Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
57 2004.
3
Original paper
Hassan-Zaki P., Shinohara, T., Nakama, Y. and Yukutake, K. :A Selective Management System(SMS) : A case study in the
implementation of SMS in managing the dipterocarp forests of Peninsular Malaysia Kyushu J. For. Res. 57:39−44,2004 The
Selective Management System(SMS)is a bicyclic tropical shelterwood system practiced as the main forest management system in
managing the dipterocarp forests of Peninsular Malaysia. SMS was adopted for management in 1978 to replace the monocyclic Malayan
Uniform System(MUS). The SMS is a flexible system which allows the determination of the most appropriate cutting regime based
on analysis of Pre and Post Felling forestry inventory data, considering the need for leaving behind sufficient stocking of intermediate
sized trees, optimal growth and mortality rates and, maintaining the species composition of the residual forest stand at a minimal
damage. This paper attempt to evaluate the various technical requirements applied for the successful implementation of SMS in
managing the hill dipterocarp forest of Peninsular Malaysia.
Key words : silviculture, dipterocarpus, residual stand, enrichment planting, Peninsular Malaysia
*1
ハサンザキ パクリアザド・篠原武夫・仲間勇栄・行武 潔:半島マレーシアのフタバガキ科経営における択伐法(SMS)の展開
と実施に関する研究
*2
United Grad. Sch. Agric. Sci., Kagoshima Univ., Kagoshima 890-0065 鹿児島大学大学院連合農学研究科
*3
Fac. Agric., Univ. Ryukyus, Okinawa 903-0213 琉球大学農学部
*4
Fac. Agric., Miyazaki Univ., Miyazaki 889-2192 宮崎大学農学部
39
Kyushu J. For. Res. No. 57 2004. 3
40
九州森林研究 No.
57 2004.
3
intermediate sized trees and poles(30-45 cm dbh)grow faster to dipterocarp species should be at least 5 cm ;()the residual
harvestable size compared from the seedling to grow to timber stocking should have at least 32 sound commercial trees per
size); )the sufficient number of young trees of many size hectare in the dbh class from 30 to 45 cm dbh(substitutions
classes can be saved under careful directional felling and using trees with dbh larger than 45 cm were given equivalent
vigorously survive ; and )SMS can be adapted to different value of 2 stems/ha, while trees in the dbh class from 15 to 30 cm
silvicultural conditions because of the floating (variable) were given equivalent value of 1/3 stems/ha ; and ()the
diameter limits for specific area and species groups. The percentage of diperocarp species in the residual stand for trees
objective of the SMS is to save young potential tree species from having dbh greater than 30 cm and above should not be less that
damage especially during harvesting of the merchantable in the stand prior to harvest. SMS employs a split cut approach,
timber from the virgin forest, through tree marking and which favors the retention and growth of the dipterocarp
directional felling. This is to retain an adequate stand and species to avoid the eventual elimination from future crops as
volume of healthy trees of desired species after harvesting to they have a tendency to dominate higher diameter classes and
assure a future timber crop, after harvesting to assure a future grow faster than other economic species. The SMS is a viable
timber crop, forest cover for the protection of soil and water. position for the management of the PM hill dipterocarp forest
SMS also has the flexibility to manage the highly variable forest which offer a reduced cutting cycle and total silvicultural cost
conditions (socio-economic environment), allows for the provided by the following technical requirements ; )mortality
optimization of forest management goals for an economic cut, and optimal growth rates )minimal logging damage to the
the sustainability of the forest and the minimum cost of forest residual stand;and )gross volume and net economic cut;and
management. )adequacy of the residual stocking(Tang, 1980 ; Shahruddin,
3.SMS technical requirement 1983 ; Thang, 1988). The SMS sequence of operations is shown
a)SMS principles in determining the cutting regimes in Table-1.
Based on the current application of SMS, it has been
envisaged that bicyclic cutting of 30 years cycle is practiced. Table-1.SMS sequence of operations
The SMS selectively logged forest has an intention to return at Year Operation
n-2 to n-1 Pre-felling forest inventory of 10% sampling
the end of the cutting cycle(30 years)until the next harvest
intensity using systematic-line-plots to determine
(60 years)
(Fig-2). SMS harvesting regimes are based on appropriate cutting regimes(limits) .
inventory data instead of arbitrary prescription, which consider n-1 to n Tree marking incorporating direction felling. No
marking of residual trees for retention.
equitable to both stakeholders(loggers and forest owners). Pre-
n Felling of all trees as prescribed.
