Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
, 3 6 0 - 3 7 0 (1966)
The solubility of CO2, CH4, A, and N~ in oriented and unoriented polystyrene films
at 25°C. has been investigated by the direct sorption method. It has been found that
Henry's law does not apply to sorption of CO~ and CHt4.The results can be quantita-
tively described by the postulation of two concurrent mechanisms for sorption: or-
dinary dissolution and mierovoid-filling.
The dissolution constants are correlated with the gas force constants, e/k. The
abnormally high solubility of CI-I~is probably due to the high polarizability of this
gas. The hole-affinity constants are also correlated with E/k. The deviation of CI-I~is
consistent with the behavior of the dissolution constant. The correlation of hole-fill-
ing constants with surface areas occupied by the individual gas molecules has been
successful.
Stress-induced orientation of polystyrene does not change the nature of the sorption
processes; however, it decreases the level of solubility. Orientation decreases the hole-
filling constants and the Henry's law solubility constants whereas it slightly increases
the hole-affinity constants.
phase and a distinct crystalline phase, the referred to as the "dual mode" sorption
amorphous phase being continuous, quasi- model.
liquid, and permeable to gas, and the crys- Recent work by Michaels, Vieth, and
talline phase being dispersed and imperme- others (7, 8) with polyethylene terephthalate
able. has contributed to the understanding of the
In certain respects, the molecular model glassy state and to the formulation of a
for sorption in rubbery crystalline poly- molecular model for sorption in glassy
ethylene has been found applicable to glassy polymers. It was found that C02 shows
polymers. One main difference is the postu- deviations from Henry's law in glassy
lation of the existence of "holes," as a stable amorphous polyethylene terephthalate below
phase in the polymer below its glass transi- 1.0 arm. The sorption data at high pressures
tion. However, a satisfactory model for with CO2 are well described by the dual
sorption in the glassy state has been pro- mechanisms of sorption. In addition, the
posed by Meares (4). In this model it is decrease in solubility accompanying crystal-
assumed that, at constant temperature and lization is smaller than the corresponding
pressure, the free energy of the polymer reduction in amorphous volume fraction.
depends on its volume through two micro- With the concept of holes, this can be ex-
seopic variables: the interehaln distance in plained because the crystallization process
closely packed regions and the number and leaves a higher volume concentration of
size of holes present. Above the glass transi- microvoids (per unit volume of amorphous
tion temperature, the two mentioned varia- phase) than that present in the completely
bles are continually adjusted to represent amorphous polymer. With the exception of
the minimum free energy. Below the glass He, the heat of sorption is more exothermic
transition temperature, one degree of too- in glassy polyethylene terephthalate than in
bility, segmental rotation, is lost, immobiliz- rubbery polyethylene terephthalate and it
ing the holes in the polymer matrix. becomes more negative with increasing e/k.
Meares (4) has found that the heats of The solubility constants correlate well with
sorption of N2, Ne, A, and O2 in polyvinyl
acetate below its Tg are negative. The exo- The effects of chain orientation have also
thermic heats observed are attributed to the been investigated (8). The sorption mech-
dispersion interactions between gas mole- anism is similar in oriented and unoriented
cules and the polymer as the dissolved gas is polyethylene terephthalate, but the solu-
sorbed into holes. Barter (t0) has also ob- bility of gas is higher in the oriented film.
served highly exothermic heats of sorption An analysis of the sorpfion data gives higher
of organic vapors in ethyl cellulose. In addi-Henry's law solubility constants, higher
tion, the isotherms obtained show the char- hole-filling constants, and higher hole a~nity
aeteristie curvature of the Langmuir iso- constants in the oriented polyethylene
therm. From these pieces of evidence, terephthalate film. However, the marked
Barrer originally postulated two concurrent increase in solubility in the thinnest oriented
sorption mechanisms: ordinary dissolution film cannot be accounted for by the effects
and hole-filling. Thus, Eq. [3] has been of orientation alone. Different thermal his-
proposed (7, 8) to describe quantitatively tory in the film preparation has been ad-
the solubility of gas in glassy polymers. vanced as a possible explanation.
