Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
1
Asst. Prof. Institute of Education, LCWU, Lahore
2
MS Education, Lahore College for Women University, Lahore
Email: asmakazi@hotmail.com
Making a career choice is a defining phase in every student’s life. Students have to consider several
factors before arriving at a decision. The purpose of this research was to see the factors which affect
the choice of career among students. This study investigated the influence of several factors such as
parental education, profession and income on the career decisions of 432 students from two public
sector universities in Lahore city. The influence of peers on the respondents’ choice of subject
specialization was also investigated along with any impressions taken from the media. It also
examined whether students at the MS level opt for their chosen fields forcefully, make compromises,
or make decisions which are independent and without external pressures. Data was collected through
a questionnaire and in-depth interviews. The results show the parents influence as most significant,
followed by influence from peers, gender, print media, financial reasons, interest and others.
Key Words: Career choice, career influences, student autonomy, higher education, Universities
Introduction importance of dialogue with peers,
The influence of career choice has a sessions with college counsellors, and
lasting impact on an individual. It serves to discussions with parents and teachers on
be a predictor and determinant of their career selection as “career convention” or
prospective level of income, nature of “career conference”. According to him
work and consequently leaves a mark on “career convention is an instrument of
the personality, demeanour and outlook of career information”, and entails the
an individual. Thus one wrong decision following:
can change the fate of an individual. It is 1. To create awareness regarding areas of
difficult for everyone to make a decision interest and prospective career fields.
regarding their career. This individual 2. To help in shortlisting preferable jobs.
action is manifested on a larger scale in the 3. Provides opportunities in which
economic prosperity of a nation. parents, employees and career
Individuals who are misfits in their counsellors can exchange views.
workplace tend to be less productive and A crucial influence in decision making
efficient, and therefore are unable to regarding career is the home environment
achieve their goals. The concept has been (James, 2000) as it lays the foundation of a
explained by Onyejiaku (as cited in Jones child’s personality. It’s the parent’s
& Larke, 2005), who defines occupation as upbringing which is the basis of the
a means of living, which has the power to outcome of the personality. The values of
change personalities, determine social the parents are transferred into the child.
status, predict expected earnings, Besides the home, another major
determine social groups etc. Thus its determinant of career choice is media. It
importance cannot be undermined. Given provides exposure at the earliest stage.
its complexity, it is then a point to ponder Media highlights social travails, global
upon as to how career decisions are made. issues, trends and fashions, portrays the
These are elucidated by Ipaye (as cited in glamour of a culture, and the glitter of the
Alemu, 2013), who elaborates the consumer world. Moreover, talk shows,
Kazi, Akhlaq
documentaries, movies and dramas portray have also been proven as determinants of
careers such as law, media and advertising career choice (Ferry, 2006). Educational
as very glamorous and appealing, thus level of parents, their profession and
drawing students towards them. income are also identified as very
Sometimes the choices of the peers also important factors (Hearn 1984, 1988).
become a determining factor in choosing a Every student at a certain juncture in their
profession. Other factors which influence life has to make a choice regarding their
career choice are family, parents, friends, career. It is incumbent that students make
culture, academic achievement, health the correct choice asserts Oladele (as cited
factors, existing income level and financial in Nyarko-Sampson 2013). This will make
constraints, media influences, prospective them more poised, stable, and endowed
levels of income, employment with a pleasant countenance.
opportunities, the social acceptability of Consequently, it will lead to knitting a
profession, recognition, and work better fabric for the society. Unfortunately,
satisfaction among others. The purpose of career choices are made with little
this research was to investigate the various awareness of the real world (Caplow, as
choices which have an influence on cited in Bright, Pryor, &Harpham 2005).
