Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
by
Shelly T. R. Treleaven
A Paper
June 2019
i
LEADING AN INCLUSIVE LEARNING COMMUNITY
APPROVED:
Acknowledgements
Our lives are a series of learning adventures; continuing my education has allowed me to
experience the support and kindness that has gratefully been afforded to me by my champions.
Many people have supported me, both when I did not know I needed it and when I did, but did
To my life companion, husband, and champion, Kelly Treleaven: You have been more
supportive than I ever thought imaginable. I am grateful for your inspiration and perspectives; I
even appreciate the not-so-gentle nagging that got me motivated when I needed to get my work
completed. You also took on many new roles while I was preoccupied with my coursework, and
I recognize you were often stretched well outside of your comfort zone. I am not only grateful
for your love and support, but I am certain I could not have done this without you.
To my amazing daughter and champion, Lisa Ducharme: While I have always tried to
model quality character traits, your character has exceeded all my dreams for you, beyond my
wildest imagination. Your love and support has guided me through challenging times, and when
I struggled with perspective or priorities you knew just the right words to kick me in the butt.
Thank you.
To my teaching partner, Katelyn Dalton: Thank you for understanding and allowing me
To my parents and champions, Terry and Carol Susut: These past two years have taxed
my ability to stay connected, but your consistent support and high regard for my abilities never
failed me. I have always felt like you were my two greatest fans and for that I am eternally
grateful.
iii
LEADING AN INCLUSIVE LEARNING COMMUNITY
Leonard, Terry Hoganson, Janice MacDonald, and Gwen Baxter: Thank you for being a part of
this learning adventure with me. Through the laughter, tears, conversations and time together we
To Gloria Antifaiff: You have been such a strong anchor for my enthusiasm. I appreciate
how you were able to take my scattered thoughts and ideas to helped me form a clear vision
while modelling grace and patience. You have been more than just an instructor or advisor; you
And last but not least, to the many Wolf Creek leaders who offered their time, guidance
and support when I had questions: Robin Irvine, Darin Ratzlaff, Marica McWhinnie, Karen
Weidner, Corinne Thorsteinson, Alda Lovell, and Danica Martin. Thank you.
iv
LEADING AN INCLUSIVE LEARNING COMMUNITY
Abstract
Leading a learning community, where the instructional leader’s role is to nurture and
sustain a culture that supports an inclusive learning community, requires a deep understanding of
structures and strategies that support inclusion. If leadership is to be truly inclusive, it must
promote the ideals of inclusion, democracy, and social justice more generally (Ryan, 2006). The
concept of inclusion in an educational setting expects that all people, regardless of their abilities,
have the right to access social, economic, political, or cultural systems. Society assumes
everyone deserves to be included fairly in all systems and practices not only in society but in
school as well (Ryan, 2006). As Ryan (2006) stated, “inclusive leadership is a process, an array
of practices, procedures, understandings, and values that persist over time” (p. 17). Many
practices and procedures are available through a variety of sources, however developing
One of the greatest challenges faced by classroom teachers involves how they support a
student who is differently abled. These students may require differentiation, modified
behaviour, or additional one-on-one time to learn. Added to this challenge is the expectation to
This study explored a variety of strategies and promising practices for instructional
leaders to develop and maintain a culture that both nurtures and supports all types of inclusion in
the modern school and classroom. Teachers require support as students are no longer removed
from a typical public school classroom to be provided support from someone other than the
primary teacher. Sometimes when a student with significant needs required support, the
teacher’s first request was for an educational assistant. Educational support in the form of an
v
LEADING AN INCLUSIVE LEARNING COMMUNITY
additional adult in the classroom while at times is necessary, it is not always possible. Even if
the teacher has the desire to be inclusive, in the absence of an inclusive culture along with
support structures, a teacher will struggle. What then is a teacher to do? The focus of this study
was to advocate for inclusion and to support leaders with structures and strategies to employ as
an educational team. Supporting teachers and other educators through developing common
values and beliefs on inclusion will allow an instructional leader to help sustain actions that
Table of Contents
Acknowledgements ……………………………………………………………………………….ii
Abstract ………………………………………………………………………………..…...…… iv
Introduction ………………………………………………………………………………..….. 7
Collaboration. ………………………………………………………………………………20
Recommendations …………………………………………………………………………… 24
Suggestion …………………………………………………………………………………… 21
Conclusion …………………………………………………………………………………… 27
References ……………………………………………………………………………………… 29
LEADING A LEARNING COMMUNITY 1
Alberta Education has stated that inclusion is a way of thinking and acting that
demonstrates universal acceptance of, and belonging for, all children and students (Alberta
Education, 2018). Within the context of school leadership, the expectation of instructional
leaders is that they will promote success for all learners. Achieving this success is complex and
requires significant consideration of the barriers that are faced both by the student whose needs
are to be addressed and by those in the building who are supporting the needs of each student. It
goals with the same understanding. Knowing that one must embrace diversity and promote
equal opportunity for every student is essential. One of the six principles of inclusion outlined
by Alberta Education is shared responsibility (Alberta 2018). DuFour and Mattos (2013)
indicated that collaborative cultures, where there is collective responsibility for students’
that staff are to work together to build understanding for the pursuit of success for all learners,
then the instructional leader needs to facilitate this. School budgets are tight and money to
provide time for teachers to collaborate during the typical school day is largely out of the
question, but given the opportunity to create learning teams around strategies to support each
other for the purpose of student success is a goal that all teachers can understand and work
toward.