A useful result of this work is the develop-
C'nb P ment of supplementary evidence supporting
C= C~+C~=]c~P+-- [31
1 "~bP" the existence of stable mierovoids in the
Ordinary dissolution CD is represented by glassy state. In addition, the work has dem-
the Henry's law term and the sorption of onstrated the applicability of the dual
gas into holes, CH, is represented by the mechanisms of sorption to explain the effects
nonlinear Langmuir expression where C'~r of crystallization and orientation on sorption
is the hole-filling constant and b is the hole behavior in a glassy polymer. The successful
al~nity constant. This may be conveniently use of this concept with polyethylene ter-
362 VIETH, TAM, AND MICHAELS
PRESSURE GAUGE
\
TO G~S 'CYLINDER
:RMOMETE;
L,~ RECORDER
MCLEOD GAUGE
TO PUMP
THERMONITOR
CONSTANT - TEMPERATURE BATH
SAMPLE BOMB
Fro. 1. Schematic diagram of the sorptiorl apparatus.
ephthalate motivates further study of this glass plates with a 20 mil casting bar. The
model for sorption. The present investiga- cast film is air-dried and removed from the
tion seeks to establish whether this concept glass plate under a jet of cold water. To re-
applies equally well to polystyrene, a well- move the strain and residual orientation, the
characterized amorphous polymer. With the film is annealed at 110°C. for 15 minutes.
available information on polyethylene ter- The average film thickness is 5.2 mil, and
ephthalate, a comparison of the solubility the density 1.0474 g./e.c.
behavior of polystyrene and polyethylene The following gases were used in this
terephthalate may also be obtained and the study: N2, A, CH4, and C02. The mini-
effects of orientation on their microstructures mum purity for all gases is 99.99 %. No
may be illustrated. attempt was made to further purify the
gases before use.
EXPERIMENTAL
~ z ~ / ~ z ~--
-- ~O / CH4 ~ J
- /
A _~
Lx N _
=~--I I I t I [ I I
0 5 ]O 15 20
PRESSURE (ATm)
pressure of the equilibrated system until an the isotherms at higher pressures and be-
equilibrium pressure of about 20 arm. is cloud rather than clarify the picture. Despite
attained. The amount of gas sorbed in the these restrictions, it was found that the
fihn sample at each equilibrium pressure is isotherms of CO2 and CIt4, in both oriented
determined from the initial and final pres- and unoriented polystyrene films at 25°C.
sures and temperatures. (Figs. 2, 3, 5), exhibited definite deviations
from Henry's law. Although the isotherms
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION for N2 and A did not display marked curva-
GENERAL CONSIDERATIONS tin'e, they too were analyzed according to
the dual-mode sorption model, and all the
The scope of data was restricted, in a results were compared with theoretical pre-
practical sense, by two factors: (a) Diffusion
dictions, as will be described later.
constants of molecules with higher force
The first step in analyzing the results
constants, such as ethane or propane, are requires the determination of the constants
very low and would have resulted in sorp- for sorption in Eq. [3] for each gas-poly-
tion equilibration times of weeks to months
styrene system.
with polymer film specimens which can be
The slope of the linear portion of the iso-
regarded as homogeneous, e.g., 1 rail or
therm in the high-pressure region is equal
thicker films. Thus, although it would have to k . . By subtracting k~P from the total
been desirable to obtain sorption isotherms
solubility C, the hole-filling contribution
for ethane or propane to seek still more
C~ is determined for each pressure.
obvious evidence of isotherm curvature, it
was not possible to accomplish this within a CP~bp
C. - [4]
reasonable period of time. (b) The upper l+bP'
limit on pressure with the current system is
about twenty atmospheres, which coincides OF
~° 1 I I r i I I T I I,,.,I~
I Q A BIAXLA.LLY ORIENTED FILNI ~,..~'z~. - -
~E
-_ . -
- 1-"'/ .-o" ~
I r ; I i i I I I I I I -
0 I0 15 20
PRESSURE (Ai-rn)
~.o
E o /
~ 2.0
J
~ E N T'~D FIL~
hO
I0 15 ZO
PRESSURE (.A'l-rn )
FIG. 4. Langmuir plots for CO2 sorption by hole filling in polystyrene at 25°C.
(least-mean-squares) fit of the data or the tion of CO2 is responsible for its larger error
Langmuir plot is achieved, and the values than the error of CI-I~, owing to the un-
of kD, C%, and b so determined for each certainty in the measurement of initial pres-
gas-polymer system are presented in Table I. sure.
An analysis of the accuracy of the direct
sorption method indicates that the initial SOLUBILITY CONSTANTS
pressures are the main source of error. At the
95 % level of confidence, the following error The over-all solubility constant can be
approximated for very low pressures. At Iow
limits on solubility C are obtained: -4-8.1%
pressures, Eq. [3] reduces to Eq. [6].
for CO2, ±6.3% for CH4, ~i0.5% forA,
and -4-15 % for N2. The faster rate of sorp- C = kDP + C%bP; [6]
DUAL SORPTION MECHANISMS IN GLASSY POLYSTYRENE 365
I I I I I I I I I I I I I
z~z;:>
UNORIENTED F ~ ~
FED FLM
V'D ~_
I I r I I I I I
0 5 I0 15 20
PRESSURE (Atm)
ORIENTED FILN
°~ / ,©r
0 5 I0 15 20
PRESSURE (Atnn)
FIG. 6. L~ngmuir plots for CH4 sorption by hole filling in polystyrene at 25°C.
