Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
CIVIL
Unrest www.PoliceMag.com
A BOBIT PUBLICATION
CONTENTS
POLICE MAGAZINE SPECIAL REPORT: Civil Unrest
LIVE AGENT ›
OC OC2 CS OC/CS
OPERATIONS ›
INERT IMPACT I.D. GLASS
O
ne of the best force multipliers for agen-
cies responding to small or large distur-
bances involving civil unrest is the use of non-
lethal tools, including aerosols and munitions. officers know what these tools can do.
Non-lethal weapons are both a visual and physical Using non-lethal weapons to deploy chemical or specialty
impact munitions can cause physiological effects. These in-
deterrent. Almost everyone has a fear of having weap-
clude respiratory distress, impaired vision, and blunt force
ons pointed at them, and in many situations this fear of
trauma that can create muscular dysfunction.
the unknown can get people to back down, which assists
Impact munitions can also cause physical bruising and pos-
agencies in maintaining the peace. sible penetration. The likelihood of these injuries can be affect-
Understanding the psychological effects of just show- ed by many factors such as the distance from the subject, age of
ing non-lethal weapon systems in the hands of officers the subject, height and weight of the subject, and the clothing
can help an agency to apply non-escalation and de-es- worn by the subject.
calation strategies before the actual deployment of these
systems becomes necessary. ZONES OF EFFECTIVENESS
Each non-lethal weapon that agencies can deploy, whether it is
DETERRENCE a chemical or specialty impact munition, is designed for a spe-
The placement of non-lethal weapons operators in a formation cific mission. And its effectiveness in accomplishing that mis-
of officers is important. There have always been psychological sion is often affected by the distance to the target. The distance
effects of seeing a shotgun or a 37mm or 40mm launcher on a from the deploying officers to the target is also important in
riot line. These non-lethal weapons tend to earn the respect of establishing justification for using it.
everyone who sees them. It's common practice to categorize the deployment rang-
Non-lethal aerosols and munitions give agencies the abil- es into zones of effectiveness, starting with 10 feet from the
ity to reach out into a crowd and apply force when necessary riot line and then extending outward from the line at 50-foot
at ranges as far away as 100 yards and as close as 10 feet. This intervals.
lets officers neutralize violent actors even when they are mixed Here's a look at what is happening in each of the zones.
among lawful protesters. Zone 1—Immediate Threat
There is only 0 to 10 feet between the police line and the pro-
PHYSICAL EFFECTS testers. Due to the close distance to the protesters, the officers
Even though non-lethal weapons are not intended to kill, they on the front line have little time to react to an attack and a very
can have serious and dangerous effects. So it's important that limited field of view.
USING FORCE
Force options are the ability to use verbalization skills and
physical alternatives
➔ Non-escalation methods are options used when establish-
ing contact with the crowd.
➔ De-escalation strategies are used when the initial contact
with the protesters escalates from contact to conflict.
➔ Disengagement tactics are used when the crowd is un-
able to be managed effectively within the assembled officers'
capabilities.
➔ Stabilization and/or control techniques are used when the
PHOTO: ©ZUMA PRESS
GR02902-00
freeinfo.policemag.com/761955
Beyond the Mobile
SPECIALLY TRAINED
In the last few years, law enforce-
ment agencies in the United States AND EQUIPPED It's important that law enforcement
response to riots single out the rioters
have dealt with more civil unrest than
they have seen in decades. Since 2008,
PUBLIC ORDER TEAMS and not trample on the rights of lawful
protesters. So we have to be very careful
we've seen the Occupy movement,
Black Lives Matter, and a number of
HAVE PROVEN TO and cautious when using force in a crowd.
Knowing how to respond properly is a
other activist groups take to the streets
in protests, protests that can turn vio-
BE EFFECTIVE IN matter of training.
lent. This has been a shock to American QUELLING RIOTERS THE HYBRID MODEL
RIGHT OF CITIZENS TO
been more likely to experience sports- unrest response team is to select the right
related riots than political unrest. people for the job. Not every officer makes
PEACEFULLY PROTEST.
So now American officers are facing a a great public order officer, just as not ev-
new era of protest, but agencies are still us- ery officer is capable of being a SWAT of-
ing tactics and methods and training their ficer. Everyone has strengths and weak-
officers to the standards of 40 or more years nesses, and will react differently under
ago. I submit to you that the time has come for change in how varying stresses or situations.
