Sei sulla pagina 1di 14

Contemporary Clinical Trials 62 (2017) 77–90

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Contemporary Clinical Trials


journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/conclintrial

Community-based participatory research to design a faith-enhanced MARK


diabetes prevention program: The Better Me Within randomized trial
Heather Kitzmana,⁎, Leilani Dodgenb, Abdullah Mamunb, J. Lee Slaterc, George Kingd,
Donna Slaterc, Alene Kingd, Surendra Mandapatib, Mark DeHavene
a
Baylor Scott & White Health and Wellness Center, Baylor Scott & White Health, 4500 Spring Ave, Dallas, TX 75210, United States
b
School of Public Health, University of North Texas Health Science Center, 3500 Camp Bowie Blvd, Fort Worth, TX 76107, United States
c
Better Me Within Community Advisory Board, New Millennium Bible Fellowship Praise Center, 9026 Elam Rd, Dallas, TX 75217, United States
d
Better Me Within Community Advisory Board, Cities of Refuge Church, 4801 Dolphin Rd, Dallas, TX 75223, United States
e
Department of Public Health Science, University of North Carolina, 9201 University City Blvd, Charlotte, NC 28223, United States

A B S T R A C T

Reducing obesity positively impacts diabetes and cardiovascular risk; however, evidence-based lifestyle pro-
grams, such as the diabetes prevention program (DPP), show reduced effectiveness in African American (AA)
women. In addition to an attenuated response to lifestyle programs, AA women also demonstrate high rates of
obesity, diabetes, and cardiovascular disease. To address these disparities, enhancements to evidence-based
lifestyle programs for AA women need to be developed and evaluated with culturally relevant and rigorous study
designs. This study describes a community-based participatory research (CBPR) approach to design a novel faith-
enhancement to the DPP for AA women. A long-standing CBPR partnership designed the faith-enhancement from
focus group data (N = 64 AA adults) integrating five components: a brief pastor led sermon, memory verse, in
class or take-home faith activity, promises to remember, and scripture and prayer integrated into participant
curriculum and facilitator materials. The faith components were specifically linked to weekly DPP learning
objectives to strategically emphasize behavioral skills with religious principles. Using a CBPR approach, the
Better Me Within trial was able to enroll 12 churches, screen 333 AA women, and randomize 221
(Mage = 48.8 ± 11.2; MBMI = 36.7 ± 8.4; 52% technical or high school) after collection of objective eligibility
measures. A prospective, randomized, nested by church, design will be used to evaluate the faith-enhanced DPP
as compared to a standard DPP on weight, diabetes and cardiovascular risk, over a 16-week intervention and 10-
month follow up. This study will provide essential data to guide enhancements to evidence-based lifestyle
programs for AA women who are at high risk for chronic disease.

1. Background programs resulted in greater weight loss than faith-based programs that
integrated faith elements, indicating that additional research is needed
Reducing obesity is strongly associated with reductions in diabetes to identify best practices [9]. Further, a review of DPP program trans-
and cardiovascular risk [1]. Modest weight loss in the diabetes pre- lations for AA found reduced effectiveness; approximately half of the
vention program (DPP) trial was associated with a 58% reduction in expected weight loss from the original study [3]. Taken together, more
diabetes risk [2]; however, the DPP has shown reduced effectiveness in research is needed to develop effective enhancements to health pro-
African American (AA) populations [3,4] that also experience higher grams for AA [9,10].
rates of obesity [5], diabetes [6], and hypertension [7,8] compared to One approach that may improve the effectiveness of health pro-
Caucasians. Faith based organizations (FBO), such as churches, have grams for AA is community-based participatory research (CBPR). CBPR
been extensively involved in the delivery of health programs in AA works to build an equitable partnership between the community, and
communities. Programs have been implemented through faith-placed, research team, with a long-term commitment to develop the relation-
secular programs held at an FBO, and faith-based, which integrates ship through co-learning leading to mutual trust and respect [11]. In
faith-based activities such as scripture into health programming [9]. A the context of CBPR, community members and leaders work together on
large review of FBO weight loss studies in AA found that faith-placed all aspects of the research study leading to quality research, community


Corresponding author.
E-mail address: heather.kitzmanulrich@bswhealth.org (H. Kitzman).

http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cct.2017.08.003
Received 3 February 2017; Received in revised form 2 August 2017; Accepted 7 August 2017
Available online 12 August 2017
1551-7144/ © 2017 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
H. Kitzman et al. Contemporary Clinical Trials 62 (2017) 77–90

empowerment, and sustainable programs with lower rates of attrition and health, 2) Attitudes, values and motivations for weight manage-
and synergy over time [12,13]. ment, 3) Hurdles to healthy weight, and 4) Elements for successful
Psychosocial and physiological factors can also influence the effec- weight loss. Specific strategies from these themes included 1) focus on
tiveness of health programs. For example, allostatic load, a composite of diabetes and chronic disease prevention, 2) address food habits and
several biological measures representing dysregulation due to pro- motivation, 3) pastor involvement in the program was critical but
longed exposure to stress, has been shown to increase the “wear and needed to be realistic from a time perspective, and 4) emphasize con-
tear” on the body [14], with data showing allostatic load is higher in AA nections between faith and health. These findings were presented to the
as compared to White females [14,15]. Further, the influence of sex CAB and used to develop the faith-enhanced weight management pro-
hormones such as estradiol on stress responses is not fully understood gram for the Better Me Within trial.
and could alter responses to intervention [16–18]. The reduced effec-
tiveness of diabetes prevention programs in AA may be multifactorial
requiring a systems approach to implementation and evaluation. 2.3. Study design
The Better Me Within (BMW) trial aims to address the lack of ef-
fectiveness of diabetes prevention programs in AA females by in- The BMW trial is a prospective randomized community-based,
tegrating a CBPR approach to design and implement a randomized trial nested design. Churches were randomized to either a standard diabetes
of a faith-enhanced diabetes prevention program in the FBO setting. prevention program (faith-placed) or a faith-enhanced diabetes pre-
The design allows for comparison of faith-based as compared to faith- vention program (faith-based) over 3 years, starting in January of 2014,
placed approaches along with mediators and moderators of outcomes. and completing in December of 2016. Each year, 4 churches were re-
This paper describes study development, methodology, recruitment, cruited and randomized to treatment condition, for a total of 12 chur-
and baseline demographics of the study sample. ches. Small churches were paired during the randomization process
within each cohort to ensure one received the standard DPP, and the
2. Methods other the faith-enhanced DPP, as church size can influence study im-
plementation. A limitation of this approach is church size was only
2.1. Study aims accounted for at the cohort level. Baseline data collection was com-
pleted in July of 2016. The Institutional Review Board at The University
The primary aim of the BMW trial is to evaluate the impact of a of North Texas Health Science Center approved the study. Informed
CBPR developed faith-enhanced diabetes prevention program (e.g., consent was collected from each study participant prior to enrollment.
faith-based) as compared to a standard diabetes prevention program
(e.g., faith-placed) on weight in AA overweight females at 16-weeks 2.4. Church recruitment
post-intervention, and at 10-month follow-up. Secondary aims include
evaluating changes in diabetes risk (hemoglobin A1c and fasting glu- The CBPR partnership recruited churches from October of 2013 to
cose), cardiovascular disease risk (blood pressure, LDL and HDL cho- February of 2016. Church inclusion criteria included 1) church size
lesterol), and health behaviors (physical activity and diet) at 16-weeks > 100 members, 2) primarily African American parishioners, 3) will-
between the faith-enhanced DPP and standard DPP conditions, and how ingness of pastor or senior leadership to be involved in program de-
psychosocial factors such as self-efficacy and spiritual health locus of livery, 4) church member willing to serve as a facilitator (e.g., health
control, and physiological factors such as cortisol and estrogen, influ- coach), and 5) space to conduct weekly group meetings. Pastors and
ence changes in primary and secondary outcomes. first ladies from the CAB led initial recruitment efforts by contacting
churches within their social and professional networks. Once a church
2.2. Study development demonstrated interest, the project director and CAB partner would meet
with church leadership to provide an overview of the program. During
The CBPR partnership that guided the development and im- this meeting the purpose of the BMW trial was described as well as the
plementation of the BMW trial had been in existence for approximately roles and responsibilities of the church and study program. A commit-
10 years. The partnership included researchers, individuals trained in ment by the pastor reserved a spot in the study. The pastor then selected
public health, and a Community Advisory Board (CAB) of several pas- a woman or women from the congregation to serve as the health coach
tors and first ladies from the Southern Sector of Dallas, TX. Based on the (es), and coach training was scheduled. This was repeated each year
findings of a large NIH funded study (GoodNEWS trial) to improve until a total of 12 churches were enrolled in the study.
cardiovascular risk guided by this CBPR partnership [19,20], it was
determined that weight management was the next community health
priority to address. Formative work was conducted through focus 2.5. Participant recruitment
groups to evaluate AA women's needs, preferences, and barriers to
weight management, along with preferences and opinions of church Pastors and health coaches received flyers and program factsheets to
leaders including pastors, first ladies, and pastor associates. distribute at church events and to interested church members.
Seven focus groups with 64 AA adults including 53 female con- Participants were pre-screened by telephone or at face-to-face events by
gregation members (mean age = 44.0 (SD = 11.3) years; 95% African study staff, and were then invited to a baseline measurement event at
American) from six congregations, and 7 pastors and 4 first ladies their corresponding church. Informed consent was collected at baseline
(mean age = 56.3 (SD = 13.6) years; 100% African American) were measurement events along with objective measures of eligibility (e.g.,
conducted in the Southern Sector of Dallas, TX, an urban, low-income, weight, height, hemoglobin A1c). Participant eligibility requirements
primarily ethnic minority community. The purpose of the focus groups included 1) identify as AA, 2) female, 3) 18 years of age or older, 4)
was to determine the perspectives of church leaders and church mem- parishioner at enrolled church, 5) overweight or obese (BMI ≥ 25), and
bers on the relationship between faith and health, as well as, weight 6) willingness to participate in a 10-month study. Exclusion criteria
loss and maintaining a healthy lifestyle, to guide the development of a included 1) currently attending a weight loss program, 2) diagnosed
faith-enhanced lifestyle program. Gathering input directly from com- diabetes, 3) medical condition that interfered with physical activity or
munity members, in addition to community leaders, has been shown to dietary changes, and 4) plans to move in the next 10 months.
improve the outcomes of behavioral interventions [10]. Using directed Individuals who were not eligible to participate were invited to attend
content analysis [21] to group participant statements, the following the sessions if room was available to meet the preferences of the CBPR
broad categories were identified: 1) Connections between faith beliefs partnership.

