Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
References:
• Bank, L. “Composites for Construction - Structural Design with FRP Materials,” John Wiley & Sons,
Inc., 2006. (Chapters 12 - 15)
• Fiberline. “Fiberline Design Manual,” www.fiberline.dk, 2003.
• Clarke, JL. (Ed.) “Structural Design of Polymer Composites - EUROCOMP Design Code and
Handbook,” E & FN Spon, 1996.
• Shahverdi, M., “Mixed-mode static and fatigue failure criteria for adhesively-bonded FRP joints”. PhD
Thesis, EPFL, Switzerland, 2013.
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 1
Outline
Introduction
(Pro’s and con’s of FRP / Examples)
Materials
(Manufacturing process / Materials / Durability)
Design Concept
(Concept / Basic assumptions / …)
Bending Beam
(Timoshenko theory / Stresses / Deformations / Buckling …)
Axial Members
(Serviceability and ultimate limit states)
Connections
(Bolted joints / Glued joints)
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 2
Page 1
Introduction
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 3
Pro’s
Material CFRP GFRP Steel S500
High specific strength:
max
lmax 138.4 km 27.8 km 6.4 km
g
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 4
Page 2
Introduction: Pro’s and con’s
Con’s
Brittle
High initial costs
Low to moderate application temperature (-20 up to 80 °C)
Low fire resistance (sometimes with unhealthy gases)
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 5
Structural profiles
Most structural profiles produced in conventional profile shapes similar to
metallic materials
Similarity in geom. and properties, however no standard geom.,
mechanical and physical properties used by all manufacturers
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 6
Page 3
Introduction: Examples
Footbridges
Pontresina bridge, Switzerland
1997
Span: 2 x 12.5 m
Weight: 3.3 tons (installation by helicopter)
http://fiberline.com/pontresina-bridge-switzerland
http://fiberline.com/fiberline-bridge-kolding
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 7
Introduction: Examples
Footbridges
Composite pedestrian bridge in Lleida, Spain
Span: 38 m
Width: 3.0 m
http://fiberline.com/international-award-innovative-grp-footbridge
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 8
Page 4
Introduction: Examples (ASSET Profile)
Road bridges
http://fiberline.com/west-mill-bridge-england http://www.fiberline.com/gb/casestories/case6314.asp
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 9
Road bridges
Bridge details
Location: Bex, Suisse
Installed on: 12th October, 2012
Dimensions: 12m x 7m (9 tons)
Longitudinal section of new bridge (dimensions in mm) [Prof. Keller]
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 10
Page 5
Introduction: Examples
Bridgedeck (Footbridges)
Introduction: Examples
Buildings
Height: 15 m
Storeys: 5
http://www.fiberline.com/gb/casestories/case1835.asp
Project: Maagtechnic
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 12
Page 6
Introduction: Examples
Laboratory bridge
Empa Laboratory Bridge, Switzerland
Span: 19 m
Width: 1.6 m
Load capacity: 15 tons
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 13
Introduction: Examples
Göschenen, Switzerland
Project: Maagtechnic
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 14
Page 7
Introduction: Examples
Balconies
Switzerland
Project: Maagtechnic
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 15
Introduction: Examples
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 16
Page 8
Introduction: Application
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 17
Material
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 18
Page 9
Material: Pultrusion process
Only pultruded GFRP profiles will be considered in this lecture
Pultrusion line
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 19
Material: Components
Supplementary
constituents
polymerisation agents
fillers
additives
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 20
Page 10
Material: Shapes of pultruded profiles
Available Profiles on Stock:
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 21
Material: Durability
Various environmental and load conditions that affect durability of
(G)FRPs in terms of strength, stiffness, fiber/matrix interface integrity,
cracking:
water/sea water
chemical solutions
prolonged freezing
thermal cycling (freeze-thaw)
elevated temperature exposure
UV radiation
creep and relaxation
fatigue
fire…
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 22
Page 11
Material: Durability
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 23
Material: Manufacturers
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 24
Page 12
Material: Manufacturers
Strongwell, USA
www.strongwell.com
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 25
Design Concept
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 26
Page 13
Design Concept: Basic Assumptions
90° perpendicular
0° parallel to pultrusion direction
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 27
Design Concept
Codes
Every manufacturer has its own profile design → No European Design
Code is available! (only EN13706, about testing and notation)
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 28
Page 14
Design Concept
R
Rd k
m
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 29
Design Concept
Operating m,4
temperature °C
Short-term load Long-term load
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 30
Page 15
Design Concept
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 31
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 32
Page 16
Design Concept: Basic Assumptions
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 33
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 34
Page 17
Bending Beam
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 35
Qd,y,max f
Shear: max
Ak,y m
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 36
Page 18
Bending Beam: Design of …
Vibrations
Light-weighted and ‘soft’ structures are susceptible to vibrations (traffic, wind,
the movement of people …)!!
