Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
a
International College of National Institute of Development Administration, Thailand
b
Mahidol University International College, Thailand
Keywords: This study is the first of its kind to examine the acceptance and usage behavior of online grocery shopping in
Online grocery shopping Thailand. It proposes an extension of the technology acceptance model, including subjective norm, visibility,
TAM perceived risk, and perceived enjoyment to better understand the factors and the extent to which they lead to the
Thailand acceptance or rejection of online grocery shopping. In order to accurately test the variables and the relationships
Acceptance
of the proposed research model, a questionnaire was developed and distributed to 450 residents in the Bangkok
Behavior
area, of which 263 valid responses were returned back to the researcher. Instrument development was done by
using existing scales and items from the current literature on technology acceptance. Partial least squares
structural equation modeling (PLS-SEM) was used for this research, with the results emphasizing that perceived
ease of use, perceived usefulness, intention to use, subjective norm, and perceived enjoyment have a statistically
significant relationship towards the acceptance of online grocery shopping in Thailand. By contrast, visibility
and perceived risk were found to have no significant impact on the perceived usefulness of online grocery
shopping. The results and implications are summarized in the discussion part of this paper where valuable
recommendations for decision makers are provided.
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: f.driediger@gmail.com (F. Driediger).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jretconser.2019.02.005
Received 2 March 2018; Received in revised form 12 December 2018; Accepted 8 February 2019
Available online 27 February 2019
0969-6989/ © 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
F. Driediger and V. Bhatiasevi Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services 48 (2019) 224–237
Table 1
Literature Review OGS.
Authors Topic Methods Findings
(Park et al., 1996) Consumer perceptions of Home Qualitative study Consumer experience increased convenience and express perceived
Shopping (OGS) in the US. risk.
(Hiser et al., 1999) Willingness to use OGS in Texas, Quantitative study (n = 390) Consumer express convenience and perceived risk as major influence.
US. Older people are less likely to use OGS.
(Morganosky and Cude, 2000) Consumer response to OGS in the Quantitative study (n = 243) Convenience and saving time are primary reasons to use OGS.
US.
(Childers et al., 2001) Hedonic and utilitarian motivations Quantitative study (Hedonic: TAM was confirmed. Navigation, convenience, and sub-experience
for OGS in the US. n = 274) (Utilitarian: n = 366) are significant.
(Raijas, 2002) Consumer benefits and problems Quantitative study (n = 93) Study confirms convenience and perceived ease of use to be
using OGS in Finland. important.
(Rohm and Swaminathan, OGS motivations in the US. Quantitative study (n = 429) Convenience, store orientation, information use, and variety seeking
2004) are significant factors.
(Hansen, 2008) OGS and consumer values in Quantitative study (n = 1058) Theory of planned behavior was confirmed. Openness to change, and
Sweden self-transcendence do not influence attitude towards OGS.
(Hand et al., 2009) Influence of situational factors on Qualitative study Quantitative Situational factors can explain continued or discontinued usage.
OGS in the UK. study (n = 1128)
(Hui and Wan, 2009) OGS in Singapore Quantitative study (n = 211) Perceived ease of use and perceived usefulness are strong predictors
for behavioral intention. Intention to use is influenced by age,
education and income.
(Anesbury et al., 2015) Observational study of OGS in Quantitative study (n = 40) OGS behavior is similar to offline shopping behavior.
(Mortimer et al., 2016) Impact of shopping frequency on Quantitative study (n = 555) Significant differences between frequent and infrequent users for
perceived risk in Australia. perceived risk.
Geistfeld (2004) further found that Korean consumers show a higher including perishables. The ordering process is generally managed by e-
extent of subjective norm, compared to their American counterparts, commerce websites or mobile apps. According to Chaffey (2011), e-
when shopping online. While the existing literature certainly provides a commerce is defined as “all electronically mediated information ex-
comprehensive overview of the different acceptance models and their changes between an organization and its stakeholders” (p. 14).
ability to explain OGS acceptance in US and European markets, further Research in the field of OGS started in the late 90s Park et al.
research is necessary in order to test their ability of prediction in the (1996), found that high-tech baby boomers utilized home shopping
environment of developing countries, such as Thailand. Thus, more services because of their urge to streamline their lives and that online
studies need to be conducted in countries culturally different to those in shopping offered one solution to increase convenience. The same study
the existing literature. also suggests, that consumers are concerned about security risks. Fur-
In order to fill this current research gap in the academic literature thermore did they express their concerns towards perceived risks. An-
and to forge more knowledge about the OGS acceptance in developing other study from Hiser et al. (1999) analyzed the familiarity and will-
countries, this study addresses the following research objectives. ingness to use online food shopping services in a local area of Texas, US.
