Urban Governance:

How Democratic?
Stéphanie Tawa Lama-Rewal

5-"
@
-

 #4
4

)#
K4
%<

#4H<#
 >
4
>

-
#4H<-#
!
'TU-

1. Facts


-@

-
<
-

%<
STU- 5-"

""

economic reforms launched in the early 1990s, #4<

%-4%
6---
"
6#

#x6-
 T#4
4
4





%

x

4-

-
-@
#<S
TU-

 
"#-U
4"
T-
4<
4E>@-H- 4

"<U>-

-4%6%
"

- #4<
%
%

4
<
--<
%##4-



%<>#-
K

4
4
'6-

-44 4%
"
46--#
K


-
-
4
< <-
%
6#
<4
4
 -
4%
"4%#-
-)#
K4-

- delivery of urban services, and therefore to
-<‡$#4- 44<-
-"
>5-

/#4--6 ""#-4
--
)#4
#46 4%)4"
4
-4T888U


"

#46

-H -4
<--
4%<>:
<

"4
4
S%
/ -
""#-T%-
-
-4%6"
 --
-4#U-

21
 #
!-
4



# "#T"

#
K-
Š(

#
> OO'MU-#4
%<
"
<


-"%64
"
5-"
4-#-"



>8





%

%
"

#4

"< T6--#
-
K<
-"<>5-%"<
 -

6
<
4>U

-#4

#
6
<#4
#
!<

6--
-%4" 


#<4
"
%<-(4
8
##T(8U -
"
-
46"
-



444- %
"
>-%!"

#6K-

4<
4 -

4<
%
%<&
!"
E>
-6"<
xR ;
-p"#-
ECO


(
-

-

#<$-
 #4##EG6
6
4<
8
-
;!

)-
"#4#- #

"##
K#
4"11>@#@
-6"- 4
"
#4"-

%
(8
6-
"# 
44
>
K44
<
#
!%
"


<K<-
 5-#4#
-



"4#
4

6
> 4<-6"6
<%--
#%
-BGrd
BFth 

##>
5--
"
<%6--" 5-

-
##

 ! " #  
context

5-

4<
K-#6

##-BGrd$$

6-
@

-BFth$$
6-%
@
>5-4<-"

Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :


>
E> @
]
<^T
H-"#U--"
#'

Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship

-
"
K4
6-H#-#--#

-4"
-4"
##>
> @#
K
#
<#4
"'"
T>>
/
U-


-%6---
"%#4#
-"%--


4

#

p
"
#%4
6H-

">5-"

44-
#
4-6-5>$
#4
"
"
6#6--

%--#TGGz

U>
G> 5-4<
#
K
#
<#4
4
"'-BFth$$

4
4
<4
x-6
##x#
4#-4
4

-#

#%


>
F> @""
4%%

%--
%


)"#x-56-->

11
5--?K

(4
8
##T?(8U#EC#
44
"-


%

%-

-#4


T6-U

T-U>

22
#4#
%4<6
--- R-

-#4
4
--

#<
-


-

4 4%
6‡5-BFth
#EG6
>5-4"
 $$4#-
6
##

#
-4


%)#4
4

%6
"4

"
 


-"

466">$
 -#

<x-6
>

"#6
K@
 -4"-
%4
"

>-

 in a restrictive way, and in most cities ward
#4
4
T#%- committees are really wards##'-<



U
#-
 H
-"
6
x


<"#


<
K-
 -
/
<

>@


--€@@--> 6

##
<#
K4

56-#
#4
#
 "<x
4#H4%
]##<#^12H" (#%
6-6
##G
46-H"6- ;x%<->@4

4
S-#
-#4
 therefore wards committees only add one
4
--##x
 level of interaction between councillors and
@
$#
""T@$U
 
>(4
"#-
#
%<-
"#
--
 6--
<
"
<4
p
the mayor, who is usually indirectly elected and 4
4
%<>
<-

#
>5-%

the reservations system, many councillors are 6"