Felling inventory is carried out to provide reliable estimates of n+1/4 to Forest survey to determine fines on trees unfelled
the population and parameters that are being measured are ; ) n+1/2 and damage to residual and royalty on shot and
tops.
all trees with 5 cm dbh and above and tree species having a dbh
n+2 to n+5 Post-felling inventory of 10% sampling intensity
less than 5 cm but having a minimum height of 15 cm and above using systematic-line plots to determine residual
stocking and appropriate silvicultural treatments.
by dbh class, species and volume/stems per hectare;and )
the
n+10 Forest inventory of regenerated forest to
physiography by slope, elevation, soil types and river systems. determine status of the forest.
After the pre-felling inventory data such as market value and
socio-economic considerations, a felling regime will be )Mortality and optimal growth rates
formulated to optimize the stated goals. All commercial timber Mortality is an important component of any stand growth
based on SMS specified diameter is identified for felling. (Wan-Razali, 1989). There are two types of mortality namely
Following the first cut, number of residual was left behind and catastrophic and non-catastrophic. Catastrophic mortality is
the interval required for them to reach merchantable sizes for a either abnormally high or low for short periods due to factors,
second cut. which are difficult to predict(e. g. disease, fire, wind throw,
b)SMS sequence of operation logging damage).Non-catastrophic mortality is death as a result
When the next harvesting is expected in 25-30 years after the of natural causes such as suppression and over topping of small
first logging with an expected net economic outturn of 40-50 m3 trees in a stand. Mortality and optimal growth rates are
per hectare enriched with dipterocarp species, the prescriptions dependent on a number species, site factor, age and size, crown
for implementation applied are ; )the cutting limit prescribed development, genetic properties and competition status.
for dipterocarp species should not be less than 50 cm dbh except Mortality rates also depend on logging intensities, tree diameter
for Neobalanocarpus heimii(chengal)not less than 60 cm dbh; class and spaces factors. Variation in original stocking, soils,
()
the cutting limit prescribed for non-dipterocarp species terrain, location and maeket situation at the time of logging will
should not less than 45 cm dbh ()
; the difference in the cutting greatly influence the stock and growth levels of the individual
limits prescribed between the dipterocarp and that of non- plots. Mortality rates decrease with time. Yong (1996)
41
Kyushu J. For. Res. No. 57 2004. 3
indicates that mortality of tree 5 cm dbh and larger decreased )Gross volume and net economic cut
from 3.75% in the fifth year to 2.5% during 14 years after a)SMS gross volume of the timber is calculated with the
harvesting. When mortality rate is higher than expected, it will following equation :
have a great effect on the projection of timber volume for the
2
π×(DBH) ×L×f
next cutting. The higher mortality rate would lead to V =
4×1
0,0 00
considerably lower yield when the harvesting cycle was
maintained at 25-30 years(Tang and Wan-Razali, 1981 ; Tang, where:
1978 ; Kirkee, 1973 ; Ashari and Kamis, 1988). V = gross volume in m3
)Logging damage to residual stand π=3.
1417;
Timber harvesting in the hill forests would cause higher DBH = diameter at breast height(in cm);
damage to the intermediate trees compared to the lowland f =0.
65[from factor]
;and
forests. Felling damage to the remaining intermediate sized L = merchantable height
trees of 30 cm dbh and above are 30% , while wastage due to Since the merchantable height cannot be measured during the
breakage and bucking is 6.5% to 8.0% of the gross timber inventory stock, the length of the timber will be calculated
volume(Griffin and Caprata, 1977). Logging damage percent according to the following diameter class(Table-4).
increases with decreasing diameter classes(Anon, 1985). The
smaller trees have a general higher tendency to be dameged in
Table-4.Calculation of diameter class, length and equivalent
logging operations(a tree is damaged when it sustains
merchantable heights
moderate/severe stem and/or crown damage)
(Table-2). Diameter Class Logs 5cm
(length) Equivalent merch.heights
+30−60cm 2 10m
+60−7
5cm 3 15m
Table-2.The relationship between diameter class
and logging damage during harvesting + 75cm 4 20m
42
九州森林研究 No.
57 2004.
3
the average stocking capacity of the PM natural forests. In In Post-F silvicultural treatments, weed girdling and
determining the adequacy of residual stocking for the next climber/tending cuttings entail again. Following logging, the
cutting cycle, the number of residual stems in the higher dbh commercial seedings have to compete with some of the fast
classes should have an equivalent value to the proportion of growing pioneer weed species, particularly when the gap
stems required by the standards of the next lower dbh class openings are rather extensive. Eugeissona triste Griff(bertam)
(Table-5). in the Shorea curtisii ridge forest grew abundantly and retarded
the growth of young re-generation.