Thus, at low pressures, the over-all solu- Hence at high pressures, hole-filling becomes
bility constant K is made up of ]Ca and less important and ordinary dissolution is
C'Hb, which is usually much larger than the main sorption mechanism.
kD. Hence, at low pressures, hole-filling is The Lennard-Jones force constant E/k,
more important than ordinary dissolution. which measures the tendency of a gas to
At high pressures, Eq. [3] becomes: condense, would also be a measure of the
gas solubility. In fact, Jolley and Hilde-
C = kDP -t- C ' , ," [9] brand (9) have successfully correlated the
366 VIETtt, TAM, AND MICtIAELS
TABLE I
CONSTANTSFOR SORPTIONIN POLYSTYRENEAT 25°C.
e.c. STP )
Gas e/K (°K.) kD c.c. Polymer Attn. b(atm.-~)
Oriented Unoriented Oriented Unoriented Oriented Unoriented
i°
o."
.~c
J
-2
j
-3 /"
F l a . 7. Correlation of over-all solubility constants (data for PET from Michaels (7)).
L] /
I FIGURE 8 ,//
CORRELATION OF HENRY'S LAW SOLUBILITY CONSTANTS J
C Ddta ~or Benzene ~rom JolicLj & Hildebrand f 3 ) ) ~ ~
e
FIG. 8. Correlation of Henry's law solubility constants. (Data for PE from ]3ixler (2) ; data for ben-
zene from Jolley and Hildebrand (9).)
are reasonably narrow, considering the size Fig. 9. At the 95 % level of confidence for all
of the statistical sample, all correlation lines gases except CH4, the slopes of the correla-
agree with the theoretical line predicted by tion lines agree with the calculated slope of
Eq. [11] and parallel the lines for benzene, 0.026 i.e., 0.0252 ~ 4.7 % for the oriented film
polyethylene, and polyethylene terephtha- and 0.0255 =E 4.0 % for the unoriented film.
late. This again supports the validity of Eq. The higher affinity of CH4 in both oriented
[11] as applicable not only to organic liquids and unoriented film is consistent with the
but also to polymers in the rubbery and previously described behavior; i.e., the high
glassy states. specific CH4-polystyrene interaction due to
the apparently high polarizability of this
HOLE AFFINITY CONSTANTS gas.
The hole affinity constant b represents the The establishment of the exponentiM de-
ratio of rate constants of sorption and de- pendence of b on e/k explains the different
sorption of gas in holes. Qualitatively, the shapes of isotherms. For CO2 with high eric
amount of gas sorbed in holes should depend and thus high b, the characteristic curvature
on the specific gas-polystyrene interaction. of Langmuir adsorption occurs within a small
By a similar thermodynamic analysis, using range of pressure and the second portion of
the definition of the isosteric heat of sorp- the isotherm can be observed at about a
lion, a relationship between b and e/k can pressure of 10 arm. For N2 or A with low
be established as for the solubility constants e/k and thus very small b, the isotherm ap-
at 25°C. pears linear in the pressure range under
consideration and only starts to become non-
In b = O.026e/k + in 1 ~e z' [12] linear near the end of the range. Thus, the
second linear portion is not exhibited. How-
where O = C,/C'H is the fraction of surface ever, at higher pressures (> 20 arm.), the
area bounding the free volume occupied by deviations would be expected to become
gas molecules and I' is a system constant more obvious and the second linear portion
dependent on the choice of the reference exhibited. With this observation, it is very
state for the gas-polymer system. probable that the dual processes of sorption
The plots of b versus e/k are shown in in glassy polymers apply to M1 gases. How-
368 VIETH, TAM, AND MICHAELS
T~
E -I
-3
-4
-5 , i
50 I00 150 2_00 250
LENNARD-JONES FORCE CONSTANT, ~/k ( oK )
ever, it is more difficult to differentiate the as the plane of closest packing of liquid (15).
two mechanisms for low e/k gases than for Figure 10 shows the plots of C'n versus
high eric gases. 1 / A 2 for oriented and uno~iented polystyrene
films. The good agreement of the experi-
HOLE-FILLING CONSTANTS mental slopes with the theoretical prediction
The hole-filling constant C'~ represents (within 4-15% for the oriented film and
the saturation limit of gas which can be 4-8.5 % for the unoriented film, all at the
sorbed into holes. Experimental evidence 95 % level of confidence) gives support to the
tends to indicate that sorption by hole filling monolayer sorption mechanism, since this
is a monolayer process. The characteristic implies a constant value of S/, unchanging
shape of the isotherms and the behavior of with the type of sorbate. The calculated
heat of sorption bear many similarities to values in square meters per cubic centimeter
Langmuir adsorption. More convincingly, of polymer of Si are 32.5 for the unoriented
holes of the order of 10 A or smaller, as are film and 25.6 for the oriented film.
