Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Vinay Kumbhar
Vinay S K 1
INTRODUCTION OF FACULTY
Name : Vinay S. K.
More than 10 years Experience in Automotive Industry,
Home appliances and Quality Management systems.
Areas of Work : ISO 9001, TS 16949, ISO 17025 (NABL), and
Core tools
(Manufacturing Industry, Calibration Lab, Consultancy
Service
Email – vinayskumbhar@gmail.com
Vinay S K 2
1
Measurement System Analysis
Vinay S K 3
OBJECTIVE
To provide
Vinay S K 4
2
Measurement System Analysis
Today’s Agenda
Brief Changes and overview of 4th edition.
Objectives
Introduction
Graphical Analysis
Vinay S K 5
Analysis of Results
3
Measurement System Analysis
Vinay S K 7
Vinay S K 8
4
Measurement System Analysis
Vinay S K 9
– use when sufficient samples to represent the process are not available and
an existing process with similar process variation is not available or the
new process is expected to have less variability than an existing process
Vinay S K 10
5
Measurement System Analysis
In the Plan and Define Program stage the team is to identify preliminary special
product and process characteristics.
The organization’s product quality planning team should build on this listing and
reach consensus through the evaluation of the technical information.
– the drawings
– Engineering specifications
Vinay S K 11
Vinay S K 12
6
Measurement System Analysis
– Understand which traceable standard are appropriate for the required testing
– The required frequency that the standards are to be used to assess the accuracy
of the measurement system
Vinay S K 13
The gauging must be used on the prototype build. An early gage study can be
performed. While the full range of process variation will probable not be
represented, as preliminary study can be performed.
The gage can be verified at the prototype stage to ensure that the required
features are being correctly measured. This will help eliminate late changes to
the gauging method.
Vinay S K 14
7
Measurement System Analysis
Introduction
A decision to adjust a manufacturing process not is commonly based on
measurement data. Measurement data are also used in analytical studies to know
the relation between two or more variables, which in turn will lead to a better
understanding of process.
Benefit of using measurement data will depend on the Quality of data. Much of the
variations in a set of measurements is due to the interaction between the
measurement system and its environment .If the interaction generates too much of
the variations then the quality of the data may be so low that the data are not
useful.
If the Quality of the data is not acceptable, then it must be improved. This is usually
accomplished by improving the measurement system, rather than by improving the
data themselves.
Vinay S K 15
After measuring the part one of the action that can be taken to determine
the status of the part.
Eg,, some times good parts will be called as bad parts – Producers risk –
Eg
false alarm
Some times bad parts will be called as good part – Customer’s risk -
Miss rate.
Vinay S K 16
8
Measurement System Analysis
Introduction…
Variation :
It is the difference between two things or an entity .
Total variation :
Vinay S K 17
Introduction
Variation due
to Interaction
Total
Variation Appraiser
Variation
Equipment
Part to MSV
Within Part Variation
Part
Variation Variation
Always Measurement System variation must be
smaller than manufacturing process variation
Vinay S K 18
9
Measurement System Analysis
Selection of Instruments
Vinay S K 19
Vinay S K 20
10
Measurement System Analysis
BIAS – WHAT IT IS ?
Ref.
Value BIAS= X bar - Ref.Value
X bar
Vinay S K 21
BIAS - STEPS
1. Capture reference value
• Use masters calibrated- traceable to
standards
• Measure by better instrument than the
instrument being measured
• By Layout inspection
Vinay S K 22
11
Measurement System Analysis
BIAS - STEPS
3. Calculate BIAS for individual reading
Vinay S K 23
ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA
Vinay S K 24
12
Measurement System Analysis
Bias :
Difference between observed average of measurements
and reference value
Vinay S K 25
Bias =
Vinay S K 26
13
Measurement System Analysis
Vinay S K 28
CONCLUSION: As observed t-static is between upper & lower limits our Bias Study is acceptable.
However observed t-static is not exactly in the middle or very near to mid value some action has to
be initiated before next study is due.
Vinay S K 29
14
Measurement System Analysis
Vinay S K 30
LINEARITY
X bar X bar 31
Vinay S K
15
Measurement System Analysis
Linearity - Steps
Vinay S K 32
Linearity – Steps
Vinay S K 33
16
Measurement System Analysis
0
Lower t limits
- VE
Is this MS acceptable ?