LEADING AN INCLUSIVE LEARNING COMMUNITY 2
establish strategies for inclusion requires a shared vision. Together the team would develop
classroom structures in that differentiation is not only possible, but natural to facilitate. How
these structures are developed will require instructional leaders to communicate celebrations and
share successes of the team, as well as the struggles, in order to support everyone and to ensure a
culture of inclusion that works at multiple grade levels. Through a collaborative framework it
Background Information
Historically, any person with any sort of handicap or disability was “excluded from
general society and largely ignored” (Brown & Andrews, 2014). Then in the early twentieth
century, persons with a handicap or disability were seen as having undesirable genetics. Having
a child with an impairment was a source of embarrassment which led to the institutionalization
of these individuals, and they were often medically altered to prevent them from procreating
(Forced Sterilization, 2018). This was not only an expensive strategy but had moral and human
rights implications as well (Leighton, 2012). From about the 1950s to the 1980s, students were
moved from being separated in different buildings to segregated within regular schools. This
started to look like special education classrooms where students with developmental disabilities
were grouped and segregated from the general population within a typical school (Chen, Lin,
Justice, & Sawyer, 2017). Students were technically a part of the school but still stigmatized and
separated. This was still an expensive program and required additional classroom space as well
as continued to have moral implications (Leighton, 2012). In the 1970s and 1980s, there was
progress made in understanding the human brain and how people learn; educators started to
advocate for a more inclusive model of education (Green & Giannola, 2011). At this time,
LEADING AN INCLUSIVE LEARNING COMMUNITY 3
special education started to follow a medical model whereby students were coded or labeled with
their disability or deficit and funding was attached to these codes (Dalkilic & Vadeboncoeur,
2016). Students with a code, depending on the severity, would typically be provided with a set
level of support. There were still some special classrooms for coded children but more and
more, the teacher had specialized training. The instructional leader’s philosophy of education
and inclusion was often the determinant to the way support for students was managed. In 2009,
the Alberta Education Minister set a new direction for special education. The new direction has
since been reformed and updated which includes the Inclusive Education Policy (Government of
are able to support the evolving role of teachers. Pre-service teachers typically graduate with
minimal training related to exceptional students, including how to best support them in the
classroom, unless they have prior experience or have taken specialized courses. Even with
significant experience and abundant courses on inclusion, there may be components of teaching
in an inclusive learning community that still may need to be addressed. Educators need to
understand how best to identify a student’s needs, be able to collaborate and consult with a
multidisciplinary team, create and maintain an individualized learning plan if needed, create a
multi-modal and multifaceted learning community, in addition to “being flexible and responsive
to the strengths and needs of individual students … [to] ensure all students are successful”
(Alberta Education, 2018). Teachers need their instructional leader to have the skill to support
them. Instructional leaders need to create a culture in which the principles of inclusive education
are at the forefront for all the educators. It is not always possible to add an educational assistant
LEADING AN INCLUSIVE LEARNING COMMUNITY 4
to a classroom; therefore, teachers need specific guidance and ongoing support on how to do
their job without them. It is understood that teaching requires an understanding of a plethora of
strategies where a host of dynamic interconnected elements create the modern classroom, and it
is essential that an instructional leader understands how to nurture and support both the teachers
and/or patterns of behaviour which can be attributed to building a culture which will positively
support inclusive learning communities. Instructional leaders are expected, as outlined in the
Leadership Quality Standard, to nurture and sustain a culture that supports evidence-informed
teaching and learning (Alberta Education, 2018). Under this heading it is explicitly stated that
leaders are to create an inclusive learning community. While these are important and necessary
expectations, the way one does this is not clear as expectations for defining success requires
fluidity and needs to be established by teachers for every individual student and class. Through
research, a variety of structures, strategies, activities, and/or patterns of behaviour specific to this
goal will be identified and made available to instructional leaders looking for support in this area.
The focus of the research was on understanding the diversity of inclusion and this study
was on understanding and compiling resources to answer the following question: How does an
Why does this study even matter? This is the first time in Alberta history where
instructional leaders have separate standards from teachers and are being held accountable for
LEADING AN INCLUSIVE LEARNING COMMUNITY 5
supporting a culture where inclusion is the expectation of all staff. The significance of this study
is to provide support and guidance so instructional leaders are provided tools to allow for success
in both understanding inclusion and understanding strategies for developing an inclusive learning
community. With the implementation of the Leadership Quality Standard it is clear that as
instructional leaders, inclusive learning communities are no longer only the responsibility of the
teachers or the specialists in schools. The instructional leaders will need to support or develop
responsibility for all children and students” (Alberta Education, 2018). As it does not delineate
only those students who are assigned to a teacher; the responsibility includes every student.
