Klingenberg L, Rogers SJ, et al. Evidence-
natural environments, OTs facilitate children building based practices in interventions for children and youth with
autism spectrum disorders. Preventing school failure: Alter-
skills to improve their coordination and overall control of native education for children and youth 2010;54:275–82.
motor movements.116 In addition, OTs can provide assis- 9. Young J, Corea C, Kimani J, et al. Autism spectrum disor-
tive technology and adapted strategies to supplement ders (ASDs) services. IMPAQ final report on environmental
motor abilities in order to increase independence and scan Baltimore. MD: Centers for Medicare and Medicaid
engagement in functional tasks and daily living skills. Services; 2010.
10. Warren Z., Veenstra-VanderWeele J., Stone W., et al. Thera-
pies for children with autism spectrum disorders. 2011.
Conclusion 11. Committee BFS. Committee MHIfCWSNPA. Identifying
infants and young children with developmental disorders in
There is a wide range of interventions available, with the medical home: An algorithm for developmental surveil-
varying levels of evidence to treat the core features of lance and screening. Pediatrics 2006;118:405–20.
ASD, which include communication and social deficits, 12. Rice CE, Van Naarden Braun K, Kogan MD, et al. Screening
challenging behaviors, and sensory processing and motor for developmental delays among young children—National
Survey of Children’s Health, United States, 2007. MMWR
coordination difficulties. Since ASD is a pervasive disor-
Surveill Summ 2014;63:27–35.
der that affects multiple areas of functioning, it is impor- 13. Radecki L, Sand-Loud N, O’Connor KG, et al. Trends in the
tant for clinicians to be knowledgeable about the most use of standardized tools for developmental screening in
effective and evidenced-informed interventions across dis- early childhood: 2002–2009. Pediatrics 2011;128:14–9.
ciplines in order to provide clinical care that optimizes 14. Bethell C, Reuland C, Schor E, et al. Rates of parent-cen-
outcomes for children with ASD. The treatment strategies tered developmental screening: disparities and links to serv-
ices access. Pediatrics 2011;128:146–55.
and interventions presented in this paper are interdisciplin- 15. Learn the Signs. Act Early(Accessed January 10, 2018, at
ary. Clinicians should strive to provide children with ASD https://www.cdc.gov/ncbddd/actearly/hcp/index.html; 2017.
an interdisciplinary, multi-modal approach that addresses 16. Zwaigenbaum L, Bauman ML, Choueiri R, et al. Early inter-
the individual patient’s deficits, while building on his or vention for children with autism spectrum disorder under 3
her strengths, and prioritizes the patient’s and family’s years of age: recommendations for practice and research.
Pediatrics 2015;136:S60–81.
goals and priorities. While this may be a complicated
17. Koegel LK, Koegel RL, Ashbaugh K, et al. The importance
endeavor, the clinician may focus on evidenced-based of early identification and intervention for children with or at
treatments as a guide for providing the best clinical care. risk for autism spectrum disorders. International journal of
speech-language pathology 2014;16:50–6.
18. Howard JS, Stanislaw H, Green G, et al. Comparison of
References behavior analytic and eclectic early interventions for young
1. Association A.P. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of children with autism after three years. Research in develop-
Mental Disorders. Fifth Edition. Arlington, VA, American mental disabilities 2014;35:3326–44.
Psychiatric Association, 2013. 19. Jacobson JW, Mulick JA, Green G. Cost–benefit estimates
2. Baio J, Wiggins L, Christensen DL, et al. Prevalence of for early intensive behavioral intervention for young children
Autism Spectrum Disorder Among Children Aged 8 Years with autism—general model and single state case. Behav-
—Autism and Developmental Disabilities Monitoring Net- ioral interventions 1998;13:201–26.
work, 11 Sites, United States, 2014. MMWR Surveillance 20. Smith T, Eikeseth S, Klevstrand M, et al. Intensive behav-
Summaries 2018;67:1–23. ioral treatment for preschoolers with severe mental

