Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
literature review
Konmd Pesudws B S c q t o m Terrien’s marginal degeneration (TMD) is a rare, bilateral, asymmetric disease of
Glenelg North, South Australia unknown aetiology. The peripheral cornea, predominantly superiorly, undergoes
lipid deposition, vascularisation, opacification and stromal thinning leading to
‘gutter’ formation, ectasia and eventual corneal perforation. Two cases are
presented which demonstrate the typical clinical features of the various stages of
this disease. The disease process and its spectrum of presentation are reviewed.
Differential diagnosis and management of TMD are discussed with particular
reference to computerised corneal topographical analysis, which has a limited role
Accepted for publication: 3 February for diagnosis but is valuable for monitoring disease progression. (Clin Exp Optom
1994 1994; 77: 3: 97-104)
Key words: astigmatism, computerised corneal topographical analysis, ectasia, pseudopterygium, Terrien’s marginal degeneration
First described by Trumpy’ in 1881 and 18 months earlier he required 1.00 D of times in both eyes were of the order of
later by others,2 including Te~-rien,~ cylinder against-the-rule for each eye. At three seconds with all the puncta open
Terrien’s marginal degeneration is a an examination seven years ago, no and in apposition to the globe. Klein
rare condition, with approximately 200 astigmatic correction was necessary and keratoscopy showed distortion of the
cases having been reported.”25 vision was correctable to 6/6 in each eye. peripheral cornea of both eyes and a
Historically, various names have been Keratometry results showed R 2.00 D slight superior ectasia of the left
given to the disease including and L 2.50 D of against-the- rule cornea.
peripheral furrow keratitis, ectatic astigmatism, with the left mire The fitting of rigid gas permeable
marginal dy~trophy,~ peripheral appearing slightly ovoid with greater (RGP) contact lenses to correct the
sclerosis and atrophy, peripheral steepening superiorly. Retinoscopy also irregular astigmatism and maximise VA
corneal ectasia, senile marginal atrophy, indicated irregular astigmatism. Pupils was discussed. However, the patient
sulcus marginalis and keratoleptynis.2 and binocular vision findings were declined this option as he felt his vision
However, Terrien’s marginal normal and intra-ocular pressures were was satisfactory with an updated
degeneration (TMD) is now the within normal limits. The anterior spectacle correction. New bifocals were
accepted term for a distinct but chambers and fundi were normal. prescribed and clipon sunglasses were
somewhat variable clinical entity. Minimal age-related lens changes were recommended to provide relief from
apparent. glare. Tear supplements were
Slit-lamp examination revealed recommended to reduce epiphora by
CASE REPORT ONE
peripheral corneal thinning with gutter preventing dryness, but these were of
A 70-year-old male presented with formation, peripheral corneal only limited benefit.
symptoms of gradually reducing opacification and vascularisation The patient was advised to present for
distance vision, epiphora and (Figure 1). These changes were review in 12 months, or sooner if vision
photophobia. There was no history of predominantly along the superior became unacceptable or other
ocular pain or inflammation. The corneal margin, but appeared to be symptoms such as pain or redness
general medical history was distributed randomly around the developed.
unremarkable as was the immediate cornea, affecting half the corneal
family history. circumference in total. These changes
CASE REPORT TWO
The patient had been examined 18 were bilateral, asymmetric and did not
months earlier and bifocals were stain with fluorescein. Pterygium-like A 56year-old, myopic male presented
prescribed. Vision with the bifocals was growths (pseudopterygia) were present for a spectacle update with symptoms of
R 6/12 and L 6/15. This improved to R at the seven o’clock position in the reduced distance vision. There was a
6/7.5 and L 6/7.5 with pinhole, but right eye and at the five o’clock and history of epiphora and recurrent
best corrected spectacle acuity was only eight o’clock positions in the left eye. chronic low-grade conjunctivitis.