The study confirmed consumers’ perceived convenience towards OGS.
Perceived convenience and saving time as the main reasons for OGS
1. To test whether the relationships from existing e-commerce literature
were also confirmed in studies by Morganosky and Cude (2000) and
replicate for online grocery shopping in Thailand.
2. To determine the factors and the extent to which they lead to the acceptance Raijas (2002). Contrary to these studies, Rohm and Swaminathan
of online grocery shopping. (2004) failed to confirm the importance of time savings, and recreation
3. To determine and recognize the factors with the highest extent of influence on and enjoyment. With regards to the technology acceptance model,
Thai consumers’ acceptance of online grocery shopping. Childers et al. (2001) Found that perceived usefulness and perceived
4. To form managerial guidance and recommendations concerning the accep-
tance of online grocery shopping.
ease of use are strong predictors for OGS usage. In a recent study by
Mortimer et al. (2016), researchers investigated the impact of shopping
frequency on perceived risk. The findings suggest that customer sa-
Answering these research objectives will help fill the current gaps in tisfaction is a strong predictor for infrequent and frequent online
the existing literature and help scholars in identifying differences in the shoppers, while perceived risk has the ability to fully mediate the effect
acceptance of online grocery shopping in the context of developing of trust on the repurchase intentions for infrequent shoppers.
countries. A comprehensive literature review is provided in the next Despite comprehensive studies of consumer behavior and accep-
section, discussing the technology acceptance model (TAM) and the tance of OGS in US and European markets, it remains unclear whether
concept of online grocery shopping (OGS). Afterwards, the paper will the results can be applied to other parts of the world. Cultural differ-
describe the research methodology employed, including instrument ences in power distance, uncertainty avoidance, individualism and
development, data collection, and participants’ characteristics. collectivism, masculinity and femininity, and long- versus short-term
Subsequently, the research model and its hypotheses are defined and orientation are well- studied subjects and known to influence people’s
elucidated, followed by a detailed analysis of the data and its results. purchasing behavior (Hofstede, 2001). For instance, a study conducted
The paper will eventually conclude with a discussion and implications by Choi and Geistfeld (2004) has shown that subjective norm is more
part. important to South Korean consumers in comparison to their counter-
parts in the US. However, as exhibited in Table 1, the English-speaking
2. Literature review literature holds little information about OGS acceptance in emerging
markets such as Thailand.
2.1. Online grocery shopping
2.2. Online grocery shopping in Thailand
Online grocery shopping (OGS) or electronic grocery shopping
(EGS) is a form of e-commerce that allows private individuals and The OGS market in Thailand is still relatively young and in the
businesses to purchase foodstuffs and various household supplies, often growing stage of the product life cycle, although it has already attracted
225
F. Driediger and V. Bhatiasevi Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services 48 (2019) 224–237
quite a number of businesses to the industry. Not surprisingly, large Ever since its introduction, TAM has been applied to different
brick and mortar stores, such as Tesco Lotus, were among the first to technologies, under different situations, with different control factors,
offer their services online (Rungfapaisarn, 2016a). The company re- and different subjects, and is well proven to be a robust model (Lee
portedly describes their major online shoppers to be in the age group of et al., 2003). Several meta-analyses have confirmed its powerful char-
25–44 years old who rate convenience as the number one reason for acteristics. In a comprehensive study by King and He (2006), 88 pub-
online shopping. Interestingly, Tesco Lotus claims that the average lished studies that utilized TAM were analyzed and results have shown
online basket size is 3.5 times as large as at the physical store that TAM is indeed a valid and robust model. The authors further
(Rungfapaisarn, 2016a). pointed out that TAM is a complete mediating model that explains the
Big C is another huge player in the grocery shopping industry in effect of PEOU on behavioral intention primarily through PU. Another
Thailand and also offering its products through several e-commerce meta-analysis that analyzed 145 published studies identified three main
platforms. However, the company reports that sales from the online factors as the root of TAM’s popularity (Yousafzai et al., 2007). Firstly,
channels are still small and further confirms its online customers’ pre- the model is described as specifically designed towards information