Curr Probl Pediatr Adolesc Health Care, & &&&& 13


ARTICLE IN PRESS

retardation and pervasive developmental disorder. American 37. Reichow B, Volkmar FR. Social skills interventions for indi-
Journal on Mental Retardation 1997;102:238–49. viduals with autism: Evaluation for evidence-based practices
21. Zachor DA, Ben-Itzchak E, Rabinovich A-L, et al. Change in within a best evidence synthesis framework. Journal of
autism core symptoms with intervention. Research in autism autism and developmental disorders 2010;40:149–66.
spectrum disorders 2007;1:304–17. 38. Wang P., Spillane A. Evidence-based social skills interven-
22. Eldevik S, Hastings RP, Hughes JC, et al. Using participant tions for children with autism: A meta-analysis. Education
data to extend the evidence base for intensive behavioral and Training in Developmental Disabilities 2009:318-342.
intervention for children with autism. American journal on 39. Wong C, Odom SL, Hume KA, et al. Evidence-based practi-
intellectual and developmental disabilities 2010;115:381– ces for children, youth, and young adults with autism spec-
405. trum disorder: A comprehensive review. Journal of Autism
23. Lovaas OI. Behavioral treatment and normal educational and and Developmental Disorders 2015;45:1951–66.
intellectual functioning in young autistic children. Journal of 40. Dawson G, Toth K, Abbott R, et al. Early social attention
consulting and clinical psychology 1987;55:3. impairments in autism: social orienting, joint attention, and
24. McEachin JJ, Smith T, Ivar Lovaas O. Long-term outcome attention to distress. Developmental psychology
for children with autism who received early intensive behav- 2004;40:271.
ioral treatment. American Journal of Mental Retardation 41. Gates JA, Kang E, Lerner MD. Efficacy of group social skills
1993;97:359-359. interventions for youth with autism spectrum disorder: A
25. Sallows GO, Graupner TD. Intensive behavioral treatment systematic review and meta-analysis. Clinical Psychology
for children with autism: Four-year outcome and predic- Review 2017;52:164–81.
tors. American Journal on Mental Retardation 2005;110: 42. Laugeson EA, Frankel F, Gantman A, et al. Evidence-based
417–38. social skills training for adolescents with autism spectrum
26. Virués-Ortega J. Applied behavior analytic intervention for disorders: The UCLA PEERS program. Journal of autism
autism in early childhood: Meta-analysis, meta-regression and developmental disorders 2012;42:1025–36.
and dose–response meta-analysis of multiple outcomes. 43. Wong C, Odom SL, Hume KA, et al. Evidence-based practi-
Clinical psychology review 2010;30:387–99. ces for children, youth, and young adults with Autism Spec-
27. Hartley S, Sikora D, McCoy R. Prevalence and risk factors trum Disorder. Chapel Hill: The University of North
of maladaptive behaviour in young children with autistic dis- Carolina: Frank Porter Graham Child Development Institute,
order. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research Autism Evidence-Based Practice Review Group; 2014.
2008;52:819–29. 44. Reiss S, Levitan GW, Szyszko J. Emotional disturbance and
28. Brosnan J, Healy O. A review of behavioral interventions for mental retardation: diagnostic overshadowing. American
the treatment of aggression in individuals with developmen- journal of mental deficiency 1982.
tal disabilities. Research in developmental disabilities 45. Magnuson KM, Constantino JN. Characterization of depres-
2011;32:437–46. sion in children with autism spectrum disorders. Journal of
29. Baer DM, Wolf MM, Risley TR. Some current dimensions of developmental and behavioral pediatrics: JDBP
applied behavior analysis. Journal of applied behavior anal- 2011;32:332.
ysis 1968;1:91–7. 46. Moskowitz LJ, Rosen T, Lerner MD, et al. Assessment of
30. Cooper J.O., Heron T.E., Heward W.L. Applied behavior anxiety in youth with autism spectrum disorder. Anxiety in
analysis. 2007. Children and Adolescents with Autism Spectrum Disorder:
31. Maurice C.E., Green G.E., Luce S.C. Behavioral intervention Elsevier 2017: 79–104.
for young children with autism: A manual for parents and 47. Magiati I, Ozsivadjian A, Kerns C. Phenomenology and pre-
professionals: Pro-ed; 1996. sentation of anxiety in Autism Spectrum Disorder. Anxiety in
32. Reed DD, Azulay RL. Teaching and behavior support for children and adolescents with autism spectrum disorder
children and adults with autism spectrum disorder: A practi- 2017: 33–54.
tioner’s guide. Functional behavior assessment (FBA) 2011: 48. Kent R, Simonoff E. Prevalence of Anxiety in Autism Spec-
13–21. trum Disorders. Anxiety in Children and Adolescents with
33. Glasberg BA. Functional behavior assessment for people Autism Spectrum Disorder: Evidence-Based Assessment and
with autism: Making sense of seemingly senseless behavior. Treatment 2017: 5.
Woodbine House; 2006. 49. Vasa RA, Carroll LM, Nozzolillo AA, et al. A systematic
34. Gray CA, Garand JD. Social stories: Improving responses of review of treatments for anxiety in youth with autism spec-
students with autism with accurate social information. Focus trum disorders. Journal of autism and developmental disor-
on autistic behavior 1993;8:1–10. ders 2014;44:3215–29.
35. White SW, Keonig K, Scahill L. Social Skills Development 50. Chandrasekhar T, Sikich L. Challenges in the diagnosis and
in Children with Autism Spectrum Disorders: A Review of treatment of depression in autism spectrum disorders across
the Intervention Research. Journal of Autism & Developmen- the lifespan. Dialogues Clin Neurosci 2015;17:219–27.
tal Disorders 2007;37:1858–68. 51. Mayes SD, Calhoun SL, Murray MJ, et al. Anxiety, depres-
36. Otero TL, Schatz RB, Merrill AC, et al. Social skills training sion, and irritability in children with autism relative to other
for youth with autism spectrum disorders. Child and Adoles- neuropsychiatric disorders and typical development.
cent Psychiatric Clinics 2015;24:99–115. Research in Autism Spectrum Disorders 2011;5:474–85.