students’ career choice. It looked into the Students make crucial decisions at a stage
interplay of various decision making when they may not be fully informed of
influences on MS students’ chosen field. It their choices, or else unavoidable
sought answers to queries whether MS circumstances prevent them from pursuing
students chose their respective fields, had their goals. Thus counsellors can play a
to reconcile with circumstances or had a positive role in guiding them to make
say in the decisions. It gives an insight into informed choices. Being interested in a
the various factors which influence particular profession is very important in
students’ decision making. decision making. If a student is forced into
Factors Influencing Choice of Career a career, he may exhibit low self-esteem
Career choice is one of the biggest and poor performance. Suutari (2003)
dilemma and challenge in any student’s reports that several studies have indicated
life. It involves an interplay of many a positive relationship between interests
factors which are intricately intertwined. It and career choice. It has also been
is not a straightforward task and involves a investigated that individuals with better
difficult process of decision making. This academic performance are able to make
issue is not confined to Pakistan only but better judgments about themselves (Arthur
is universal in nature. According to &Rousseau, 1996). Herbart (2005) opines
Bandura, Barbaranelli, Caprara, and that a child coming from an environment
Pastorelli (2001) an individual’s where he/she receives parental support and
environment, talents, skills, and academic lives harmoniously is more likely to be
achievement exert an influence on career dictated by them. In such a scenario, a
choice. In case of a wrong choice, it may child’s occupational aspiration is most
lead to resultant failure and likely to be influenced by the parents’
disappointment. Research shows homes, profession. Research reports career choice
schools and the social setup influence an is greatly influenced by students’
individual’s career choice. Financial surroundings, society and family etc (Gim,
prospects influence the career choice of 1992; Leong 1995). In his analysis, Watts
men as they have to meet household (1996) concluded that developing
expenses, whereas women show more countries direct their students into careers
concern for social values and utility (Sax, according to the country needs.
1994). Other factors such as aptitude, life Professions have varying degrees of
circumstances, and academic achievement acceptability in different cultures which
188
JRRE Vol.11, No.2 2017
189
Kazi, Akhlaq
190
JRRE Vol.11, No.2 2017
Table 2 presents the statements with least of least influence on their career choice,
frequent responses, reflecting that these and 72% disagreed that their family
factors were not influencing their career business influenced them. Information
choice. Results show 78% denied being from the internet (72%) and inspiration
influenced by print media. For 76% of the from their relatives (71%) also came
respondents, their parents’ profession was across as the least influencing reasons.
191
Kazi, Akhlaq
Table 2
Frequency of Reasons Least Influencing Career Choices
1 2 3 4 5
Item no Statement Mostly Disagree Mostly Agree
M SD
17. I chose this field due to 36.3 41.7 3.2 12.5 6.3 2.10 1.20
influence of print media.
1. I chose this field because 39.1 36.8 1.6 13.9 8.6 2 2.15 1.30
my parents are/are in the
same profession.
4. I chose this field as it is 37.5 34.7 6.7 14.1 6.9 2.18 1.26
part of my family business.
16. I chose this field after 28.9 43.1 3.5 11.1 13.4 2.34 1.32
getting information from
internet.
23. I chose this career 31.9 39.4 6.5 15.0 7.2 2.26 1.25
because I was inspired by
one of my relative.
In the present study, analysis of data education reveals that there was a
through ANOVA reveals no significant statistically significant difference for
effect of independent variables such as Family Influence: F (44,432) = 2.775, p =
father’s and mother’s profession and total .027, Peers’ Influence: F (44,432) =
household income on the students’ career 4.003, p = .003. The results of other six
choices. Results of ANOVA on father’s categories did not yield significant results.
Table 3
One- Way Analyses of Variance (ANOVA) of Career Choice Influenced by Fathers’ Education
Factors N M SD F Sig
(44, 432)
Analysis of one way variance applied on only “interest” yielded a significant result:
the level of mothers’ education to know to F (44,432) = 2.62, p = .034. The results of
determine its influence on career choice other seven categories are non-significant.
revealed that from the eight categories,
192
JRRE Vol.11, No.2 2017
Table 4
One- Way Analyses of Variance (ANOVA) of Career Choice Influenced by Mothers’ Education
Factors N M SD F Sig
(44, 432)
Table 5
Means, Standard Deviations and t-Tests for Overall Reasons of Career Choice by Gender
*p <0.05
An independent samples t-test was their school/ college friends. They further
conducted to explore the impact of gender elaborated that it is easy to study with
on students’ career choice, which was friends one is comfortable with. It is also
found significant for the category of Peer possible to ask for their help comfortably.