78
H. Kitzman et al. Contemporary Clinical Trials 62 (2017) 77–90

2.6. Interventions expectations for church, health coaches and university staff. Specific
training components were tailored based on group assignment. The S-
2.6.1. Faith enhanced diabetes prevention program (Faith-DPP) DPP Pastors reviewed the DPP curriculum and discussed how to support
The faith-enhanced curriculum was faith-based and developed using the program at their church. The Faith-DPP pastors were given an
CBPR approaches where focus group findings provided community overview of the faith components that were added to the DPP, received
level input that was then used by the BMW CAB to develop the faith- instructions and samples of the sermonettes and lesson plans.
enhanced curriculum. The research team provided edits to the curri-
culum after it was developed by the BMW CAB. The Faith-DPP condi-
tion included delivery of the diabetes prevention program (DPP), an 2.7. Measures
evidence-based lifestyle enhancement program from the Centers for
Disease Control that has been evaluated in large randomized controlled Participants attended measurement events at their respective
trials [2,22]. The group intervention was delivered by one to two churches where food was offered after completion of fasting measures,
trained peers from the church and consisted of 16 weekly group celebratory music was played, church staff were present, and a small
meetings followed by 6 bi-monthly or monthly maintenance sessions. monetary incentive was provided ($20 gift card at baseline and 16-
Each church received approximately 10 months of programming that weeks, $40 gift card at 10-month follow-up). All measurement devices
included a group intervention, participant and facilitator handouts, and and tools were transported by study staff to church sites. Measures were
supplies. Participants completed a private weigh-in with their facil- collected by trained and blinded research staff that attended a two hour
itator on a medical grade digital scale followed by an hour and a half training prior to measurement events for instruction and hands-on
faith-enhanced DPP group intervention. practice. Measures were conducted at baseline, 16 weeks post-inter-
The faith enhanced curriculum included five strategies: 1) a mini vention, and a limited battery at 10 month follow-up (see Table 2).
sermon (~ 15 min in length) delivered by a pastor (head pastors were Reliability and validity of primary and secondary measures are de-
required to deliver at least one per month), first lady, or church leader scribed in Table 2. Participants completed standard surveys on demo-
(pastor associate, deacon, elder, etc.), 2) a memory verse, 3) in class or graphic, medical history, medication use (type, and dose), last two
take-home faith activity (application of faith principles), 4) promises to menstrual cycles, and menopausal status. The following are descrip-
remember, and 5) scripture and prayer integrated into participant tions of primary and secondary measures expected to change due to the
curriculum and facilitator materials. These five faith enhancements DPP intervention.
were developed by the CAB to enhance the DPP's weekly learning ob-
jectives, which resulted in faith components specifically linked to each Anthropometrics. Weight (primary measure) (lbs) was collected
week of DPP content. The DPP learning objectives, faith-enhanced with a digital scale in light clothing with shoes removed. Height
learning objectives and content are described in Table 1. (inches) was collected with a stadiometer. Weight and height were
collected twice and the average was computed. BMI (weight/
2.6.2. Standard diabetes prevention program (S-DPP) (height2) × 703) was calculated from the averaged height and
The S-DPP condition was faith-placed, a secular program (the DPP) weight data. Waist circumference was taken at the top of the pelvis
held at an FBO. This condition received the same diabetes prevention (e.g., above the uppermost lateral border of the right ilium) with a
program (DPP) as the Faith-DPP, but did not receive any faith en- measuring tape twice and averaged.
hancements or pastor involvement. Weekly learning objectives are Diabetes risk. Risk for diabetes was measured with a fasting blood
shown in Table 1. sample obtained by finger stick. Fasting glucose was measured with
the Cholestech LDX system, and glycated hemoglobin A1C was
2.6.3. Coach support measured with Bayer A1cNow + Multi-Test A1c System.
In both interventions, health coaches participated in weekly com- Cardiovascular risk. Markers of cardiovascular risk were measured
munications with a research staff member via email or conference call with a fasting blood sample obtained by finger stick with the
depending on need. Weekly communication sessions reviewed: 1) cur- Cholestech LDX system and included low-density lipoprotein cho-
riculum and supplies needed, 2) participant progress based on weekly lesterol (LDL), high-density lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL), total
weights, attendance, and receipt of food logs, and 3) participants ex- cholesterol, and triglycerides. Blood pressure was collected with an
periencing difficulties or barriers. Coaches were reminded to stay in automated blood pressure device following a seated 5 min rest in a
communication with participants and complete make-up sessions with quiet area. Two measurements were taken following Eighth Joint
absent participants through verbal, text, and email reminders. National Committee [23] protocols and averaged.
Dietary patterns. Diet was measured with the Lower Mississippi
2.6.4. Training Delta Nutrition Intervention Research Initiative (Delta NIRI) food
One research staff member was trained by the Diabetes Training and frequency questionnaire, developed initially for the Jackson Heart
Technical Assistance Center (DTTAC) at Emory University. This trained Study, that measures typical dietary intake patterns including en-
individual created a coach training for church members who facilitated ergy intake (kcals), fat (saturated and unsaturated) grams, sugar,
the group intervention. The training included an overview of the ori- carbohydrates, protein, fiber, and fruits and vegetables [24,25]. The
ginal DPP trial, review of 16 CORE sessions, facilitator roles and re- Delta NIRI was developed specifically for AA populations, and has
sponsibilities, facilitation skills, DPP core elements, food tracking 101, strong correlations with 24-h dietary recalls, but is less expensive to
process evaluations, classroom logistics, troubleshooting and warning administer [24]. Data is scanned and analyzed by Northeastern
signs of dropout, identifying the circumstances and environment of University's Dietary Assessment Center.
participants struggling with pre-diabetes or overweight/obesity, hands- Physical Activity. Physical activity was measured by self-report with
on practice with food tracking, role playing and facilitating a lesson. the Past Week Modifiable Physical Activity Questionnaire [26].
Training was 12 h long and was conducted over 2–3 sessions depending Objective physical activity was collected over a week time period
on the church's schedule. Facilitators also received a booster training using the YAMAX digi-walker.
session (2–4 h) prior to the Maintenance phase of the program. All fa-
cilitators attended the training or a make-up session before im- Additional measures including physiological and psychosocial
plementation. variables hypothesized to mediate the effect of the intervention on
Pastors also attended one training module that provided an over- primary and secondary outcomes were collected, and are described
view of the program and curriculum, research principles, and below.

79
Table 1
Faith-DPP and standard DPP curriculum.

Standard DPP curriculum learning Faith learning objectives Mini-sermon summary Memory verse Faith activity/homework Promises to remember Scripture references faith
objectives handout & devotional
H. Kitzman et al.

Week 1: Welcome to the National DPP We are created by God. God is The purpose for a Better Me Within Psalm 119:73 Create a vision board Ephesians 3:20 Acts 27:34
the Creator; therefore, He is the Proverbs 3:5–10 Deuteronomy 32: 47
- Describe purpose and benefits sustainer. We are sustained by - Define biblical health, how to set a Full and abundant life begin Ecclesiastes 3:11
- Describe session content God's word vision by looking to God and with seeking God's plan for our Genesis 43:28
- Weight loss and physical activity scripture lives Isaiah 58:8
goals established by the National DPP - Describes health principles that Developing a vision for healthy Jeremiah 30:17; 33:6
- Develop individual weight loss and lead to improved physical health living requires preparation Proverbs 3: 1–2,5–10;
physical activity goals and improved spiritual health through spending time in God's 4:22; 12:18; 13:17; 29:18
- Importance of self-monitoring - Biblical health is a state of physical Word and seeking obedience Psalm 42:11; 43:5; 67:2;
and spiritual well-being We have purpose because we 119:73
- Possible through faith in Jesus know Christ. Live in that 1 Peter 1:2
Christ purpose through seeking and 2 Samuel 20:9
obeying God's Word
Week 2: Be a fat & calorie detective The plan for A Better Me Within The plan for a better me within Exodus 15:26 Matching activity to identify Ephesians 3:20 1 Corinthians 10:31
begins with our steps being scriptures about actions/behaviors Romans 9:33b 2 Corinthians 7:1
- Self-monitor weight ordered by God - God's plan for how to use our that lead to good health Become a conscience calorie Deuteronomy 6:24;
- Document weight at home and at each Accepting God as the source of bodies discussing biblical During the week: meditate/pray that counter and stay within fat 14:1–3
session our wisdom, knowledge and principles for good physical, God will help you to incorporate the gram budget Ecclesiastes 12:13
- Relationship between fat and calories strength mental, and spiritual health and principles in the faith activity in your “With God all things are Exodus 15:26; 23:25
- Reasons and basic principles of self- Receiving Biblical instruction for the importance of understanding life possible” (Mark 10:27) Ezekiel 11:18–19
monitoring fat grams/cal good health how being obedient to God's Jesus is ready to break the Galatians 6:7
- Identify personal fat gram goals Following the Biblical principles commands can benefit our health shackles that bind us (John Genesis 1:29, 2:16, 3:18
- Practice using the Fat and calorie of good health - Specific scriptures highlighting 1:12) Hebrews 4:13
counter health are included Christ is for our joy “These Isaiah 55:2