ference for convenience and customized offers (Rungfapaisarn, 2016b). technology and as a good measure to provide explanation and predic-
While the OGS market is growing, it provides a great opportunity for tion of a diverse user population’s acceptance of a wide range of
research in order to explain certain consumer behavior. The driving technologies, within varying organizations, cultural contexts, and ex-
forces such as growth of the middle income class and its move from a pertise levels. Secondly, TAM has a well-recognized theoretical back-
low-income country to an upper-income country are expected to help ground, is well researched, and provides a validated inventory of
OGS to improve its acceptance in Thailand (World Bank, 2018). Fur- measurement scales. Thirdly, because the model is well researched, it
thermore, the strong female workforce (45.7% of the total workforce) has accumulated a strong empirical support for its explanatory qualities
might be another accelerator for OGS in Thailand (World Bank, 2017). and attributes. It is therefore considered to be the prevailing model of
With reference to general e-commerce acceptance in Thailand, most users’ acceptance of technology. According to the valuable insights of
existing academic research focuses on the adoption of small and previously conducted research and analyses, this study will therefore
medium enterprises, rather than individual consumers (Lertwongsatien employ the modified version of TAM and further integrate four external
and Wongpinunwatana, 2003; Limthongchai and Speece, 2003; variables, namely subjective norm, visibility, perceived risk, and en-
Rotchanakitumnuai and Speece, 2003; Sutanonpaiboon and Pearson, joyment.
2006). Sutanonpaiboon and Pearson (2006) found that non-adoption of
e-commerce among SMEs can be explained by cultural, technological, 3. Research model and hypotheses
financial, and logistical reasons. Probably the most comprehensive
work on internet usage behavior among Thai consumers was conducted As described previously, the TAM consists of 4 permanent variables.
by the Electronic Transactions Development Agency (ETDA) and the The belief on a system’s perceived ease of use (PEOU) can be a predictor
Ministry of Information and Communication Technology (ICT) (ETDA, for its perceived usefulness (PU). This relationship has been supported
2016). This annually executed survey aims to collect information about in several studies (King and He, 2006). According to Davis (1989),
users’ internet usage behavior and to provide implications for policy- PEOU is defined as “the degree to which a person believes that using a
makers and businesses. According to the latest report, 59% of internet particular system would be free of effort” (p. 320). The term “effort”
users purchase goods online, suggesting a great confidence and trust refers to the finite resources a person may allocate to the activities he or
among online shoppers. Thailand’s e-commerce industry is currently she is responsible for (Radner and Rothschild, 1975). PU is defined by
booming and expected to see double-digit growth in the future, Davis (1989) as “the degree to which a person believes that using a
meaning that the number of consumers today, 11 million, is likely to particular system would enhance his or her job performance” (p. 320).
double in the next three to five years (Potkin, 2016). As both definitions imply, they were initially intended to measure
people's technology acceptance in a job setting, but have long been
2.3. Technology acceptance model transferred and tested in various other fields (Yousafzai et al., 2007).
According to several studies, in various fields, such as mobile
The technology acceptance model (TAM), originally articulated to commerce (Wu and Wang, 2005), e-commerce (Ha and Stoel, 2009),
explain the behavior of computer usage, was derived from the theory of and internet banking (Lai and Li, 2005) have confirmed that PEOU
reasoned action (TRA) (Ajzen and Fishbein, 1975, 1980). Due to its positively affected PU at a significant level. A study on the impact of
robust characteristics, TAM is the most commonly employed model to cognitive absorption on perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use
explain an individual’s acceptance of a particular information system in online learning has accepted the positive relationship between PEOU
(Lee et al., 2003). The model was first introduced by Davis (1989) and and intention to use (ITU) (Saadé and Bahli, 2005). Lallmahamood
has ever since been used in countless studies to predict and explain why (2007) who tested the relationship in a study on the acceptance of in-
users accept or reject information technology (Legris et al., 2003). TAM ternet banking in Malaysia also supported this relationship. A study
introduced two new variables, namely perceived usefulness (PU) and about the intention to use the Internet among Chinese older adults
perceived ease of use (PEOU), and proposed them as the major de- further confirmed the relationship (Pan and Jordan-Marsh, 2010).