Influence (.001) and Overall (.015) as This was particularly true for the female
reported in Table 5 given below. students. As remarked by a female
Analysis of the Semi-Structured respondent (1) “I got admission in
Interviews computer sciences, but my friend didn’t, so
The following themes which emerged I took admission here”. This was also
from the study are presented asunder. found in the male respondents as
Family Influence remarked: “We are used to group study, so
None of the respondents reported the we all took admission in the same
negative influence of the family. However, profession”.
they did express that their parents Gender
expressed their reservations and concerns None of the respondents felt that their
in the stage of making a choice. However, Gender was a barrier to their career choice.
they were affable and relaxed once the One female student from the Department
decisions were made. One female student of Communication Studies reported that
reported that she was inspired by her initially, her family was against her choice
father, and it was his choice in making her as they felt the field was not “safe” for her.
career decision. As one female respondent They were of the opinion that “girls should
(4) elaborated “I opted for media studies, opt for teaching”. However, she took a
and my family did not consider it a stand, and eventually, they reconciled with
respectable profession for girls”. her decision.
Peers’ Influence Academic Reasons
Even at the MS level, it was seen that All the respondents praised their teachers
students reported feeling more comfortable for helping them make career choices.
and confident making choices to be with They either inspired them or motivated
193
Kazi, Akhlaq
them to choose their field of interest. particularly. The Sheffe post hoc results
However, one female respondent reported reveal that fathers who had a professional
not securing enough marks as a hindrance degree exerted more influence. Similarly,
for her to choose a career of her liking. mothers’ influence was significant in the
Media Influence category of Interest=.03. Thus mothers
Only one student reported opting for exert a lot of inspiration and motivation in
Journalism as a field as she was inspired their children’s lives. Similar results were
by the way they were portrayed in movies. reported by Grissmer (2003) whose study
None of the other reported and influence showed that parents’ educational
of print or electronic media in their career background serves as a determinant in the
choices. career choices of their children. Results of
Financial Reasons the t-test reveal that gender has a
Most of the students did not express significant influence on career choice. In
financial constraint as a factor inhibiting the present study, the effect of gender on
them from pursuing a career of their the category of peer influence is significant
choice except one, who did not secure at .006. Girls have reported being more
good marks in FSc and could not afford influenced by their peers as compared to
the fee of private medical colleges. boys. The interviews also reveal that
However three male and one female media, financial constraints and academic
respondent remarked that they would have performance are some factors which
like to secure admission to a private influence students when making career
university, but that is too expensive and choices.
unaffordable. Conclusion
Interest The study reveals that role of school
All the students showed that the main counsellors is minimal when it comes to
reason for their choice was their interest in making informed career choices. It also
the subject. However, one of the female reveals that the youth is impressionable,
respondents reported she had other areas of and gets swayed by peers, and impressed
interest in early life, which she could not by media when it comes to choosing a
pursue either because of not being able to career. It also highlights the role of the
secure admission (medical college), or teachers who motivate and inspire their
financial constraint. students. The work environment is also a
Influence of Others factor that attracts students towards a
One female student from the Physics career. The study shows that students from
Department reported opting for her career these institutions were not influenced by
on the advice of her paternal uncle. Others the parents’ profession, or pressurized by
did not report any factor influencing them them. It also reveals that girls are more
Discussion and Analysis inclined towards their peers, and their
To know the extent to which career choice choices are dependent on them.