14 Curr Probl Pediatr Adolesc Health Care, & &&&&


ARTICLE IN PRESS

52. Walkup JT, Albano AM, Piacentini J, et al. Cognitive behav- American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry
ioral therapy, sertraline, or a combination in childhood anxi- 2007;46:1403–13.
ety. New England Journal of Medicine 2008;359:2753–66. 68. McGillivray J, Evert H. Group cognitive behavioural therapy
53. Compton SN, March JS, Brent D, et al. Cognitive-behavioral program shows potential in reducing symptoms of depres-
psychotherapy for anxiety and depressive disorders in chil- sion and stress among young people with ASD. Journal of
dren and adolescents: an evidence-based medicine review. autism and developmental disorders 2014;44:2041–51.
Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent 69. Pahnke J, Lundgren T, Hursti T, et al. Outcomes of an accep-
Psychiatry 2004;43:930–59. tance and commitment therapy-based skills training group
54. Kendall P. Cognitive-behavioral therapies with youth: guid- for students with high-functioning autism spectrum disor-
ing theory, current status, and emerging developments. Jour- der: A quasi-experimental pilot study. Autism 2014;18:
nal of consulting and clinical psychology 1993;61:235–47. 953–64.
55. Vasa RA, Mazurek MO, Mahajan R, et al. Assessment and 70. Spek AA, Van Ham NC, Nyklı́ček I. Mindfulness-based
treatment of anxiety in youth with Autism spectrum disor- therapy in adults with an autism spectrum disorder: a ran-
ders. Pediatrics 2016;137:S115–23. domized controlled trial. Research in developmental disabil-
56. Ung D, Selles R, Small BJ, et al. A systematic review and ities 2013;34:246–53.
meta-analysis of cognitive-behavioral therapy for anxiety in 71. Hughes C, Kaplan L, Bernstein R, et al. Increasing social
youth with high-functioning autism spectrum disorders. interaction skills of secondary school students with autism
Child Psychiatry & Human Development 2015;46:533–47. and/or intellectual disability: A review of interventions.
57. Keehn RHM, Lincoln AJ, Brown MZ, et al. The Coping Cat Research and Practice for Persons with Severe Disabilities
program for children with anxiety and autism spectrum dis- 2012;37:288–307.
order: a pilot randomized controlled trial. Journal of Autism 72. Palmen A, Didden R, Lang R. A systematic review of behav-
and Developmental Disorders 2013;43:57–67. ioral intervention research on adaptive skill building in high-
58. Kendall PC, Hedtke KA. Cognitive-behavioral therapy for functioning young adults with autism spectrum disorder.
anxious children: Therapist manual. Workbook Publishing; Research in Autism Spectrum Disorders 2012;6:602–17.
2006. 73. Odom SL, Thompson JL, Hedges S, et al. Technology-aided
59. Kendall P, Hedtke K. The coping cat program workbook. interventions and instruction for adolescents with autism
Ardmore. PA: Workbook Publishing; 2006. spectrum disorder. Journal of autism and developmental dis-
60. Ehrenreich-May J, Storch EA, Queen AH, et al. An open trial orders 2015;45:3805–19.
of cognitive-behavioral therapy for anxiety disorders in ado- 74. Mandelberg J, Laugeson EA, Cunningham TD, et al. Long-
