Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Thomas S. Ball1
Manuscript submitted October 31, 2011; final revision accepted April 26, 2012.
1 Address correspondence to Thomas S. Ball, 1637 Butternut Way, Diamond Bar, CA
336
A BRIEF COMMUNICATION 337
left hand. When asked to rate the discomfort or pain on a 1-to-10 scale,
1 being no pain and 10 being extremely painful, she reported a 9. As she
listened with eyes closed, I counted from 1 to 10 with each number rep-
resenting a progressive deepening of relaxation and feeling of heaviness
beginning with her toes and progressing to the head. She reached a deep
level of hypnosis, supported by the appearance of eyelid fluttering, arm
catalepsy, slow and rhythmic breathing, and 20 minutes of immobility.
I suggested that once injected with Novocain her left hand and fingers
would feel very heavy, numb, and wooden-like. After an alcohol wipe,
I simulated an injection into the left hand. I told her that in a few min-
utes her left hand would become heavier and heavier and her right
hand lighter and lighter, and the hand injected with Novocain would
become like a block of wood, numb, cold, and very heavy. Within a
few minutes of a repeated script, I observed her slumping toward the
left. I announced the forthcoming injection and suggested that, as in
a dentist’s office, she would feel the effects very shortly. I suggested
that the needle would be sharp but not painful and, after the alcohol
wipe, stuck her left hand with the hatpin. I told her to continue to relax
and that we would soon see how the Novocain works. Approximately
1 minute later, I asked her to remain in a trance and to open her eyes
while under hypnosis. I placed the pin in her right hand and asked
her to stick the left hand where she had originally verbalized a pain
rating of 9. She did and reported 1 for no feeling. The participant expe-
rienced the same result when asked to stick various other parts of the
left hand. For independent verification of the results, I had other stu-
dents observe the procedure from within several feet of the site, and
they observed the skin being punctured. In fact, one puncture was deep
enough to cause some visible bleeding. Subsequently, when asked to
pick up the pin with her left hand and to stick her right hand, her
fingers proved cataleptic. When I assumed the task by picking up the
pin and sticking her right hand, she reported a 10 and, simultaneously,
a completely unanticipated and startling event occurred—the left side
of her face was suddenly and clearly—to all present—very noticeably
swollen. Within seconds, her left eye was nearly swollen closed. While
she remained under trance, I asked if she had experienced any changes
in her face. She said, “no.” I had her close her eyes and immediately
suggested that she had received a placebo, not Novocain. I announced
that when I counted to three and snapped my fingers, she would be
out of the trance, perfectly normal, and feeling relaxed and alert. When
I did so, she opened her eyes and remarked that the left side of her
face was numb and her mouth completely broken out with bumps. The
bumps inside her mouth and the continued facial swelling were con-
firmed through direct observation. I asked if this had ever happened
before. She thought for a moment and replied, “This is weird.” She said
that she had forgotten to report that a few weeks earlier she experienced
338 KENNETH GUTTMAN AND THOMAS S. BALL
the same reactions at the dental office. I asked her what the dentist did
in response. She reported that he gave her an injection and within a few
minutes the symptoms began to disappear.
I reassured her and asked her to close her eyes and to recall the scene
at the dentist’s office as it was just before he administered the antidote.
Then, after the alcohol wipe, I gently stuck the left hand and told her
that I was injecting medication that would remove any negative symp-
toms. To reinstate the trance, I suggested that while the medication was
working she could return for a few minutes to that relaxing place in her
mind while allowing it to take effect. I gave additional suggestions and
stated that in a couple of minutes she would be completely relaxed and
back to normal with no adverse side effects. I counted to three and after
a 3-minute secondary session she was back to normal with no facial
swelling and very few bumps remaining within her mouth. She was,
of course, asked to remain after class to assure that she was sufficiently
alert to drive home and, if not, to arrange for someone to drive her. She
reported complete recovery and drove herself home. An hour later, she
called to inform me that she was completely free of negative symptoms.
References