Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
www.soed.in
ABSTRACT
Entrepreneurship has been recognized as a vital tool for bringing rural prosperity. The impact study on entrepreneurship
Members Copy, Not for Commercial Sale
development programme (EDP) and licensing of post-harvest technology in terms of promoting agro processing was undertaken.
www.IndianJournals.com
Multiple regression and Garrett’s ranking techniques were applied to understand the factors affecting the adoption of technology
and prioritization of constraints (i.e., techno-economic, financial, market related, etc.), respectively. EDPs found to be effective
towards encouraging and motivating potential entrepreneurs, resultant to establishment of economically viable enterprises.
Market was found to be key driver, as it has positive and significant (p£
0.01) relationship with adoption of processing technology.
Further, high cost of raw materials and competition among private companies were rated as top most constraints by the
entrepreneurs.
Keywords
EDP, food processing, post-harvest technology, constraints
JEL Codes
Q13, O13, Q18, R11
679
Indian J Econ Dev 12 (4): 2016 (October-December)
of Post Harvest Engineering and Technology (CIPHET) Percent position = 100 × (Rij – 0.5)/Nj
www.IndianJournals.com
680
Dixit et al.: Entrepreneurship through EDP and licensing of post-harvest technology: An impact assessment
Table 1: Opinion of Beneficiaries about EDP more are coming in a big way in other parts of the country
Particulars (n=125) Mean score* as well, as a result of demonstration effect. Survey results
(1 to 5) indicated that 84.21 persons were found to be motivated
Awareness creation about technology and 4.55 and adopted ICAR-CIPHET technology in case of soy
its utility processing followed by and 37.5 percent in meat
processing (Table 3). However, the percent adoption per
Improvement in technical know-how 4.33
about process/technology se does not always depict the real picture as there was 100
percent adoption in case of Makhana Kheer Mix and
Confidence building as a result of hands 3.98
Turmeric processing, as number of licensee and adopter
on practices
was one in each case.
Understanding about source of credit 3.5 Establishment of large scale Guava processing at
Helpful in providing better marketing 3.2 Hambran village and Pasta making plant in Hoshiarpur,
option gave the clear message that ICAR-CIPHET intervention
Facilitate for preparation of business plan 3.3 in the form of EDP/ documentation of project
profile/licensing have been found rewarding in terms of
Persuasion for establishment of 3.53 promoting entrepreneurship. Overall, 27.55 percent of
processing unit licensee and EDP participants adopted ICAR-CIPHET
Change in overall outlook towards 3.6 technologies (Table 3).
processing Income and employment generation
*5- Highly Agree, 4-Agree, 3- neither agree nor disagree, The enterprises were found economically viable, as
2- disagree and 1 - Highly Disagree evident from selected case study of soy processing, meat
processing, green chilli processing and guava processing.
Downloaded From IP - 14.139.225.2 on dated 13-Jan-2017
and impact on the ground was reported by the researchers The impact of these enterprises was realized in terms of
as one of the difficulty. The data pertaining to time lag enhanced income and employment per unit in a year. On
Members Copy, Not for Commercial Sale
between selected technologies (developed by ICAR- an average economic benefits accrued in case of soy
www.IndianJournals.com
CIPHET) and their commercialization was found processing (capital investment of `7.4 lakh/unit) was to
reasonably acceptable (Table 2). In some cases, the tune of `5.85 lakh/annum and benefit- cost ratio of
technology has been commercialized without any time 1.86 (Table 4), indicating these ventures are on good
lag or a lag of 6 months to one year. The institute is rightly financially footing. Similarly, economic benefits of the
putting up the efforts in the direction of enterprises such as meat processing (`3.20
commercialization of technology, as evident from the lakh/unit/annum), green chilli processing (`1.54
analysis. lakh/unit/annum) and guava processing (`1.40
Adoption of ICAR-CIPHET Technology by the lakh/unit/annum) were estimated and presented in
Entrepreneurs abridged form so as to economize the space (Table 5).
EDP and licensing were found to be motivated The cumulative economic benefits of the selected
beneficiaries that further led to adoption of some enterprise have been estimated on an annual basis taking
enterprise. Interestingly, spillover effect was experienced into account the number of processing units established
in some cases. For instance, a good number of soy by EDP participants/license at the time of this study.
processing plants have been established in Punjab and Besides, these enterprises generated direct employment
681
Indian J Econ Dev 12 (4): 2016 (October-December)
to the tune of 24000 man days per annum in soy Table 4: Economic benefits from soybean processing
Downloaded From IP - 14.139.225.2 on dated 13-Jan-2017
and guava processing (27 Nos) have gained net benefits of (`)
`121.08 lakh per annum and total direct employment A. Fixed cost
generated was to the tune of 38220 man days per annum (i) Cost of machineries and equipments 735000
(Table 5). These units also provided indirect employment (ii) Installation charges 5000
to a reasonable degree to those engaged in marketing of
A1. Fixed cost (` per month) 6660
raw and final products. Interestingly, one Mega Project on
fruits (guava, mango, litchi, and apple) and vegetable B. Variable cost per month
(tomato) processing plant of worth `6.0 crore was (i) Cost of raw material @ `30 /kg 27000
established after getting motivation and guidance from (ii) Electricity charge (` per month) 2500
ICAR-CIPHET. As per our estimate, this plant has a (iii) Labour charges 15000
potential to generate an income of `60 lakh per annum and (iv) Monthly repair and maintenance charges 500
employment to 125-150 persons for six months.
