Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
ABSTRACT
This paper presents the preliminary results of the study undertaken in order to address
some issues and problems of women seafarers on board ships. This is therefore intended
to discuss the most common problems encountered by women seafarers on board ships
and the solutions to lessen or totally solve the problems mentioned. There were fourteen
(14) respondents who are all midshipwomen of the Maritime Academy of Asia and the
Pacific who painstakingly shared their wisdom in order to improve the women seafarers'
status, lifestyles and have more courage to face whatever challenges lie ahead of them.
These women cadets are automatically members of the local group of Women Seafarers in
the Academy. The insights of some maritime instructors and department heads were also
noted which the readers interested on women seafarers could ponder upon. The result of
the studies would also provide some insights that could be utilized for MET innovations.
Recommendations are also advanced which are believed to contribute on the innovations
of MET to possibly address the perceived problems and prevent them on board ships by
women seafarers.
INTRODUCTION
1
In year 2003, the International Labour Office (ILO) in collaboration with
the Seafarers International Research Centre (SIRC) came up with a publications
2003 entitled “ Women Seafarers: Global Employment Policies and Practices”.
Commissioned by the ILO, this book was drawn on the extensive researches done
by the SIRC team. The SIRC team namely: namely H. Sampson, J, Veiga, M.
Thomas, M. Zhao and P. Belcher are the contributing authors. The book focuses on
contemporary women seafarers at a global level. It addresses a host of issues that
surrounds the working conditions and welfare of women, from both developed and
developing countries, employed aboard the world’s merchant and passenger ships.
The book also presents women participation levels in the industry, and examines
policies concerning their recruitment, training, maternity and employment rights,
and other aspects of works and life at sea. It also offers first-hand accounts from
women seafarers describing how they have dealt with discrimination, sexual
harassment, paternal disapproval and array of other difficulties.
The first step was the Research led workshop on Women Seafarers, which
was facilitated by the SIRC Director, Dr. Helen Sampson and Research Associate
Dr. Jaime Veiga. The Maritime Academy of Asia and the Pacific in Mariveles
Bataan hosted this activity on June 1-4, 2004. Representatives from University
Polytechnic of Catalunya (UPC), Spain, Singapore Maritime Academy (SMA),
Philippine Merchant Marine Academy (PMMA) -Zambales and the Maritime
Academy of Asia and the Pacific-Kamaya Point (MAAP) –Bataan, Philippines
have merged and participated actively on this timely activity that dealt with the
issues that relate to women seafaring profession. This activity was actively
participated by five (5) selected professionals from MAAP – the Team on Women
Seafarers or WS team namely: Ms. Ethel Capellan, Ms Janice Wakat, Ms. Susan
Murillo, 2/M Zandro Nieto and 3/M Jasmin Labarda. The activity has addressed
one of the research areas that the SIRC has undertaken important and
groundbreaking work that has the potential to inform curriculum development and
over-all maritime strategy. MAAP also shared one slot to John B. Lacson, Iloilo
City, so as to provide a co-maritime school the opportunity of global research
networking and therefore strengthen maritime research network in the country.
Following this activity was an Echo Seminar and workshop, which was
attended by 25 faculty, staff, 14 midshipwomen and Department Heads. Based on
SIRC's research that was disseminated during the echo-seminar, the participants
were also able to come up with their own perceptions and solutions to problems
and issues concerning women seafarers. MAAP has also established its local
group of women. With the support and cooperation of women cadets from all class
2
levels, a midshipwoman heads this. This group has willingly participated to
improve the conditions and welfare of women on board the world's merchant
ships. In Dr. Baylon’s speech during the echo-seminar and workshop on July 14,
2004, she emphasized, to wit "being involved in the ASEAN-EU Project- research-
led seminar workshop on Women Seafarers is crucial to the Academy's effort to
create and cultivate research culture in MAAP and promote research network
outside MAAP, in line with the MAAP President call for improving MET and
maritime research networking.”