80
- Record daily fat grams - God designed our body as a finely things have I spoken unto you … James 4:17
- Calculate fat, calories, & serving sizes tuned, resilient instrument that can that your joy might be full” (John John 14:15; 15:11
from nutrition labels endure constant use and even 15:11) 1 John 2:5; 3:3
pain/trauma, but it is fragile 3 John 1:2
Proverbs 3:1–2,8
Psalm 84:11
Romans 4:12
Week 3: Reducing fat and calories Remember God has placed high Building a Queenly body fit for The Corinthian List 10 positive characteristics or Knowledge is power for 1 Corinthians 6:19–20
value on each of us. Your body is King qualities (individually or small knowing what's best for me 3 John 1:2
- Weigh and measure foods a temple you have received from group) Plan what we eat to develop 1 Peter 3:3–4
- Estimate the fat and calories of God. Therefore honor God with - Biblically motivate ourselves to eat Homework: meditate on meaning of discipline within me Proverbs 14:1
common foods your bodies by first less fat and fewer calories “body to be a temple of the living Make better choices with self- Proverbs 23:7
- Describe three ways to eat less fat and acknowledging and then - Honor the body because it is a God” motivation for me
fewer calories embracing your positive temple of Holy Spirit (being
- Create a plan to eat less fat the characteristics and qualities mindful to measure food - Impact on your life?
following week accurately, and watch portion - Review positive characteristics
sizes) How can these propel your journey in
- Physical and spiritual are the BMW program?
connected so do not neglect one for
the other
- Educate yourself to know what is
best for body and spirit (practice
discipline in tracking fat
grams & spiritual health)
- Develop a plan for success (use
technology or resources to assist
you in monitoring your food
intake)
(continued on next page)
Contemporary Clinical Trials 62 (2017) 77–90
Table 1 (continued)

Standard DPP curriculum learning Faith learning objectives Mini-sermon summary Memory verse Faith activity/homework Promises to remember Scripture references faith
objectives handout & devotional
H. Kitzman et al.

Week 4: Healthy eating God has given us free will. He has Replace eating the spiritually fat for Genesis 1:29 Word Search to identify Exodus Knowledge Is power for 1 Corinthians 6:19–20
prepared for us scriptural eating the spiritually lean 23:25 “I will take sickness away from knowing what's best for me Exodus 23:25
- Health benefits of eating less fat and solutions to guide us through among you” Making wise choices develop Genesis 1:29
fewer calories challenges and questions - Bible can motivate us to eat During the week: what are some discipline within me 3 John 1:2
- MyPlate food healthy changes you have been able to make Knowing I′m never alone is Leviticus 7:23–24
guide & recommendations - Healthy eating is determined both in BMW with the help of God? self-motivation for me Matthew 4:4
- Compare/contrast guidelines with by what we eat and how we eat What of your unwise choices would 1 Peter 3:3–4
current eating habits - By incorporating plant-based foods you be willing to trade for a healthier Proverbs 23:7
- List ways to replace high-fat & high- and avoiding excess fat our choice?
calorie with low-fat & low-calorie physical health improves
foods - Our spiritual health improves by
- Importance of whole grains, feeding our spirit
vegetables, fruits, within fat gram - Matthew 4:4 “Man shall not live by
goals bread alone, but by every word
- Eat foods from all groups that comes from the mouth of God
- Eat a variety of foods
- Eat a balanced diet
Week 5: Move those muscles Believers must live out the The provision for the Better Me Within I Corinthians Find a partner and pray for each Start moving Acts 17:28
command to glorify God in our 6:19–20 other to be victorious as you begin Acts 17:28 “For in Him, we live 1 Corinthians 6:19–20
- Establish physical activity goal bodies and in our spirits - How to start treating your body the physical activity component of and move and have our being” John 6:63
- Importance of physical activity goal like God's temple through BMW. Helpful scriptures (Matthew Start training Matthew 26:41
- Describe current level of physical remembering the Holy Spirit 26:41, John 6:63, Romans 8:26) I Timothy 4:7–8 “Have nothing Proverbs 23:1–2, 19–21,
activity dwells in you Homework: Write down names of to do with godless myths and 29–32
- Name ways already physically active - Exercising wisdom in making group members & commit to pray for old wives' tales; rather train Romans 8:26
- Develop personal plans for physical decisions about food, training your each other this week yourself to be godly. For 1 Timothy 4:7–8

81
activity for the next week body physically and gaining in physical training is of some
godliness value, but godliness has value
- Trust God's promise that godliness for all things, holding promise
is profitable now and forever for both the present life and the
life to come”
Week 6: Being active: a way of life God is faithful to provide all The promises for a Better Me Within Isaiah 40:31 Get in groups of 2–3 and pray for Review the promises of Deuteronomy 8:18; 28:6,8
things to persevere in physical - Summarizes many of the promises each other to be victorious in blessing, abundance, health Isaiah 26:3; 40:31;58:8
- Graph daily physical activity activity in the bible that can help to physical activity this week and peace from the mini- Jeremiah 29:11; 30:17
- Describe two ways to find time to be transform our health sermon (worksheet) John 1:16; 14:27; 16:33
active - One of the titles of God is Jehovah 3 John 2
- Define “lifestyle activity” Jireh, The Lord My Provider Malachi 3:10
- How to prevent injury - By focusing on promises of Numbers 6:26
- Develop an activity plan for the blessing, abundance, health and Proverbs 10:22; 28:20
coming week peace listed we can battle the Psalm 4:8; 31:19; 34:19;
weight of daily life (defeat, 35:28;102: 2–3; 103:2–3
poverty, despair, sickness
hopelessness, etc.), and
achieve & sustain the goals we set
for health (being active and eating
well)
(continued on next page)
Contemporary Clinical Trials 62 (2017) 77–90
Table 1 (continued)

Standard DPP curriculum learning Faith learning objectives Mini-sermon summary Memory verse Faith activity/homework Promises to remember Scripture references faith
objectives handout & devotional
H. Kitzman et al.

Week 7: Tip the Calorie Balance Imbalanced means out of Balance Provides Purposeful Living Ecclesiastes Illustration activity from health Knowledge is power for 1 Corinthians 15:58
proportion, unstable, instable, 10:17 coach with discussion knowing what's best for me Daniel 10:3
- Define calorie balance disturbed, unhinged. God has - How to biblically motivate Plan what we eat to develop Ecclesiastes 10:17
- Explain how eating and being active purpose for all things to balance ourselves to tip the calorie balance discipline within me Philippians 3:19
are related to calorie balance at a proper time. We must submit A few ways to help us identify balance Make better choices with self- Proverbs 23:1–31
- Relationship between calorie to the balance God has for us in our spiritual life and live healthy motivation for me Psalm 46:1
balance & weight loss because when we choose our are: Feast at the proper time 1 Samuel 26:23
- Describe progress as it relates to own direction, life becomes (Ecclesiastes 10:17), refrain from
calorie balance imbalanced and unbalanced indulging daily (Daniel 10:3), and
- Develop an activity plan for the exercise wisdom considering your food
coming week carefully (Proverbs 23:1–31)
Week 8: Take charge of what's around you Revealing is revelation Develop the good within you, in order James 4:7–8 Participant matching activity led by Knowledge is power for 2 Corinthians 5:17
to control what is around you the coach to help participants find knowing what's best for me James 4:7–8
- Recognize positive and negative cues commonality with one another Plan what we eat to develop 1 John 3:16
- Change negative food and activity - How to be “like-minded” with discipline within me Mark 13:13
cues to positive cues Jesus to enable us to take charge of Make better choices with self- Philippians 2:5
- Add positive cues for activity and what's around us motivation for me Proverbs 17:17
eliminate cues for inactivity - Changing your Attitude (Mindset)-
- Develop a plan for removing one become aware of the many factors
problem food cue for the coming week that influence our behavior related
to eating and activity (Philippians
2:5)
- Changing your Affiliation
(Environment)-identify and change
negative food and activity cues into

82
positive cues (2 Corinthians 5:17)
- Changing your Acquaintance
(Authority) by adding positive cues
for activity (James 4:7–8)
Week 9: Problem solving Dependence upon God and the Problems are opportunities waiting to James 1:5 Journal how God is helping you Remember these scriptures James 1:2–5
scriptures is key to learning the happen problem solve: when you face problems- John 16:33
- List and describe five steps to problem process of problem solving which Step 1: Be honest & specific in written Matthew 10:24 and Romans Matthew 11:28
solving aids is the desirable outcome of a account of problem (Proverbs 12:17) 8:17–18 Proverbs 3:4–6; 18:13, 15,
- Apply five problem solving steps to Better Me Within - How to view problems and create Step 2: Brainstorm your options; When we are in a difficult 17
resolve a problem with eating less fat solutions through applying our depend on God (Proverbs 3:4–6) place, recall to mind how God Psalm 145:14
and fewer calories or being more faith Step 3: Pick 1 option to try; ask God has delivered you before Romans 8:28
active - Scripture makes it clear that there to instruct you. (James 1:5–8) Jesus is sufficient for 2 Thessalonians 1:5
will be problems and suffering in Step 4: Make a plan (Jeremiah everything, everybody, and in
our lives 32:18b-19) every circumstance
- Several steps are outlined to assist Step 5: Try It; Have faith God will not
with problem solving including: let you fail. (Romans 8:28)
get the facts (Proverbs 18:13), be
open to new ideas (Proverbs
18:15); hear all sides (Proverbs
18:17)
(continued on next page)
Contemporary Clinical Trials 62 (2017) 77–90
Table 1 (continued)

Standard DPP curriculum learning Faith learning objectives Mini-sermon summary Memory verse Faith activity/homework Promises to remember Scripture references faith
objectives handout & devotional
H. Kitzman et al.