terminants for attitude towards a given technology. Con- Translated to the context of our study, the intention to use OGS is in-
temporaneously, Davis (1989) suggested that further external variables fluenced by a user’s belief on whether OGS is free of effort.
have to be defined in order to explain perceived usefulness and per- The influence of PU on ITU was shown to be positive in a study
ceived ease of use. The model considers PEOU and PU to be the most conducted in Thailand concerning the structural relationship for the
important variables in explaining system use (Legris et al., 2003). De- determinants of cloud computing adoption in education (Bhatiasevi and
spite its high extent of adoption, many researchers have since expressed Naglis, 2015). A positive relationship was also supported in a study by
the need for additional variables to provide an even stronger model Klopping and McKinney (2004) who tested the acceptance of consumer
(Legris et al., 2003). In their proposed extension, Venkatesh and Davis e-commerce. The relationship was further confirmed in a study on
(2000) removed attitude towards a given technology because of its mobile wireless technology adoption (Kim and Garrison, 2009). Along
weak prediction of both behavioral intention and actual system use. with the previously conducted studies in various technological fields,
The decision was confirmed and supported by several other studies hypotheses are proposed as follows:
(Lederer et al., 2000; Teo et al., 1999; Wu and Wang, 2005). Ad-
H1. PEOU is positively related to the PU of online grocery shopping.
ditionally, the new model re-introduced subjective norm as an external
variable (Venkatesh and Davis, 2000). H2. PEOU is positively related to the ITU of online grocery shopping.
226
F. Driediger and V. Bhatiasevi Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services 48 (2019) 224–237
H3. PU is positively related to the ITU of online grocery shopping. and formulated:
According to the original TAM, behavioral intention to use a given H6. VIS is positively related to the PU of online grocery shopping.
system is positively related to the actual system use (Davis, 1989). It is
worth mentioning that 47% of the studies related to TAM measure self-
reported usage and only 9% measure the actual usage (Yousafzai et al., 3.3. Perceived risk
2007). However, there is still enough literature available to support this
hypothesis. A study by Horton et al. (2001) confirmed the positive re- The perceived risk (PR) of using a given technology is another factor
lationship in an attempt to explain intranet use with TAM, tested in two originating from the diffusion of innovation theory (Rogers, 2010).
UK companies. The relationship was also found to withstand in the field According to Rogers (2010), PR comprises of several facets, such as
of e-commerce (Klopping and McKinney, 2004). In a comprehensive psychological risk, social risk, performance risk, financial risk, time
literature review of the TAM’s ability to predict actual use, the re- risk, and privacy risk. For the purpose of this study we will classify PR
searchers summarized, based on 73 published articles, that intention to as a combination of performance risk, time risk, and privacy risk. Per-
use is likely to be correlated with actual use (Turner et al., 2010). Since formance risk is defined as “the possibility of the product mal-
our study does not measure the actual usage of the respondents, but functioning and not performing as it was designed and advertised and
rather self-reported habits, the term “usage behavior” is used (UB). therefore failing to deliver the desired benefits” (Grewal et al., 1994, p.
Verification of previous studies leads to the following hypothesis: 455). In the context of this study, it translates to the consumer’s risk of
not receiving the groceries in the expected and desired condition. Time
H4. ITU is positively related to the UB of online grocery shopping.
risk is defined as the possibility of “making a bad purchasing decision
by wasting time researching and making the purchase, learning how to
3.1. Subjective norm use a product or service only to have to replace it if it does not perform
to expectations” (Featherman and Pavlou, 2003, p. 455). As this is,
Subjective norm (SN) originates from the theory of reasoned action, generally speaking, a matching definition for most technologies, it is
and is defined as a “person's perception that most people who are im- missing a very important aspect of e-commerce, namely the delivery
portant to him think he should or should not perform the behavior in time and its associated risk of not receiving the ordered products on
question” (Ajzen and Fishbein, 1975, p. 302). Within the context of this time. Privacy risk is defined as the “potential loss of control over per-
study, consumers will conduct OGS if they feel that influential people of sonal information, such as when information about you is used without
their environment think OGS is a good thing to do. According to the your knowledge or permission” (Featherman and Pavlou, 2003, p. 455).