"
"4
4

6#6--#
K-##4 %


-
"#-4
6

"
H- 
>#-6
46
4
">$
#4
4
 <
#'--
6-4
4
<

K
-<6--H4
-
-
- 4
##
%<
"#
#
<-
<K6
#<6 T-
--

-#x%6U
many of whom are also unaware of the name of %<(4
4
TK-$"

-
> 7
<(

#;4
OOE
(#%
U>--
4
4


5-
"#H4 #%#4'
#

#4

-6
4
4
-
 T---U4%

-

#4
>#
4%
>
-6"-

4
4

-

level is even more determined by class than it is
2. The Legal and Policy Framework
6-@
TV
OOCU'6-
-
#

%
##4
 5-BFth$$TEU
%
K--
4"4
4
en massex -4

!<4@

#4
4-6-
 6
'TU4

6--BGrd$$
4%
6K6-6-# 
-

#%


-<

4"#
6- 4<
#
%"STU
-

4%
-%
-#4

 
)"##
--"T;--Š5
6
7
#
)&6
OO -
-"
-
6-4

-OEOU> 46--
-%



12
5-

"#4
#
‹(
<))<#Œ#4#<R

(
-<
8
->@
-
<#--
-H"6-(
<%<#4
#
#-#"6--#


#
#%6-
"-
-#
4T-
6




>U
#-
]^-#


%-R#<#>

23
 -
>6"-BFth$$-
%< "
"4%-T

4
<#4#'#4
4" 4%-U
4
"
-
-#4
6
 6%##%-6
##>5-
##-
"%4
"< 87-
%<%<
"6
<S6-##

<4" ->:<-]#87^
-
-#
(4
8
 %<-V &(4<6---
##-
"#4<%# 4
"6%#


> %<-><
6
<-




%-
4
"#-

<")
-
%!"-V
6
-

 4-4"-

-

%
&6
( 44
6-6%%/44
TV &(U)
-OO
44 #
>:
<
-

#4#
-BFth$$-M ###%-4-%


>5-V &(4
<4 6
H#
6-#
K

-4
4
<#
 4
%


44
#
democracy, yet its contribution in the matter has area sabhasEF>

<
-

%"
>:
-


%-
-
%<
%%-V &( %<)4
#-
#44
4

6
-
%

<3"4#8
 -
--(3-
-87
T38U>>
#4-"#< -
%#4#<
'$-

-%
4!-
-
%"4< 8
-$
#;!


?


K
>

4"

#
4"%

"4#>38644 $44


<
-4

K-6--#4 -%!"-


H"
6-<)6% 4<
#<-7
$
3"4#
-
44"%H#< -#T7$3EGU6--

6#
'
# 4
"
-
"T>>(#%
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :

6
-
6
<-
-<#
- 7
"$#%<(7$U

-
4
4
-4-
"< 

"T>>(#%8

#
S6--<
K4
#
<- (8U
44
<K6
-(8
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship

64

-
 (7$>5-4<
6
-(8(7$
38T

OOU> 4
"
#T
<"U
--<
4)
5-V &(
#
K#

<% #-

6
4#4>
#4#
##<8
4
 @%


-#4#
<-
7
6T87U#

-"6-
6
 #4
4
>5-4"
##
#<

#4%6T6-



4
4
<4
-

sabha (or -
"
%4-<U



#%<U6--


4
"
--"S
#4

6


 #

)

%
6-4
"-
EG> 4
"

"
5-


%-
6%#4
 -


<
>5-4"-


EG
--
4
"

<H#
%
)

4
<'-#4
-



]%#
^6-#-##%6-
"<4"
6-4

#
K-#

###4
#
%6#

4
TV-
&
RKOOU>
EF
:

%
/-87$(
%
"-$"
#-<%
#--(H
(
##<8
4
7
6T87U>R-
8
4
‡R-##<‡$"

