Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
for
Transportation Survey
Acknowledge by :
Ir. Tri Tjahjono, M.Sc., Ph.D. (FTUI, 1981; Leeds University, 1987, 2004)
Ir. Ellen Sophie Tangkudung, M.S. (FTUI, 1982; ITB, 1992)
Ir. Alan Marino, M.Sc. (FTUI, 1984; Wisconsin Madison University, 1989)
Ir. Heddy R. Agah, M.Eng (FTUI, 1978; Asian Institute of Technology, 1984)
Ir. Alvinsyah, MSCE. (FTUI, 1986; University of Michigan, 1990)
Foreword
This book is guidance for both bachelor (transportation engineering) and master (traffic
engineering) degree student in the process to learn a study related to transportation science. This book
explains to collect and process data also analysis process needed for particular studies
All of these modules are still far from perfection. Any improvement and evaluation will always
do for the completion of the book. Furthermore, any suggestion and criticisms are still expected from
readers and users of this manual therefore that authors can always improve this book
NIP 195611221983031001
The Need for Traffic and Parking Surveys
The results of traffic surveys are used in traffic planning, traffic management, economics
studies, traffic and environmental control, road-safety studies, land use transport interaction
studies, and in monitoring trends (i.e. in vehicle design and use) for establishing and revising
design standards and systems models. In addition, surveys of vehicle parking accumulation
form necessary inputs for traffic generation and impact studies.
Traffic engineers need information about traffic for many purposes as they plan, design,
construct and operate traffic systems. Estimates are required of the likely impacts of changes.
The techniques for making such estimates are based on a range of theories and models which
need to be tested against observations of behaviour in real-world traffic systems. Thus the
purposes for which traffic data is required may be summarised as (Young, Taylor, and Gipps
1989):
Monitoring. The collection of information about the traffic conditions prevailing at any
time, and as they change over time.
Forecasting. The use of data on existing traffic systems as one of the inputs to a
procedure for estimating what the traffic would be like under different conditions, either
now or in the future
Calibration. The use of traffic data to estimate the values for one or more parameters
in a theoretical or simulation model
Validation. The verification of a theoretical or simulation model against information
independent of that used to calibrate the model
The first two items are primarily the concern of practitioners, whereas the last three items lie
more in the area of interest of researchers, traffic theorist, and model developers.
Information sought in traffic and parking can vary enormously. Information collected may
include:
Travel Time
Parking Study
Traffic Queuing
Trip Rate
Transportation
Engineering
Module 1
Spot Speed (Manual Method)
Objective
Determine the spot speed of particular road segment and develop a cumulative speed distribution
curve
Literature Review
Time Mean Speed : Arithmetic average speed of vehicles passing a point on a highway
Space Mean Speed : Harmonic average speed of vehicles passing a point on a highway
Free Flow Speed : Theoretical speed when the density and flow rate on the study segment are
both zero
Equipment
1. Measuring Tape
2. Stopwatch
3. Survey Form
4. Stationary
Data Requirement
Procedures
Determine the location of the survey and measure and measure the length of the road that will
be used as survey road segment
Convert all the data into appropriate required data (s into km/h)
Where:
𝑉 = spot speed (km/h)
𝐷 = the trap length (meter)
𝑇 = the travel time of each vehicle which is pass the trap length (second)
Make a frequency distribution table to determine speed percentiles
15 1 1 1%
18 2 3 3%
21 6 9 9%
24 12 21 21%
27 13 34 34%
50th
30 20 54 54%
33 18 72 72%
85th
36 14 86 86%
39 6 92 92%
42 6 98 98%
45 1 99 99%
48 1 100 100%
Determine the 50th and 85th percentile speed from the cumulative percent column
i.n
- Fk
Pi = Li + [ 100 ] c
f
Where:
Pi = Percentile-i
Li = Lower limit
n = Number of data
Fk = Cumulative frequency
f = Frequency
c = Range of class
Future Readings
CTRE. 2009. Traffic Studies Module 2: Spot Speed. Iowa State University. Institute for
Transportation
Link : http://www.ctre.iastate.edu/pubs/traffichandbook/2SpotSpeed.pdf (last accessed
L 24 Augsut 2015)
MassSAFE 2005. Spot Speed Study Workshop Instruction Manual. University of
Massachusetts, Amberst.