6/9 R and L. The patient’s prescription These growths were broad and flat at Repeated treatments with various
now required R 2.00 D and L 2.50 D of the leading edge rather than pointed antibiotics prescribed by his general
cylinder, axis against-the-rule whereas as in a true pterygium. Tear break-up medical practitioner over several years
Figure 1. Case one, left eye showing superior temporal Figure 2. Case two, left eye showing TMD changes includ-
degenerative changes typical of TMD. Note the specular ing obvious opacification and vascularisation in the inferior
reflection from within the corneal gutter. nasal cornea.
were unsuccessful. The general medical corneal thinning with gutter formation, than the central cornea. Unfortunately,
history was unremarkable but the peripheral corneal opacification and the topographical changes occurring at
immediate family history included vascularisation (Figure 2). The gutter the limbus are beyond the analytical
conjunctival malignant melanoma. sloped gently from the limbal side, but powers of the Eyesis CAS. Careful
The patient had been examined two rose sharply on the clear corneal side observation of the Polaroid Eyesis
years earlier and bifocals had been (Figure 3). These changes were along photograph of the left cornea (Figure
prescribed. Vision with the bifocals was the inferior-nasal corneal margin of 6), shows gross distortion at the limbus
R 6/7.5 and L 6/9. This improved to both eyes and the temporal corneal including flattening into the peripheral
R 6/6 and L 6/6 with pinhole and margin of the left eye, affecting one- gutter and steepening over the
spectacle correction. The axes of quarter to one-third of the corneal pseudopterygium.
astigmatism rotated towards the vertical circumference in total. This peripheral New multifocals were prescribed to
in both eyes with an increase in the degeneration was bilateral, although alleviate the patient’s visual problems.
strength of against-the-rule cylinder. much more extensive in the left eye and Tear supplements were recommended
Keratometer mires and retinoscopy did not stain with fluorescein. A to reduce epiphora by preventing
reflexes were both regular. Pupils and pseudopterygium was present at the dryness, but these were of only limited
binocular vision findings were normal eight o’clock position in the left eye benefit. The patient was advised of the
and intra-ocular pressures were within (Figure 4). Tear break-up times in both presence of Terrien’s marginal
normal limits. The anterior chambers eyes were of the order of three seconds degeneration and counselled in the
and lenses were normal. Both fundi with all the puncta open and in prognosis, including a future role for
showed old myopic degenerative apposition to the globe. RGP contact lenses to correct irregular
changes. Computerised corneal topographic astigmatism and the possible need for
Slit-lamp examination two years prior analysis was performed using the Eyesis surgical repair.
was unremarkable except for a corneal corneal analysis system (CAS) . Both The patient was advised to present for
arcus which was unusually prominent eyes demonstrated regular with-the-rule review in 12 months, or sooner if vision
for a 54-year-old without astigmatism on a flat cornea (Figure 5 ) . became unacceptable or other
hyperlipoproteinaemia. At this visit, slit Interestingly, the periphery of both symptoms such as pain or redness
lamp examination revealed peripheral corneae was two to three dioptres flatter developed.
3a 3b
Figure 3a. The peripheral corneal gutter from case two in Figure 4. Pseudopterygium from the LE of case two. Note
section. Photograph of gutter showing the gentle slope the broad, flat head and the oblique angle of insertion.
from the limbus and the sharp rise to the central cornea.
Figure 3b. The peripheral corneal gutter from case two in
section. Diagrammatic representation of the photograph in 3a.
Figure 5. Computerised corneal topographical analysis (Eyesis) of both eyes of case two. Note the regularity of the astigmatism
in the central corneae. Note also the excessive flattening in the far periphery.
