Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
T H E N AT U R A L P E R F O R M A N C E E N H A N C E R
CONTENTS
1. WHAT IS MICROFIBRILLATED CELLULOSE (MFC)?...................................................................................... 3
History of MFC............................................................................................................................................. 4
What is MFC?............................................................................................................................................... 6
Variations of MFC......................................................................................................................................... 7
2. WHAT CAN YOU EXPECT WHEN USING MICROFIBRILLATED CELLULOSE?............................................. 8
Thick and easy flowing formulation.............................................................................................................. 9
High yield stress and improved stability...................................................................................................... 11
Improved water holding capacity................................................................................................................ 13
Strength & reinforcement ........................................................................................................................... 14
Barrier properties ...................................................................................................................................... 15
Innovation opportunities............................................................................................................................. 16
1
WHAT IS MICROFIBRILL ATED
CELLULOSE (MFC)?
HISTORY OF MFC
Microfibrillated cellulose (MFC) was first studied in the late 1970s as a part of research at
the ITT Rayonier labs in the US. Albin Turbak, who worked on MFC at the ITT Rayonier
lab, pursued this new type of cellulose quality and discovered that by using a high-
pressure homogenizer, cellulose fibers could be fibrillated into cellulose microfibrils.
This new material had interesting properties that were The interest in the concept of MFC has increased in
quite different from regular cellulose. ITT Rayonier the end-user markets since 2005, and more and more
did not develop full scale production, and in 1983, manufacturers of end-products are both patenting and
they gave a free license to all parties interested in testing out MFC.This interest can also be found in the
investigating this new concept of MFC. From 1983 to search trends for the subject MFC, where a steady
2005, little activity was seen in the industrial field of increase has been found during the same period
MFC, while the amount of patents after 2005 and until (Figure 2)
present (2015) has exponentially increased (see figure
below, data up to 2012).
FI G U RE 1
Patent families by year for microfibrillated cellulose and nanocellulose
Despite the large interest in MFC both in the As a result, focus on delivering MFC in a wet state,
academia and the industry, the commercial utilization and the use of MFC in water based systems, has
of MFC has been limited. The main challenges increased. The benefit of using MFC delivered in a wet
in commercializing MFC has been to develop a state is that it is readily activated and less energy is
process for the fibrillation of the cellulose that is needed to incorporate the MFC into formulations.
suitable on a large commercial basis. The fibrillation
of the cellulose, and the material handling during Borregaard is currently building the first large scale
the process, can be a challenge and also drying the commercial plant for MFC production, with a capacity
material without losing performance can be difficult. of 50 000 tons dispersion (1000 tons dry based).
FI G U RE 2
Microfibrillated cellulose and nanocellulose search trends.
FI G U RE 3
MFC (Exilva MFC from Borregaard) seen through scanning
electron microscopy.
VARIATIONS OF MFC
2
WHAT CAN YOU E XPECT WHEN USING
MICROFIBRILL ATED CELLULOSE?
MFC water suspensions have high viscosity already at low concentration, and it is
extremely shear thinning material (Pääkkö et al. 2007, Iotti et al. 2011). Viscosity is a
measure of how much the material resists flow.
As mentioned earlier, MFC consists of a three thus leading to a lower viscosity upon flow. When
dimensional network of long and thin fibrils. This the mixing speed or shear rate is increased, these
network is very strong and it resists the flow efficiently, aggregates resize and orientate along the flow. This
thus providing the high viscosity. However, when leads to a decreasing viscosity with increasing shear
you start mixing the suspension, in rheological terms rate and it is called shear-thinning behaviour. MFC is
apply force on the suspension, the network eventually extremely shear thinning, as illustrated in Figure 5.
breaks and the fibers start to flow in small aggregates.
The aggregates can flow easier than the network,
FI G U RE 5
Viscosity as a function of shear rate for 2% MFC suspension in water. Viscosity drops drastically over the shear rate range
0.2...1000…0.2 s-1 (point time 1 s).
FI GU RE 6
MFC is an ideal thickener for cosmetic spray products. This picture shows how 0.3% MFC (Exilva
MFC from Borregaard) makes an oil in water sunscreen formulation with inorganic pigments (titanium
dioxide) thicker and prevents dripping totally (on the right hand side) compared to reference without
MFC (on the left hand side). Sun screen containing 0.3% MFC is a liquid product whereas adding 1%
MFC makes a thick cream which also can be sprayed without dripping.