extension of TAM, SN has a positive relationship towards PU With regards to our study, perceived privacy risk refers to the security
(Venkatesh and Davis, 2000). The proposal was confirmed by a study of information and payment methods when using OGS. The influence of
related to US consumers’ readiness to adopt mobile technology for PR on PU has been studied by Lu et al. (2005), who found that PR
fashion goods (Kim et al., 2009). The overall influence on subjective negatively affects PU upon intentions to use online applications. An-
norm, used with TAM, has been studied in a meta-analysis that con- other study conducted in the field of online shopping acceptance sup-
cluded and supported the positive relationship between SN and PU ported the negative relationship between PR and PU (Li and Huang,
(Schepers and Wetzels, 2007). The authors of the study analyzed 51 2009). Crespo et al. (2009) confirmed the negative influence of PR on
articles, containing 63 studies, in order to evaluate the influence of SN PU on internet shopping behavior among people with previous online
on PU and ITU. Based on these findings, the following hypothesis can be shopping experience, although pointing out that the effect is insignif-
formulated: icant among non-buyers. According to Rose and Fogarty (2006), the
negative relationship is also reported in a study on self-service banking
H5. SN is positively related to the PU of online grocery shopping. technologies among senior consumers. Despite some contradictory re-
search, most studies support the negative relationship between PR and
PU, hence the subsequent hypothesis is formed:
3.2. Visibility
H7. PR is negatively related to the PU of online grocery shopping.
The visibility (VIS) of a given technology originates from the dif-
fusion of innovation theory by Rogers (2010), and refers to the extent to
which an innovation is apparent to potential adopters. Visibility in 3.4. Perceived Enjoyment
combination with the TAM has been studied by Karahanna et al. (1999)
who investigated the influence of visibility on attitude towards in- According to Davis et al. (1992), perceived enjoyment is defined as
formation technology adoption across time. They confirmed the posi- “the extent to which the activity of using the computer is perceived to
tive relationship to be of statistical significance. In a study about OGS be enjoyable in its own right, apart from any performance consequences
acceptance in Australia, Kurnia and Chien (2003) found VIS to be an that may be anticipated” (p. 1113). In the context of our study, the
important factor for the community’s acceptance of this particular definition can be translated to the extent to which a user perceives
technology. The positive influence of VIS on attitude towards mobile online grocery shopping to be enjoyable. Venkatesh (2000), who stu-
banking was also supported and consistent among actual user- and non- died the influence of PEOU on user acceptance, added perceived en-
user-groups (Karjaluoto et al., 2010). However, all of these studies joyment to his research model and found a positive relationship be-
employed the original TAM that included attitudes towards a given tween ENJ and PEOU among users with increased experience. Mun and
technology, a variable that has been removed in the extension of TAM Hwang (2003) studied the prediction of web-based information systems
due to its weak prediction (Venkatesh and Davis, 2000). In a cross- use and found a positive relationship between ENJ and PEOU, as well as
cultural study on digital library adoption, researchers partially sup- between ENJ and PU. Both relationships were also supported in an
ported the relationship between VIS and PU (Miller and Khera, 2010). assessment of the influence of perceived enjoyment and attitude on the
While one group from Peru supported the positive relationship, parti- intention to use technology among pre-service teachers (Teo and Noyes,
cipants from Kenya did not. This suggests that the role of VIS differs 2011). In the context of e-commerce acceptance among college stu-
throughout cultures. Research on the effect of VIS on PU is still limited dents, the relationship between ENJ and PU has been supported as well
and our study aims to fill this gap. Based on the existing literature (Ha and Stoel, 2009). In a manner consistent with the existing literature
which suggests a positive relationship between VIS and attitude to- and to research the role of ENJ on the acceptance of OGS, the following
wards a given technology, the following hypothesis has been derived hypotheses have been formulated:
227
F. Driediger and V. Bhatiasevi Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services 48 (2019) 224–237
228
F. Driediger and V. Bhatiasevi Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services 48 (2019) 224–237
Table 3 Table 5
Descriptive statistics of the samples. Means, standard deviation, internal consistencies and item loadings.