Link : http://bit.ly/massSAFEspotspeed (last accessed : 24 August 2015)
Roess, R. 2011. Traffic Engineering 4th Edition. New York. United States
Khisty, J; Mohammadi, J. 2012. Systems Engineering with Economics, Probability, and
Statistics 2nd Edition. Fort Lauderdale. J.Ross Publishing
WORKSHEET 1
Date :
Locations :
Duration :
Determine the spot speed of particular point of road segment and develop a cumulative speed
distribution curve
Time Mean Speed : Arithmetic average speed of vehicles passing a point on a highway
Space Mean Speed : Harmonic average speed of vehicles passing a point on a highway
Free Flow Speed : Theoretical speed when the density and flow rate on the study segment are
both zero
Equipment
Procedures
Determine the location of the survey and determine the spot to shoot the vehicles
Stay in such a good position so that can see the upcoming vehicles clearly
Press the speed gun as the vehicles pass by to determine the speed of the vehicles
Write down the data collection in the worksheet
Data Processing
15 1 1 1%
18 2 3 3%
21 6 9 9%
24 12 21 21%
27 13 34 34%
50th
30 20 54 54%
33 18 72 72%
85th
36 14 86 86%
39 6 92 92%
42 6 98 98%
45 1 99 99%
48 1 100 100%
Determine the 50th and 85th percentile speed from the cumulative percent column
i.n
- Fk
Pi = Li + [ 100 ] c
f
Where:
Pi = Percentile-i
Li = Lower limit
n = Number of data
Fk = Cumulative frequency
f = Frequency
c = Range of class
Future Readings
CTRE. 2009. Traffic Studies Module 2: Spot Speed. Iowa State University. Institute for
Transportation
Link : http://www.ctre.iastate.edu/pubs/traffichandbook/2SpotSpeed.pdf (last accessed
: 24 Augsut 2015)
MassSAFE 2005. Spot Speed Study Workshop Instruction Manual. University of
Massachusetts, Amberst.
Link : http://bit.ly/massSAFEspotspeed (last accessed : 24 August 2015)
Roess, R. 2011. Traffic Engineering 4th Edition. New York. United States
Khisty, J; Mohammadi, J. 2012. Systems Engineering with Economics, Probability, and
Statistics 2nd Edition. Fort Lauderdale. J.Ross Publishing
WORKSHEET 1
Date :
Locations :
Duration :
Determine the capacity and the performance (Level of Service) of particular road segment based on
Highway Capacity Manual 2010
Literature Review
Flow (q) is the number of vehicles passing a fixed point per unit time. Typical units for 1 are veh/hour
Density (k) or concentration is the distance travelled by a vehicle per length of lane or roadway at a
given instant of time (veh/km)
Speed (u) or velocity is the distance travelled by a vehicle per unit time
Headway (h) is the time gap between successive vehicles in a traffic stream
Spacing (s)
Occupancy
Level of Service (LOS) expresses the performance of a highways facilities at traffic volume less than
capacity. LOS is used to analyse highway and intersection by categorizing traffic flow and assigning
quality levels of traffic based on performance measure like speed, density, and congestion.
Level of Service A : the highest quality of service that can be achieved. Motorists are able to travel
at their desired speed. The need for passing other vehicles is well below the
capacity for passing and few platoons of three or more cars are observed. 40%
Level of Service B : at this level of service, if vehicles are to maintain desired speeds, the demand
for passing other vehicles increases significantly. At the lower level of LOS B
range, the passing demand and passing capacity are approximately equal. 40-
55%
Level of Service C : further increases in flow beyond the LOS B range results in a noticeable
increase in the formation of platoons and an increase in platoon size. Passing
opportunities are severely decreased. 55-70%
Level of Service D : flow is unstable and passing manoeuvres are difficult, if not impossible, to
complete. Since the number of passing opportunities is approaching zero as
passing desires increase, each lane operates essentially independently of the
opposing lane. It is uncommon that platoons will form that are 5 to 10 consecutive
vehicles in length. 70-85%
Level of Service E : passing has become virtually impossible. Platoons are longer and more
frequent as slower vehicles are encountered more often. Operating condition are
unstable and are difficult to predict, 85-100%
Level of Service F : traffic is congested with demand exceeding capacity. Volumes are lower than
capacity and speeds are variable.