Teachers will need to understand the needs of all students and how to support them. This will
require school personnel to adapt and evolve in order to create functional, inclusive learning
communities.
Chapter One of this study provided the reader with an introduction to inclusive education.
In providing the purpose and significance of the study one saw the expectation to respond to the
education and the way this impacts the classroom was shared, as well as how inclusion has
inclusive learning community. The literature review focus is on strategies, structures and
behaviours of an instructional leader. Ideas will be provided on how they can incorporate the
Chapter Three will provide a summary of the challenges pertaining to inclusive learning
communities and offer the recommendations for instructional leaders on the behaviours,
structures and actions necessary for the creation of an inclusive culture that nurtures, develops,
Introduction
Historically the formal leaders in the building were teachers who were willing to take on
the role of ‘Principal Teacher’; over time this responsibility has continued to change and has
included financial manager and human resource officer, to name a few of the additional roles.
The new Alberta Leadership Quality Standard that will become official in September of 2019,
contains nine competencies along with indicators. The newest competencies include supporting
the application of foundational knowledge about First Nations, Metis, and Inuit, and embodying
visionary leadership. Meeting the competencies might pose some challenges as the document
offers indicators that may demonstrate competency, but it is not an exhaustive list.
time when it is formally acknowledged and expected that formal leaders will support teaching
and learning. There are many examples of the strategies that leaders may employ to develop
competency, but the focus must remain on the overarching goal of the Alberta education system -
which is to ensure the success of all learners. A person’s role in an educational setting may have
been either a learner or a teacher. The new Teacher Quality Standard, that will also be
implemented in September 2019, states that teachers are to remain career-long learners. This
implies that while the leader is to lead the learning community, there is a combined responsibility
for the development and implementation of appropriate strategies while ideally holding each
other accountable for supporting the learning community. When it is stated that the goal is to
ensure the success of all learners, one ought to assume this implies the teachers as learners as
well. Teachers are naturally supportive and inclusive, but may lack strategies or knowledge of
inclusion and/or may be reluctant to admit their struggle with some learners. If the culture is not
LEADING AN INCLUSIVE LEARNING COMMUNITY 8
inclusive, then it is likely to become one of exclusion. Inclusion is a challenge if the perception
is that those who are differently abled or those requiring support are perceived as though they are
a problem requiring fixing or an issue needing to be dealt with or managed. In the fourth
competency of the Leadership Quality Standard a leader is to nurture and sustain a culture that
creates an inclusive learning community. The question remains, how does one create the
Definition of Terms
build capacity for change and improvement (Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, 2017).
• Inclusion - A way of thinking and acting that demonstrates universal acceptance of, and
• Instructional Leader – The person/people who inform and support the instruction and
development of educational strategies. This may, or may not be formal leaders within the
• Leadership – Anyone who holds themselves accountable for finding the potential in
Why Inclusion?
One must start with a genuine understanding of inclusion. Historically the concept of
inclusion was ubiquitous in reference to programming for students with diagnosed medical
disabilities and other ‘exceptionalities’ (Gilham & Williamson, 2014). This view of inclusion no
longer fits. In order to understand inclusion one must recognize exclusion. Ryan (2006) stated
the following:
All of us have been excluded at one time or another. We may have been excluded by not
being asked out as adolescents or by not being regarded as cool because we were
overweight, shy, or studious. We may have been excluded when we were newcomers to
a school or a neighborhood and people talked about us among themselves. People are
excluded when they are bullied or silenced or ignored. These kinds of exclusions can
arise as the result of personal cruelty or, often, mere thoughtlessness. (p. 9)
Inclusion must recognize the needs of everyone in the educational field. As Ryan (2006)
suggested, when thinking about inclusion one ought to consider the type of access people get to
societal systems: “To what extent do men, women, and children participate in decision-making
and political processes, to employment, and material resources, and to common cultural
processes like education?” (Ryan, 2006). This question is not only for the differently abled; but
rather, the entire population. As educators and leaders there is a moral imperative to develop an
As an instructional leader there are a number of structures and strategies one can employ
to create an inclusive culture. Creating a culture that assumes everyone is included requires the
LEADING AN INCLUSIVE LEARNING COMMUNITY 10
leader to focus “one’s actual efforts in making all people feel that they are included and part of a
team” (Richter, 2013). Having an understanding of how people feel excluded, will provide
insight on methods to ensure this does not happen. Richter shared how “a substantial challenge
with regard to inclusion [is] the challenge of how to create an organizational culture that is
sensitive and open …[and] treats everyone fairly” (p. 510). A key component to achieving this
would require people to engage with those who are different. “Engagement requires a
commitment to move out of one’s comfort zone and create genuine relationships with others
across differences” (Richter, 2013). Building relationships can create a culture of collaboration
which develops commitment to common goals that can be set as a team and achieved.
DeMatthews and Mawhinney (2014) identified that in order for a leader to implement
inclusive practices there are three areas that need to be the focus: school culture building,
resource allocation, and ongoing professional development. For the purpose of this study, it will
be assumed that without a strong school culture, the other elements are unlikely to develop
strong, sustainable inclusive strategies. This chapter will demonstrate strategies and practices, as
identified in the research, that will lead to supporting or creating culture within a school. In
order to create a culture of inclusion the literature provides some behaviours and structures that
are necessary; they include; authentic leadership, a sense of urgency, shared vision and
leadership, safe and caring community, collaboration, trusting relationships, and professional
learning groups.
