Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Original Investigation
MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES Incidence of and time to orbital recurrence, metastasis, and
death.
RESULTS There were 5 orbital recurrences (incidence, 7.9%) in the primary enucleation group
and 1 orbital recurrence (incidence, 1.3%) in the primary OAC group during median follow-up
times of 42.6 months (range, 6.2-97.1 months) and 38.7 months (range, 9.0-104.3 months),
respectively. The 24-month Kaplan-Meier estimate for orbital recurrence–free survival was
worse for the enucleation group (92.1%; 95% CI, 82.0-96.7) than for the OAC group (100%)
(log-rank test, P = .049). The enucleation group had 5 cases of metastatic disease (7.9%) and
2 deaths (3.2%). In the OAC group, there were 3 cases of metastatic disease (4.2%) and no
deaths. Kaplan-Meier analysis of metastasis-free survival and overall survival yielded no
differences between the 2 treatment groups. Analysis of a number of features of the 2 groups
revealed more eyes with iris neovascularization in the enucleation group (25.4%) than in the Author Affiliations: Ophthalmic
OAC group (5.2%) and more eyes with group E retinoblastoma in the enucleation group Oncology Service, Memorial Sloan-
Kettering Cancer Center, New York,
(87.3%) than in the OAC group (29.9%), although neither of these factors was an
New York (Yannuzzi, Francis, Marr,
independent predictor of orbital relapse in a Cox proportional hazards model. Belinsky, Abramson); Department of
Ophthalmology, Weill Cornell Medical
CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE In this single-institution retrospective study of advanced College, New York, New York (Francis,
Marr, Abramson); Department of
intraocular retinoblastoma, there were more orbital recurrences in the group primarily Pediatrics, Weill Cornell Medical
treated with enucleation. Ophthalmic artery chemosurgery for advanced intraocular College, New York, New York
retinoblastoma was not found to increase the chance of orbital recurrence, metastatic (Dunkel); Department of Pediatrics,
Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer
disease, or death compared with primary enucleation.
Center, New York, New York
(Dunkel); Service of Interventional
Neuroradiology, Department of
Neurology and Radiology, Weill
Cornell Medical College, New York,
New York (Gobin).
Corresponding Author: David
Harold Abramson, MD, Ophthalmic
Oncology Service, Memorial Sloan-
Kettering Cancer Center, 1275 York
JAMA Ophthalmol. 2015;133(9):1062-1066. doi:10.1001/jamaophthalmol.2015.2243 Ave, New York, NY 10065 (abramsod
Published online July 16, 2015. @mskcc.org).
D
uring the past several years, ophthalmic artery che-
mosurgery (OAC) has emerged as a safe and effective At a Glance
treatment for advanced retinoblastoma. A recent sur-
• Ophthalmic artery chemosurgery has emerged as a leading
vey revealed that 74% of retinoblastoma treatment centers therapy for advanced retinoblastoma.
worldwide are using OAC as first-line therapy for advanced uni- • Orbital retinoblastoma carries a poor prognosis and is often
lateral disease.1 Eyes treated initially with OAC have been associated with metastatic disease.
shown to have ocular event-free survival rates at 2 years of • This retrospective study compares orbital recurrence, metastatic
greater than 80% despite their advanced stage.2 These find- disease, and overall survival in naive eyes treated primarily with
either ophthalmic artery chemosurgery or enucleation.
ings have been replicated at multiple centers, demonstrating
• More orbital recurrences were found in the enucleation group
that OAC as a primary therapy3-5 or with intravenous chemo- than in the ophthalmic artery chemosurgery group.