American officers respond to protests and riots, and that you Once you have the right people, you need to give them solid
could learn a lot from your colleagues across the Atlantic. training. Public order training needs to not only cover passive
Before I explain exactly what you can learn from the experi- crowd control, but also needs to take officers out of their "com-
ences of your colleagues in the United Kingdom and Europe, fortable bubble" so they will be able to deal with extreme and
let me say that the current mobile field force model of response violent disorder in the correct manner.
here in the U.S. is dated and needs to Training on how to respond to pas-
evolve, but it still can provide a founda- sive crowds needs to move away from
tion that you can build upon. the umbrella approach of "Helmets On,
The current basic riot response has Sticks Out, Step and Drag movement"
often been used as a broad and sweep- and instead needs to get back to train-
ing response to generically resolve civil ing officers to stand the line in their pa-
unrest issues in cities and towns in the trol uniforms communicating individu-
U.S. However, it's important to note that ally and interacting with the crowd. It's
not all protests turn into unrest. important that public order officers be
Every law enforcement officer in the trained to see crowds not as a pack or
United States swears to uphold the U.S. a tribe but groups of individuals, each
Constitution, which is a great thing. person having unique attitudes and
The First Amendment of the Constitu- intentions.
tion allows Americans to speak out and Because public order events can roll
peacefully assemble and protest and over into a number of endless hours and
that right must be supported and safe- can be physically and mentally drain-
guarded by law enforcement. Sadly, the ing, agencies need to have enough per-
tactics used by American law enforce- sonnel either on their own or through
PHOTOS: GEOFF PERRIN
ment in response to some of the pro- mutual aid agreements to keep the
tests that have happened over the past
few years have clouded the lines on how Specialized public order vehicles carry
we treat violent offenders and peaceful officers and their equipment to sites
protesters. where crowd control is needed.
tactics used.
One of the key differences between the U.S. public order re-
sponse training model and the British model is that in the U.K.
chiefs and commanders have to attend a three-week-long pub-
lic order cadre course where in addition to other training they
go through highly realistic real world scenarios with the line
officers. This results in the command ranks having an under-
standing of the capabilities of their teams to influence the out-
come of public order events. At the same time, they learn how
to oversee the welfare and safety of every officer under their
command.
U.S. Park Police public order team officers train in all weather
conditions, both night and day. LEVEL 1 TRAINING
Make the right call for backup—the Arbitrator BWC from Panasonic.
Learn more at us.panasonic.com/bwc
freeinfo.policemag.com/760030
Beyond the Mobile Field Force
the officers do not appear paramilitary. Each officer in the team who are not committing offenses who are inadvertently caught
will have the option to wear either covert or overt ballistic body up in a location where disorder is nearby and those munitions
armor. have been used. It can affect unprotected officers. It can cause
Officers' feet and ankles should be protected by a public or- alarm and distress to children and the elderly who may have
der boot. These boots will be rated to stop punctures by nails and breathing difficulties. And it can also cost an agency or city
glass. The top and side of the boots must be rated to protect feet financially due to decontamination and civil law suits. There
from bricks and other kinetic objects. The whole boot has to be are some agencies worldwide that have moved away from this
fully fire resistant with the ability to shed burning chemicals. type of munition in favor of the dynamic action of small team
Public order team gloves need to be impact-, slash-, and fire tactics.
resistant. But they also have to give the officers enough dex- Some of the modern less-than-lethal weapon systems avail-
terity that they can proficiently operate firearms and execute able to law enforcement for crowd control in violent situations
hands-on defensive tactic and subject control skills. can be extremely effective. But proficiency through training is
For gear, each officer should carry a hydration system, com- essential, and such weapon systems need to be highly accurate
munication system, and used only against
personal Halotron fire individuals committing
extinguisher, sidearm, violent offenses who we
24-inch acrylic baton (or intend to arrest.
equivalent), and accord- A policy of indis-
ing to the SOPs of their criminate targeting of a
agency the rest of their crowd is unacceptable
personal protective tools in today's policing prac-
such as a TASER, OC tices. All officers should
spray, or other tools. remember that every ac-
Shields are extreme- tion they take will be re-
ly critical for a Level 1 corded by either the me-
public order team. Each dia or individual citizens
officer needs to have ac- with recording devices.
cess to varying types of No officer is above the
Makrolon shields. Mak- law. Every officer should
rolon is a type of gasoline clearly display their call
shedding high-impact sign or ID numbers or
polycarbonate. Poly- It's important that public order teams train realistically using all of their public order numbers so
carbonate riot shields equipment so they can build confidence in their ability to withstand attacks. that the agency they are
come in a 6-foot, 4-foot, with can be transparent
and round shield configuration. They can protect the officers about the actions taken by the officers under their command.
