Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES
Plaintiff,
SUMMARY OF ARGUMENTS
I. PRELIMINARY CONSIDERATIONS
2 of 11
3. The errors of the truthfulness of the testimonies
made by the accused should be considered. The
inconsistency of the statements made by the
accused himself is enough to question his
credibility.
1
People v. Barcela, G.R. No. 179948, 8 December 2010
2
25 August TSN, Audio.
3 of 11
9. Mr. Cogsworth W. Clock, on the other hand, has
also inexplicably and systematically recounted the
fact of him seeing the accused stab the victim in the
chest several times.3
3
27 October 2018 TSN, pp. 8
4
People v. Claro, G.R. No. 199894, 5 April 2017
5
People v. Tadepa, G.R. No. 100354, 26 may 1995
4 of 11
14. While no general rule can be laid down as to the
quantity of circumstantial evidence which will suffice
in a given case, all the circumstances proved must
be consistent with each other, consistent with the
hypothesis that the accused is guilty, and at the
same time inconsistent with the hypothesis that he
is innocent, and with every other rational hypothesis
except that of guilt.
C. Tatay positively
identified Mr. Mack Hale
D. Beast as having raped
beauty n. Belle in his
presence.
6 of 11
26. Mr. Cogsworth W. Clock in his testimony dated last
10 October 2018, positively identified and testified
to the fact that Mr. Mack Hale D. Beast killed Ms.
Belle N. Beauty.7
7
10/27/2018 TSN page 8.
8
Id.
9
Heirloom Dagger marked as Exhibit “O” in court records
10
Id
11
Bastian vs CA, G.R. No. 160811, 14 April 2008
7 of 11
testimony can make or break the prosecution case
and uphold or derail justice.
8 of 11
corroboration. This is because the mere fact that
the accused and the victim were lovers should not
exculpate him from criminal liability for rape.
9 of 11
40. This principle is founded upon the law of reason,
justice and conscience. When an accused consents
to the filing of a motion for reconsideration of the
judgement against him, double jeopardy cannot be
invoked by him since he waived his right not to be
placed in double jeopardy.
10 of 11
every wordings of the law-there should be progress.
The rule on double jeopardy is strict.
PRAYER
11 of 11
Antipolo City, April 4, 2019.
12 of 11