therapy as a bridge6 may achieve globe salvage and tumor con-
trol in a high percentage of eyes with group D and E retino-
blastoma. Further, OAC has been shown to be useful in the
treatment of vitreous seeds7 and to prevent the development out subretinal fluid or up to total retinal detachment. In con-
of new intraocular tumors, suggesting that it may affect oph- trast, eyes with group E retinoblastoma have 1 or more poor
thalmoscopically undetectable tumors present at initial prognostic features, including tumor touching the lens, tu-
diagnosis.8 mor anterior to the anterior vitreous face or involving the cili-
While the multiple benefits and favorable risk profile of ary body or anterior segment, diffuse infiltrating retinoblas-
OAC have been documented in the literature, the incidence of toma, neovascular glaucoma, opaque media from hemorrhage,
orbital recurrence in patients treated with this modality has tumor necrosis with aseptic orbital cellulitis, or phthisis bulbi.
not been previously described, to our knowledge. Several prior Patients were treated initially with either enucleation at
studies have documented rates of orbital recurrence after pri- MSKCC or OAC at New York–Presbyterian Hospital (Weill Cor-
mary enucleation ranging from 5%9 to 7.6%,10 although these nell Medical College) and then followed up at MSKCC. The start
series included eyes that presented with extraocular disease. date of this series represents the advent of OAC at our institu-
The one study that was limited to patients who presented with tions. Clinical characteristics, including sex, age at presenta-
intraocular disease revealed an incidence of only 4.2% dur- tion, laterality of disease, treatment history, presence of iris
ing the course of almost 100 years, ranging between 3.7% and neovascularization on clinical examination at initial presen-
5.1% when calculated using 20-year periods.11 tation, and postenucleation pathology, were collected via the
Because orbital involvement carries a poor prognosis and electronic medical record.
is commonly associated with metastatic disease both outside Orbital recurrence was initially assessed by clinical exami-
and within the central nervous system,12-14 the characteriza- nation and magnetic resonance imaging. When there was sus-
tion of orbital recurrence in the context of OAC is of signifi- picion for orbital disease, cases were confirmed with biopsy
cant interest. Eighty-five percent of patients with orbital re- and histopathology. Metastatic disease was assessed by com-
currence have been reported to develop metastatic disease and puted tomography, bone scan, bone marrow biopsy or aspi-
75% die from metastatic retinoblastoma, although mortality rate, and magnetic resonance imaging. Eyes treated primar-
rates have decreased in the modern era.11 The purpose of this ily with OAC but eventually enucleated were included in the
study was to reexamine orbital recurrence in advanced reti- OAC group and not the enucleation group. Eyes that had re-
noblastoma after treatment with OAC and to compare these ceived systemic, intra-arterial, or intravitreal chemotherapy
rates with those in eyes treated with enucleation during the or external beam or plaque radiotherapy prior to enucleation
same period in the same institution. were excluded from the analysis. Other exclusion criteria were
follow-up time less than 6 months, orbital or extraocular reti-
noblastoma at initial presentation, or trilateral retinoblas-
toma.
Methods The study was approved by the MSKCC Institutional Re-
Data Collection view Board. Informed consent was not required owing to the
This single-institution cohort study is a retrospective record retrospective nature of the study.
review of patients primarily treated at Memorial Sloan-
Kettering Cancer Center (MSKCC) who presented between Feb- Statistical Analysis
ruary 14, 2006, and March 4, 2014, with advanced intraocu- SPSS version 21 (IBM Corp) and Prism (GraphPad Software) were
lar retinoblastoma that fulfilled criteria for Reese-Ellsworth used to construct Kaplan-Meier (KM) curves of orbital recur-
group 5 or International Classification of Retinoblastoma (ICRB; rence–free survival, metastasis-free survival, and overall sur-
Children’s Oncology Group) group D or E. This analysis was con- vival. The KM curves were then compared using a log-rank test.
ducted between August 1, 2014, and March 1, 2015. Eyes with A multivariate Cox proportional hazards regression model was
Reese-Ellsworth group 5 retinoblastoma are defined as hav- used to assess for associations between treatment (OAC vs
ing massive tumor involving more than 50% of the retina and enucleation), presence of iris neovascularization, and ICRB
vitreous seeding. Eyes with ICRB (Children’s Oncology Group) group E classification and the outcome measure of orbital re-
group D retinoblastoma are defined as having diffuse disease currence–free survival using Wald stepwise backward elimi-
with significant vitreous or subretinal seeding, with or with- nation.
