Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Censorship in Argentina
Author(s): R. Dwight Wilhelm
Source: International Social Science Review, Vol. 66, No. 1 (WINTER 1991), pp. 21-28
Published by: Pi Gamma Mu, International Honor Society in Social Sciences
Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/41881969 .
Accessed: 16/06/2014 14:29
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Pi Gamma Mu, International Honor Society in Social Sciences is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize,
preserve and extend access to International Social Science Review.
http://www.jstor.org
R. Dwight Wilhelm
Telecommunications Department
Ball State University
Muncie, Indiana 47306
USA
PrintMedia Intimidation
Even such an internationally knownand respectednewspaperas Buenos Aires'
La Prensa was forcedto comply.Followinga visit to Argentinain 1977, Massa-
chusettsCongressman Robert Drinan wrote, "the 108 year old newspaper La
Prensa printswhat it is told to."3
A few did not and, as a result,broughtdown severe consequences on them-
selves. Robert Cox, the 41-year-old O.B.E.-winning editor of the English-
languagedailyBuenos AiresHerald, refusedto capitulateto censorship.The result
was thatin April 1977, he was arrestedand jailed briefly.Afterhis release, he
persistedin ignoringgovernmentgag rules and so had to leave the countryin
December 1979 because of deaththreatsagainsthim and membersof his family.4
Another example of violent action against the press happened in Córdoba,
Argentina'ssecond largestcity,and was directedat thatcity's largestnewspaper,
La Vozdel Interior( The Voice of the Interior). On January23, 1975, just after
midnight,a delegationfromtheArgentineAnticommunist Alliance, laterrevealed
to be a government-backed secretparamilitarygroup, invadedthe facilitiesof the
paper. Employees were rounded up, the press room sprayedwith machine gun
fire,and explosives were set off. An earlier attempthad been made to bomb the
same newspaper and, on thatoccasion, employees had recognized some of the
would-bebombersas policemen.5It should be notedthat,in Argentina,thepolice
are actually a part of the country'smilitaryforces.
Kidnappingsand unexplaineddisappearancesof workingjournalistswere com-
mon. In April 1977, newspaper executive Edgardo Sajón was kidnapped6and,
laterthatyear,Oscar Serrat,an ArgentinejournalistworkingforAssociated Press
as day editorin theirBuenos Aires office,disappeared on his way to work one
morning.7The followingyear,theeditorof El CronistaComercial (The Commer-
cial Analyst),JulianDelgado, disappearedmysteriously forreasons stillnotclear.8
The most internationallyfamous case was that of La Opinión and its editor,
Jacobo Timerman.At first,his refusalto complywithgovernment censorshipwas
meton severaloccasions withthe confiscationof all copies of his newspaperas it
hitthe streetsof Buenos Aires. Later,therewere visitsto his facilitiesby detach-
mentsof troops. When this still did not bringthe resultsdesired by the govern-
ment, several of his staffwere attackedand severelybeaten by persons never
apprehended.Then, at least one of his staffmembersbecame one of the early
desaparecidos (disappeared ones) forwhich thatperiod of Argentinehistoryhas
now become internationally notorious.Finally,in 1977, whenTimermanpersisted
in reportingcensored information about humanrightsviolationsby the armyand
federalpolice, raids on militaryinstallationsby various antigovernment groups,
the increasingnumberof persons (usually professionals)who were disappearing
mysteriously, etc., he was arrested,imprisoned,and his newspaperconfiscatedby
the government.Probably,the only thingwhich kepthim also fromdisappearing
was the focusof attentionon his situationby internationalmass media and by the
world Jewishcommunity.He was held in prison by militarydictatorGeneral
RobertoViola formore than a year.
When worldopinion againsttheArgentinemilitarygovernmentfinallybecame
strong,Tïmermanwas strippedof his Argentinecitizenshipand deportedto Israel
in 1979. The governmentseizure of La Opinión and events surroundingTimer-
man's life received much attentionin the world news media. Subsequently,he
wrote of his experiences, includingtorture,at the hands of the militaryregime.
The book, Prisoner WithoutName, Cell WithoutNumber,was published in 1981
by Alfred Knopf. A made-for-television movie by the same name based on the
book aired in the United States on NBC on May 22, 1983, and starredRoy
Scheider as Timermanand Liv Ulmann as his wife.9
Nor were magazines exemptfromgovernment controlor retaliationwhenone of
themprintedsomethingwhich incurredthe wrathof themilitary.One of themost
notable instances of such retaliationwas against Primera Plana (Front Page),
Argentina'sleading news magazine. In 1969, the magazine reportedthetakeover
of a radio stationin Córdoba by a group of retiredarmyofficersto broadcast an
antigovernment attack. The same magazine had also reportedon othernational
unrestand suggestedthat the then-presidentGeneral Juan Carlos Ongania was
about to be overthrown by a right-winggroup.