Respondent characteristics (n = 263) Frequency Percentage Construct Mean SD Item Factor AVE CR Cronbach
Age loading alpha
< 18 9 3.4 ENJ 4.27 0.80 ENJ_1 0.719 0.616 0.918 0.896
18–25 42 16 ENJ_2 0.790
26–45 161 61.2 ENJ_3 0.815
46–60 48 18.3 ENJ_4 0.762
> 60 3 1.1 ENJ_5 0.855
Gender ENJ_6 0.784
Male 86 32.7 ENJ_7 0.764
Female 177 67.3 ITU 4.86 1.12 ITU_1 0.881 0.728 0.914 0.876
Education ITU_2 0.855
High School 56 21.3 ITU_3 0.845
Some College 24 9.1 ITU_4 0.831
Bachelor's Degree 122 46.4 PEOU 4.80 1.02 PEOU_1 0.789 0.761 0.927 0.894
Master's Degree 58 22.1 PEOU_2 0.897
Invalidity 3 1.1 PEOU_3 0.906
Marital Status PEOU_4 0.893
Single 131 49.8 PR 5.30 1.09 PR_1 0.723 0.659 0.885 0.855
Married 110 41.8 PR_2 0.750
Divorced 21 8 PR_3 0.873
Invalidity 1 0.4 PR_4 0.888
Number of people in household PU 4.62 0.88 PU_1 0.621 0.510 0.891 0.861
1 7 2.7 PU_2 0.778
2 19 7.2 PU_3 0.647
3 48 18.3 PU_4 0.828
4 94 35.7 PU_5 0.600
5 41 15.6 PU_6 0.701
>5 54 20.5 PU_7 0.686
Job Position PU_8 0.812
Junior staff 75 28.5 SN 3.89 1.05 SN_1 0.848 0.698 0.902 0.856
Senior staff 25 9.5 SN_2 0.795
Lower-level manager 14 5.3 SN_3 0.843
Middle-level manager 24 9.1 SN_4 0.854
Senior-level manager 2 0.8 UB 2.24 1.17 UB_1 0.887 0.720 0.884 0.816
Other/Self-employed 120 45.6 UB_2 0.707
Invalidity 3 1.1 UB_3 0.935
Total income of household (in THB per month) VIS 4.40 1.13 VIS_1 0.830 0.685 0.897 0.848
0 – 24,999 36 13.7 VIS_2 0.836
25,000–49,999 74 28.1 VIS_3 0.851
50,000–74,999 42 16 VIS_4 0.792
75,000–99,999 20 7.6
100,000 – 150,000 29 11
> 150,000 28 10.6
equation modeling (PLS-SEM) was used to test the proposed model.
Not disclosed 34 12.9
PLS-SEM is used for variance-based structural equation modeling and
allows testing of complete theories and concepts. Variance-based SEM
Table 4 differs from co-variance-based SEM (i.e., AMOS) in cases where it is
Heterotrait-monotrait ratio of correlations matrix. more exploratory than confirmatory (Hair et al., 2011). PLS-SEM is
used for predicting and identifying key driver constructs as well as
Construct ENJ ITU PEOU PR PU SN UB VIS
testing an extension of an existing structural theory (Hair et al., 2011).
ENJ – In comparison with first generation regression models, such as linear
ITU 0.593 – regression, ANOVA, and MANOVA, SEM provides the ability to si-
PEOU 0.596 0.684 – multaneously test model relationships among multiple dependent and
PR 0.119 0.205 0.109 –
independent variables (Gerbing and Anderson, 1988). Thus, SEM was
PU 0.568 0.774 0.720 0.176 –
SN 0.583 0.527 0.447 0.059 0.476 – chosen as the tool of measurement for this research. According to Hair
UB 0.352 0.272 0.186 0.193 0.228 0.381 – et al. (2011), when using PLS-SEM, the primary evaluation criteria for
VIS 0.392 0.411 0.396 0.184 0.349 0.588 0.329 – the structural model are the R2 measures together with the level of
significance of the path coefficients. Accordingly, the R2 should be high
with respect to the research discipline. Since this paper aims to explain
Discriminant validity was tested by using the heterotrait-monotrait consumer behavior and acceptance, a R2 value of 0.20 is considered
ratio of correlations (HTMT), which is an alternative approach to assess high (Hair et al., 2011). As described in Table 6, the model allocates
discriminant validity, and according to Henseler et al. (2015), superior 52.3% of the variance to intention to use, 28.8% of the variance to
to traditional approaches (i.e. the Fornell-Larcker criterion and cross-
loadings) when using variance-based structural equation modeling. A
Table 6
HTMT value below 0.85 means that discriminant validity has been es-
Evaluation of the structural model.
tablished between two reflective constructs (Kline, 2015). As reported
in Table 4, all values are within the desired range. Construct R2 Adjusted R2 P-value Q2
229
F. Driediger and V. Bhatiasevi Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services 48 (2019) 224–237
230
F. Driediger and V. Bhatiasevi Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services 48 (2019) 224–237
Table 8
House-hold size > 5 n = 95 Summary of hypotheses testing.
