Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
com
Level III of CFA Program
Mock Exam 3
June, 2019
Revision 1
The morning session of the 2019 Level III Examination has 12 questions. For grading
purposes, the maximum point value for each question is equal to the number of minutes
allocated to that question.
Total: 180
Kyle Lucas is the owner of a small privately traded manufacturing concern which is
currently worth $12 million and was established twenty-five years ago. Lucas is 65 years
of age and intends to sell the business two years from today.
Lucas has approached portfolio manager Gus Weaver to manage his investment portfolio
which is currently worth $8.5 million and is equally allocated to long-term corporate
bonds, domestic and international equities, and alternative asset classes. In response to a
question regarding his investment experience, Lucas states, “I have faced significant
financial crises in the past and now always look to avoid making investment choices
which hold the potential for disastrous consequences.”
Lucas earns annual business income which is fixed at a pre-tax amount of $100,000. His
living expenses are $98,000 in the current year and are expected to increase at the annual
rate of inflation of 5%. Upon retirement, he will no longer earn business income and his
annual living expenses will become constant at $150,000.
If Lucas sells his business at its expected market price, two years from today, he will be
able to purchase his dream house for $8 million and a boat currently sold at a price of
$1.0 million and will donate the remaining amount to a local charity. He has instructed
Weaver to exclude the sale of his business from the investment decision. Lucas intends to
finance his grandson’s college education as well as purchase residential property for him.
Total estimated costs will amount to $30 million and will be required fifteen years from
today.
Lucas is subject to an ordinary income and capital gains tax rate of 25% and 30%
respectively. He always maintains an emergency reserve equal to 3 years of his annual
business income in addition to his portfolio holdings.
I. Time Horizon
II. Unique Circumstances
(4 minutes)
B. Determine whether an increase in inflation rate, reduction in the sales price of the
business, and an increase in the price of his dream house will increase, decrease or
have no impact on risk tolerance. Justify your choice with one reason.
(6 minutes)
(3 minutes)
D. Calculate Lucas’ annual after-tax nominal rate of return for the IPS if his
business is sold at its current market price two years from today. Show your
calculations.
(6 minutes)
(4 minutes)
Lucas is an avid follower of the stock market and makes investment decisions on behalf
of friends and family members. His most recent investment decision involved a $100,000
purchase of French Inc.’s stock. The decision was influenced by recent media attention
on the corporation following a ‘brave’ policy shift towards unconventional production
processes promising shorter lead times and a greater focus on organic raw materials as
input. He further justifies his decisions by stating, “Over the course of industry history,
companies who were experimental in setting their policy have been popular amongst
investors.”
F. Identify the bias demonstrated by Lucas and justify your selection with one
reason.
(3 minutes)
Impact on Risk
Tolerance (Circle Justify Your Choice With
Factor the Correct One Reason
Answer)
Increase
No impact
Increase
No impact
Increase
Identify the Bias (Circle the Justify Your Choice with One
Correct Choice) Reason
Regret Aversion
Overconfidence
Availability Bias
A Solution:
I. Time Horizon:
Stage 2: Retirement to the funding of his grandson’s college education and home
purchase – 15 years
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 2, Study Session 5, Reading 10, LOS h
B Solution:
Impact on Risk
Tolerance (Circle Justify your choice with one
Factor the Correct reason
Answer)
An increase in the inflation
rate will increase the shortfall
Increase between business income and
Increase in inflation living expenses which is
rate Decrease
Decrease expected to equal $27,900
s [($100,000 × 0.75)– ($98,000
No impact × 1.05)] in the following year
and increase annually
thereafter.
Given that Lucas’ living
Increase expenses after retirement are
not dependent on the sale of
Reduction in sales Decrease the business, therefore
price of business reduction in this source of
funds will not impact his
No impact ability to tolerate risk.
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 2, Study Session 5, Reading 10, LOS g
C Solution:
Lucas needs to generate sufficient income to fund his living expenses on an inflation-
adjusted basis, provide for his retirement spending needs and grow his portfolio to
finance his grandson’s college education and the purchase of residential property.
