Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Digital Grid:
Communicative Electrical Grids of the Future
Rikiya Abe, Member, IEEE,
Hisao Taoka, Senior Member, IEEE and David McQuilkin, Member, IEEE
II. INTRODUCTION
modules, from 1976 to 2006, the price per watt dropped generation grid. With renewable energy, the generated energy
almost 100-fold. is inserted at random points throughout the grid, and this
A European Union Joint Research Committee found a generated energy fluctuates dramatically. This makes it
close relationship between annual production rates and cost increasingly difficult to manage the power flows throughout
reduction as shown in Fig.2, where the cost of PV modules the grid, and simple demand-side management does not
dropped 22% for each doubling of cumulative module resolve this problem.
production [2]. To avoid this issue in Europe, where there is increasing
Data storage prices have shown an even more dramatic deployment of renewable energy, a “CELL” concept is being
drop as production increases, with prices dropping from developed, where the grid is subdivided by voltage-class
$50/megabyte in 1986 to less than $0.01/megabyte in 2008. (making a local area a “cell”), whereby each cell provides
These products have similar pricing structures, where balanced supply-demand, and tries to avoid the reverse power
investment for manufacturing facilities is relatively large, flow to the higher voltage grid [6]. Nevertheless, it still might
however material cost is lower. be difficult to avoid very fast cascading outages by using this
Since some of energy storage devices have similar price control method.
structures, such as lithium ion batteries and Ni-MH batteries,
we therefore can forecast that energy storage prices will
likewise exhibit continuing price reductions as technology and
production methods improve and as production volume
increases.
controller (LPC) systems, both of which use AC/DC/AC controlled by or through digital grid controllers (DGCs).
conversion. These are asynchronous power exchange between IP controlled power can be recorded when it is exported
two cells. On the other hand, the DGR enables coordinated and imported, and thereby we can distinguish the power flows
asynchronous power exchange among more than three cells at from one another.
the same time, enabling a wider variation of connection points Digital Grid Router
Digital Grid Routers
and power capacities. Several DGRs enable coordinated USA
operations and transport the power to the remote cells like an Cells
internet mail, using newly designed routing algorithms.
The cells can use the existing transmission lines for Maps are to
the same scale
asynchronous power coordination among multiple neighboring
cells. The size of a cell can be as large as one state, medium Japan
operated in stand-alone mode and is freed from the Fig.5 Image of Digital Grid in USA vs. Japanese Grid
conventional restriction of exactly matching generated power
with demand each second. This illustrates the concept that in Europe Maps are to
the existing grid, the value of energy is inherently tied to the the same scale
Cells
time it is produced as well as the time it is required, or the Japan
time-related value of electric power. 50Hz
In order to remove this time-related value of energy, and
enable commodity pricing of energy, a digital grid is proposed.
AC/DC/AC
The following is a description of the proposed digital grid. Link
When the strategy is to increase grid robustness and energy exchanges energy using power routers among hierarchically
security, the existing large area synchronous grid can be organized power clusters. ECO net used DC between clusters,
subdivided into two or three sub-grids, with digital grid and it can also be said to be seminal [11].
connections between each sub-grid. This improves robustness There have been many other proposals such as using
to wide area failure and prevents sabotage from affecting more routers to control the energy flow and using mesh type
than the local sub-grid. Segmentation of the wide-area grid so networks, however, most of them are more general ideas.
as to improve robustness was recently proposed by Clark, et
al. in Power & Energy Magazine [7], which states VI. DIGITAL ELECTRIC POWER
“segmenting the grid … into a set of dc-inter-connected Each DGR is configured as one unit integrated with
sectors … completely eliminates the regional stability multiple parallel terminals. One CPU controls both power and
limitations of AC ties and their inherent power-flow information, controls each terminal and controls the set of
problems.” terminals. The energy and information are integrated into a
On the other hand, in cases where increasing penetration of unit and delivered to the coordinated power line. The basic
renewables becomes an issue, municipalities or other idea is to integrate the energy and the information into a unit
relatively small areas who wish to become self-sufficient can and control it simultaneously, even though an actual system
likewise further sub-divide the grid, and rely on infrequent may have multiple CPUs, DSPs (Digital Signal Processor) etc.
imports and exports of energy to supplement their self- In this research paper, the energy with information is called
generation. This stage will require the deployment of storage. “digital electric power”.