Authentic leadership.
Being a leader takes courage. Courage to be willing to lean in when things get difficult
and stay active in the process of tackling issues. In order to truly influence people, a leader
needs to understand what inspires people to follow them, and likely the most difficult notion for
LEADING AN INCLUSIVE LEARNING COMMUNITY 11
leaders to face is that they must be authentic. Brown (2013) defined being authentic as
cultivating the courage to be emotionally honest, to set boundaries, and to allow oneself to be
(2002) recognized that vulnerability is not sharing inappropriately with team members, but rather
being honest about how one feels about the work that they are doing. Brown (2018) stated that
fake vulnerability is not only ineffective, but it breeds distrust. People may feel manipulated in
this case. Combining the ability to be honest with themselves and others, models the type of
authenticity that engenders people to value one’s opinion. Feedback is a necessary component to
growth and when one is receiving the feedback, they need to trust they are receiving honest or
genuine information. If the leader is not sharing authentic feedback, there is no incentive to
improve or change (Kouzes & Posner, 2012). Goffee and Jones (2017) explained authentic
feedback as tough empathy; giving people what they need, not what they want. Some of the
hardest information to receive may also be the most impactful on a person’s practice, and one
only hears it as constructive when it is told honestly from a leader that is trusted.
Strategies on becoming more authentic begins with knowing who you are and what you
believe. Leaders need to be themselves, no matter the situation. According to Quy (2012) the
o Carve out a role that draws upon your strengths every day.
o Recognize that your greatest room for growth is in the areas of your
greatest strengths.
LEADING AN INCLUSIVE LEARNING COMMUNITY 12
o Find ways to manage your weaknesses so you can free up time to hone
your strengths.
o Expand the list by adding other personal values that are important to you.
leaders.
LEADING AN INCLUSIVE LEARNING COMMUNITY 13
o Be prepared for the adversaries that will be created because you have
Being an authentic leader takes courage and willingness to delve deep into who you are as a
person in order to deeply understand what motivates and drives your leadership style. While this
list is not exhaustive, in the search for personal and professional development these strategies
Create urgency.
“Jumpstarting a sense of urgency is vital, whether you want to initiate change or weather
it” (Soto, 2012). Ryan (2009) indicated that the “dark side of urgency” was panic. Setting one’s
focus on short-term survival rather than long-term success placed the focus on survival rather
than improvement (Ryan, 2009). Kotter (2014) also indicated that without a sense of urgency
people will not give extra effort that is often essential. The concept that Ryan (2009) and Kotter
(2014) agreed upon is that complacency replaced the urge to change when there was a feeling
that the change was not necessary. Kotter (2008) defines complacency as “a feeling that a
person has about his or her own behaviour, about what he or she needs to do or not do” (Chapter
2, para. 2). Kotter (2014) explained how complacency could be developed. He stated that if
there had been too much past success, a lack of visible crises, low performance standards, or
insufficient feedback among other factors, they resulted in complacent behaviours. Ryan (2009)
explained the natural tendency for people to relax or slow down after achieving a goal. While
each of these authors confirmed these are natural reactions to success, preserving a sense of
urgency was the only way to maintain continuous progress and growth.
LEADING AN INCLUSIVE LEARNING COMMUNITY 14
While Kotter (2014) stated that there was an eight-stage process to developing urgency,
Ryan (2009) had only five factors and Soto (2012) stated them even more succinctly with only
four factors. While each of these articles indicated a step-by-step process to develop urgency,
The first common factor was to create a higher purpose for the goal. People need to
understand the ‘why’ of change. Once the leader is clear about where and why there is a need
for change, everyone is able to face the challenge with purpose and direction. The second
common factor for creating urgency was to get the right people activated, then empower them.
What this really means is every organization, group, or staff must have a few key members
identified as having the ability to inspire, influence, or drive change. Once the leader involved
these people the next step was to allow these people to guide or lead the others. This creates
group momentum and will inspire and motivate others. The third common factor was to shed the
distractions. In an educational setting this can happen as teachers can get stuck focusing solely
on their classroom and lose sight of the ‘big picture.’ Soto (2012) stated that the only thing
worse than a lack of urgency was false urgency: “People often confuse being busy with having a
sense of urgency, yet they are busy doing the wrong things” (para. 4). An example may be the
teacher who states there is no time to try anything new, they may be so caught up in the day-to-
day activities they have lost sight of the purpose of professional development; to improve their
practice. The final step to building a strong sense of urgency was to communicate relentlessly.