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 2, Study Session 5, Reading 10, LOS g
D Solution:
Outflows
Living expenses* $98,000 $102,900 $108,045
Tax on salary ($100,000
× 0.25) $25,000 $25,000 $25,000
Net inflows/(outflows) ($23,000) ($27,900) ($33,045)
* expected to increase at the annual rate of inflation of 5%
Investable Asset Base at the beginning of Year 3:
Current
Cash flow – Year 2 ($33,045)
Portfolio assets $8,500,000
Cash reserve (3 × $100,000) $300,000
Total $8,766,955
PV = - 8,766,955
N = 12 years
FV = 30,000,000
PMT = - 150,000
I/Y = 9.771%
The after-tax nominal required rate of return is 9.771%
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 2, Study Session 5, Reading 10, LOS g
E Solution:
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 2, Study Session 4, Reading 9, LOS b
F Solution:
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 2, Study Session 4, Reading 8, LOS c
Carl Segal is an asset advisor at Vector Asset Management. Segal is working closely with
a private client, Timothy Allen; aged 45 to ascertain the behavioral investor type (BIT)
exhibited by Allen. Allen has considerable investment experience and often recommends
potential investments for further evaluation to his adviser. During a discussion between
Segal and Allen, the client shares his investment approach:
“I have devoted a significant amount of time to studying security markets and asset
classes. Based on the insight which I have gained over these years, I can comfortably
trust my instincts when making investment decisions for myself as well as acquaintances,
who have entrusted me with the management of their financial wealth. I trust nothing but
my own research and prefer not to let my judgment get influenced by the advice of those
who possess little knowledge about wealth planning.”
A. Classify Carl’s BIT, determine the risk tolerance, and identify one emotional bias
typically associated with the identified behavioral category.
(3 minutes)
B. Carl participates in the defined contribution (DC) offered by his employer. Segal
determines that Carl is fifteen years away from retirement. Segal would like to
compare the client’s current allocation to plan assets with the average allocation
held over the past five years. Segal also determines that:
Exhibit:
Carl’s Allocations to the DC Plan Assets
Average
Historical Current
Allocation Allocation
(2009-2013) (2014)
Stocks – Corporate stock 36% 34%
Stocks – Domestic Non-corporate stocks 6 7
Stocks – Global stocks 3 4
Fixed Income 45 48
Short-term income 10 9
Total 100% 100%
I. Using the data collected by Segal, explain one bias exhibited by Carl in his
portfolio selection decisions with respect to the DC plan. Support your response
with two reasons.
(4 minutes)
(3 minutes)
A Solution.
Determine risk tolerance
associated with the Identify one emotional bias
Classify Carl’s BIT behavioral category typically associated with
(Circle the Correct Choice) (Circle the correct choice) the behavioral category
Independent
Independent Individualist (II) High
Individualist (II)
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 2, Study Session 4, Reading 9, LOS b
B – (i) Solution:
Bias 1: Carl demonstrates inertia and default by maintaining the composition of his
current allocations at the average level observed over the previous five years. A
decomposition of his holdings reveals that the allocation to:
The receipt of inheritance should increase Carl’s risk tolerance which should be reflected
by an increase in the allocation to stocks as opposed to an allocation with a higher
proportion of less risky (fixed income and short-term income) securities. By keeping the
allocation constant despite the change in financial circumstances and risk tolerance, the
client demonstrates inertia.
Bias 2: Carl also demonstrates familiarity. His allocation to corporate stock outweighs
that to domestic non-corporate and global stocks (34% vs. 7% and 4%
respectively). Furthermore, his allocation to domestic stocks his higher relative to
global stocks (7% and 4% respectively) which lead to a confirmation of this bias.
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 2, Study Session 4, Reading 8, LOS c
B–(ii) Solution:
Following the receipt of the inheritance, Carl’s risk tolerance will increase, and an
autopilot strategy should increase his equity allocation which is currently lower than the
allocation to the less risky fixed income and short-term income combined (45% vs. 55%
respectively).
Furthermore, his long-term horizon (fifteen years) dictates a higher allocation to risky
securities such as equities. The autopilot strategy would also diversify the equity
allocation and reduce the high concentration in own company stock.
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 2, Study Session 4, Reading 9
Mr. and Mrs. Fairview, aged 65 and 60 respectively, are the owners of a hotel chain
which has branches located across the US and has been in establishment for the past
thirty years. Their business is currently worth $60 million and has appreciated by 10% in
the current year leading to an increase in the wealth of its owners. The hotel chain is a
privately traded concern.
The Fairviews are seeking to transfer the business to their daughter, Samantha, but would
like to retain ownership rights. They have approached Kim Young, a tax advisor, for a
solution. Under current tax laws a donor’s annual gift exclusions are limited to $13,000
per donee. Gifts exceeding this allowance are taxed at a rate of 25%. Young discovers
that the couple has consumed this allowance and now sets out to devise a wealth transfer
strategy which will minimize transfer taxes and retain ownership rights.
After considerable evaluation, Young has identified three potential wealth transfer
strategies. She would now like to determine the most appropriate strategy.
