Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Slab waveguides are important ingredients of both passive and active devices. Therefore,
discussion and understanding of their properties are critical. The following topics will be
discussed in this chapter:
In this section we discuss applications of ray optics concepts to analyse the propagation
of light in slab waveguides. We start with summarizing the concept of numerical aperture
(NA).
3 1 n
B 2
θa
n0 φ 2
A φ c C n1
θ2
D 3 n2
θ1
2
1
From triangle ABC, one finds θ 2 = π/2 − φ (angle θ 2 not shown in Fig. 4.1). From
Snell’s law for ray 3, we obtain
1/2
n0 sin θ1 = n1 sin θ2 = n1 sin (π/2 − φ) = n1 cos φ = n1 1 − sin2 φ
From the above, we have (using Eq. 4.1) for ray 2 (propagating at the acceptance angle, i.e.
for θ1 = θa )
1/2 1/2
n0 sin θa = n1 1 − sin2 φc = n21 − n22
NA = n1 (2 )1/2
x
nc cover
h φ nf film
z
ns substrate
Let β be a propagation constant of the guided mode of the slab. One has
ω
β= = kn f sin φ (4.3)
vp
where v p is the phase velocity. Please note that not all angles are allowed (sometimes none).
Referring to Fig. 4.2, rays at φ = 90 ◦ travel horizontally along the waveguide. Generally,
rays which undergo total internal reflection can travel within the waveguide. That condition
can be fulfilled for rays travelling at angles fulfilling the condition (all angles are determined
with respect to normal)
φc ≤ φ ≤ 90 ◦
or
n f sinφc ≤ n f sinφ ≤ n f sin90 ◦ = n f
where we have also multiplied the inequality by n f . Using Eqs. (4.1) and (4.3), one obtains
ns ≤ N ≤ n f (4.4)
Here we introduced ‘effective guide index’ N defined as
β
N= = n f sinφ (4.5)
k
Expression for the Fresnel phase for TE polarization was derived in Chapter 3, Eq. (3.50).
Modifying notation slightly (angle θ1 is replaced by φ), the relation reads
and
b+a N 2 − n2c
= 2
1−b nf − N2
and also
n2f − N 2
1−b=
n2f − n2s
Using the above relations, the expressions for phases, Eqs. (4.7) and (4.8) can be written as
N 2 − n2c b+a
φc = tan−1 = tan−1
n2f − N 2 1−b
and
N 2 − n2s b
φs = tan−1 = tan−1
n2f − N2 1−b
n2f − n2s
N = 1+b ns
n2s
2 2
1 n f − ns
N 1+b ns
2 n2s
1 (n f − ns )(n f + ns )
N = 1+b ns
2 n2s
69 Fundamentals o EM theory o dielectric waveguides
1
ν=0
0.8 ν=1
0.6
ν=2
b 0.4
a=0 a=50
0.2 a=0 a=50
a=0 a=50
0
0 5 10 15 20
V
x
z
y
Ey (TE mode)
Hy (TM mode)
ax ay az
az × Et = 0 0 1
Ex Ey 0
where ax , ay , az are unit vectors along the corresponding directions, we write general
Eqs. (4.24)–(4.27) in expanded form (dropping mode index)
∂Ey ∂Ex
0, 0, − = − jωμ [0, 0, Hz ] (4.28)
∂x ∂y
∂Hy ∂Hx
0, 0, − = jωε [0, 0, Ez ] (4.29)
∂x ∂y
∂Ez ∂Ez
,− , 0 − jβ −Ey , Ex , 0 = − jωμ Hx , Hy , 0 (4.30)
∂y ∂x
∂Hz ∂Hz
,− , 0 − jβ −Hy , Hx , 0 = jωε Ex , Ey , 0 (4.31)
∂y ∂x
In the following sections the previous general equations will be used to analyse specific
situations.
For the wide waveguide where its dimension in the y-direction is much larger than thickness,
the field configuration along that direction remains approximately constant, see Fig. 4.4.
Therefore, we can consider only confinement in the x-direction and set
∂
=0
∂y
Also, the refractive index assumes only x-dependence
n = n (x)
From general formulas given by Eqs. (4.28)–(4.31), one obtains a set of three equations
describing TE modes and also three equations describing TM modes. Those are written
below for both types of modes separately.