For the past five (5) years, the Academy accepted only four (4) to six (6)
midshipwomen per year. Although there were many applicants coming from the
different parts of the country, this minimal number of midshipwomen remarkably
has surpassed the rigid screening process of the Academy. Two (2) classes have
already been graduated. All the four female graduates of the first batch have
impressively landed a job at sea. The three batches in the Academy with fourteen
(14) midshipwomen, are currently taking up either the Marine Transportation or
Marine Engineering Course.
Women are simply not present in the numbers we would expect in the
Seafaring profession. The broad demographics of female seafarers throughout the
country disturbingly, far fewer women than we could expect given their
prominence throughout the system and their importance as seafarers. These data,
coupled with the participants' perceptions about women seafarers and the problems
they have encountered, their beliefs, experiences in the seafaring industry can
serve as a road map for navigating women challenges based on the well-considered
recommendations, tried and true practices and numerous tips for success from the
contributors of the study.
Objectives
The research presented here was drawn from the recently concluded echo
seminar – workshop on Women Seafarers conducted by the WS team in the
Academy. The workshop focused on the personal viewpoints of the MAAP
Midshipwomen about women seafarers’ working at sea. Emphasis was on the
problems they had encountered or might encounter. Possible solutions to the
problems were also tackled, as this is considered vital in finding out its implication
in the seafaring careSer of women. Specifically, this paper intends to provide
answers to the following questions:
1. What are the most common perceptions about women seafarers and
what are the effects in their career?
2. What are the problems the women cadets have encountered or what
problems the women seafarers might encounter at sea and how are these
problems be solved and will be solved?
3. What are the implications of these problems mentioned in the seafaring
career of women on board ships?
METHODOLOGY
3
This research utilized descriptive type of research using the following
methods of data collection: observation, questionnaire survey of fourteen (14)
midshipwomen in MAAP, interviews and documentary analysis. The women
cadets’ respondents were from the Class of 2005, 2007 and 2008.
FINDINGS
There are now (14) midshipwomen present in the Academy and this
excludes those working on board ships. Almost all of them have common reasons
why they chose the maritime profession. Some of these reasons are: they love to
travel, seafaring is a unique profession, it has high demand in terms of salaries, for
4
practicality sake and most importantly, these women cadets want to improve their
family's lifestyle.
On the other hand, there were also negative perceptions that serve as eye
openers and which can be corrected. Some of these negative outlooks about
women are:
Source of trouble. - The officers’ wives misinterpreted many women
seafarers because the latter tend to forget their etiquette at sea. Some
are involved in extra marital affairs thus this creates a big problem.
Lighter work in the ship - Obviously, women are weaker (physically)
than men thus, males tend to offer their help with women seafarers
5
when given a task. More often than not, women are given lighter job
to do than men.
Prone to harassment - Working at sea could be very difficult among
men and women. So when a man sees a woman at sea sometimes
harassment can be inevitable. Men on board may take advantage and
underestimate them.
6
As shown in table 1, the Maritime Academy of Asia and the Pacific women
cadets are very positive in their outlook, as well as in facing the challenges that lie
ahead of them. They think that all of the above perceptions will serve as their
stepping-stones to succeed and as MAAP women cadets. They would like to prove
that they are different among other women cadets in the world. Every one of them
is encouraged to pursue their profession with pride, honor and dignity as they sail
along the maritime profession.
Hard To Work
Discrimination
Harassment
Discrimination
Harassment
Hard to work
7
caused by prejudice. Although discrimination involves action whereby members
of a particular group are accorded negative treatment on the basis of racial, ethnic
or religious background. But in this study, what is being discriminated is the
gender. Discrimination is in fact, a negative belief or attitude towards somebody
or something.
In this research work, discrimination plays the number one (1) problem of
women seafarers on board ships. It is rated as almost 53% based on the study
being conducted and as perceived by the women cadets of MAAP. Discrimination
which according to them is an actual response whereby members of the particular
group like women are accorded negative treatment by males on the basis of their
characteristics or combination of traits like sex or race. Aquino (1991) validated
that discrimination can be positive or negative. It is also a behavior that arbitrarily
gives or denies people privileges accorded to others by virtue of their group
membership.