Recommend the most suitable wealth transfer strategy. For the choices not selected
provide one reason for their unsuitability.
(3 minutes)
Recommend the most Suitable Wealth Provide One Reason for Why the
Transfer Strategy Choices Not Selected are Unsuitable
Recommend the most Suitable Wealth Provide One Reason for Why the Choices
Transfer Strategy Not Selected are Unsuitable
Corporate estate tax freezes are suitable
wealth transfer strategies before the
concentrated position has appreciated
Corporate Estate Tax Freeze significantly. The position has increased by
10% in the current year and before the
Fairviews approach Young. Therefore, this
is not a suitable wealth transfer strategy.
Family Limited
Family Limited Partnership
Partnership
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 2, Study Session 6, Reading 13, LOS g
Yellow Tires (YT) offers a defined benefit pension plan to its employees. Sean Martin is
managing YT’s investment portfolio and has collected the following details which are
relevant for the analysis:
(2 minutes)
B. Identify one purpose which the sponsor may have in stating a return objective of
8.5%.
(2 minutes)
I. risk tolerance
II. liquidity
III. time horizon
(6 minutes)
D. For each of the following scenarios, determine whether risk tolerance will
increase or decrease. Explain your choice.
(8 minutes)
Impact on
Risk
Factor Tolerance Explain Your Choice
Introduction of an early
retirement provision
A Solution:
YT is required to achieve a minimum return equal to the discount rate used to determine
the present value of fund liabilities, 8.0%.
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 2, Study Session 7, Reading 15, LOS b
B Solution:
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 2, Study Session 7, Reading 15, LOS b
C Solution:
I. Risk tolerance:
YT’s risk tolerance can be described as being above average due to the following
reasons:
II. Liquidity:
YT’s liquidity requirements are low as evidenced by the low number of retired
lives and an absence of early retirement provisions.
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 2, Study Session 7, Reading 15, LOS b
D Solution:
Template for Question 4 D.
Impact on
Risk
Factor Tolerance Explain Your Choice
An early retirement provision will
Introduction of an early Decrease reduce the duration of plan liabilities,
retirement provision resulting in a lower risk tolerance.
A higher discount rate will reduce the
present value of plan liabilities and the
Increase in discount rate Increase funded status will most likely change
from fully funded to a surplus.
The sponsor stock is highly correlated
with its operating results. A lower
Decrease in the allocation of allocation will reduce the correlation
fund assets to YT stock Increase between the performance of plan assets
and that of the sponsor and increase risk
tolerance.
An increase in the degree of bankruptcy
risk may increase financial obligations
Increase in bankruptcy risk Decrease and may jeopardize YT’s going concern
status and/or weaken its financial status.
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 2, Study Session 7, Reading 15, LOS c
First Bank is a commercial lending institution operating in the U.S. Sasha Wilson is the
bank’s senior investment officer. Wilson would like to implement more stringent risk
management measures with respect to the bank’s liabilities and has convened a meeting
to address the following objectives:
Wilson is analyzing the implications of the recent unexpected rise in interest rates on the
bank’s market value of equity.
Exhibit:
First Bank’s Balance Sheet
Market value Market value
Duration ($ millions) Duration ($ millions)
Assets Liabilities
Loans 7.4 65
Fixed 4.5 31 Time 3.0 60
assets deposits
Cash 0.0 4 Demand 3.5 40
deposits
Total 6.2* 100 3.2* 100
A. Discuss one implication of a positive interest rate shock on the bank’s balance
sheet.
(2 minutes)
B. Determine what course of action should most likely be taken to achieve Objective
2.
(2 minutes)
I. time horizon
II. liquidity
III. unique circumstances
(6 minutes)
D. First Bank has implemented three policy changes with respect to its loan
portfolio. Wilson would like to determine how each policy change will impact the
objectives and constraints for the securities portfolio. The three policies are as
follows:
Explain the impact of each policy change on the bank’s objectives and constraints. Your
response should consider each policy in isolation.
(6 minutes)
A Solution.
A positive interest rate shock will reduce the market value of the company’s equity.
Although the market values of assets and liabilities will both decline in response to an
increase in interest rates, the decline in the value of assets will be greater due to a higher
weighted average duration.
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 2, Study Session 7, Reading 15, LOS m
B Solution.
Given that the weighted average duration of the assets exceeds that of liabilities, the most
suitable course of action would be reduce the duration of the securities portfolio by
purchasing shorter maturity securities.
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 2, Study Session 7, Reading 15, LOS m
C Solution.