DISCUSSION
These cases demonstrate the classical
presentation of Terrien's marginal
degeneration. Early reviews of this
disease found that 75 per cent of
reported cases occurred in males, the
age of the patient varying from 10 to 70
years, with two-thirds being over age 40.2
More recent reports have emphasised
the presence of TMD in female patients
and patients under the age of 40,
including children as young as four
years of age.4-6J3.2528
The clinical picture of TMD can be
considered as having five stages.13~25-2931
to improved vision if scarring from the inconsistent and seemingly in disease differentiation.' In particular,
healing process causes corneal shape i n ~ i d e n t a l . ' ~Pathological
*~~ the presence of inflammation in eyes
changes opposing those created by the investigations have reported stromal with circumferential TMD changes has
disease.36 material in phagocytic cells and the led to the diagnosis of inflammatory
suggestion of a hypersensitivity reaction, TMD, but if the TMD type changes are
Stage 4. Total corneal ectasia but these have been inconsistent and unilateral and confined to a smaller
Stage four occurs when the thinning is fouled by questionable diagnosis of the portion of the circumference, then the
so extensive that the gutter has di~ease.'.~,'~ The significance of such diagnosis may be considered to be
encircled the cornea and total ectasia errors has been highlighted in a recent Mooren's Such difficulties
results. This is rare and results in report that finds strong evidence for an have led some to consider corneal
corneal protrusion similar to that seen autoimmune reaction in Mooren's disease as being not classifiable into
in keratoconus, but the central cornea ulcer, but not for TMD.24 distinct clinical entities but a
will not be as steep as the corneal continuous spectrum of d i s e a ~ e . ~ . ~ ~
thinning is peripheral not central as in Differential diagnosis Similar spectra exist for corneal stromal
keratoconus. Gross astigmatism is Marginal corneal disease has been dystrophies, atopic eye disease and
typical in this stage although the central classically differentiated into a series of anterior segment mesodermal
cornea may be remarkably distinct clinical entities that may be dysgenesis.3w42 This approach recognises
~ymmetrical.~~ associated with systemic disease and which the limited importance of differential
may have a clinically similar appearance diagnosis, if patient management is
Stage 5. Central corneal to TMD. Table 1 lists all such conditions based on the clinical signs and
opacification and their differentiating features. symptoms rather than disease
Small opacities appear in the ectatic Unfortunately, the diagnosis of nomenclature. This is a far more
central cornea remote from the corneal disease is seldom simple. sensible approach that would allow
marginal degeneration." This is Significant overlap in presenting signs diagnoses such as Terrien's type
probably analogous to the cone scarring and symptoms often causes difficulties marginal degeneration (with
seen in keratoconus and may represent
a breakdown of corneal transparency
due to gross stretching. This stage is
rarely seen, since perforation, radical
treatment or mortality has usually Condition Differentiating features
intervened."
Terrien's marginal degeneration is Pellucid marginal degeneration Inferior corneal thinning only; no pseudopterygia; inferior
classically thought to occur without corneal ectasia only.
inflammation, but some reports have Marginal furrow degeneration Asymptomatic, involves 360°of the cornea, no
emphasised an inflammatory ~ a r i a n t . ~ opacification, no vascularisation, no pseudopterygia, no
Inflammation can occur at any stage of ectasia, no change in astigmatism.
the disease, usually effects younger Dellen Localised corneal depression only, not extending
patients and is recurrent. The signs and circumferentially, adjacent to raised lesion, unlikely to be
bilateral.
symptoms include conjunctival
hyperaemia, lacrimation, photophobia Mooren's ulcer Inflammatory, epithelium is disrupted, with consequent
fluorescein staining, tends to be localised, rapidly progressive.
and disabling ~ a i n . ~The
. ~ ' cornea
Rheumatoid disease Associated systemic disease, usually inflammatory, can
appears unaffected in such cases, the
have non-inflammatory peripheral gutter formation with
inflammation being centred in adjacent vascularisation, opacity, lipid deposition, but progresses
deep episclera or superficial scleral more rapidly and leads to keratolysis rather than
Austin and Brown speculated keratectasia.
either that TMD could be considered as Keratoconus No gutter, gross CentraVinferior ectasia, dramatic
a disease with a spectrum of reduction of vision, often in young people, no peripheral
presentations, at one end of which is an opacification, no pseudopterygia.