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 37
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 38
Page 19
Bending Beam: Timoshenko Theory
w w and ψ w, ψ and …
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 39
Kinematic relationships
ux y w( x),x ux y ( x)
u y w( x) u y w( x)
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 40
Page 20
Bending Beam: Euler vs. Timoshenko Theory
Equilibrium
M ( x)
1 1
qLx qx 2 , w(0) 0 and w( L) 0 w(0) 0 and w( L) 0
2 2 M (0) 0 , x (0) 0 and M ( L) 0 , x ( L) 0
1 1 1 2
w, xx qLx qx
E 0° I z 2 2 Functions:
L3 2 Lx 2 x3 w( x) A1 x 4 A2 x3 A3 x 2 A4 x A5
qx
w( x)
24 E 0° I z ( x) B1 x3 B2 x 2 B3 x B4
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 41
Put in , E I w, GA 0 and
xx 0° z x
w( x)
2 GA 24 E 0 I z
Deflection at midspan
w L 5 qL w L 5 qL q L
4 4 2
2 384 E I z 2 384 E I z 8 GA
0 0
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 42
Page 21
Bending Beam: Euler vs. Timoshenko Theory
General expression for the total beam deflection as a sum of the deflection
due to bending and shear:
f1 ( x) f 2 ( x)
w( x)
E0 I z GA
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 43
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 44
Page 22
Bending Beam: Example
L = 3.0 m
qd,uls = 13 kN/m
qd,ser = 10 kN/m
wmax/L = 1/300 → wmax=0.01 m
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 45
Page 23
Bending Beam: Example
5 qd , ser L4 qd , ser L2
wmax 9.3 10 3 m wmax 0.01 m
384 E0 I z 8 GA
(7.7 mm) (1.6 mm) (κ=0.42)
5 qd , ser L4 qd , ser L2
wmax 9.1 10 3 m
384 E0 I z 8 GAweb
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 47
Lateral-torsional buckling
Flange (compressive) displace laterally to the
transverse load direction.
Page 24
Bending Beam: Stability problems
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 49
Axial Members
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 50
Page 25
Axial Members: Tension
x N L A = gross area
E0° A
Remark: The critical aspect of axial members in tension are neither the serviceability
nor the ultimate limit state. Critical is the load transfer to the GFRP profile!
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 51
Nd Fc
1 Fc
NEuler
A f
FC c,0° … maximal compressive load
m
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 52
Page 26
Axial Members: Compression
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 53
Connections
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 54
Page 27
Joints in FRP composite structures
Page 28
Connections: Introduction
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 57
Connections: Introduction
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 58
Page 29
Connections: Bolted joints
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 59
The design procedure is comparable to the one for steel connections, but
since there exist no standard GFRP material → each manufacturer has its
own design rules for bolted joints.
IMPORTANT REMARKS:
The direction of pultrusion and the direction of the force is RELEVANT!!!