I. Time horizon: A bank’s liability structure tends to have a shorter overall maturity
than its loan portfolio. The time horizon of the securities portfolio is therefore of
an intermediate term.
II. Liquidity: Requirements for liquidity are determined by net outflows of deposits
as well as demand for loans.
III. Unique circumstances: There are no unique circumstances.
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 2, Study Session 7, Reading 15, LOS k
D Solution:
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 2, Study Session 7, Reading 15, LOS m
Becky Sands established the “Sands & Steel Financial Firm (S&S)” with her classmate
and colleague, Linda Steels, around five years ago. S&S is a financial consultancy firm
that assists institutional clients in managing their investment portfolios. Often, the firm
works in coordination with an already established, internal financial team of the clients
they deal with. Over the course of its business, S&S has built a client base of more than
twenty regular and loyal institutional funds. A few days ago, the firm landed consultancy
of three additional funds totaling a net worth of approximately 300 million US dollars.
Sands appointed three of the firm’s most seasoned portfolio managers to meet with the
board of directors of each of the concerned institutions. After their initial meeting with
the clients, Sands met with the managers to inquire about strategic issues relating to the
respective investment strategies and constraints of each of the clients. The managers
presented Sands with the following key summarized information:
§ Insurance fund:
The portfolio is overfunded and offers life insurance policies to individual clients.
It incorporates a very low risk premium in the discount rate used to find the
present value of its liabilities. The discount rate is primarily determined by
regulatory authorities and then adjusted downward to reflect the conservative
nature of the fund’s policy. The board wishes to reduce the need of any additional
contribution over the next year and also, to significantly decrease the risk of not
being able to pay next year’s liabilities.
§ Pension Fund:
The present value of the pension fund’s liabilities equals $550 million whereas the
fund’s assets equal $475 million. The fund’s board of directors has instructed
S&S to maintain a surplus volatility of not more than 8% per year. The fund has
an established risk aversion score of 6.5. The focus has primarily been on the
systematic risk of the asset mix and how it relates to that of the portfolio of
liabilities. The board has directed S&S to achieve a return of 13% over the next
year, while ensuring that the risk objective is not violated.
§ A hospital endowment:
The endowment has sporadic spending needs due to an erratic influx of patients at
irregular intervals. The fund’s board of directors wants to ensure that enough
capital is available at the time liabilities are due. They want to minimize tail risk
and ensure that worst-case outcomes are properly incorporated when constructing
a strategic asset allocation. As such, their main goal is to minimize the probability
of not being able to make future contributions and to keep the 1% VAR at the
desired level.
A. For each of the above funds, determine the most appropriate way to account for
liabilities. Justify your response for each fund with three reasons each.
(6 minutes)
Sands selects the following strategic asset allocation for the insurance fund based on
mean variance optimization:
The research analysts at S&S provide Sands with the following information about the
different asset classes:
§ A rising trend in US stock prices has been observed for the past three years, which
is expected to continue. Since the overall market is also expected to rise, the US
stocks will have a correlation between 0.80-0.85 with the rest of the asset classes.
§ Trading stocks in the international market is exceedingly challenging due to a lack
of a properly functional financial market in many countries. However, the
presence of derivatives on international stocks makes it easy to synthetically
create the desired positions.
§ US fixed-income has historically shown little diversion from its base values over
the past 25 years.
§ Taxes on interest income are expected to be lower than taxes on dividend income.
§ The insurance fund has a conservative approach to investing and thus wants to
keep exposure to volatile asset classes to a minimum.
§ International equity, although illiquid, offers significant diversification benefits.
B. For the cost-benefit ranges given, state the asset class for which the range is most
inconsistent. Justify your response with four reasons.
(4 minutes)
SOLUTION:
Part A.
Insurance Fund:
Most suitable approach is the ‘hedging/return seeking approach’
Reasons:
1. It has a conservative (risk-averse) policy for which hedging is appropriate.
2. It is an overfunded plan that will allow the surplus to be invested in a return-
seeking portfolio (the basic two portfolio approach can easily be used).
3. The focus is on a single period, and also on the ability to reduce the risk of not
being able to meet liabilities. Hedging the liabilities will help ensure that.
Pension Fund:
Most suitable approach is the ‘surplus optimization using MVO’.
Reasons:
1. The plan is underfunded.
2. Focus is on a single period—return should be met over the next year—and also on
surplus volatility.
3. Emphasis is on systematic risk, which is what the correlation between assets and
liabilities is based on, the main focus of MVO.
Hospital Endowment:
Most suitable approach is the ‘Integrated Asset-Liability Approach’.