Week 10: Healthy eating out We are reduced to choice makers. What would Jesus eat 1 Corinthians Discussion questions As our Lord did, always 1 Corinthians 3:16–17;
Choose you this day, which 6:12 How will you appropriate God's remember to respond rather 6:12,19–20; 9:27; 10:31
- List and describe the four keys for appetite you will satisfy? - Principles of eating from the Bible Word to free you from your former than react to life. The more we Deuteronomy 6:24
healthy eating out and the availability of certain foods way of thinking about eating out? practice responding the more Ecclesiastes 2:22–23;
- Give examples of how to apply these during biblical times What changes are you willing to likely it is to become a life 3:13; 5:12; 10:17
keys at restaurants participants go to - The possible diet of Jesus based on make to do this? principle Exodus 20:9.10; 23:25
regularly his period of life is discussed as Memorize one of the verses presented Let your choices be guided by Genesis 1:29; 2:16; 3:18
- Make an appropriate meal selection well as the importance of health in in this lesson. Before you go out to the Holy Spirit Isaiah 52:11; 55:2
from a restaurant menu scripture eat, pray the scripture, asking God to Reliance upon God's Word 3 John 1:2
- Demonstrate how to ask for a - Suggestions are described to plan strengthen you as you go out to eat enables you to resist temptation Luke 21:34
substitute item using assertive for meals and eating out and follow in obedience Matthew 5:23–24
language and a polite tone of voice When facing temptation, we Proverbs 14:30; 17:22;
always have a choice and God 23:2,7
always provides a way of Psalm 84:11; 127:2
escape
Week 11: Talk back to negative thoughts Talk BACK! … to the negative With christ all things are possible for Psalm 61:1–2 List 1 thing in your journal/notes I can do all things through Mark 5:8
me that is a habitual negative thought. Christ who strengthens me Philippians 4:13
- Give examples of negative thoughts Look at it carefully and prepare a Calls those things which do not Psalm 61:1–2
that interfere with losing weight and - How to recognize and fight response for it and say it out loud exist as though they did Romans 4:17; 7:18–23
being more physically active negative thoughts Take time in class to share your The most powerful antidote for
- Describe how to stop negative - Negative thoughts can be habitual negative thoughts with the group, negative thoughts is to stop
thoughts and talk back to them with - Keys to changing negative thoughts and help one another with them mid-sentence and counter
positive thoughts are to remember truth through encouraging words to battle the them with positive thoughts
- Practice 1) stopping negative scripture “I can do all things negative thought and prayer
thoughts and 2) talking back to through Christ” (Philippians 4:13),

83
negative thoughts with positive ones counter them with positive
thoughts (Romans 4:17), and ask
for help from Jesus through prayer;
he can help in our time of need
(Psalm 61:1–2)
Week 12: Slippery slope of lifestyle Slips happen … take time to I′ve fallen down and I can get up! Proverbs Try to build a house of cards; discuss Slips are opportunities to learn Philippians 4:12–13
change learn from them 24:16a this activity with the health coach When you slip don't give up Proverbs 24:16
- How to recover after a slip and apply it to slips in life Slipping is natural, normal and
- Describe their current progress - When you slip there is hope and Find passages in scripture that can usual…learn from it, re-focus
toward defined goals you can receive help from God to encourage you when a slip occurs. and move on
- Describe common causes for slipping regain control Write them down, and put them in a
from healthy eating or being active - Remember these steps: slipping off place where you can see them
- Explain what to do to get back on the path to healthy eating and regularly
their feet after a slip physical activity is natural
(Proverbs 24:16); don't give up,
keep a positive attitude, and regain
control as soon as possible
(Philippians 4:13); slips are
opportunities to learn (Philippians
4:12)
(continued on next page)
Contemporary Clinical Trials 62 (2017) 77–90
Table 1 (continued)

Standard DPP curriculum learning Faith learning objectives Mini-sermon summary Memory verse Faith activity/homework Promises to remember Scripture references faith
objectives handout & devotional
H. Kitzman et al.

Week 13: Jump start your activity plan Remain steadfast. Persevere and What makes you move? Isaiah 40: In each scripture on the worksheet, Though our bodies are wasting Colossians 2:20–23
press on 29–31 list the promises and conditions. away daily, we are encouraged 1 Corinthians 6:19–20
- Describe ways to add - Getting to know God better Share with others how you can be to be good stewards of God's Galatians 6:9
interest & variety to activity plans through reading scripture, and obedient and God can fulfill the gift to us, our bodies, by Isaiah 40:29–31
- Define aerobic fitness being obedient to God can have a promise to you achieving a balance that James 1:25
- Explain the four F.I.T.T. principles positive impact on our health Ask the Lord to help you to discover promotes both spiritual and Mark 12:30
(frequency, intensity, time, and type physically, mentally and spiritually new ways to “stay the course” and to physical health Matthew 11:28–29;
of activity) and how they relate to - Practical steps to apply your faith increase your activity to greater A regular physical activity 18:21–22
aerobic fitness and encourage physical activity are heights of fitness and physical routine in addition to a healthy Philippians 4:13
outlined strength eating plan significantly Proverbs 3:7–8; 14:30
- Benefits such as being able to serve reduces the risk of many Psalm 119:93,143
the Lord are also described diseases and helps us to Romans 12:1–2
maintain optimum well-being 1 Samuel 16:7
1 Thessalonians 5:17
1 Timothy 4:8
Week 14: Make social cues work for you Learn to conquer the war within Who's influencing you? 2 Corinthians Use your vision board or create a new The power of a purpose is our 1 Corinthians 6:19–20
10:3–5 one and apply the armor of God from motivation to always be 2 Corinthians 10:3–5
- Examples of problem and helpful - How to reflect on our cues (social, Ephesians Ephesians 6 to it. Review scriptures prepared to respond rather Ephesians 2:10; 5:18;
social cues environmental, physical) to help us 6:13–18 that are applicable to each type of than react. Having a planned 6:13–18
- How to remove problem social cues identify habits and patterns that armor and, write them on your response to negative social cues Isaiah 62:5
and add helpful ones lead to poor health habits board. Use them to help you combat will assist in forming new John 14:23
- Describe ways of coping with - By identifying these cues, new negative social cues habits Philippians 2:14
vacations, social events, patterns for positive health can be Romans 12:2
holidays, & visits established
- Create an action plan to replace - Examples from Jesus' life are used

84
problem social cue with helpful one to show how his purpose
influenced his response to
situations
- A challenge is given to plan for
situations with a response and
practice it to create new habits
Week 15: You can manage stress Your Worship can defeat the war Your walk is your warrior against Job 1:20 Identify a stress point in your life. The victory of the war is in Job 1:11,20; 6:6–7
of stress worry (stress) How can you handle it through your worship Matthew 6:25–34
- How to prevent or cope with stress worshipping God? List 3 of worship Seek God first for directions for Psalm 1; 40:1–3; 55:1–7
- Program can be stressful - How to overcome the effects of stances and share with the class me
- How to manage stress stress by putting to practice simple Develop coping tools that help
- Action plan for preventing/coping coping tools for life me
with stress - One illustration is through worship Maintain a healthy lifestyle
- Job's life is used as an example that supports me
through this section
Week 16: Ways to stay motivated You can do it!!!!! Knowledge is power to motivate the 1 Samuel 30:6 Write 10 reasons or strategies to keep Remind yourself of your 1 Samuel 30:6,8
unmotivated yourself encouraged and motivated strength in the Lord! Psalms 121:1
- Measure progress toward weight and Motivation comes from within
physical activity goals - How to stay motivated to live a me when I have the Holy Ghost
- Develop a plan for improving healthy and blessed lifestyle within me
progress, if goals have not yet been - The example of David is used to Knowledge is power that
attained show how he prayed and transforms me
- Describe ways to stay motivated long- remembered the promises of God Success is achievement that
term in times of discouragement and surpasses me
fear Progress is forward movement
- A deep connection to God can keep that motivates me
us motivated when our own efforts
begin to falter
Contemporary Clinical Trials 62 (2017) 77–90
H. Kitzman et al.

Table 2
Anthropometric (primary*) and secondary measures.