Vinay S K 34
Date:
Instrument under study:-
Part 1 2 3 4 5
Ref val
1
2
T 3
R 4
I
A 5
L 6
S
7
8
9
10
11
12
Observed Avg
Bias
Vinay S K 35
17
Measurement System Analysis
Vinay S K 36
T1
T2
T3
Vinay S K 37
18
Measurement System Analysis
Stability :
Stability (or drift) is the total variation in the measurements obtained with a measurement
system on the same master or parts when measuring a single characteristic over an
extended time period.
Make this part as a master part and ensure that the part is preserved till the study is
completed.
Decide the subgroup size (3 to 5), no. Of subgroup (20) & frequency (every day) of data
collection.
As per the frequency, measure the master part 3 to 5 times and record the details in
the Xbar-R chart.
After completion of data collection, calculate each subgroup avg and range.
Vinay S K 38
Calculate the upper control limit & lower control limit for range ( R ).
Calculate the upper control limit & lower control limit for X double bar.
After calculating the 't' value compared that value with 't' distribution
table value.
Vinay S K 39
19
Measurement System Analysis
Stability -example
Vinay S K 40
Vinay S K 41
20
Measurement System Analysis
Procedure for Gage R&R study:
Identify the measurement system for which R&R study to be conducted.
Select the instrument and ensure the instrument is calibrated and is within
the acceptance criteria.
Identify the location on the part where the measurement has to be done
repeatedly.
Calculate AV, EV, PV, R&R & TV as per the data sheet and calculation sheet.
Vinay S K 42
Vinay S K 43
21
Measurement System Analysis
Graphical Analysis :
It is used to analyze the results of a measurement system. It provides
insight in to the variation model and inter- relationship.
-Average Chart
Since the group of parts used in the study represents the process
variation. Approximately one half or more of the averages should fall
outside the control limits.
- If less than half falls outside the control limits then measurement
system lacks adequate effective resolution or the sample does not
represent the expected process variation.
Vinay S K 44
Graphical Analysis
-Range Chart
if all ranges are within control all appraisers are doing the same
job.
Vinay S K 45
22
Measurement System Analysis
An Attribute Gage :
Compares each part to a specific set of limits and accepts the
part if the limits are satisfied.( It detects the Nonconforming
parts)
Is designed to accept / reject a set of master parts
Cannot indicate how good or bad a part is, only whether the
part is accepted or rejected ( Pass/Fail )
Vinay S K 46
Vinay S K 47
23
Measurement System Analysis
Procedure ( Contd…)
• After completion of collecting the data calculate the probability of
miss and probability of false alarm.
• Based on the probability of miss and false alarm, obtain the bias (miss)
and bias (false alarm) from the table.
• Calculate the effectiveness and bias factor as per the calculation
sheet.
• Interpret the effectiveness results as defined below.
Eff is > 0.9 - M.S is effective.
Eff is betwn 0.7 – 0.9 - M.S is acceptable under Concession
based on the importance, cost of
repair, etc..
Eff is < 0.7 - M.S is not effective.
Vinay S K 48
SL. Master
Appraiser and trails
NO status
I II III IV V
1 2 3 1 2 3 1 2 3 1 2 3 1 2 3
Vinay S K 49
24
Measurement System Analysis
10 Effectiveness (E) = N GD / N X n
11 * Conclusion
* Refer table
Vinay S K 50
Vinay S K 51
25
Measurement System Analysis
Vinay S K 52
0.33 0.3621
0.34 0.3668
0.35 0.3712
Constants for evaluating attribute data
0.36 0.3739
0.37 0.3778
0.38 0.3814
0.39 0.3836
0.40 0.3867
0.41 0.3885
0.42 0.3910
0.43 0.3925
0.44 0.3945
0.45 0.3961
0.46 0.3970
0.47 0.3977
0.48 0.3984
0.49 0.3989
0.50 0.3989
Vinay S K 53
26
Measurement System Analysis
Vinay S K 54
Conclusion :
Vinay S K 55
27
Measurement System Analysis
Any
QUESTIONS ???
Vinay S K 56
Thank You !
Vinay S K 57
28