Communication is key as complacency happens when people are not reminded of the outside
factors that drive the need for change and this is the enemy of urgency. Ryan (2009) stated
“when someone in your organization – regardless of their level – moves quickly to make
something happen, thank them and make sure everyone knows about it. Small acts of urgency
LEADING AN INCLUSIVE LEARNING COMMUNITY 15
have the power to inspire larger ones” (para. 11). Kotter (2008) added to the concerns when
describing the ‘NoNos’, these are people who are not skeptics but rather relentless urgency-
killers. The ‘NoNos’ would have a group remain complacent and would sabotage the group
teachers who either cannot or will not make changes to their practice stating that if the current
strategies are working, why change. Developing strategies and support for those in the school
prepared to resist complacency and be active in the changes is essential for cultural growth. The
more information and clarity the instructional leader can offer, the stronger the commitment and
urgency.
Of the four factors in creating a sense of urgency the two that may be the most significant
are being clear about where and why there is a need for change, and communication. People
typically internalize and respond more positively to change when they are clear about the
purpose and understand why there is a need for the change. According to Soto (2012), the more
clarity around the topic of change one is able to articulate, the greater likelihood of success at
Kouzes and Posner (2012) stated that leaders tend to assume their responsibility is to
create the vision and to lead the team. While this may seem intuitively correct, Kouzes and
Posner (2012) cautioned that people want to be part of the vision development process as nobody
likes to be told what to do or where to go. When educators are not involved in developing the
approach to inclusive learning, the leader is likely to find the progress extremely challenging and
are likely to experience strong push-back from those under their leadership. Kotter (2014) stated
that without a vision to guide decision making, each and every choice that is made can result in
LEADING AN INCLUSIVE LEARNING COMMUNITY 16
an interminable debate. A leader cannot make people do things they see no purpose in;
therefore, it is critical to include them and allow them to aid in developing the vision for
inclusion.
Hoppey and McLeskey (2013) stated that principals need to not only engage in fostering
a shared vision but they also needed to develop teachers as leaders within the school through
distributed or shared leadership. They stated that through distributed decision making and a
shared approach to leadership one can build a strong sense of community and this will develop
ownership of the team goals. In other words, one needs to allow the educators the responsibility
to make meaningful decisions about how their work will be accomplished (Kouzes & Posner,
2012). Once the collaborative work has been completed that creates a shared vision, utilizing
In order for distributed leadership to be effective it will include not only the leadership
team, but will be fully representational of the larger school community (Bill and Melinda Gates
Foundation, 2017). The Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation (2017) on their website, lists tasks
progress;
LEADING AN INCLUSIVE LEARNING COMMUNITY 17
It is important to note that distributed leadership is not about dividing the tasks among a variety
of individuals, but rather purposeful and guided collaboration to incorporate a growth mindset to
develop high-quality teaching as well as accentuate the culture so that the forefront of the focus
Trusting relationships.
Creating a climate of trust is of utmost importance. Kouzes and Posner (2012) indicated
that trust is the central issue in human relationships and without trust a person cannot lead.
Individuals who are unable to trust are not able to lead because they are unable to be dependent
on the words and work of others. Their lack of trust is obvious and results in others not trusting
them. Kouzes and Posner (2012) stated that “trust is a strong, significant predictor of employee
acceptance of the leader’s influence, and team and organizational performance” (p. 219-220).
There are many definitions of trust, but Lencioni (2002) defined it as “the confidence among
team members that their peers’ intentions are good, and that there is no reason to be protective or
careful around the group” (p. 195). Lencioni (2002) shared the characteristics and behaviours of
● Give one another the benefit of the doubt before arriving at a negative conclusion;
● Look forward to meetings and other opportunities to work as a group. (p. 197)
While Lencioni (2002) suggested a number of methods to build trusting relationships, he stated
that the “most important action a leader must take to encourage the building of trust on a team is
uncertainty, risk, and emotional exposure” (p. 19). Brown (2013) stated that “most people shield
themselves in masks and armor rather than be vulnerable and that it is the last thing we want
people to see in us, but it is the first thing we look for in others” (p. 113). According to Brown
(2018) most people equated vulnerability to weakness, but stated that of all the skills a leader
needs to develop, vulnerability takes the most courage. Brown (2018) stated that as a leader, one
of the primary strategies in order to establish a trusting team, requires one to pull off the armor
Creating a community where everyone can feel both included and safe is not something
that can be dismissed. In order for a school environment to feel inclusive, the people in the
building need to feel cared for and safe (McLinden et al., 2018). People do not participate or
become a creative problem solver if they are unsure of how others will respond to them. Brown
(2018) discussed the items that impede psychological safety in teams or groups, and they include
judgement, unsolicited advice giving, interrupting, and sharing outside the team meeting. Brown
goes on to include the behaviours that people need from their team or group almost always
includes listening, staying curious, being honest, and keeping confidence. McNamara (2013)
LEADING AN INCLUSIVE LEARNING COMMUNITY 19
skills, needed to start with the instructional leaders reviewing policies and programs and
afterwards making certain all the adults in the building received training. McNamara shared
research and evidence based programs that indicated the first step was to create awareness.
McNamara (2013) indicated that many teachers were unaware of the severity of bullying
behaviours in schools and how these behaviours impacted the perception of safety for students.
Prior to implementing a program, students and staff needed to be included in a needs assessment.