Reasons:
1. The multi-period model works best in incorporating the probability of not being
able to make future contributions.
2. Since spending needs are sporadic, it is best to manage assets along with liabilities
in an integrated approach so that best compromise decisions can be made.
3. Worst-case scenarios and tail risk can best be managed using an integrated
approach. It can incorporate multiple assumptions and constraints.
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 3, Study Session 9, Reading 19
Part B.
The cost-benefit range seems most inconsistent for domestic equity.
Justification:
1. A momentum of trend in US stock prices is expected to continue. This warrants a
wider rebalancing range (the range is only slightly higher than that for fixed
income).
2. The correlation of US stocks with the rest of the portfolio is significantly high,
again meriting a wider range.
3. Even though international stocks are illiquid, the presence of derivatives can make
synthetic rebalancing possible and reduces the need to widen the range (relative to
domestic stocks). This indicates that the difference in the range of domestic and
international stocks should not be as high. International stocks also have a lower
correlation with the rest of the portfolio (offer diversification) meriting a tighter
balance than that of domestic stocks.
4. Unlike domestic stocks, US fixed-income has shown mean reversion and has
lower taxes than those on dividend income. This indicates that the rebalancing
range of fixed-income should be reasonably lower than that of domestic stocks.
Yet, the difference is only of 1%.
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 3, Study Session 9, Reading 19
Jill Starc is a senior asset manager at RP Financial (RPF), a portfolio management firm.
Starc oversees the Global Equity Fund I (GEF I) which is being offered by the firm. The
fund holds global (Canadian, Mexican and British) and domestic U.S. equities. Foreign
currency exposures are currently unhedged. The exhibit below illustrates the values of the
fund assets, spot exchange rates, and correlations between movements in foreign
currency-asset returns and foreign currency returns.
Exhibit
GEF I Fund Asset Values,
Spot Rates, and Correlations
Last Year Current
(2013) Year
(2014)
CAD-denominated asset value 100 150
in CAD millions
MXN-denominated asset 80 70
value in MXN millions
GBP-denominated asset value 230 300
in GBP millions
USD-denominated asset value 500 450
in USD millions
CAD/USD spot rate 0.7900 0.8100
USD/MXN spot rate 15.2420 15.0050
GBP/USD spot rate 1.4754 1.5000
p(RCAD,RCAD/USD) + 0.7
p(RMXN,RMXN/USD) - 0.3
p(RGBP,RGBP/USD) + 0.2
Gracy Singh is one of Starc’s clients. Singh’s investment portfolio comprises solely of
the securities held in the GEF I fund. Her allocation to CAD-, MXN-, GBP- and USD-
denominated equities is 30%, 40%, 25% and 5% respectively.
(4 minutes)
Based on a discussion with Singh, Starc determines that hedging the client’s foreign
currency risk exposures is essential. However, she is yet to establish the degree to which
currency risk exposures should be hedged.
B. Describe two potential considerations which Starc will need to account for when
determining the degree of currency risk exposures to undertake. Your answer
should focus on Singh’s current portfolio allocation and the information in the
exhibit.
(6 minutes)
To aid her currency hedging decision, Starc collects necessary details with respect to
Singh. She will examine each factor independently to determine whether a full currency
hedge will be required.
Information on Singh:
C. For each of the four points collected, determine whether the strategic currency
position of the portfolio should be biased towards a fully hedged currency
management program. Consider each factor independently and support each
answer with one reason.
(8 minutes)
Strategic Currency
Position Biased
Towards a Fully
Hedged Currency Support Each Answer
Point Collected Management with One Reason
Program?
Circle the Correct
Answer.
Yes
Risk averse to portfolio
losses No
Yes
Has a relatively long time-
horizon No
Yes
Desire for foreign fixed-
income security exposure No
A Solution.
or 10.42%
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 4, Study Session 10, Reading 21, LOS a
B Solution.
Marks will be awarded for any two of the three points discussed.
1. Diversification Considerations:
Starc will need to consider the asset composition of the foreign-currency asset portfolio.
Maintaining a 100% hedge results in no currency risk exposure but is costly to maintain
especially if a large number of rebalancing trades are required increasing the frequency of
payments based on the bid-ask spread.
To be 100% hedged requires forgoing the possibility and favorable foreign currency rate
moves. A less than 100% hedge ratio may be desirable to minimize regret.
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 4, Study Session 10, Reading 21, LOS b
C Solution.
Template for Question 7-C
Strategic Currency
Position Biased Towards a
Fully Hedged Currency
Management Program? Support Each Answer with One
Point Collected Circle the Correct Reason
Answer.