Table-5.Minimum residual stocking standards
Enrichment Planting (EP)scheme was developed to
Tree(s)equivalent to
No.of trees restructure the forest content in term of marketable and high
Class Size no. of trees in the
per hectare
30-45 cm dbh class quality species composition when stocking of regeneration
Exploitable +45 cm dbh 25 2
following establishment of new crop is inadequate, log yards,
lngrowth 30−45 cm dbh 32 1
kongsi sites, mataus, clear felled and abandoned cultivation
Small trees 15−30 cm dbh 96 (trees below 30 cm dbh
are not considered for areas took place which despite inadequacy of seedling
the next cut)
regeneration of economic species. EP is essential to improve
residual stocking of a poorly stocked logged-over forest for the
After logging the minimum residual stocking(medium-sized next cut or rotation. The composition, constitution and structure
trees)should not be less than 32 sound marketable trees of good of logged-over forest do not support a polycyclic system as a
from dbh class 30 to 45 cm or its equivalence. This is achieved result of the current logging practice. The implementation of
through tree marking incrporating directional for those trees to EP would help to introduce specific good quality timber and
be felled resulted minimize damage to the residual stand and inevitably allowed large proportion of dipterocarp species being
enable full utilization of the timber resource. For example, when introduced into the logged-over forest. The stocking of
a stand after logging has 8 trees of +45 cm dbh and 17 trees of dipterocarps is not sufficient to sustain continuity of dipterocarp
dbh class 30 to 45 cm, in total 25 trees of +30 cm dbh would management. The regeneration dynamics of the logged-over
safisfy the rules for class +45 cm, neither for 30 to 45 cm, not forest is often not as expected and EP would be able to increase
even the total +30 cm. However, the 8 remaining trees of +45 cm the number of specific regeneration artificially into the areas.
dbh are equivalent to 16 trees of 30 to 45 cm dbh class and the The genetic quality of logged-over forests has also deteriorated
total equivalence becomes 16+17=33 trees which satisfies the as a result of the removal of the emergent trees. EP increase the
minimum number required for 30 to 45 cm dbh class. The age of number of selected good genetically timber tree species into the
the whole stand has to be accordingly lowered and used in the forest areas. Several potential commercial indigenous timber
calculations to estimate the expected yield and time of next tree species suitable for EP by line planting technique are
harvest. In order to enhance the next cut with a greater Shorea parvifolia, Hopea odorata, Dyera costulata, Dipterocarpus
proportion of dipterocarp species than the non-dipterocarp aromatica, Pentaspadon spp., Schima wallichi, Heriteria spp. and
species, the cutting limit prescribed for the dipterocarp species Agathis borneensis.
should be higher than that for the non-dipterocarp species for
any cutting block or compartment.
Ⅳ.
Conclusions
4.Natural regeneration, silvicultural tending and enrichment
planting The SMS is specifically designed to optimize the management
The nub of all sustained yields natural forests management objectives of economic and efficient harvesting, sustainability of
practices remain in the regeneration process and future cuts the forest and minimum forest development cost under
ultimately depend on fruiting and seedling establishment. Under prevailing conditions. The SMS is a flexible system as it allows
SMS, the process of natural regeneration assumed to take place. the determination of the most appropriate cutting regime based
Whatever is ready on the forest floor in a virgin stand would on the analysis of Pre-Felling forest inventory data, taking into
automatically provide regeneration. Large commercial trees of consideration the need for leaving behind sufficient stocking of
about 50 cm and above are removed. Therefore, future intermediate-sized trees, an economic cut, and in maintaining
regeneration would depend on the small residuals. When it was the species composition of the residual forest stand.
planned to keep the species composition of the forest unchanged, Under the SMS, the application of Reduced Impact Logging
the uncommon or rare species in a forest have to be protected. (RIL)harvesting procedure is mandatory since the
To be more effective, large clumps mature individuals stand international market forces requiring forest management and
were left behind as sufficient mother trees per unit area of timber certification to ensure Malaysia tropical timber can be
dipterocarp. exported. SMS implementation and objectives was implemented
Pre-F silvicultural tending aimed to reduce the felling damage. according to the International Tropical Timber Organization
43
Kyushu J. For. Res. No. 57 2004. 3
(ITTO)indicators and criteria for the measurement of harvesting in humid tropical forests.(In Lugo, C. and Child,
sustainable tropical forest management. Under the rotation of J.R. Ecological development in the humid tropics. Winrock
this selective harvesting system, PM forests have ability to Intern. Inst Agric. Devel., Morrilton, Arkansas, USA), 191-
return to their former eco-balance, thereby allowing for better 235.