%
-4'
##>>64>
#OOCO##<)4
4
)
6>4

24
4
<%T6

%
# Box 6. The undemocratic governance of


 Special Economic Zones (SEZs)
-<%<(8
(7$U<
"#-
%6

 5-4

- ,$OO
T?#
Š7
<OOU> -@
"#p4<
6
-
4

H



:
<-&-@#
$T&5@U H4



>5- ,


%<
#
!
"%- 4<#
4#4"
T




#
<>5-&5@$
#U"#

#-
"
<- 
-
H4


(
?
-
K

-
T(?U
 !%6-#
%
6>5-
;%
&
!
-
6
4
OO 
"
%
H
4<# ,

at the national level15%-
%
4 "%-"4 ,
"

"%-

>5-&5@ T6-66U
#-
4
#
K#

<


"  ,> ,
%"4-%<-
"#4"
<#/ 4"

"#

%<
T6-
6H4U6- --
8%8"
8
-4T888U>
GO
<-
44


 5-4-
%"<4"6-
T-4'-#
>">U>@
 #-
BOO44
"
>
46##


 ,-
"4
#4

-
%%<"
4
%

@
>( ,
<

H44
-<46
"4H
>5-<

%<4%
->
-4
-6--#

-
-<
%#4"
6-4>@
3. Political and Academic Debates 

<H4-
 ,6


5-#]"
^-

</ into 50 to 70 new satellite towns (with a
%/6-#-#

# 44
#4%6-


of urban affairs, has been the object of an #
#-
%
U"-
international academic debate, in which H
>
@
4
-
"%#4
 5- ,4<-%!
"<
%>5-"
 "
4>-#-
-

#4
#-"
%
<-  ,H#4<#
"
'
4
-
-6#4

 -

4<
#


4
#
<TV
<

44
% ,--
%

EB-
-KOOGU6---#
< !<
<-4
4
-
--<#-
 "
%<--
-#
)#
K> 4
"TVK?<

5-

#%
--K (K-4
-<
<-#U>
#
"-]
"
^>
-%
H%
<#>

$#@
)%
6#- TOOB'BEBU
-]44

V-

8
-
-
!6 4

-#
#"#4
<

-46K@

6- 
>>>
44#
<


4

4
4
4
 "6K4
^
-]64>>>%4

15
5-&5@
44
%-
V
##
?
-#>

25

"
<

"< %
&
!
-
U-
--

--
4
4

6
 -#
>5-
#

-

#"#q
--

%

 "4%
x

#

q##
--
 %6
44
4%
-
6K4
^>#
<-
!TOOFU
"
6--"
"<
--]4
<^%< #


%<>8%
/
4
4



 -""#
 ;
3-
-#
#-]"<^#4 8
"

(%+-V

#-
]44^6-#%-#" -
"
6--4

#
--

>-4

 "
6-
6--/
---
4%6

 %
">@(#%
-<-
#%

> 8#$
&T8$&U
-
%#-""-#%

5-

#%

-- #6-->5-
#4
#-4-
H4 is now a debate, both in the activist and in the
-#"@
>-4

#4-"-/-
##<
-#-
 ;
#%
"
>3
%
-
-

-
-4 %4%
#
<
%6-"

-
>@@
 T$44

OOEU]
6<4

<T%
U-4
# %
%
#
<^TROO'

%
%<
 FOU‡-
<

-
44
-6%<4
4-
4 #
4-
-

%


#>--
-%- 6
T&<OO%U‡


-
#<4#

-
-<-obligations

%<-4S-
#-4-

4. Good (and Bad) Practices
-
]
6
%
H4
<^> $
"%

Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :

---


4


 "

4

4#6-rights, <>:
EM-
;"#
-%
-#
-
" ?