Risk aversion will reduce the
Yes
Yes propensity to assume active currency
Risk averse to risk exposure.
portfolio losses No
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 4, Study Session 10, Reading 21, LOS c
Weaver is making inflation forecasts for Lidon, a country with an emerging market. His
analysis focuses on two historical periods, 1990-1995 and 1996-2001. The first time
period was marked with above average inflation, GDP growth exceeding its target, and
an economy in danger of becoming overheated. The cause of the high inflation was a
global rise in energy prices triggering cost-push inflation in the country. Circumstances
changed in the 1996-2001 period when monetary authorities implemented restrictive
policy measures to cool down the economy.
Based on economic analysis, Weaver projects that Lidon’s economy is once again
expected to overheat due to the rapid supply of money currently being injected by
monetary authorities. To calculate the anticipated increase in inflation, Weaver uses the
average inflation prevailing over the two time periods, assigning a higher probability to
the inflation observed during 1990-1995, as input to his analytical model.
(2 minutes)
B.
i. Identify the psychological trap which Weaver has fallen into. Justify you choice.
Answer B-i in the template provided below.
ii. For the identified bias, discuss two possible measures which can be taken to avoid
this bias.
(5 minutes)
Recommend which asset class will be a suitable investment choice given Weaver’s
expectations. For the asset classes not selected, explain why they are inappropriate.
(7 minutes)
D. The authorities in Lidon have announced their intention to peg the local currency,
LDN, to the U.S. dollar (USD). The market is weary of the strategy’s
effectiveness and expects the LDN to be devalued shortly before Lidon
implements the policy. The current interest rate differential between Lidon and
U.S. sovereign bonds is 4.5%.
(2 minutes)
ii. Determine whether the change in interest rate differential will be positive,
negative or neutral based on the information provided on the market’s
views concerning the exchange rate peg. Justify you answer.
(3 minutes)
Overconfidence
Confirming evidence
Status Quo
Select the most suitable asset class given Explain why the choices not selected
Weaver’s expectations are inappropriate
Stocks
Cash
A Solution.
Weaver has introduced time period bias while developing inflation forecasts. His forecast
is heavily influenced by the inflation observed in the 1990-2005 time period. His analysis
is not appropriate given that the underlying cause of inflation is not cost push. His
forecast for inflation would have differed if he had given both time periods the same or
relatively similar emphasis.
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 3, Study Session 10, Reading 21, LOS b
B-(i) Solution:
Overconfidence
Status Quo
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 3, Study Session 10, Reading 21, LOS b
B-ii Solution:
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 3, Study Session 10, Reading 21, LOS b
C Solution:
Select the most suitable asset class given Explain why the choices not selected are
Weaver’s expectations inappropriate
There are signs of inflation moving out of
equilibrium as demonstrated by the
Equities expectation that the central bank will act to
slow down the economy. Equity securities
will not be an appropriate investment
choice in this scenario.
Cash
Cash
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 3, Study Session 10, Reading 21, LOS g
D-(i) Solution.
Domestic businesses have some reassurance that exchange rates will not fluctuate wildly.
By pegging its exchange rate, a pegged country often hopes to control inflation.
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 3, Study Session 7, Reading 18, LOS l
D-(ii) Solution
The interest rate differential will widen with the LDN rate being higher relative to the US
rate as:
• investors will demand a substantial interest rate differential because they see
the peg policy as being unsustainable.
• the LDN is expected to be devalued before Lidon pegs its currency.
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 3, Study Session 10, Reading 21, LOS l
Melissa Reed manages the equity allocation of institutional client portfolios at Wood-
Carter. The Smithson Foundation (SF) is Reed’s most recent client. During a meeting
with the foundation’s chief executive, Reed deems that the portfolio’s equity allocation
should be indexed to the Russell 3000 index.
In her conversation with the chief executive concerning the portfolio management
strategy, the latter states, “The chosen passive management strategy should minimize
portfolio rebalancing costs and be cost effective in terms of portfolio construction costs.”
(Note: The provided justifications for the three strategies should be distinct.)
(7 minutes)
Reed is of the opinion that the investment universe of SF’s portfolio should be expanded
to include global equities. However, she does not wish to undertake the purchase of
individual stocks and so engages in an equity index swap whereby the SF policy portfolio
will receive the return on the MSCI global equity index in exchange for interest payments
on U.S. Treasury bonds.
B. Discuss two usual motivations for Reed’s global equity swap strategy.
(4 minutes)
Reed also manages the equity portion of Glenn Endowment’s (GE) policy portfolio. The
fund’s prospectus identifies the investment mandate as “active large-cap exposure with a
growth bias.”