Measure Time point Instrument Description Validity Reliability

Weight* 0, 16 week, 10- Doran Digital Scale DS6100 Measured twice to the nearest 0.1 lbs., – –
month averaged
Height* 0, 16 week, 10- Seca 213 Stadiometer Measured twice to the nearest 0.01 in, – –
month averaged
Waist circumference 0, 16 week, 10- Tape measure Measured twice with inelastic tape to the r = 0.62 for correlation between WC and visceral r = 0.998 for intraclass correlation in females [42]
(WC) month nearest 0.1 cm using NIH Guidelines [40] abdominal tissue among women [41]
Blood Pressure 0, 16 week, 10- Omron Digital Blood Pressure Measured twice to the nearest 1 mm Hg, – –
month Monitor (HEM-907XL) averaged
Blood Lipids 0, 16 week Cholestech LDX system Measures fasting blood lipids and glucose TC, r = 0.92; TRG, r = 0.93; HDL, r = 0.92; ρ > 0.75 ICC for all 4 lipid categories [44]
profiles from blood sample collected via LDL, r = 0.86; with Lab values [43]

85
finger stick
HbA1c 0, 16 week Bayer A1cNow + Multi-Test HbA1c measure collected via finger stick r = 0.893 with Laboratory results [45] Sensitivity 0.95, specificity 0.74, positive predictive value
A1c System 0.85, negative predictive value 0.91 [45]
Diet 0, 16 week, 10- Delta NIRI (short FFQ) 158-item questionnaire designed to assess Statistical correlations in energy intake were Energy adjusted correlations for macronutrient and
month African Americans food intake patterns demonstrated between Delta short FFQ and 24-h micronutrient intakes between the short FFQ and 24-h
[24] dietary recalls [24] dietary recalls ranged from 0.13–0.54 [24]
Physical Activity 0, 16 week, 10- Past Week Modifiable Physical Self-report duration and type of physical r = 0.51 with pedometer [46] r = 0.77 ICC for test-retest reliability [26]
month Activity Questionnaire activities completed in the past week [26]
Physical Activity 0, 16 week, 10- Yamax Power Walker Ex-510 Pedometer that stores daily step counts r = 0.98 with manual count [47]. c α = 0.992 [48].
month Pedometer
Estradiol (pg/mL) 0, 16 week 4 mL Saliva, ELISA assay Saliva collected in 4 consecutive weeks and r = 0.71 with serum sample [49,50]. CV = 5.2% in interassay [50]
method in ZRT Lab sent to a laboratory to assay
Cortisol (ng/mL) 0, 16 week 4 mL Saliva, EIA assay method Fasting morning saliva sent to a laboratory r = 0.81 with serum sample [51,52] CV = 2.2% in interassay [53]
in ZRT Lab to assay
Contemporary Clinical Trials 62 (2017) 77–90
H. Kitzman et al.

Table 3
Psychosocial measures (collected at baseline, 16-weeks, and 10 months).

Measure Description Construct validity Reliability coefficient

Body Image Body Appreciation Scale 13-Item scale for assessing positive body image [54]. Exercise frequency correlated with higher positive body image Cronbach's α = 0.93 [56]
in women with low to average levels of appearance-based
physical activity motivation [55]
Pulvers Figure Rating Scale Figure rating scale with 9 silhouettes developed to examine Ratings of body image strongly correlated with participants' Inter-rater reliability Cronbach's α = 0.95 [56]
body image perception and obesity relationship in African BMI's [56]
Americans [56]
Self-efficacy Weight Efficacy Lifestyle 8-Item eating self-efficacy instrument derived from validated WEL-SF items strongly correlated with the original validated Pearson's r value = 0.968 for correlation
Questionnaire- Short Form (WEL-SF) 20-item WEL questionnaire [57]. Assesses degree of WEL.4 WEL-SF items overall represented difficulty resisting between WEL-SF and the full version of WEL
confidence to resist overeating eating in the presence of increased food availability, social [57].
pressure, negative emotions, physical discomfort, and positive
activities [57]
Self-efficacy for Exercise Behaviors 12 Items, measures degree of confidence to exercise despite Change in exercise self-efficacy significantly correlated with Cronbach's α = 0.85 resisting relapse.
Scale [58] certain barriers. 2 subscales: resisting relapse (5 weight loss 4 months postintervetion [59] Cronbach's α = 0.83 making time for exercise
items) & making time for exercise (7 items) [58] [58]
Physical Activity and Nutrition Self- 11-Item instrument used to assess weight-loss self-efficacy Increases in weight-loss self-efficacy (PANSE) scores Cronbach's α coefficient of r = 0.89 [60].
Efficacy (PANSE) Scale among lower-income postpartum women [60]. significantly correlated with reduced unhealthy behavior
practices [60].
Health Locus of Spiritual Health Locus of Control 13-Item scale with 2 subscales: active (11 items) & passive (2 Active spiritual beliefs were positively associated with fruit Active subscale internal consistency r = 0.88

86
Control items). Evaluates spiritual locus of health responsibility [61] consumption and negatively associated with alcohol for female subjects [61].
consumption. Passive spiritual beliefs were associated with Passive subscale internal consistency r = 0.58
lower vegetable and increased alcohol consumption [61] for female subjects [61]
Multidimensional Health Locus of 18-Item measure with 3 dimensions that assess individuals' Almost all of pure internal group (99%) reported their health Coefficient α = 0.85, 0.75 and 0.71 for I, P,
Control (MHLC) Form A Internal (I scale), Powerful Others (P scale) and Chance (C as very good or good compared to the yea-sayer group (87%) and C scales respectively [63]
scale) Loci of Control to capture general beliefs about [63]
perceived internal and external control over their health
[62,63]
Motivation Intrinsic Motivation for Diet and 19-Item instrument derived from validated scales used in other Motivation for physical activity and fruit & vegetable intake Reliability coefficient = 0.53 diet
Physical Activity studies. 2 subscales: Intrinsic Motivation for Diet and Intrinsic significantly increased post-intervention [64,65] Reliability coefficient = 0.78 physical activity
Motivation for Physical Activity [64]
Mood Center for Epidemiologic Studies 10 items, screens for depressed mood symptoms [66,67] Overweight and obesity categories were shown to be r = 0.71 for test-retest item correlation of
Depression (CESD-10) Scale positively associated, and physical activity negatively CESD-10 with CESD-20 [66]
associated with depressive symptoms at 3-year follow up [67]
Stress Perceived Stress Scale (PSS-10) [68,69] 10 items, measures the degree of stress perception Using multiple regression analysis, perceived stress Internal reliability (Cronbach alpha
significantly predicted responses for emotional eating and coefficient = 0.78) [68]
haphazard meal planning [69]
Social Support Weight Management Support Inventory 52-Item inventory: 26 items each on Frequency and Both frequency and helpfulness of supportive behaviors were For frequency scale test-retest reliability
(2 scales: Frequency and Helpfulness Helpfulness subscales. Assesses frequency and helpfulness of demonstrated to be significantly associated with restrained r = 0.75; for helpfulness scale test-retest
scales) social support for weight loss [70] eating [70] reliability r = 0.80 [70]
Contemporary Clinical Trials 62 (2017) 77–90
H. Kitzman et al. Contemporary Clinical Trials 62 (2017) 77–90

Physiological variables. Saliva samples were collected over 4-weeks weights in church j after controlling for all other variables. Whereas,
(one fasting sample for cortisol and estradiol; 3 non-fasting weekly β1 and βc are fixed level-1 effect of weight (Wi) at baseline and other
samples of estradiol to determine peak level over a month time covariates for the ith subjects; and ri is the subject level error term,
period), and were stored in a sub-zero freezer to measure fasting which is assumed to be normally distributed.
morning cortisol (ng/mL), and estradiol (E2, pg/mL). Samples were Level 2 (Treatment effect).
mailed to a CLIA compliant laboratory, where samples were cen-
β0j = γ00 + γ01 Tj + u 0j ,
trifuged and assayed.
Psychosocial variables. Constructs hypothesized to be mediators or β1 = γ10,
predictors of primary and secondary outcomes were measured with
reliable and valid self-report surveys at baseline, 16-weeks, and βc = γc0, c = 1, 2, …, C
10 months, see Table 3 for detailed descriptions.
where, Tj is a treatment indicator variable (1 = intervention,
A process evaluation protocol was developed to ensure fidelity to 0 = control), γ00 is the adjusted mean change of weight in the control
treatment assignment, and evaluate dose of treatment received and group churches, and γ01 is the treatment effect.
participant satisfaction, as described below. γ10 and γc0 are the pooled within-church regression coefficients for
the level-1 covariates; and u0j is an error term representing a unique
Process evaluations. Process evaluations were developed to measure effect associated with church j, and it is assumed to be normally dis-
dose and fidelity to program implementation based on previously tributed.
published models [27]. Churches were evaluated approximately Our primary purpose in fitting this model is to examine the treat-
once per month during the 16 week intervention by independent ment effect in reducing body weight after adjusting for baseline weight,
trained raters. During the maintenance phase, churches were eval- education level, annual household income, comorbidities, age, meno-
uated approximately once per month. Dose measured whether pre- pausal status, smoking status, alcohol consumption in the last 30 days,
determined intervention components were delivered (response YES and hemoglobin A1c level. We will estimate a parsimonious model that
or NO), such as completion of weigh-in, distribution of materials, best fits the data. To do so, we will start with an unconditional model
checking for food and physical activity tracking, and reviewing (with no predictors) to estimate the intraclass correlation coefficient
learning objectives. The criterion for achieving dose was at least (ICC) to explain how much variation in weight loss is explained by
75% of program components successfully delivered. Fidelity mea- level-2 units (churches). After that, we will gradually build a complex
sured if program components were delivered as expected on a 1–4 model that best fits the data. Likelihood ratio test will be used as a
point Likert scale, with higher scores indicating greater fidelity. measure of model fit along with AIC (Akaike Information Criterion) and
Fidelity was assessed for behavioral skills, communication skills, BIC (Bayesian Information Criterion). A model accounting for church
social support, session content (including the faith-based component level effects such as church size and fidelity to intervention determined
in the Faith-DPP group). The criterion for achieving fidelity was a by process evaluations will also be conducted.
mean of 3.0 on the assessed variables. Additional process evaluation
measures included participant attendance, and satisfaction mea- Analysis plan for secondary aims. Several multilevel models will be
sured at post-intervention with an 8-item self-report survey. fit to address the secondary aims to compare S-DPP and Faith-DPP
on reducing risk factors for cardiovascular disease (blood pressure,
2.8. Data analysis HDL and LDL cholesterol) and diabetes (hemoglobin A1C), and
change in behavioral factors (diet, exercise) in AA overweight
The primary objective of this study is to assess the impact of a CBPR women at 16-week post-intervention, and at 10-month follow-up
developed faith-enhanced diabetes prevention program (Faith-DPP) as periods. The effect of psychosocial (e.g., self-efficacy, spiritual locus
compared to a standard diabetes prevention program (S-DPP) in AA of control, support) and physiological (cortisol, estrogen) variables
overweight women on decreasing body weight (in lbs) at two assess- will be tested with mediation analysis to determine the influence on
ment periods: 1) at 16 weeks (post-intervention) 2) at 10 months primary and secondary outcomes [30,31].
(maintenance). As the treatment groups were randomized at the church Missing data. Multiple imputation will be used to estimate the
(cluster) level, subjects within a church must be considered dependent missing values. Multiple imputation is a standard technique for
(nested) observations. Therefore, a multilevel model will be used where imputation [32] and appropriate for cluster randomized trials that
the treatment group will be analyzed as a fixed factor and the church as provide unbiased estimate of the parameter and its standard error
a random factor to account for the hierarchical structure of the design. under the assumption that data is missing at random [32,33]. We
We will assess treatment effects in terms of weight loss (in lbs) from will make several attempts during data collection to reduce the at-
baseline to 16 weeks and from 16 weeks to 10 months using separate trition rate. We will perform Little's test [34] to evaluate the as-
multilevel models. Baseline weight will be entered in the model as a sumption of whether data is missing at random or completely at
covariate to account for the longitudinal design of the study as sug- random for the main outcome variable (weight) and the con-
gested by Wilson et al. [28]. Variables that were significantly different founding variables (comorbidities, socio-economic status, demo-
at baseline will be included as covariates in all models. Using the no- graphics etc.). After confirming that the data is missing at random
tation of Raudenbush and colleagues [29], the model for the 16-week we will identify predictors of attrition to use as covariates in the
and 10-month assessments will be: multiple imputation model.