Hypothesis Relationship Supported
0.467*** (5.409)
0.354*** (4.491)
0.482*** (5.916)
0.577*** (5.710)
−0.016 (0.184)
H1 PEOU → PU Yes
0.282* (2.534)
0.108 (0.947)
0.189 (1.515)
0.197 (1.895)
H2 PEOU → ITU Yes
H3 PU → ITU Yes
H4 ITU → UB Yes
H5 SN → PU Yes
H6 VIS → PU No
H7 PR → PU No
H8 ENJ → PU Yes
H9 ENJ → PEOU Yes
House-hold size < 5
0.590*** (12.275)
0.288*** (3.121)
0.503*** (7.832)
0.463*** (6.606)
0.212** (3.173)
−0.008 (0.109)
0.216* (2.151)
0.110 (1.512)
their grocery shopping. Given the responses, it is fair to say that con-
n = 168
venience is one of the most important factor for influencing the per-
ceived usefulness, followed by the time-saving effect of OGS (PU_2 with
Significant at: *p < 0.05; **p < 0.01; ***p < 0.001; T-statistics in parentheses; Coefficients in bold indicate a significant difference between the two groups.
0.425*** (5.335)
−0.009 (0.122)
0.184* (2.235)
0.176 (1.825)
0.177 (1.788)
0.331*** (4.206)
0.507*** (5.367)
0.014 (0.155)
0.048 (0.547)
0.131 (1.306)
0.539*** (6.347)
0.594*** (6.014)
Married n = 110
0.247** (2.718)
0.252** (2.657)
−0.063 (0.660)
0.053 (0.530)
value of 3.89, which suggests that most people reported their en-
vironment to have a rather negative opinion of OGS. This is not overly
surprising, since OGS is a relatively new form of grocery shopping.
Thus, it is important to understand that family, friends, and acquain-
Single and divorced n = 152
0.300*** (4.502)
0.427*** (5.758)
0.434*** (6.098)
0.064 (0.684)
0.138 (1.548)
0.014 (0.184)
0.317*** (5.415)
0.279*** (3.214)
0.470*** (6.499)
0.317*** (7.098)
0.218** (2.829)
enjoyable. One reason for this neutral opinion could be that those who
Female n = 177
0.094 (1.208)
0.049 (0.744)
0.024 (0.356)
have not yet tried OGS are unsure about the enjoyment factor of doing
so. In their study about consumer e-shopping acceptance, Ha and Stoel
Path coefficients of multi group analysis.
0.518*** (4.402)
−0.025 (0.259)
0.321* (2.206)
0.280* (2.195)
0.236 (1.664)
0.141 (1.013)
0.140 (1.286)
0.009 (0.093)
the highest correlation (0.537) within the model. In other words, OGS
providers must attach an enjoyment factor to their systems in order to
increase the users’ perceived ease of use as well as perceived usefulness.
Mun and Hwang (2003) also support this hypothesis in their study
ENJ → PEOU
Relationship
PEOU → ITU
PEOU →PU
PU →ITU
VIS →PU
SN →PU
PR →PU
231
F. Driediger and V. Bhatiasevi Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services 48 (2019) 224–237
232
F. Driediger and V. Bhatiasevi Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services 48 (2019) 224–237
study, it does have limitations. First and foremost the study tried to Furthermore, since this paper measured usage behavior on a self-re-
gather an overall picture of the online grocery shopping acceptance in porting basis, it remains unclear if the responses truly represent actual
Thailand. As seen in Table 3, the survey has successfully delivered data usage. In order to test actual usage, researchers would need to obtain
from all strata of society. However, it is unclear how the results of the primary data from OGS firms. Technological advancement and chan-
hypotheses testing would change when conducted only for certain ging business models are also subject to future research. As companies
subgroups. It is also uncertain if the sample of respondents from employ new strategies such as click & collect at store, click & collect at
Bangkok truly represents the acceptance of OGS in Thailand. Due to the 3rd party, and click & drive, it remains unclear how this would impact
logistical challenges involved in OGS, it is likely that the perception of consumer behavior. Lastly, the research model of this study is based on
consumers changes in rural areas where infrastructure is less developed. TAM, extended by external variables such as subjective norm, visibility,
Secondly, as mentioned before, OGS is a new concept and people need perceived risk, and enjoyment. As seen in the model testing part of this
time to adopt this technology. It could be possible that results of this paper, two out of four external variables are not supported, which
survey change once the concept is more strongly integrated into society. means further research needs to be conducted to find additional factors
Also, with reference to the usage behavior, further research is necessary that can explain perceived usefulness. For the purpose of identifying
in order to find differences in consumer behavior among early adopters external variables, it might be necessary to administer qualitative re-
and the early/late majority. A longitudinal method might deliver a search in order to discover unknown factors.