from an enhanced threat from handheld weapons such as axes, Public order in the 21st century must evolve from the lessons
baseball bats, machetes, and even samurai swords. learned in the past century where some inappropriate action
When acquiring PPE and gear for your team, be aware that by poorly trained officers resulted in negative views of how the
not all equipment is equal. One officer injured is one officer too police dealt with minority groups protesting under their First
many and an officer hurt due to substandard equipment is an Amendment right.
officer who may use excessive use of force to retaliate in anger, We must get better at separating anarchists and violent agi-
which can be costly in terms of injury and liability for everyone tators from peaceful protestors who are following the law and
involved. facilitate the ability for peaceful protestors to protest safely and
without fear of retribution from police and federal agencies. We
USING FORCE must also accept that we need specially trained and specially
B
ack in 2015 after its experi- did some research and they sought out into 14 platoons, with two of those pla-
ence in the Baltimore riots Geoff Perrin of Survival Edge Tactical toons trained to the highest standard.
sparked by the in-custody Systems Inc. (www.survivaledgetac- On the MSP mobile field force, the
death of Freddie Gray, the tical.com). Perrin, a naturalized U.S. highest standard of training is Level
Maryland State Police mo- citizen from England, is a veteran of nu- 1 and the lowest standard is Level 3.
bile field force team knew it was time to merous riots in Northern Ireland and in All MSP troopers receive Level 3 pub-
make some changes in its response to metropolitan London, where he served lic order training, which consists of
civil unrest. as a law enforcement officer. And as you eight hours of training in such topics as
First Sergeant Richard Carroll says can read on page 6, he believes Ameri- crowd dynamics, crowd behavior, legal
the MSP sent about 500 officers to Bal- can law enforcement agencies need to considerations, and how to de-escalate
timore to work the riots. They were pri- modify their approach to crowd and tense situations. Level 3 officers stand
marily assigned to guard and protect riot control to add elements of the tac- the line in patrol uniforms, show pres-
the city's infrastructure working with tics and equipment used in the United ence, and maintain order during peace-
National Guard units. What Carroll saw Kingdom. ful protests. When things get more tense
in Baltimore convinced him that the and dangerous, the MSP's Level 2 public
tactics and organization of the MSP's LEVELS OF RESPONSE order officers, who are members of the
mobile field force needed to evolve to Carroll returned after taking the train- mobile field force, are sent in. They re-
meet the challenges presented by pos- ing at Perrin's Salt Lake City facility to ceive 24 hours of training in crowd con-
sible future riots. reorganize the way the MSP approaches trol, including how to work in basic riot
"After two or three days of the unrest civil unrest. He also brought in Perrin to gear. Then if things get violent, the Level
that we experienced in Baltimore, I just conduct specialized training. 1 officers are deployed.
felt there had to be a better way to de- The MSP public order response team Level 1 officers receive all the train-
escalate these types of incidents. Up to is still called a mobile field force, but it is ing received by the other levels of offi-
that point our team hadn't been tested now organized into three levels of train- cers plus practical riot scenarios in full
in that way. Once you're battle tested ing and responsibility. There are 300 personal protective equipment (PPE),
like that, it can change your philoso- MSP troopers, not including command carrying all necessary equipment. MSP
phy," Carroll says. personnel, trained in public order re- mobile field force officers who perform
Working with Montgomery County sponse and assigned to the unit as part Level 1 public order operations learn to
Police lieutenant Pete Davidov, Carroll of their duties. They're broken down trust the protection of their impact- and
ver in any bicycle contact. The bicycle create a larger barrier to move in front
is simply placed between the officer of large crowds. The number of officers
and their contact. The officer stands on is dictated by the size of the crowd and
the non-drive side of the bicycle. The the environment it is in. Maneuvers
bike can either be positioned with the are done in either a static or moving
kickstand down or up, with the officer position.