Often what happened was that due to specific behavioural gaps or exceptional students within the
school, there was a deficit in a specific targeted skill that was identified by polling the needs of
the people in the school (McNamara, 2013). Ryan (2006) goes so far as to say that school safety
is not only about bullying policies but rather creating a haven for learning and expression where
Strategies for building a safe and caring school community are essential in developing an
inclusive culture. Haynes (1996) offered 12 precepts they felt were critical to establishing this
environment:
• Parent involvement.
311)
Using these precepts to instill a foundation of safety and well-being at school is inextricably
linked with the students’ ability to perform well academically as stated by Haynes (1996).
Collaboration.
Collaboration has been identified as a critical competency for achieving and sustaining
high performance (Kouzes & Posner, 2012). In any school, team or group there are a number of
people who bring with them a variety of skills and knowledge. Collaboration is the tool that can
leverage the individual skill and knowledge to create something amazing. A team that works
together utilizing collective abilities is likely to accomplish significantly more than a single
individual. The struggle with building collaborative skills is the natural tension created due to
conflicting interests and divergent thinking. The role of the instructional leader is to create a
One of the strategies that supports collaboration and collective responsibility for the
DuFour and Mattos (2013) “the PLC process has two powerful levers for changing adult
behaviour: irrefutable evidence of better results and positive peer pressure” (p. 38). DuFour and
Mattos (2003) stated that the instructional leader who creates the PLCs needed to focus on five
key steps which are: form teams where members share the responsibility to help all students
learn essential content and skill, provide teams with time to collaborate, help clarify the work the
teams need to do, and ensure teams have access to resources and support to accomplish their
LEADING AN INCLUSIVE LEARNING COMMUNITY 21
objectives. Another perspective on the role of PLCs came from McLeskey, Waldron and Redd
development. They indicated the key qualities would include a focus on teacher identified needs,
limited ‘sit and get’ forms of professional development, support would be embedded and
supported by coaching in the classroom and offered over an extended period of time and expect
committed to them can be a challenge. As indicated earlier by Kouzes & Posner (2012) the
natural tendencies of people to hold their own ideas in higher regard along with their own
priorities remains a challenge for the instructional leader. Through sharing increased learning
and achievement results for students and the professional benefits of collaboration as DuFour
and Mattos (2003) indicated, educators will see the benefits of collaboration.
school community to be authentic in order to build trusting relationships so that all feel safe
when developing a shared vision as part of a collaborative team. The Leadership Quality
Standard applies to all leaders and the literature reviewed for this study offers strategies,
structures, and behaviours that indicated achievement of many of the listed competencies.
LEADING AN INCLUSIVE LEARNING COMMUNITY 22
Summary of Findings
Through this study, it was evident that consistent patterns of behaviour, activities,
structures, and strategies can be learned and exhibited by an instructional leader. Literature
authentic behaviours, built trusting relationships, created a sense of urgency, made certain people
felt safe and cared for, all while having distributed leadership among the staff and ensured there
was a shared vision. These qualities are all needed to create an inclusive learning community.
inclusive learning community. Being authentic and being willing to be seen as an individual for
an instructional leader is not only valued, but is necessary to inspire people to follow. In other
words, an instructional leader needs to have the courage to be emotionally honest and be willing
one’s life, but rather the willingness to let others understand your thoughts about important
ideals. Behaviours that develop the necessary trust are needed to build strong relationships that
Those who have always felt included may be complacent. Complacency is the belief that
things are good enough and therefore there is no need to change. Preventing complacency by
inciting a sense of urgency was identified as a key skill of an instructional leader. If people are
to change they must want to, and this will not happen if they see no reason to change. The
instructional leader must identify the higher purpose or the why of the goal, and once there is
understanding, activate the key staff that have the power to influence their peers. Urgency will
LEADING AN INCLUSIVE LEARNING COMMUNITY 23
inspire perseverance and prevent distractions from shifting the focus. The leader then must
continue to communicate relentlessly with their team on progress towards the goal.
Inclusion cannot happen unless students feel safe and cared for. One structure that had
significant impact on an inclusive culture required staff to review the implementation of anti-
bullying policies and procedures. The research indicated that when anti-bullying policies and
procedures were consistently employed by all staff, there was a significant increase in feelings of
safety. When adults respond to concerns of students with predictable consequences, the
perception of caring within schools is positively impacted. Making certain staff are consistent
with the expectations for positive behaviours from students created a safe and caring culture of
When a leader was willing to have staff demonstrate and build their leadership skills
among their peers, this willingness developed compassion and empathy for each other. Sharing
the leadership by distributing it equitably through the staff, built a strong sense of community
and developed an ownership of the team’s shared goals. As part of this inclusive learning
community, recognizing and leveraging the skills and attributes of the staff added to the positive
Providing opportunities for the entire staff to participate in creating a shared vision of
inclusion is one strategy that instructional leaders need to employ to develop a positive outlook
towards inclusive learning communities. When all people feel that their voice is heard and
common goals are developed, the literature indicated a positive impact on the learning of all
students.