inflammatory variant, or that all TMD Fungal ulcer Inflammatory, localised, rapidly progressive, history of
trauma.
cases involve inflammation but the
memory of previous inflammation fades Acne rosecea Associated systemic disease, inflammatory more
extensive pannus formation, loss of epithelial integrity.
as the disease runs its protracted course.4
Arcus senilis Possible systemic hyperlipidaemia, no gutter formation, no
The aetiology of TMD remains vascularisation, no ectasia.
unknown with only speculative theories
proposed to date. Many conditions have
been reported to be associated with
TMD, but all associations are Table 1. Differential diagnosis of Terrien's marginal degeneration
Hornhautdeformitat (Diss), G Fussli Monatsbl Augenheilkd 1985; 187: degeneration: a case report with
Zurich (1881) cited by Duke-Elder 374-378. corneal modelling evaluation. Clin
S, System of Ophthalmology. Vol. 14. Insler MS, Baumann JD. Corneal Eye & Vis Care 1992; 4: 64-69.
VIII. London: Kimpton, 1965: thinning syndromes. Ann 26. Grayson M. Diseases of the Cornea.
909-914. Ophthalmol 1986; 18: 7475. St Louis: CV Mosby, 1979: 189-191.
2. Duke-Elder S. System of 15. Soong HK, Fitzgerald J, Boruchoff 27. Sugar AH. Corneal and Conjunctival
Ophthalmology. Vol. VIII. London: SA, Sugar A, Meyer RF, Gabel MG. Degenerations. In: Kaufman HE,
Kimpton, 1965: 909-914. Corneal hydrops in Terrien’s Barron BA, McDonald MB, Waltman
3. Terrien F. Dystrophie marginale marginal degeneration. SR. The Cornea. New York:
symetrique des deux cornees avec Ophthalmology 1986; 93: 340-343. Churchill Livingstone, 1988:
astigmatism regulier consecutif et 16. Guyer DR, Barraquer J, McDonnell 454455.
guerison par la cauterisation ignke. PJ, Green WR. Terrien’s marginal 28. Poirer RH.The Corneal Limbus. In:
Arch Ophtal (Paris) 1900: 20; 12-21, degeneration: clinicopathologic case Liebowitz HM. Corneal Disorders:
cited by Duke-Elder S. System of reports. Graejes Arch Clin Exp Diagnosis and Management.
Ophthalmology. Vol. VIII. London: Ophthalmol 1987; 225: 19-27. Philadelphia: Saunders, 1984: 209.
Kimpton, 1965: 909-914. 17. Hayasaka S, Tsuchiya M, Seikomoto 29. Etzine S, Friedmann A. Marginal
4. Austin P, Brown SI. Inflammatory M, Noda S, Shibuya Y, Setogawa T. dystrophy of the cornea with total
Terrien’s marginal corneal disease. Lysozymal enzymes in tear fluids ectasia. Amm J Ophthalmoll963; 55:
Amer J Ophthalmol 1981; 92: 189-192. from patients with Terrien’s 150-151.
5. Carty RE, Maino JH. Terrien’s marginal degeneration. G a g e s Arch 30. Hinken M V . Marginal degeneration
marginal corneal degeneration: a Clin Exp Ophthalmol 1987; 225: of the cornea. Report of a case
case report. Amm J Optom Physiol Opt 225-227. treated with a scleral autograft. Arch
1981; 58: 1131-1133. 18. Donshik PC, Tedesco J, Carlton R, Ophthalmol 1964; 72: 29-31.
6. Beauchamp GR. Terrien’s marginal Telfer A. Terrien’s marginal 31. Suveges I, Levai G, Albreth B.
corneal degeneration. J Pediatr degeneration associated with central Pathology of Terrien’s disease.