influences the various demographic Recommendations
variables ANOVA and t-test were applied. A career decision is undoubtedly on the
The results of the one way between-group most crucial choice in any students’ life.
analysis of variance revealed that father’s New and emerging careers and existing
and mother’s profession and total prestigious preferences pose a challenge in
household income had no significant making these decisions. Moreover, it
influence on the students’ career choices. requires a balance between the freedom
Fathers’ education yielded significance, given to the pupil to make an independent
particularly in the category of family decision, and counselling on behalf of the
influence and peers influence. This shows parents and teachers, to share their insight
that fathers played a role in these two areas and experience. Exerting pressure and
194
JRRE Vol.11, No.2 2017
dictatorial attitude may demotivate the Ferry, T. R., Fouad, N. A., &
students and also lower their performance. Smith, P. L. (2000). The role of family
The types of jobs that might be relevant to context in a social cognitive model for
their interests, skills or aspirations should career-related choice behaviour: A math
be discussed in a democratic way to avoid and science perspective. Journal of
problems. Students should choose the Vocational Behavior, 57(3), 348-364.
career which is according to their Greenberger, M. (2002). Nation’s
capabilities and of their interest. In this high schools still operate “Separate and
decision, the school should help the Unequal” Vocational education for
student by making centres of counselling male and female students. Career
for students. Thus students easily Development Quarterly, 8(2), 29-43.
understand which career is best for them. Grissmer, R. H. (2003). Beyond
Student interest should never be helping with homework: Parents and
undermined in choosing a career path. children doing mathematics at
References home. Teaching Children
Alemu, Y. (2013). Assessment of Mathematics, 14, 120-131.
the provisions of guidance and counselling Hearn, J. C. (1984). The relative
services in secondary schools of East roles of academic, ascribed, and
Harerge Zone and Harari Region, socioeconomic characteristics in college
Ethiopia. Middle Eastern & African destinations. Sociology of Education, 22-
Journal of Educational Research, 2, 28- 30.
37. Hearn, J. C. (1988). Attendance at
Arthur, M. B.,& Rousseau, D. M. higher-cost colleges: Ascribed,
(1996).A Career lexicon for the 21st socioeconomic, and academic influences
Century. The Academy of Management on student enrollment patterns.Economics
Executive, 10(4): 28-39. of education review, 7(1), 65-76.
Bandura, A., Barbaranelli, C., Hoover-Dempsey, K. V., & Sandler, H. M.
Caprara, G. V., & Pastorelli, C. (2001). (2005). Final performance report for OERI
Self‐efficacy beliefs as shapers of Grant# R305T010673: The social
children's aspirations and career context of parental involvement: A path to
trajectories. Child development, 72(1), enhanced achievement. Project Monitor,
187-206. Institute of Education Sciences, US
Bani-Khaled, T. A. (2014). Career Department of Education.
Intentions of Jordanian Undergraduate Issa, A. O., & Nwalo, K. I. N.
Students of English. Middle-East (2008). Factors affecting the career choice
Journal of Scientific Research, 21(1), 249- of undergraduates in Nigerian library and
262. information science schools. African
Borchert, M. (2002). Career choice Journal of Library, Archives and
factors of high school students (Doctoral Information Science, 18(1), 27-27.
dissertation, University of Wisconsin- James, R. (2000). How school-
Stout). leavers chose a preferred university course
Bright, J. E., Pryor, R. G., & and possible effects on the quality of the
Harpham, L. (2005). The role of chance school-university transition. Journal of
events in career decision making. Journal Institutional Research, 9(1), 78-88.
of Vocational Behavior, 66(3), 561-576. Jones, W. A., & Larke, A. (2005).
Brock, C., &Cammish, N. (1997). Enhancing the quality of life for Hispanic
Factors Affecting Female Participation in individuals through career
Education in Seven Developing preparation. Journal of Hispanic Higher
Countries. Education Research Paper. Education,4(1), 5-18.
195
Kazi, Akhlaq
196