Inclusive learning communities are important because all people are of value and
providing appropriate support should not depend on whether a student has met typical
LEADING AN INCLUSIVE LEARNING COMMUNITY 24
expectations. Instructional leaders who know the skills necessary to create an inclusive learning
community will be at the forefront of our educational future, as supporting learning for all
remains an ongoing focus in the Leadership Quality Standard. With ever-changing needs in a
classroom, teachers will need to adapt and with capable and visionary leaders who understand
the imperative need to develop a positive inclusive culture they will have the necessary support
they need to ensure that all students are able to succeed. Supporting collaboration inspires
collective responsibility for the success of all learners; therefore, a focus on creating a climate
The literature reviewed in this study offered instructional leaders a variety of suggestions
for behaviours, activities, structures and strategies for attaining competency for the Leadership
Recommendations
With the focus always on students, instructional leaders need to create and sustain a
culture that supports an inclusive learning community. Here are five recommendations for
3. Authentic communication
The first recommendation is to make certain that all instructional leaders understand and
believe in inclusion. The goal would be to have leaders able to model an inclusive learning
community through their leadership practices. Teachers look to their leaders for their opinions
LEADING AN INCLUSIVE LEARNING COMMUNITY 25
about what to spend their time on and what to learn more about. If the principal expresses fear, a
lack of knowledge or dislike about inclusion, then the teachers may follow. Conversely, if the
principal displays knowledge about or a desire to have involvement in inclusion, the rest of the
staff will be inspired to do so as well (Van Horn, 2011). Ensuring leaders have access to
excellence through pre-service and in-service training is central to making educational settings
more inclusive” (Mag, Sinfield & Burns, 2017). No matter the size of staff, there must be a clear
understanding about the cultural characteristics of inclusivity needing to be developed. All staff
should have the desire and willingness to learn in order to implement inclusive learning
persevere while developing their structures and skills to sustain their own inclusive practices.
For a truly inclusive learning community to exist, ongoing targeted and specialized training
needs to be provided for all people working in schools. The gifts, exceptionalities, and
challenges evident in a school population, whether staff or student, would be the determinant to
the professional development that would need to be available for staff. Optimally all training
and learning opportunities would be reviewed and selected collectively by all staff, ensuring
and relentlessly. Through communication they will be actively involved in supporting all
learners within the community. Utilizing authentic collaborative feedback of the challenges and
successes of the individuals will support the growth of the educational community. The purpose
LEADING AN INCLUSIVE LEARNING COMMUNITY 26
inclusion.
(PLCs) designed to support the needs of teachers and students. Kugelmass and Ainscow (2004)
be integrated in the school’s culture. They also explained that a common belief that the
differences in students and staff are a resource, rather than a concern, indicated successfully
inclusive educational communities. Ensuring all staff were committed to the collaborative team
through shared time for meeting and planning every week not only provided support for the
teacher, but also allowed the group to remain focused on a common vision with the focus on
success for all learners. One person would not be expected to know everything or support
everyone, but rather the team would develop individual talents and passions to build capacity for
A fifth recommendation is for instructional leaders to create a clear and shared vision of
how to develop inclusive practices in their community. Through cultivating an appreciation for
the group culture one can influence change which supports the learning needs in an inclusive
where all groups, not only those of administration or powerful individuals and groups, but
equitably from all segments of the school community (Ryan, 2006). Including parents in
developing the vision adds to the collaborative efforts of the community and the parents are then
able to commit and support the teacher in the classroom. “No educational enterprise will
succeed if students, teachers, parents, and administrators do not share some common
understandings about inclusive values” (Ryan, 2006). The leader must focus on growth and
LEADING AN INCLUSIVE LEARNING COMMUNITY 27
forward momentum as implementing inclusive strategies and creating this culture may require
At this time there are numerous articles and research papers with information on
inclusive education, the struggle is with lack of urgency or focus for professional development.
What is needed are in-service and opportunities to develop individual and group skills for
Further study would provide a significant benefit to the inclusive learning communities if
there was research completed on the inclusion practices and cultural changes needed for
LGBTQ2+ and First Nation, Metis, and Inuit students in the field of education. These are two
areas where training has typically been voluntary or has previously had limited focus; however,
ensuring an environment of inclusion for these groups will be paramount in the coming years.
Conclusion
Inclusion is a moral imperative and it needs to be understood. Mag, Sinfield, and Burns
All children benefit from inclusive education, because it allows them to: develop
individual strengths and gifts, with high and appropriate expectations for each child,
involve their parents in their education, foster a school culture of respect and belonging,
differences, lessening the impact of harassment and bullying, develop friendships with a
wide variety of other children, each with their own individual needs and abilities and
positively affect both their school and community to appreciate diversity and inclusion on
For those inspired to be instructional leaders, recognizing the importance of how their own
values, biases, priorities, and beliefs impacts their leadership is essential. One needs to be clear
on one’s own goals and be prepared to articulate why their vision has purpose and significance
all while being prepared to create a common vision as an educational community. The skills
necessary to build an inclusive educational community are no longer a secret. This study found
learning to build these inclusive communities requires one to practice authentic, collaborative,
trusting leadership with a sense of urgency and vision. Developing these skills is both possible
Leadership matters and school communities deserve to have people committed to their
success. Leaders need to have a strong understanding of inclusive educational communities and
the culture that supports them, however, inclusion is not only a mindset of a culture but a way of
life. Given a choice, no one intentionally chooses to struggle. With a focus on what people have
to offer and the skills which can be built upon, we will honor the challenges many people face
when we support and celebrate them. My hope is that one day the focus will no longer need to
be on inclusion, as people will assume and behave as there is no other way. Supporting all
students, with a focus on leveraging their talents and abilities will be the norm. Given the
diverse nature of the challenges that are needing to be faced, no one person can do it all.