jamaophthalmology.com (Reprinted) JAMA Ophthalmology September 2015 Volume 133, Number 9 1063
1064 JAMA Ophthalmology September 2015 Volume 133, Number 9 (Reprinted) jamaophthalmology.com
jamaophthalmology.com (Reprinted) JAMA Ophthalmology September 2015 Volume 133, Number 9 1065
United States and other more developed countries, however, poor prognostic features such as iris neovascularization, neo-
it is a marker for metastatic disease. Eighty percent of pa- vascular glaucoma, or phthisis bulbi. This explains the larger
tients in the United States who present with orbital disease are percentage of eyes with advanced group E retinoblastoma and
found to have concurrent widespread metastases,21 and the iris neovascularization in the enucleated group. However, these
orbital disease can be considered a surrogate of metastatic dis- differences were addressed in our regression analysis.
ease. Therefore, it is plausible that orbital disease, as well as
metastatic disease, is present microscopically at the time of
treatment with enucleation or first OAC. A possible mecha-
nism by which OAC reduces the incidence of orbital disease
Conclusions
but not of metastases is that OAC, with its high ocular concen- This study demonstrates that treatment-naive eyes with ad-
tration of drug, effectively obliterates microscopic orbital foci, vanced retinoblastoma treated in our institutions with OAC had
but because the systemic dose is so low, it has no impact on fewer orbital recurrences and that no differences in meta-
distant metastatic disease. static disease could be identified compared with enucleation.
A limitation of our study is its retrospective design. Our Additional studies on orbital and metastatic disease in eyes
center typically recommends primary enucleation for eyes with treated with OAC could help to support or refute our findings.
ARTICLE INFORMATION 2. Gobin YP, Dunkel IJ, Marr BP, Brodie SE, 12. Doz F, Khelfaoui F, Mosseri V, et al. The role of
Submitted for Publication: March 20, 2015; final Abramson DH. Intra-arterial chemotherapy for the chemotherapy in orbital involvement of
revision received May 28, 2015; accepted May 29, management of retinoblastoma: four-year retinoblastoma: the experience of a single
2015. experience. Arch Ophthalmol. 2011;129(6):732-737. institution with 33 patients. Cancer. 1994;74(2):
3. Suzuki S, Yamane T, Mohri M, Kaneko A. 722-732.
Published Online: July 16, 2015.
doi:10.1001/jamaophthalmol.2015.2243. Selective ophthalmic arterial injection therapy for 13. Singh AD, Shields CL, Shields JA. Prognostic
intraocular retinoblastoma: the long-term factors in retinoblastoma. J Pediatr Ophthalmol
Author Contributions: Drs Yannuzzi and Abramson prognosis. Ophthalmology. 2011;118(10):2081-2087. Strabismus. 2000;37(3):134-141.
had full access to all of the data in the study and
take responsibility for the integrity of the data and 4. Shields CL, Manjandavida FP, Lally SE, et al. 14. Kopelman JE, McLean IW, Rosenberg SH.
the accuracy of the data analysis. Intra-arterial chemotherapy for retinoblastoma in Multivariate analysis of risk factors for metastasis in
Study concept and design: Yannuzzi, Francis, Marr, 70 eyes: outcomes based on the International retinoblastoma treated by enucleation.
Gobin, Abramson. Classification of Retinoblastoma. Ophthalmology. Ophthalmology. 1987;94(4):371-377.
Acquisition, analysis, or interpretation of data: 2014;121(7):1453-1460. 15. Rubin CM, Robison LL, Cameron JD, et al.
Yannuzzi, Francis, Marr, Belinsky, Dunkel, Gobin. 5. Peterson EC, Elhammady MS, Quintero-Wolfe S, Intraocular retinoblastoma group V: an analysis of
Drafting of the manuscript: Yannuzzi. Murray TG, Aziz-Sultan MA. Selective ophthalmic prognostic factors. J Clin Oncol. 1985;3(5):680-685.