-
/H4#'-
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship

H4-
]-44-## 84p
#4
3
8
>
#
^><--
-
4%
 K"<6-@

#
<
64
4
#-#
 6
"<

H
-
<"K

-4S< 4
T6"
6

"
<

#
!4
 4U%


4
4
>
-4

-4
 :#EMOOE-
446
-#
-"@
 #%4
4
<4
>?

p
-
4"


 H4#6
/'-
6
<
44<]4#^--4 44-
"S
6
T
ŠECMU> 
"</K<S

%


44-%6
%


Another debate concerns the role of civil society --4
4
<4
T-
#
OOGU>


TU-#
-

 6"6--73#
:
%
"
>$#%-
" 
OOE-H4#6

4
<


-x 4%<-6)#

6)46
-
 "#>
>x<6>$#-(?
T-(
?
-
K

-
 ; .#
-#
!#4
4


26
 $%  &$'*+-

@OO-;"#@

4-/@
$-<@
T@3$@U


<-
#4#-/@

4!-<>
-4!"<
6%"
E#%


4-
4-

%#

T4U
#
K-
-@3/>5-@3#
#
K
44"%-

-"
%!"'TU
-
-4

%
6
4
##STU44]
K
^4
#
K
-

-4"%
--%
STU-



ST"U-#>

5-@3
4!-
"K
#T
&
#

-
OEOU
-
4'-
%<<
#

>:-
%
--

%<-4!


-
-



6%4>6-
"
#
/
H4-
#
!

%
%
K
-##
6
/@3
#-#>5--@3

%
6%K6--<


%
6--#
-
-46"
"-44
6
#
>

-
-

@
$-<@
T8

#
3#%OEOU-
<

-
4"
<-6%
4#-#
6-

%
T-@3$@U#
->


#
<>@-
6
%" "-#46
-

"
##

-

@
%
#'

4
--# -(
8
>H4

"
%">-6
-

-
3-(
8


-OOB#4
3-' "


#4#
-#

6
#% -4
4
44-4>


4<%
6

 
46"
ration cards are not an individual document H4-"6x6---<S%-
T-

4
#<6--
 
(
8
#-BOOO4


%"U>#

" ##
"T


<#T-
8$ 
" OOU>
4-%U#4
"#
6--%<
%

"> 8
4
--


5-|/@
p#%-
 4
4
<-#-
-

3-
-4%
%-6- -$"
7
<(

#T$7(U
44
@
#-4"
% 4(#%
>


->
--


-$7((#%
-
"
In India as in many other countries, there are %
%
#
%
4S

#4
"4
#4
4
"
 -6-<#46-
#
<
--


<46>`--#-
"

4-
-
"%##/ 4""
%<-
-4

-]"
^
%!"
%<-

"
44p4
4
>5-6 44

#<-#
>:

27
 Box 8. The Bhagidari scheme T5
6
7
#
)&6
OOBU>@(#%

#$7(4-
"!#4

elections in 2007, and their candidate has been
5-%
4
4
<"
- T,*
-OOBU-
-
OOO%<--(3--
 4
4
<4
##
-4--
3K-4"
-H
#4- electoral abstention of the middle classes, which
4
#4-
4
4
< 
<#4
-#
<

"
>5--#

-<
"#>
]
x"#4
-4^EM is



%6 $#-
"]4--


residents and city administrators in order -#^T
3-p-(18U
"4

#4
4
 ("'-4
##6

4#
<%
">5- 
OOC%
-

-

T|4
-4pU-# 6
4
#-3-"#

<
#
]"4
#
 -
)66<#

#6K6--4
 --6--%

<

##


4
-46- -#-

4


"#"
"#4 >@OEO-4
##66

<4%#^17>@4
--# #
#-##6
-$


#H"<-
"
& 8%$#

(

#
R
$
#
- T$8$(U6
%
T
6



U> "
>6"("!
5--

-##4
< K--

-#<

-#
6K-4T
< %<4
"6--

-
<U--6-- 
-
%

T
U
4
"&R$
-"
 6--4"-#-




#

6-%
" #
%6-6
4
#
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :

meet and debate, with the intention that

%
>
-<
%
T
--
U

$#%/4
-4"
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship

|5
#3-p"##4%#%<
-
%<

#%
<|
44p
K<

#

6-3-
$-

--#>5--

-#
8
-x6
6--(-
"
6


%4
%<-
4
<
-###]