Level 1 (between subjects effect). 2.9. Power analysis

C Priori power analyses were conducted to attain a power of at least


Yij = β0j + β1 Wi + ∑ βc (Covariatec ) + ri, 80% with 0.05 level of significance for the primary statistical analysis.
c=1 We used the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) as 0.03 among the
churches using the data from The GoodNEWS Trial, a community
where, Yij is change in weight from baseline of participant i in church-based study, conducted in the same geographic location [19].
church j (j = 1, 2, …, 11). β0j is the adjusted mean change of We used the effect size of 0.50 (a medium effect size), which is the
overall standardized mean differences of weight loss, from a meta-

87
H. Kitzman et al. Contemporary Clinical Trials 62 (2017) 77–90

Fig. 1. Better Me Within CONSORT diagram.


Enrollment

Churches (N=12)
Assessed for Eligibility
(n=333)
Excluded (n = 70)
-Not Eligible after screening (n = 14)
- Diabetes (n=7)
- BMI < 25 (n=4)
- Other* (n=3)
- Church dropped (n = 20)
- Declined to participate (/drop) (n=10)
- Lost to follow-up (n=26)

Attended Baseline Measures


(n=263)

Excluded (n=42)
- Not Eligible after measures (n = 41)
- Diabetes (n=39)
- BMI < 25 (n=2)
- Other* (n=1)

Randomization
Churches (N=11)
(n = 221)

Allocation

Faith Enhanced DPP Standard DPP


(Churches N=6) (Churches N=5)
(n = 119) (n = 102)

*Other: Participant readiness, current weight program, moving out, medical condition that
interferes with diet or physical activity change, pregnant

analysis of 18 randomized controlled trials on weight loss through diet on their church's randomization assignment. During the enrollment
and exercise intervention by Wu, Gao, Chen and van Dam [35]. Stan- process, one of the 12 churches dropped from the study due to lack of
dardized mean difference between two groups is equivalent to ‘effect capacity to enroll at least 20 women. Overall, the consort flow chart
size’ as defined by Cohen [36]. Based on these numbers, a power ana- shows minimal attrition throughout the enrollment and randomization
lysis was conducted through simulation using the SAS code provided by process.
Donner and Klar [37] for a cluster randomized trial. It was estimated Table 4 shows the baseline characteristics of enrolled participants in
that 12 churches with 20 participants in each church (N = 240) were the Better Me Within trial. Participants in the S-DPP and Faith-DPP
needed to attain at least 80% power. A goal of 25 participants per were on average, middle-aged, obese, and had an elevated waist cir-
church was set to account for a 20% attrition rate. The overall study cumference. Although recruitment for this study targeted overweight
goal was to recruit 300 participants, 150 in each intervention group, to women to improve lifestyle, participants in both the S-DPP and Faith-
attain at least 80% power. DPP had HbA1c in the pre-diabetic range. Significant baseline differ-
ences were found between the two groups that were consistent across
several variables. Women in the Faith-DPP were better educated, had
3. Study participants higher incomes, better HDL cholesterol, and lower HbA1c levels than
women in the S-DPP group. All other baseline variables were non-sig-
Fig. 1 displays the consort flow chart for the Better Me Within trial. nificant between groups. Outcome analysis models will control for
12 churches were recruited and 333 females were screened by tele- statistically significant baseline differences.
phone or in-person to determine initial eligibility. Of those 333 females,
14 were ineligible from pre-screening, 56 did not attend the in-person
baseline measurement, and 263 were pre-eligible and attended an in- 4. Study implications
person baseline measurement event at their church. Women who did
not attend in-person measures (n = 56) had lower self-reported BMI Due to the growing health disparities and reduced effectiveness of
(p < 0.01) and were younger (p < 0.01) than women who attended health promotion programs such as the DPP in AA communities, cul-
baseline measures. After objective collection of measures to determine turally relevant enhancements to evidence-based approaches need to be
eligibility, 221 individuals were enrolled in a treatment condition based tested with rigorous study designs to inform public and population

88
H. Kitzman et al. Contemporary Clinical Trials 62 (2017) 77–90

Table 4 principles and activities. This distinction is important as tailoring and


Baseline characteristics of enrolled participants. delivery of more complex interventions requires greater resources [39].
This is particularly relevant for FBOs in lower income settings with
Mean (SD), n (%)
limited capacity to deliver programming.
Faith Standard DPP
enhanced 5. Conclusion
DPP

n 119 102 Overall, by using CBPR approaches from inception to enrollment,


Weight (lb) 212.2 218.3 (53.47) the Better Me Within trial was able to successfully recruit AA FBO and
(47.75) female congregation members. Further, the CBPR approach led to a
Waist circumference 40.7 (6.1) 42.0 (6.04) culturally relevant and novel DDP faith-enhanced adaption. This study
(inch)
will provide essential data to guide enhancements to evidence-based
BMI 36.0 (7.70) 37.44 (9.18)
Age (year) 48.0 (10.27) 49.8 (12.27) lifestyle programs for high-risk AA women who have demonstrated an
Education⁎ High school or less, n 7 (6.2) 25 (26.3) attenuated response to evidence-based programs, and a continued in-
(%) crease in chronic disease risk.
Technical degree or less 35 (31.0) 41 (43.2)
than college, n (%)
College degree or more, 71 (62.8) 29 (30.5) Funding
n (%)
Annual Income⁎ $24,999 or less, n (%) 12 (10.7) 28 (29.2) This study was funded by a National Institutes of Health grant,
$25,000–$49,999, n (%) 37 (33.0) 31 (32.3) P20MD006882-2.
$50,000–$75,000, n (%) 23 (20.6) 24 (25.0)
$75,000 or more, n (%) 40 (35.7) 13 (13.5)
SBP 128.1 (17.8) 128.4 (20.89) References
DBP 83.2 (11.02) 81.2 (10.45)
Hypertension Yes, n (%) 38 (32.5) 27 (27.0) [1] A.R.G. Look, R.R. Wing, Long-term effects of a lifestyle intervention on weight and
(SBP ≥ 140 or No, n (%) 79 (67.5) 73 (73.0) cardiovascular risk factors in individuals with type 2 diabetes mellitus: four-year
DBP ≥ 90) results of the Look AHEAD trial, Arch. Intern. Med. 170 (17) (2010) 1566–1575.
HDL⁎ 57.9 (14.94) 53.6 (12.66) [2] W.C. Knowler, E. Barrett-Connor, S.E. Fowler, R.F. Hamman, J.M. Lachin,
LDL 97.5 (26.85) 103.8 (26.6) E.A. Walker, D.M. Nathan, Reduction in the incidence of type 2 diabetes with
TRG 113.3 112.9 (47.82) lifestyle intervention or metformin, N. Engl. J. Med. 346 (6) (2002) 393–403.
(67.41) [3] C.D. Samuel-Hodge, C.M. Johnson, D.F. Braxton, M. Lackey, Effectiveness of dia-
TC 175.4 177.9 (31.39) betes prevention program translations among African Americans, Obes. Rev. 15
(Suppl. 4) (2014) 107–124.
(30.06)
[4] D.S. West, T. Elaine Prewitt, Z. Bursac, H.C. Felix, Weight loss of black, white, and
FG 88.5 (10.38) 91.4 (12.81)
Hispanic men and women in the diabetes prevention program, Obesity 16 (6)
HbA1C⁎ 5.9 (0.52) 6.2 (0.67)
(2008) 1413–1420.
[5] C.L. Ogden, M.D. Carroll, B.K. Kit, K.M. Flegal, Prevalence of childhood and adult