Peak Hour Factor is used to convert the hourly volume into the volume rate representing the busiest
15 minutes of the hour. Highway Capacity Manual (HCM) recommends a PHF of 0.88 for rural areas
and 0.92 for urban areas (Tarko, 2005)
Average flow rate
PHF =
4 x peak 15 minutes flow rate
Equipment
1. Counter
2. Survey Form
3. Stopwatch
4. Stationary
5. Measuring Tape
Data Requirement
Determine the location of the survey and determine the spot to count the upcoming vehicles
Stay in such a good position so that can see the upcoming vehicles clearly
Count or record every passing vehicle based on vehicles classification (motorcycle, passenger
car, heavy vehicles)
Do the counting process until the specified duration (15 or 30 minutes)
Data Processing
Where,
FFS = FFS of basic freeway segment (mi/h)
fLW = adjustment for lane width (mi/h)
fLC = adjustment for left-side lateral clearance (mi/h)
TRD = total ramp density
Select FFS curve based on the FFS calculation before (exhibit 11-3)
Adjust demand volume by consider adjustment factor for heavy vehicles
Where,
vp = demand flow rate under equivalent base conditions (pc/h/ln)
V = demand volume under prevailing conditions (ve/h)
PHF = peak hour factor
N = number of lanes in analysis direction
fHV = adjustment factor for presence of heavy vehicles in traffic stream
fp = adjustment factor for unfamiliar driver population
Where,
fHV = heavy-vehicle adjustment factor
Pt = proportion of trucks and buses in traffic stream
PR = proportion of RV in traffic stream
Et = passenger-car equivalent (PCE) of one truck or bus in traffic stream
Er = PCE of one RV in traffic stream
Estimate speed and density
D = Density (pc/mi/ln)
vp = demand flow rate (pc/h/ln)
S = mean speed of traffic stream under based conditions (mi/h)
Determine LoS
Future Readings
CTRE. 2009. Traffic Studies Module 3: Traffic Volume Count. Iowa State University. Institute
for Transportation
Link : www.ctre.iastate.edu/pubs/traffichandbook/3trafficcounts.pdf (last accessed: 24 August
2015)
Leduc, Guillaume. 2008. Road Traffic Data: Collection Methods and Applications. European
Commission. Joint Research Centre – Institute for Prospective Technological Studies
Link: ftp.jrc.es/EURdoc/JRC47967.TN.pdf (last accessed: 24 August 2015)
Transportation Research Board. 2010. Highway Capacity Manual Volume 2 : Uninterrupted
Flow. TRB. Washington DC
Garber, Nicholas; Hoel, Lester. 2009. Traffic & Highway engineering 4 th Edition. Virginia.
Cengage Learning
WORKSHEET 2
TRAFFIC COUNTING
Time :
Date/Month/Year :
Weather :
From :
To :
Location :
Surveyor :
Passenger Public
15 Small Bus (Elf,
Time Car, Jeep, Transportation, Big Buses Truck (2 as) Truck (3 as) Motorcycle Unmotorized
mins Colt, L-300)
Pick up Minibus
1st
2nd
3rd
4th
5th
6th
Total
Module 4
Traffic Counting (Manual Kapasitas Jalan Indonesia)
Objective
Determine the capacity and the performance (Level of Service) of particular road segment based on
Manual Kapasitas Jalan Indonesia (MKJI) 1997
Equipment
1. Counter
2. Survey Form
3. Stopwatch
4. Stationary
5. Measuring Tape
Data Requirement
The selection of study method should be determined using the count period. The count period should
avoid special event or compromising weather condition. Count period may range from 5 minutes to 1
year. Typical count periods are 15 minutes or 2 hours for peak periods.
Average Daily Traffic (ADT) counts represent a 24-hour count at any specified location. These counts
are obtained by placing an automatic counter at the analysis location for a 24-hour period. Accuracy
of the ADT data depends on the count being performed during typical roadway, weather, and traffic
demand conditions. Local levels of government will typically conduct this type of count.