At the smallest level of granularity, each home can also The standard energy information format has leading header
become a digital grid cell. Such a digital grid home can take information, main body of energy (payload) and footer
advantage of high power applications and retain safer information. Both information and power pass through the
operation than the existing 120V system with circuit breakers. same power line. Information can be separated into two sets.
One is a simple key signal that passes through the same power
V. COMPARISON WITH OTHER CONCEPTS line and the other contains additional information including
A. Differences Between the Digital Grid and Smart Grids the key signal analyzer and passes through an outside data
The Smart Grid, which is currently being widely developed, network. When using PLC communications, those two sets
is contributing methods to manage power on the grid by are combined into one. The header has both sender address
computerization, especially by managing the load at the and receiver address, so the digital electric power can be
consumer end [8]. Nevertheless, the grid is a synchronous transferred to the given address passing through the specified
system and the power flow depends on the existing impedance intermediate DGRs. The required amount of exchanged
within the grid. energy can be divided into smaller units, where each has its
Even if the power flow is intended to be improved through own header and thereby these sub-units of energy can be sent
automation [10], the power flow cannot be completely by different routes.
controlled with available data because of the complexity of the The magnitude of the electric power and its duration can be
fluctuating impedance. Some equipment such as FACTS included in the header information as the energy profile, and
(Flexible AC Transmission Systems), HVDC (High Voltage the footer information can be used to define the end. This
Direct Current) [9], intelligent transformers by EPRI or profile can be recorded for energy trading information.
Controllable Network Transformers from Georgia Institute of
Technology are proposed to improve the total power flow, but VII. SPECIFIC EXAMPLES OF DIGITAL GRIDS
not for controlling power coupled with information. Fig.8 shows the specific example of a digital grid as
proposed in this paper. This configuration can be achieved by
B. Packetized Energy
changing the existing power system gradually, exhibiting the
H. Saito and J. Toyoda introduced the concept of benefit that the system can be deployed without system-wide
packetized electric power tagged by power routers which was changes.
based on the research of the Open Electric Energy Network in The cells numbered #1 to #4 do not need to be
1995 and 1997 [8] [10]. This research was seminal because it synchronized with others. Each cell has a large proportion of
proposed the routing of power with identifying information. renewable energy, and manages the supply-demand balance
However, this concept was made only in regards to the through distributed fossil fuel generator(s) and energy storage.
synchronous grid, and does not comprehend asynchronous Each cell has its own power generation and load
transmission and arbitrary routing of energy with information. configuration, and the frequency or phase is allowed to vary
C. Power Cluster from cell to cell. Each cell has its own power bus to which
generator (G) and storage (B) are connected. The loads from
A power cluster configured through a network of micro
residences are connected also, although not displayed in the
grids was also previously conceived. This concept, called
figure. The DGRs are shown surrounded by dash-dot-dash
“ECO net”, which exchanged energy among clusters using a
lines. The terminal of each DGR is composed of breakers,
power router, was submitted by Y. Matsumoto and S. Yanabu.
line switches and power inverters. Not shown in the figure,
The ECO net proposed a new power grid architecture which
the terminal has an inductor or an isolating transformer. The
6
load variations across a large area cause complex power flows Internet and internet protocols.
that are difficult to control. Communications technology which is widely deployed for
This type of converter can supply reactive power as well, so many applications on the internet, using Internet Protocols (IP)
as to maintain the voltage of a cell-grid. It can also be a is sufficient for the digital grid. The low cost which this
voltage source when the grid has to start up after blackout (so- equipment has achieved as well as the advances in technology
called blackstart). which will continue to be made can be used to the best
Multiple BTB components can be used like a DGR, advantage for the digital grid.
however, DGR uses fewer converters and has an advantage The technology which can be used includes routing, routing
with integrated control. optimization and automatic updating, automated address
Fig.11 shows a simple simulation of three-way power assignment, packet sequence control, flow control and
conversion. The model was developed using power collision control, and data error detection and correction.
simulation software PSIM.