Intangible benefits realized by the EDP participants (v) Packing and packaging cost @ `1/100g 7250
and licensee packet
? The beneficiaries have started commodities/products (vi) Other ingredients (sugar, SMP, preservative) 9000
diversification such as processing of tamarind, (` per month)
mango, litchi and apple based on EDP on guava Total variable cost ( i to vi) 61250
processing. C. Total cost (A1+B) 67910
? Guava entrepreneurs have explored new marketing D. Returns
channels in the state of Haryana, Delhi, Himachal (i) Soya paneer (qtuantity % price @ `70/kg) 42000
Pradesh and Punjab by establishing linkages with per month
traders of other food commodities.
(ii) Flavoured milk @ ` 40 /lt. 90000
? The enhancement of quality, safety and hygienic
conditions. Bhatinda based Soya processor has E. Gross Returns from milk and paneer 132000
installed RO system, Automatic packaging with batch F. Marketing cost and Commission to 10560
number after getting educated on good manufacturing middleman @8% on MRP
practices (GMP) in training programme. After getting G. Return from by-product, i.e., okara (`/month) 5000
inspired from ICAR-CIPHET EDP, the soya H. Gross income after marketing cost and 126440
entrepreneur(s) got exposure on soya processing from Commission (D-E)+F
USA and Canada. Net profit (G-C) per month 58530
? Broaden knowledge contours of the entrepreneurs. Annual net profit (300 days) 585300
For instance, one entrepreneur has designed and Benefit-cost ratio 1.86
682
Dixit et al.: Entrepreneurship through EDP and licensing of post-harvest technology: An impact assessment
developed new machine for turmeric processing based Table 6: Factors affecting adoption of technology
on the idea received while visiting ICAR-CIPHET Explanatory variables Regression t-value
workshop at Ludhiana. coefficient
Factors Affecting Adoption of Technology Age (years) -1.62* -2.191
Undoubtedly, EDP/licensing of technologies
contributed in adoption of technology and establishment Education (schooling years) -0.004NS -0.07
of processing unit but it is equally true that EDP per se is Family size 2.129 1.561
not the deciding factors for adoption. In an examination, Raw material availability 0.679*** 5.204
personal characteristics of farmers’/entrepreneurs’ such
Innovativeness in Technology 0.087* 2.057
as age, ability/skill of creating and evaluating a business
strategies, recognizing and realizing opportunities and Higher initial cost of machinery -0.185NS -1.406
Downloaded From IP - 14.139.225.2 on dated 13-Jan-2017
networking with traders and marketing agents were found Approachable Market for final 0.213*** 3.702
deciding factors for adoption of the technology. It was product
Members Copy, Not for Commercial Sale
also noticed that availability of raw material (in vicinity) Non-availability of credit -0.071NS -0.573
www.IndianJournals.com
683
Indian J Econ Dev 12 (4): 2016 (October-December)
basis. Labour and capital were rated as moderate but Garret ranking was low. There is a need to develop
constraints. As far as marketing related constraints are comprehensive strategies by government, research
concerned, packing, packaging, storage and institutions and other line departments in an integrated
transportation were not reported as ‘very serious manner to deal with these constraints so as to accelerate
constraint’ but retailers’ commission was rated as the growth of processing sector.
‘extreme constraint’. Market for soya products, was Expectations of the Entrepreneurs from R&D
initially considered as ‘least constraint’ but once business Organization
progress, market was not a constraint, provided quality 1. Need for improved technology for enhancing the
being maintained. It is mentioned that huge margins of recovery of guava pulp and efficient drying of guava
middle man/marketing agencies restricts new entrants in leather.
processing sector. 2. Automatic machine for toffee/candy manufacturing
Prioritization of Constraints need to be designed and developed for small and
The constraints faced by the EDP participants and medium entrepreneurs. Presently, work is being done
entrepreneurs were further prioritized with the help of manually, which is tedious and time consuming.
Garrett mean score. Further, non-availability of market 3. Training on smart marketing is required for
for final product, competition among entrepreneurs and establishing linkages of small entrepreneurs with co-
private companies were rated as top most constraint operatives, marketing agencies/actors and
(Garret score 76.35). The entrepreneurs have also consumers.
expressed their concern that the price of raw material was 4. Training on by-product utilization is required. For
high particularly in case of peanut/groundnut and green example, utilization of soybean okara for making
chilli. Participants asked for more hands on practices value added products.
during EDP/training programmes, as they have rated this 5. Process protocols need to be further standardized for
Downloaded From IP - 14.139.225.2 on dated 13-Jan-2017
IIIrd most influential constraint (Table 7). In addition, non- retaining/maintaining colour of green chilli powder
availability of credit and non-availability of precise and for each batch.