maintaining control of the bike with both hands. If the officer is
placing the kickstand down, they can move laterally to keep the MOVING OR STATIC DISPLAY
subject at bay. It provides a safety barrier for the officer and an The static use of bicycles is usually seen at the end of roadways
increased reactionary gap for any potential threats. The officer or at large intersections. They can be placed across roadways,
then can move the bicycle itself, laterally or forward, to escort placing the bikes front wheel over rear wheel, in solid forma-
the subject away or direct the subject by mirroring the subjects' tion that allows for a skirmish line to be created in a mobile
actions. The bicycle can be placed down on the ground to cre- field force situation. As long as the integrity of the formation
ate more distance with an aggressive subject. is maintained, a unit can conduct arrests and maneuvers be-
The bike fence is also the legal boundary between you and hind the line of bicycles effectively and safely. Mobile field force
your contact. An appropriately outfitted bicycle with police units that deploy accessory weapons or those that are on foot
insignias and markings can serve as more than just a mode can move through the skirmish line to effect arrests. The static
of transportation. When placed appropriately, the bicycle can line of bicycles can be much more effective than patrol officers
serve as a clear demarcation of where not to go. If bicycle offi- standing shield to shield. A group of bicycles can be placed
cers use good communication and properly articulate that the front tire to rear tire, the officers can move back several feet,
line is not to be crossed, anyone who might pass through a bike and the integrity of the line is still maintained.
fence could possibly face arrest for entering a crime scene or A moving group of bicycle officers can be used in the same
disobeying police commands. manner as most mobile field force formations. They can be po-
You can add to the bike fence by overlapping the front tire sitioned in a wedge formation, forcing groups to move laterally
must be used in time with moving the bike fence back toward
a group or subject.
Bicycles can also be used in columns to prevent moving sub-
jects form gaining access to a particular area. This is the easi-
est and most effective way to move a group of bicycles. Once
in a column, officers can turn and form a barrier between the
intended groups. Officers can then be placed away from the
crowd to quickly respond only when needed. This provides a
swift movement of officers to one location with little disruption
of a crowd.
These columns can also be used to protect dignitaries and
move them through a crowd. The columns will ride on each
side of the individual with a point officer directing the group by
clearly communicating turns and parting the crowd.
In 2016, thousands of people attended the Republican Na-
tional Convention. Some were supporters while others were
attending in protest. In anticipation of the large crowds, the
organizing bodies elected to use bicycle officers instead of pa-
trol resources for security. This was because bicycle officers
are more mobile and can react more quickly to the movements
of the protests. They are also less
The right clothing and gear will
assuming and have a less threat- help protect against violence while
ening effect on most crowds. A maintaining maneuverability.
concern in any moving protest is
how to maintain professionalism aggressive crowd.
and effectiveness, without sacri- Effective communication is
ficing the safety of the group. As also a must in moving crowds. The
a moving unit of 20-30 bicycle of- calmest crowd can be a chore to
ficers per group, 300 bike officers control when the group is not act-
were able to surround entrances ing as one, or when the goal has
and seal off corridors to raucous not been properly communicated.
protestors, which were constantly The lead, or point, officer should
moving back and forth. They did so by positioning their bicy- be clearly identified prior to moving the crowd. Always assess
cles in a proper bike fence with overlapping tires. the routes of escape for the crowd as well as potential hang-ups
prior to attempting to move them.
TRAINING AND EQUIPMENT To best prepare yourself to handle crowds as part of a bicycle
The greatest asset in moving crowds is proper training and unit, look for proper training in your area. The International
equipment. In field force and crowd movement situations, Police Mountain Bike Association provides a 40-hour course
wearing long sleeves and pants is best if munitions are being covering basic police cycling. Additional courses provided in-
used. Wearing padded sleeves or shoulder pads has been found struction in the use of bicycle response teams. These courses
to be effective against crowds that are violent. The use of down- focus on crowd control and dispersal techniques as well as
hill riding gear has shown to be effective due to its reduced quelling riot groups.
weight and ease of maneuverability in it.
Officers must practice using specialty equipment to create a Officer Christian Bailey has been a police officer for 12 years with
professional and effective response. Riding while wearing a gas the Scottsdale (AZ) Police Department and is currently assigned
mask can cause some officers to panic. Mimicking riot-like at- to the Bike Unit where he has been a member for nine years. He
mospheres in training can reduce the risk of panic during a real is an International Police Mountain Bike Association (IPMBA)
incident. The use of smoke canisters in training can also help EMS and Police Cyclist Instructor and most recently taught at the
practice the reduced visibility one might face in addressing an 2015 National Conference in Chandler, AZ.
50
RIGHT TO THE CORE
YEARS
7
SI
N
CE 19
6
50 Years.
120 Million Garments Made.
And We’re Not Done.
Commitment. Strength. Integrity. It all boils down to who you are inside. Your values shape your actions. At Propper,
we share those values. Since 1967, we’ve proudly served those who serve. The ones who put it all on the line every
day to keep the country and the community safe. This year, we celebrate 50 years of providing outstanding military, law
enforcement and tactical apparel and gear to folks like you who understand what it takes to get the job done right.