lescents with autism spectrum disorders. Focus on Autism term treatment outcomes for parent-assisted social skills
and Other Developmental Disabilities 2014;29:145–55. training for adolescents with autism spectrum disorders: The
61. Storch EA, Arnold EB, Lewin AB, et al. The effect of cogni- UCLA PEERS program. Journal of Mental Health Research
tive-behavioral therapy versus treatment as usual for anxiety in Intellectual Disabilities 2014;7:45–73.
in children with autism spectrum disorders: a randomized, 75. Duncan AW, Bishop SL. Understanding the gap between
controlled trial. Journal of the American Academy of Child cognitive abilities and daily living skills in adolescents with
& Adolescent Psychiatry 2013;52:132–42:e132. autism spectrum disorders with average intelligence. Autism
62. Wood JJ, Drahota A, Sze K, et al. Cognitive behavioral ther- 2015;19:64–72.
apy for anxiety in children with autism spectrum disorders: 76. Kanne SM, Gerber AJ, Quirmbach LM, et al. The role of
A randomized, controlled trial. Journal of Child Psychology adaptive behavior in autism spectrum disorders: Implications
and Psychiatry 2009;50:224–34. for functional outcome. Journal of autism and developmental
63. Wood JJ, Ehrenreich-May J, Alessandri M, et al. Cognitive disorders 2011;41:1007–18.
behavioral therapy for early adolescents with autism spec- 77. Duncan A, Ruble LA, Meinzen-Derr J, et al. Preliminary
trum disorders and clinical anxiety: A randomized, con- efficacy of a daily living skills intervention for adolescents
trolled trial. Behavior Therapy 2015;46:7–19. with high-functioning autism spectrum disorder. Autism
64. Reaven J, Blakeley-Smith A, Nichols S, et al. Facing your 2017:1362361317716606.
fears: Group therapy for managing anxiety in children with 78. Daston M, Riehle JE, Rutkowski S. High school transition
high-functioning autism spectrum disorders. Baltimore, MD: that works!: Lessons learned from Project SEARCH: Paul H.
Brookes; 2011. Brookes Publishing Company; 2012.
65. Jennett HK, Hagopian LP. Identifying empirically supported 79. Wehman P, Schall CM, McDonough J, et al. Effects of an
treatments for phobic avoidance in individuals with intellec- employer-based intervention on employment outcomes for
tual disabilities. Behavior Therapy 2008;39:151–61. youth with significant support needs due to autism. Autism
66. Hagopian L.P., Lilly M., Davis T.E. Behavioral Treatments 2017;21:276–90.
for Anxiety in Minimally Verbal Children With ASD. Anxi- 80. Autism. at http://www.asha.org/PRPSpecificTopic.aspx?fol-
ety in Children and Adolescents with Autism Spectrum Dis- derid=8589935303&section=Signs_and_Symptoms.)
order: Evidence-Based Assessment and Treatment 2017:193. 81. Murray DS, Creaghead NA, Manning-Courtney P, et al. The
67. Klein JB, Jacobs RH, Reinecke MA. Cognitive-behavioral relationship between joint attention and language in children
therapy for adolescent depression: a meta-analytic investiga- with autism spectrum disorders. Focus on Autism and Other
tion of changes in effect-size estimates. Journal of the Developmental Disabilities 2008;23:5–14.