Members Copy, Not for Commercial Sale
timely market information were rated as IV and V 6. Business profile for each technology need to be
www.IndianJournals.com
position, respectively. Some physical (such as non- prepared for interested participants and should be
availability of power, communication, and quality provided during EDP/training.
control) and institutional constraints (least developed Suggestions for Further Improvement in EDP
social capital and franchising model) were also reported 1. Certain criteria based on need assessment,
684
Dixit et al.: Entrepreneurship through EDP and licensing of post-harvest technology: An impact assessment
processing units have resulted into economic benefits to rural entrepreneurship: A case study evidence from
the intended beneficiaries, besides generating direct and Cumbria, England. Environment and Planning. 38 (8):
Members Copy, Not for Commercial Sale
benefits such as quality conscious, product Kumari, I. 2014. A Study on Entrepreneurship Development
diversification, design and development of machinery, Process. Indian Journal of Research. 3 (4): 51-53.
exploring market channels, participation in training at Labrianidis, L. 2006. Fostering entrepreneurship as a means
abroad, etc. were also realized by the participants. Finally, to overcome barriers to development of rural peripheral
need based EDPs considering socio-economic areas in Europe. European Planning Studies. 14 (1): 3-
conditions, willingness, resources availability, 8.
geographical dimensions, and market for final product are Lackeus. 2015. Entrepreneurship in education. In:
to be promoted so as to encourage processing in the Entrepreneurship 360 Background Paper by OECD.
production catchments. McClelland, D.C. and Winter, D.G. 1969. Motivating
REFERENCES Economic Achievement. Free Press, New York.
Arrow, K. 1962. The Economic Implications of Learning by Mruthyunjaya, Pal, S., Pandey, L.M., and Jha, A.K. 2004.
Doing. The Review of Economic Studies. 29 (3): 155- Impact of selected technologies refined under NATP.
173. Agricultural economics Research Review. 17
Bharti, D. K. 2005. Economics of agro processing centres/ (conference issue): 1-13.
units in Punjab, Haryana and Western Uttar Pradesh. Oladipo, J.A. 2008. Agro-industry as strategy for rural
Technical Bulletin No CIPHET/Pub./03/2005,CIPHET development: An impact assessment of Nigeria oil palm
Ludhiana: 29. industry. European Journal of Social Science. 7 (1): 75-
Bosworth, G. 2008. Entrepreneurial in-migrants and 87.
economic development in rural England. International Panigrahy, G. and Hota, P.K. 2016. Entrepreneurship
Journal of Entrepreneurship and Small Business. 6: education influencing students’ entrepreneurial
355-369. competence building. Siddhant. 16 (1): 69-72.
Chand Khem, Roy, P.K. and Singh. Y.V. 2006. Market and Rastogi, P. 2014. India: Licensing and technology transfer: A
processing infrastructure development versus growth of g l a n c e o n I n d i a n s c e n a r i o .
Henna in arid fringes of Rajasthan. Indian Journal of http://www.mondaq.com/india/x/346256/Licensing+S
Agricultural Economics. 61 (3): 57. y n d i c a t i o n / L i c e n s i n g + A n d + Te c h n o l o g y +
Chowdhary, N. and Prakash, M. 2010. Entrepreneurship Transfer+A+Glance+On+Indian+Scenario (web
Development Programme or Process. IIMS Journal of accessed on 24 May 2016)
Management Science. 1(1): 46-59. Saini, J.S. and Bhatia, B.S. 1996. Impact of
Dixit, A.K., Nanda, S.K., Singh, K.P. and Kudos, S.K.A. Entrepreneurship Development Programmes. The
2011. Economic benefits of Vivek millet thresher-cum- Journal of Entrepreneurship. 5 (1): 65-80.
pearler and agro processing centre in hilly region of Singh, K.P., Srivastava A.K., Srinivas K., Singh S.R.K. and
Uttarakhand. Journal of Hill Agriculture. 2 (2): 177- Gupta H.S. 2007. Entrepreneurship development in
685
Indian J Econ Dev 12 (4): 2016 (October-December)
Agriculture through agro processing centre: a case study income and employment: A case study of Agro
of Almora district in NW Himalaya. Invited Overview 2 Processing Centre in Almora district. Journal of
(9): 1-13. Agricultural Development and Policy. 19 (1): 44-53.
Singh, R. and Verma, O.P. 2012. Entrepreneurship Walker, T., M. Maredia, T. Kelley, R. La Rovere, D.
Development Practices: A Case Study of Himachal Templeton, G. Thiele, and B. Douthwaite. 2008.
Pradesh. International Journal of Physics and Social Strategic Guidance for ex-post impact assessment of
Sciences. 2 (6): 139-158. agricultural research. Report of the Standing Panel on
Srinivas K, Singh K.P., Kumar A. and Bisht K.K.S. 2009. Impact Assessment, (CGIAR) Science council, Science
Rural entrepreneurship developmen for generating Council Secretariat: Rome, Italy, 1-88.
Downloaded From IP - 14.139.225.2 on dated 13-Jan-2017
Members Copy, Not for Commercial Sale
www.IndianJournals.com
686