Ophthalmol Strabismus 1982; 19: anterior basement membrane-like Histochemical and electron
97-99. dystrophic changes. Cornea 1987; 6: microscopic study. Amer J Ophthalmol
7. Binder PS, Zavala EY, Stainer GA. 246-249. 1972; 74: 1191-1200.
Noninfectious peripheral corneal 19. Ashenhurst M, Slomovic A. Corneal 32. Goldman KN, Kaufman HE. Atypical
ulceration: Mooren’s ulcer or hydrops in Terrien’s marginal pterygium: a clinical feature of
Terrien’s marginal degeneration? degeneration: an unusual Terrien’s marginal degeneration.
Ann Ophthalmol 1982; 14: 425-35. complication. Can J Ophthalmol 1987; Arch Ophthalmol 1978; 96: 1027-1029.
8. Brito C, Honrubia F, Elia J, Yuste V. 3: 28-30. 33. RowseyJ. Ten caveats in
Maladie de Terrien. J Fr Ophtalmol 20. Romanchuk KG, Hamilton WK, keratorefractive surgery.
1982; 5: 675-679. Braig RF. Terrien’s marginal Ophthalmology 1983; 90: 148-155.
9. Berkowitz PJ, Arentsen J,Felberg degeneration with corneal cyst. 34. Schultz MH. Bilateral marginal
NT, Laibson PR. Presence of Cornea 1990; 9: 86-87. thinning and keratectasia with
circulating immune complexes in 21 Wilson SE, Lin DT, Klyce SD, Insler perforation on one side. Arch
patients with peripheral corneal MS. Terrien’s marginal Ophthalmol 191 1; 40: 368-372.
disease. Arch Ophthalmol 1983; 101: degeneration: corneal topography. 35. Richards WW. Marginal
242-245. Repact Corn Surg 1990; 6: 15-20. degeneration of the cornea with
10. Brown AC, Rao GN, AquavellaJV. 22. Pettit TH. Corneoscleral freehand perforation. Arch Ophthalmol 1963;
Peripheral corneal grafts in lamellar keratoplasty in Terrien’s 70: 610-615.
Terrien’s marginal degeneration. marginal degeneration of the 36. Catania LJ. Primary Care of the
Ophthalmic Surg 1983; 14: 931-934. cornea-long term results. fifract Anterior Segment. Connecticut:
1 1 . Caldwell DR, Insler MS, Boutros G, Corn Surg 1991; 7: 28-32. Appleton and Lange, 1988: 97-99.
Hawk T. Primary surgical repair of 23. Kremer I. Terrien’s marginal 37. Iwamoto T, DeVoe AG, Farris RL.
severe peripheral marginal ectasia in degeneration associated with vernal Electron microscopy in cases of
Terrien’s marginal degeneration. conjunctivitis. Amer J Ophthalmol marginal degeneration of the
Amm J Ophthalmol 1984; 97: 332-336. 1991; 111: 517-8. cornea. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci
12.Joseph A, Fernandez ST, Ittyarath 24. Lopez JS, Price FW Jr, Whitcup SM, 1972; 11: 241-257.
TP, Williams J. Keratectomy in Li Q de Smet M, Chan CC. 39. Watson PG. Vascular changes in
Terrien’s marginal degeneration. Immunohistochemistry of Terrien’s peripheral corneal destructive
Indian J Ophthalmol 1984; 32: and Mooren’s corneal degeneration. disease. Eye 1990; 4: 65-73.
1 13-1 14. Arch Ophthalmol 1991; 109: 988-992. 39. Rodrigues MM, Kratchmer JH.
13. Schulze F. Keratectomy and cataract 25. Horner DG, Heck D, Pence NA, Recent advances in corneal stromal
extraction in Terrien’s disease. Klin Gilmore DM. Terrien’s marginal dystrophies. Cornea 1988; 7: 19-29.
Author's address:
K Pesudovs
5A Mary St
Glenelg North
South Australia 5045
AUSTRALIA