(anisotropic material)
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 60
Page 30
Connections: Bolted joints (Fiberline recommendations)
Minimum distances
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 61
Page 31
Connections: Bolted joints (Fiberline recommendations)
Bolted connection in shear: e.g. shear in longitudinal direction
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 63
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 64
Page 32
Connections: Bonded joints
But be careful …
Adhesive agents have properties that depend on time, temperature, humidity …
Failure in glued joints takes place suddenly (brittle behaviour)
The load-bearing capacity is not proportional to the area which is glued
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 65
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 66
Page 33
Connections: Bonded joints
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 67
Displacement control,
1 mm/min, 5 Hz
Ambient conditions
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 68
Page 34
Connections: Bonded joints, fracture modes
Mixed-mode bending (MMB-Mode I/II) MMB (mixed-Mode I/II)
c L=170
Lever Pg cg
Center of gravity
P
Applied load
Fulcrum
=
Saddle a =50
0 5.7
Specimen
Loading roller 13.4
Pre-crack
Base 2L=340 7.7
DCB (Mode I)
+
ENF (Mode II)
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 69
Mode I fracture
Step 1
Crack tip
300 160
Bridging length Load
Crack length
Step 2 250 140
Crack tip
Crack length (mm)
200 120
Load (N)
150 100
Fully active fiber bridging
Step 3 100 80
Crack tip
Fiber breakage
50 60
Bridging length 0 40
0 5 10 15 20 25
Displacement (mm)
Schematic of fiber bridging phenomenon Output from experiment
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 70
Page 35
Strain energy release rate calculation
300 160
Load
Crack length
250 140
Load (N)
P 2 dC 150 100
G
2 B da
C ka n 100 80
nP
G
2 Ba
50 60
Experimental compliance method (ECM)
0 40
0 5 10 15 20 25
Displacement (mm)
Output from experiment
Shahverdi, M., “Mixed-mode static and fatigue failure criteria for adhesively-bonded FRP joints”. PhD Thesis, EPFL, Switzerland, 2013.
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 71
400
GI (J/m )
2
300
200
100
0
0 300 600 900 1200 1500 1800 2100
2
GII (J/m )
M. Shahverdi, A.P. Vassilopoulos, and T. Keller. Mixed-mode quasi-static failure criteria for adhesively-bonded pultruded GFRP joints.
Compos Part A-Appl S, 2014, 59: 45–66.
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 72
Page 36
Connections: Bonded joints, mixed-mode fatigue failure criterion
2 3
Gth Gc
2
G (J/m )
Shahverdi, M., “Mixed-mode static and fatigue failure criteria for adhesively-bonded FRP joints”. PhD Thesis, EPFL, Switzerland, 2013
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 73
G Q1
1 th
G
m
da
D G
dN G Q2
1
Gc
M. Shahverdi, A. P. Vassilopoulos, T. Keller, A total fatigue life model for the prediction of the R-ratio effects on fatigue crack growth of
adhesively-bonded pultruded GFRP DCB joints. Compos Part A-Appl S, 2012; 43(10):1783–1790.
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 74
Page 37
Connections: Bonded joints, mixed-mode fatigue failure criterion
Shahverdi, M., “Mixed-mode static and fatigue failure criteria for adhesively-bonded FRP joints”. PhD Thesis, EPFL, Switzerland, 2013
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 75
2.20
9.00
1200 Prediction
Model
8
1.0
900
3 used to establish a progressive damage
0.4
GI (J/m )
600
0.25 loading for structural joints compose of
da
ta
1
N=
G I/G II=0.1
t ic
300
10
-2
-4
-3
10 -5
-7
10
0
0 400 800 1200 1600 2000 2400 2800 3200
2
GII (J/m )
M. Shahverdi, A.P. Vassilopoulos, and T. Keller. Mixed-mode fatigue failure criteria for adhesively-bonded pultruded GFRP joints. Compos
Part A-Appl S, 2013, 54: 46–55.
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 76
Page 38
Connections: Other joints
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 77
Where large stiffness is needed (where static height and deflections must
remain very small) → GFRP does not always lead to lighter structures than with
steel.
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 78
Page 39
Thank you for attention
any question?
Design of FRP-Profiles and All-FRP-Structures, 17.10.2018 Fiber Composites, FS18 Dr. M. Shahverdi 79
Page 40