Critical revision of the manuscript for important artery infusion of chemotherapy for advanced 16. Baez KA, Ulbig MW, Cater J, Shields CL, Shields
intellectual content: All authors. intraocular retinoblastoma: initial experience with JA. Iris neovascularization, increased intraocular
Statistical analysis: Yannuzzi. 17 tumors. J Neurosurg. 2011;114(6):1603-1608. pressure and vitreous hemorrhage as risk factors
Obtained funding: Abramson. 6. Gobin YP, Dunkel IJ, Marr BP, Francis JH, Brodie for invasion of the optic nerve and choroid in
Administrative, technical, or material support: SE, Abramson DH. Combined, sequential children with retinoblastoma [in German].
Belinsky, Gobin, Abramson. intravenous and intra-arterial chemotherapy Ophthalmologe. 1994;91(6):796-800.
Study supervision: Francis, Marr, Belinsky, Dunkel, (bridge chemotherapy) for young infants with
Gobin, Abramson. 17. Shields CL, Shields JA, Baez KA, Cater J, De
retinoblastoma. PLoS One. 2012;7(9):e44322. Potter PV. Choroidal invasion of retinoblastoma:
Conflict of Interest Disclosures: All authors have 7. Abramson DH, Marr BP, Dunkel IJ, et al. metastatic potential and clinical risk factors. Br J
completed and submitted the ICMJE Form for Intra-arterial chemotherapy for retinoblastoma in Ophthalmol. 1993;77(9):544-548.
Disclosure of Potential Conflicts of Interest. Dr eyes with vitreous and/or subretinal seeding: 2-year
Dunkel reported receiving personal fees from 18. Chantada GL, Gonzalez A, Fandino A, et al.
results. Br J Ophthalmol. 2012;96(4):499-502. Some clinical findings at presentation can predict
Bristol-Myers Squibb, Bayer, and Ipsen. No other
disclosures were reported. 8. Abramson DH, Francis JH, Dunkel IJ, Marr BP, high-risk pathology features in unilateral
Brodie SE, Gobin YP. Ophthalmic artery retinoblastoma. J Pediatr Hematol Oncol. 2009;31
Funding/Support: This work was supported in part chemosurgery for retinoblastoma prevents new (5):325-329.
by The Fund for Ophthalmic Knowledge, Inc. intraocular tumors. Ophthalmology. 2013;120(3): 19. Shields CL, Shields JA. Intra-arterial
Role of the Funder/Sponsor: The funder had no 560-565. chemotherapy for retinoblastoma: the beginning of
role in the design and conduct of the study; 9. Hungerford J, Kingston J, Plowman N. Orbital a long journey. Clin Experiment Ophthalmol. 2010;
collection, management, analysis, and recurrence of retinoblastoma. Ophthalmic Paediatr 38(6):638-643.
interpretation of the data; preparation, review, or Genet. 1987;8(1):63-68.
approval of the manuscript; and decision to submit 20. Jabbour P, Chalouhi N, Tjoumakaris S, et al.
the manuscript for publication. 10. Khelfaoui F, Validire P, Auperin A, et al. Pearls and pitfalls of intraarterial chemotherapy for
Histopathologic risk factors in retinoblastoma: retinoblastoma. J Neurosurg Pediatr. 2012;10(3):
REFERENCES a retrospective study of 172 patients treated in a 175-181.
single institution. Cancer. 1996;77(6):1206-1213. 21. Ellsworth RM. Orbital retinoblastoma. Trans Am
1. Grigorovski N, Lucena E, Mattosinho C, et al. Use
of intra-arterial chemotherapy for retinoblastoma: 11. Kim JW, Kathpalia V, Dunkel IJ, Wong RK, Riedel Ophthalmol Soc. 1974;72:79-88.
results of a survey. Int J Ophthalmol. 2014;7(4):726- E, Abramson DH. Orbital recurrence of
730. retinoblastoma following enucleation. Br J
Ophthalmol. 2009;93(4):463-467.
1066 JAMA Ophthalmology September 2015 Volume 133, Number 9 (Reprinted) jamaophthalmology.com