The press, in general, was being blamed for fomentingunrestin Córdoba, a
hotbedofantigovernment activity,whereprotestingstudentsand workershad been
attackedby the federalpolice at the cost of 21 lives.
So, even thoughtheArgentineconstitutionguaranteesfreedomof thepress, the
militarygovernmentclosed PrimeraPlana and also confiscatedtwo othermaga-
zines whichcarriedstoriesof therumoredoverthrowof Ongania. Commentingon
thechillingeffectthismighthave on the freeflowof news about eventswithinthe
country,Newsweek stated, "Given the pressure he [Ongania] is puttingon the
Argentinepress, readers may not be able to tell very much fromthe papers and
magazines thatcontinueto publish."10
Even the publicationsof religious materialsdid not escape governmentattack.
In September1976, the publicationand distributionof the materialsof Jehovah's
Witnesseswere banned in the country."
Satire and humor,when aimed at the governmentin general or at the heads of
state in particular,were not tolerated.General Ongania was quick to close the
weeklysatiricalTía Vicenta(AuntieVicenta)because it had made funin a cartoon
of his walrus-likemoustache. It had also sarcastically suggested that the two
clasped hands prominenton the Argentinanational emblem be changed to a
militaryboot.
As a result,thepublishersof thedaily Buenos Aires newspaperEl Mundo ( The
World),which had distributedTía Vicenta, replaced its managingeditor with a
relativeof the same ministerof the interiorwho had been orderedby the Ongania
governmentto close the magazine.
When the respectedLa Prensa sided with Tía Vicenta,sayingthatOngania had
committeda "grave error," what resultedwas a furthertighteningof press con-
trols.Police were orderedto confíscatefromthenews vendors' kiosksall copies of
local politicalmagazines, girliemagazines, and anyforeignpublicationscriticalof
Ongania.12
Observations
These specific attemptsof the Argentinemilitarygovernmentsto muzzle all
theirmass media fornearlytwo decades point us towardseveral observations.
First,media censorshipas an effectivemeans of controllingtheflowof informa-
tion into, and within, a countryhas become a thing of the past. In today's
electronicage, itis futileifnot,in thefinalanalysis,impossible. Whereas national
channelsof printand electronicjournalismmaybe somewhatcontrolled,multiple
incomingelectronicsignalscannot. In situationssuch as Argentina's,wheremany
broadcast band stationscan easily be picked up fromneighboringcountrieson
readilyavailable transistorizedradios and on car radios, thereis no effectiveway
of preventingpersons withinthe countryfromlistening.And, withsuch a multi-
plicity of signals, jamming becomes impossible. Now, with receptiondirectly
fromsatellites,internalcensorshipis renderedeven more useless.
Second, attemptsat media censorshipare counterproductive.When a people
becomes aware thatnews is being withheldfromthem, rumorsrun rife. In the
absence of reliable information,human naturetends to imagine the worst. This
conditionis exacerbatedwhere thereis already great distrustof the government
and, in addition, it leads to even greaterdistrustand animosity.The personal
experience of the author in the Argentinesituationverifiesthat the numberof
rumorsseemed to runin directproportionto thedegree of media repressionat any
given time. So, the streetswere constantlyalive withdistortedor totallybaseless
reportsabout supposed incidentswhichhad happenedin one partofthecountryor
whatwas about to happenwithinthegovernment.But nobodybelieved theofficial
reportsin the nationalmedia.
Third, the only way a governmentcan hope to controlnews effectivelyis to
preventmedia's access to it in the firstplace. But even thistypeof controlhas its
limits. For media personnel have ways of obtaininginformation.And, unless
bordersare totallyclosed and watched carefully,reporterscan and do cross into
neighboringcountriesand file theirstories. And, once in internationalchannels,
news inevitablymakes its way back to the place of its origin via some medium.
These conclusions are not necessarilypeculiar to the Argentinesituationof the
1960's and 1970's. They only demonstratethatthe Argentinemilitaryregimesof
thatera fell victimto what theyeitherdid not know,or chose to ignore, about
attemptsat mass media censorshipin today's world.
NOTES
'J.Frost, editor,WorldRadio-TV Handbook 1985, New York: Billboard Publi-
cations, 1984, pp. 313-315, 429.
2RobertBrown, editor, Editor and Publishing International Yearbook 1985,
New York: Editor and Publisher, 1985, pp. 57-60.
3Commonweal,February 18, 1977, pp. 103-104.
"ArthurBanks and William Street,editors, Political Handbook of the World:
1982-1983, New York: McGraw-Hill, 1983, p. 25.
'New Yorklimes, January¿4, 1973, p. I.
6Ibid., May 15, 1977, p. 17.
Ubid., November 11, 1977, p. 7.