%-
-
<
"
^>-

#

%

-#4
-


-K<-"

%
4
"<
<3->
4
K

#<
4
<>5-
"

%<
#4"
#


3-&R
$
 4-
K#
!%


T&R$U-
"""
4-
 as well as the name, function and contact of the


<-
"# 4-
<
#4
4
-#4
4

-<-
" towards a true accountability of administrations

6-

4-%
 >6"-
#4
-
4
#"#-4"

 -
#
<4TU-
4
<
6
"<6--#
<4" 
-44
-

EM
-4'-">>
17
3-#T%---

-#3-;"#OOBU
18
:OGOOEO>

28


-#x6-- -
"<6K6

-
/-""#
"
< ; 4
-BF-$$#-
-
]#<<
44
^--
 %

46>
T
!OOM'EEUS
TU-H

<"

#-
#x $-%
"%
"

6--<
-#4#
 
#

'-6
<"

-&-@#
>
"4
4

#%<
>
$##4
4
#4

:
<
##%
- 
46-#4
4


4bandhT
KU 4
4
<-#
#
>
dharnaT)UgheraoT
4
4-
-<U
-
"-6-4
- 6. Policy Recommendations
<>:
--
-K 
"4%6
<#46

3-OOM
-#4#
 )"#
#
K#4"
-6(
8

4
" <6> #46

#4-"
#"
 
6-
#
K%

#
%"'4
#4
8@719 street "
#"%

4>#
<6
-K

-#
44
-
%4
"
demonstrations called by the traders, and joined 4%
-4<6>
%<
-446--- At the same time, it is necessary to create
"#
4#H
" 4

%6

-
#4
#-(
8
-
 4
"-
44
-

66-
<->5- would involve middle class residents as well, in
4H#4-66- "
-#-#

-
%#%
44 6K%<->5-6-

--%<4>R-44 %<"%-
"


#4#
-(
8
T>> T6-
-)OEO)

-44U
"

" ]%K

4

^U6


-
-(
8
6
%%<
6 T
U##>
44"K-
!-



-!<-44 E> 5-(
<))<#-%

-44#H

> 
20'5-#4
#


<#4#6
"
5. Barriers H"
-<--
-
5-#
%

#4#
- (
<> "-(4
##
4-

4<#% #
%<-
4
<
#
!


-

 -#4#
-(4

---
46
 4
p--4%
%<
"4


>R- -(
<))-

--
44
-

"# "#>

19
5-8%@7


4
%--
<ECO@
6-%<
4





44
--
K
#<
6-4%

K"---
4




"4
<>
20
5-##
4--
-‹((4
7
6Œ44
%<-(<%
3"4#
-
#6K-V &(6--
"
'] H"46"6- #46
##^S]:"<
#
(
<-
#
^S
]8"6

6
##^>

29
 > 5-(
<-%<%< F> 5-(8(7$7
$
3"4#
"
"<
>3 -#-%44

"
as well as a tenure that matches that of the -
"%4%<
#%
#4
4
6 %">-%-<
-"%<-(
<"
 4
"6-
--


4
" 

-<>

)"#")„)"

 $
-#
6-


-6%<-5
# credibility in the eyes of voters and

H4-
> 
>

G> -%<#


<4" > 5-##<8
4
7
6-%
6-6
 #4"x

6
#

!
%>5-
 4
-"

4
-
-
TU#
<-# 4-
<x
#4#>
are newcomers (because of the rotation of 5-"4#-%-
"#
"U
TU-<-
" -4

-
-6-
#
6K6-
6-
# class residents are concerned with local
H4-
-<
>$
 


-#>:

6#46#
K-% area sabhas are much needed to channel this
-4
"> <
##
6
<>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship

30