Neubeck (1996) wrote in his book that gaining accurate knowledge of the
extent of sexual harassment is difficult. It is sensitive subject, difficult to define,
and subject to varying interpretations. They were being subjected to sexual
comments, jokes, gestures, or looks; being touched, grabbed, or pinched in a
sexual way; being intentionally brushed up against sexually; and being shown,
given or left sexual pictures, photographs, illustrations, messages, or notes.
Finally, the third problem is very hard to work in the ship most especially
in the presence of male community. This bears 5.26% in the study that was
conducted. Neubeck in his same book Sociology emphasized, "Women have to
live in fear of rejection by men.... Women's role as sex objects is not natural and
inevitable but an instrument of male domination. In the same manner, feminists
underscore the difference between sex and gender, pointing out that the roles
accorded women are largely of men's making. Women alone are capable of
bearing children, but men are as capable as women in playing a nurturant role.
They simply choose to allocate most of that task to women. Given the opportunity,
women can fulfill virtually any position in work and politics that is presently male-
8
dominated. Similarly, men are eminently capable of doing 'women's work' in the
labor force. Finally, current social conditions make it clear that women can and
must be able to support themselves. Millions of women who are unmarried,
separated or divorced, widowed, with many children - are independent by
necessity or choice. The demands faced by these women for their own survival
and the earnings accorded to ‘women’s work’ cannot meet that of their children,
often.
Due to the top three (3) problems that have mentioned in this research work,
the MAAP midshipwomen believed that these problems could still be settled
and/or lessened by resolving into the following solutions:
Women must engage in various activities in the ship - in order to
learn more about the men's environment and be accustomed to their
ways in the ship; they must also know how to interact with men's
environment as necessary.
There must be a law about gender discrimination - if our country
could come up with a kind of a law that speaks about gender
discrimination most especially with women then, the problem would
be lessened
Women must be aware/conscious in their manners in the ship - this is
necessary so as not to provoke men of any malicious act or intent.
Women must prove their worth - women must seek special attention
aboard ship but rather they must prove their worth - which they can
accomplish what men can accomplish. Avoid being too emotional
and sensitive on things going around the ship.
Women must have the right attitude - they must take their job
professionally and must continuously seek to improve their career.
Women must know about their rights - women must show that they
are skilled and knowledgeable in upholding their rights against abuse
so that they will not be underestimated or belittled by male seafarers.
They must also actively and willingly participating in all seminars
and trainings with regards to women's rights, privileges and many
others as seafarers.
9
Women must also consider the positive things a woman seafarer may
contribute
Women seafarers must attend seminars and workshops about women
issues and concerns aboard ships. They can also be speakers to
various seminar or workshops regarding women issues
Women etiquette at sea must be established so they can improve the
conduct of business
Women should know how to face challenges in the ship and not be
put down by the mockery of male seafarers
Coming up with the production of international newsletters regarding
success stories of women seafarers
10
On asset of a woman amidst the man’s world as in the seafaring profession
Dr. Baylon also cited that in the maritime world, there is a need for woman to
develop some typically “male strengths or assets “to be recognized or promoted in
a man’s world but it is also important to retain the valuable female characteristics.
The key to success lies in using them appropriately according to her. She also
added that Women don’t have to be like a guy to get ahead in business, but have to
be adult women. Women need to be advocates for themselves by playing up their
strengths - like being nurturing, empathetic, supportive, accommodating, good
listeners and coaching workers - while also adding complementary behaviors.