Annual Average Daily Traffic (AADT) counts represent the average 24-hour traffic volume at a given
location averaged over a full 365-day year. AADT volume counts have the following uses:
Measuring or evaluating the present demand for service by the roadway or facility
Developing the major or arterial roadway system
Locating areas where new facilities or improvements to existing facilities are needed
Programming capital improvements
Procedures
Determine the location of the survey and determine the spot to count the upcoming vehicles
Stay in such a good position so that can see the upcoming vehicles clearly
Count or record every passing vehicle based on vehicles classification (motorcycle, passenger
car, heavy vehicles)
Do the counting process until the specified duration (15 or 30 minutes)
Data Processing
Classify vehicles into 3 group (Light Vehicles, Heavy Vehicles, and Motorcycle)
Count the number of vehicle based on the result of the survey
Count the traffic flow (Q) and the capacity (C)
Q = QLV + (QHV x pceHV) + (QMC x pceMC)
C = Co x FCW x FCSP x FCSF x FCCS
Where,
C = Capacity (pcph)
Co = base capacity (pcph)
FCW = Adjustment factor for wide road
FCSP = Adjustment factor for separation direction (only for undivided roads)
FCSF = Adjustment factor for side barriers and roadside
FCCS = Adjustment factor for city size
Determine degree of saturation (DS)
DS = Q/C
Determine the Level of Service (LoS0 of the road
Compare the result with LoS from previous survey
Future Readings
CTRE. 2009. Traffic Studies Module 3: Traffic Volume Count. Iowa State University. Institute
for Transportation
Link : www.ctre.iastate.edu/pubs/traffichandbook/3trafficcounts.pdf (last accessed: 24 August
2015)
Leduc, Guillaume. 2008. Road Traffic Data: Collection Methods and Applications. European
Commission. Joint Research Centre – Institute for Prospective Technological Studies
Link: ftp.jrc.es/EURdoc/JRC47967.TN.pdf (last accessed: 24 August 2015)
SWEROAD and PT Bina Marga. 1997. Manual Kapasitas Jalan Indonesia. Jakarta. Direktorat
Jenderal Bina Marga
WORKSHEET 2
TRAFFIC COUNTING
Time :
Date/Month/Year :
Weather :
From :
To :
Location :
Surveyor :
Passenger Public
15 Small Bus (Elf,
Time Car, Jeep, Transportation, Big Buses Truck (2 as) Truck (3 as) Motorcycle Unmotorized
mins Colt, L-300)
Pick up Minibus
1st
2nd
3rd
4th
5th
6th
Total
Module 5
Travel Time
Objective
To evaluate the traffic movement quality or characteristics along a route and to determine the location
type, and length of traffic
Literature Review
Floating Car Method : Floating car data are position of vehicles traversing city streets throughout
the day. The driver tries to float in the traffic stream. The number of vehicle
that observer vehicles overtake should be as many vehicle that pass the
observer vehicles.
Average Speed Method : In this method the driver is instructed to travel at the average speed of the
majority of the vehicles in the traffic stream regardless of the number of the
vehicles.
Moving-vehicle Method : In this method, the observer moves in the traffic stream and make round trip
on the test section. The observer starts from particular direction i.e. west to
east and turn the vehicle around in the opposite direction. (This method is
used for the module)
Maximum-car Method : the driver is instructed to drive at the maximum speed that still in the range
of design speed of the facility.
Elev-Observe Method : the observer choose high buildings or other elevated points that
considerable length may be observed. The observer select random vehicles
and record necessary data i.e. time or cause-of delay
License Plate Method : Observer stationed at control point along the route enters, on a time control
basis, the license-plate numbers of passing vehicles recorded. On the end of
the route, another observer stationed to record the license-plate numbers of
passing vehicles. At the end of observation. Both of the observer match the
recorded data to obtain the travel time between to point
Photographic Method : This method is primarily a research tool for studies of interrelationship of
several factors such as spacing, speeds, lane usage, acceleration rates,
merging, and crossing manoeuvres, and delays at intersections.
Interview Method : This method may be useful where a large amount of material is needed in a
minimum of time and at little expense for field observation. Usually the
employees of a farm or establishment are asked to record their travel time to
and from work on a particular day
Travel Time : total time to pass particular road segment (including running time, stopped
time and delay)
Running Time : Part of Travel Time which means total time when a vehicle move
Travel Time Delay : Differences time between travel and running time
Running Speed : Mean speed on particular road segment that include delay time (=
distance/running time)
Equipment
1. Test Vehicles
2. Stopwatch
3. Survey Form
4. Stationery
Data Requirement
Procedures
Marked the start and end point of the road that observed
Activate the stopwatch to record the travel time
Write and record for every check point in accordance with operational criteria
Record the duration of the stop using stopwatch, the location, time, and the reason of obstacles
See and count the vehicles that pass (P), oppose (M), and Overtake (O)
Switch off the stopwatch and write down the total travel time from starting point to end point
Data Processing
Future Readings
Roess, R. 2011. Traffic Engineering 4th Edition. New York. United States
To evaluate the characteristics of an existing parking area to determine the demand and supply of the
parking area
Literature Review
Parking Index
Parking Turnover
In-out Survey
Equipment
1. Stopwatch
2. Survey Form
3. Stationary
Data Requirement
Data Processing
Where,
TR = Parking Turnover (veh/slot/hr)
Nt = Number of total vehicles during survey period (veh)
S = Number of parking slot
Ts = Duration of analysis/survey (hr)
Category Example
Low Turnover All-day parking
Medium Turnover Parking duration between 2-12 hours
(apartment and hotel)
High Turnover Short term parking duration (Department
Store)
Future Readings
Iitb.vlab.co.in. 2011. Parking Analysis. NME ICT Initiative of MHRD (Licensing Terms)
Link : iitb.vlab.co.in/?sub=42&brch=132&sim=466&cnt=1 (last accessed: 24 August 2015)
Abubakar, I. 1998. Pedoman Perencanaan dan pengoperasian Fasilitas Parkir. Jakarta.