p < 0.05. obesity in the United States, 2011–2012, JAMA 311 (8) (2014) 806–814.
[6] A. Menke, S. Casagrande, L. Geiss, C.C. Cowie, Prevalence of and Trends in Diabetes
Among Adults in the United States, 1988–2012, JAMA 314 (10) (2015) 1021–1029.
health approaches [3,10]. With rising chronic disease rates and
[7] U.E. Bauer, P.A. Briss, R.A. Goodman, B.A. Bowman, Prevention of chronic disease
healthcare costs, practical and sustainable programs need to be eval- in the 21st century: elimination of the leading preventable causes of premature
uated. To our knowledge, this is the first randomized trial evaluating a death and disability in the USA, Lancet 384 (9937) (2014) 45–52.
faith-placed standard DPP program as compared to a CBPR developed, [8] A.T. Geronimus, J. Bound, D. Keene, M. Hicken, Black-white differences in age
trajectories of hypertension prevalence among adult women and men, 1999–2002,
faith-based DPP program. The Better Me Within faith-enhanced curri- Ethn. Dis. 17 (1) (2007) 40–48.
culum is novel by connecting faith-components to weekly DPP beha- [9] K.J. Lancaster, L. Carter-Edwards, S. Grilo, C. Shen, A.M. Schoenthaler, Obesity
vioral and learning objectives to strategically emphasize behavioral interventions in African American faith-based organizations: a systematic review,
Obes. Rev. 15 (Suppl. 4) (2014) 159–176.
principles through multiple integrated faith components. Another novel [10] A. Kong, L.M. Tussing-Humphreys, A.M. Odoms-Young, M.R. Stolley,
component of the faith enhanced curriculum is the addition of a brief M.L. Fitzgibbon, Systematic review of behavioural interventions with culturally
pastor led sermon connected to each DPP weekly session, to further adapted strategies to improve diet and weight outcomes in African American
women, Obes. Rev. 15 (Suppl. 4) (2014) 62–92.
emphasize the faith-health relationship from a highly respected [11] B.A. Israel, A.J. Schulz, E.A. Parker, A.B. Becker, Review of community-based re-
member of the church. This study also evaluates possible psychosocial search: assessing partnership approaches to improve public health, Annu. Rev.
and physiological mediators of the relationship between faith-based Public Health 19 (1998) 173–202.
[12] N. Wallerstein, B. Duran, Community-based participatory research contributions to
programming and outcomes, which has been a consistent call for future
intervention research: the intersection of science and practice to improve health
research in this area [9,10]. Lastly, this study uses peer leaders from equity, Am. J. Public Health 100 (Suppl. 1) (2010) S40–6.
within the church to ensure cultural relevancy and sustainability. [13] J. Jagosh, P.L. Bush, J. Salsberg, A.C. Macaulay, T. Greenhalgh, G. Wong, M. Cargo,
L.W. Green, C.P. Herbert, P. Pluye, A realist evaluation of community-based par-
Faith-based organizations have been involved extensively in health
ticipatory research: partnership synergy, trust building and related ripple effects,
promotion programs in AA communities; however, recent data found BMC Public Health 15 (2015) 725.
that integrating faith components into health promotion (e.g., faith- [14] D.M. Upchurch, J. Stein, G.A. Greendale, L. Chyu, C.H. Tseng, M.H. Huang,
based) curriculum is not necessarily more effective than delivering T.T. Lewis, H.M. Kravitz, T. Seeman, A longitudinal investigation of race, socio-
economic status, and psychosocial mediators of allostatic load in midlife women:
standard programming inside a FBO (e.g., faith-placed) [9], although findings from the Study of Women's Health across the nation, Psychosom. Med. 77
studies have not directly compared this relationship in a randomized (4) (2015) 402–412.
design. One study found a beneficial effect of faith-based programming [15] L.M. Tomfohr, M.A. Pung, J.E. Dimsdale, Mediators of the relationship between
race and allostatic load in African and White Americans, Health Psychol. 35 (4)
on weight when compared to general health education [38]. The Better (2016) 322–332.
Me Within randomized trial allows for comparison of a faith-based DPP [16] A.C. Incollingo Rodriguez, E.S. Epel, M.L. White, E.C. Standen, J.R. Seckl,
program (e.g., faith-enhanced DPP) developed by faith leaders using A.J. Tomiyama, Hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis dysregulation and cortisol
activity in obesity: a systematic review, Psychoneuroendocrinology 62 (2015)
CBPR approaches as compared to a faith-placed DPP program (secular 301–318.
program held at a church). This comparison provides essential in- [17] R. Pasquali, The hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis and sex hormones in chronic
formation on whether delivering readily available health promotion stress and obesity: pathophysiological and clinical aspects, Ann. N. Y. Acad. Sci.
1264 (2012) 20–35.
programming, such as the DPP, inside a FBO is equally as effective as
[18] V. Vicennati, F. Pasqui, C. Cavazza, U. Pagotto, R. Pasquali, Stress-related devel-
tailoring health promotion programming to include faith-based opment of obesity and cortisol in women, Obesity 17 (9) (2009) 1678–1683.