Curr Probl Pediatr Adolesc Health Care, & &&&& 15


ARTICLE IN PRESS

82. Whalen C, Schreibman L, Ingersoll B. The collateral effects 98. Krantz PJ, McClannahan LE. Social interaction skills for
of joint attention training on social initiations, positive affect, children with autism: A script-fading procedure for begin-
imitation, and spontaneous speech for young children with ning readers. Journal of applied behavior analysis
autism. Journal of autism and developmental disorders 1998;31:191–202.
2006;36:655–64. 99. MacDuff GS, Krantz PJ, McClannahan LE. Teaching chil-
83. Adamson LB, Bakeman R, Deckner DF, et al. Joint engage- dren with autism to use photographic activity schedules:
ment and the emergence of language in children with autism Maintenance and generalization of complex response chains.
and Down syndrome. Journal of autism and developmental Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis 1993;26:89–97.
disorders 2009;39:84. 100. Charlop-Christy M.H., Kelso S.E. Teaching children with
84. Kasari C, Freeman S, Paparella T. Joint attention and sym- autism conversational speech using a cue card/written script
bolic play in young children with autism: A randomized con- program. Education and Treatment of Children 2003:108-
trolled intervention study. Journal of Child Psychology and 127.
Psychiatry 2006;47:611–20. 101. Mesibov GB, Shea V. The TEACCH program in the era of
85. paul r, Landa R, simmons e. Communication in asperger’s evidence-based practice. Journal of autism and developmen-
syndrome. 2nd Eds ed. New York, NY: The Guilford Press; tal disorders 2010;40:570–9.
2014. 102. Bondy AS, Frost LA. The picture exchange communication
86. Kjelgaard MM, Tager-Flusberg H. An investigation of lan- system. Focus on autistic behavior 1994;9:1–19.
guage impairment in autism: Implications for genetic sub- 103. Bopp KD, Brown KE, Mirenda P. Speech-language patholo-
groups. Language and cognitive processes 2001;16:287– gists’ roles in the delivery of positive behavior support for
308. individuals with developmental disabilities. American Jour-
87. Tager-Flusberg H, Kasari C. Minimally verbal school-aged nal of Speech-Language Pathology 2004;13:5–19.
children with autism spectrum disorder: the neglected end of 104. Harrell LG, Kamps D, Kravits T. The effects of peer net-
the spectrum. Autism Research 2013;6:468–78. works on social—communicative behaviors for students
88. Howlin P, Savage S, Moss P, et al. Cognitive and language with autism. Focus on Autism and Other Developmental Dis-
skills in adults with autism: a 40-year follow-up. Journal of abilities 1997;12:241–56.
Child Psychology and Psychiatry 2014;55:49–58. 105. Millar D. Effects of AAC on the natural speech development
89. Kasari C, Paparella T, Freeman S, et al. Language outcome of individuals with autism spectrum disorders. Autism Spec-
in autism: randomized comparison of joint attention and play trum Disorders and AAC Baltimore: Paul H Brookes 2009.
interventions. Journal of consulting and clinical psychology 106. Schlosser RW, Wendt O. Effects of augmentative and alter-
2008;76:125. native communication intervention on speech production in
90. Howlin PA. The effectiveness of operant language training children with autism: A systematic review. American Jour-