When the shear is stopped and the MFC suspension is High viscosity at low shear rates and shear thinning
standing still, the network of fibrils builds up again and behaviour makes MFC a good thickener. For example,
the suspension regains its viscosity. This occurs fast, MFC can be used as a thickener in sprayable sun
and the viscosity goes back to the original value or creams. It allows the spraying of very thick suspension
close to that. Figure 5 illustrates this by showing a flow since the viscosity decreases during the spraying.
curve measured from low shear rate to high shear rate However, when the cream is on the skin and no forces
and back. The upwards and downwards curves are on are applied to the cream, the viscosity retains quickly
top of each other, meaning that the suspension does and the product stays where it was applied and does
not show any time dependent behaviour and viscosity not drip. Another good example is paints. When they
recovers immediately to the original values when are applied, for instance by brushing, the viscosity
shearing is decreased. Sometimes extensive shearing must be low enough, so that the paint is easy to apply
(mixing) can cause permanent aggregation of the fibers and does not leave brush marks. Immediately after
and lower viscosity of the suspension. However, this application, the viscosity increases. This prevents
rarely occurs in a formulation where there are other dripping and sagging.
substances between the fibrils which prevent them
from aggregating.
HIG H YIELD STRES S AND Stress is measured by applying force on a certain area
IMPROVED STAB ILIT Y of the material, and this force divided by the area
is stress. The stress value where the material starts
A certain amount of force is needed to flow is called yield stress. Figure 7 shows a stress
before a MFC suspension starts to flow. ramp measured for 1.4% MFC suspension. The test
starts with insufficient stress to make the suspension
This means that it has a yield stress.
flow, and therefore the viscosity is extremely high.
At a certain point (yield point), the stress exceeds the
yield stress, the material starts to flow and the viscosity
drops. The yield stress of the suspension in Figure 7 is
above 41 Pa.
FI G U RE 7
Stress ramp measurement showing the yield point for 1.4% MFC suspension (Exilva, Borregaard).
FI G U RE 8
MFC (Exilva MFC from Borregaard) tested as stabilizer for acrylic based exterior flat paint (45% polyvinylchloride, PVC, solids volume
37%). Reference paint on the left hand side contains 0.31% HEC and paint on the right hand side contains 0.38% MFC. The stability was
tested over 2 weeks at 49 °C. Reference paint showed moderate syneresis whereas syneresis in the paint with MFC was very low. No
settling was observed in either of the formulations.
FI G U RE 9
MFC can hold a lot of water compared to its mass. This pic-
ture shows 2% MFC suspension in water, which is creamy or
gel-like even if it contains 98% water.
Microfibrillated Cellulose has a very high aspect ratio with fibril diameters in the
nanometer range and fibril length in the micrometer range. This high aspect ratio,
together with the high crystallinity of MFC, makes MFC a potential reinforcement of
composites, films and coatings, amongst others.
The strength of crystalline cellulose has been Cellulose in general is biocompatible (Lin and
compared to the strength of Kevlar and various Dufresne 2014) which means it can be used in
composites containing MFC has been described as composite materials used in the human body. For
having tensile strengths greater than cast iron (Moon, example, an MFC/polyvinyl-alcohol composite
2011 and Miao, 2013) coating can be used to reinforce Bioglass-based
porous scaffolds. Bioactive glasses are a group of
MFC is biodegradable and thus a good candidate surface reactive glass-ceramic biomaterials. The
for reinforcing agent in biodegradable plastics biocompatibility and bioactivity of these glasses
and packaging materials. For instance, MFC can has led them to be investigated extensively for use
be combined with polylactic acid and be used as implant materials in the human body, to repair
in nanocomposites. Polylactic acid is a versatile and replace diseased or damaged bone. However,
polymer derived from renewable sources like sugar a problem with this material is its brittleness, which
beets and sugar canes. However, a problem with the causes challenges in load bearing applications. It has
polylactic acid is that it is brittle. It has been tested to been tested to dip Bioglass samples into an aqueous
use MFC to reinforce the polylactic acid composites solution of MFC and polyvinyl alcohol. The addition
and increase the strength. The incorporation of MFC of the MFC/polyvinyl alcohol coating led to a 10-fold
resulted in improved mechanical properties, especially increase in tensile strength of the material (Bertolla,
the toughness of the composite was improved. 2014).
(Nakagaito, 2009).
For further reading on the use of MFC in
MFC makes flexible composites needed in many reinforcement of composites, Miao and Moons
novel applications, like reinforcement of Li-ion ((Moon, 2011 and Miao, 2013) reviews on cellulose
batteries. It has been demonstrated that MFC can reinforced polymer composites and cellulose
be used to reinforce methacrylic-based composite nanomaterials are recommended.
polymer electrolyte membranes. The MFC reinforced
membranes had excellent mechanical properties,
high conductivity and good overall mechanical
performance. Especially the flexibility of the
membranes was very good, and this is interesting
for, amongst others, the use in flexible and extra thin
batteries for flexible electronics (Chiappone, 2011).