89
H. Kitzman et al. Contemporary Clinical Trials 62 (2017) 77–90

[19] M.J. DeHaven, M.A. Ramos-Roman, N. Gimpel, J. Carson, J. DeLemos, S. Pickens, [43] M. Carey, C. Markham, P. Gaffney, G. Boran, V. Maher, Validation of a point of care
C. Simmons, T. Powell-Wiley, K. Banks-Richard, K. Shuval, J. Duvahl, L. Tong, lipid analyser using a hospital based reference laboratory, Ir. J. Med. Sci. 175 (4)
N. Hsieh, J.J. Lee, The GoodNEWS (Genes, Nutrition, Exercise, Wellness, and (2006) 30–35.
Spiritual Growth) Trial: a community-based participatory research (CBPR) trial [44] R.A. Dale, L.H. Jensen, M.J. Krantz, Comparison of two point-of-care lipid analyzers
with African-American church congregations for reducing cardiovascular disease for use in global cardiovascular risk assessments, Ann. Pharmacother. 42 (5) (2008)
risk factors—recruitment, measurement, and randomization, Contemp. Clin. Trials 633–639.
32 (5) (2011) 630–640. [45] J.R. Arrendale, S.E. Cherian, I. Zineh, M.J. Chirico, J.R. Taylor, Assessment of
[20] J.A. Carson, L. Michalsky, B. Latson, K. Banks, L. Tong, N. Gimpel, J.J. Lee, glycated hemoglobin using A1CNow +™ point-of-care device as compared to cen-
M.J. Dehaven, The cardiovascular health of urban African Americans: diet-related tral laboratory testing, J. Diabetes Sci. Technol. 2 (5) (2008) 822 Online.
results from the Genes, Nutrition, Exercise, Wellness, and Spiritual Growth [46] K.P. Gabriel, J.J. McClain, C.D. Lee, P.D. Swan, B.A. Alvar, M.R. Mitros,
(GoodNEWS) trial, J. Acad. Nutr. Diet. 112 (11) (2012) 1852–1858. B.E. Ainsworth, Evaluation of physical activity measures used in middle-aged
[21] H.F. Hsieh, S.E. Shannon, Three approaches to qualitative content analysis, Qual. women, Med. Sci. Sports Exerc. 41 (7) (2009) 1403–1412.
Health Res. 15 (9) (2005) 1277–1288. [47] S.E. Crouter, P.L. Schneider, M. Karabulut, D.R. Bassett, Validity of 10 electronic
[22] G. Diabetes Prevention Program Research, W.C. Knowler, S.E. Fowler, pedometers for measuring steps, distance, and energy cost, Med. Sci. Sports Exerc.
R.F. Hamman, C.A. Christophi, H.J. Hoffman, A.T. Brenneman, J.O. Brown-Friday, 35 (8) (2003) 1455–1460.
R. Goldberg, E. Venditti, D.M. Nathan, 10-Year follow-up of diabetes incidence and [48] P.L. Schneider, S.E. Crouter, O. Lukajic, D.R. Bassett, Accuracy and reliability of 10
weight loss in the Diabetes Prevention Program Outcomes Study, Lancet 374 (9702) pedometers for measuring steps over a 400-m walk, Med. Sci. Sports Exerc. 35 (10)
(2009) 1677–1686. (2003) 1779–1784.
[23] P.A. James, S. Oparil, B.L. Carter, W.C. Cushman, C. Dennison-Himmelfarb, [49] C.M. Worthman, J.F. Stallings, L.F. Hofman, Sensitive salivary estradiol assay for
J. Handler, D.T. Lackland, M.L. LeFevre, T.D. MacKenzie, O. Ogedegbe, S.C. Smith monitoring ovarian function, Clin. Chem. 36 (10) (1990) 1769–1773.
Jr., L.P. Svetkey, S.J. Taler, R.R. Townsend, J.T. Wright Jr., A.S. Narva, E. Ortiz, [50] Y. Lu, G.R. Bentley, P.H. Gann, K.R. Hodges, R.T. Chatterton, Salivary estradiol and
2014 evidence-based guideline for the management of high blood pressure in progesterone levels in conception and nonconception cycles in women: evaluation
adults: report from the panel members appointed to the Eighth Joint National of a new assay for salivary estradiol, Fertil. Steril. 71 (5) (1999) 863–868.
Committee (JNC 8), JAMA 311 (5) (2014) 507–520. [51] W.S. Gozansky, J.S. Lynn, M.L. Laudenslager, W.M. Kohrt, Salivary cortisol de-
[24] T.C. Carithers, S.A. Talegawkar, M.L. Rowser, O.R. Henry, P.M. Dubbert, termined by enzyme immunoassay is preferable to serum total cortisol for assess-
M.L. Bogle, H.A. Taylor Jr., K.L. Tucker, Validity and calibration of food frequency ment of dynamic hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis activity, Clin. Endocrinol. 63
questionnaires used with African-American adults in the Jackson Heart Study, J. (3) (2005) 336–341.
Am. Diet. Assoc. 109 (7) (2009) 1184–1193. [52] C. Kirschbaum, D.H. Hellhammer, Salivary cortisol in psychobiological research: an
[25] A.F. Subar, Developing dietary assessment tools, J. Am. Diet. Assoc. 104 (5) (2004) overview, Neuropsychobiology 22 (3) (1989) 150–169.
769–770. [53] R.F. Vining, R.A. McGinley, J.J. Maksvytis, K.Y. Ho, Salivary cortisol: a better
[26] K.P. Gabriel, J.J. McClain, K.K. Schmid, K.L. Storti, B.E. Ainsworth, Reliability and measure of adrenal cortical function than serum cortisol, Ann. Clin. Biochem. 20 (6)
convergent validity of the past-week Modifiable Activity Questionnaire, Public (1983) 329–335.
Health Nutr. 14 (3) (2011) 435–442. [54] L. Avalos, T.L. Tylka, N. Wood-Barcalow, The Body Appreciation Scale: develop-
[27] R.P. Saunders, M.H. Evans, P. Joshi, Developing a process-evaluation plan for as- ment and psychometric evaluation, Body Image 2 (3) (2005) 285–297.
sessing health promotion program implementation: a how-to guide, Health Promot. [55] K.J. Homan, T.L. Tylka, Appearance-based exercise motivation moderates the re-
Pract. 6 (2) (2005) 134–147. lationship between exercise frequency and positive body image, Body Image 11 (2)
[28] D.K. Wilson, H. Kitzman-Ulrich, K. Resnicow, M.L. Van Horn, S.M. St George, (2014) 101–108.
E.R. Siceloff, K.A. Alia, T. McDaniel, V. Heatley, L. Huffman, S. Coulon, R. Prinz, An [56] K.M. Pulvers, R.E. Lee, H. Kaur, M.S. Mayo, M.L. Fitzgibbon, S.K. Jeffries, J. Butler,
overview of the Families Improving Together (FIT) for weight loss randomized Q.J. Hou, J.S. Ahluwalia, Development of a culturally relevant body image in-
controlled trial in African American families, Contemp. Clin. Trials 42 (2015) strument among urban African Americans, Obes. Res. 12 (10) (2004) 1641–1651.
145–157. [57] G.E. Ames, M.G. Heckman, K.B. Grothe, M.M. Clark, Eating self-efficacy: develop-
[29] S.W. Raudenbush, A.S. Bryk, Hierarchical Linear Models: Applications and Data ment of a short-form WEL, Eat. Behav. 13 (4) (2012) 375–378.
Analysis Methods, Sage, 2002. [58] J.F. Sallis, R.B. Pinski, R.M. Grossman, T.L. Patterson, P.R. Nader, The development
[30] A.J. Fairchild, D.P. MacKinnon, A general model for testing mediation and mod- of self-efficacy scales for health related diet and exercise behaviors, Health Educ.
eration effects, Prev. Sci. 10 (2) (2009) 87–99. Res. 3 (3) (1988) 283–292.
[31] D.P. Mackinnon, A.J. Fairchild, Current directions in mediation analysis, Curr. Dir. [59] A.L. Palmeira, P.J. Teixeira, T.L. Branco, S.S. Martins, C.S. Minderico, J.T. Barata,
Psychol. Sci. 18 (1) (2009) 16. S.O. Serpa, L.B. Sardinha, Predicting short-term weight loss using four leading
[32] R.J. Little, D.B. Rubin, Statistical Analysis With Missing Data, John Wiley & Sons, health behavior change theories, Int. J. Behav. Nutr. Phys. Act. 4 (2007).
2014. [60] L. Latimer, L.O. Walker, S. Kim, K.E. Pasch, B.S. Sterling, Self-efficacy scale for
[33] M. Taljaard, A. Donner, N. Klar, Imputation strategies for missing continuous out- weight loss among multi-ethnic women of lower income: a psychometric evalua-
comes in cluster randomized trials, Biom. J. 50 (3) (2008) 329–345. tion, J. Nutr. Educ. Behav. 43 (4) (2011) 279–283.
[34] R.J. Little, A test of missing completely at random for multivariate data with [61] K.J. Debnam, C.L. Holt, E.M. Clark, D.L. Roth, H.R. Foushee, M. Crowther,
missing values, J. Am. Stat. Assoc. 83 (404) (1988) 1198–1202. M. Fouad, P.L. Southward, Spiritual health locus of control and health behaviors in
[35] T. Wu, X. Gao, M. Chen, R.M. van Dam, Long-term effectiveness of diet-plus-ex- African Americans, Am. J. Health Behav. 36 (3) (2012) 360–372.
ercise interventions vs. diet-only interventions for weight loss: a meta-analysis, [62] K.A. Wallston, B.S. Wallston, Health Locus of Control Scales, (1981).
Obes. Rev. 10 (3) (2009) 313–323. [63] S.N. Raja, S. Williams, R. McGee, Multidimensional health locus of control beliefs
[36] J. Cohen, A power primer, Psychol. Bull. 112 (1) (1992) 155. and psychological health for a sample of mothers, Soc. Sci. Med. 39 (2) (1994)
[37] A. Donner, N. Klar, Statistical considerations in the design and analysis of com- 213–220.
munity intervention trials, J. Clin. Epidemiol. 49 (4) (1996) 435–439. [64] D.K. Wilson, R. Friend, N. Teasley, S. Green, I.L. Reaves, D.A. Sica, Motivational
[38] R.W. Sattin, L.B. Williams, J. Dias, J.T. Garvin, L. Marion, T.V. Joshua, A. Kriska, versus social cognitive interventions for promoting fruit and vegetable intake and
M.K. Kramer, K.M. Narayan, Community trial of a faith-based lifestyle intervention physical activity in African American adolescents, Ann. Behav. Med. 24 (4) (2002)
to prevent diabetes among African-Americans, J. Community Health 41 (1) (2016) 310–319.
87–96. [65] D.K. Wilson, A.E. Evans, J. Williams, G. Mixon, J.R. Sirard, R. Pate, A preliminary
[39] R.E. Glasgow, L. Fisher, L.A. Strycker, D. Hessler, D.J. Toobert, D.K. King, T. Jacobs, test of a student-centered intervention on increasing physical activity in under-
Minimal intervention needed for change: definition, use, and value for improving served adolescents, Ann. Behav. Med. 30 (2) (2005) 119–124.
health and health research, Transl. Behav. Med. 4 (1) (2014) 26–33. [66] E.M. Andresen, J.A. Malmgren, W.B. Carter, D.L. Patrick, Screening for depression
[40] N. NIH, L. National Heart, B. Institute, N.A.A.f.t.S.o, Obesity, the Practical Guide in well older adults: evaluation of a short form of the CES-D (Center for
Identification, Evaluation, and Treatment of Overweight and Obesity in Adults, NIH Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale), Am. J. Prev. Med. 10 (2) (1994) 77–84.
Publication, 2000, pp. 35–38 Number DO-4084. [67] K. Ball, N.W. Burton, W.J. Brown, A prospective study of overweight, physical ac-
[41] A. Bosy-Westphal, C.-A. Booke, T. Blöcker, E. Kossel, K. Goele, W. Later, B. Hitze, tivity, and depressive symptoms in young women, Obesity 17 (1) (2009) 66–71.
M. Heller, C.-C. Glüer, M.J. Müller, Measurement site for waist circumference af- [68] S. Cohen, Perceived stress in a probability sample of the United States, The Social
fects its accuracy as an index of visceral and abdominal subcutaneous fat in a Psychology of Health, Sage Publications, Newbury Park, CA, 1988, pp. 31–67.
Caucasian population, J. Nutr. 140 (5) (2010) 954–961. [69] R. Sims, S. Gordon, W. Garcia, E. Clark, D. Monye, C. Callender, A. Campbell,
[42] J. Wang, J.C. Thornton, S. Bari, B. Williamson, D. Gallagher, S.B. Heymsfield, Perceived stress and eating behaviors in a community-based sample of African
M. Horlick, D. Kotler, B. Laferrere, L. Mayer, F.X. Pi-Sunyer, R.N. Pierson, Americans, Eat. Behav. 9 (2) (2008) 137–142.
Comparisons of waist circumferences measured at 4 sites, Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 77 (2) [70] S. Rieder, A. Ruderman, The development and validation of the weight manage-
(2003) 379–384. ment support inventory, Eat. Behav. 8 (1) (2007) 39–47.

90

Potrebbero piacerti anche