better understanding of Thai consumers’ acceptance of OGS.
Appendix A
Instruction
The purpose of this questionnaire is to study the acceptance of Online Grocery Shopping among Thai users. Information provided in this
questionnaire will be kept confidential by the researcher and the institute. The researcher kindly appreciates your help and contribution. If you
would like to receive a copy of this research, feel free to leave your email address in the field below.
Section 1
1. General Information
Section 2
Kindly let us know your opinion about Online Grocery Shopping by indicating to which extent you agree or disagree with the statements below.
Please circle the number (from 1 to 7) which best represents your opinion where 1 means you strongly disagree with the statement and 7 means you
strongly agree with the statement.
2.1 Members of my family think that it is a good idea to buy groceries via the 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Internet.
2.2 Most of my friends and acquaintances think that shopping groceries via the 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Internet is a good idea.
2.3 People who influence my behavior think that I should buy groceries online. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
2.4 People who are important to me think that I should buy groceries online. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
233
F. Driediger and V. Bhatiasevi Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services 48 (2019) 224–237
4.1 I am concerned with the payment security aspects of Online Grocery Shopping. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
4.2 I am concerned with the privacy of my information provided when using 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Online Grocery Shopping.
4.3 I am concerned with the punctuality of the delivery time of Online Grocery 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Shopping.
4.4 I am concerned with the quality of the products delivered when ordering from 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Online Grocery Shopping.
4.5 I am confident over the security aspects of Internet banking in Thailand. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
5. Enjoyment Strongly Disagree Disagree Somewhat Disagree Neutral Somewhat Agree Agree Strongly Agree
5.1 Online Grocery Shopping is/would be fun for its own sake. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
5.2 Online Grocery Shopping is/would make me feel good. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
5.3 Online Grocery Shopping is/would be boring. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
5.4 Online Grocery Shopping is/would be exciting. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
5.5 Online Grocery Shopping is/would be enjoyable. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
5.6 Online Grocery Shopping is/would be uncomfortable. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
5.7 Online Grocery Shopping is/would be interesting. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
6. Perceived ease of use Strongly Disagree Somewhat Neutral Somewhat Agree Strongly
Disagree Disagree Agree Agree
8.1 I intend to use Online Grocery Shopping when the service becomes 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
widely available.
8.2 Whenever possible, I intend to use Online Grocery Shopping to purchase 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
groceries.
8.3 I intend to use Online Grocery Shopping when there is free home 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
delivery.
8.4 I intend to use Online Grocery Shopping when the price is competitive. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
9. Usage behavior Not at all Less than once a About once a 2–3 times a 4–5 times a About once a Several times
month month month month week each week
234
F. Driediger and V. Bhatiasevi Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services 48 (2019) 224–237
Appendix B
Table B1
Questionnaire items.
Item Missing Mean Median Min Max SD Kurtosis Skewness
SN = Subjective norm; VIS = Visibility; PR = Perceived risk; ENJ = Perceived enjoyment; PEOU = Perceived ease of use; PU = Perceived usefulness; ITU
= Intention to use; UB = Usage behavior.
Appendix C
Table C1
Collinearity statistics.
Factor ENJ ITU PEOU PR PU SN UB VIS
SN = Subjective norm; VIS = Visibility; PR = Perceived risk; ENJ = Perceived enjoyment; PEOU = Perceived ease of use; PU = Perceived usefulness; ITU
= Intention to use; UB = Usage behavior.
235
F. Driediger and V. Bhatiasevi Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services 48 (2019) 224–237
Supplementary data associated with this article can be found in the online version at doi:10.1016/j.jretconser.2019.02.005.
236
F. Driediger and V. Bhatiasevi Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services 48 (2019) 224–237
237