BARRIER PROPERTIES
MFC has good film forming properties, and the dried MFC films have been reported to
have very interesting barrier properties. Two parameter that has been studied is the water
vapor permeability and oxygen barrier properties of MFC films (Lavoine, 2012).
The oxygen barrier properties of MFC films are An interesting approach, also subject to studies, is
excellent and have been reported to be comparable to to coat MFC films on polymer films that typically
many well-known synthetic polymer films. The good have good water vapor permeability. As a result a
oxygen barrier properties are believed to be related to good oxygen barrier and a good water barrier can
the crystalline structure of MFC and the ability of the be obtained. This is a new way of producing barrier
microfibrils to form a dense network with inter and materials and could offer the advantages of both the
intra fibrillary hydrogen bonds. polymers and the MFC.
The water vapor permeability of MFC films are also The novel barrier properties renders MFC an
good but not as good as for other polymer films. This appealing new biomaterial for, amongst others, food
is due to MFC’s high affinity for water, but this can packaging, paper coating and printing applications.
be improved by modifying the hydroxyl groups on For further reading on MFC and its barrier properties,
the surface of the microfibrils, either chemically or by a review article from Lavoine and co-workers is
absorption of polymers. recommended (Lavoine, 2014).
3
CRITICAL SUCCES S FACTORS
WHEN APPLYING MFC
When introducing MFC into a formulation one of the most critical success factors is to
make sure that the MFC is dispersed correctly. To make use of the large available surface
area of the MFC, it is important that the product is incorporated properly in the matrix
surrounding it.
The microfibrils in the MFC has high affinity for or milling step that will help the dispersion of the
each other and high shear is needed to obtain good MFC. As an example, MFC can be added in a grind
dispersion. Lower shear equipment can also be used, phase with pigments and fillers, and this will aid the
but then longer time is required. If optimal dispersion dispersion.
of the microfibrils is not achieved, the functionality
and the transfer of the characteristics from the MFC Various types of equipment can be used to disperse
may be lower or less efficient, decreasing the potential MFC. In the lab, the use of high shear equipment,
performance in the finished product. like an Ultra Turrax homogenizer or a Dispermat
disperser, will generally give a good dispersion.
When MFC is added into a formulation there are a few However, lower shear equipment, like a propeller
things that are important to consider. The MFC should mixer, can also be used, but longer time is required.
be added to the most polar phase of the formulation, It is important to ensure that the whole dispersion
preferably in the water phase. For example, in an volume is homogenously mixed and that there is an
emulsion, the MFC should be added to the water efficient transfer of the energy from the stirrer to the
phase before mixing with the oil phase. MFC is a full volume of the dispersion.
robust material and can be added in a homogenizing
4
POTENTIAL APPLICATIONS
The previous chapter showed how versatile material MFC is. This chapter will show examples where
these properties can be utilized, based on Borregaard’s own experience and the literature.
A high variety of rheology performers have been used in coatings for decades, since good control over the
rheology is crucial for the application and quality of the product. We have listed some examples:
• Improving stability: MFC has high yield stress and high viscosity at rest, which is important for the
product´s performance as an anti-settling aid and as anti-syneresis aid.
• Very high pH stability: MFC has shown extremely high stability towards pH. The product can withstand
differences in pH from pH 1 to pH 13, giving flexibility in processing the product as MFC typically can
tolerate any part of the production process when it comes to pH.
• Matting effect: Opaque appearance of MFC gives a matting effect to the final paint or coating products.
This typically eliminates coatings and paints where high gloss is wanted.
• Good spray properties and anti-sag agent: MFC has very high shear thinning capabilities and rapid
viscosity recovery. This behavior makes it suitable for products where rapid response to shear forces is
wanted. Typical example is application by spraying.
• Longer open time and wet edge time: MFC is good at holding water, so it can keep the coating wet longer.
This prolongs the time when corrections or second layer can be applied without brush marks or other
defects.
• Good film and barrier properties: MFC improves the mud-crack and scrub resistance of paints. This
comes probably from the strong and flexible network of the microfibrils, which can resist defects coming
from the drying or external stress (see also Borregaard’s technical bulletin on this topic). These properties
enable thicker layers to be applied, which reduces the number of film layers needed.
