2/26/2019 FPE Extra Issue 38, February 2019

 (https://www.facebook.com/sfpe.org)
Home (/) Renew (/?Page=Renew)  (http://blog.sfpe.org/feed/)
Donate (/?Page=Donate) Contact Us (/General/?Type=CONTACT) 

(https://twitter.com/SFPE_Inc) 
Your Cart (/Store/YourCart .A spx) Sign In (/Login.A spx) Join (/General/Register_start .A sp)
(https://www.youtube.com/user/SFPEorg/videos) 
(https://www.linkedin.com/company/340573/)
(/) MENU

FPE EXTRA ISSUE 38, FEBRUARY 2019

Ten Fundamental Principles on Defining and Expressing

Thermal Exposure as Boundary Conditions in Fire Safety
Engineering
By Ulf Wickström, FSFPE
Predicting the temperature of exposed objects is one of the most-common and fundamental
tasks in fire safety engineering. As a first step, thermal exposure must be specified. That can be
done by measurements, fire modeling or standard specifications. These must be clear, well-
defined and consistent. However, how these are interpreted is o en clouded by a lack of
common understanding of how the exposure parameters shall be used to estimate and calculate
the temperature of exposed bodies. This deficiency hinders a sound development of fire safety
engineering (FSE).

Fire safety engineers typically use gas temperature, incident heat fluxes and — lately —
adiabatic surface temperature (AST) to express thermal exposure. However, since approaches
are not always consistent, the task group on Local Fire Exposures of the SFPE Standards-Making
Committee on Calculating Fire Exposures has formulated 10 key fundamental principles for how
to define and express thermal boundary conditions in FSE.

The principles are general and can be applied to material reaction fire problems, such as time to
ignition estimates and fire resistance of structures under very high temperature exposures. 1

The 10 principles are shown in bold type with comments providing additional explanation. 2

Principle 1
Thermal exposure is governed by two independent parameters: incident radiant heat flux
(or irradiance) and gas temperature T g .

https://www.sfpe.org/page/FPEExtraIssue38 1/6
2/26/2019 FPE Extra Issue 38, February 2019

Since   and T g  are independent, they must be treated separately and cannot, in principle, be
replaced by one single parameter, such as fire temperature or heat flux, as is o en seen in FSE
literature.  

Principle 2
Heat is transferred to solid surfaces by radiation and convection here denoted 
 where the net radiation is the di erence between the absorbed and
emitted radiation, i.e. .

The net radiation  is the di erence between the two independent entities, absorbed radiant
heat   and the emitted radiant heat  . Convection heat flux, on the other hand, depends on
the di erence between the gas and surface temperatures. The heat flux   is proportional to
the solid surface temperature gradient.

Principle 3
The incident radiation can be expressed as  . The radiation temperature

may be either greater or smaller than the gas temperature  .

The term radiation temperature is to be used as an alternative to incident

radiation. It includes the contributions from all surfaces, gas masses, flames, etc., that might
radiate onto a surface.

Principle 4
The heat transfer   to solid surfaces consists of three independent components: heat
absorbed by radiation , heat emitted by radiation   and heat
transferred by convection , i.e.  .

Thus, the three parameters — incident radiation, surface temperature and di erence between gas
and surface temperatures — govern the heat transferred. Heat transfer by convection cannot be
split into positive and negative physical quantities as can be done for radiation.

Principle 5
Gas temperature T g can be measured with very thin or aspirating thermocouples. Incident
radiation  or T r can be measured using radiometers.

Thermocouples influenced by the radiation and gas temperatures adapts to temperatures

between T g and T r . The thinner they are, the closer they measure gas temperature.

Water-cooled heat flux meter measures the heat flux to a small surface at a temperature near
that of the cooling water. When placed in room temperature they measure incident radiation.
However, when placed in hot gases the heat transfer by convection to the sensor may be of the
same order of magnitude as that by radiation, and the output is in practice more or less
impossible to interpret in terms of incident radiation.

Incident radiation can be measured with plate thermometers (PT). These have a large exposed
surface and therefore the contribution by convection is small. Combined with gas temperature
measurements, plate thermometers can be used to attain incident heat flux and adiabatic
https://www.sfpe.org/page/FPEExtraIssue38 2/6
2/26/2019 FPE Extra Issue 38, February 2019

surface temperatures in both ambient air and hot fire gases.

Principle 6
Heat flux (radiation plus convection) is o en measured in Fire Safety Engineering (FSE)
with water-cooled Heat Flux Meters (HFM). Given an exposed surface is assumed to have the
same emissivity and convection heat transfer coe icient as the HFM sensor, the heat
transfer to an exposed surface can be calculated as
 where   is the temperature of the sensor
surface.

Thus, when using data from water-cooled HFM assumptions must be made concerning the
convection heat transfer coe icient and the emissivity of the sensor surface. 3  

Principle 7
With a given relation   a single ‘e ective’ exposure temperature, the adiabatic surface
temperature , can be defined by the relation   or

. is always between T g and T r .

When a solid surface has the adiabatic surface temperature, the sum of the heat transfer by
radiation and convection is zero. The AST is always between the gas and radiation
temperatures. The AST can be measured with PTs made of thin metal plates insulated on the
back side.

Principle 8
The heat flux to a surface with a temperature T s can be calculated as
.