Cell A, B, C are 60Hz, 50Hz, 40Hz, respectively and all X. ENERGY EXCHANGE PROCEDURE ON THE DIGITAL GRID
are 6.6kV. During power transmission from A to B, C to B,
A. Energy Exchange Procedure
then A to B + C, each cell voltage is kept stable. The
magnitude of current changes as the control signal changes The following steps describe the general steps of energy
and the phase of current shifts smoothly as the control signal exchange.
changes. 1. Either the DGR or the DGC broadcasts a request to the
As shown in this simulation, it is easy to control power flow other equipment to find a candidate. The broadcast outlines
among cells with different frequency and phase. When a fault trading conditions including various options such as the
occurs, the DGR can instantly stop the gate signal of the quantity and direction of real power, the quantity and direction
converter which is faster than switchgears. This will stop a of reactive power, starting time of exchange, ending of
cascading blackout. A DGR can also be used in stand-alone exchange, minimum and maximum exchange trading price,
cells such as in developing countries. and type of power generator. If any power equipment can
DGR
supply under the requested conditions, then it replies with an
Cell B
(2)
AC
50Hz offer of trading conditions.
Cell A
60Hz
(1)
DC 2. Reserve the energy exchange with one candidate, and get
AC (3) AC
Cell C an acknowledgement to confirm. Reserved trading conditions
Voltage(V)
40Hz
Current(A) are almost the same as those of the request. The system which
(1)→(2) (3)→(2) (1)→(2) and (3) +200 accepts this reservation replies with a repeat of the suppliers
(1) 60 Hz 0 terms to confirm.
-200
3. These processes are similar to the ordinary reservation in
hotels, air tickets, etc. The reservation can be for a few
+200
seconds or a few days in advance.
0
(2) 50 Hz 4. Find the best route to the candidate from the requester.
-200 It is very important to use an algorithm which minimizes
+200 power loss due to power conversion and transmission line loss
(3) 40 Hz 0 as shown in Fig.12.
-200
0.04 0.06 0.08 0.10 0.12 0.14 0.16 0.18 0.20 0.22(sec)
Fig.11 Transient of Power Flow among Cells Using DGR
B. Recording Energy Transactions [3] Yasuhiro Hayashi, Shoji Kawasaki, Ju unpei Baba, Akihiko Yokoyama,
et.al., “Active Coordinated Operation of Distribution Network System
Energy transactions between DGRs annd/or DGCs are for Many Connections of Distributed Generators ” , IEEJ Trans.PE,
initiated through requests from others. Eachh DGR and DGC Vol.127(2007), No.1 pp.41-52
operates autonomously based on their local ppolicy, algorithms [4] Akira Shiki, Akihiko Yokoyama, Ju unpei Baba, Tomohiro Takano,
and rules, initiating the power transfers approopriately. Energy Tadahiro Goda, Yoshio Izui, “Autonomous Decentralized Control of
Supply and Demand by Inverter Baased Distributed Generations in
flows will be monitored by built-in meterring devices and Isolated Microgrid”, IEEJ Trans.PE, Vol.127(2007),
V No.1 pp.95-103
recorded together with reservation informatioon, including time, [5] Hiroshi Suzuki, “Advanced Metering g Infrastructure based on Smart
seller, buyer, price, energy source, energy am
mount, etc. These Meters”, IEEJ, Vol.127(2007), No.9 pp.977-980
p
records will be like a bankbook for ordinary financial [6] Ronnie Belmans (EUREC agency)), ESAT/Electa, p28, 03-
_Ronnie_Belmans-eurec-17_june_2009_Smart_Grids 2009,
transactions as shown in Table 1. http://www.eurec.be/component/option,,com_docman/task,doc_view/gid,
The digital grid enables electric energy too be handled as a 526/Itemid,79/
commodity product, resulting in low, stablle prices. This [7] Harrison Clark, Abdel-Aty Edris, Mohamed
M El-Gasseir, Ken Epp,
Andrew Isaacs and Dennis Woodfford, “Softening the Blow of
mechanism may create futures and derivativves market related
Disturbances”, IEEE Power and Energy y Magazine, 4/2010, p. 99.