• No VOC: MFC will not add any VOC substances to the coating
FI G U RE 10
The anti mud-crack effect of adding Exilva to a
45% PVC exterior acrylic paint was compared
to the same formulation based on a standard
HEC. A film was prepared at multiple thick-
nesses, ranging from 14 through 60 Mils. Exilva
provides increased crack resistance during
curing from 2oC to 24oC (35oF to 75oF) when
added 0.38% to the paint. With Exilva, no
cracking was observed even at 60 Mils thick-
ness (i.52 mm) (lower picture), whereas the
HEC paint displayed cracking for all thickness-
es above 14 Mils (0.36 mm) (upper picture).
See more in Borregaard's technical bulletin.
Adhesives are in many instances increasingly robust and stable product system towards
high variety in pH during production.
manufactured through processes including
a wide range of pH. Thus, pH stability of Since MFC is a water-based suspension, it is suitable
the additives used in these processes is key for waterborne systems, like:
• Waterborne polyurethane formulations
to obtain and maintain functionality of the
• Waterborne epoxy formulations
resin or the finished adhesive. • Waterborne acrylic formulations
• Urea formaldehyde systems
CONSTRUCTION -
RHEOLOGY CONTROL AND INCRE A SED STAB ILIT Y
AG RICULTUR AL CHEMICAL S –
ENHANCED UPTAKE OF HERB ICIDES
One of the less obvious application areas for MFC water on the leaf longer and, in that way, prolongs
is agricultural chemicals. Borregaard has shown that the time the glyphosate is able to penetrate the leaf
MFC enhances the uptake of herbicides (see patent cuticle. However, the mode of action is not totally
application by Øvrebø (2015) and Borregaard’s understood.
technical bulletin) when added to the spray solution
(see Figure 10). After the herbicide has been sprayed In addition to herbicides, other type of pesticides and
on the leaves, it needs to permeate through the leaf fertilizers can be applied by spraying on the fields.
cuticle into the plant. In case of glyphosate (commonly MFC has the potential to improve the uptake of such
used herbicide), this only occurs if it is dissolved in compounds as well. As for the other application areas,
water. Because of the high water holding capacity of MFC can also stabilize suspensions and emulsions, for
MFC, it is reasonable to assume that MFC keeps the example nutrient formulations.
FI G U RE 1 2
Fresh weight of black nightshade plants 2 weeks after treating them with a herbicide solution (glyphosate) (grey column) and glyphosate
and different amounts of MFC (Exilva). Fresh weight is given as a percentage of the untreated plants. The picture shows the same plants
treated with 0.6 mM glyphosate (A) and with 0.6 mM glyphosate + 0.01% MFC (B) 2 weeks after the treatment. MFC improved the effect
of herbicide (lower fresh weight of the plants meaning that herbicide has effectively prevented the growth) and quite low concentrations
were sufficient (0.0025-0.02% of the spray solution). (ref to bulletin)
Flow properties, together with good temperature- and pH stability, makes MFC a good
candidate for oil drilling and other oil production applications.
Drilling fluids are used to carry out the cuttings xanthan gum) (Turbak et al. 1982; Weibel 1983;
from the wellbore to the surface, cool drill pipes Laglois et al. 1997; Laukkanen et al. 2011; Li et al.
and bits, reduce friction between the formation 2015).
and drill equipment, stabilize wellbore and avoid
formation collapse. Drilling fluids should tolerate MFC can also be used in well treatment fluids to help
high temperatures and salt concentrations, be obtain the oil and gas collected from the well (Lafitte
environmentally friendly and safe and be low reactive. et al. 2015). For example, fracturing fluids are used to
MFC fulfills these requirements and it could be used break down the geological formation around the well
in drilling fluids alone or in combination with other bore and create fracture by pumping the fluid at high
polymers (modified polysaccharides, guar gum, pressure. This enhances the production rates.
MFC can improve wet and dry strength in paper and multilayer packaging (Taipale et al.
2010; Kajanto and Kosonen 2012).
It can also be used to increase the amount of fillers MFC can be used for paper coating, since it is shear
in paper, which improves the optical properties and thinning, easy to apply, and the coating layer becomes
reduces the cost by lowering the grammage (Hentze even and thin. This improves the printing properties.
2010). On the other hand, it can make the dewatering However, MFC might reduce the gloss of paper and
more difficult and reduce opacity. MFC can improve possibly suits better for matte paper. MFC coating also
the barrier properties of packages (oxygen and grease improves the oxygen and grease barrier properties.
barrier) and improve the printability. It is very hygroscopic, which can reduce the water
barrier properties, but this can be improved by adding
some hydrophobic elements to the coating.
5
WHAT IS E XILVA AND BORREG A ARD?
FI G U RE 1 3
Borregaard's first of a kind commercial plant for production of microfibrillated cellulose is being built in Sarpsborg, Norway.
REFERENCES