TE modes
To describe TE modes we use only equations which involve Ey and its derivatives. One
observes that when Ex = Ez = 0, from Eq. (4.30) Hy = 0. Equations describing those
modes are
βEy = −ωμHx (4.32)
∂Hz
+ jβHx = − jωεEy (4.33)
∂x
∂Ey
= − jωμHz (4.34)
∂x
The last step will be to eliminate Hx and Hz . We will differentiate the third equation, then
substitute for ∂H
∂x
z
using the second equation and finally eliminate Hx using first equation.
We obtain a wave equation for TE modes
∂ 2 Ey
= β 2 − n2 k 2 Ey (4.35)
∂x2
ω √
where k = c
= ω ε0 μ 0 .
TM modes
We proceed in a similar way as for the TE modes. From Eq. (4.31) when Hx = Hz = 0,
one obtains that Ey = 0. We keep only equations which involve Hy and its derivatives.
Equations which describe TM modes are
βHy = ωεEx
∂Hy
= jωεEz
∂x
∂Ez
+ jβEx = jωμHy
∂x
We will use the fact that ε = ε0 n2 and eliminate Ex and Ez . Here one must be more
careful because n2 can be x dependent. From the first equation we determine Ex and from
the second equation we determine Ez . Substituting the results into the third equation gives
the wave equation for TM mode
∂ 1 ∂Hy
n2 2
∂x = β 2 − n2 k 2 Hy (4.36)
∂x n ∂x
We will analyse the three-layer symmetrical structure for TE modes. The structure is as
shown in Fig. 4.4. The details are illustrated in Fig. 4.5. A film layer of thickness 2a and
73 Three-layer symmetrical guiding structure (TE modes)
n0 z
a
nf
0
n0
−a
y
refractive index n f is surrounded by a substrate and cladding layers have refractive indices
equal to n0 .
We introduce the following notation:
κ 2f = n2f k 2 − β 2 (4.37)
and
γ 2 = β 2 − n20 k 2 (4.38)
Here, γ is determined by the value of refractive index around the film. In general, γ assumes
values which are dictated by the values of refractive indices in the cladding and substrate.
Therefore, one deals with more than one value of γ .
The wave equation is
d 2 Ey (x)
= β 2 − n2 k 2 Ey (x)
dx2
We discuss two separate solutions: odd and even modes.
Odd modes:
We assume the following guiding solution:
Ey (x) = Ac e−γ (x−a) , a<x (cladding)
Ey (x) = B sin κ f x, −a < x < a (film) (4.39)
Ey (x) = As eγ (x+a) , x<-a (substrate)
dEy
At the interfaces, i.e. for x = ±a, the field Ey and its derivative dx
must be continuous.
The continuity at x = a gives the following equations:
Ac = B sin κ f a
−γ Ac = κ f B cos κ f a
From above equations, one obtains
−γ = κ f cot κ f a (4.40)
The continuity at x = −a gives an identical equation. By introducing variable
y = κf a
Eq. (4.40) can be written as
−y cot y = γ a
74 Slab waveguides
g1 g2 g3
1 3 y
2 π R 2 π
−γ a = a n2 k 2 − β 2 = a2 n2 k 2 − a2 β 2 (4.41)
a2 κ 2f = a2 nn2f k 2 − a2 β 2
Determining a2 β 2 from the above and substituting into Eq. (4.41), one finds
−y cot y = R2 − y2 (4.42)
y tan y = R2 − y2 (4.45)
The function R is defined by Eq. (4.43). Eq. (4.45) is represented in Fig. 4.6. Intersections
between line h which represents the right hand side of Eq. (4.45) and lines g s which
represent the left hand side of Eq. (4.45), determine propagation constants. Those must be
found numerically. For numerical searches, the following functions are introduced:
and
fodd (y) = −y cot y − R2 − y2 (4.47)
75 Modes o the arbitrary three-layer asymmetric planar waveguide in 1D
The above functions are used in numerical search, since e.g. feven (y1 ) = 0 corresponds
to the solution y1 from which propagation constant β1 is determined. The algorithm is
described in the next section.
where the first argument contains search function and the second one contains interval for
search.