AST can replace the radiation and gas temperatures and be used as single parameter boundary
condition.

Unfortunately, in many standards on calculation of temperature in fire exposed structures the

boundary conditions are specified imprecisely as ‘heat flux’ or implicitly ‘heat flux to a surface
at ambient temperature’ or similar. This type of boundary conditions is generally not possible to
apply for calculations and should be avoided.

Principle 9
 can be measured with Plate Thermometers. PTs have large surfaces to get a
convection heat transfer coe icient as well as an emissivity like a real exposed body. The
PT sensing plate is thin to achieve a fast time response (a short time constant). As incident
radiation depends on directions, the PT temperature T PT and   depend on orientation.

 The AST measured with PTs can be the basis for calculation of the heat flux to fire exposed
bodies. In many cases of severe fire conditions PT measurements are in practice the only way of
getting input data to be used for calculation of temperature of for example steel structures.

https://www.sfpe.org/page/FPEExtraIssue38 3/6
2/26/2019 FPE Extra Issue 38, February 2019

Principle 10
Given the HFM and PT are assumed to have the same emissivities and convection heat transfer
coe icients, .

  Under certain conditions there is a one-to-one relation between the heat flux measured with an
HFM and the temperature measured with a PT. Thus, ‘incident heat flux’ or shorter ‘heat flux’ to
a cooled surface as given in a standard can be interpreted as an AST and used for calculations.

Ulf Wickström, FSFPE is with Luleå University of Technology and TASEF Fire Consulting

References

1
Wickström, U., Temperature Calculation in Fire Safety Engineering, Springer International Publishing. 2016.

> 2 Wickström U, Hunt S, Lattimer B, Barnett J, Beyler C. Fire and Materials. 2018;1–4.

3
Brian Y. Lattimer, “Heat Transfer from Fires to Surfaces,” in Hurley, et al., Eds. (2015). SFPE Handbook of

Fire Protection Engineering, 5th Ed. Gaithersburg, MD: SFPE.

(https://www.clixtrac.com/banner/click.php?
banner=274978)

https://www.sfpe.org/page/FPEExtraIssue38 4/6
2/26/2019 FPE Extra Issue 38, February 2019

ABOUT SFPE (HTTPS://SFPE.SITE-YM.COM/?PAGE=ABOUT)

BOARD OF DIRECTORS (HTTP://WWW.SFPE.ORG/?PAGE=BOARDOFDIRECTORS1)

GOVERNANCE DOCS (HTTPS://SFPE.SITE-YM.COM/?PAGE=GOVERNANCE)

SFPE FOUNDATION (HTTPS://WWW.SFPE.ORG/PAGE/FOUNDATION)

I want to…

SHOP THE SFPE STORE (/STORE/DEFAULT.ASPX?)

FIND AN FPE (HTTP://WWW.SFPE.ORG/SEARCH/CUSTOM.ASP?ID=4605)

EARN CEUS & PDHS (HTTPS://SFPE.SITE-YM.COM/?PAGE=UPCOMINGSEMINARS)

MAKE A DONATION (HTTPS://WWW.SFPE.ORG/MPAGE/FOUNDATIONFUNDS)

FIND A NEW CAREER (HTTP://JOBS.SFPE.ORG/)

FIND A LOCAL CHAPTER (HTTP://WWW.SFPE.ORG/PAGE/CHAPTERS)

 (HTTPS://WWW.FACEBOOK.COM/SFPE.ORG)
 (HTTP://BLOG.SFPE.ORG/FEED/)
 (HTTPS://TWITTER.COM/SFPE_INC)
 (HTTPS://WWW.YOUTUBE.COM/USER/SFPEORG/VIDEOS)
 (HTTPS://WWW.LINKEDIN.COM/GROUPS/SFPE-
96627/ABOUT/)

CONTACT SFPE STAFF (HTTPS://SFPE.SITE-YM.COM/PAGE/CONTACTUS)

9711 WASHINGTONIAN BLVD.

SUITE 380

GAITHERSBURG, MD 20878

+ 1 301.718.2910 (TEL:1301.718.2910)

INFO@SFPE.ORG (MAILTO:INFO@SFPE.ORG)

Membership

https://www.sfpe.org/page/FPEExtraIssue38 5/6
2/26/2019 FPE Extra Issue 38, February 2019

JOIN (HTTPS://SFPE.SITE-YM.COM/GENERAL/REGISTER_MEMBER_TYPE.ASP)

RENEW (HTTPS://SFPE.SITE-YM.COM/LOGIN.ASPX?RETURL=%2FDEFAULT.ASP%3FPAGE%3DRENEW)

BENEFITS (HTTPS://SFPE.SITE-YM.COM/PAGE/MEMBERBENEFITS)

SFPE FORUM (HTTP://WWW.SFPE.ORG/?PAGE=SFPEFORUM)

MEMBER ONLY AREA (HTTPS://SFPE.SITE-YM.COM/LOGIN.ASPX)

© SFPE ® | All Rights Reserved

PRIVACY POLICY (HTTP://WWW.SFPE.ORG/MPAGE/PRIVACYPOLICY)

Membership So ware Powered by YourMembership (http://www.yourmembership.com/)  ::  Legal

(/ams/legal-privacy.htm)

https://www.sfpe.org/page/FPEExtraIssue38 6/6