Dr. Baylon opined that some of the typical assets or strengths of character
typical of women that men can emulate or develop further are the following female
aptitudes and inclinations:
1. to regard feeling as a basic and essential part of life, as guides to
authenticity and effectiveness for a fully functioning person, rather than as
impediments to achievement;
2. to accept the vulnerability and imperfections that are part of all persons;
3. to assert the right to work for self-fulfillment rather than only playing the
role of provider;
4. to learn how to fail at a task without feeling one has failed as a person;
5. to accept and express the need to be nurtured when feeling hurt, afraid ,
vulnerable, or helpless rather than hide these feelings behind a mask of
strength , rationality and invulnerability;
6. to touch and be close to both men and women , minimizing any inhibition
over the presence or absence of sexuality in such contact ;
7. to listen empathetically and actively without feeling responsible for solving
others’ problems; to share feelings as the most meaningful part of one’s
contact with others , accepting the risk and vulnerability that such sharing
implies;
8. to build support systems with other men , sharing competencies without
competition, feelings, needs and without dissembling; to personalize
experience , rather than assuming that the only valid approach to life and
interpersonal contact is objective;
9. to acknowledge the emotional , spontaneous and irrational as valid parts of
oneself to be explored and expressed as needed; and to nurture and
actively support other men and women in their efforts to change. This to her
opinion would be an asset amidst man’s world like the maritime.
11
IMPLICATIONS
(In the Seafaring Career of women on board ships and MET Innovations)
It is not that easy to become a female seafarer. For centuries males have
dominated the maritime industry. This implies that it would be very rare for
women to get into the maritime industry and be recognized. However, there are
still women facing the wave of resistance. Instead of being disappointed and
discouraged to pursue the seafaring career, they became more courageous,
determined and challenged to equal men if not surpass in the seafaring profession.
Obviously, maritime industry follows the rule of biology, that customarily or
traditionally, men are to dominate women. Neubeck (1996) stressed that men are
equipped to exercise power and function under demanding circumstances. Women
are best suited for supportive, care taking occupations and professions - those that
call upon the particular strengths nature has given women for duties in the home.
Apparently, the woman cadets of the Maritime Academy of Asia and the
Pacific believe that they can lead the way. This study implies that women
seafarers must bear the following qualities in order to survive: endurance,
patience, perseverance, sacrifice, and hardworking, being wise, competitive
and more importantly knowledgeable on their job. Aware of the problems and
struggles that women seafarers may encounter on board the vessels, these woman
cadets or cadettes need to be on alert when they finally be immersed in a man's
world.
CONCLUSIONS
Due to the limitations and misconceptions presented in this paper that were
identified during the workshop, we cannot conclude that our MAAP women
seafarers will succeed in seeking equality in the maritime field. However, MAAP
anticipates the positive output or impact that these woman graduates will
undoubtedly make a mark in the seafaring business. This study disclosed that these
MAAP future women seafarers are unlikely to quit the maritime business despite
the hardships and struggles they had undergone in the Academy. They are highly
motivated to pursue their seafaring career amidst the identified problems they
might come across on board the vessels.
12
MAAP is certain that its projection on its highly selected woman cadets will
be realized and proven in due time.
RECOMMENDATIONS
13
For the International Maritime Organizations and the other International
Bodies Concerned
1. Set specific guidelines with respect to the roles of women seafarers so
as to prevent biases and prejudices. This would ensure equality if not
better on the outputs that they can produce regardless of gender
differences.
2. Monitor the condition of women seafarers on board ships say quarterly
or annually in order to assess the performance and status of women
seafarers on board ships.
REFERENCES
14
Message taken from MAAP President from MAAP Research Agenda and Its
Mechanics of Implementation 2002-2011, published by the Department Research
and Extension Services.
A Report on the Echo-seminar and Workshop held in the Maritime Academy of Asia and
the Pacific. Kamaya Point Mariveles, Bataan. July 14,2004. Prepared by Ms.
Ethel R. Capellan, Ms. Janice K. Wakat and 2/M Zandro DV. Nieto.
A Speech of Dr. Angelica M. Baylon during the Echo-seminar and Workshop held
in the Maritime Academy of Asia and the Pacific. Kamaya Point, Mariveles,
Bataan. July 14,2004.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Dr. Helen Sampson, SIRC Director and Dr. Jaime Veiga , Research Associate of
the Seafarers International Research Centre, Cardiff University, South Wales,
,United Kingdom, the AUNP project leaders.
Dr. Angelica M. Baylon, the Research and Extension Services Director of MAAP
and AUNP project Officer for MAAP and Vadm. Eduardo Ma. R. Santos, AFP
(Ret), MAAP President.
15
16