Direktorat Bina Sistem Lalu Lintas dan Angkutan Kota Direktorat Jenderal Perhubungan
Oppenlander, J; Box. P. 1976. Manual of Traffic Engineering Studies 4 th Edition. Washington
DC. Institute of Transportation Engneering Washington DC
WORKSHEET 4
PARKING STUDY
Date :
Day :
Starting Time :
Location :
To evaluate the traffic movement quality along a route and to determine the location type, and length
of traffic
Literature Review
Definition
Module 9
Traffic Signal Phase
Objective
Literature Review
There are three types of traffic signal controllers: pre timed, fully actuated, and semi actuated. Many
signalized intersection in Indonesia using pre timed controllers which have a preset sequence of phases
displayed in repetitive order. Each phase has a fixed green time and change interval that are repeated
in each cycle to produce a constant cycle length. The most critical aspect of setting of signal timing
selection of an appropriate phase plan. Determination of the cycle time can be made by the Webster
method (1996) to minimize the total delay on an intersection, using the formula
After determining the cycle time, it can be determined effective green time. Because the allocation of
green time is an important for the estimation of delay. Effective green time is the time during which a
given traffic movement or set of movements may proceed at saturation flow rate; it is equal to the cycle
length minus the effective red time.
The graphic above illustrates effective green time. Effective green time excludes start-up delay that
occurs at the beginning of the phase as well as any lost time that might occur near the end of the phase.
Equipment
1. Stopwatch
2. Work Sheet
3. Stationary
Data Requirement
Procedure
Data Processing
Calculate the cycle time before adjustments, using the following formula
To determine the length of queue at the signalized intersection when the beginning of the green time
(signal) and also to determine the average vehicle stops, include the vehicle that repeated stop in the
queue
Literature Review
A queue of vehicles is a disorder that occurs regularly due to signals or traffic lights at the intersection
or in the other words, a queue is the number of vehicles that waiting at an intersection that expressed
in vehicle (veh) or units of passenger cars (pcu).
Distributions
Service Method:
Equipment
1. Traverse Tapes
2. Measuring Tape/Digital Roller
3. Hand Counter
4. Stopwatch
Data Requirement
Procedures
Measuring the intersection geometric data by using a transverse tape
Counting the green time and the cycle time for each traffic light by using a stopwatch
Counting the traffic flow for each arm of the intersection by using a counter
Queue length data is got by measuring length of the vehicle that queuing at the end of green
time and red time with digital roller, then make a mark so the observer can see the mark clearly
Data Processing
Capacity (C)
C = S x g/c
Where:
C = Capacity of lane group (pcu/hour)
S = Saturation flow rate for lane group (pcu/hour)
g/c = Effective green ratio for lane group
Degree of Saturation (DS)
DS = Q/C
Where:
Q = traffic flow (pcu/hour)
C = Capacity (pcu/hour)
Total of passenger cars from previous green signal (NQ1)
If DS > 0.5
8 x (DS - 0.5)
NQ1 = 0.25 x C x [(DS – 1) + √(DS - 1)2+ ]
C
If DS < 0.5
NQ1 = 0
Total of passenger car which came during the red signal (NQ2)
Total vehicle Queuing
Queuing Length (QL)
Module 11
Trip Rate
Objective
To determine the model of relation between land use and arrival or departure to or from an area/zone.
Literature Review
In evaluating the travel characteristics of a development, two terms that should be understood are trip generation
and trip rates. Trip generation refers to the trips which enter and leave a particular development while trip rates
refers to the intensity of travel due to the development which can either be defined by the number of trips in
comparison to the size of the development or by the number of trips for a particular time period. Transport
generated trips are divided into two types: trip production and trip attraction which can be seen on Figure 1. The
selection of a trip rate is important in estimating the travel generation of a site. Various factors that need to be
taken into account in selecting a rate for the size of the development are the following: the propensity to walk or
cycle; the type, quality and frequency of public transportation; the level of on-site parking restraint; whether there
are parking controls in the vicinity of the scheme; the potential for linked trip opportunities; and for retail sites,
the competition within the locality.
In order to be able to use the linear regression method, the independent variables or the data required include
following:
Equipment
1. Stopwatch
2. Survey Form
3. Stationary
Data Required
Procedure
Data Processing