with autistic children. Journal of Autism and Developmental nal of Speech-Language Pathology 2008;17:212–30.
Disorders 1981;11:89–105. 107. Ganz JB. AAC interventions for individuals with autism
91. Coe D, Matson J, Fee V, et al. Training nonverbal and verbal spectrum disorders: State of the science and future research
play skills to mentally retarded and autistic children. Journal directions. Augmentative and Alternative Communication
of autism and developmental disorders 1990;20:177–87. 2015;31:203–14.
92. Lafasakis M, Sturmey P. Training parent implementation of 108. Cincinnati Children’s Hospital Medical Center: Evidence-
discrete-trial teaching: Effects on generalization of parent based clinical care guideline for Occupational Therapy Inter-
teaching and child correct responding. Journal of applied ventions for Children and Youth with Autism Spectrum Dis-
behavior analysis 2007;40:685–9. order (ASD). at http://www.cincinnatichildrens.org/svc/
93. Nuzzolo-Gomez R, Leonard MA, Ortiz E, et al. Teaching alpha/h/health-policy/ev-based/title.htm.)
children with autism to prefer books or toys over stereotypy 109. Ayres j. Sensory Integration and the child. Los Angeles:
or passivity. Journal of Positive Behavior Interventions Western Psychological Services; 1979.
2002;4:80–7. 110. Miller L.J., Anzalone M.E., Lane S.J., et al. Concept evolu-
94. Jones EA, Carr EG, Feeley KM. Multiple effects of joint tion in sensory integration: A proposed nosology for diagno-
attention intervention for children with autism. Behavior sis. 2007.
Modification 2006;30:782–834. 111. Parham LD, Roley SS, May-Benson TA, et al. Development
95. Schreibman LE. The science and fiction of autism. Harvard of a fidelity measure for research on the effectiveness of the
University Press; 2005. Ayres Sensory Integration intervention. American Journal of
96. Schreibman L, Dawson G, Stahmer AC, et al. Naturalistic Occupational Therapy 2011;65:133–42.
developmental behavioral interventions: Empirically vali- 112. Watling R, Hauer S. Effectiveness of Ayres Sensory Integra-
dated treatments for autism spectrum disorder. Journal of tion and sensory-based interventions for people with autism
Autism and Developmental Disorders 2015;45:2411–28. spectrum disorder: A systematic review. American Journal of
97. Carter AS, Messinger DS, Stone WL, et al. A randomized Occupational Therapy 2015;69:6905180030p6905180031-
controlled trial of Hanen’s ‘More Than Words’ in toddlers 6905180030p6905180012.
with early autism symptoms. Journal of Child Psychology 113. Fournier KA, Hass CJ, Naik SK, et al. Motor coordination in
and Psychiatry 2011;52:741–52. autism spectrum disorders: a synthesis and meta-analysis.

16 Curr Probl Pediatr Adolesc Health Care, & &&&&


ARTICLE IN PRESS

Journal of autism and developmental disorders 115. Lloyd M, MacDonald M, Lord C. Motor skills of toddlers
2010;40:1227–40. with autism spectrum disorders. Autism 2011;17:133–46.
114. Green D, Charman T, Pickles A, et al. Impairment in move- 116. Jensen JL. The puzzles of motor development: how the study
ment skills of children with autistic spectrum disorders. Devel- of developmental biomechanics contributes to the puzzle sol-
opmental Medicine & Child Neurology 2009;51:311–6. utions. Infant and Child Development 2005;14:501–11.

Curr Probl Pediatr Adolesc Health Care, & &&&& 17

Potrebbero piacerti anche