Reed’s manager, Carl Edgar, evaluates his subordinate’s performance using a returns-
based style analysis and employs four benchmarks – Russell 1000 Value Index, Russell
1000 Growth Index, Russell 2000 Growth Index, and Russell 2000 Value Index. The
results of the performance evaluation are summarized below.
Exhibit:
Results of Edgar’s Returns-Based Style Analysis
Factor Weights
Russell 1000 Value 0.45
Russell 1000 Growth 0.25
Russell 2000 Value 0.20
Russell 2000 Growth 0.10
(2 minutes)
D. State and justify whether GE’s portfolio is invested in accordance with the stated
mandate.
(4 minutes)
Full Replication
Stratified Sampling
Optimization
A Solution.
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 4, Study Session 12, Reading 27, LOS d
B Solution.
Typical motivations for using equity index swaps are given below:
Efficient asset allocation: Equity swaps can be used to efficiently effect a change in asset
allocation. A manager can use swaps to rebalance portfolios to the strategic asset
allocation and incur rebalancing costs which are lower than having to trade the
underlying securities.
Tax savings: One prime motivation for using equity swaps is to avoid high taxes on the
full return amount from an equity investment under circumstances where tax laws are
favorable. Equity swap applications are motivated by differences in the tax treatment of
shareholders domiciled in different countries.
Other motivations may include gaining synthetic exposure to index returns, adding
leverage or hedging a portfolio etc.
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 4, Study Session 12, Reading 27, LOS c
C Solution.
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 4, Study Session 13, Reading 28, LOS i
D Solution:
The fraction of the portfolio explained by the manager’s security selection ability is
9.58% indicating that the portfolio is indeed being managed actively. A closer look at the
benchmark weights reveals that Reed has drifted from her stated investment style.
His factor weight of .70 (0.45 + 0.25) on large-cap stocks exceeds his weight of 0.30
(0.20 + 0.10) on small-cap stocks. However, his allocation to small-cap stocks is not
insignificant. In addition, his factor weight of 0.45 on large-cap value stocks exceeds his
factor weight of 0.25 on large-cap growth stocks. GE’s portfolio appears to be an actively
managed large- and small-cap market-oriented portfolio with a value bias.
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 4, Study Session 12, Reading 28, LOS d
Smithson has placed an order to purchase 100,000 shares of Reliable Corp, a software
manufacturer. The average day’s volume of the manufacturer’s stock is 400,000. The
firm’s purchase decision is based on earnings growth projections generated by the firm’s
in-house forecasting model. The chief executive has instructed to Storm, “We would not
like to reveal the full extent of our purchase order to the market.”
The chief executive emphasizes on giving brokers free reign to make purchase decisions
for the fund’s policy portfolio whenever the market presents a favorable opportunity. All
trades must be executed within three trading days of placing the order.
Determine which order is most suitable for the two clients. Explain your choice.
(6 minutes)
Reserve order
Participate order
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 6, Study Session 18, Reading 35, LOS d
Bjore Traders is a shipping company listed on the NYSE. The company has divisions
operating in several states across the U.S. Each divisional manager is responsible for
overseeing the risk management of its exposures.
A. Identify one benefit and one drawback of BT’s risk management system
structure.
(2 minutes)
Jacqueline Andrew is the head of risk management at BT’s Idaho division. Andrew is
preparing a report on the division’s risk exposures in order to determine how to manage
them effectively. She begins her report by discussing the division’s strategy for risk
management:
Statement: “We manage risk strategically by avoiding risk taking in areas in which we do
not have expertise and hedging only tactically in areas in which we have an edge.”
(3 minutes)
Answer Question 11-B in the template provided at the end of Question 11.
The Idaho Division is BT’s only division delivering orders to customers outside the U.S.
A portion of its sales are on credit. Shipping fuel is procured by paying for 12 months’
fuel in advance using over-the-counter (OTC) prepaid commodity swaps. The firm has
hedged its foreign currency exposures using currency futures.
In the current year, the management is seeking to expand the division’s delivery
destinations and will be purchasing three freight ships from a U.S. supplier. Funds from
the purchase will come from issuing a combination of equities and corporate bonds.
C. Identify five risk exposures faced by the Idaho division. Your answer should
explain each risk exposure by identifying one source.
Answer Question 11-C in the Template provided at the end of Question 311.
(10 minutes)
Identify Five Risk Exposures Faced by Explain Each Risk Exposure with
the Idaho Division One Identified Source
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
A Solution.