Developing an approach to implement the changes needed for a culture of inclusion – must be a
team effort!
LEADING AN INCLUSIVE LEARNING COMMUNITY 29
References
https://cassalberta.ca/resources
Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. (2017). 4 key things to know about distributed leadership.
distributed-leadership/
Brown, B. (2013). Daring greatly: How the courage to be vulnerable transforms the way we live,
Brown, B. (2018). Dare to lead: Brave work. Tough conversations. Whole hearts. New York,
Brown, R. I. & Andrews J. (2014). Special education. In The Canadian Encyclopedia. Retrieved
from https://www.thecanadianencyclopedia.ca/en/article/special-education.
Chen, J., Lin, T., Justice, L., & Sawyer, B. (2017). The social networks of children with and
Dalkilic, M., & Vadeboncoeur, J. A. (2016). Re-framing inclusive education through the
DeMatthews, D., & Mawhinney, H. (2014). Social justice leadership and inclusion: Exploring
DuFour, R. & Mattos, M. (2013). How do principals really improve schools? Educational
http://proxy.cityu.edu/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=
eue&AN=86921387&site=ehost-live&scope=site
Forced Sterilization. (2018). In Global Issues in Context Online Collection. Farmington Hills,
http://link.galegroup.com.proxy.cityu.edu/apps/doc/CP3208520210/GIC?u=cityu_main&
sid=GIC&xid=f8f92348
Goffee, R. & Jones, G. (2017) Practice Tough Empathy. Authentic Leadership. La Vergne:
from http://search.ebscohost.com.proxy.cityu.edu/login.aspx?direct=true&db=nlebk&AN
=1798825&site=ehost-live&scope=site
https://www.alberta.ca/inclusive-education.aspx?utm_source=redirector
Green, L. S. & Giannola, D. C. (2011). 40 active learning strategies for the inclusive classroom:
Haynes, N. M. (1996). Creating safe and caring school communities: Comer school development
Hoppey, D., & McLeskey, J. (2013). A case study of principal leadership in an effective
Kotter, J. P. (2008). A sense of urgency. Boston, Mass: Harvard Business Review Press.
Retrieved from
LEADING AN INCLUSIVE LEARNING COMMUNITY 31
http://search.ebscohost.com.proxy.cityu.edu/login.aspx?direct=true&db=nlebk&AN=675
063&site=ehost-live&scope=site
Kotter, J. P. (2014). Kotter on accelerating change. Boston, Mass: Harvard Business Review
http://proxy.cityu.edu/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=
nlebk&AN=828246&site=ehost-live&scope=site
Kouzes, J. M., & Posner, B. Z. (2012). The leadership challenge: How to make extraordinary
Kugelmass, J., & Ainscow, M. (2004). Leadership for inclusion: A comparison of international
Leighton, D. C. (2012). The effects of symbolic and realistic threats on moral exclusion from the
scope of justice (Order No. 3522046). Available from ProQuest Central; ProQuest
http://proxy.cityu.edu/login?url=https://search-proquest-
com.proxy.cityu.edu/docview/1039267448?accountid=1230
Lencioni, P. (2002). The five dysfunctions of a team: A leadership fable. San Francisco, CA:
Jossey-Bass.
Mag, A. G., Sinfield, S., & Burns, T. (2017). The benefits of inclusive education: New challenges
disabilities: Strategies and techniques to create a safe learning environment for all.
McLeskey, J., Waldron, N. L., & Redd, L. (2014). A case study of a highly effective, inclusive
McLinden, M., Lynch, P., Soni, A., Artiles, A., Kholowa, F., Kamchedzera, E., & Mankhwazi,
M. (2018). Supporting children with disabilities in low- and middle- income countries:
Quy, L. (2012, January 6). 5 ways to become a more authentic leader [Blog post]. Retrieved
from https://michaelhyatt.com/5-ways-to-become-a-more-authentic-leader/
Ryan, J. R. (2009). John Ryan: Creating a sense of urgency among employees. BusinessWeek
http://search.ebscohost.com.proxy.cityu.edu/login.aspx?direct=true&db=bth&AN=43797
735&site=ehost-live&scope=site
Sharma, R. (2010). The leader who had no title: A modern fable on real success in business and
Soto, I. (2012). Creating a sense of urgency. In Ell shadowing as a catalyst for change (pp. 4-
Van Horn, S. M. (2011). The principal's role in managing special education: Leadership,
inclusion, and social justice issues. Available from ProQuest Central; ProQuest
LEADING AN INCLUSIVE LEARNING COMMUNITY 33
com.proxy.cityu.edu/docview/886274472?accountid=1230