with weather forecast. A certification process will be [8] Hiromi Saitoh, Junichi Toyoda, “A New N Concept of Electric Power
necessary for accounting for the inevitable losses caused by Network for the Effective Transportation of Small Power of Dispersed
transmission and storage. This function cann be provided by a Generation Plants”, T. IEEJ, Vol.115--B (1995), No.6 pp.568-575
third party energy service provider. [9] Hiromi Saitoh, Satoshi Miyamori, Toru u Shimada, Junichi Toyoda, “A
Study on Autonomous Decentralized Co ontrol Mechanism of Power Flow
in Open Electric Energy Network”, T. T IEEJ, Vol.117-B (1997), No.1
Table 1 Recording Energy Transacctions pp.10-18
Date Starting Finishing Source Sending Receiving Sending Loss Baalance Tariff Money [10] American Electric Power , “Interstate Transmission Vision for Wind
Time Time Cell Cell Energy Energy (c/kWh) Balance www.aep.com/about/i765 project/
Generation (Whitepaper)”,2007, http://w
docs/windtransmissionvisionwhitepaperr.pdf
2010.6.25 10:29 11:50 Cell A 200 kWh 10 kWh 1990 kWh 30.4 xxx [11] Yoshihiko Matsumoto, Satoru Manab bu, “ A Vision of the Electric
2010.6.26 12:50 15:40 Cell X 120 kWh 7 kWh 633 kWh 19.5 xxx Power System Architecture Aiming forr Our New Generation”, IEEJ,
2010.6.27 16:40 18:30 Cell B 420 kWh 20 kWh 4663 kWh 20.2 xxx Trans.PE, Vol. 123 (2003) No.12,pp14 436-1441
2010.6.28 22:15 0:40 Cell Y 230 kWh 16 kWh 2117 kWh 38.5 xxx
Rikiya Abe (M’2008) was born in Fukushima
prefecture in Japann, on September 12, 1953. He
XI. CONCLUSION graduated from thee Electronics Engineering at the
The digital grid enables a more robust griid, by segmenting University of Toky yo. His employment experience
included the Electricc Power Development Company,
it into largely autonomous cells, and withh energy storage Tokyo, Electric Powwer Research Institute, USA and
enables a large proportion of renewable enerrgy, which cannot the University of To
okyo. His special fields of interest
be achieved with the existing grid architeccture. It can be included renewablee energy, energy storage, and
smart grid. He reeceived a doctoral degree from
applied to the current grid step by step and mmay contribute to institutions of cheemical engineering at Kyushu
increase the utilization factor of transmissiion lines. It also University, Japan. He is a Professor since 2008
2 at the University of Tokyo
enables the commoditization of energy, resuulting in low and and is teaching undergraduate students at Program for Social Innovation and
graduate students at Technology Managementt for Innovation.
stable electricity prices. Finally, it supportss new third party
services such as energy storage, energy tradinng markets, green Hisao Taoka (SM M'1997) was born in Okayama
energy supply certification service and em mergency energy prefecture in Japan n, on September 8, 1953. He
supply. graduated from thee Electric Engineering and the
Graduate School of Engineering at the University of
Tokyo in 1977 and 1979, respectively. In 1979, he
XII. ACKNOWLEDGMENT joined Mitsubishi Ellectric Corporation, where he has
engaged in the research on power system control and
The authors gratefully appreciate David E Eskinazi and Mark analysis using advan nced computer technologies. He
McGranaghan, Electric Power Research Insstitute in US who received a doctoral degree from the University of
recognize this concept and encourage us, andd appreciate Prof. Tokyo in 1986. Aftter being as a professor in Fukui
University of Technology for seven years, hee is now an associate professor in
Kazuyuki Aihara, the University of Tokyo and Prof. the Graduate School of Engineering, Electrical and Electronics Engineering,
Masakazu Kato, Tokyo Denki University inn Japan, for their University of Fukui. He is a member of CIGR RE and IEE of Japan.
contributions to the original version of this doocument.
This research is partially supported by the Japan Society for David McQuilkin was w born in the USA in 1953 and
has a B.S. in Physiccs from Wheaton College (1975).
the Promotion of Science (JSPS) througgh its “Funding His employment ex xperience includes Asia Pacific
Program for World-Leading Innovative R&D D on Science and Ventures, Xerox, and d AT&T. His specialties include
Technology (FIRST Program)." information techno ology hardware and software
engineering, renewaable energy, energy storage and
the smart grid. He is a member of the IEEE Power
XIII. REFERENCES and Energy Socieety and the Association for
[1] http://www1.eere.energy.gov/solar/myths.html, M Myth1 Solar electricity Computing Machineery. He is currently a consulting
cannot serve any significant fraction of U.S. or worrld electricity needs. engineer with Kyum maru Pacific Alliances providing
[2] Earth Policy Institute “World Average Photovolttaic Module Cost per services to Japanese and US-based companies.
Watt, 1975-2006”, December, 2007; http://www.earth-
policy.org/datacenter/xls/indicator12_2007_7.xls