biological functioning of the forests. Kamaruzaman, J. (1991) A survey of soil disturbance from
With regard to the socio-economic development, other tractor logging in a hill forest of Peninsular Malaysia.(In
important factor of the SMS is the diversification of the flora and Appanah S, Ng FSP, Roslan I(Eds.)Malaysian Forestry
timber species. Unlike the formal MUS, the SMS could enhace and Forest Products : Proceedings of the Conference. FRIM,
the development of domestic wood-based industry by utilizing a Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia),16-21.
wider spectrum of timber species. Moreover, the increasing Kirkee, T. B.(1973) Growth and development of a Malaysian
technological innovations and sophistication in wood processing dipterocarp forest after harvest, 142 pp, M. Sc. thesis, Univ.
coupled with the changing patterns of wood use in the forestry Pertanian Malaysia.
sector render a lot of the presently non-commercial timber Nicholson, D. T.(1979) The effects of logging and treatment on
species marketable in both domestic and export markets. It can the mixed dipterocarp forests of Southeast Asia, 65 pp,
be concluded that the conservational forest management Report FO : MISC/79/8 FAO, Rome, Italy.
approach adopted under SMS would achieve following beneficial Shaharuddin, M. I. (1983) The development and
effects ()conservation and sustainability of the forest implementation of a Selective Management System in
resource ; ()minimize reinvestment in forest rehabilitation Peninsular Malaysia, 141 pp, M. Sc. thesis. Australian
work ;()enhance environment stability and quality ;() National Univ., Australia.
minimize logging waste ; and()induce optimum utilization of Tang, H. T.(1978). J. Malayan Forester : 41(2): 176-183.
the forest resources. Tang, H. T.(1980). J. For. Economic Management, 21 : 3-20.
Tang, H. T. and Wan-Razali, M.(1981) Report on growth and
yield studies in inland mixed indigenous forest in Peninsular
Ⅴ.References
Malaysia, 73 pp, Forestry Department, Malaysia.
Anon (1985) Penentuan had tebangan melalui Tang, H. C.(1988) Selective Management System concept and
maklumat-maklumat inventori sebelum tebangan, 45 pp, pratice in Peninslar Malaysia.(Second Edition), 19 pp, For.
Forest Depart. Headq. Peninsular Malaysia. Depart. Headq., Malaysia.
Appanah, S. and Putz, F. E.(1984), J. Malayan Forester 47 : 335- UNDP/FAO (1978) Forest Development in Peninsular
342. Malaysia. Project Results, Conclusions and
Ashari, M. and Kamis, A.(1988) Paper presented at Regional Recommendation, 119 pp, FO : DP/MAL/75/012. Terminal
Training Seminar on Recovery of Vegetation in Tropical Report.
Traded Coastal Areas. 13-17 March 1988, South China Vandana, S. (1992) What is sustainable forestry? World
Institute of Botans, Academia Sinica, Guanzhou, China. Rainforest Movement, 946 pp, Penang, Malaysia.
Awang, N.(1997) Economic viability of SMS.(In Proceedings Wan-Razali, W. M. (1989) Modeling tree mortality in mixed
of the workshop on SMS and Enrichment Planting, Perak, tropical forests of Peninsular Malaysia.(In Proceeding of
Malaysia),53-86. the Seminar on Growth and Yield in Tropical Mixed/Moist
Bruijneel, L. A. and Critchley, W.R. S.(1994) Environmental Forests, 1988. FRIM, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia),96-105.
impacts of logging moist tropical forests, 224 pp, IHP Humid Wyatt-Smith, J. (1963) Manual of Malayan silviculture for
Tropic Progr. Series No. 7 UNESCO, Paris. inland forest, Malayan Forest Record 23(1), Forest Dept.,
Griffin, M. and Caprata, M. (1977) Determination of cutting Malaya.
regimes under the Selective Management System(SMS), 26 Yong, T. K.(1996) Growth and development of a selectively cut
pp, ASEAN Seminar on Tropical Rainforest Management, hill dipterocarp forest in Peninsular Malaysia. 184 pp, M. F.
Pahang, Malaysia. thesis, Univ. British Columbia, Canada.
Hamilton, L. S. (1988) Minimizing the adverse impacts of (Received : 4 Nov. 2003, accepted : 9 Jan. 2004)
44