estimated for polystyrene (14), would pre-
vent accommodation of more than one layer EFFECTS OF ORIENTATION OF CHAINS ON
of gas molecules on the surface of holes. MICROSTRUCTURE OF POLYMERS
Additional evidence of this monolayer
The similar shapes of the isotherms in both
sorption process is supplied by the correla-
oriented and unoriented films indicate that
tions of hole-filling constants. Hole-filling
constants, C'n, are inversely proportional to orientation does not change the nature of
the surface areas occupied by the individual the sorption process. However, the changes
sorbate gas molecules according to Eq. [13]: in microstructure are reflected in the changes
in the levels of the sorption constants. Ori-
c ' . = [~T~Ss . ! [13] entation decreases the solubility of CO2 in
N.~P~ As ' polystyrene whereas, from previous work, it
where R is the gas constant; N~ the Avo- increases the solubility in polyethylene
gadro number; T~ and P~, the standard terephthalate (8).
temperature and pressure; Ss, the surface Considering COs as a typical gas, in both
bounding the free volume; and A 2 the area polymers the hole affinity constants, b, are
occupied by one sorbate gas molecule calcu- slightly higher in the oriented film, 0.40
lated on the assumption that the molecules versus 0.37 for polystyrene and 0.52 versus
adsorbed have the same hexagonal packing 0.44 for polyethylene terephthalate (7). This
DUAL SORPTTON MECHANISMS IN GLASSY POLYSTYRENE 369
~o I I I I [ I 1 I I I I I I I I I
~=: ~ FILM
CO 2 N2 A
5 I I I I I 1 1 1 r 1 1 I 1 1 1 r
5.0 5.5 6.0 6,5 7.0
A-zxlo ~8 (cr~2)
FIG. 10. Correlation of hole-filling constants with areas occupied by individual sorbed gas molecules.
seems reasonable because the strained ary effects of crystallization, are responsi-
amorphous regions bounding holes could ble for the higher kD/a in the oriented flm,
have a higher affinity for gas, especially if 0.65 versus 0.38 for the unoriented film (7).
the molecular details of the hole periphery For polystyrene, kD is smaller in the oriented
change upon stretching of the film. film, 0.57 versus 0.65 for the unoriented film,
The hole-filling constant C'H is smaller in as a result of the closer packing and higher
oriented polystyrene film, 6.05 versus 7.7 for cohesive energy density of the oriented
the unoriented film, indicating a decrease in amorphous regions.
free volume, while C'H in the oriented film is In summary, the solubility data of poly-
larger for polyethylene terephthalate, 5.7 styrene are satisfactorily described by the
versus 5.5 for the unoriented film (7), indi- sorption model for glassy polymers and the
eating an increase in free volume. More sig- correlations of the constants for sorption
nificantly, the quantity C's/a = 10.6 for have been successful. Orientation decreases
oriented polyethylene terephthalate film the level of solubility and changes the values
(7) indicates a much larger saturation of the constants for soprtion, reflecting the
capacity per unit volume of amorphous change in the microstrueture of polystyrene.
phase. However, orientation of chains in
polyethylene terephthalate by stretching is ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
accompanied by crystallization. The crystal- The financial assistance of the National Science
lites formed exert large stress on chains in Foundation (Grant GP-707) is gratefully acknowl-
neighboring amorphous regions, thereby en- edged.
larging holes present or creating new holes
and making those amorphous regions NOMENCLATURE
"loose." B y contrast, in polystyrene, orienta- A2 surface area occupied by one sorbate gas
tion of chains reduces the interchain dis- molecule, A2.
tance, makes certain amorphous regions b hole affinity constant, arm. -1.
more compact, and hence reduces the num- C concentration, e.e. STP/c.e. Polymer.
ber and size of holes. CD concentration by ordinary dissolution, c.c.
Another difference between oriented and STP/e.c. Polymer.
unoriented films appears in the Henry's law
CH concentration by hole-filling, c.e. STP/c.e.
Polymer.
solubility constants los. For polyethylene C'n hole-filling constant, e.c. STP/e.e. Polymer.
terephthalate, "loose" amorphous regions of AH~ heat of condensation, kcal./g, mole.
lower cohesive energy density than the un- AH~ heat of mixing, kcal./g, mole.
oriented amorphous film, created as second- AH~ heat of sorption, kcal./g, mole.
370 VIETH, TAM, AND MICHAELS