Disadvantage (Marks will be awarded for any one of the following disadvantages
identified):
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 5, Study Session 16, Reading 31, LOS d
B Solution:
Does Andrew’s Statement
Reflect Efficient Risk
Andrew’s Statement: Management Practices? Justify Your Answer:
(Circle the Correct Option)
Although the tactical
hedging of areas in which
the entity has comparative
“We manage risk advantage is an efficient
strategically by avoiding strategy, the division should
risk taking in areas in which Yes hedge risks in areas in
we do not have expertise which they have no
and hedging only tactically No
No expertise. Efficient risk
in areas in which we have management involves
an edge.” adjusting levels of risk to
appropriate levels and not
necessarily eliminating
risks.
Reference
CFA Level III, Volume 5, Study Session 16, Reading 31, LOS a
C Solution:
Identify Five Risk Exposures Faced by the Explain Each Risk Exposure with
Idaho Division One Identified Source
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 5, Study Session 16, Reading 31, LOS d
Capex Asset Management is a U.S. based portfolio management firm which has always
invested in domestic stocks on behalf of client portfolios. Victor Solanki is CAM’s senior
most portfolio manager. Solanki has allocated €100 million for investing in German
stocks with an average beta of 0.75. The spot exchange rate is $0.89. The German interest
rate is 4%.
Solanki will be hedging both German market risk as well as currency risk for a three
month period. A three-month futures contract on the German market is priced at
€200,000 and has a beta of 0.60. The three-month forward rate is $0.9560.
i. Identify the strategy Capex Asset Management will need to undertake for
hedging German local market return.
ii. Calculate the hedged portfolio return. Use a ‘n/360’ days convention and show
your calculations.
(5 minutes)
Question 12 Solution:
i. Capex Asset Management will need to sell futures contracts to hedge the German
local market return.
Explanation: Capex has a long exposure to the German equity market. A fall in
return will generate losses for its investment portfolio. Therefore, to hedge against
potential losses the company will need to sell futures contracts.
ii. The portfolio is hedged for local market risk and therefore it will grow to a value
of €101,000 = €100,000[1 + (0.04 × 90/360)]. Capex can hedge this amount using
a currency forward contract with a notional principal of €101,000.
With the portfolio hedged for currency risk, the dollars received at contract
expiration will equal to $96,556 (€101,000 × $0.9560).
Based on the original portfolio value of $89,000 (€100,000 × $0.89), the hedged
portfolio return is equal to 8.49% ($96,556/$89,000 – 1).
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 5, Study Session 17, Reading 32, LOS f
Steven Blair, CFA, has been contracted to help Betty Davis put together an Investor
Policy Statement and a strategic allocation for her $2.5 million in assets. The funds are
currently allocated to the asset classes established by a previous advisor
They begin to discuss the asset classes and recommendations in their first meeting.
Steven tells Betty that the previous advisor did not correctly specify the asset classes. He
also recommends treasury-inflation protected securities as a separate asset class from the
nominal bonds currently in the portfolio and provides the table below as evidence.
(2 minutes)
B. Describe three errors that were made in the specification of asset classes
(6 minutes)
Steven has experience developing strategic asset allocations using traditional mean
variance optimization with unadjusted historical returns, variances and covariances. To
construct a strategic allocation for Betty, he is interested in using other approaches like
Black-Litterman and Monte Carlo simulation.
C. Identify one advantage and one limitation for each of the approaches listed in the
case (Mean-Variance, Black-Litterman, and Monte Carlo)
(9 minutes)
A Solution:
TIPS are a homogenous asset class (they are correlated with themselves). They also
provide important protection against inflation, which is not provided in nominal bonds.
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 3, Study Session 9, Reading 19.
B Solution:
2) Asset classes should be mutually exclusive or have no overlap. The U.S. large
cap and the S&P500 fund will overlap significantly.
3) Asset classes should be diversifying for risk control. The U.S. corporate bonds
and Treasuries are highly correlated and it is assumed that the U.S. large cap
and S&P500 funds will also be highly correlated.
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 3, Study Session 9, Reading 19.
C Solution:
Mean-Variance:
Advantage is that it identifies portfolios with the highest expected return at each level of
risk, though it is limited in the number and nature of estimates can overwhelm the
analyst.
Black-Litterman:
Advantage is that it provides portfolios that are well-diversified and a stable efficient
frontier, though it is limited in that it relies on historical returns and variances.
Monte Carlo:
Advantage is that it can be used to generate a distribution of probabilities, though its
limitation is the complexity of the approach.
Reference:
CFA Level III, Volume 3, Study Session 9, Reading 19.