Consider the modified version of the structure shown in Fig. 4.5. The structure has different
values of refractive indices of substrate and cladding and it is known as asymmetric planar
waveguide. Here, nc signifies refractive index of cladding, n f of film, and ns that of substrate.
For an asymmetric slab, nc = ns . Define the following quantities:
where γi describes transverse decay and κi contains propagation constants. i takes the
values c, f , s as appropriate. In the next subsection we discuss TE modes for this three-
layer structure.
76 Slab waveguides
4.5.1 TE modes
For guided TE modes the following solutions exist:
Ey (x) = Ac e−γc (x−a) a<x (cover)
Ey (x) = A cos κ f x + B sin κ f x −a < x < a (film) (4.49)
Ey (x) = As eγs (x+a) x < −a (substrate)
Derivatives are determined as follows:
dEy (x)
= −γc Ac e−γc (x−a) a<x (cover)
dx
dEy (x)
= −κ f A cos κ f x + κ f B sin κ f x −a < x < a (film) (4.50)
dx
dEy (x)
= γs As eγs (x+a) x < −a (substrate)
dx
Boundary conditions dictate that
dEy (x)
Ey and are continuous for x = a and for x = −a (4.51)
dx
dEy (x)
When applying boundary conditions for Ey and dx
, we get the following equations:
P = −2 dxEy Hx
−∞
+∞
2β
= dxEy2
ωμ
−∞
ε0 2
= N E · he f f
μ0 f
= E f · H f · he f f (4.56)
1 1
where he f f ≡ 2a + γs
+ γc
is the effective thickness of the waveguide.
and
As = A (4.58)
78 Slab waveguides
nc = 1.40 —
n f = 1.50 5 µm
ns = 1.45 —
and
γs As = κ f B (4.60)
From Eqs. (4.58) and (4.60) the constants A and B can be expressed in terms of As .
Substitution of those expressions into Eq. (4.57) gives constant Ac in terms of As . Using
those results, we can replace constants A, B and Ac in Eq. (4.49). The resulting equations
are
γs
Ey (x) = As cos κ f h + κf
sin κ f h exp [−γc (x − h)] h < x
γs (4.61)
Ey (x) = As cos κ f x + κf
sin κ f x 0<x<h
Ey (x) = As exp (γs x) x<0
Example We consider the three-layer asymmetric planar structure described in Table 4.1
(from [1]) operating with light of wavelength λ = 1 µm.
79 Multilayer slab waveguides: 1D approach
Table 4.2 Propagation constants or a three-layer asymmetric structure defned in Table 4.1.
Mode Propagation constant β(µm−1 )
TE0 9.40873
TE1 9.36079
TE2 9.28184
TE3 9.17521
10
4
Search function
−2
−4
−6
−8
−10
8.9 9 9.1 9.2 9.3 9.4 9.5
β
Fig. 4.7 Graphical plot o Eq. (4.63) or the three-layer asymmetric waveguide defned in Table 4.1.
The structure is analysed with MATLAB code from Appendix 4A.2.1. The resulting
propagation constants are summarized in Table 4.2. There is a good agreement with pub-
lished results [1]. Field profiles for two modes are plotted in Fig. 4.8.
In this section we discuss slab waveguides consisting of more than three layers.
Multilayers require the repeated applications of boundary conditions at the layer
80 Slab waveguides
5 4
TE electric field
TE electric field
4
2
3
0
2
−2
1
0 −4
0 10 20 30 0 10 20 30
x (microns) x (microns)
Fig. 4.8 Field profles or an asymmetric three-layer structure. Fundamental mode TE0 (le t). Mode TE1 (right).
x7
thickness
refractive
x index
2
Ey
nc d6
x6
n4 d5
x5
n3 d4
x4
n2 d3
x3
n1 d2
x2
ns d1
x1
z
Fig. 4.9 Multilayer guiding structure. Electric feld profle is also shown.
interfaces. Schematically, the structure is as shown in Fig. 4.9. We make the following
assumptions:
• 1D problem
• n = n(x) is the refractive index
∂
• ∂y =0